Yes. If all the social media platforms would demonetize all pet monkey channels, there would be a huge wave of abandoned monkeys and the pet monkey videos would come to a screeching halt. If they aren’t making money off the videos, they aren’t going to make the videos. It is all about the money they make. Easy money.
@@gsmith6026 NaH. APoaching simply cant be stopped. Not when someone pays more strong currency for a monkey femur bone or some junk thant a whole weeks low pay living in some places. It is sad. We couldn't save the white rhinos for this reason exactly.
@@gsmith6026 If I had 1 wish it would be for RUclips Stop allowing Monkey channels to earn/make Money!!! Agree, 98% of the channels would dump the innocent monkeys! There's many channels making Huge money 😢, Bibi, Cutis monkey channels
When I Voiced My Concern Over Bibi's Wellbeing And Welfare As He Has Problems, Due To Walking On His Hind Legs. The Amount Of Abuse I Got From The Die Hard Fans, Who Are So Ignorant To What Is Really Going On And Wish To Wear Rose Coloured Glasses. I Was Told To Move On, Don't Watch Bibi If I Have Nothing To Say Etc, Etc. Viewers Love To Comment On Bibi's Cute Outfits, And Clever Antics. Mr Quan Adores Bibi Like A Son, They Say. He Is Adored And Well Care For, They Say. That Little Monkey Is Exhausted Filming 3 Times A Day, Taking Orders From The Cameraman For His Every Move. Oh Yes Mr Quan Loves Bibi. Who Would Not Love A Money Making Machine That Has Made Him Very, Very Wealthy. They Have Now Introduced A New Baby Monkey To The Channel, Is This Baby Monkey Replacing Bibi, As He Matures And His Cuteness Fades. All Very Tragic All Very Sad All For Money, Money, Money. Not The Happiness Or The Wellbeing Of The Monkey.
I watched Bibi for about 2 - 3 months I think, and was so so so attracted to him. Then I began to question the channel but got no answers. The channel then banned me. I reported the channel and took it further and filed a complaint to env in Vietnam. The protection law for endangered species there is active.
Same treatment got some of us who criticize Kaka and Mit, and congratulate ENV for having them confiscated. All the fans are putting a big mess, mailing and calling ENV because they want the monkeys back.
@@mariagloriazanardi3142Env has Kaka and Mit in dirty nasty cage thanks to confiscated of them. They have lost half of there weight. Monkey Puka who is in the cage with them is very sick in this cage with no medical care. There are 4 Monkeys in this cage. This is where all the confiscated monkey go by the ENV. They go into a cage.
2:14 To add to your point, and to this clip you've added: Baby monkeys *_do not_* spend all of their time *_screaming_* bloody murder, like this poor fellow here. Macaques are normally not very noisy unless they're in a fight with each other or are in distress. These Pet Monkey channels give us such a distorted view, that I've seen well-meaning people make comments on videos from animal rescue groups in India, comments accusing them of "cutting their vocal chords" and/or drugging the macaques in these groups' care. The reality is, that India reveres monkeys, due to Hinduism, and that these macaques are actually calm, not in distress, because they're being cared for.
There was an article in National Geographic that quoted a vet who said that 99.9% of baby monkeys raised by humans end up with severe emotional trauma that they never outgrow. Similar thoughts in the same article from the director of a primate rescue in Kentucky that echoed the same things
I Have Now REPORTED The Miker/ Lucky Channel. Could Believe What I Was Seeing. Thumbnail Always Exposing His Privacy. The Owner Is A Monster. That Darling Little Monkey Is So Very Traumatized And Nervous. He Knows And Feels What That Lady Is Doing To Him Is Wrong. She Is Abusing Him In The Most Horrific Way Showing His Private Parts After Doing Whatever She Was Doing To Him. Please, Please, Please Let's All Unite And Shut Down This Horrifying Channel. How Could People Do This To Innocent, Beautiful Little Beings. Thank You.
Aw thank you so much for doing this! I can see these channels have upset you here. You're right, I have no idea how anyone could do any of this to these beautiful animals... I've reported several recently and haven't heard a thing about any of them yet 😡
@@ToxicBarbz Thank You Very Much For Your Comment. I Hope Little Miker Is Safe And Well. So This Monster Of A Woman Is Still Making Money From Old Videos! It Should Not Be Allowed.
