The internal divide over Taiwan’s future | Witness Documentary

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 10 дек 2024

Комментарии • 69

  • @aljazeeraenglish
    @aljazeeraenglish  8 дней назад +3

    Thanks for tuning in. Share your thoughts with us in the comments below. Please note that hateful and inappropriate comments will be removed. If you'd like to watch more documentaries from Witness, find them here: ruclips.net/p/PL6698BA1F3CDC7323
    More from Witness on:
    Facebook: facebook.com/AJWitness
    Twitter: twitter.com/AJWitness
    Instagram: instagram.com/AJWitness

    • @1.4billion65
      @1.4billion65 5 дней назад

      After watching your video, My thought is China should ally with Israel.

  • @danieljames6941
    @danieljames6941 3 дня назад +3

    These Taiwanese people have not been in and experienced their life at 'War Zone' before, acting like they are brave enough to face in the real situations. God bless you!

  • @Ccb88888
    @Ccb88888 6 дней назад +7

    Omg what an ugly city Taipei is……

    • @tonydevos
      @tonydevos 2 дня назад

      @@Ccb88888 most mainlanders would love to live in that ugly city. Orderly, clean, free

  • @travellerswill
    @travellerswill 7 дней назад +6

    So in the end she says she cares for her people which is people that only agree to her views which differs from his father's views

    • @eddyg4742
      @eddyg4742 7 дней назад +5

      Yep. Even when it comes a day the majority of Taiwanese don't mind unification, she would still resist because what she's defending is not the people, she's defending her own attachments.
      "You can fool all the people some of the time, and some of the people all of the time, but you cannot fool all the people all the time.
      Taiwanese resistance against reunification is ultimately due to the lack of exposure to the truths and the lack of clarity.
      Time will clear things up.

    • @lijackson-x6r
      @lijackson-x6r 5 дней назад

      @@eddyg4742 then deport her, because Taiwan is an island belong to China, since she does not want be a chinese, then leave.

  • @danielyu6399
    @danielyu6399 5 дней назад +5

    其实你没那么重要

  • @Ccb88888
    @Ccb88888 6 дней назад +3

    Mongolia has been part of China longer than Taiwan. Europeans have settled for longer in the Americas than Han Chinese in Taiwan…..

  • @andrewlim892
    @andrewlim892 6 дней назад +3

    May peace prevail for both sides of the Taiwan Straits.

    • @evatam4393
      @evatam4393 6 дней назад

      Peace is a win win solution. Don't fall for the US proxy war trap. War is destructive neither China nor Taiwan will win except US and the Western World.

    • @lttan2867
      @lttan2867 5 дней назад

      It's difficult for peace to prevail when pure Chinese have father who are not Chinese.

  • @DarkInksGaming
    @DarkInksGaming 8 дней назад +5

    Very well made.

  • @Jerry-sf3vd
    @Jerry-sf3vd 2 дня назад +1

    Interesting propaganda. I am from Taiwan but have not seen this side of it. The ruling party DPP supported the short-lived curfew in Korea. Maybe that's what DPP wants.

  • @tnt_pkk1311
    @tnt_pkk1311 8 дней назад +13

    Back to motherland is not a question anymore but a imminent future reality

    • @cosimocub
      @cosimocub 4 дня назад

      why would CCP risk party rule invading Taiwan?? they need to concentrate on the economy

    • @tonydevos
      @tonydevos 2 дня назад

      Dream on. Who wants to voluntarily walk into jail?

  • @kampoengbatoe2699
    @kampoengbatoe2699 6 дней назад +5

    23:04 He is correct when he said he is both Taiwanese and Chinese. Look at the Chinese in other countries:
    In Singapore, one would call himself as Chinese Singaporean.
    In Malaysia, one would call himself as Chinese Malaysian.
    In Indonesia, one would call himself as Chinese Indonesian.
    In the US, one would call himself as Chinese American.
    What you see is that all of them are Chinese, but with different nationalities.
    So is this something quite difficult for the young Taiwanese to understand?

