Vodafone Case & New Tax Amendment Bill, 2021

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 21 окт 2024
  • Hello People,
    For All Updates
    t.me/bbsirdt
    For Lecture Relates Queries
    www.BhanwarBor...
    Follow us on Social Media
    Facebook - / cabbdt
    Insta - / ca_bhanwar_borana
    Twitter - / bhanwarborana

Комментарии • 308

  • @rohitsaha428
    @rohitsaha428 3 года назад +243

    Been a CA since 2019, still feel like a student. You r the best.

  • @journeytospirituality
    @journeytospirituality 3 года назад +38

    Har khoon khoon mein teaching ka passion...... Being a Ca finalist and a teacher I can understand the pain that one has to go through to teach at this level.....you are genius 🙏

  • @debojitdeb1393
    @debojitdeb1393 3 года назад +39

    A very welcome step by government to bring in FDI. As retrospective effect in law reflects volatility in Government policies which is something that a Investor does not look forward to.

  • @aarkay3514
    @aarkay3514 3 года назад +22

    I'd studied the case already but wasn't aware of the latest development. Thanks for sharing, sir..🙏

  • @darpansharma8508
    @darpansharma8508 3 года назад +10

    Great explanation and clarity. Now I can explain the whole case to my dad and uncle.
    Thanks

  • @Economyredefined
    @Economyredefined 3 года назад +18

    I read 100s of articles on this topic but couldn't understood anything, Thank you BB sir...Love you.

  • @himanshusahu2007
    @himanshusahu2007 3 года назад +12

    There should be 3rd player in telecom sector. But it is NOT possible until & unless govt waive pending AGR dues because VI has 2 lakh crore liabilities and VI is burning cash and it is not possible to survive in such situation.

  • @AbC7007
    @AbC7007 3 года назад

    A great step towards the development of country and maintain the reputation in the global market...

  • @manishthakur9851
    @manishthakur9851 3 года назад +57

    *Vodafone enjoying after defeating IT department*
    Pranab Mukherjee : Ruko jaraa sabar karo

  • @sidpr007
    @sidpr007 3 года назад +17

    The best ever explanation of the whole case study 📖

  • @vijayvenkatram6173
    @vijayvenkatram6173 3 года назад +6

    Been your student and cleared CA back in Nov 2018, please keep making such videos on current affairs, love watching them :)

  • @gauravcharaya793
    @gauravcharaya793 3 года назад +5

    *Your explanation is fantabulous*
    Believe me this statement is underrated
    Thank u very much sir for the explanation 😍

  • @saubhagyaagarwal5303
    @saubhagyaagarwal5303 3 года назад +5

    Sir your way of explanation is unmatched 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
    Thank you for clearing all the doubts regarding the case 🙏🙏🙏

  • @michelledmello6892
    @michelledmello6892 3 года назад +3

    Cleared in Nov 2020, but still watched the entire video. Wonderfully explained Sir!

  • @CuteVishrut
    @CuteVishrut 3 года назад +1

    First video of you after becoming CA ❤️❤️ it still feels awesome 😘

  • @tamannapatil3266
    @tamannapatil3266 3 года назад +2

    Best ever explanation of Case n its Current Scenario. Being CA finalist and ur student I feel proud to have teacher like u sir...👍

  • @hpanchal08
    @hpanchal08 3 года назад +1

    Central Government move to remove retrospective amendment is very appreciated. Very good compilation sir and u r great teacher. Now I am fully understand vodafone case. Thank u so much. 🙏

  • @ChandanKumar-xo2zc
    @ChandanKumar-xo2zc 3 года назад +1

    Right move by the Govt. finally. Even Montek Singh Ahluwalia the deputy chairman at that time was against this so called retrospective amendment. Thank you Sir for this informative video…

  • @bharatchhabra6354
    @bharatchhabra6354 3 года назад +1

    Sir aap great ho👍 har chiz ko itta badiya explain karte ho

  • @rishabhgalhotra3528
    @rishabhgalhotra3528 3 года назад +7

    BB Sir's explanation is unmatchable♥️♥️♥️

  • @amiteshkumarshaw356
    @amiteshkumarshaw356 3 года назад +3

    Just bcoz of you I cleared my CMA final examination. Thank you Sir...🙏
    Kindly highlights the transaction between Aakash and ByJu's and effect of Tax in India.
    Regards

  • @aish_30
    @aish_30 3 года назад +12

    Literally ,sir,u explained it very lucidly and i enjoyed this case study.
    Hope u will upload more content like this.