Și eu am raportat canale, dar nu am văzut decât ca își fac canale noi și o iau de la început cu tortura. Tina, Poor, Luk, Kyo, Lucky sunt canale actuale și care promovează o tortura mascata. Am scris și la ENV și mi au răspuns ca în Vietnam nu se difuzează aceste canale și ei nu au ce face. Le am propus sa ia fiecare strada în parte pe picioare și vor confisca o mulțime de maimuțe și mi au răspuns ca ei acționează doar la o reclamație. Am reclamat Tina Monkey și au dat din umeri. Cum putem scoate aceste păpuși sălbatice din mâinile acestor tirani? Trebuie sa fie o soluție! Mulțumesc!
3:32 Another enhancement of your point here: Due to habitat loss, macaques have become problem-wildlife in India. And the reality of human-monkey interaction is *_not good:_* people are having to abandon their villages, which just shows how *_completely ill-suited monkeys are as pets._*
Forest cover in India is actually growing. It is not habitat loss causing monkey human interaction in India. It is greedy macaques who get used to handouts of food from humans and feeding on easily available food waste, thereby incentivising themselves to migrate closer to human settlements.
Thank you for helping to bring the unknowns to peoples eyes regarding these channels. IMO Monkeys in the wild offer much to love but less to learn about ourselves. People cannot often benefit from knowing nature but they can benefit from knowing themselves better. What is done should be stopped if it is wrong but what is done is done and should be learned from. I think people SHOULD see monkey channels before they get removed (as they should indeed be removed). I believe the inherent cruelty of what they are seeing will resonate with them in some sense and they could make connections between their behaviors and those captivity monkeys. Abused Humans can learn volumes from watching these Monkeys in a suffering not too far from removed from their own. After all , that is truly all these mean channel owners are doing. Revisiting the pains of their past on the creatures and people of the present. This is a human behavior and human behavior is as wild as monkeys. Simply because we don clothes and hold forks does NOT MAKE US HUMAN, you have said this yourself Monkey Mercy, but in terms of monkeys holding forks and wearing clothes not being human just because they do so.. Being human is something learned. Being Human is taken for granted in our own sufferings and we forget that we must build humanity in others. The monkeys can remind of us our humanity as we peer into them so intently looking to see their humanity. We can improve together.
Χαρηκα πολύ για το νέο σας βιντεο λατρευω τα ζώα και πιο πολύ τα μαϊμουδάκια όταν τα βλέπω στη φύση τους κρεμασμένα από το στήθος της μάνας τους σκέφτομαι τα καημένα που ζουν με τους βασανιστές ποσό υποφέρουν για ένα πιάτο φαΐ και είμαι τόσο θυμό μένη με τους θεατές που υποστηρίζουν αυτή την εκμετάλλευση ποσό άδειοι στην ψυχή είναι για να χειροκροτούν αυτό το ψέμα το βλέπουν ότι όλοι κάνουν τα ίδια και έχουν ένα μεγαλύτερο και παίρνουν όλοι και ένα μικρο και αναγκάζουν το μεγαλύτερο να κουβαλάει το μικρο αηδιάζω και όταν τους γράφω ότι είναι λάθος αυτό που κάνουν με βρίζουν δεν με ενδιαφέρει φυσικά έχω υγείη μυαλό και βλέπω το λάθος από το σωστό ευχωμαι να το δουν και αυτοί και μονο τότε θα σταματηση αυτό το κακό
Aw I know, it is absolutely heartbreaking seeing the babies trying so hard to cling and nurse as they should do with their real mothers... Thank you for your comment.
Le contenu de la vidéo est fait pour vous mener exactement à cette déclaration, et lle conditionnement a bien fonctionné, vous avez répété comme un perroquet, sans plus réfléchir.
@@monkeymercy124you don't have to be nervous. But, no video will change anything until all animal videos are banned from all social media platforms. Then monkeys will stop being kept at home. Since these are only kept because money can be made through the viewers. But the helplessness of not being able to do anything against these companies makes me angry and sad at the same time.
