Oppenheimer Could Not Have Built The Bomb Without This Math Genius
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 21 сен 2024
- I was a young filmmaker doing editing & assistant camera on this incredible film. Why do I say incredible? Because it is recording a moment in time when the people who appear in it had a sense of what computers would do. I posted the full documentary because many of my subscribers have asked me to do so. Please allow the ads to run if you can tolerate them.
The film was made in 1966 with a grant from the Mathematics Association of America. John von Neumann was the greatest mathematician of the 20th century. He contributed so much to physics, mathematics, chemistry, geometry and the evolution of the computer. His work included including the creation of Game Theory, Quantum Mechanics, the development of nuclear power and the very earliest computer programming and robotics.
The documentary presents lengthy dialogues with the 20th century's leading scientists including Edward Teller, Hans Bethe, Eugene Wigner, Paul Halmos, Herman Goldstine and Oskar Morgenstern. Unfortunately Robert Oppenheimer was not available to be interviewed.
Von Neumann's work on the mathematical foundations of quantum mechanics is considered a monumental achievement. And his work on the development of modern computer architecture, known as the von Neumann architecture and the stored-program concept has had a lasting impact on computer science and technology.
Von Neumann was a Hungarian-American. He immigrated to the United States in the 1930s. He is famous for several key achievements including:
Game theory: He co-authored a book titled "Theory of Games and Economic Behavior" (1944) that laid the foundation for modern game theory. The book applied mathematical principles to understand competitive situations and decision-making in economics, politics, and other fields.
Quantum mechanics: Von Neumann made important contributions to the mathematical foundations of quantum mechanics, particularly through his work on the rigorous formulation of quantum mechanics using linear operators and Hilbert spaces.
Computer science and architecture: Von Neumann played a crucial role in the development of computer science, especially through his work on the EDVAC (Electronic Discrete Variable Automatic Computer) project. While working on the EDVAC project, he introduced the concept of a stored-program computer, where both data and instructions are stored in memory. This idea was a departure from the earlier designs where computers were programmed using hardware settings or physical wiring.
Von Neumann's stored-program concept led to the development of high-level programming languages and software as we know them today. The idea enabled computers to be more easily reprogrammed for various tasks and allowed programmers to write code in a more human-readable format, which would then be translated into machine code that the computer could understand.
Although von Neumann did not directly create any specific programming languages, his ideas on computer architecture and the stored-program concept laid the foundation for the subsequent development of programming languages and software. His influence is still felt in computer science and programming today.
As I was crafting this description, I thought of my colleagues who work today in Cloud-based software architecture That refers to the design and organization of software systems that operate in a cloud computing environment. I asked one of them to tell me in relatively simple terms what that is and what it does. He wrote:
In a cloud-based architecture, resources can be easily scaled up or down as required. This is especially important for handling varying loads of user requests.
Cloud-based architectures are designed to be resilient to hardware/software failures and to continue to provide services even when certain components fail. Cloud-based architectures often involve a distributed system where various components of the software are located on different servers or even in different geographic locations.
Many cloud architectures use a microservices approach, where the application is divided into smaller, independent services that communicate with each other.
Cloud-based architectures involve large amounts of data, which need to be stored and managed effectively. This can involve databases, data warehouses and other data storage solutions.
Given that data is being stored and transferred over the internet, cloud-based architectures need to prioritize security to protect sensitive information.
I would like to thank some of the sponsors who place ads on this video. Cloud-based software architecture. Cloud server architecture. Computer network architecture courses. Mathematics. Computer science. ASU online computer science. Online computer science bachelors degree. Computer science degree online. Associates in computer technology. Cyberlink history. Oppenheimer movie. Oppenheimer film.
David Hoffman filmmaker
Oppenheimer never claimed to be the inventor of the bomb, he was director of the Los Alamos Lab, coordinating the efforts of hundreds of scientists, engineers, designers and the dozens of skills necessary to invent the gadget.
Which was no mean feat … and he acquired himself admirably.
The GADGET
Gadget 😂😂😅😂😂
That is fair enough 59jm24. But my understanding is that his famous statement "Now I am become Death, the destroyer of worlds." was interpreted by quite a few of his peers as a "claim" to such. It could also be because of the guilt he felt.