  • @swamiiyer8658
    @swamiiyer8658 3 года назад +1

    GOD of Direct Taxation🙏
    Respect & Salute to BB sir❤️

  • @sedditguy1836
    @sedditguy1836 3 года назад +8

    Wonderful!
    Sir can you please explain the Reliance-Future Group-Amazon feud as well ?

  • @Indian_Tax_Law
    @Indian_Tax_Law 3 года назад +14

    After reading news yesterday regarding bill,i wanted to see video on this entire case .Seems like BB sir knows exactly wht students wants.Very well explained.Thnku u sir.
    My take: There should be three players in telecom market.If vi is not able to sustain it can affect price as well as quality of service in telecom sector.

  • @apoorvetarway6990
    @apoorvetarway6990 3 года назад +2

    Very nice explaination sir LAYMAN Language/Simple language really enjoying this video 👏👏

  • @AdarshKumar-rt1ob
    @AdarshKumar-rt1ob 3 года назад +4

    BB Sir's explanation is of next level .....Astounding informative video sir ......✨🙌

  • @PujaKumari-zv4wh
    @PujaKumari-zv4wh 3 года назад

    Sir ji
    Aap ki teaching GREAT hai.....
    Aap ko salute.

  • @shuddhadevrajderkar7709
    @shuddhadevrajderkar7709 3 года назад +3

    Great explanation as always sir ! Thank you for making it so simple and easy to comprehend 👍👍🙏

  • @toshniwalmalu9320
    @toshniwalmalu9320 3 года назад

    Very excellently described. Surely BIG TELECOM PLAYER WILL COME FROM OUT OF INDIA.

  • @ashwiniramesh7518
    @ashwiniramesh7518 3 года назад +2

    Very insightful, sir. Very grateful for your time and explanation.

  • @canitishbansal8232
    @canitishbansal8232 3 года назад +1

    Your are the best teacher ever. Thanks for teaching us and always enhance us our knowledge 🙏🏻🙏🏻

  • @ashutoshparik673
    @ashutoshparik673 3 года назад +9

    Beautiful explanation sir, as always
    Thank you 😊
    I passed CA in 2019 but I still watch all your videos 😃

  • @jatinpatodia9674
    @jatinpatodia9674 3 года назад

    Explained beautifully, the is the best explanation one can find on the internet as of now.

  • @ca.bhawnakumari2096
    @ca.bhawnakumari2096 3 года назад

    Welcoming step and thanks for deliberating from the scratch.. 👍👍

  • @MrVinilkrishna
    @MrVinilkrishna 3 года назад

    Most welcoming action by Indian Govt as waiving off of the right of retrospective ammendment w.r.t Income Tax Laws.
    This invites certainity of taxation & motivation for inviting FDI into India.
    Hope the same applies to all laws on indian land in nearby future.
    #jayahomovement #financebill
    Love u sir 😘❤️
    BB Sir Students

  • @akankshaagrawal9179
    @akankshaagrawal9179 3 года назад +2

    Government took a very good decision as it will improve the image of India in the foreign.

  • @pritamsahoo9143
    @pritamsahoo9143 3 года назад +2

    Sir, I read this news today but Your explanation make easy to understand the case study.

  • @shivammah
    @shivammah 3 года назад +1

    Full in depth Case Study, Wahh Sirji. Great.

  • @canaveenchandra
    @canaveenchandra 3 года назад

    Thanks a lot such valuable information and i welcome government initiative towards ending retro tax amendment which certainly give reliance in Indian economy for investment by foreigners.

