As a real woman (thanks Rishi) I’d never vote Labour again. They have treated c50% of their voters(women) with utter CONTEMPT throughout this gender identity nonsense in favour of supporting c1% of potential voters Not once has Lisa Nandy ever pushed back in support of us not once I’ve supported JKR from the get go and always will she’s a woman of integrity unlike those in the Labour Party Damage has been done
Am 41 always gave my vote to labour because they where ‘ the working class vote’ that has been drilled into me from childhood, the labour government now,it feels like they want the younger peoples votes so they will agree with anything not to potentially upset just to gets votes, what’s the old saying ‘stand for something or you will fall for everything’ , i just don’t think any English parties are showing any passion for the country
"A scrawny ex bloke" he says......denying physical reality ....... a man is stronger than a woman........it is a safety issue, never mind fairness. I believe this man Katy makes his living out of this special form of nonsense. Look up autogynaphile and ask yourself if you want that paraphylia around women and children.
Men aren't automatically against women's rights. Men have a biological bias towards real women, for reasons that may be obvious to anyone outside the Labour Party.
Because men allowed women the vote, lol. Trans mainly are misogynists, they hate women so what better than to pretend to become a woman and take everything they've achieved.
Labour don't know what a woman is . . . hence the confusion and Labour's vote chasing dilemma. What they gain with MBGT TRANSAXLES, they'll more than lose from the ladies (who KNOW who they are).
Who would want to enter that stinking sewer? And have you seen the TRA’s death threats against her and other women like Kellie J Keen for defending biological women. Their lives are in danger
I will not bow down or agree to anyone who say they are ‘trans’ by calling them by a different gender to what they really are, that’s just their own OPINION The real term for them to be called is a ‘masquerader’ Which the word masquerade defined by the English Oxford dictionary is exactly what they are doing. If they don’t like me calling then a masquerade, that’s their problem. ‘Masquerade Deceptive show or pretence at which masks and costumes are worn by a person pretending to be someone or something else. ‘
When dialogue was mentioned I nearly fell over laughing. When have the trans community tried dialogue? The hissy fit over JK Rowling shows they have no intention of debating just attacking anyone who disagrees with basic biology. My wife will not be voting labour as strangely enough she knows what a woman is and does not want men in skirts in female.spaces.
For what it’s worth I think jk is an outstanding female as for Nandy she is just a female. There are very very few women like jk but jeez there are millions of average run of the mill women like Nandy and even the vast majority of them KNOW THAT A MAN IS A MAN AND A WOMAN IS A WOMAN NO MATTER WHATEVER THESE VERY VERY VERY SMALL PERCENTAGE OF TRANS PEOPLE THINK.
Why would women trust politicians who have thrown them under the bus for a minority of mentally unwell men? I thsnk Rowling from the bottom of my heart, she has more courage, intelligence and honour than all of those male politicians put together.
It was neither politicians nor the public at large that pitched trans rights and women's rights against each other, it was the hard-line trans rights activists.
Thats not a 'transgender person', he's a man. You can immediately tell simply by looking at him and hearing his voice. He's got no right to talk about women's rights. When women tried to talk about trans people, men like him screamed 'No Debate' endlessly and loudly. They screamed it for so long that it's hypocritical of them to ask for it now. And it isn't about trans people and women. Trans people are nothing to do with women. This is about women. Adult human females. We deserve dignity, safety and respect. Something men like him are not willing to give us regardless of how they back track now. My parents were born in the 1920's and fought for the welfare state. They drilled it into me that I should always vote Labour. No more! This isn't a Labour Party, it just identifies as one.
So he thinks that a male in a women's team, such as rugby, only makes a slight advantage. I'd like to know what the women that was tackled by a man over 6' tall and obviously weighed significantly more than her thinks. After the tackled she just lay there on the ground, seemingly unconscious.
Even my mother got riled up by Lisa Nandy a few years ago, remember Women’s Place, and my mother never gets angry we’ll not since around 2006 when West Ham lost in the FA Cup final.
I still say the world has become a Monty Python sketch made reality. This guys even got the appropriate shirt for the lumberjack song. "I wish I were a girlie just like my dear Papa..." If we stop taking it seriously, will it go away?
