Anupama Chopra's Movie Review of Manmarziyaan | Anurag Kashyap | Taapsee | Vicky | Abhishek
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 8 сен 2024
- Love, it is often said, is a many splendored thing. In Manmarziyaan, director Anurag Kashyap and writer and creative producer Kanika Dhillon offer us a deep-dive into this splendor.
For years, I’ve exited Anurag’s films raging with frustration and wondering why he inevitably becomes indulgent. Manmarizyaan is no different. He’s so damn talented but he doesn’t know when to stop.
Like love, this film is messy and flawed and glorious. You have to sign up for all of it.
Have you subscribed to Film Companion yet? Join us here -
bit.ly/FCsubscribe
Visit us at filmcompanion.in
Do Like, Share, Comment & Subscribe to our channel.
Subscribe: bit.ly/FCsubscribe
Follow Us On:
/ filmcompanion
/ filmcompanion
/ filmcompanion
The Film Companion is a web channel intended to promote Indian cinema through films review, interviews, discussions, video essays and analytical compilations. It is intended primarily for the purpose of encouraging informed discussions, criticism and review of cinema and towards such purpose the programs use short extracts of cinematograph films, sounds recording and photographic works. These clips and extracts are of a minimal nature and the use is not intended to interfere in any manner with their commercial exploitation of the compete work by the owners of the copyright. The use of works are in compliance with the fair dealing exception provided under Sec. 52 of the Copyright Act, and we asset our use of the works under the exception provided for criticism and review.
Anurag: "Hindi cinema's high priest of darkness..... Probably the most accurate description ever
i thought that title would fit RGV (anurags teacher) more than anurag. even the recent veerappan.
matlab bhi pata hai uska?
This is the most mature indian movie I have watched. Must have been a little too spicy for many. Beautiful movie...
1. An affair with intimacy
2. Parent aware of the affair
No dad threatening to shot a daughter who has brought shame to the family
3. Talk of abortion
4. Kissing
5. Infidelity etc
sometimes it felt unreal😄😄. I watched it in English dubbed I had to remind myself it's Bollywood. The 3 of them were a joy to watch and performed so well.
She didn't use the word 'Convoluted'... movie must be good 🤔
You rightly pointed out that Anurag Kashyap movies suffer from self indulgence at times,he doesn't know when to stop. I especially felt this while watching Mukkabaaz.
So Abhishek has reenacted his role from "main prem ki diwani hu"..only crazy Roshan is missing now
that and maybe a shade of Kabhi Alvida Naa Kehna. if they cast someone else it would be much more interesting.
Hahaha 😂 crazy Roshan was high on drugs in that movie
that movie was a competition between 3 leading actors as who’ll do the best overacting and guess it was a tie between Kareena and Roshan
@@amaanimtiyaz4489 but still it wasn't Kareena's best... Remember pooo in kabhi khushi kabhi gum...
@@amaanimtiyaz4489 na Roshan was the best in that movie..but at least most actors knew what tone the movie was..on other hand our boy bluff master even ruined that movie
I honestly think Indian audiences are genuinely stupid. I agree with Mrs. Chopra- despite its flaws, Manmarziyaan is a genuine film with amazing performances, great music (probably the best soundtrack of the year), and solid direction. It’s a bit too long, but I don’t think this deserves to flop. It’s ridiculous that Race 3, and DHADAK mint 100 Cr’s and this cant make 50. Collection isn’t the most important thing, but I don’t understand how an Anurag Kashyap film isn’t pulling audiences but two star kids who can’t act pull massive crowds. Even Stree somehow made it to a 100, although while extremely funny and a great movie, kind of had a nonsensical plot. Manmarziyaan isn’t a masterpiece, but it should get more crowds than what it’s getting. I went in with zero expectations, only looking forward to Vicky Kaushal’s and Abishek’s performance, and it turned out to be quite entertaining. It’s kind of a shame...
