it wouldve been better if mai had some more vocal training because it was incredibly hard to watch and sit through. mai definitely improved as the show went on but holy shit her drama performance was atrocious. even if drama was the best out of all the entry performances, it doesnt automatically make it good or even listenable, it just means the others were worse but it doesnt default to be a good or even okay performance. mai is much better now but truly drama wouldve been one of the best iland performances if she had all those improvement BEFORE the show began
I took cake out last minute, it was gonna be the last worst performance but I noticed that almost all of my worst performances were from I land… TRUST she’s not safe she will be featured soon
the hype boy cover was so funny, because the editor for some reason put sound effects to his dance, making me remember the sounds everytime i listen to the original.
it is insane to me how bora hasn't debuted in any of the shows she's been on. i feel like everyone loves her it just isn't enough to get her into the tops and it's so upsetting honestly jiwon also was robbed so many times, i would be traumatized if i were them but they did introduce me to cherry bullet since i watched both gp999 and queendom puzzle
OMFGGGG finally somebody who pays respect to the my house performance omfggg, everything about it was perfect, the arrangement, the vocals, the energy, the concept... Wang Yale getting kicked out after delivering so hard will haunt me forever
Who is Yang Wale? I am pretty sure My House was done by Doha and Mingyu who had better vocals then Ariana Grande, Wendy, Baekhyun and Beyoncé combined. Their dance was also way better then Kai, Taemin, J-Hope, Lisa, Seulgi, Momo and Niki. Those kinds showed how stuff is done🥰🥰
@@luvuchuu Not only was the Budget high but the contestants were beyond skilled and talented as most of them came from experienced backrounds.They were way too crazy for their own good cause wow...and the youngest was 18 and not 14 or 12 😍
@@luvuchuu I think Chuang 2020 had a big budget because it was made at the height of hype for Chinese survival shows (Youth with you 2 was also a show premiering at the time of Chuang 2020 and they are both wildly successful shows, maybe less hype than their predecessor groups from earlier shows) but something happened with the government imposing more regulations on these shows in between 2022-2023 because they were cracking down on entertainment industry practices (like crowdfunding to pay for more votes, etc) so survival shows are less popular and more restricted how that's why Chuang Asia (or the fifth season of the Chuang survival show) was hosted in Thailand as an international show (the show budget was pretty low compared to the previous ones). sorry for the long comment, also if you're interested go check out gen1es and Chuang Asia! It's a pretty good show, Ruan from gp999 also joined and debuted
rookie from idol school… truly one of the most iconic worst performances out there i'm so glad that you included chuang, curley gao's vocals >>>>> and i think about the miss freak performance on a daily basis
My House by the two houses in Boys Planet was legendary. Those kings showed js what dance and vocals are. Even Beyoncé got impressed and revealed that she learned singing from Doha and Mingyu. Put some respect on those legends name😡😡 Without them Beyoncé would have never learned to sing, even know Doha and Mingyu outsing Beyoncé, Whitney Houston, Taeyeon, Baekhyun, Jungkook, Ariana Grande, Chen, IU and basically every singer on the planet.
everyone keeps talking about how amazing drama was, i personally did not like it 😭 the chorus sounded so weird and out of breath, the girls did good but did way better later in the show, the vocals sounded off, the concept didnt fit them that well...
honestly in drama i used to love it so much but i agree with you, every single time i watch it over and over again i dislike it more, but jungeun ate that performance up though (they are all talented but im sorry if this doesnt make sense)
idk why everyones fighting for their lives defending drama when it genuinely is such a shit performance 😭 its SOO hard to watch like i genuinely have never cringed so badly listening to someone sing/rap the way i do when iland 2 drama comes up. why is it so hard to avoid too its EVERYWHEREE i cant get far enough away from it. all the girls did great after drama and mai especially improved significantly but holy fuckkk...