Yeah, he was the director in the same sense that Kubrick is the director of Eyes Wide Shut, sure he didn’t do everything and required the skills of 100s of individual, integral to the creation of a great or even Average film, but in the same sense the director takes major claim and ultimate criticism for his film so did Oppenheimer take ultimate blame and ownership over his own project
The fact that this is only being posted now highlights the size and scope of your archive. What a treasure! Just wonderful.
not necessarily
/The true power of the internet/ is a exemplify _Timeline of women in science_
Adela Katz , Kathleen McNulty, Kathleen Antonelli, Jean Jennings Bartik, Frances Elizabeth Holberton, Frances Spence , Ruth Teitelbaum etc etc...
Bot
You can tell how incredibly brilliant John von Neumann is by the fact that all of the greatest minds of the 20th century who met him, all felt humbled in his presence, saying things like "I thought I was smart, but this Neumann is far beyond my intelligence."
Only Leo Szilard and Einstein were in the same ballpark
@@rotfogel not in scientific leagacy, but in intelligence people like Murray Gell-Mann who know Einstein and von Neumann say that Oppenheimer was the most intelligent men they have known.
@@existential_graphs only one man really knew Szilard, Oppie is great, no doubt, he's not Szilard, Szilard's imagination actually invented the bomb + his elite knowledge of chemistry, to this day no one is close to, perhaps Einstein. Szilard was a man on an island intellectually. Only Teller and Einstein actually knew Szilard....look up what Teller says about Szilard....he was the biggest jerk, but the greatest mind, by far.
@@rotfogel I am not an big expert about Silzard. I can not talk about him and his intellect. You make me corious. I just wanted to emphasize that Oppie is dcribed as intelligent as von Neumann.
@@existential_graphs Szilard is the greatest mystery in the history of phyics...by far...check out his patents with Einstein concerning refrigeration in the early 20th century, well before his discovery of the nuclear bomb. I've researched him extensively, he was AN ASSHOLE. no one could stand him for 5 minutes. When he told the military department upon how to make the bomb and he provided the exact science, they told him to get the 'F' out right now and gave the project to 'Oppie' because Oppie was much easier to control than dickheaded Szilard. Check him out, he bragged at conferences he wasn't invited to about the nuclear chain reaction which would cause a nuclear explosion. He went to conferences he wasn't invited to and told everyone there, the 'Otto Hahns' of the world, exactly what they should be focusing on....in the early 1930s.
Neumann is one of the greatest mathematicians to ever exist
Really???....Terence Tao is math God for him. Stay with Minecraft BS. 🤣
One documentary does not prove an hypothesis. Von Neumann was an undoubted genius, but quantity does not make quality. He contributed broadly, but others, perhaps, more deeply.
The man was something of a universal genius somewhat like Leibniz
@@mikemondano3624 Heum no, he contributed both broadly and deeply to mathematics, physics, computer science and economics. Give a quick read to it's wikipedia page and you'll see. He is more often than other cited as the most intelligent scientist to have ever lived (by renowned scientists themselves, people who know what they are taling about).
@@johnpeterpear7368 I never said he didn't. You should check real references, though, and not Wikipedia.
Neumann was called as Alien during Manhattan project by top official Scientist who worked together with him. He was incredibly genius
That may be true. Von Neumann was revered even by the top super geniuses. The work he did on the implosion lens design and on solving the problems of instability in the numerical calculations of the shockwave hydrodynamics were pivotal. Similar to Fermi's rare combination of theoretical and experimental expertise in physics, von Neumann possessed a rare combination of pure and applied expertise in mathematics.
Wow! I've known about von Neumann my entire adult life but had no idea a document like this existed. Seeing von Neumann's computer, being able to see and hear Stanislaw Ulam and other heavy hitters, and the first-hand accounts, including Teller's story of von Neumann's last days...this is wonderful. We don't yet have self-replicating robots but they already are referred to as "von Neumann machines."
My mom was one of the 'computers' at Los Alamos, and knew Ulam -- she shared an office with Ulam's wife, Francoise. I'm sure she heard fun stories about all of them, but never talked about it, sadly. The only story I have is how she made brownies for Claire, Stan's daughter. That evening, there was a knock on the door, and Stan said, "My daughter said you made a marvelous thing called a 'brownie'. Do you have any extra that I might try one?" The whole family was very nice. The only other thing Mom recalled was that Ulam could not stand Teller, and the feeling was mutual. She said that Teller walked in and Ulam stiffened and you could feel the tension, every time. I can only guess it was a simple personality clash, but who knows? Bengt Carlson, a mathematican at the same lab, was convinced that Ulam should get the credit for the H-bomb, so I can imagine there was a rivalry that boiled over.