Hi, can you please tell me why vets (real ones) will treat these pet monkeys but not report them to the authorities? I've seen Monkey Bibi and others taken to the vets and they receive full care and even get played with and have their photos taken at times. I find this very confusing. Perhaps by law they are bound to treat all animals?? I looked up the vet Monkey Bibi goes to and it's legit.
@@fightagainstanimalcruelty-k1xYes, if you pay close attention to the little details, you can clearly see they are fake. Like “curtains” with folds in them, where it is clear the fabric was just taken out of the package. White coats with a Red Cross made out of paper stuck on the coat, you can see it is just stuck there with tape as you can see places where it is lifted up off the shirt. Another clue is that they shove a thermometer clear up the monkeys rectum, causing great pain, when they really only need to just barely putting it in the rectum. Many have no idea how to give a shot either.
I have been so upset lately at seeing a social media page that keeps popping up with monkeys dressed and doing human things. Called Bibi I think. Thank God for you educators!!!
Here on RUclips there’s a Family BiBi and Monkey BiBi channel, same family, same monkey. Many YT and Facebook channels and pages have some variation of the name ‘Bibi’, it’s very popular.
Le commentaire introductif relève d'une philosophie essentialiste, qui pense que tout comportement est instinctif, et que les individus, humains ou animaux, ne peuvent apprendre et évoluer, en fonction des circonstances, des rencontres, et de l'environnement. C'est une vision figée des choses, qui s'oppose d'ailleurs à la théorie de l'évolution de Darwin. Je ne la partage pas, et très peu de scientifiques en sont encore là. Ne sous-estimez pas l'intelligence et la capacité d'adaptation et d'évolution des singes. Des études scientifiques montrent qu'il peuvent apprendre jusquà 800 mots écrits, et communiquer par le langage des signes des sourd-muets. Ce n'est pas dans leurs meutes naturelle qu'ils l'apprennent, bien que certaines mères transmettent en partie à leur progéniture ces acquisitions, comme ils apprennent entre eux les maniements d'outils et par exemple à ouvrir les coquillages pour les consommer. C'est au contact des humains qu'ils apprennent ou de leurs congénères plus évolués. Bref votre vision figée de la vie et de la nature est avant tout idéologique et n'a rien de scientifique.
I'm think you may have misunderstood the video because nobody is underestimating the intelligence and abilities of these primates. Indeed, these are very intelligent animals and that is kind of the point... I am not talking about their ability to learn words and other forms of communication.
@@monkeymercy124 Je pense avoir compris votre propos. Mais je ne peux le partager pour les raisons ci dessus. Tout progrès, qui peut prendre des siècles voire des millénaires, se produit par le changement et les contacts et expériences nouvelles, la nature elle même n'est pas stable et et évolue sans cesse, le climat également, et la progression en nombre de l'espèce humaine entraine inéluctablement la déforestation et une urbanisation croissante, à laquelle du reste de nombreuses espèces de singes qui envahissent les villes se sont adaptées. (New Dehli) Nous devons cohabiter sur cette planète et les formes de cohabitation évoluent elles aussi, nous sommes à ce tournant. Il faut élargir votre perspective.
@@electra-gal I will be happy to broaden my perspective when I see reliable evidence that these wild animals are not being unnecessarily exploited, abused and suffering as a consequence.
@@electra-gal Have you seen the planet of the apes? I don't know about you, but for me, I prefer to stay human if someone trains me to be a monkey. Perhaps you don't mind being a monkey and called a monkey. Does a monkey have a choice in the hands of a dumb human being? We are talking about animal abuse here and there is a protection law for them from being abused. Get lost with your evolution theory. This is not the worry and pain of monkeys. They just want freedom like you do,, being themselves.
It's not just about macaques, it applies to all wild animals that end up in zoos and not in their natural environment. The videos you show are only those in Southeast Asia. But when an American does that, where the macaques walk around in clothes and are treated like human babies, strangely enough most people say (you are a good mom, so cute, etc.). I wonder if you are perhaps racist!!?? What about the animals that act or work in Hollywood, is that fair??? ruclips.net/video/nTxTyIJ7oYM/видео.htmlsi=qJHNEK9YPM01BwRZ
i totally agree with your point and yes I have discussed other animals in other parts of the world too. The reason I chose specifically to focus on macaques in these recent videos is because it starts to get confusing when I discuss different species in all in one video. It is not possible to cover everything coherently at once. As macaques are very popular at the moment, that is why I decided to research this species for now. This research takes me a long time to conduct, so I cannot cover it all in such a short time.