  • @darshan753
    @darshan753 3 года назад

    To be honest
    I watched around 3-4 videos of presenting this vodafone case, but
    Sir you presented in such a simple and understandable language
    Great sir💯💯

  • @NadishAgarwal-
    @NadishAgarwal- 3 года назад

    This video is very easy to understand the case law of Vodafone and I think that share of Vodafone will go up till ₹20 in near future and India will see strong 3 competitors in telecom industry.
    Thank you sir for this video.

  • @bhushanbhegade8861
    @bhushanbhegade8861 3 года назад

    A very welcome move by the GOI and I think VI should exist in the telecommunication industry otherwise there would be a havoc in the country because it will lead to monopoly and they will charge any price from the customer and thanks to you sir for great explanation. 🙏

  • @harshshahiwala6025
    @harshshahiwala6025 3 года назад

    As always.. best professor who makes teaching and understanding looks so easy.

  • @renugadiya9498
    @renugadiya9498 3 года назад

    Sir you rrrrrrr justtttt amazing..... Fabulous....
    Plzz make the video like that...
    On regularly basis
    Plz also explain
    Rcom case as well.
    And y video to kya hi bole..
    Ek no. Explain kra h..
    I have gut feeling
    Very soon this video cross
    Millions view and channel get more subscriber..

  • @mohitgupta-learngrow7488
    @mohitgupta-learngrow7488 3 года назад +1

    Perfect sir. Absolute explanation!!
    It will be very difficult for Vodafone Idea to continue as the AGR dues are much against their revenue, which is 51400 crore. Accepting the staggered payment over 10 years might not be worthy if the revenue does not support it over that period.
    Jio is the master player i.e cash-rich company which can easily turn up the situation anytime. Also supporting Rcom to stay.
    I think diversification by Vodafone idea could help them for generating revenue like reliance which has revenue streams from multiple businesses.
    Multiple players must be there to stop the monopoly.

  • @ramubanothu5376
    @ramubanothu5376 3 года назад

    Agree with you, healthy competition should be there in India
    Otherwise monopoly creation not good for any market and customer
    Thanks for the brief explanation sir

  • @RamchanduNaidu
    @RamchanduNaidu 3 года назад

    Sir, You not explained,
    Played a Video in my mind,
    Got absolute clarity, over case study
    Thank you Sir🙏❤

  • @kankipathisurya4107
    @kankipathisurya4107 2 года назад

    so valuable Information That helps not only for students ,for others also full thank you sir

  • @khushboogoel8274
    @khushboogoel8274 3 года назад +1

    Wow..very much informative video Sir👍👏keep making such informative video for us❤

  • @amishagupta6892
    @amishagupta6892 3 года назад +2

    Thankyou soo much Sir for explaining the whole case so well!

  • @foreversubhadip803
    @foreversubhadip803 3 года назад +1

    Thank you so much Sir, everything is cristal clear now, Sir you always make hard things very very easy, love and respect 😊😊

  • @sonalinanda8152
    @sonalinanda8152 3 года назад

    Hope you shall continue to introduce these kind of current topics related to our field more often. Thank you for this

  • @aman_tamboli_7786
    @aman_tamboli_7786 3 года назад

    Issues raised by CA Kumar birla sir are absolutely relevant.
    Government should consider these points.
    And of course excellently explained by CA BB sir.

  • @cajatinaswani609
    @cajatinaswani609 3 года назад

    Perfect Phrase for GOI
    Because IT’S EASY TO DESPISE WHAT YOU CANNOT GET
    JAB ANGOOR HAATH NAA AAYE TOH ANGOOR KHATTE HONGE!

  • @hardikpandya364
    @hardikpandya364 3 года назад

    1 wrong decision costs so much... Your videos are all full of information, and energy..😇 Thank you sooo much sir...

  • @farooquekhan7600
    @farooquekhan7600 3 года назад +7

    Loved & request if you can continue such general discussion series sir

  • @arunpanday1730
    @arunpanday1730 3 года назад

    Awesome Explanation . I have revise my vodafone case with practical isssue.
    Thanks Sir.