Sorry but Went is not an ' x bloke '. He is completely male - and will be forever. I'm sick of all the stupid biological games and lies they spin to try and make themselves important.
It’s good that Katy Jon Went has changed some of his opinions by listening to the other side. He still thinks trans inclusion and women’s right to fair sport is equal, though. It’s not. Women need to have their own sports and men, whether they have a trans identity or not, need to either compete in the men’s or open category. There’s nothing more to discuss.
Beautifully said, Katy. How refreshing to hear a hot topic being discussed in a calm, common sense manner without insulting any person's sensibilities. Thank you! ❤ 🇨🇦
I'll stand up for the working class men when I see that they are being usurped by women and transgender and denied the basic freedoms of their gender because a woman wants to be treated as special because she has an artificial peepee. I haven't seen that happening yet.
@@jessebongo46 Complete rubbish more like a feminist society feels like we are living out the barbie movie. There literally no opportune or Help for working class white men all the schemes, funds and attention is diverted towards every single other group the best thing to be now adays in this country is a black lesbian women. White working class boys and men are the: . Worst performing in schools out of any group . Highest suicide rate out of any group . Lowest attendance at university out of any group . There’s also a problem socially and economically a lot of men are simply checking out of society as they don’t feel part of it and have no investment in it anymore. Women are born with value men have to earn it a women will always find a partner to be with and has access to sex if wanted men don’t. I’d love for women like yourself to be in my shoes for just a day to experience what it’s like to be a working class white man so you could see what complete and utter crap your world view is.
@@jessebongo46 Hasn't been that for a while and it has no real benefit outside of a few powerful people, bit like many powerful feminists who only benefit themselves.
He's wrong - 1 man on a women's rugby team can do a hell of a lot of damage, so it's not just in individual sport that it's a problem. There is footage online of a teenage boy who thinks he's a girl knocking a female opponent out at a volleyball match, which proves the point.
We LOVE J K Rowling .... just look at who you have on to discuss womens rights??..... your not an ex bloke you are a bloke. Nothing wrong with my eyes, nothing wrong with my ears , nothing wrong with my senses.... your a bloke mate, a bloke in every way.
No it's not 'trans and women' as nobody is trans. Katy Jon Went is a bloke with long hair. I don't care if he's had his danglers cut off and fake boobs attached, he's still a bloke.
I agree with JK Rowling, I don't trust labour for those very reasons. Prision scenario: A full transition isn't good enough. They have to be non violent towards women.
@@elainecameron5545how is it about men taking away from women? Trans gender isn't just men becoming women but also women becoming men so yes it is also about men or are you too ignorant to see that
I was a working class lad and i want to sort this problem because men have a vested intrest in the women in their lives too plus you do know the same people pushing this are the same who destroyed hope for many at the bottom like me with the DEI mantra we havd the same enemy
Labour is lost to me. And I come from 3 + generations of solid Labour voters from the North-east of England ie ‘dyed in the wool’. My Mum & Dad would not recognise this Labour Party, it has NOTHING to do with real people, especially WOMEN 🤦♀️
The man who is being interview is talking a lot of sense, more people should listen to him. He does speak a little too fast for me. I have a learning difficulty. However he seems very reasonable. First one to talk some common sense I to debate. If people chose to be trans and this truly helps them, then I say go for it. Why do we moan about people removing genitals etc and getting cosmetic surgery, but we don't moan as much when some bimbo gets a boob job. That's a terrible double standard. Good on him for bringing some common sense to the debate
Why do you keep inviting this annoying dude to speak about women's rights? If a real woman waffled on and never gave a concise answer like he does, there's no way she'd be reinvited to the show.
I can tell you exactly how we stand up for both biological woman and people who identify as transsexual woman. We go back to a position of objective reality. We go back to the position most people were up until very recently. We go back to way people like Lou Reid, David Bowie and Boy George treated it. People are free to express themselves by wearing and calling themselves what ever they want. You are a man who dresses like a woman. There is obviously situations which everyone understands where it would not be acceptable to be in your woman character, your rights to live like you do is balanced with reality.