I heard your arguments but example monkey Bibi is clear as day he is part of the family and not abused in any way..he loves the family and the family loves him back so there is nothing wrong
Thank you for your comment, but unfortunately this little guy is extremely exploited for entertainment. This is exactly what the channel owners want you to believe. The monkey is displaying so many worrying signs in relation to his mobility and overall health...
bibi is a money earning tool for quan...u've been following them? haven't u realised they live in 3 big houses in Vietnam? bibi being separated since birth from mother is correct to u? how u feel if u got seperated from yours?!
@@alvinkhoo in fact that they live already well makes explotaion of such a cool monkey improbable imo ..Apart from the fact that the love shown to Bibi is family quality, how Bibi reacts to other animals reflects a happy and loving upbringing. Just as dogs, monkeys apparently can enjoy a good family life. There are too many good signs to place accusations without concrete evidence.
@@siliconmalta2349Do you ever see them as adults on similar videos? No, because as soon as they grow up, they aren't as cute and are hard to handle, so they get dumped and suddenly there is a new "Bibi".
@@CindyKern-wj9wg Bibi is the first ever channel I watched, so I don't have that experience. What age are you referring to when they are dumped? because RUclips has been around for so long... I think we have to wait and see what happens with Bibi. In Vietnam, it is very common for people to keep monkeys as pets. Like there are people who treat dogs bad that doesnt mean every dog owner is bad... I still have to see any evidence Bibi is being maltreated or abused.
Ho letto un commento di qualcuno che diceva che la 🐒 xxx, era fortunata poiché viveva nel "lusso", andava al ristorante, aveva la piscina ecc... e per questo era amata dal suo "papà", questo è quello che credono o vogliono credere i suoi seguitori, loro vedono l'apparenza e non pensano o non vogliono pensare a cosa c'è dietro alla sceneggiatura, purtroppo c'è gente che ancora crede che queste 🐒🐒 sono "salvate" e fortunate perché hanno una casa, una "mamma" e/o un "papà"
I think you are referring to monkey Bibi that is a male animal. I read somewhere that his human father has had monkeys before. Monkey Bibi is the biggest monkey channel at the moment I think. To get this large, a lot of work has been put on Bibi. When it is offset, Bibi is at the mercy of these people. The viewers are a big part of the problem. They encourage this sort of exploitation.
Who in their right mind would want one of these animals as a pet living in their homes???
Thank you for your dedication to helping advocate for the protection of baby macaques.
It is impossible for humans to meet the physical and emotional needs of a monkey.
4:00 I would go so far as to say that Pet Baby Monkeys on social media *_PROMOTE Poaching._*
Yes. If all the social media platforms would demonetize all pet monkey channels, there would be a huge wave of abandoned monkeys and the pet monkey videos would come to a screeching halt. If they aren’t making money off the videos, they aren’t going to make the videos. It is all about the money they make. Easy money.
@@gsmith6026 NaH. APoaching simply cant be stopped. Not when someone pays more strong currency for a monkey femur bone or some junk thant a whole weeks low pay living in some places. It is sad. We couldn't save the white rhinos for this reason exactly.
@@gsmith6026 If I had 1 wish it would be for RUclips Stop allowing Monkey channels to earn/make Money!!! Agree, 98% of the channels would dump the innocent monkeys! There's many channels making Huge money 😢, Bibi, Cutis monkey channels
@@dharobed3329 Yes, this would stop it instantly!
When I Voiced My Concern Over Bibi's Wellbeing And Welfare As He Has Problems, Due To Walking On His Hind Legs.
The Amount Of Abuse I Got From The Die Hard Fans, Who Are So Ignorant To What Is Really Going On And Wish To Wear Rose Coloured Glasses.
I Was Told To Move On, Don't Watch Bibi If I Have Nothing To Say Etc, Etc.