Lol. This movie makes absolutely no sense. Not entertaining but most frustrating.. unnecessarily complicating things. Already we hv seen hum dil de chuke sanam in this genre nd dat was the best n made sense.. but this one is total shit
All 3 main characters of the movie had absolutely no stand at all. And ya u r right Bollywood audience is really stupid to like this shit
@kunal Do we in real life take stand in such situations? Life is not black n white like bollywood movies
mind-blowing movie from MR... KASHYAP....
AND ALL STARS PERFOMANCE IS FENOMINAL..NO WORDS FOR DESCRIBING THEM .. VICKY KAUSHAL IS VRSATILE....
KAL HI TANKI FULL KRAYI HAI TERE YAR NE.....WHAT A EXPRESSIONS ...😂
I was expecting 4 star with a big smile on my face through out the review
Anurag kashyap movies shows the fourth dimension of love which is far away of being good at everytime. His cinema is more natural and characters looks real. Anurag has his own world where only the untouched part of any relation unfolds.
Hence proved that there is no limit to Kashyap's brilliance
Anupama's English is getting thicker than Anurag's darkness... 😍😎😲
What an outstanding review, ma'am.. I mean, from metaphors to the selection of words.. Omg.. Thank you very much Anupama ma'am :) Brightened up my day!
I could listen to her speak till the end of time. this was such a beautifully presented review!
Want to watch it for Mr. Abhishek Bachchan.Want him in more movies .omg those beautiful big eyes emoting.Its amazing how in the movies he portrays the character of this deep beautiful man .
You are so spot on about Anurag's indulgence always taking things away from the films.
With this generation lazily hailing him as a cinematic god, glad we still have critics who give us a fair review of his films.
Sarah Siddiqui I couldn’t agree more
She gave 3.5/5 ⭐'s
Save ur time😇
i hav never understood Annu's definition of indulgent? one wonders what wd she say while watching tarsokvsy's film then
She will give it again 3and half stars ;)
Hey Bro, Where did you find Tarasokvsy's movies? Could you please share the link?
ruclips.net/video/gVpJTLpPLD0/видео.html
tarkovsky's movies are NOT TO BE REVIEWED movies. they stand at the highest level of subjectivity, especially the last one: Sacrifice
thanks bro
I am sitting here with a thesaurus.
That's sad if you need a thesaurus for simple English.
Why? Because I am supposed to know all the words of the English Language? Or do you feel it is imperative for everyone to understand this particular language?
It is even sadder that you don't understand a good joke.
Haha... U r not the only one...
Its good that Anupama's reviews are helping you learn basic English. Because as film critiques they have ceased to be informative and have become very predictable.
Lol..good one.
Anurag Kashyap directs a love story? I bet for the scene in the promos when Abhishek and Tapsee were taking drinking shots together, the original script probably meant a whole different type of 'shots.'
I was going to watch it as it's an Anuraag film, but your review sealed the deal. 👌
Good content for english listening practice, TOEFL, IELTS!
Loved the movie...Welcome back Abhishek..Vickey and Tapasi..long ways to go.. Happy for you people.and obvio the Ship of the captain..Kashyap sir.
Anyone first day first show ? You can trust Anurag and his movies
Saw it here in Abu Dhabi. Loved it.
Reviews after Toronto were average, it's ok but it doesn't stray from typical bollywood romantic films. Could see shades of tanu weds manu hddcs and probable what other movies anupama mentioned. Watch it for Vicky kushal, he part where abhishek comes starts to become predictable and less interesting. Abhishek character or his performance made madhavans look great, I'll be seeing tanu weds manu again after this average movie.
