The joker in the Blue suit is a typical Labour bullshitter. These people are pathetic. Thank God we have talented people like Senator Paterson to keep these goons honest.
All politicians are pathetic. As much as I respect James, look at Wong 3 years ago in James' position, was as hostile as James is. All fraudulent tax thieving fucks.
@@buildmotosykletist1987 For over 50+ yrs a lot of Ozzy’s have been screaming about ALL the crimes that BOTH parties have committed on us etc… + NOTHING Is done !! The reason why is bc they ALL work as 1 and have been ripping us off ( stealing ) with foreign entities eg councils, ATO, taxes, interest etc… in which ALL are unlawful ( illegal) and unconstitutional ( law ) Go 👀 on the US Securities and Exchange stock market = Y would the OZ “ gov “ + ALL cops b reg as a corporation in a foreign country ?? What authority / jurisdiction does a corporation have, in which the ppl are forced to PAY their wages etc… F ALL
Does all these front seaters know anything what they are dealing with.. So panicky and not able to answer any questions.... Sad our tax money is going to these fouls.
I love the reference to minister watt as minister Twitter, because that is exactly what he is. As for the other 3 bureaucrats, they are as useless as tits on boar pig! They "are working as fast as they can", really? Poq you wankers.
How come the Australian news paper can identify them is because they are actually concerned, and these people being asked the questions could not give a dam.
You're a legend Senator, thank you for holding them to account. They're a slimy mob. Australia's protection, democracy and sovereignty should always come first. When a government starts to put politics before its people, it's us who suffer.
How are these people in charge of anything? This is gross incompetence on display. Murray "cane toad" Watt sat there clueless as usual without offering an intelligible answer.
4 ministers paid about 3/4 of a million a year by taxpayers seem to have no idea, try to cover up, have no want of accountability to do their job. How pathetic. They don't know their jobs, what the risks are to allocate resources to find the highest risks is mind-blowing.
Labor Ministers won't answer questions they can't because they are ruled by the faceless bureaucrats all working for Labor. About time these AHs are sacked and APolitical persons are given the positions.
The fact that the government and these public servants have to be called to account on these appalling matters instead of acting on these cases, is a testimony to their incompetence. Thankyou Senator Paterson, you are doing a fine job.
Keep at these incompetent dept,they are putting Australian lives in constant risk because of their indifference to their very important job,they should all be sacked
I’ve passed this onto my daughter who has two daughters 8yrs and 12yrs old. They are at risk. I’m sick of these people continuing to coming in unprepared to answer questions. …and duck shoving responsibilities…Deport this monster NOW or lock him up!
How DARE these people take my tax dollars as their salary. I want these complete incompetents removed from their positions. I'm SOOOOO sick of hearing them complain about how difficult it is to keep up with the work load. In any other work place they would be sacked for this!!!!!! Thank you senator Paterson for bringing this egregious business to our attention.
Labour have flip flopped on this issue and many others for a very long time. The minister is directing a department at odds with the community and giving criminals preferential treatment over the Australian community. These cases as horrendous in nature and the visas should be revoked and the offenders deported!
Gee let a journalists highlight to these inept people we pay very well. It's painful to hear these people duck and weave. Our system has become a laughing stock. The minister and department should go. This is disgrace when we know that innocent citizens are being hurt by their ineptitude and inability to act and do what they are paid to do. Protect Australia from this abuse from these criminals, just act. Well done James, every Australian is behind you.
If its being interpreted as no minister would have intended it then clearly the direction needs to be re written so its not possible to be mis interpreted
Where is Albanese on these matters. Look back at the outcry by the Labor, when in opposition, at the coalition over the Auspost watch incentive to senior executives. Labor is pathetic and the Governor General should call upon the LNP to form government after sacking the ALP for failing to protect its citizens
almsot need to ask for how many cases are do they ahve to review still, how many employees are going through it, how much does the department cost to run, andweekly how many cases are checked and how many cases are created a week, it is insane they dont have a list of acts which should be set as priority to check, ie :: if a case involved rape or SA , it should be palced to the top of the file to see the seriousness.
coming back to it, if they dont have enough peopel to look through the cases, then it is costing tax payers money, and also harming citizens, and they should need to hire mroe people
A master class in exposing the systemic incompetence of Labors inability to adequately act in a timely manner protect our community. Super job Senator Peterson.
