When Sean says "If you were my boss, I'd never laugh again." he's predicting his future as well, since the mission leader for "A Short Walk in a Pretty Town" is Bill.
Bill always was one of my favorites. Sure, he's not the smartest, but he was loyal as hell and when Jack got kidnapped, he really cared and instantly offered his help. It was at the end when Dutch became crazy that he didn't know what to do and choose Dutch's side in the moment. Even in RDR1 at Fort Mercer, he could've easily shot John, but he just told him to piss off multiple times until John drew his gun and got shot by one of his men.
It’s funny how these are the only good reasons to not hate him I can reason with slightly is impressive. Bill is such a loose canon throughout the entire game and he is doing nothing but for himself and himself only. He antagonizes everybody throughout the entire game except sometimes Arthur [he can kick his ass], Bill barely considered helping the gang at times it’s really only because they all go somewhere; like when they go to save eagle flies he only agrees because everyone is going so he can’t be that one who doesn’t go. He laughs hysterically when his men shoot John and just liked toying with him when he ran into him in rdr1. Javier is someone who can be compared to bill in Rdr1 but he had so many great traits in Rdr2 that he was just so likable until the ending went down. He did look out for himself too siding with Dutch, even hesitating to point his gun at Arthur and John. So overall Bill is something else. Just plain dumb and that’s why most people even feel bad for him, me included. Yet he’s still interesting enough to talk about him this long that’s why he’s still a great addition to the gang and story. Still screw him though he ran past Lenny without any emotion when he got shot.
@@JackAttack-fb4jd Correct. I think it's telling in RDR2 that Hosea pretty much hated Bill. Hosea is intelligent and he prefers to make money via hucksterism; swindling people out of money in a non-violent manner. Bill is precisely the opposite...he's an idiot that can't scam anyone out of anything, so his only option when it comes to making money is violence. That was a big part of why Hosea became disillusioned with the gang during RDR2. Dutch kept bringing in more characters like Bill and Micah into the gang. "We've turned into a bunch of killers, I mean it."
As bad as Strauss is I kinda feel bad for him being ignored lol. He truly did care for the betterment of the gang and did everything he can to earn his keep (even if his actions were cruel and dubious) and heck he literally died while he was being interoggated by the pinkertons
He really only care about his self he didn’t say anything bc he wouldn’t say anything to anyone. And he was pretty tough even tho he doesn’t look like it
@@NaderHmagSHORTS I find that contradicting because if he only cared for himself then he would’ve cracked and told everything he knew about the gang. Instead he held his ground till death. And yeah he was pretty tough, but obviously not as tough as the other gang members cuz I doubt he’d survive a gunfight and thats why he had to rely on his slyness and cunningness in order to survive. The point is, despite being a crook, he had had loyalty.
@@NaderHmagSHORTS well if they were willing to give someone like John Marston and Arthur Morgan a chance to walk free or prolong their lives, im pretty sure they would give him that choice too. But that aint the point. He was given a choice to take the easy way out (regardless of whether they kill him or not) or take a slow and painful death through torture and he chose the latter. I see no benefit for him to choose to not rat out on the gang besides out of sheer loyalty to them.
Aruthers hair doesn't turn white, he ages a little but his hair does not turn white unless you use a mod. Don't give us lies, I usually like what you post
He's one of those RDR videos channels that gives everywhere the same shitty clickbait and even after that he gives fake info to get attention. i block his channel and recommend that to any sane person
@@maksymalnybul6145 I was watching that, waiting for some nod towards the fact that bartenders and shop proprietors comment on Arthur's deteriorating health if you've visited their businesses frequently before getting sick, then going to see them afterwards (something I didn't notice in my first playthrough bc I was very story focused and didn't soak in the environment as much as I'd have liked to) but it was some modded bs I typically don't trust allegedly factual videos from people who use mods in their gameplay at all, like he modded post-Guarma Dutch to have his epilogue beard, I was waiting for more bs like that through the video, and old-ass Arthur proved that
@@maksymalnybul6145 yeah, I mean mods to show you sort of behind the scenes stuff like Catherine Braithwaite burning herself up, I'm fine with, it's when they drastically alter a characters appearance for no reason, then do some clickbaity bullshit, that always pisses me off Especially if what they're showing seems very unlikely or you know its demonstrably untrue, then you know its a load of bs
Half of what's here is either modded, or he's made several videos about already. The "Micah cuts Pinkerton's throat to keep him from talking" is something that i commented on a previous video of his, and he decided to run with it and pose it as fact lmao.