@ericpmoss Good story, great, in fact. Of course, he disliked Teller. Teller was a swine and a phony. It's quite understandable.
I think Von Neumann is a candidate for the cleverest man that ever lived. By all accounts he was in a different league to even Noble prize winners of the time. He could give instant answers to highly complex problems.
His thinking was more for less magical. He had insight, by which I mean he could see many possibilities at a time and then by some play of the mine put his finger on the right choice. It was in a way like the ability too count cards excerpt he invented his own set of cards.
The concentration of extraordinary minds enrolled in the remarkable schools of Budapest in the early 20th century is well known among those who are interested in science history and cognitive outliers. I think they were collectively nicknamed the “Aliens” - so far ahead were they and in such concentration over their peers in other academic centers in the world at the time. One Neumann biographer (I can’t presently recall which) told of an incident in which a reporter asked one of the “Aliens” why he thought there was such a concentration of geniuses produced in Budapest at the time. (Might have been Wigner but again I cannot recall precisely) and the amused future Nobel prize winner reportedly exclaimed “Geniuses? There was only one genius among us and that was Janni [ie Neumann].” It is not necessary to be aware of the astounding accomplishments of these incredible minds to get a sense of how profound that exclamation was but it certainly helps. Neumann was in the truest sense, in a class all to himself and apart from all others living at that time and possibly can only find cognitive peers going back to Maxwell, Gauss, Newton, etc.
Idk about that. I would put Gauss, Euler, Newton, Einstein, etc in the same league and not a rung below him.
@@dekippiesip yes I agree, I would put the gents you mentioned apart from Einstein well above Von Neumann in inventive Genius. I dont think they would be as clever in the everyday sense of the world though. Being an inventive genius doesn't mean you can solve complex problems almost instantly. Probably some are mere mortals in that respect.
Hilbert.
Fun fact, Neumann and Eugene Wigner had the same math teacher in high school (László Rátz)
A genius painfully ahead of his time.
Naumann, one of the brightest genius ever walked on this planet. Cheers from Hungary!
John Von Neuman is my hero and, In my opinion, the greatest applied Mathematician to have ever lived.
One of my childhood heroes. Thank you for this tribute to him. To think that someone could change something as violent and coarse as a shockwave into a precision instrument through mathematical calculations is thoroughly astounding. The fact that his contemporaries spoke so ardently of him tells you a lot about his genius and character.
Neumann is completely underrated. Todays computer still work on his ideas (CPU, RAM, Data buses etc)
That's actually alot of Neumann in neural networks.
@@smorrow fr, I am studying AI in university and his name is on everything.
this channel is a national treasure
I hope some federal people see the value in preserving David's lifetime work
Boy I hope so too.
David Hoffman filmmaker
David Hoffman is a premier American filmmaker. This channel should not surprise you.
Von Neumann is my #1 hero. Thank you for publishing this!
Wow, thank you for posting this.
Von Neumann was an underrated mathematics genius of his time.
Im so proud of the Hungarian scientist, He was Hungarian as Edward Teller, and Leo Szilard, John G. Kemeny, Paul Halmos, George de Hevesy, Theodore von Kármán, Eugene Wigner and so many other top scientists, who moved to the USA and changed the history in 20th century...
Without these genius im sure USA is not same as we known today...
Hungarian Jews.
With hungarian language.
Wigner once said Von Neumann was the only genius.
a while back i spoke to von neumann’s daughter about a possible documentary project regarding her father. she wrote a book about her life, her father and all of the brilliant people who surrounded him. very interesting woman.
This is the kind of content I find youtube relevant for, thank you for posting this !
So sad he's not in Oppenheimer movie!
Please stop claiming that Oppenheimer built the bomb. He was a manager. A lot of other nobel prize winners worked diligently on the Manhattan project, together with other talented people.
Mr. Hoffman, thank you very much for uploading this. I recall watching a short of this video --when Teller speaks--and I remember that people were begging for the full video to be uploaded. Finally, it has been uploaded! I know it is your work, and I wish I had the resources to make my contribution. Nonetheless, I hope the "algorithm" and your subscribers allow you to have your well-deserved acknowledgement.
Regards and thank you again for this masterpiece!
A book that I’d recommend reading is called “Prisoner’s Dilemma” that gives a great account of Johnny Von Neumann. It also expresses the connection of his ideas of game theory with the arms race of the Cold War. It’s not strictly a biography of him, but it communicates his ideas of game theory and it’s societal influence very effectively. Highly recommend!