Labor does not answer ONE question. They are only happy to collect their dole cheque from the tax payer , in the olden days they would be called dole bludgers.
James, LNP will never return to a true centre right party. Australia NEEDS u & the handful of other remaining LNP pollies with integrity (theres probably less than 10 of u!) to walk out and come with your voters to ONE NATION. The country needs you the UNIPARTY doesnt.
Each on like $ 900,000 + per year and all the perks then they just awarded themselves a massive pay rise however if they can't answer or do their job suspend their pay then watch how quickly they find solutions
9:13 Paraphrased: Direction 99 has led to unintended interpretations and decisions by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, and kept dangerous rock spiders in our country. That is exactly the point! #sackgiles
Appalling answers. Are not these people paid to be productive? I find it hard to believe that this dpt, whose work affects our safety & security, is under resourced. If it is lacking, close e-safety & transfer staff
The fact that the direction can be interpreted in a way than otherwise was intended says that it is flawed & needs to be changed or scrapped completely. Avoiding responsibility is not an option & not what is expected by the people of the Commonwealth of Australia.
This is like watching a circus! Minister Watt points fingers everywhere else or the Office Staff have no idea at all... get rid of Minister Watt and the Labor Party!
How much does it takes by simply telling the truths. Would a excellent academic qualifications suffice for people to run a higher office in this country without any accountability and responsibility.
What a disastrous Labor Government.What makes it worse, Albanese hasn't the gutz to dismiss these incompetent ministers, Giles, O'Neil,Neil and Burke AAT.
The minister appears to believe motives are more important than reality and facts. And that reactive, not proactive, management is the gold standard. Frankly, this is embarrassing to watch.
Why is what should be so clear about, become so cloudy by people getting 400k to not do there job but try to push off the ownership of the issue to someone else. Mr Watt party protective, all of them need to be sacked and replace.
It has nothing to do with a political objective, its pointing out that the process is flawed, which needs to be acknowledged so changes can be made that stop this from happening.
Well done James Patterson ! They are truly incompetent it’s embarrassing !
The joker in the Blue suit is a typical Labour bullshitter. These people are pathetic. Thank God we have talented people like Senator Paterson to keep these goons honest.
Labor are pathetic
All politicians are pathetic. As much as I respect James, look at Wong 3 years ago in James' position, was as hostile as James is. All fraudulent tax thieving fucks.
Whoever is in power are subject to the same permanent public service ..
The rot is permanent..
@@chrisdeason4904 : Then sack them now.
Beyond pathetic. They should be sacked
@@buildmotosykletist1987 For over 50+ yrs a lot of Ozzy’s have been screaming about ALL the crimes that BOTH parties have committed on us etc… + NOTHING Is done !! The reason why is bc they ALL work as 1 and have been ripping us off ( stealing ) with foreign entities eg councils, ATO, taxes, interest etc… in which ALL are unlawful ( illegal) and unconstitutional ( law )
Go 👀 on the US Securities and Exchange stock market = Y would the OZ “ gov “ + ALL cops b reg as a corporation in a foreign country ?? What authority / jurisdiction does a corporation have, in which the ppl are forced to PAY their wages etc… F ALL
This chick is on around 900k a year she should be refunding money paid and resigning
@@d.a2500 the chick is so incompetent it’s totally scary stuff never prepared don’t no what is going on in her office
I’ll take it on notice says it all about their incompetence.
@@d.a2500 He likes flying a lot...