Viewers Love To Comment On Bibi's Cute Outfits, And Clever Antics.
Mr Quan Adores Bibi Like A Son, They Say.
He Is Adored And Well Care For,
They Say.
That Little Monkey Is Exhausted Filming 3 Times A Day, Taking Orders From The Cameraman For His Every Move.
Oh Yes Mr Quan Loves Bibi.
Who Would Not Love A Money Making Machine That Has Made Him Very, Very Wealthy.
They Have Now Introduced A New Baby Monkey To The Channel, Is This Baby Monkey Replacing Bibi, As He Matures And His Cuteness Fades.
All Very Tragic
All Very Sad
All For Money, Money, Money.
Not The Happiness Or The Wellbeing Of The Monkey.
I agree! And now he brought in another monkey.
I watched Bibi for about 2 - 3 months I think, and was so so so attracted to him. Then I began to question the channel but got no answers. The channel then banned me. I reported the channel and took it further and filed a complaint to env in Vietnam. The protection law for endangered species there is active.
Same treatment got some of us who criticize Kaka and Mit, and congratulate ENV for having them confiscated. All the fans are putting a big mess, mailing and calling ENV because they want the monkeys back.
Aw this is awful, yes i could imagine the horrible responses you received from this...
@@mariagloriazanardi3142Env has Kaka and Mit in dirty nasty cage thanks to confiscated of them. They have lost half of there weight. Monkey Puka who is in the cage with them is very sick in this cage with no medical care. There are 4 Monkeys in this cage. This is where all the confiscated monkey go by the ENV. They go into a cage.
2:14 To add to your point, and to this clip you've added: Baby monkeys *_do not_* spend all of their time *_screaming_* bloody murder, like this poor fellow here. Macaques are normally not very noisy unless they're in a fight with each other or are in distress.
These Pet Monkey channels give us such a distorted view, that I've seen well-meaning people make comments on videos from animal rescue groups in India, comments accusing them of "cutting their vocal chords" and/or drugging the macaques in these groups' care. The reality is, that India reveres monkeys, due to Hinduism, and that these macaques are actually calm, not in distress, because they're being cared for.
Well said. There are too many misconceptions about these macaques...
It’s like thinking we can learn about human society by watching Popeye cartoons.
There was an article in National Geographic that quoted a vet who said that 99.9% of baby monkeys raised by humans end up with severe emotional trauma that they never outgrow. Similar thoughts in the same article from the director of a primate rescue in Kentucky that echoed the same things
That's very sad to hear this, but it is not surprising...
Es ist auch das Problem, wieviel von diesen armen Tieren diese Tourturen generell überleben 😢😢😢
@@fightagainstanimalcruelty-k1x tours?
Cant stand them monkey channels that dress them up and put diapers on them
Are these the same experts that shut down the world for a BAD COLD.
Wild animals should not be pets, caged, or treated as entertainment
I Have Now REPORTED The
Miker/ Lucky Channel.
Could Believe What I Was Seeing.
Thumbnail Always Exposing His Privacy.
The Owner Is A Monster.
That Darling Little Monkey Is So Very Traumatized And Nervous.
He Knows And Feels What That Lady Is Doing To Him Is Wrong.
She Is Abusing Him In The Most Horrific Way Showing His Private Parts After Doing Whatever She Was Doing To Him.
Please, Please, Please Let's All Unite And Shut Down This Horrifying Channel.
How Could People Do This To Innocent, Beautiful Little Beings.
Thank You.
Aw thank you so much for doing this! I can see these channels have upset you here. You're right, I have no idea how anyone could do any of this to these beautiful animals... I've reported several recently and haven't heard a thing about any of them yet 😡
She doesn't even own Miker anymore. He was taken away a long time ago. All of those videos are old.
@@ToxicBarbz
Thank You Very Much For Your Comment.
I Hope Little Miker Is Safe And Well.
So This Monster Of A Woman Is Still Making Money From Old Videos!
It Should Not Be Allowed.