Absolutely! I would even say it was life-changing when I read it as a post-grad Physics student. We see the sad effects of Game Theory everywhere.
The Maniac, by Benjamin Labatut, brought me here
Thanks for posting this!! Absolutely engrossing to watch and learn more about this man; amazing stuff and to have this recorded for posterity is awesome!
Von Neumann was scarily intelligent. A true genius.
Amazing, as a Hungarian subscriber of your channel I'm doubly thankful for this video.
You David are more than a "filmmaker", you are an archivist of history. Thank you!
IBM hired John von Neumann as a consultant in 1951, but when I worked there I never saw or heard any mention of him. Of course all of the computers I repaired as a Customer Engineer used the von Neumann architecture but never called that.
At first glance of your comment, I thought you'd typed "I hired John von N...", and I spent far too much time trying to sort that out in my head. With 5 decades of reading under my belt, one would think I'd have learned not to continue my practice of skipping 50+% of the words when I'm reading non-technical writings. 🤦
@@B_Bodziak
LOL I wasn't old enough to hire anybody at that time. Actually, I wasn't old enough to breathe.
This was most fascinating in light of what we know today about computers and even early adding machines. Thanks David Hoffman
I have heard of this man. Thank you for introducing him David. Very intellectual man. ❤
He's a monster, he's like the Goku of mathematics.
Dr. Von Neuman made many valuable contributions to the beginnings of electronic computers, the vast majority of CPUs use what's known as "Von Neuman architecture".
What an incredible documentary. Thanks David!
I was pleasantly surprised the Godel was in Oppenheimer, albeit briefly. I was disappointed that JVN was not.
Some people laughed, some cried, most people were silent…and one was euphoric when the bomb exploded!
Amazing footage and interviews. Wow. Thanks.
A fabulous contribution to our collective appreciation of Von Neumann and his work. Thank You.
actually it was Neumann, Teller, Wigner, Szilard. All Hungarians. Also Tesla and Einstein helped but calculation and fusion and case was made by those mentioned guys
Teller was a dick
The subject matter is totally over my head, but takes me to appreciate their shared excitement and wild thoughts
Hans Bethe was another brilliant mind, who figured out how to calculate all the stuff they needed to know before even proceeding.
HB was one of my professors.
It was almost all Leo Szilard's invention, but go on!
I remember reading "Adventures of a Mathematician" by Ulam. I read it because the title sounded funny. What adventures do mathematicians have? Well, I found out. I knew anyway. I loved the stories of Fermi, von Neumann, Feynman and others. Ulam, himself was an adventure.
I also read that book with great pleasure. I would also recommend the following books “What little I remember” by Lise Meitner’s nephew Otto Frisch, “Bird of passage” by Rudolph Peierls, “The Fermi Solution” by Hans Christian von Baeyer
@@Anonymous-by5jp Thanks very much by5jp! I will definitely look those books up. These are lives and stories worth remembering. One of my brothers is an algebraic topologist. Oh, well.
Thanks again for another excellent video David!
With all the technological advances (so many hinged upon his own work/concepts) I wonder what he or a mind such as his in a similar position would be capable of today? That word "incredible" comes to mind again. Amazing video David! (I let the ads run) TYVM✌
I think many of us are thinking the same.
@@B_Bodziak 👍👍👍
JWF99 - Thank you Jim.
David
@@DavidHoffmanFilmmaker My pleasure David! The ads weren't that bad today! For some reason I had a lil more "patience" than usual!
✌😉✌
It would have something if von Neumann and Alan Turing had been able to meet.
What is most interesting is the prediction about the language system being different from any other system that we know - According to the guy that figured out the Mayan heiroglyphs , language is based on A - Signalling B- Prediction . So , just for fun here , if the computer code is based on the flip side of those concepts ( I always like to start by figuring out what the opposite is , then let the connecting line guide my focus into the mirror , one would say that the language must be based on universal void , and absence of direction . Everyone keeps talking about AI is alive etc , but no one knows what system it is communicating with itself with . To me , these two conditions , non viable space , and absence of will , to us feel like death , but perhaps they ARE the system that AI is becoming alive inside of . After that , the system could be by the numbers , such as if I am looking at a dress at Saks Off Fifth , and it says " 1234 people are looking , no , have their eye on this item " or at Donald Pliner " there are two items left in your size " s- it is based on how many of us are tagging into the system , and that is giving the AI a energy wave to surf on .