  • @akashgupta6187
    @akashgupta6187 3 года назад +1

    Definitely this law help to gain investor of vi if not now then after years .. and thanks sir for this amazing video🙏🏻🙏🏻

  • @cmaamityadav285
    @cmaamityadav285 3 года назад +1

    Best explanation of this case study.thank u sir ji🙏🙏🙏

  • @rishabp20
    @rishabp20 3 года назад

    Amazing, someone who wouldn't know tax would understand this. Crystal clear explanation 🔥

  • @Unfiltered_aesthetics
    @Unfiltered_aesthetics 2 месяца назад

    Hands down the best professor ever!!

  • @aditi28oct
    @aditi28oct 3 года назад +2

    treaty ka matalb hota hai agreement, agreement ka matlab hota h convention , convention ka matlab hota h arrangement :D :D

  • @amitkumar-sz6co
    @amitkumar-sz6co 3 года назад

    Thanku so much for such understanding explanation sir and a good initiative taken by govt it provides a hope to the foreign investor 😀😀😀😀😀

  • @VinayKumar-bj8sz
    @VinayKumar-bj8sz 3 года назад

    Love from hyderabad 😍😍😍 sir.... Way of teaching awesome 🙏🙏

  • @honeysharmaca
    @honeysharmaca 3 года назад

    Very usefull sir. Please make continue video on Current affairs related to our taxation and its provision.

  • @CaSoniaagarwal
    @CaSoniaagarwal 3 года назад

    U r the best sir. So nicely u explained everything. Thank u sir.

  • @RahulGupta-ie4kc
    @RahulGupta-ie4kc 3 года назад +3

    As usual, you very nicely explained everything !!

  • @akshayughade9574
    @akshayughade9574 3 года назад

    Informative video... Government's step is Welcomed !!!

  • @gopaljhalawat5727
    @gopaljhalawat5727 3 года назад

    Concept me clarification aa gaya hai pahle se jyada . Which will help me in my CA final exam also. So, thank you very much sir !

  • @nimishasinghal2894
    @nimishasinghal2894 3 года назад

    thanks sir ... please keep making such type of vedios related with corporate world news

  • @mehulsharma2925
    @mehulsharma2925 3 года назад

    i am preparing for clat and came across this news recently, i had no idea what the issue was, but not i can go and explain it to someone with full confidence, thankssss sir!

  • @pranavjain5040
    @pranavjain5040 3 года назад

    Looking forward for more videos on such informative topics... love you sir

  • @rahuldhananiya
    @rahuldhananiya 3 года назад

    Sir isi type k informative videos post krte rahiyega.........tysm sir

  • @ashwinideshmukh3249
    @ashwinideshmukh3249 3 года назад

    This was much neeeded thanks for explaining it in the simplest form sir

  • @darshanpobaru1106
    @darshanpobaru1106 3 года назад +1

    Amazing Explanation Sir 🙏🙏
    Mere hisaab se Vodafone ke sath achha hua hai, kyunki agar Vi nahi rahega to mujhe Airtel ya Jio lena padega 😂😅

  • @thisworldliness
    @thisworldliness 3 года назад

    You are best teacher , Dil se .... Imaging 💞

  • @Ghumkkkad_boys
    @Ghumkkkad_boys 3 года назад +1

    Thank you sir for updating our taxation knowledge.

  • @vishnuagar19
    @vishnuagar19 3 года назад +1

    Sir best expained by you sir. and Govt decision is right regarding FDI.

  • @vandanajain7804
    @vandanajain7804 3 года назад

    There can't be a better explanation sir, thank you!

  • @yashved5994
    @yashved5994 3 года назад

    Thank you for explaining in such a simplified manner

  • @cmanavinkanaki
    @cmanavinkanaki 3 года назад

    Now I understand the Vodafone case study in detail😊thank you sir 🤩

  • @srinibashsahu6281
    @srinibashsahu6281 3 года назад

    Yes Sir, there should be an 3rd player in telecom industry. Govt. Should take some initiative about this.
    The new Final Bill presented by MF will be a cherry on Cake for our Country Economic Grwith.

  • @krupaliniacharya6606
    @krupaliniacharya6606 3 года назад

    Wonderful explanation sir. I totally agree with Kumar Birla sir bcz after Vodafone there will be 2network Airtel and Jio.& Obviously it will be a situation of monopoly.For a common people it's too difficult for recharge every month.Govt should look at this matter so that everyone can use a mobile phn.