That last clip might be the only time i've seen people actually respect Bill. Granted they're the gang's young kids but still they treated him like the vicious bastard he was in 1, not as the clown he gets presented as in 2.
One of arthurs greetings to dutch is "youll figure it out dutch, you always do" and in that one where micah slits the pinkertons throat, micah actually says the same thing
Y'all may not like strauss but he's the better person than everyone in the camp. Murdering people or being a loanshark. And he didn't say a single word after he was captured.
It was hamish who was a veteran side quest. He was honestly really cool and Arthur seemed to love hanging out with him from his expressions and dialogue. He also gives you his horse when he dies. Genuinely one of the saddest deaths for any side character.
he's pretty bad but not really compared to the others who are killers and robbers, plus I doubt strauss knew that downes was sick, and arthur was pretty much bound to die anyway
@@PatienceKiss usury is still better than robbing, in the end its your choice to take the money. And there is no different outcome for an outlaw, both games are literally saying this
Strauss may have done some bad things to the loan takers, but honestly the rest of the gang are no better than him. Robbery and murder are no better than usury. Even when he was caught he never ratted the gang out. Although he was indirectly responsible for Arthur’s death, there’s no way for him to know that Thomas had contracted TB
Thomas downes Debt collection is kinda sad even sadder when you consider the exact second arthur gets his Tb idk its also like arthur wash your mouth be better
After Catherine burned in the mansion, I actually went back to visit it a couple days after and looted her body lol. But if you visit around the end of the game, you’ll notice that her body’s not there no more. I know she was kinda stuck up, a liar, and selfish, but I actually felt bad when she walked back into her burning home, and if I could, I woulda have stopped her because people can still change.
I have a complicate opinion about Strauss. Before the mission of kick him of the gang, I get spoiled about his destiny (spoiler...) of died by torture for not sell the gang. When I found out about this, I didn't have the heart to kick him, and I just ignored that mission to leave him to go by him self.
Well Arthur might have done good things from time to time it's him pulling the scam here with Strauss that I mean it led to his own death I mean had he not done all this work for Strauss said he not been going around terrorizing people and treat people like crap he wouldn't have died it was his own downfall.
I don’t get it either. Arthur’s hair turns grey? Doubt it/definitely a mod. Bartender’s have told me “to your health” to my arthur well after being sick. So idk either
Jeez only now realized how selfish Abigail is, Arthur just got back, has a longass beard, looks like he has been starving for a month and has a sick man's face and she's like "hey arthur they got john", damn let the man take a seat first at least
Друг,я не понимаю,ты русский или нет? Просто у тебя в видео есть субтитры и на русском и на английском.Friend, I don't understand, are you Russian or not? It's just that you have subtitles in both Russian and English in your video.
I hate micah Marston and dutch Williamson But i love John bell and Arthur escuella and Javier morgan and Abigail Jackson and molly grimshaw and Susan o shay tilly milton and i hate bill van der linde and their is also jack Bronte
What is the fourth one (the one about playing for too long before Arthur gets sick) even supposed to be? That he gets gray hair? I'm pretty sure that's just literally not true. Gotta be a mod or something.