Și eu am raportat canale, dar nu am văzut decât ca își fac canale noi și o iau de la început cu tortura. Tina, Poor, Luk, Kyo, Lucky sunt canale actuale și care promovează o tortura mascata. Am scris și la ENV și mi au răspuns ca în Vietnam nu se difuzează aceste canale și ei nu au ce face. Le am propus sa ia fiecare strada în parte pe picioare și vor confisca o mulțime de maimuțe și mi au răspuns ca ei acționează doar la o reclamație. Am reclamat Tina Monkey și au dat din umeri. Cum putem scoate aceste păpuși sălbatice din mâinile acestor tirani? Trebuie sa fie o soluție! Mulțumesc!
3:32 Another enhancement of your point here: Due to habitat loss, macaques have become problem-wildlife in India. And the reality of human-monkey interaction is *_not good:_* people are having to abandon their villages, which just shows how *_completely ill-suited monkeys are as pets._*
Forest cover in India is actually growing. It is not habitat loss causing monkey human interaction in India. It is greedy macaques who get used to handouts of food from humans and feeding on easily available food waste, thereby incentivising themselves to migrate closer to human settlements.
Thank you for helping to bring the unknowns to peoples eyes regarding these channels. IMO Monkeys in the wild offer much to love but less to learn about ourselves. People cannot often benefit from knowing nature but they can benefit from knowing themselves better. What is done should be stopped if it is wrong but what is done is done and should be learned from. I think people SHOULD see monkey channels before they get removed (as they should indeed be removed). I believe the inherent cruelty of what they are seeing will resonate with them in some sense and they could make connections between their behaviors and those captivity monkeys. Abused Humans can learn volumes from watching these Monkeys in a suffering not too far from removed from their own. After all , that is truly all these mean channel owners are doing. Revisiting the pains of their past on the creatures and people of the present.
This is a human behavior and human behavior is as wild as monkeys. Simply because we don clothes and hold forks does NOT MAKE US HUMAN, you have said this yourself Monkey Mercy, but in terms of monkeys holding forks and wearing clothes not being human just because they do so.. Being human is something learned. Being Human is taken for granted in our own sufferings and we forget that we must build humanity in others.
The monkeys can remind of us our humanity as we peer into them so intently looking to see their humanity. We can improve together.
Χαρηκα πολύ για το νέο σας βιντεο λατρευω τα ζώα και πιο πολύ τα μαϊμουδάκια όταν τα βλέπω στη φύση τους κρεμασμένα από το στήθος της μάνας τους σκέφτομαι τα καημένα που ζουν με τους βασανιστές ποσό υποφέρουν για ένα πιάτο φαΐ και είμαι τόσο θυμό μένη με τους θεατές που υποστηρίζουν αυτή την εκμετάλλευση ποσό άδειοι στην ψυχή είναι για να χειροκροτούν αυτό το ψέμα το βλέπουν ότι όλοι κάνουν τα ίδια και έχουν ένα μεγαλύτερο και παίρνουν όλοι και ένα μικρο και αναγκάζουν το μεγαλύτερο να κουβαλάει το μικρο αηδιάζω και όταν τους γράφω ότι είναι λάθος αυτό που κάνουν με βρίζουν δεν με ενδιαφέρει φυσικά έχω υγείη μυαλό και βλέπω το λάθος από το σωστό ευχωμαι να το δουν και αυτοί και μονο τότε θα σταματηση αυτό το κακό
Aw I know, it is absolutely heartbreaking seeing the babies trying so hard to cling and nurse as they should do with their real mothers... Thank you for your comment.
Una iluminada 😂😂😂
These Monkey Pet Channels must be forbidden, that is pur Animal abuse and cruelty to our lil cousins!
Nuestros primos????😂😂😂😂 a lo mejor pariente tuyo sera
Cousins?? Seriously?? Wow, the sickness is real!
@@c.c.1070 I doubt that "cousin" was meant in a literal way.
I understand what you said. And yes,they are being abused.
Le contenu de la vidéo est fait pour vous mener exactement à cette déclaration, et lle conditionnement a bien fonctionné, vous avez répété comme un perroquet, sans plus réfléchir.
Education are teaching us how we're humans not creatures
People take monkeys form the wild. Forget that. If Society allowed me, and wouldn't try and jail me for being homeless, Id go live with the monkeys!
humans can be worse than animals and scarier than ghost...sad but true
very true!