So the trans footballer didn't mind facing a team of women but OMG dont let me face a team of trans women even though every woman who plays against him is up against a male. No extra balls in womens sports
It's all very simple really: men have their spaces and their sports; women have their spaces and their sports; and trans people have their spaces and sports. And each respects the other.
Trans my ass. He is a man pretending to be a woman. We don’t need co-exist, men need to leave woman’s spaces alone. I don’t care what he calls himself.
Why can't we go back to when things used to be normal - when men were proper men, not half man half woman, and women were women, not half women and half men , being turned into something they are not. - what a crazy world we are living in right now.
Saying it like no one has ever noticed before. “You know the number 2? Well we have been looking at it from a lot of different sides and have come to the decision that if combine that 2 with another number 2,,,,you actually get 4!!!!!”
In his dreams ! Not any where near 2 percent . in the united states it has over time been consistently less than ,5 percent averaged across age groups.
The problem is a male rapist should have never gone to a woman’s prison in the first place
As a real woman (thanks Rishi) I’d never vote Labour again.
They have treated c50% of their voters(women) with utter CONTEMPT throughout this gender identity nonsense in favour of supporting c1% of potential voters
Not once has Lisa Nandy ever pushed back in support of us not once
I’ve supported JKR from the get go and always will
she’s a woman of integrity unlike those in the Labour Party
Damage has been done
Don't thank Rushi, it's all lies and electioneering PR.
I agree with you completely (I'm a man)
Am 41 always gave my vote to labour because they where ‘ the working class vote’ that has been drilled into me from childhood, the labour government now,it feels like they want the younger peoples votes so they will agree with anything not to potentially upset just to gets votes, what’s the old saying ‘stand for something or you will fall for everything’ , i just don’t think any English parties are showing any passion for the country
Well said
"A scrawny ex bloke" he says......denying physical reality ....... a man is stronger than a woman........it is a safety issue, never mind fairness.
I believe this man Katy makes his living out of this special form of nonsense.
Look up autogynaphile and ask yourself if you want that paraphylia around women and children.
He's not an ex-bloke, he's a bloke. Pure and simple.
@phoebecaulfield4062 No black face & no woman face!
Why couldn't you have a woman on there talking about women's rights, instead of two men.
Men aren't automatically against women's rights. Men have a biological bias towards real women, for reasons that may be obvious to anyone outside the Labour Party.
Why are we asking a man about Women's Rights. FFS 😡
Thank you! I'm transDONE.
Because men allowed women the vote, lol. Trans mainly are misogynists, they hate women so what better than to pretend to become a woman and take everything they've achieved.
A man, transvestite.
Womens rights are soon going to mean nothing if people keep pandering to these muppets delusions.
Women are second class citizens again
Asking a geeza???????? Ask a Woman.
Exactly.
They risk being cancelled for hate speech so they get the ‘next best thing’ 🤦♀️ but at least they can raise the subject….
Labour don't know what a woman is . . . hence the confusion and Labour's vote chasing dilemma. What they gain with MBGT TRANSAXLES, they'll more than lose from the ladies (who KNOW who they are).
We need men to defend this as much as women. Do men not have mothers, daughters, sisters 🤔
Never hear Nandy standing up in parliament supporting Rosie Duffield when shes getting heckled for standing up for womans rights.
Probably because she’s a huge bigot
Well said Rosie Duffield has been treated disgracefully
@@stephenholmes1036 Duffield is a fascist
@@thetransagender2866 ha ha ha ha ha your so funny , very monty python ha ha
Lisa Nandy speaks out of both sides of her mouth. JK says it like it is. No way would I vote for a party with Keit Starmer in it.😡
In a less polite world we'd say she talks out of her ass.
Jk Rowling, a real woman with integrity, not like those fakers with a dangler.
JK Rowling is spot on
JK is great to take on these people. If she went into politics I could see her winning a seat hands down. Keep standing up for women JK.
Who would want to enter that stinking sewer? And have you seen the TRA’s death threats against her and other women like Kellie J Keen for defending biological women. Their lives are in danger
"How do we co-exist?"
WE don't. You take your weirdo crap somewhere else and WE live in peace.
Damn right!!
God bless JK Rowling, she tells it like it is.
True lies ... migration from balls of the year to women of the year.