1 is just playing as john while arthur is dead, rdr2 is better, i never played 1 bc i love good graphics, so in my opinion 2 edit; red dead 2 takes place before red dead 1, that is why arthur is dead
If you just wanna see the changes between the two in gameplay, 1 then 2 is more satisfying. If you want a continuous story, 2 then 1 for extra immersion.
wait wait wait wait wait wait? the whole guy coughing in his face as an easter egg?????? I thought that was just part of the game? (incoincidentally I IMMEDIATELY knew that guy gave arthur tb my first playthrough)
I like that Arthur likes everyone in the gang, even uncle. Everyone except Strauss and Micah
It's not that he don't like Strauss he just doesn't like what Strauss does nor does he like when Strauss asks him to do
@@carter2.005 Thats literally what "not liking someone" means
No it’s not
Pero le gusta que haga algo por la pandilla @@lamardavisakald4438
He only starts to really dislike strauss in chapter 6
it surprises me how people still find new things
Not new, but, intriguing 🤨
🤓
@@jackconklin5398🤓
Bro I'm just now seeing that part when Micah killed the last Pinkerton so he doesn't say anything, that's crazy
Depends of your definition of new
6:23 The sight of Charles just teleporting and beating that guy is terrifying
I really don't want to be Charles' enemy 💀
Lol I need a PoV: The guy getting punched.
Charles used super Saiyan technique!!!
Biblically accurate charles
You can actually find catherine Braithwaites body burnt to a crisp in the epilogue
Or after we move to shady belle
You can also find a gold bar next to her in the burned house after chapter 4
@@deadjoker13 where? I’ve tried looking multiple times and then I tried after the epilogue and I can’t find her burnt corpse
@@nonspicymemes5753her body is right there when you walk in the gold bars are in a room to the left in a chest underneath a piece of wood
@@deadjoker13Doesn't her body also hold a pretty valuable piece of jewelry? Can't remember the exact name anymore.
3:51
They gave him three words because he says
-Okey (what a surprise)
-Beechers
-Hope
Uuuuuuuuuuuhh
its not beachers its beechers you smartass
Ok
its beechers and not beachers my guy
@@edoe6374 my mistake
When Sean says "If you were my boss, I'd never laugh again." he's predicting his future as well, since the mission leader for "A Short Walk in a Pretty Town" is Bill.
Interesting.
Truly the most realistic game
Fr
Bill always was one of my favorites. Sure, he's not the smartest, but he was loyal as hell and when Jack got kidnapped, he really cared and instantly offered his help.
It was at the end when Dutch became crazy that he didn't know what to do and choose Dutch's side in the moment. Even in RDR1 at Fort Mercer, he could've easily shot John, but he just told him to piss off multiple times until John drew his gun and got shot by one of his men.
It’s funny how these are the only good reasons to not hate him I can reason with slightly is impressive. Bill is such a loose canon throughout the entire game and he is doing nothing but for himself and himself only. He antagonizes everybody throughout the entire game except sometimes Arthur [he can kick his ass], Bill barely considered helping the gang at times it’s really only because they all go somewhere; like when they go to save eagle flies he only agrees because everyone is going so he can’t be that one who doesn’t go. He laughs hysterically when his men shoot John and just liked toying with him when he ran into him in rdr1. Javier is someone who can be compared to bill in Rdr1 but he had so many great traits in Rdr2 that he was just so likable until the ending went down. He did look out for himself too siding with Dutch, even hesitating to point his gun at Arthur and John. So overall Bill is something else. Just plain dumb and that’s why most people even feel bad for him, me included. Yet he’s still interesting enough to talk about him this long that’s why he’s still a great addition to the gang and story. Still screw him though he ran past Lenny without any emotion when he got shot.
@@JackAttack-fb4jd Correct. I think it's telling in RDR2 that Hosea pretty much hated Bill. Hosea is intelligent and he prefers to make money via hucksterism; swindling people out of money in a non-violent manner. Bill is precisely the opposite...he's an idiot that can't scam anyone out of anything, so his only option when it comes to making money is violence. That was a big part of why Hosea became disillusioned with the gang during RDR2. Dutch kept bringing in more characters like Bill and Micah into the gang. "We've turned into a bunch of killers, I mean it."