    • @evatam4393
      @evatam4393 6 дней назад +3

      I am a US citizen but my DNA and blood are from China. I am proud to have this heritage even though I don't like mainland China government. Carey Chang and many Taiwan born youth regard themselves as Taiwanese only. They don't accept they are Chinese even their passport says Republic of China. This is their rights if you believe in free speech. in reality they are Chinese if they trace their blood line. As mentioned by Carey her paternal grandma is from Zhejiang China. I think by whitewashing your Chinese identity doesn't help Taiwan and mainland political dilemma. If Taiwan youths accept their Chinese identity and heritage they have more motivation to resolve the political difference between Taiwan and mainland peacefully.

    • @slchoong007
      @slchoong007 5 дней назад +3

      I would elaborate on this by saying that when your country is called "Republic of China" how the heck are you not Chinese by nationality?

    • @NoFrillz-G
      @NoFrillz-G 5 дней назад

      @@evatam4393I’m Americans but one must question when people say “they don’t like the Chinese Govt” please expand on that? Are you getting that vibe from the mainstream media? Have you been to China enough to make that distinction. The mainstream media has been hyping up the China threat and at times down right manufacturing anti-China news. I know that a lot of people has been conditioned to feel the same. It’s quite sad but I get it. Inside every Asian man there is an American yearning to be free. Being Chinese American, I see who the white man is on a pedestal in Asia, heck even in amongst Asian-Americans. You don’t have to be proud to be ethnic Chinese but to be ashamed of it is truly sad.

    • @kampoengbatoe2699
      @kampoengbatoe2699 5 дней назад

      @@evatam4393 You're right.
      And when someone said "I am Taiwanese, not Chinese"
      - If what he meant was his nationality, then he was still correct.
      - But if what he meant was his race, then he was not only racist but also an idiot. Since when someone was able to change his own race?

  • @Giles20
    @Giles20 7 дней назад +12

    This girl likes to play politics with other people's lives. Look what Zelensky did to his country, Ukraine. Taiwan is following the same path.

    • @AlphaCookies
      @AlphaCookies 5 дней назад

      Borderline megalomaniac narcissist. So cringe watching her

  • @petertiang71
    @petertiang71 16 часов назад

    Have not learnt even from the Ukraine war.
    Whole generation of men wiped out, and now they are lowering the conscription age to 18 years old.

  • @yamadakenji4143
    @yamadakenji4143 8 дней назад

    This was interesting. I would have liked to see a bit more of her political activism though, to get a clearer picture of her views

  • @chriscarrol9373
    @chriscarrol9373 7 дней назад

    The USA China and the EU are all now rapidly developing domestic high end chip plants. Once the USA completes this it's in their best interest to see the competition gone. I'd either try to leave or not speak out to loudly against probably your future government. Look to Hong Kong If you want to see the future of Taiwan.

  • @dashong8912
    @dashong8912 8 дней назад

    Not bad. At least it is not so one sided.

  • @leponpon6935
    @leponpon6935 7 дней назад

    沒有你沒有你沒有你不能沒有你~ Come back to me! 阿兜仔不教美語! 133

  • @ubertakeyouseesydney2139
    @ubertakeyouseesydney2139 5 дней назад

    好无聊,干就是啦😂

  • @LittlePenguin1-17
    @LittlePenguin1-17 8 дней назад +5

    Taiwan is a Democratic Republic fighting for it's survival & values against Chinese Aggression.

    • @eddyg4742
      @eddyg4742 7 дней назад +4

      @@LittlePenguin1-17 sorry what's the name of this republic? Could you please remind us? Republic of Xxxxx??

    • @leponpon6935
      @leponpon6935 7 дней назад

      DPRT

    • @lalmaniyadav8214
      @lalmaniyadav8214 6 дней назад

      ​@@eddyg4742republic of China deff from ppls republic of China

    • @9thdrag0n
      @9thdrag0n 5 дней назад

      ​@@eddyg4742No so different as Chinese claim of being "Communist" or Chinese constitution guaranteeing "free speech".

  • @Comrade_Xavier
    @Comrade_Xavier 8 дней назад +3

    First Comment

  • @comacuma2869
    @comacuma2869 8 дней назад

    Hahhaaaa ,,, al thaaani is graaay taalll and has open eyes ,,,,toward somaliaaaa