Watched first day first show. 1st half is entertaining but after that it becomes pain in the ass and boring. But i liked the ending. 3/5
Watched it was ok, still a waste of money since 2nd half wasn't as good as first half. Anurag could have done it better or stick to his kind of film. Same old performance by abhishek, nothing new. People saw him in comedy in past films, for them abhishek in romantic would be probably liked. Because of him the movie drags and anurag cannot do much. Obviously we have seen other movies like this, the only thing that is a breath of fresh air is Vicky and tapsee. It's like contination of tanu weds manu.
A must watch 👍🏻👍🏻Anurag is the best.
The only thing I like about Anurag is his irrepressible indulgence. That is what lends the distinctive edge to his movies. What you call as messy and flawed is what I find original. Whatever is original cannot have a set template that the audience can relate to, it is often gloriously messy and flawed. However I do think instead of Abhisekh he should have taken madhavan.
That's never ending process, all star kids are doing every kind of films and we always end up saying he/she would have good instead of him or her. So let it go
I have not yet watched the movie so dont want to be critical of AB not unless i see his performance. But from the reviews I am getting sense that he his character has been dull. By the way everyone was going gaga over kangana in Tannu weds Mannu series but I think Madhavan performed much much better than her.
Ditto
madhvan ... no not at all ... that would be also a case of typecasting . Madhvan deserves better roles .
@@djshelin
Considering the producer of this movie brought tanu weds manu, it would be great to see madhavan again in Hindi movies even if it means typecasting him. But he deserves better.
Is she speaking Shakespearean English.. I doubt..ye hindi movie bhi English subtitle ke saath dekhti hogi.
Sahi bola bhai
lol
i was also going to comment the same thing
kya bola bhai😁😁😁😁👏👏👌
This version of English is the standard one.Step yourself up a bit.
Anurag Kastyap directing a movie with a love triangle is good enough reason to buy the tickets!
she sum up everything brilliantly.
♥️
3 and a half means it's great
nabin steyn or may b biased sacred games link....
@@scarlettohara85 *sCaRed* games? Lol
Ava Zahed thnx 🤗🤗...corrected 🤓🤓 still learning eng...🙄
She's the same woman,who gave Ram Leela just 2 & 1/2 half stars.
Happy Ganesh chaturthi ma'am😀
Baba itna bhari English, sab upar se nikal gaya.. Movie dekhna hai ya nahi 🤔
Pakka Dekhni hai bhai..
Befikre Unty ke 3.5 ⭐ means movie 4 ⭐ ki hai.
Ankit Jalan
3.5 🌟mtlb acchi h....dekh lena👍😊
3 1/2 star is a definite yes.
Ankit Jalan , bilkul dekho yaar.
"इतना" भारी नहीं "इतनी" भारी, अंग्रेजी नहीं आती तो कम से कम हिंदी तो ठीक से लिख लीजिये।
Where's sucharitas review? Lol tell her to start reviewing 2 movies a week again, like she used too lol thx
So happy for the team.. 😍..Congrats guys..
I prefer the indulgent AK. No other way.
I think 3.5 starts is her set line like which movie is ever gonna get a different rating? Good or bad or excellent or worse, any film she reviews is 3.5 stars. I don’t think that all movies are of the same rating!
Oh no.. never expected to hear this dialogue in an Anurag Kashyap movie..
"Tum Insaan k roop mey Bhagwan ho ya Bhagwan k roop mey Insaan" yukks 😝
Bacha Bachchan is probably the weak link of the story.. will have to watch the movie now to find out if character was weak or the portrayal..
trailer also had hints of " zero spark " between AB & TP..
hmm idk.. but maybe.. someone like Kunal Kapoor could have pulled it off better.
but he had done a ditto role in Bachna hai Haseeno I gz
that dialogue is in kabhi kabhi not manmarziyan....spouted by rakhi
Heard it first in Veer Zara from Rani Mukherjee.
No he beat ranbir in that movie. It was different character
Madhavan would be better wonder why Anand rai the producer didn't choose him after all the role and story of manmarziyan resembles tanu weds manu. It would be great to see madhavan again.