This is exactly how I feel, all the girls on the team did PHENOMENAL in genuinely every single other performance which is another reason I think drama aged poorly FOR ME AT LEAST
LOOOOVE THE EDITING!!! And I agree with Drama, people all said like OMGGG THE DRAMA TEAM SLAYED SOO HARD VOCALS AND ALL… like gurl all of them are talented but that stage honestly I so overhyped. I mean Aespa songs are so hard and not for everyone. They definitely had all better stages than that one. But thanks to drama stage you could see the improvement of those members
i've never really been into survival shows but i remember watching the MITM performance from GP999 and my jaw DROPPED. i literally downloaded an mp3 of the audio so i could listen to it offline. all three girls were phenomenal, but fu yaning would have been SUCH a great idol if not for... yknow. the racism and the evil editing. sigh.
My biggest regret as a kpop fan is that I never tried to enjoy the really campy songs from 2nd and early 3rd gen. Now I want genuine boy and girlfailures who don't even try to pretend they're good. I need the sisters (twins?) to make crayon pop 2.0. Edit: I love TWICE but as soon as a survival show uses their songs I fear for the contestants. Using LOA is even more blatantly setting those girls up. The comments also mentioned that the break dance was originally missing from the upload too so it's suspect for sure.
two of my favorite survival show performances is queendom 2 pantomime wjsn and loona butterly... ik queendom/kingdom had debuted groups but like WOW those performances were amazing (the way ptt still ate even tho they had covid)
The way I agree with all of these... Drama wasn't bad but I had too much of a high expectation 😭 I don't think their voices suited the song. Also MISSING YOU MENTION YES YES YES I STILL GO BACK TO THAT STAGE DAILY IT'S ENOUGH TO MAKE ME ASCEND TO THE HEAVENS (also Hanbin saying no to the gays while being mother... It's giving gatekeeping the community /j)
Yeah I agree, I think it’s also cuz it was super hype in social media that I expected a LOT more Missing you is soooooo underrated when it was genuinely so so so perfect And literallyyyy that’s what I’m saying 🙈
Not kpop but youth with you 2's Flammable and Explosive, such an underrated performance with AMAZING vocals, some of the best you'll ever hear from a survival show, literally all the members from thay group were really really really good
I have always said the Tomboy stage from Boys planet is one of the BEST stages from survival shows i’ve ever watched so i’m super glad it was included here😫
bro i don't understand why is drama is the worst here when other iland entrance performances exist to me drama was the best performance of iland JUNGEUN KILLED IT
I am happy about rain on me. 😀😊 but like seriously !!! what the hell I'm literally going mad 😡 how drama is the was the worst performance. you didn't put cake one and saying that drama was the w~o~r~s~t like what????
I actually had it before the rain on me performance but I had way too many worst performances that were from I land…. Trust they will make an appearance if I make a part 2..
My intro was created on video star! It’s an editing app on iOS only (I’m pretty sure not sure if it’s changed) and I added the coloring on video star :))
drama is def NOT a bad performance, it's just that mai moment which, even though actually i don't hate at all, i can understand why people might not like it but the rest of the performance is literally perfect and don't get me even started on the jungeun highnote
other than hot, my house and probably a couple other performances i haven’t seen boys planet was so good for performances and the best tomboy cover done my men
I think I could perform Hype Boy, My House, and Boombayah better than them, and that's saying something (my singing is fine, but I never exercise so my voice gets shaky after 30 seconds)
Personnally, one of my favorite performances is in the UNIT when the vocal team ( if i'm not mistaken cuz i didn't watch the show ) performed mamamoo's you're the best: ruclips.net/video/ISuV7_-9oSk/видео.htmlsi=t5m16ROG0LBGjyUS
It's not that the Rain on me performance from I-landers was bad, no, it was really good. It's just that the choreography from grounders was clearly better and they lost for narrative purposes. It sucked so hard to witness.
I don't want to offend anyone, but Fantasy Boys is one of the most terrible shows I've ever watched. 1) attitude towards the participants. 2) the debut line-up... many talented participants were left out, and too many children were included in the group. 3) what happened after the debut, I wouldn’t wish any fan to experience that
off topic but how the hell is 6th gen next year? I've barely gotten used to 5th gen😒 Also I hated my bag. The only person who came close to delivering was Jeemin and they gave wonhee the highest score for slipping and not reacting. Like wha-
4:57 when i tell you i agree with this, i mean i AGREE with this. the only person who really ate was jungeun, mai's voice was way too nasally and jiyoon/jeemin sounded so.. plain?