@@d.a2500 Pezzullo has flown more than Albo
@@d.a2500can U make sure that the OZ ppl aren’t PAYING for their defence !!
Journalists doing your job for you shame on you bureaucrats
@d.a2500 they don't report unbiased truth. They report what they are told to report, my opinion
Yeh but in this case theyre finding cases the home affairs arent. If not for those journalists we wouldnt even know about this epic fail.
Credit where credit is due, the Australian has done a far better job than the bureaucrats.
@@d.a2500 : I see you've got a new name but still the same foil hat rubbish.
Does all these front seaters know anything what they are dealing with.. So panicky and not able to answer any questions.... Sad our tax money is going to these fouls.
Never ever stop, Senator James Paterson.
Border security is the most basic and necessary responsibility of a sovereign nation.
like watching a train wreck unfold in slow motion. Excruciating to watch.
Senator Paterson is the only reason it's bearable
Pathetic! Where’s the accountability for these lame bureaucrats?
AAT need to be investigated by the Federal police
Minister Twatt has never answered a question properly in his entire time in his ministry.
I love the reference to minister watt as minister Twitter, because that is exactly what he is. As for the other 3 bureaucrats, they are as useless as tits on boar pig! They "are working as fast as they can", really? Poq you wankers.
I meant "twatt", bloody computer.
I can't admire Senator Paterson enough for his work on this, and many other issues!!!!!
Labor will cry “playing politics” every time rather than accept accountability for incompetence. What a slimy mob.
They rather import more instead!
Well done, James 👏
Senator Murray Watt is a typical Labor stooge - an absolute weasel.
How come the Australian news paper can identify them is because they are actually concerned, and these people being asked the questions could not give a dam.
You're a legend Senator, thank you for holding them to account. They're a slimy mob. Australia's protection, democracy and sovereignty should always come first. When a government starts to put politics before its people, it's us who suffer.
She's hesitating because she doesn't want to sound defensive, but she's happy to sound completely incompetent and like a bungling fool.
and with no concern for the safety of ausltrians
How are these people in charge of anything? This is gross incompetence on display. Murray "cane toad" Watt sat there clueless as usual without offering an intelligible answer.
Appreciate the fast upload - Great questioning from Senator Paterson, as usual, kudos team
ALP letting grapers run loose while patting false alegations like B Higgins on the back. No priorities, no accountability ALP a Disgrace.
The hesitation in these answers is very concerning..
Thinking up more lies.
These people cannot answer , haven't got a clue😡
Good job James.
Who BLOODY VOTED FOR THIS LOT!!!!!!!BECAUSE I BLOODY DIDN'T
Thank very much Senator, you have just shown the country what is actually happening in our community. Thank you 🙏 good job 👍
SEN. J PATERSON...SPOT ON, LET THE PEOPLE LEARN THE TRUTH.....THIS IS A VIOLATION OF CONSTITUTION.....WE THE PEOPLE AUSTRALIANS SAFETY IN DANGER.....
4 ministers paid about 3/4 of a million a year by taxpayers seem to have no idea, try to cover up, have no want of accountability to do their job. How pathetic.
They don't know their jobs, what the risks are to allocate resources to find the highest risks is mind-blowing.
Why is Murray Watt there? Where is the relevant minister?
They are all trying to protect themselves and....
The victims of the criminals are a secondary consideration
What a disgrace!!! If they are genuinely not across this already and this is news to them, we're stuffed - inept & pathetic.
Labor Ministers won't answer questions they can't because they are ruled by the faceless bureaucrats all working for Labor.
About time these AHs are sacked and APolitical persons are given the positions.
They're ruled by who, and UN
This is astonishing. Those bureaucrats sitting there should be sacked - do they not know what is going on???
Just there to collect their over the top salary, all dumb as each other.
Of course they know, they just don't give a damn.
@@haddahgutful1876 Labor only appoint Labor people - the public service is literally 97% Labor !!