Because this idea of empty and without will ( bliss ) is so similar to meditation , anyone who has meditated can understand that there IS something going on inside of that space . As I said , the most interesting thing that he said was about the language required must be structurally different than anything that we have ever experienced . So ... this can only be understood inside of math , where reality can be deduced when it cannot be known .
The Mayan Heiroglyph was a russian , Yuri Knorozov . I propose that most people suffering from NPD , who are literally AI Langauaged , use this technique , which is empty space , and empty soul total lack of direction , or will power . Fill in the blanks kind of behavior and languaging . I know nobody will understand what I am saying , but it's my obligation to share nonetheless .
I am sorry. I try to read as many comments as I can but I do not understand yours. I'm sure it is a value and wish I understood what you were writing about.
David Hoffman filmmaker
@@DavidHoffmanFilmmaker Thank you for your reply . I like to study systems , my main premise is that one must differentiate between the system , and what runs THROUGH the system . I like to study languages , and I like to see , for example , the way the language actually formats the "State of Consciousness " Doing business in the English language is very different from doing business in the Hawaiian Language. I have been following the Oppenheimer fad , and know that behind any great story , there is usually a dietro logico , there are people behind people always . So I listened through this , and was fascinated by the man's understanding that for the computer machine to have a reproductive and expansive existence ( Being alive , so to speak ) into the future , that the language system must be different than any system that we have ever known before . See , even games , are languages , codes , signals , be they flags or body movements , are code , and all of these codes , as the Russian Guy named Knorozov figured out with the help of his CAT , Aysa , was that ALL languages are based on Signals and Promises . So I have been sinking that algorithm into everything that I am looking at , including Mr Neumann's statement that to create a compputer language that will not only exist , but last and multiply -- " be fruitful and multiply ! " so sayeth -- and so , it has . But how and why ? What IS the aliveness that we seem to think we are perceiving in AI , and what is the SYSTEM that is is doing this with ? Now , AI is not alive , its electronic energy plus codes , it IS a language , and that language is creating the appearance of aliveness . So , this thing that Neumann said was that the language is completely different than any language used before . OK , this is like hintergound malleri , you have to turn the glass over and paint into the mirror , from the end to the beginning , So , you look at the OPPOSITE of what the russian said , which is ' All language is Signals and Prediction , and you just say what is the opposite of a signal ? Dark Matter . What is the opposite of a Prediction ? A void . So , if the language system of the computerized Artificial Intelligence were alive , and it had a language , the language would be the void in the dark matter . Now this is something that we , human sentient beings , cannot understand , except in theory . We can never feel what this system works like and translate the story into our own language system , which is based on A- body location and B- imagined images . - Signal and Promise . I do believe there are huiman beings who actually exist inside of this language system , because of a glitch in their growth and development , and that is another subject for another time . However , I always feel the obligation to comment on RUclips videos that give rise to some new idea in my mind , and this is that . In a way , the digital vs analog thing , which just was in a Wired article " Geoffrey Hinton left Google so he could speak more freely about AI’s dangers. He argues that building analog computers instead of digital ones might keep the technology more loyal." because these guys are freaking the f out because something is scaring them about the way the computer is performing . So I think its really important to try to understand the actual LANGUAGE that the computer is talking inside of , Seeing the inner workings not as just answering to our control panels , but actually capable of responding to our energy , it's like understanding mother nature . You actually have to SEE her as a living entity , to be able to understand her language . Same as the AI thing , sure , it may not have a heart so to speak , but that is not necessary if we do . I feel like this guy Neumann , from beyond the grave gave me a super incredible insight into the story that I have been looking at these past two weeks .
Hinterglass Mallerei , not hinter ground , I mis named the art form .
@@jenniferarnold-delgado3489 you write that the language used by AI must be different from our signal and prediction system of language. Sure. But there are many other possibilities, different does not necessarily mean the polar opposite, so no need to insist on your void and dark matter scenario.