Can we just talk about how drama was the best entry performance for iland yet it's still considered bad 💀
nah the best was baggy jeans
it wouldve been better if mai had some more vocal training because it was incredibly hard to watch and sit through. mai definitely improved as the show went on but holy shit her drama performance was atrocious. even if drama was the best out of all the entry performances, it doesnt automatically make it good or even listenable, it just means the others were worse but it doesnt default to be a good or even okay performance. mai is much better now but truly drama wouldve been one of the best iland performances if she had all those improvement BEFORE the show began
@@inimmz it still doesn't deserve to put it in the wordt category, the performance overall is good 🤷♂️
Not having Cake from ILand 2 but having Drama is a crime💀
I took cake out last minute, it was gonna be the last worst performance but I noticed that almost all of my worst performances were from I land… TRUST she’s not safe she will be featured soon
it's just an opinion bro
Cake was better than drama
At least it didn't give me trauma
I love Mai, she improved a lot. But Drama was a disaster
the hype boy cover was so funny, because the editor for some reason put sound effects to his dance, making me remember the sounds everytime i listen to the original.
Still can't listen to hot without hearing the voice crack lol
They made HISTORY
Bwaaa 🗣
me with Sweet Venom lmao
im convinced that boys planet was like 90% people they just picked off of the street
But more than 50% of them were still talented
@@nickorlando1219 yeah, that’s correct. because you’ll always find some people on the street who can do things well. lol.
not having runext bad boy as the best is extremely insane
it is insane to me how bora hasn't debuted in any of the shows she's been on. i feel like everyone loves her it just isn't enough to get her into the tops and it's so upsetting
honestly jiwon also was robbed so many times, i would be traumatized if i were them but they did introduce me to cherry bullet since i watched both gp999 and queendom puzzle
OMFGGGG finally somebody who pays respect to the my house performance omfggg, everything about it was perfect, the arrangement, the vocals, the energy, the concept... Wang Yale getting kicked out after delivering so hard will haunt me forever
EXACTLYYYYY OMFG IT HURTS TOO CUZ ALL THREE DID INCREDIBLE BUT AYA AND YALE RARELY GRT PRAISED 😢😢😢
Who is Yang Wale? I am pretty sure My House was done by Doha and Mingyu who had better vocals then Ariana Grande, Wendy, Baekhyun and Beyoncé combined. Their dance was also way better then Kai, Taemin, J-Hope, Lisa, Seulgi, Momo and Niki. Those kinds showed how stuff is done🥰🥰
My house was literally one of the best arrangements and covers for kpop, god everything was just so smooth.
Chuang 2020 was a masterpiece..they sadly don’t make survival shows like this in kpop😭
EXACTLYYYYYYYY but also the budget was genuinely so so crazy like god I wanna know how much the season cost and if the pay off was enough
@@luvuchuu Not only was the Budget high but the contestants were beyond skilled and talented as most of them came from experienced backrounds.They were way too crazy for their own good cause wow...and the youngest was 18 and not 14 or 12 😍
@@guinnmyahslaysstaymadTHISSSSSS IT WAS SO REFRESHING IN EVERY ASPECT UGH I LOVE IT
that wuji piano rendition kills me every time. chinese survival shows are built different fr.
