@pussiestroker to be honest, they're both very good singers. i love both their voices. but sandy's work ethics to me is by far more admirable. faye is gifted but never seems to work hard yet for sandy she's gifted too but she never ceases to improve herself. that's why she is my favourite.
I'm a Faye fan but I like this version more - more mature. But that's not unexpected when I think about when Faye first sang this - pretty early in her career... compared to Sandy singing this say only a couple of years ago? I'm sure if Faye sang it now, it'd be different, but I have a feeling that Faye probably thinks she is over this type of 'pop' song now, which is a pity in my view.
It's interesting to see this performance. In fact, Faye was pushed by her company to imitate Sandy in the early stage of her career. Faye later developed her own unique style, but I bet she probably has learned quite a bit (especially the voice control) from Sandy. Nice to see Sandy still has it.
I totally dont agree with you, I think the melody of the song is kinda R&B style n it suits Sandy as Sandy's voice for R&B songs is very impressive than Faye! and this version arrangement is similar to Jazz and Antony Lun's a partner with Sandy Lam, so I think Sandy has a better performance than Faye but overall, Sandy and Faye are good singers!
我認為王菲和林憶蓮同樣擁有天籟之聲，但我喜歡憶蓮是因為她除了天份，亦十分努力，不停脫變。她絕對是一個上進及專業的歌手。
就是呼吸聲肥佬
這是氣聲
聽咗廿幾年呢隻歌。。。一直都覺得王菲唱得好好聽。。。但今天聽完林憶蓮演繹後我覺得好震撼。。。覺得隻歌好有靈魂。。。林憶蓮把聲更啱個feel。。。
香港樂壇最美好的年代出現過王菲同林憶蓮兩位能力同質量有極高要求既天后真係可一不可再
我比較喜歡憶蓮的版本..好有味道
Sandy除咗有把靚聲，最重要係唱歌好有感情，聽眾FEEL得到，不是流於表面的所謂唱功
华语乐坛首席女音
林每首歌都堪称经典
她太好，歌太動聽，溫溫柔柔，婉婉動人。
王冷冷的聲音真的透出一絲孤寂
永遠的Diva~林憶蓮
王菲唱出來的是感覺，SANDY則是充滿味道.....
年紀輕王菲唱得係好聽但感覺好交貨咁，歷練後憶蓮就唱出首歌嘅神韻
超享受聲音
Sandy is the best !
無與侖比！百聽不厭！
2023/9/30 日, 依然覺得好好聽❤❤❤
有實力嘅人唱咩歌都咁有人欣賞, i love u sandy lam.
我不懂評論人品，但我知道亦欣賞憶蓮的坦白。很久以前，憶蓮被問及有否介意被形容為「人間昆蟲記」的女主⻆，她坦率承認：介意，很介意。能忠於自己，剖白內心的藝人，寥寥可數。喜歡憶蓮，是有這個一原因吧！
「人間昆蟲記」的女主角也適合形容另-女歌手葉倩文。
台灣全體支持林憶蓮！
太棒
阿菲和憶蓮都是一代難得的中文歌壇歌后
現在的香港女歌手都太不知所謂了
憶蓮唱得真係好正，好有味道
@pussiestroker to be honest, they're both very good singers. i love both their voices. but sandy's work ethics to me is by far more admirable. faye is gifted but never seems to work hard yet for sandy she's gifted too but she never ceases to improve herself. that's why she is my favourite.
唱的有自己的味道，可是我很懷疑那髮型師是何居心，給林憶蓮弄一個菜市場大嬸剛起床的頭，很顯老阿
会吗？其实我很喜欢Sandy 这个造型，很复古，很“上海”的感觉。
不嬲sandy d style duo Mmd ... except for periods of 許願
不會啊
很上海法租界的復古感呀
这首歌好适合sandy❤
惊艳忆莲♉❤🎉⚖️🎯😊
唱的太美了
倫永亮好可愛
王菲的cd版本還是最完美的.王菲聲音比較亮.乾淨.唱這種歌無人可敵
陳彥銘 王菲勝在當年的音色，林勝在對爵士樂的掌握，不相上下
林忆莲的更性感，王菲的技巧性更强，两个各有千秋
sandy is the best
simply classic~
A very nice and a fantastic performance
專業！SANDY, forever love.
好好聽哦^^以前都是聽她的國語
Master class!
好正好正!
lovely voice!
聽出耳油
@TimTimato
4 Queens ! 4 Divas
Amazing
正！
I like both version, be it from Faye Wong or Sandy lam, both are DIVA
@xoxiyy 對阿.相對於王菲.sandy她的唱功一直進步.唱什麼歌都一把罩.實音又可以唱超高.