Another informative video 🤝🙏
Aw thank you for your support. I still get nervous after releasing these videos...
@@monkeymercy124 You are doing a phenomenal job!!!
@@monkeymercy124you are doing a great job.😊
@@monkeymercy124you don't have to be nervous. But, no video will change anything until all animal videos are banned from all social media platforms. Then monkeys will stop being kept at home. Since these are only kept because money can be made through the viewers. But the helplessness of not being able to do anything against these companies makes me angry and sad at the same time.
Hi, can you please tell me why vets (real ones) will treat these pet monkeys but not report them to the authorities? I've seen Monkey Bibi and others taken to the vets and they receive full care and even get played with and have their photos taken at times. I find this very confusing. Perhaps by law they are bound to treat all animals?? I looked up the vet Monkey Bibi goes to and it's legit.
Corruption is a problem in Vietnam. Bribes and who you know carry the day.
@@ElenaGeorge1 Ah OK, thank you
@@Chlobet Yes, unfortunately when I looked into this, i have come to the conclusion that it is a mixture of things, with money being a big one...
Ich denke, es sind auch viele Fake- Ärzte dabei... wenn man die Räumlichkeiten und Details genau beobachtet, wird dieser Verdacht stärker...??
@@fightagainstanimalcruelty-k1xYes, if you pay close attention to the little details, you can clearly see they are fake. Like “curtains” with folds in them, where it is clear the fabric was just taken out of the package. White coats with a Red Cross made out of paper stuck on the coat, you can see it is just stuck there with tape as you can see places where it is lifted up off the shirt.
Another clue is that they shove a thermometer clear up the monkeys rectum, causing great pain, when they really only need to just barely putting it in the rectum. Many have no idea how to give a shot either.
Merci pour les sous-titres en français
Félicitations pour votre travail
Je préfère regarder les singes dans la nature
Bonjour de France
Hi Lisa, thank you for watching!
I have been so upset lately at seeing a social media page that keeps popping up with monkeys dressed and doing human things. Called Bibi I think. Thank God for you educators!!!
Here on RUclips there’s a Family BiBi and Monkey BiBi channel, same family, same monkey. Many YT and Facebook channels and pages have some variation of the name ‘Bibi’, it’s very popular.
@NancyM1115 and it's all exploitation, unfortunately 😢
@@NancyM1115all the monkey channels play the same repeated music..wonder if it's even the 1 same video editor .. lmfao
@@alvinkhoonever thought about that good point!!
I do watch this channel and the vervet channel.
Love the vervet channel! You may also enjoy the Orangutan Jungle School, they have the series here on RUclips.
@@NancyM1115 Okay thanks. I have also been watching a chimp channel.
Le commentaire introductif relève d'une philosophie essentialiste, qui pense que tout comportement est instinctif, et que les individus, humains ou animaux, ne peuvent apprendre et évoluer, en fonction des circonstances, des rencontres, et de l'environnement. C'est une vision figée des choses, qui s'oppose d'ailleurs à la théorie de l'évolution de Darwin. Je ne la partage pas, et très peu de scientifiques en sont encore là. Ne sous-estimez pas l'intelligence et la capacité d'adaptation et d'évolution des singes. Des études scientifiques montrent qu'il peuvent apprendre jusquà 800 mots écrits, et communiquer par le langage des signes des sourd-muets. Ce n'est pas dans leurs meutes naturelle qu'ils l'apprennent, bien que certaines mères transmettent en partie à leur progéniture ces acquisitions, comme ils apprennent entre eux les maniements d'outils et par exemple à ouvrir les coquillages pour les consommer. C'est au contact des humains qu'ils apprennent ou de leurs congénères plus évolués. Bref votre vision figée de la vie et de la nature est avant tout idéologique et n'a rien de scientifique.
I'm think you may have misunderstood the video because nobody is underestimating the intelligence and abilities of these primates. Indeed, these are very intelligent animals and that is kind of the point... I am not talking about their ability to learn words and other forms of communication.