Why is he asking this bloke?
Remember the days when this sort of thing was only in the realms of comedy?
Yep. Monty python life of Brian.
@@terryreknaw6152He's not the Messiah, He's a Very Naughty Boy 😂 I miss Normal 😘❤️🙏
@@amyshoneye5455 😂👍👍
One of the most powerful women in the world, using her platform for what's right.
Thank God someone is.
Why are you asking a man about women's rights?
I will not bow down or agree to anyone who say they are ‘trans’ by calling them by a different gender to what they really are, that’s just their own OPINION The real term for them to be called is a ‘masquerader’ Which the word masquerade defined by the English Oxford dictionary is exactly what they are doing. If they don’t like me calling then a masquerade, that’s their problem.
‘Masquerade
Deceptive show or pretence at which masks and costumes are worn
by a person pretending to be someone or something else. ‘
When will these people realise they’re not the norm!
When liberals stop pandering to them. Their aim is to marginalise 51% of the population so they won't have to be compared to real woman.
I love Rowling
me too, what a woman.
When dialogue was mentioned I nearly fell over laughing. When have the trans community tried dialogue? The hissy fit over JK Rowling shows they have no intention of debating just attacking anyone who disagrees with basic biology. My wife will not be voting labour as strangely enough she knows what a woman is and does not want men in skirts in female.spaces.
For what it’s worth I think jk is an outstanding female as for Nandy she is just a female. There are very very few women like jk but jeez there are millions of average run of the mill women like Nandy and even the vast majority of them KNOW THAT A MAN IS A MAN AND A WOMAN IS A WOMAN NO MATTER WHATEVER THESE VERY VERY VERY SMALL PERCENTAGE OF TRANS PEOPLE THINK.
Why would women trust politicians who have thrown them under the bus for a minority of mentally unwell men? I thsnk Rowling from the bottom of my heart, she has more courage, intelligence and honour than all of those male politicians put together.
Nice interview with Hugh Fearnley Whittingstall.
😂😂😂😂😂
Hugh Fearnly Whittingstall!! 😅😂, too funny .... still laughing ....
I love JK. What a woman. ❤
She didn't only write Harry Potter.
Well done Joanne for standing up for women and girls
It was neither politicians nor the public at large that pitched trans rights and women's rights against each other, it was the hard-line trans rights activists.
Yes but when the politicians took sides with the activists then it became everyone’s business
Thats not a 'transgender person', he's a man. You can immediately tell simply by looking at him and hearing his voice.
He's got no right to talk about women's rights. When women tried to talk about trans people, men like him screamed 'No Debate' endlessly and loudly. They screamed it for so long that it's hypocritical of them to ask for it now.
And it isn't about trans people and women. Trans people are nothing to do with women. This is about women. Adult human females. We deserve dignity, safety and respect. Something men like him are not willing to give us regardless of how they back track now.
My parents were born in the 1920's and fought for the welfare state. They drilled it into me that I should always vote Labour. No more! This isn't a Labour Party, it just identifies as one.
Well said x
Love JK Rowling.
A decent and honest lady.
So too the brave and tenacious Sharron Davies.
Nandy is perfectly ghastly.
It's a bloke in a wig
Isnr that Nana Akua?
@@thetransagender2866😂 be careful, misogyny will be a crime soon.
So he thinks that a male in a women's team, such as rugby,
only makes a slight advantage. I'd like to know what the women that was tackled by a man over 6' tall and obviously weighed significantly more than her thinks. After the tackled she just lay there on the ground, seemingly unconscious.
This interview just proves that women are slowly being eradicated when it comes to hearing from them, and talking to them.
If you can’t define my sex you won’t get me ‘X’!
In this video, there are two blokes having a chat.
Even my mother got riled up by Lisa Nandy a few years ago, remember Women’s Place, and my mother never gets angry we’ll not since around 2006 when West Ham lost in the FA Cup final.
Nandy Pandy needs to sod off, Liebour are a joke.
I still say the world has become a Monty Python sketch made reality. This guys even got the appropriate shirt for the lumberjack song. "I wish I were a girlie just like my dear Papa..."
If we stop taking it seriously, will it go away?