😊😊😘😘😍😍🤩🤩👍👍👏👏
天后的较量也是一场长跑，林忆莲是后天的刻苦和坚持成就今日的DIVA，王菲多得天赋，但复出后只剩名气的哄抬。
+Yoo Yao 你也去哄抬憶蓮吧，拜託
阿菲是我爱了20年的女歌手 但这首歌更喜欢sandy演唱版本
Yoo Yao 娘娘洗撚同凡人較量咩～
你也去哄抬林忆莲吧，抬得起来你还会在这里瞎bb？
perfect
I'm a Faye fan but I like this version more - more mature. But that's not unexpected when I think about when Faye first sang this - pretty early in her career... compared to Sandy singing this say only a couple of years ago? I'm sure if Faye sang it now, it'd be different, but I have a feeling that Faye probably thinks she is over this type of 'pop' song now, which is a pity in my view.
哇 好聽到 不得了 如果企起身唱更好
@xoxiyy
是啊，十分同意，我欣賞王菲的聲音及技巧，但有時真討厭她愛理不理的態度。
觀眾在看著她的演出，她大小姐卻是不認真的唱完便算，有點「你聽就聽不聽就算」。
其實不大尊重觀眾和表演。
這是不專業，也不重視歌迷，忘本。唱功頂好如甄妮，作品豐富廣泛如梅艶芳，聲線動聽如關淑怡，絶不遜色/甚至超越王菲，她們從來感謝歌迷欣賞愛載。而王菲，-紅了，唱完就是交了貨，你們歌迷還想怎樣？這倒教曉歌迷，甚麼是貼錢買難受。
much better than original
forever sandy!
Agree! Wong's version is very good
@jemdogdogghost 原本王菲的版本去到第二段副歌都係未彈晒就入，所以憶蓮同Eugene都應該冇錯。
I dont really think so and I do think Sandy has a better performance for this song , rather than Faye!
It's interesting to see this performance. In fact, Faye was pushed by her company to imitate Sandy in the early stage of her career. Faye later developed her own unique style, but I bet she probably has learned quite a bit (especially the voice control) from Sandy. Nice to see Sandy still has it.
同意
😔😔
这个版本已经超越王菲。
林比王更好听
I think Sandy's voice is a little too sentimental for this song so I prefer Faye's version.
But both are great singers.
靜夜的單眼皮.厘首至係原曲！
無懈可擊的演繹，但是可惜有9個人沒帶耳朵
憶蓮人品似乎好些！
@harrisonfuk
用肺還好，
她們只是用舌頭讀歌.
比原唱唱得還要好
Faye's album version is more penetrating than Sandy's. Just thinking that the way Sandy performed this song is a bit weak.
agreed. Sandy is a phenomenal singer but her rendition of this song isn't my favourite.
鮑以靜 Eugene Pao
@bbleung12 王菲現在的聲音.跟以前差太多了
退步變差了太多？
I totally dont agree with you, I think the melody of the song is kinda R&B style n it suits Sandy as Sandy's voice for R&B songs is very impressive than Faye! and this version arrangement is similar to Jazz and Antony Lun's a partner with Sandy Lam, so I think Sandy has a better performance than Faye but overall, Sandy and Faye are good singers!
憶蓮唱出了不同的味道，王菲固然好，但憶蓮一點無失禮。
天瀨
粉絲可以瘋狂自我洗腦 吹噓 無必要踩原唱者
又唔可以咁講，不知所謂嘅係那些公司及一些傳媒！
王菲是標準大頭症.一紅話就變少了..她剛出道話還蠻多的.也很謙虛.之後就跩的跟什麼一樣
唱得比王靖雯好!
始終香港人比大陸人好!
佢會唱得好過王菲係因為真係比較適合佢唱... 王菲唱腔唔啱呢種..當時都只係因為市場需要先會唱呢種歌
王菲唱好聽過林憶蓮多多啦
Yiu Sammy 王菲這首從沒勝過林憶蓮，錄音版與94最精彩頂多平手,菲比尋常則是被秒殺,你如果聽過林憶蓮88年的ready專輯就會覺得這首根本是寫給林憶連的歌
Yiu Sammy 又一個白痴王菲粉絲
林憶蓮版絕對比原唱好聽
唱得像哮喘病似的
没有哮喘
@@eelju 不停在搶氣還說不像哮喘？
你不如公開唱一次。
林憶蓮最可惜的，是演唱會的影片錄音效果都太差，相對的，王菲就好多了，真的錯過又蹧蹋了天籟，還是我只能找到這兩首惟二優質的現場(另一首是1991年的愛上一個不回家的人）!有人能指點迷津嗎？
sandy is the best