    • @samratkunwar
      @samratkunwar 3 года назад

      Govt is promoting jio and certainly want to bring one nation one network in future....it's BJP after all and it's allies partner ambani

  • @nidhinthomaspaul5264
    @nidhinthomaspaul5264 3 года назад

    Thanks for that in depth explanation. Beautifully explained.

  • @vdchaudhary
    @vdchaudhary 3 года назад +1

    Make more video of indian stock market, like DHFL

  • @shubhamfitkariwala4166
    @shubhamfitkariwala4166 3 года назад

    Sir pls keep us updated on all these things on regular basis

  • @gopalshastri8685
    @gopalshastri8685 3 года назад +2

    Very informative session sir. You're are mind-blowing sir 🙏🔥🎉🥰

  • @rajpanchal6863
    @rajpanchal6863 3 года назад +1

    sir thanks,, please keep on posting such latest current affairs relating to tax ,, its really interesting!

  • @cacmapradeepreddy
    @cacmapradeepreddy 3 года назад +3

    Excellent 👌 sir Thank you
    1. Ethically and Morally Vodafone is wrong
    2. But as per law Vodafone is right.

  • @subhambarnwalfca8235
    @subhambarnwalfca8235 3 года назад

    so good explain sir in very simple manner

  • @ravitejakukudala9036
    @ravitejakukudala9036 3 года назад +4

    I think they have been waiting to bring this amendment earlier only but subject to demise of pranab mukherjee...A good Amendment it is..

    • @Shivani.M
      @Shivani.M 3 года назад

      No I don't quite think so.. I think it's more because of the international heat India faced from arbitration council, treaties it'd signed and of course, the fact that Cairn energy's top management met with Nirmala sitaraman in early 2021.. must've pushed the govt too change its mind.. afterall the way our economy has been battered, we need those investments flowing in ASAP..

  • @shagungarg1704
    @shagungarg1704 3 года назад

    Was your student and cleared second grp in one go....... You are so good sir.... Thanku so much.....

  • @vikashjaiswal347
    @vikashjaiswal347 3 года назад

    Very well explained sir. Such a informative video.

  • @Sanchitchoudhary08
    @Sanchitchoudhary08 3 года назад

    Vodafone Idea to hona chahiye aur mujhe lagta hai ki India 🇮🇳 Government ne pehle galat kiya 2012 me kyuki isse India ki reputation bhi kharab ho rahi thi aur Supreme Court ke decision ko bhi override kar diya Pranab Mukherjee ji ne but Nirmala Sitharaman ji ab sahi kar rahi hai kyuki foreign investors tabhi aayenge jab unko bhi thoda tax se free ho aur Indians ko employment milega agar Foreign Companies India 🇮🇳 me investment karegi to aur rahi baat Telecom players ki to mujhe lagta hai ki 4 telecom players to hone chahiye jaise Jio, Airtel, Vodafone Idea & Tata Docomo...thank you BB sir

  • @inceptionright5370
    @inceptionright5370 3 года назад

    Thank you so much sir,
    Everything was well explained. This brought a lot of clarity about voda & cairn's case.🤠

  • @vanshika8653
    @vanshika8653 3 года назад

    Thanku so much for this....pls make further video on such type of topics

  • @himanshusindha993
    @himanshusindha993 3 года назад

    Awesome Explanation Sir Thank you so much for this video lecture

  • @nikshadkar1625
    @nikshadkar1625 3 года назад

    Thank you so much sir..
    It's a very good explanation...
    As you asked our opinion on this case..
    Be a student and investor of India ..
    This bill is very good for investors, because of this we will attract many foreign investors which enable to boost our economy.. but
    As a Bhartiya,
    I personally feel that, this action will send wrong message to rest of the world that, they can do anything with Indian just like tax aviation, which will create future uncertainty towards our Nation..
    At last..
    It's just my opinion

  • @ippilisravant9011
    @ippilisravant9011 3 года назад +1

    Thank u so much sir ❤❤ ur way of explaining z really well