Wisconsin Supreme Court Oral Argument: Wisconsin Legislature v. Andrea Palm
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 17 окт 2024
- On May 5, 2020, the Wisconsin Supreme Court heard oral arguments on Wisconsin Legislature v. Andrea Palm. Case #2020AP765-OA
The justices heard arguments related to the following questions:
-Whether the Department of Health Services (the Department) violated Wis. Stat. § 227.24, governing emergency rules, by issuing Emergency Order No. 28 without complying with § 227.24’s procedures?
-Even if the Department did not violate § 227.24, whether Emergency Order No. 28 exceeds the Department’s authority by closing all “nonessential” businesses, ordering all Wisconsin persons to stay at home, and forbidding all “nonessential” travel?
#wisconsineye #COVID19
Thank God for those that stand by and will uphold our constitution. The Constitution was not created to bind mankind, it was created to bind Government. "Government is not reason, it is not eloquence - it is force. Like fire it is a dangerous servant and a fearful master; never for a moment should it be left to irresponsible action." - George Washington
macintologist04 wrong application of the 10th on your behalf!
People who are afraid or unhealthy should absolutely stay home.
“My question for you is, where in the Constitution did the people of Wisconsin confer authority on a single unelected cabinet secretary to compel almost six million people to stay at home and close their businesses and face imprisonment if they don’t comply - with no input from the legislature - without the consent of the people,” she said. “Isn’t it the very definition of tyranny for one person to order people to be imprisoned for going to work, among other ordinarily lawful activities? Where does the Constitution say that’s permissible counsel?”
This guy defending the governor sucks, good going Wisconsin!!
It was interesting to see this oral argument before the court. I was surprised that Atty Ryan Walsh did not have to first explain to the court what authority he had to come before the court and to speak and act on behalf of the Wisconsin State Legislature. I do not recall the Wisconsin Legislature meeting after the last DHS stay-at-home order to discuss the situation, review options, and approve the preparation of a legal case for the court's consideration. For all we know, Ryan Walsh was acting on his own behalf, but we know this is not the case as someone must be paying him for his time.
this is odd watching the justices duke it out through #zoom.
I can't believe there are people who are really still falling for this.
All these people in a position of power are seeing just how much they can overreach. How does one dog control an entire herd of sheep? Fear.
Justice R. Bradley should be on a soap opera. She's like that annoying neckbeard in your Poli Sci 101 class who read too much Rand and wants everyone to know about it.
She is unable to follow and inserts her own opinions as priority. Hopefully she won't be reelected.
Yeah, those pesky malcontents, and their reading, and their dislike of circular, self-referential authorities that have unlimited scope, unlimited duration, and are the sole arbiters of how much power they have over other people and how far they can go. You're right we need less reading.
It's pretty clear the legislative act is defective and should be struck down immediately. There's no better time to redirect this matter back to the legislature to amend the statute so that it does actually respect and comport with constitutional law. This would include establishing sure and certain limits on the state agency's scope of action and circumscribing its authority and power.
so they get to do what they want and then you have to come up with the money to sue for your rights? Am I hearing that right?
014508:WisHer:WHO:US
The judge is letting him have it and he is stumbling on is own words now lol
Good. Fuck these tyrants. We are a FREE country.
@John Duncan Yeah fuck the people that are trying to help limit the spread so we can eventually reopen🙄 this is why we’re the farthest country behind...
@@5q88 , you literally cannot get this under control. The only solution is herd immunity. It's a highly contagious virus, we aren't going to eliminate it. All we will eliminate is our own economy.
@@newvocabulary You'll eventually need to clarify what you mean by 'free' since you live in a civilized society with me, and I with you. It's hardly ever free for all.
@John Duncan That is 100% false South Korea has their first case the same day the U.S. did. They have a much higher population density so it could easily effect them a lot more. Instead of fucking around and making it a political debate they went into an actual quarantine and a few days ago had no new domestic cases. They’re now getting ready to reopen their economy and lift the restrictions. Quarantining does work the U.S. just hasn’t really done it yet. Also if you open too early you risk obliterating the rest of our economy if we’re forced to shut down again.
I find it cringy to watch Roth argue his points.
Bradley seems like a loon.
Why is Justice Dallet so combative? Not very neutral
I'm sorry but to give one example of a crisis to another is not right. A fire is one thing, earthquake is another, flood, tornadoes and even illnesses. Sorry but each one needs to have a standard and limits!
I think he just made the case that if the fire department wants to set up fire-breaks and they feel people are inhibiting their ability to do that, they can start double-tapping people in the head. I mean, weird flex for a fire department, but okay.
I don't hear where the legislature is all too different from the current DHS order... so far
"Orders" are no different than "Edicts".....which ARE NOT laws. The legislature gave these fools at DHS unlimited power to act as KINGS and pronounce EDICTS.
We the people elected the legisture and they represent us AND YES THEY HAVE STANDING
Fascinating exchange. We should be having the same argument everywhere.
Please share this my fellow Wisconsinultes this must be heard throughout our counties! Not stuffed in the attic to be left in the dust!
sin 33 watching this from California. We see you Wisconsin. They are trying to do the same stuff here. Stripping us our rights to peacefully assemble. California stands with the people of Wisconsin.
Ahhh, the classic "people will die" non-argument @1:13:32 - see "Remy: People Will Die" video for more hilarious examples.
1:40:00
1:11:11
1:10:50 lol!
SO CLEAR TO SEE who is a liberal ....my god she argues for him !!!!
It is going to explode into an inferno !!!!
If they get sick, that's their choice. If they get sick n die, less to worry about at this point...I wish our stay at home was extended.
Well aren’t you a terrible person!
@@goodtimes8092 I'm not a terrible person. Its everyone's choice to do whatever. My sister passed away from this crap...n it's horrible to see people not care about anyone else.
1:41:00