Arey keep Madhavan away from this now. He's much better in dark and intense roles (Breathe, Vikram Vedha, Saala Khadoos). Looking forward to his villanious act in Simbaa.
Anupama bandi na barri sahi hai lakin achi film ki ratings pay hug deti hai.
This comment made my day🤣😆👏👏👏👏
All said nd done over all superb movie anurag kashyap prove it he is dark nd blowing future in Hindi cinema's. Worth watched it
so, now I'll exit the theater after watching the first half. thanks for saving my time.
Hehe don't do that, or you'll end up like the Cannes audience when Karan Johar was screening Kabhi Khushi Kabhie Gham! : ruclips.net/video/5Yu3kkH2reg/видео.html
Haha
Exactly
Did you follow her words even in Befikre (3.5) but Padmaavat (2.5) Karwaan (2)..If yes then you can do that.If not then ..no comments..Watch Race 3.
I've never seen the whole theatre audience feeling like running away from the theatre ... Worst movie I've ever seen
haha, after being frustrated by anurag for years i've come to the conclusion that he just hates conclusions. he's allergic to neatly tied up narrative structure and loves leaving things open-ended and inconclusive. and we just have to love him for it. :D
(ps - Film Companion, can't you make an executive decision to just delete the trolling comments about Anupama's english? i understand you want to keep an open discussion but when it's the same crap in video after video, clearly by people who have no aim but to personally attack, i think it's ok to delete. why give idiots a platform they don't deserve?)
I don’t have an issue with open-ended films - it’s the length that kills me 😄
- Anupama Chopra
:D
Well, that's exactly what I said walking out from the theatres..He should have stopped atleast 15 min before "the end"...and as much as I loved the first half..the last walk between the two characters sharing their lives...just didn't connect..
Anurag Kashyap was making his own way...but towards the end (with that walk shot) he went Imtiaz's way - where he fall s flat...
Having said all that - I can watch it again for Vicky Kaushal and Taapsee Pannu - their relationship felt REAL. Such a good complex, messy romantic story after such a long time :)
Tum isnaan k roop mein devta yah devta k roop mein insaan... This was already used in veer-zaara... Bas "devta" ki jagah "khuda" tha usme
Yeh Veere Zaara ka dialogue tha na..
@@sidharthanayak1064 yes sir
Abe over intelligent. It's a normal dialogue /phrase. Aise to kitni movies me bolte hain, I love you I can't live without you. Ab isey bhi copy manoge kya? Chirkut
@@stifler4eva1 it was just an observation... There's no intelligence in it but you seems to be over-couragous by hiding behind a device... But i respect u dude... May be the intelligence taught you to be cordial even with non-cordial people too! Best of luck
My fav .. F for Fyaar ... Then Dhyan Chand and then Daryaa.... 💃💃💃
Throughout the movie I wondered who are the twin girls who kept showing up across the movie and both kept doing the same things. Now I think they were Rajeev Masand and Anupama Chopra!!!! Identical reviews!!!
She didn't mention Abhishek's perfromance People have really like performance.Sometimes I really think she has some problem with the Bachans..Why mam!!Abhishek Bahcan!Welcome back..and Congratulation team..
What a glorious use of the english language by Anupama
three and a half star from her! Damn I have to watch this movie
Wait guys, we are yet to hear our Rajiv's review on this movie.
Is it only me who thinks this is by far the best Anupama chopra has ever reviewed any damn film in her entire carrier.
#HandsDown THE BEST🙂
I will never take bollywood seriously unless Punjabis in bollywood movies stop speaking Hindi.
Wow anupama seriously after 1,2 stars now suddenly 3 and a half I think now your review are improving.
By saying Abhishek plays role that is "Sacrificing", have you spoiled the movie for us?
One of the most beautiful review of year
Lots of vocab I learnt today for this interview 😉
I watch her reviews to read comments.