@@monkeymercy124 Je pense avoir compris votre propos. Mais je ne peux le partager pour les raisons ci dessus. Tout progrès, qui peut prendre des siècles voire des millénaires, se produit par le changement et les contacts et expériences nouvelles, la nature elle même n'est pas stable et et évolue sans cesse, le climat également, et la progression en nombre de l'espèce humaine entraine inéluctablement la déforestation et une urbanisation croissante, à laquelle du reste de nombreuses espèces de singes qui envahissent les villes se sont adaptées. (New Dehli) Nous devons cohabiter sur cette planète et les formes de cohabitation évoluent elles aussi, nous sommes à ce tournant. Il faut élargir votre perspective.
@@electra-gal I will be happy to broaden my perspective when I see reliable evidence that these wild animals are not being unnecessarily exploited, abused and suffering as a consequence.
@@electra-gal Have you seen the planet of the apes? I don't know about you, but for me, I prefer to stay human if someone trains me to be a monkey. Perhaps you don't mind being a monkey and called a monkey. Does a monkey have a choice in the hands of a dumb human being? We are talking about animal abuse here and there is a protection law for them from being abused. Get lost with your evolution theory. This is not the worry and pain of monkeys. They just want freedom like you do,, being themselves.
It's not just about macaques, it applies to all wild animals that end up in zoos and not in their natural environment. The videos you show are only those in Southeast Asia. But when an American does that, where the macaques walk around in clothes and are treated like human babies, strangely enough most people say (you are a good mom, so cute, etc.). I wonder if you are perhaps racist!!?? What about the animals that act or work in Hollywood, is that fair???
ruclips.net/video/nTxTyIJ7oYM/видео.htmlsi=qJHNEK9YPM01BwRZ
i totally agree with your point and yes I have discussed other animals in other parts of the world too. The reason I chose specifically to focus on macaques in these recent videos is because it starts to get confusing when I discuss different species in all in one video. It is not possible to cover everything coherently at once. As macaques are very popular at the moment, that is why I decided to research this species for now. This research takes me a long time to conduct, so I cannot cover it all in such a short time.
I heard your arguments but example monkey Bibi is clear as day he is part of the family and not abused in any way..he loves the family and the family loves him back so there is nothing wrong
Thank you for your comment, but unfortunately this little guy is extremely exploited for entertainment. This is exactly what the channel owners want you to believe. The monkey is displaying so many worrying signs in relation to his mobility and overall health...
bibi is a money earning tool for quan...u've been following them? haven't u realised they live in 3 big houses in Vietnam? bibi being separated since birth from mother is correct to u? how u feel if u got seperated from yours?!
@@alvinkhoo in fact that they live already well makes explotaion of such a cool monkey improbable imo ..Apart from the fact that the love shown to Bibi is family quality, how Bibi reacts to other animals reflects a happy and loving upbringing. Just as dogs, monkeys apparently can enjoy a good family life. There are too many good signs to place accusations without concrete evidence.
@@siliconmalta2349Do you ever see them as adults on similar videos? No, because as soon as they grow up, they aren't as cute and are hard to handle, so they get dumped and suddenly there is a new "Bibi".
@@CindyKern-wj9wg Bibi is the first ever channel I watched, so I don't have that experience. What age are you referring to when they are dumped? because RUclips has been around for so long... I think we have to wait and see what happens with Bibi. In Vietnam, it is very common for people to keep monkeys as pets. Like there are people who treat dogs bad that doesnt mean every dog owner is bad... I still have to see any evidence Bibi is being maltreated or abused.
Ho letto un commento di qualcuno che diceva che la 🐒 xxx, era fortunata poiché viveva nel "lusso", andava al ristorante, aveva la piscina ecc... e per questo era amata dal suo "papà", questo è quello che credono o vogliono credere i suoi seguitori, loro vedono l'apparenza e non pensano o non vogliono pensare a cosa c'è dietro alla sceneggiatura, purtroppo c'è gente che ancora crede che queste 🐒🐒 sono "salvate" e fortunate perché hanno una casa, una "mamma" e/o un "papà"
I think you are referring to monkey Bibi that is a male animal. I read somewhere that his human father has had monkeys before. Monkey Bibi is the biggest monkey channel at the moment I think. To get this large, a lot of work has been put on Bibi. When it is offset, Bibi is at the mercy of these people. The viewers are a big part of the problem. They encourage this sort of exploitation.