@@JackAttack-fb4jdsooo..... You don't like bill, I'm assuming
As bad as Strauss is I kinda feel bad for him being ignored lol. He truly did care for the betterment of the gang and did everything he can to earn his keep (even if his actions were cruel and dubious) and heck he literally died while he was being interoggated by the pinkertons
He really only care about his self he didn’t say anything bc he wouldn’t say anything to anyone. And he was pretty tough even tho he doesn’t look like it
@@NaderHmagSHORTS I find that contradicting because if he only cared for himself then he would’ve cracked and told everything he knew about the gang. Instead he held his ground till death. And yeah he was pretty tough, but obviously not as tough as the other gang members cuz I doubt he’d survive a gunfight and thats why he had to rely on his slyness and cunningness in order to survive.
The point is, despite being a crook, he had had loyalty.
@@yayothejowen2541 maybe you right, still he was a piece of shit 🤣
@@yayothejowen2541 I also believe they would have killed him anyway even if he talk and I think he knew that
@@NaderHmagSHORTS well if they were willing to give someone like John Marston and Arthur Morgan a chance to walk free or prolong their lives, im pretty sure they would give him that choice too.
But that aint the point. He was given a choice to take the easy way out (regardless of whether they kill him or not) or take a slow and painful death through torture and he chose the latter. I see no benefit for him to choose to not rat out on the gang besides out of sheer loyalty to them.
Aruthers hair doesn't turn white, he ages a little but his hair does not turn white unless you use a mod. Don't give us lies, I usually like what you post
He's one of those RDR videos channels that gives everywhere the same shitty clickbait and even after that he gives fake info to get attention. i block his channel and recommend that to any sane person
@@maksymalnybul6145 I was watching that, waiting for some nod towards the fact that bartenders and shop proprietors comment on Arthur's deteriorating health if you've visited their businesses frequently before getting sick, then going to see them afterwards (something I didn't notice in my first playthrough bc I was very story focused and didn't soak in the environment as much as I'd have liked to) but it was some modded bs
I typically don't trust allegedly factual videos from people who use mods in their gameplay at all, like he modded post-Guarma Dutch to have his epilogue beard, I was waiting for more bs like that through the video, and old-ass Arthur proved that
@@matthewlacey4198 One modded thing is the sign unfortunately
@@maksymalnybul6145 yeah, I mean mods to show you sort of behind the scenes stuff like Catherine Braithwaite burning herself up, I'm fine with, it's when they drastically alter a characters appearance for no reason, then do some clickbaity bullshit, that always pisses me off
Especially if what they're showing seems very unlikely or you know its demonstrably untrue, then you know its a load of bs
Half of what's here is either modded, or he's made several videos about already. The "Micah cuts Pinkerton's throat to keep him from talking" is something that i commented on a previous video of his, and he decided to run with it and pose it as fact lmao.
That mission at Manzanita Post with Nils should've been called ".....OKAY!" 😂
Okay
Okay
If you visit nils after the epilogue he greets you in Norwegian 😊
@@antonnilsson2928 lol, and here's me constantly thinking he's Swedish whenever I ride past Manzanita...for whatever reason 🤣
That last clip might be the only time i've seen people actually respect Bill. Granted they're the gang's young kids but still they treated him like the vicious bastard he was in 1, not as the clown he gets presented as in 2.
@Matasiete1850 The way Lenny flinched and stuttered when Bill snapped was so sarcastic, really got one over on him there
So u didn't play the game lol@@PatienceKiss
0:31 STRAUSSS CLIMBING NOTHING
But seriously what is he doing 😂
Lol
He was climbing on the bunk bed 0:27 .
Staying fit
Nills is an acquired taste.
Okay!!
When you're in the recycling content and passing off mods as vanilla competition and Brother Foller walks in
He did say “Beecher hope” not just “ok”
Okay two words
@@Zghost276 no, three
@@DiddyIsNotShitty whats the third?
@@Zghost276 really? Can’t you count? Beechers = 1, Hope = 2, Okay = 3. You must be trolling.
@@Zghost276 beechers, hope, and okay
I didn't realise that Catherine went back into the mansion to burn with it until recently when doing my second play through. So dark.