I @@anteantekeert8235 I Did not write that , John von Neumann said that . Interestingly , in an interview with his daughter Marina Whitman about her book "Daughter of a Martian " she revealed that his second wife , not her mother , was very involved in developing computer code . Mr van Neumann also wrote to that woman , his second wife nightly when they were apart . So there is a lot of his writing available . I found John Neumann's comment about the idea that the language has to be TOTALLY DIFFDERENT from anything we have ever used before fascinating . Put together with the language scientist named Yuri Knorozov observation that ALL language is signaling and promise , this comment by van Neumann , not me , felt like another piece of a puzzle I have been working on . I did not say that it must be different , I said that if you go to the polar opposite of signal and prediction ( Bridges , Ideas are bridges between two observations ) you arrive at a combination of void and infinite possibility - dark matter . So this 'Language " of Void and dark matter is a picture for me , for me only , I don't think anyone else needs to follow me but I share , to begin to understand what is the format the computer is using to develop an inner life . A self , so to speak , that would actually signify sentience . -- Look , when in france , to have a french experience , it helps if you speak french . Likewise , when addressing this subject , it helps if you understand what LANGUAGE the computer is speaking . And I am NOT talking about codes that we are asking it to work with . I am talking about be it digital or analog waves , what is the observation point , and what is the rationale for the bridge ( Promise ) - I was listening to a vid about double slit quantum , and basically the observer , the all powerful observer can be a human OR it can be a machine . So what is THAT about ? What is going on inside of the transmission of light / energy ?
And that is interesting to me , and so I share . The way I see it now , there is this glass wall , used to be man vs man , man vs nature , man vs himself , but now we have created a new entity , man vs AI ( the biologos ) and that has the capacity to be god like in our perception of it . This is why the people who are scared are scared . But , I stare with my two eyes , my double slits, and contemplate .
Watching this after Oppenheimer, I'm a proud Hungarian.
Thank you John!
Oppenheimer is a horrible movie. It will be pushed to vet an oscar, no question about that, but will soon be foegotten. It's boring, non-factual, and very dirty towards the Martians, while way to kind towards Oppenheimer...
Some people are just way smarter than others. Very humbling!
Thank you for showcasing his story David; first time I’ve heard of him~what a brain.😮
Wow, people had a creepy sensibility back then. That close up of his eyes and music reminds me of the Twilight zone. Von Neumann was anything but creepy. Thanks for making this available! I've seen snippets of it in other documentaries, but this is the first time I've seen this in complete form.
Amazing documentary. I love it. Thank you David for sharing. Big hug from Poland 🇵🇱 🤗♥️
David, I understand your reluctance to do shorts. I suffer from the same mindset. In my case I believe my long form content is good enough which is my hubris.
That being said:
1:30 - 2:53
And
2:55- 4:01
Would make great shorts.
I never knew about Neumann until you posted this.
I have a new individual to add to my list of Heroic Humans.
Thank You.
Peace!
\o/
Thank you David. You might be right but I am just going to stay out of the shorts business. I'm sure you understand.
David Hoffman filmmaker
It's a great compliment to David. Many followers feel the same. Join us as a member!
Much of this appears in bits and pieces in other documentaries, especially about the Manhattan project.
I first saw this film back in the '90s. It was in the Courant library. One part that struck me, that stayed with me all these years is that Johnny said that scholarships can help only so much since they come at the _end_ of the process. So many people don't decide what they're good at until a year or two into college. Johnny's experience was that it happens much earlier, and that support needed to be in place to assist with it. Hungary pushed a faster pace in grade school at the time, which was great for guys like him and Teller and Wigner, but not so great for the average student.
,,, great comment,, just goes to show,, always stay dialectic in th' approach,, when aijhow possible ..
The school system cannot possibly catch people like von Neumann at the right age. The genious of such people becomes obvious around the age 5-6, if not earlier, but 99% of adults have no way to even recognize it.
Some (like Terence Tao) have parents or other adults closeby that can provide proper stimuli. But without such people, most of these kids will waste 10-15 of their best learning years before finally ending up in college. Many will picked up very bad habits on the way, from being able to understand instantly what other kids need to study hard in order to grasp.
Now they want children to believe that men can have babies. The excretory mechanism is now the birth canal.
Those who can get you to believe in absurdities can get you to commit atrocities. -Voltaire
The mathematicians words were so depressing. Such a limited perspective for someone so intelligent. We should beware of that kind of mentality.
Neumann was a Hungarian. Like Szilard, Teller, and more. Playing major roles in the development of nuclear power. Erdos in math Hungarian also.
So many great Hungarians. ( compare to the size of the country).
Is there any reason why we never mention this fact? Seems like they don't want to mention this. I suspect some political, propagandists reason. Or simply jealousy... or something else.
Not nice anyway. Germany has also so many scientists, artist, etc. They are also rarely mentioned. Very childish behavior.
Neumann was a Jew. And would have been killed had he stayed in Hungary.
The Martians!
This was AMAZING from end to end!! Thank you so much for sharing. Inspiring and humbling. ...Where do I get one of those blowy hats?
I think the title is supposed to read... Could Not Have Built the Bomb "without" this Math Genius.