To be honest, this person speaking is very reasonable and speaks with common sense, and I rarely find that in transspokespeople.
Sorry but Went is not an ' x bloke '. He is completely male - and will be forever. I'm sick of all the stupid biological games and lies they spin to try and make themselves important.
Nandy needs a psychiatrist.
So does this GUY.
It’s good that Katy Jon Went has changed some of his opinions by listening to the other side. He still thinks trans inclusion and women’s right to fair sport is equal, though. It’s not. Women need to have their own sports and men, whether they have a trans identity or not, need to either compete in the men’s or open category. There’s nothing more to discuss.
The thought of L T being involved in governing the country worries me deeply.
I am voting Reform, but I do desperately hope Labour never get into power .
Is this a serious interview ……
P l e a s e ….. give me strength
So sick of this &$#@
Its obviously a skit of a Harry Enfield sketch
Beautifully said, Katy. How refreshing to hear a hot topic being discussed in a calm, common sense manner without insulting any person's sensibilities. Thank you! ❤ 🇨🇦
Anyone empowering working class men? Sick of this bs discrimination
I'll stand up for the working class men when I see that they are being usurped by women and transgender and denied the basic freedoms of their gender because a woman wants to be treated as special because she has an artificial peepee. I haven't seen that happening yet.
You live in a patriarchal society what more do you want ?
@@jessebongo46 Complete rubbish more like a feminist society feels like we are living out the barbie movie. There literally no opportune or Help for working class white men all the schemes, funds and attention is diverted towards every single other group the best thing to be now adays in this country is a black lesbian women.
White working class boys and men are the:
. Worst performing in schools out of any group
. Highest suicide rate out of any group
. Lowest attendance at university out of any group
. There’s also a problem socially and economically a lot of men are simply checking out of society as they don’t feel part of it and have no investment in it anymore.
Women are born with value men have to earn it a women will always find a partner to be with and has access to sex if wanted men don’t.
I’d love for women like yourself to be in my shoes for just a day to experience what it’s like to be a working class white man so you could see what complete and utter crap your world view is.
@@jessebongo46 Hasn't been that for a while and it has no real benefit outside of a few powerful people, bit like many powerful feminists who only benefit themselves.
The NHS has good psychiatrists … you should visit with one.
He's wrong - 1 man on a women's rugby team can do a hell of a lot of damage, so it's not just in individual sport that it's a problem. There is footage online of a teenage boy who thinks he's a girl knocking a female opponent out at a volleyball match, which proves the point.
But thats a bloke if my eyes do not deceive me ? what happened to the UK
Oh come on, are we expected to take that bloke in a dress seriously? There was a time when this"ex bloke" would have been a comic turn!
Why dont you ask a women
We LOVE J K Rowling .... just look at who you have on to discuss womens rights??..... your not an ex bloke you are a bloke. Nothing wrong with my eyes, nothing wrong with my ears , nothing wrong with my senses.... your a bloke mate, a bloke in every way.
"Diversity and Inclusion Facilitator". God this country has gone to the dogs.
No it's not 'trans and women' as nobody is trans. Katy Jon Went is a bloke with long hair. I don't care if he's had his danglers cut off and fake boobs attached, he's still a bloke.
JK 👏 👏 👏
Someone with GENDER DYSPHORIA WOULD HAVE BEEN A MORE APPROPRIATE TITLE
Jk Rowling . Well done. First class.
Well done JK for speaking out against this madness , common sense , she's a true hero for real women (the one's born with a uterus).
I agree with JK Rowling, I don't trust labour for those very reasons. Prision scenario: A full transition isn't good enough. They have to be non violent towards women.
Why is he asking this dude? 🤔
When that woman started to talk i had to turn down the bass on my speaker.
lol comment of the day .
Women have had more than enough support and empowerment over the last 30 years...what about working class boys ?