6:44 Charles punching faster than the speed of sound
No
No
No
No
No
6:10 bro thinks he is Dutch van der Linde 💀
2:28 wtf is this? this isn't in the game
Yeah it is
@@Battlefieldfreak1 nope
I believe it’s called a joke
yes it is
@@HankScrader186 yeah alright asac shrader the title isn't jokes you don't notice in RDR2
One of arthurs greetings to dutch is "youll figure it out dutch, you always do" and in that one where micah slits the pinkertons throat, micah actually says the same thing
this game released almost 5 and a half years ago and we're still discovering new things! imagine how insanely beautiful gta6 will be
Arthur: “hey-“
*turns into bull frog*
Y'all may not like strauss but he's the better person than everyone in the camp. Murdering people or being a loanshark. And he didn't say a single word after he was captured.
Has anyone else looted the Braithwaite Metal Family Crest ?
You made Arthur look like Dumbledore or Gandolf lol
It was hamish who was a veteran side quest. He was honestly really cool and Arthur seemed to love hanging out with him from his expressions and dialogue. He also gives you his horse when he dies. Genuinely one of the saddest deaths for any side character.
@@Suigeneris999 nice give Arthur the Hamish Sinclair look. When you ride Buell. You feel that Hamish is always with you.
If you go back to the Braithwaite manor after it burned down you can actually find her body
That Nils guy is the biggest chad in the game
Strauss is my least favorite character. He is the reason arthur died.
he's pretty bad but not really compared to the others who are killers and robbers, plus I doubt strauss knew that downes was sick, and arthur was pretty much bound to die anyway
@@falchions_n_foccacia Usury is just robbery with extra steps.
Arthur could have done many things differently and had a different outcome
@@PatienceKiss usury is still better than robbing, in the end its your choice to take the money. And there is no different outcome for an outlaw, both games are literally saying this
Arthur is the reason Arthur died
What mod is it to cancel cutscenes like you did with Catherine Braithwaite
Charles teleports behind you: - Nothing personal kiddo
Strauss may have done some bad things to the loan takers, but honestly the rest of the gang are no better than him. Robbery and murder are no better than usury. Even when he was caught he never ratted the gang out. Although he was indirectly responsible for Arthur’s death, there’s no way for him to know that Thomas had contracted TB
You can't shoot the Braithwaite matriarch but you go and watch the terrible woman burn. Very interesting.
4:37 fat John isn’t working for me 🤣
This game will always be amazing
Wait... Arthur gets old trying to avoid TB, YET Thomas Downes and his family are STILL younger than him??? That's messed up!
You can actually come back and see ms braithwaite burned and dead after that mission in the house.
Not to mention the comparison of the greetings dutch receives later
that saving jack mission is my favorite its so badass
3:23 wait its possible to sell someones wife ?
Thomas downes Debt collection is kinda sad even sadder when you consider the exact second arthur gets his Tb idk its also like arthur wash your mouth be better
Besides the modded lies these are pretty cool
I’m fully convinced that in 2030 we’ll still be finding stuff in here
We have for gta so surely for red dead
After Catherine burned in the mansion, I actually went back to visit it a couple days after and looted her body lol. But if you visit around the end of the game, you’ll notice that her body’s not there no more. I know she was kinda stuck up, a liar, and selfish, but I actually felt bad when she walked back into her burning home, and if I could, I woulda have stopped her because people can still change.
Thomas was the gut that stopped you from killing Tommy wasn’t he?
Yes
the only npc the developers have given one word.
"beechers hope, okay"
3:51i am groot😂😂😂
This is not new but I really never thought about these things until now 🏴☠️
Okay.
@@Rockstardaily Okay.
I have a complicate opinion about Strauss. Before the mission of kick him of the gang, I get spoiled about his destiny (spoiler...) of died by torture for not sell the gang. When I found out about this, I didn't have the heart to kick him, and I just ignored that mission to leave him to go by him self.
I hope RDR 1 be on PC one day
Well Arthur might have done good things from time to time it's him pulling the scam here with Strauss that I mean it led to his own death I mean had he not done all this work for Strauss said he not been going around terrorizing people and treat people like crap he wouldn't have died it was his own downfall.
Another Day in Rdr 2 World
Hello Everyone.