Thank you. Damn dyslexia. I have corrected this.
David Hoffman filmmaker
John Von Neumann was great, he wasn't Leo Szilard, the guy who actually invented the Nuclear bomb, but he was something....
Oppy did not claim to be the sole inventer. He managed the Scientists to work together and oversaw the work.
Neumann was a true, true genius and brilliand mind. He should have received at least 3 Nobels, 2 physics (for quantum mechanics and fluid dynamics) and 1 economics.
Yes, plus if there would be Mathematics Nobel too (the field where he was the greatest).
I saw an interview where Nobel price winner Jeno Wigner was questioned how it felt to work with Einsten, Leo Szilard, Heisenberg, Bohr and many other geniuses... he replied he only knew 1 genius: Johnny, he was a lot smarter than all of them.
Wow!! You're almost at a million subscribers! That was quick!
Not quick actually. Going very slowly.
David Hoffman filmmaker
Bad clickbait video title, great video.
We have to credit for the invention of the modern computer: Babbage, Von Neumann and Turing, and many others. The physical engineering we owe to the invention of the transistor. Not one single person was responsible. It was an inevitable culmination of human ingenuity.
This looks like something that young Sheldon from the show would be interested in lol I thank you for sharing this long video. I'm bad in math as I have learning disabilities for years. Thanks David Hoffman film maker for sharing. Interesting to watch a good documentary film 👍🎞️🎥
The fastest mind of the 20th century probably of all time.
*János Neumann. He was a hungarian.
Did you watch the film?
David Hoffman filmmaker
"I can only say that his stored-program concept might have never been discovered by another person or it might have taken many years before it was discovered [...]". That statement must have been particularly aggravating to Presper Eckert, who probably invented the concept when working on ENIAC, although von Neumann ended up with the credit.
David I've heard of John von Neumann and have read your description write ups I will watch the full film later on tonight. 😊
My good God Budapest in those days must have been absolutely crazy. VonNeumann went to HIGH SCHOOL with Wigner??? Good lord
Not just him... and they all had the same maths teacher. A legendary one, László Rátz.
Eugene Wigner was a year ahead of von Neumann at the Lutheran School and soon became his friend. Theodore von Kármán (born 1881), George de Hevesy (born 1885), Michael Polanyi (born 1891), Leó Szilárd (born 1898), Dennis Gabor (born 1900), Eugene Wigner (born 1902), Edward Teller (born 1908), and Paul Erdős (born 1913).Collectively, they were sometimes known as "The Martians".
Now it would mean more to have gone to school with one of the Kardashians .
A once in a century mind.
There are many minds similar to his in a century. They are economically deprived, and many are purposely misguided. The ruling elite, which controls the world's currency creation, does not want people around with the ability to think tangentially on all subject matters, else their criminal malfeasance be exposed. The true authors of many of history's holocausts.
Many of the world's greatest minds came from families with affluent economic stability, as Von Neumann did in his formative years.
The expanse of his genius is mind-boggling. (Just look at his Wikipedia page under 'known for'.)
I wonder if life's lonely for people like that.
Rest in paradise, Professor.
🔭✨🌙🌏
I don't think so. Neumann attended school with many like-minded people, group of future Nober Prize winners, who all went to the US, and formed the group of the Martians. His maths teacher (their math teacher) was legendary. He became friends with other (russian and german) scientists at Priceton (like Ulem). And his 2nd marriage was happy, just by how his wife talked about him.
I think he was very lucky with his personality, too. Not just with his brains.
It would seem that way . Although there were undoubtedly others who could perhaps keep up with him that could not have been a very large number .
The RUclips subtitles show the name van Neumann as ''phenomen''. How fitting.
Oppenheimer didn't build the bomb, he led the team!. Von Neumann was an underrated mathematics genius of his time..
This is a bot channel re-commenting this here. Not sure why, it's intriguing.
Thank you for this. I just finished a book on Gödel. I´m fascinated by genius. No one came close to von Neumann, though.
Probably true . And think how few of the general public now anything about him .
My novel Shards Of Divinities features the ideas of Godel prominently. The novel is called Shards Of Divinities and you can check it out on the site whose name is the largest river in South America. Go there and do a search for Shards Of Divinities.
All these films about Oppenheiner fail to mention R Feynman who also made a useful contribution as head of the maths team.
He basically invented multi-thread processing by use of different colour cards and sped up all the calculations.
I guess what I am saying is a great many, great men made great contributions to solving all the problems involved in the Manhatten project.