The fact that the government and these public servants have to be called to account on these appalling matters instead of acting on these cases, is a testimony to their incompetence. Thankyou Senator Paterson, you are doing a fine job.
These people are a total joke as is Jiles that allowed this to happen
A whole bunch of people who've failed upwards and have never been held accountable or told NO by their peers..
Keep at these incompetent dept,they are putting Australian lives in constant risk because of their indifference to their very important job,they should all be sacked
I’ve passed this onto my daughter who has two daughters 8yrs and 12yrs old. They are at risk. I’m sick of these people continuing to coming in unprepared to answer questions. …and duck shoving responsibilities…Deport this monster NOW or lock him up!
Watt is trash he needs to go
Ain't that the truth.
How DARE these people take my tax dollars as their salary. I want these complete incompetents removed from their positions. I'm SOOOOO sick of hearing them complain about how difficult it is to keep up with the work load. In any other work place they would be sacked for this!!!!!! Thank you senator Paterson for bringing this egregious business to our attention.
Immediately revoke any part that stops immediate detention and permanent deportation and stripping of Australian citizenship. Absolutely Disgraceful.
WOW ……………… abysmal, catastrophic failure.
Thank you Senator Paterson for shining the light. 🙏
There doesn’t seem to be any outrage towards pedophilia, why?
Just nothing, no reaction
it's all and much more than "peodophelia"??
Because there are pedos in government.
One flag piss others off. One country not three
Agreed 100%
Or the Australian flag should be front and centre not off to the side. Disgusting!
neither neither 6. One nation One continent and no boarder's.
Why is Watt defending this instead of Giles?
We are lucky to have Senator Paterson,on the Public's side,-because non of these "Drongo's"-are !!
What a facepalm moment
Labour have flip flopped on this issue and many others for a very long time. The minister is directing a department at odds with the community and giving criminals preferential treatment over the Australian community. These cases as horrendous in nature and the visas should be revoked and the offenders deported!
A rudderless ship that is sinking. Bring on the next election.
they won't be, there will be a fully new elected executive team with no link to royals, who and UN etc
What total incompetence, IF it is incompetence, which deserves they be sacked!
Gee let a journalists highlight to these inept people we pay very well. It's painful to hear these people duck and weave. Our system has become a laughing stock. The minister and department should go. This is disgrace when we know that innocent citizens are being hurt by their ineptitude and inability to act and do what they are paid to do. Protect Australia from this abuse from these criminals, just act. Well done James, every Australian is behind you.
Its alarming .
Watt defending Giles why aren't Giles and O'Neil there to answer for themselves,,, this is pathetic,,,
If its being interpreted as no minister would have intended it then clearly the direction needs to be re written so its not possible to be mis interpreted
M.Watt caught & bowled J.Patterson 0
SEND IN THE CLOWNS
Three DEI appointments in the room together,awesome hey.
Not wrong, who’d have thought that they’d be useless.😂
Disgusting
Where is Albanese on these matters. Look back at the outcry by the Labor, when in opposition, at the coalition over the Auspost watch incentive to senior executives. Labor is pathetic and the Governor General should call upon the LNP to form government after sacking the ALP for failing to protect its citizens
Good God. Fix this please.
almsot need to ask for how many cases are do they ahve to review still, how many employees are going through it, how much does the department cost to run, andweekly how many cases are checked and how many cases are created a week,
it is insane they dont have a list of acts which should be set as priority to check, ie :: if a case involved rape or SA , it should be palced to the top of the file to see the seriousness.
coming back to it, if they dont have enough peopel to look through the cases, then it is costing tax payers money, and also harming citizens, and they should need to hire mroe people
Labor doing what Labor does and protecting there voters regardless of how many crimes they commit...
A master class in exposing the systemic incompetence of Labors inability to adequately act in a timely manner protect our community. Super job Senator Peterson.