@@luvuchuu I think Chuang 2020 had a big budget because it was made at the height of hype for Chinese survival shows (Youth with you 2 was also a show premiering at the time of Chuang 2020 and they are both wildly successful shows, maybe less hype than their predecessor groups from earlier shows)
but something happened with the government imposing more regulations on these shows in between 2022-2023 because they were cracking down on entertainment industry practices (like crowdfunding to pay for more votes, etc) so survival shows are less popular and more restricted how
that's why Chuang Asia (or the fifth season of the Chuang survival show) was hosted in Thailand as an international show (the show budget was pretty low compared to the previous ones).
sorry for the long comment, also if you're interested go check out gen1es and Chuang Asia! It's a pretty good show, Ruan from gp999 also joined and debuted
girl this is just amazing I am desperately needing part 2 rn😌
The editing is so cute!!❤
EYES NOSE LIPS HAD A DESERVED WIN FIGHT ME 😡😡😡fine was lacking emotion imo but atleast both of them survived ep 11 tho (im sorry fuko)
rookie from idol school… truly one of the most iconic worst performances out there
i'm so glad that you included chuang, curley gao's vocals >>>>> and i think about the miss freak performance on a daily basis
I did love Saebi in Sweet Venom though…
Istg rumour (h.i.n.p ver.) is def my most favourite survival show cover ever along with love whisper. They did so well!
THATS SUCH A GOOD CHOICE OMG. I love rumor I think it’s probably the most professional idol like survival show stage
Yessss rumor (hinp) legit made me splurge to heaven
My House by the two houses in Boys Planet was legendary. Those kings showed js what dance and vocals are. Even Beyoncé got impressed and revealed that she learned singing from Doha and Mingyu. Put some respect on those legends name😡😡 Without them Beyoncé would have never learned to sing, even know Doha and Mingyu outsing Beyoncé, Whitney Houston, Taeyeon, Baekhyun, Jungkook, Ariana Grande, Chen, IU and basically every singer on the planet.
everyone keeps talking about how amazing drama was, i personally did not like it 😭 the chorus sounded so weird and out of breath, the girls did good but did way better later in the show, the vocals sounded off, the concept didnt fit them that well...
Ngl the only good thing about that performance was the dancing but otherwise it was painful to listen to.
honestly in drama i used to love it so much but i agree with you, every single time i watch it over and over again i dislike it more, but jungeun ate that performance up though (they are all talented but im sorry if this doesnt make sense)
Gyuri constantly getting set-up in the entire show is actually my villain arc 😭
Thank you for the Bora appreciation. She deserves so much more 😭😭
idk why everyones fighting for their lives defending drama when it genuinely is such a shit performance 😭 its SOO hard to watch like i genuinely have never cringed so badly listening to someone sing/rap the way i do when iland 2 drama comes up. why is it so hard to avoid too its EVERYWHEREE i cant get far enough away from it. all the girls did great after drama and mai especially improved significantly but holy fuckkk...
This is exactly how I feel, all the girls on the team did PHENOMENAL in genuinely every single other performance which is another reason I think drama aged poorly FOR ME AT LEAST
I miss the Liang twins. They were so cute. And when they got separated😭😭😭
LOOOOVE THE EDITING!!! And I agree with Drama, people all said like OMGGG THE DRAMA TEAM SLAYED SOO HARD VOCALS AND ALL… like gurl all of them are talented but that stage honestly I so overhyped. I mean Aespa songs are so hard and not for everyone. They definitely had all better stages than that one. But thanks to drama stage you could see the improvement of those members
I honestly would mention Loco and Girls on Top of Universe Ticket for Best
YEAH I WAS EXPECTING GIRLS ON TOP
oh we are i loved so much too, this trio really has my entire heart
SAME I feel so nostalgic towards it even tho it shot that old lol 😭😭😭
Hmph! Is my beloved one too❤❤❤
The Hype boy cover is so bad fr I'm sorry 😭😭
Ive only watched runext and iland2 BUT YES ALL OF THEM WERE SO TRUE (gyuri did highkey great in after like and bggg was amazing)
i've never really been into survival shows but i remember watching the MITM performance from GP999 and my jaw DROPPED. i literally downloaded an mp3 of the audio so i could listen to it offline. all three girls were phenomenal, but fu yaning would have been SUCH a great idol if not for... yknow. the racism and the evil editing. sigh.
My biggest regret as a kpop fan is that I never tried to enjoy the really campy songs from 2nd and early 3rd gen. Now I want genuine boy and girlfailures who don't even try to pretend they're good. I need the sisters (twins?) to make crayon pop 2.0.