🎩👋
I got done robbing a bank with Uncle and Charles and I saw an X so I went to go loot it and found out it was Catherine like a while after that mission
In 6.23 charles gets flash power 😂
Okay!! Okay!!
No way the gray hair Arthur is real
If Micah is the rat it doesn’t make sense that the Pinkerton’s would allow him to kill agents
It's because milton wants micah to act like he is with Dutch and that he also hates pinkertons. Once he gained trust he can do what was planned
I don't understand the finding about the TB part?
"Okay" 💯💯💯💯💯💯🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣
4:08 this is illegal to have john with no beard 😭😭😭😭
Arthur had just followed Catherine to hell 💀
i actually did see the 3rd one in my first playthrough
Is the thomas down’s mission a side mission for Strauss if so I never did them and I’m in chapter 4
arthur looks like a joel
I always tried to tie up pinkertons, why they can't just interrogate one of them and ask him about the rat
5:54
Me and my mum when I keep saying...
Where was jack during the stay at lakay?
It surprises me how all the rdr videos are with Russian subs I mean thanks
if you shoot the guy on the right when looking for the friend you get a cool secret
Okaaaaayyyyyy
I dont get the 4th one, is there an other way to get TB?
I don’t get it either. Arthur’s hair turns grey? Doubt it/definitely a mod. Bartender’s have told me “to your health” to my arthur well after being sick. So idk either
@@TheJuggerClutch you can absolutely get his hair to go grey if you don’t see thomas downes
Its a joke i think
That was kinda rude. Micah walked all that way over there just for Arthur to dismiss him. Smh
5:38
Jeez only now realized how selfish Abigail is, Arthur just got back, has a longass beard, looks like he has been starving for a month and has a sick man's face and she's like "hey arthur they got john", damn let the man take a seat first at least
What mods for going out of cutscenes?
Друг,я не понимаю,ты русский или нет? Просто у тебя в видео есть субтитры и на русском и на английском.Friend, I don't understand, are you Russian or not? It's just that you have subtitles in both Russian and English in your video.
No one actually believes in the playing Arthur for long before he gets TB right? 😂
Feel bad for Strauss
"OK OK OK OK"
I hate micah Marston and dutch Williamson
But i love John bell and Arthur escuella and Javier morgan and Abigail Jackson and molly grimshaw and Susan o shay tilly milton and i hate bill van der linde and their is also jack Bronte
What is the fourth one (the one about playing for too long before Arthur gets sick) even supposed to be? That he gets gray hair? I'm pretty sure that's just literally not true. Gotta be a mod or something.
It’s a joke (I’m pretty sure)
2:26 dint notice the point
What mission was the bratitewaite burning?
@@Goofygoobers117 blood feuds ancient and modern
why was the farmer's hat glimmering? can you take it?
oh hats glimmer i think if they fall off someones head, yes, u can take it
Nah come on straus was real one didn't say a word that costed him everything...
Poor strauss
Abigail and Tilly can get it 💀
Molly drunk ass too
Guys does anyone know if I should play rdr 1 before 2 or if I should play 1 at all?
1 is just playing as john while arthur is dead, rdr2 is better, i never played 1 bc i love good graphics, so in my opinion 2
edit; red dead 2 takes place before red dead 1, that is why arthur is dead
If you just wanna see the changes between the two in gameplay, 1 then 2 is more satisfying. If you want a continuous story, 2 then 1 for extra immersion.
wait wait wait wait wait wait? the whole guy coughing in his face as an easter egg?????? I thought that was just part of the game? (incoincidentally I IMMEDIATELY knew that guy gave arthur tb my first playthrough)
Ok ok ok ok
Okay okay okay 😂😂😂
I saw that rat Micah do that
The very fact that Charles teleported to him, and started beating his ass is terrifying enough. 6:22
Part 2?
Hello mister
Why is your john so fat in that “okay” clip? 😂
Yes sir😁
Did Arthur ignored Strauss cuz he understood that he got TB technically by his fault ?
1:30
bruh wtf Arthur can get old???
Obviously no is a mod
He ruined the whole thing
he ruined what ???