What a masterful review Masha Allah. Anu ma'am u are sooo good with words it's like poetry in motion.
Why Anurag is given all the credit? Critics should praise the effort put up by the Screenwriter. Anurag has just played the role of a manager in this film. Coz the film was supposed to be directed by another man. Anurag came on board after a while.
And got stuck with abhishek.
Cindy S That's the point. She appears to be selective when it comes to appreciate the team effort.
was waiting to hear your review.... Will go tow watch this one for sure....
that is my opinion also. anurag is an excellent directir but he don't know when to stop (y)
Ywoooo..
Iam the first to have liked this video.. You should send me across a gift hamper..But but , I expected some more scrutiny, some more detailed critical insight..You sounded incomplete Anupama.. We, the overseas audiences almost see movies through your eyes..
Anurag was due.
Great come back that..😉🏂🏇⛷️🤺
Robbie kills Vicky's future with his maturity n without a single physical blow. Kuch Ladkiyaan ek settled future ke khatir, pyaar ko fyaar samajke, pichle rishte ko aasani se bhulakar, naye rishte joddney ka mouka kabhi nahin thukrayegi. A good lesson for the Next Gen. Zindagi ki taali ek haath se nahin bajti. SalmanKhan as Vicky, Robbie as Abhi n Taapsee as Aish? Wish there is a sequel when Vicky becomes a millionaire instead of a Taxi Driver n Robbie dumps Rumi for a British girl in London 😃😃
3.5
Means the movie is worth watching ...
Hum dil dey chukay Sanam...with Facebook...the whole story...
Guys movies is superb go watch it its modern day real time Romance🔥🔥Abhishek role long and superb tapsi and Vicky is freemind...... Background music superbbbb👌👍... Only Anurag make this kind of Superbbbb Romance👌👍🔥🔥
I know its too much to ask, but could you please educate people with interest in writing on how to write a screenplay for a story that is on paper.
Glad that you are trending anupama mam..
Toh achhi hai ya kharab ?
aunty ke hisab se achhi hai...
@@joeyballinger4077 itne heavy words maare...samjha hi nahi tareef kar rahi hai ya burai..
Ok better to stay home and watch tanu weds manu.
She can't understand what you said.. she can't speak hindi...since it's not cool nor makes her look intellectual...its beneath her status to speak hindi or review in hindi.... all the tapori indians are out of luck..haha
@@joeanil bhai fans basically!
Anupama please watch Jules and Jim, 1962 French movie. The best movie in this type of love triangle genre. I don't know if anurag is influenced by this French movie b.c manmarziyaan also resembles this one among other movies too.
Review is good , But of Befikre factor we don't believe you ! Befikre Aunty
Mujtaba Sonaullah Really ???
Befikre banane k liye Aditya Chopra Ko shayad itta hate nahi Mila Hoga.. jitta uske 5 min review k liye..
suno sab ka.. par
khud ka dimag lagao
Karwaan 2 stars..lol
For the first time I agree with you a 100%
Wonderful review again by You Anupama Ma'am .
Now I'm waiting to see how sucharita reviews this!
After this review Anurag Kashyap will say Itna to maine bhi nahi socha tha
Haan maine bhi... KANK, Main prem ki diwani & now this... I'm seeing AB in these sort of roles since my childhood....
I knew it was going to be 3.5 stars before even watching the review! The reviews are always a fun watch, but the final rating is always maddening - I feel like 85% of the films get 3.5 stars, ugh!
Waiting for Sucharita's review of Manmarziyaan..
Why did she speak so less about Abhishek sir? He is an AMAZING actor and was sooo good in the film! Give him his due credit! Disliked. (really sorry, but big AB fan)
The movie is not for you guys, it's for people who love Vicky and tapsee.
Cindy S have you really watched the movie??Be honest..