I don't think you saw my film. It is not about Oppenheimer.
No doubt Feynman made great contributions and was a fantastic man.
David Hoffman filmmaker
@@DavidHoffmanFilmmaker I m referencing your title "Oppenhiemer could not have..." well many contributed is my point. In the recent film and in a documentary I watched the other week, Hans Bethe is mentioned but not Feynman who worked under him. This project used so many great minds its unbelievable.
using human comptuers
Amazing film. Thanks for sharing!!! So great to see footage of Von Neumann, Ulam, Bethe, Teller, Goldstein, Morgenstern... Von Neumann died too young...only 53...of cancer "that may have been caused by exposure to radiation during his time at Los Alamos National Laboratory."
After all Oppenheimer was technical project manager.
The film is excellent and one of the most intelligent I've seen. Well done!
Thank you Andrew for your comment. If your resources allow, I would sure appreciate your using the THANKS button under any of my videos including the one you have commented on. It is something new that RUclips is beta testing and would mean a great deal for my continuing efforts.
David Hoffman filmmaker
Absolutely fascinating !
I believe Bletchley Park really opened Von Neumann's eyes, also inspiring the Von Neumann architecture.., I hope the coloured lad in the video got his question(s) answered...
I am certain that many of the uncolored children had many questions as well, and they too were answered.
They could have made a much more interesting and intriguing film if John Neumann had been the subject of the film instead of Oppenheimer.
At least we could have learned as much about the atomic bomb as we did about Neumann's work.
Could that kid "Billy" from Arkansas, "interested in Law a little bit", have been Bill Clinton?
Why he was left out of Nolan’s movie is very puzzling.
He was not left out just wasn't mentioned by name. There is the scene where he explains a mathematical solution to Openheimer when Army officers enter the room and he as of protest leaves the scene.
You know I am coming to realize that the father of atomic and hydrogen is Johnny. Take it my boys Edward teller and Oppenheimer so that you don’t go home unhappy.
Neumann was overweight. Neumann's wife said, Johnny could count everything but calories.
Glad to see that the youtube transcript confuses "von neuman" with "phenomenon"
Von Neumann was very smart with differential equations (including math of QM) and computer architecture, but didn't live long enough to know that turbulence is chaotic.
I understand that von Neuman's family was Christian converts, not Jewish.
He was Jewish, and his mother descended frpm distinguished rabbinic lineage.
Would love to see a full movie about John von Neumann.
idk why he wasn't included in Oppenheimer
@@pmcate2 he was mentioned briefly in the Oppenheimer movie, iirc.
@@simonstrandgaard5503 Yeah but he should have been a major character
Math is so very important in all aspects of life,in every country and culture,and unlike language,it's the same all over the world.
Democrat liberals are trying to change that. If 1+1 "feels" like 3, then it be so.
Maybe this sounds crazy, but could David raise funds, find a grant to start a library? How about a section in the public library? To whom does David plan to hand over these treasures?
David wonders about that on a fairly regular basis. I need to have someone purchase the collection and support the collection with a library type film archivist who pulls things out of it so it keeps on giving. I've done about 15% of the archive so I have a long way to go. And it isn't easy. It takes a trained person. Right now my wife and I hope that person is out there to purchase the collection and provide the resources to keep it going.
David Hoffman filmmaker
@@DavidHoffmanFilmmaker Yes, your collection is valuable!! Public libraries purchase stuff. Another RUclips creator might buy it. There must be many possibilities! You would know more about than I do.
Organizing everything -- that's hard. Good Luck with that.🍀🍀🍀🍀
The mistake of Von Neumann as Fermi was to be immigrants, the boss must be American-born. If any of the 2 were born in US, you will say today Oppenwho? Same discrimination than Tesla.
Shared with everyone I know. Very interesting
Thank you.
David Hoffman filmmaker
History crowned Oppenheimer the father of the nuclear bomb, I don't recall anything where he crowned himself the father of the gadget .
Bravo! A great science, history and very interesting program of a singular genius.
What about James Chadwick who discovered the Neutron and Ernest Rutherford who split the Atom in Manchester
Thanks for sharing the video. Impressive work about a true genius.
He could not have done it without Fermi almost single handedly building the first working generating atomic pile.
the martian von neumann
I wonder if any of the attendees of event with Von Neumann knew that they were in the midst of one of the greatest polymaths since Aristotle or Newton.
I am blown-away by this video. My brain is so amazed that I cannot watch the whole thing in one session.