Edit: I love TWICE but as soon as a survival show uses their songs I fear for the contestants. Using LOA is even more blatantly setting those girls up. The comments also mentioned that the break dance was originally missing from the upload too so it's suspect for sure.
CURLEYYY CHUANG 2020 bless you for spreading her voice to more people and nene, those auditions were iconically amazing
i think the reason the earlier iland2 performances are so bad is because the mixing and autotune makes them sound rancid
two of my favorite survival show performances is queendom 2 pantomime wjsn and loona butterly... ik queendom/kingdom had debuted groups but like WOW those performances were amazing (the way ptt still ate even tho they had covid)
I love the nintendo 3ds intro its so nostalgic thank you.
TYYYY
The way I agree with all of these... Drama wasn't bad but I had too much of a high expectation 😭 I don't think their voices suited the song. Also MISSING YOU MENTION YES YES YES I STILL GO BACK TO THAT STAGE DAILY IT'S ENOUGH TO MAKE ME ASCEND TO THE HEAVENS (also Hanbin saying no to the gays while being mother... It's giving gatekeeping the community /j)
Yeah I agree, I think it’s also cuz it was super hype in social media that I expected a LOT more
Missing you is soooooo underrated when it was genuinely so so so perfect
And literallyyyy that’s what I’m saying 🙈
To this day, I don't care about the eyes nose lips performance from iland2, I really didn't care when I heard it, I still don't care
god i just found your channel, I know this comment is not about the content in this video, but I LOVEEEEEEE your aesthetic
AWE TYSM!!! Im happy you like it :))
Not kpop but youth with you 2's Flammable and Explosive, such an underrated performance with AMAZING vocals, some of the best you'll ever hear from a survival show, literally all the members from thay group were really really really good
Where’s the jellyfish girls’ audition
The gasppp I did when I saw drama being the worst!! I'm still shocked while typing haha
FINALLY SOMEONE WHO TALK ABOUT MISSING YOU, GUYS THIS IS THE BEST PERFORMANCE IN GP999 (also MITM)
Latata from mtg is also a pretty bad performance,but mostly bcs of that one girl
Bon Bon Girls (Chuang 2020) had the best vocal line I've seen in any survival, like 4 out of the 7 girls are AMAZING vocalists!
Universe ticket has so many great performances too actually
3:45 omg I was shocked to see my queen nene here wtf
u better include energetic and dont know you by produce 48 in the next part!! (jkjk its ur opinion but those were my favs :D)
I have always said the Tomboy stage from Boys planet is one of the BEST stages from survival shows i’ve ever watched so i’m super glad it was included here😫
ALSO KILL THIS LOVE
1:16 fun fact, during the show, daniel improved to an insane level
bro i don't understand why is drama is the worst here when other iland entrance performances exist
to me drama was the best performance of iland
JUNGEUN KILLED IT
2:31 we need red house and hot. They all deserve it
But we all love them
Edit: yeah, now I'm happy
Live red and blue houses
DRIP TOTALLY MY FAV PERFORMANCE OF THE ILAND😭😭😭😭
You ppsted this kn my birthday pol
HAPPY BIRTHDAYYYYYYY YAYYYY🎈🎈🎈🎈🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎊🎊🎊🎊🎊
I have an idea, maybe you could rank survival show songs next (doesn’t have to solely be kpop)
Sorry I'm commenting every two seconds but that rain on me performance gave me chills
this is lacking some my teenage girl, decalcomanie and rich boss is so good😭😥
drama is good though but the expectations was high because it is an aespa song 😭 Jungeun is the only sounds great in their performance
Youth with you 2 is all imma leave in the comments, some of the best performers period. And one of the best lineups for a gg at the end of the show.
4:00 nobody gets takuto like i do ☹️
Tomboy and over me from boys planet actually changed my life
I am happy about rain on me. 😀😊
but like seriously !!!
what the hell I'm literally going mad
😡 how drama is the was the worst performance. you didn't put cake one and saying that drama was the
w~o~r~s~t
like what????
finally someone that recognizes the my house from girls planet performance, one of, if not the best performances of the show for me
chuang 2020 was crazy bc in the final group like half of the girls had main vocal potential
Hello??? Drama is in the worst performance list but not Cake???? I see how it is 🤨
I actually had it before the rain on me performance but I had way too many worst performances that were from I land…. Trust they will make an appearance if I make a part 2..