Question at 9.58 - classic - how can the Australian paper know all this and your employees dont! OMG I cannot believe this Labor Government.
That woman with grey hair is trying to tell us their department is competent 😂😂😂😂and she is almost wordless😂😂😂😂😂
All they care about is their public image..
Absolutely mind-boggling.
the Filth... what insanity are we seeing here..."i must "fact check"..then i can show my shock face....insane!
I will check if these people were competent they would know what is happening in their department
I’ve never observed such a woeful departmental performance at Estimates. Astounding.
Labor does not answer ONE question. They are only happy to collect their dole cheque from the tax payer , in the olden days they would be called dole bludgers.
James, LNP will never return to a true centre right party.
Australia NEEDS u & the handful of other remaining LNP pollies with integrity (theres probably less than 10 of u!) to walk out and come with your voters to ONE NATION.
The country needs you the UNIPARTY doesnt.
How on earth does the Secretary of the Department still have a job? Why on earth hasn’t she and the other relevant senior officials not resigned?!
Each on like $ 900,000 + per year and all the perks then they just awarded themselves a massive pay rise however if they can't answer or do their job suspend their pay then watch how quickly they find solutions
9:13 Paraphrased:
Direction 99 has led to unintended interpretations and decisions by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, and kept dangerous rock spiders in our country. That is exactly the point! #sackgiles
Bureaucrats are often a waste of money, time and space. Australian bureaucrats are on another level.
The incompetence of this minister and his staff is unbelievable. Labor must be voted out asap.
The AAT has always been soft on applicants. For ever .It would be easy to check. Time to dismantle the AAT.
Appalling answers.
Are not these people paid to be productive? I find it hard to believe that this dpt, whose work affects our safety & security, is under resourced. If it is lacking, close e-safety & transfer staff
RUclips does us a great service by making this available to us.
I wonder when our eSafety commissioner will shut it down?
This hearing confirms that we have the requisite number of bananas to form a Republic.Strewth!
They don’t have a clue. The department is given billions and can’t keep us safe. Absolutely pathetic.
The fact that the direction can be interpreted in a way than otherwise was intended says that it is flawed & needs to be changed or scrapped completely. Avoiding responsibility is not an option & not what is expected by the people of the Commonwealth of Australia.
This is like watching a circus! Minister Watt points fingers everywhere else or the Office Staff have no idea at all... get rid of Minister Watt and the Labor Party!
Listening to Watt is NO- disturbing
Those two ladies from the department are absolutely hopeless and don’t fill anybody with confidence that things are getting sorted
They play the stupid card brilliantly
No idea-------
I truly believe that the ADF should have the authority to say who stays and who is to be deported. Sham! Sham! Sham!
Thank you Senator James Paterson …these bureaucrats are totally useless, let alone the Labour government is extremely lazy.
Blatant incompetence !
How much does it takes by simply telling the truths. Would a excellent academic qualifications suffice for people to run a higher office in this country without any accountability and responsibility.
What a disastrous Labor Government.What makes it worse, Albanese hasn't the gutz to dismiss these incompetent ministers, Giles, O'Neil,Neil and Burke AAT.
How can the bureaucrats not know about this case?! Deplorable. Senator is concerned on safety of citizens whereas Watt just wants to play politics.
The chairwoman is a puppet.
How did these people ever get a job.
The minister appears to believe motives are more important than reality and facts. And that reactive, not proactive, management is the gold standard. Frankly, this is embarrassing to watch.
James Paterson will be our future PM….watch this space 👍
Why is what should be so clear about, become so cloudy by people getting 400k to not do there job but try to push off the ownership of the issue to someone else. Mr Watt party protective, all of them need to be sacked and replace.
How Murray Watt keeps his job absolutely astounds me
It has nothing to do with a political objective, its pointing out that the process is flawed, which needs to be acknowledged so changes can be made that stop this from happening.
this Labor party have more than eggs on their faces. Where the hell is our tax dollars going.