@@RahulMishra-sz2ss
Yes not good, it was overhyped. Anurag cannot do much other than what has been done in other films like tanu weds manu queen. Movie drags when abhishek comes in, maybe people will like it because he hasn't done romantic films recently. First half good, but it's not worth my money. Oh well, hope anurag gets back to doing what he does best.
excellent movie by anurag kashyap realistic and our public dnt lyk real movies they like all fairy tales
this Movie is beautiful disappointment... First half is on Steroids while second half is painfully slow..feels like filler😞
AB BABY IS BACK WITH GREAT
With so much praise comes 3.5 stars. Really? I just don't understand the algorithm!
Ok.. so we can watch.. the only thing I understand is 3.5
You might have forgot to mention Ram Akshya Kumar from Dhadkaan
😉
/*Spoiler Alerts */
Good review ...as expected from you ... I think those twin sisters dancing behind actress represent the duality of her mind ... all three characters are confused in their way and really don't know what they want....but the actress is the most confused one between two choices (I think Anurag wanted to represent that duality of mind through those twin sisters...the significance of the two twins is, in my opinion, most of the time we have two choices that appeal to us but we can't decide which one to choose ) ...The actress wanted to be a rebellion, but at the same time, she is also practical and knows the stability of life and marriage is also important and here Vicky Vs. Abhishek represents these two possibilities in their way...
funny thing in the movie is both Romi & Vicky wanted to be rebellion, but their parents are so understanding & sweet they couldn't find the fun of bhag ke sahddi kar lenge because girl's family always support their marriage except for Vicky's father who thinks his son is not mature enough to take the responsibility of the marriage and may ruin Romi's life (again so sweet and mature attempt to show the change in the society) ...this is very relevant to the current generation where love marriages are no longer a taboo.
To be honest, I loved the last five mins of the movie where both lead characters have a casual talk about why they married in the first place. ...and here you see Abhishek's real character as he is also a little bit twisted as the other two characters and not a god-like character played by Ajay Devgan in Hum Dil De Chuke Sanam ...
so she left intellectual , Sacrificing , humble , well understanding , Responsible man for a local wasterul...
doesn't all that women aspire to have in Men whom they love...
I am a huge anurag fan so i went to watch it the first half was quite engaging and anuragish but the second half was just of the tune and became predictable and anurag showed a glimpse of karan johar escpecially the last scene.
When will she ever be satisfied by movie!! 🙄 Manmarziyaan sure deserves a 4 at least!
"Kab Tak Rokoge" ABHI Is Next Superstar Of Bollywood
Paid review. The movie is boring. And doesn't seem to end. Watch some other movie. Instead of wasting money on this shit.
In Toronto after TIFF saw the evening show, it's an ok movie. Watched it for anurag and tapsee. But the movie becomes bore and predictable after abhishek enters. He doesn't do much than b.c the love triangle stories have been done and there is no originality in his performance. His role is been there done that, weak point of the movie. Other than Vicky and tapsee were interesting part of the movie and their story. Tapsee and kangana have are the new women in today's day and age. Overall I wish the movie would be better. Because of Anand rai's previous movie i had preconceived motions. The movie is just ok.
It’s awesome movie, wish more boys in the worls like Robbie
Alright. So, that means movie is as good as 'Befikre'. :)
Anupama, I love you. 💕
I LL just confirm with Rajeev Masand and Sucharita
You confused me at the end
Don't understand why AB never works on his accent and diction? He should have sounded fluent Punjabi-speaker but he just doesn't
I'm loving this channel.
Nothing new in this movie. I think Anurag have seen lots of south movies which have same theme and story.then he added punjabi masala to it to make this version. But Abhishek done good job. Stars 2/ 5
You were not happy with second half..and said anugrag did not know when to stop for loving scene and repeatative also.....still 3.5 star.....made me confused watch or not to watch😂😂😎😎
Meaning second half abhishek is coming, get out of the theatres as fast as you can.
@@Finnola ....Ha ha ha.....absolute right...