YOUTH WITH YOU FLAMMABLE AND EXPLOSIVE IS THE BEST
0:02 how did you make that? If you don’t mind me asking
My intro was created on video star! It’s an editing app on iOS only (I’m pretty sure not sure if it’s changed) and I added the coloring on video star :))
Drama from iland2, I also didn't think it was the best, I thought the group with yui and koko was the best one, but technically I think drama was top2
drama is def NOT a bad performance, it's just that mai moment which, even though actually i don't hate at all, i can understand why people might not like it but the rest of the performance is literally perfect and don't get me even started on the jungeun highnote
idk man i hard preferred the love me right g group, it just had more feel to it if that makes sense
Eyes, Nose, Lips is really good and even won but Minseo still stayed on the ground until she got eliminated hmmm
other than hot, my house and probably a couple other performances i haven’t seen boys planet was so good for performances and the best tomboy cover done my men
Produce 48 performances were and are the best kick everybody else to worst
Boys Planet HOT is ✨Legendary ✨🤣
Oh and most of the Boys planet performances were good but some of the best were ZOOM, LIMOUSINE & BACKDOOR(K group)
iland1 had no bad performances tbh
Honestly I agree I was re watching some recently and there weren’t any obviously bad performances🤷🏻♀️🤷🏻♀️🤷🏻♀️
I think I could perform Hype Boy, My House, and Boombayah better than them, and that's saying something (my singing is fine, but I never exercise so my voice gets shaky after 30 seconds)
5:30 is that.... a history reference?....? :O
Hold up.... gp999 mitm and bp tomboy are kinda sibling 😮😮
Personnally, one of my favorite performances is in the UNIT when the vocal team ( if i'm not mistaken cuz i didn't watch the show ) performed mamamoo's you're the best:
ruclips.net/video/ISuV7_-9oSk/видео.htmlsi=t5m16ROG0LBGjyUS
might be biased but i really love girls planet 999's performances. i listen to missing you till i fall asleep, wish those girls were more recognized
It's not that the Rain on me performance from I-landers was bad, no, it was really good. It's just that the choreography from grounders was clearly better and they lost for narrative purposes. It sucked so hard to witness.
I don't want to offend anyone, but Fantasy Boys is one of the most terrible shows I've ever watched. 1) attitude towards the participants. 2) the debut line-up... many talented participants were left out, and too many children were included in the group. 3) what happened after the debut, I wouldn’t wish any fan to experience that
f(x) ice cream as the intro omg instant like and sub
Runext - good girl bad girl (the best best best ever)
IT ATE
off topic but how the hell is 6th gen next year? I've barely gotten used to 5th gen😒
Also I hated my bag. The only person who came close to delivering was Jeemin and they gave wonhee the highest score for slipping and not reacting. Like wha-
Boys planet hot , is um something. They tried i guess
Not having bp zoom here is a crime
Somehow one of the worst of pd 101 😂
WHERE IS CAKE, WHERE IS NANAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA. ILAND2 WAS A MESS BUT U CANT FORGIVE NANA PLSSSS
I’m sorry but ru next’s best performance will always be the boys to me
yuna from a2k????
Where is bad boy runext???
4:57 when i tell you i agree with this, i mean i AGREE with this. the only person who really ate was jungeun, mai's voice was way too nasally and jiyoon/jeemin sounded so.. plain?
rain on me (ilanders) is life changing
What do you mean the drama presentation is bad????? Are you deaf???
nah just respect the opinion bro, i dont like how they tried to mimic the high tone in drama like that, sorry if i made u upset 😓😓
well mai and jeemin are bad vocalists ..
@@user-jj7td5yg9p no theyre not. this was just a bad day ig
My favorite performance from a survival show is "Fever" from Build up 🫦