This is not about men, but men taking away from women...oh that's right nothing has changed
I agree
@@elainecameron5545how is it about men taking away from women? Trans gender isn't just men becoming women but also women becoming men so yes it is also about men or are you too ignorant to see that
I was a working class lad and i want to sort this problem because men have a vested intrest in the women in their lives too plus you do know the same people pushing this are the same who destroyed hope for many at the bottom like me with the DEI mantra we havd the same enemy
Labour is lost to me. And I come from 3 + generations of solid Labour voters from the North-east of England ie ‘dyed in the wool’. My Mum & Dad would not recognise this Labour Party, it has NOTHING to do with real people, especially WOMEN 🤦♀️
The man who is being interview is talking a lot of sense, more people should listen to him. He does speak a little too fast for me. I have a learning difficulty. However he seems very reasonable. First one to talk some common sense I to debate. If people chose to be trans and this truly helps them, then I say go for it. Why do we moan about people removing genitals etc and getting cosmetic surgery, but we don't moan as much when some bimbo gets a boob job. That's a terrible double standard. Good on him for bringing some common sense to the debate
what a complete nutcase,they shut the asylums,dont give em air time,makes me sick
That's a man 😂
Why do you keep inviting this annoying dude to speak about women's rights? If a real woman waffled on and never gave a concise answer like he does, there's no way she'd be reinvited to the show.
What is going on in mens prisons where theyre so desperate to be transferred?
Sex offenders. Long sentence.
Is this manspainling?
Seriously couldn’t you find woman to ask
I can tell you exactly how we stand up for both biological woman and people who identify as transsexual woman.
We go back to a position of objective reality. We go back to the position most people were up until very recently. We go back to way people like Lou Reid, David Bowie and Boy George treated it. People are free to express themselves by wearing and calling themselves what ever they want. You are a man who dresses like a woman. There is obviously situations which everyone understands where it would not be acceptable to be in your woman character, your rights to live like you do is balanced with reality.
Elton John is looking a bit rough these days !.
Best not look at him/her😂
Do transgenders have periods 😂
So the trans footballer didn't mind facing a team of women but OMG dont let me face a team of trans women even though every woman who plays against him is up against a male. No extra balls in womens sports
Why is it always man-to-woman and rarely the other way around?
the other way is not oppressing any groups so you dont hear it
By heck ....!!!
"2+2=5"
OR
J.K.Rowling, a women with balls from steel.
This country's in ruins .and waste time talking about trivier .despicable society.
Oh come on 'girlfriend' jazz it up alittle,you look like you have been cleaning out the attic.
What next BDSM rights?
Pedofile rights iss already on.
take your meds grandpa
@@nyeoastra We are taking an antiviral. So get lost.
I find this lady to be very reasonable and fair, I like what she said.
what's that thing with long hair an glasses
Katy Jon Went seems to talk a lot of sense. Impressed.
J.K. is absolutely right and Nandy is very dangerous in what she says (as well as being extremely irritating).
How do we get JK as an MP? No idea who to vote for as none of the parties represent the people of the UK.
I stand with JK Rowling. A biological woman like myself. Trans 'women' are biological men.
A trans person willing to speak in nuance, remarkable.
It's all very simple really: men have their spaces and their sports; women have their spaces and their sports; and trans people have their spaces and sports. And each respects the other.
I agree with everything he said - finally a trans who isn’t on a crazy power trip 👍
Doesnt matter how nice he is a very large part of his 'comunity ' are dangerous lunatics unable to debate except through threats and abuse
Trans my ass. He is a man pretending to be a woman. We don’t need co-exist, men need to leave woman’s spaces alone. I don’t care what he calls himself.
Why can't we go back to when things used to be normal - when men were proper men, not half man half woman, and women were women, not half women and half men , being turned into something they are not.
- what a crazy world we are living in right now.
Nandy should stick to pie eating.
Only women have a valid place on planet earth
any that wish to argue.. are more than welcome
Can’t begin to tell you how little I care about a transgenders opinion.
Feminists need to leave the left and become classical liberals/conservatives.
And Noaha took the Animals two by two and nothing else got on board.
That bloke in drag is brave to appear dressed as a woman .
Saying it like no one has ever noticed before. “You know the number 2? Well we have been looking at it from a lot of different sides and have come to the decision that if combine that 2 with another number 2,,,,you actually get 4!!!!!”
Woman can speak for them selves
In his dreams ! Not any where near 2 percent . in the united states it has over time been consistently less than ,5 percent averaged across age groups.
'ex bloke' eh?