nah it’s not a hybe problem it’s a illit (wonhee iroha and moka) and le sserafim (sakura and kazuha) problem. gotta narrow it down. u made it too vague.
bro even yujin has been getting shit recently just go watch her performance of im so stupid in love with max. And eunchae is also not controversy free since shes very unstable when singing and performing 😭@snowboardeater
Maybe if Knetz actually voted for groups based off talent instead, this wouldnt be happening. I mean you have groups out there with good music and talent, and yet the Korean public chooses the groups who offer more visuals than talent. People werent lying when they said visuals will get you far in the entertainment industry.
Idols who can't sing?? What is even the point. Just be models/actresses or whatever other profession where they don't need to sing. How did they even debut like that, that's crazy
It’s because they came from bigger companies. There are much more talented girl groups out there only that they where from the small complanies and we’re barely noticed
Not a fan of their group, but I do have ears. Their song is viral and it's everywhere. From this video, I can hear that they're not good singing live, which is a fail for an idol. Something I noticed about fans these days is that they don't care about actual skills anymore, a lot of fans care only about visuals. They even defend their beloved idol or idol group even when you can hear them singing/dancing bad or 'decent' (decent as in compared to the average person whose livelihood doesn't depend on singing and dancing. Hello, that's their job, they shouldn't simply be decent!) The thing is, they should've been better than decent BEFORE debut. Company should also not have debuted them with their skills just at that level, but it's not like they can un-debut. So people SHOULD critique them (without death threats, that's too far) so they know what to work on. If they really cared about their craft, they would work hard to quickly improve to catch up to, and perhaps even surpass, the expectations people have of them. And that's all I have to say about that
@@ojealism thank you for saying this. There's literally people who have never had a day of vocal training and sound better. Like if you can't do your job, just be an actress
@@norrinamohd4906That's more than half of the group and I think Wonhee wasn't too bad as well. Moka just wasn't in her vocal range, so what are y'all hating on?
For ILLIT Hybe can buy awards and achievements but can't buy talent.Their stans can be proud of their fake achievements but can't proud of their talent, because they don't have it 💀. Now ILLIT Stans are gonna eat me for saying some facts😂
Absolute facts, kpop is srsly being ruined. Idols need to be able to sing live, its LITERALLY their job and what they do. I'm so dissapointed by this encore
I can somehow quite understand Min Heejin's complains (although I'm in no one's side) Newjeans still sing better than Le Sserafim and IILIT combined when Sakura literally debuted for the 3rd time and Yunjin has taken part in a few reality shows and IILIT was formed through a reality show
@@ZaNC4847 yeah she can sing so well too but the problem is she’s probably tone deaf. same with sakura. they can’t sing unless they hear themselves. like umm for example when moka covered her ears for one of the encores. she sounded way better when she didn’t. and that is because when you cover one of your ears, it allows you to hear yourself better. ykkk.
Who voted them in R U next??? U vote them because their visual and now you blame them because they can't sing?? This is why u should wise when you vote them.
Nah I remember r u next the members were not voted for they were picked by the producers I mean jiwoo was the most voted but she didn't make it except for wonhee idk how ppl voted for her?
Minju, Jiwoo, Chanelle, Jeemin, Yunah and Youngseo were the most popular, what u talking about? Wonhee was voted by the korean public and the others were chosen by the producers.
@@OnceUBellieve Those names that you mentioned do not deserve to debut because of their appearance. Although they're talented, what's the point of having talent if you're not attractive?😂😂
There is a reason why the Big3 aka Sm, Jyp and Yg have been relevant even after decades and have produced high quality legends after legends. There is no shortcut to longevity and the big3 have dedicated years and years of time, hardwork, creativity and originality into their artists and still do. This 2 days old company who lacks any creativity of their own can only go so far before they collapse and their greed will be the biggest reason for their downfall as we can see what's happening with them.
@@K-pop_Sim yeah so ? So what if they have BTS ? What's your point ? Is fame more important than talent and legacy in Kpop !? Hybe just proved lately that the other 3 companies are still better even if they are the richest in the industry 🤦♀️
I don't know should I laugh or cry. It's pathetic and tragic at the same time... I thought that they were chosen for the group based on their vocal and dancing skills. But apparently Hybe chose the prettiest faces, thinking that the rest of the work would be done by producers or sound engineers... Who allowed this to happen? Did anyone think that they would later have to face criticism personally? it's cruel that for profit Hybe take advantage of these poor girls who just wanted to come true their dreams, but are not ready for debut at all It's sad to watch
What's worst is the song is not even hard. No high note..nothing special even a child can sing it properly. I cant see new jeans in them I see lesserafim.
Yunah and Minju are amazing as they are former yg trainee's but Wonhee and Iroha are okay, they aren't so bad, Moka is the only one who needs improvement
Shameful idols.. They can still smile while terrorizing our ears.. Hahahaha The first one, had me like WTF with that face. She's about to cry, and doing her best to look cute but sound hilarious 🤣🤣🤣
The fact that Minju and Yunah have good stable vocals but they aren’t getting recognised for that instead they are known for bad live vocals, I feel so bad for them
2/5 memebers r obviously good but i think they must be given some songs that matches their voices not baby like song like this ,I've watched the " r u next?" Performances, and hybe made a big mistake by debuting yunnah and minju in this group , they must've been debuted with chanelle and joo and the other girl (forgot her name) in more mature concept, Moka ,and iroha aren't that bad according to the "r u next?" Performances but they need more practice and another concept as well, Hybe choose a concept for wonhee and put the other girls in it . It's als undeniable that it's k fans fault from the beginning cs they vote this lineup instead of some talented onces.
@@moonlightpaw5868yeah no, you’re actually delulu if you think they’re anywhere near other groups that can actually sing. Only 2 members are somewhat stable
Minju: 💗 Yunah: 💖 Wonhee: 👍 Iroha: 😐👀 Moka: Definitely not her vocal range, but the improvement is kinda nice And honestly, can y'all give them a break? They've been getting hate since their debut , while some of the members don't deserve criticism at all. And I said criticism, because what are y'all doing is HATING, and do you really have to add another comment that's about the same fuckin thing like every other? Once, Moka said that the comments don't bother her that much, but they do at the stage when she remembers them. Also, Wonhee was literally reading hate comments on their live trying not to cry. THIS AMOUNT OF HATE IS CROSSING THE LINE.
Bad singers is not a new phenomenon in KPOP. The thing is, even when the members can't really sing they still contribute something to the group. I look at ILLIT and have no idea what's the purpose of this group. They don't stand out in dance, performance, rap, personalities, or even the super shallow visuals. Def. not vocals.
They don't need to be all at Minju(that one strong singer) 's level but Moka is soooo random... like WHY IS SHE EVEN THERE. She is literally like the blonde girl from les sserim. Go be actresses....
I noticed that Yunnah struggled a bit with her low part, then what’s the problem to give did part to Moka that can really beautifully sing low range songs (u can hear it from Disco with JYP). In addition to that in Magnetic they gave her parts with higher tone and again what’s the problem of giving this part to Yunnah who is better at vocal and can handle higher range? Just swipe their parts
Well Knets where the ones voting for them in R u next when perfectly we could have Channel, Jiwooo, Youngseo and Jeemin the talent and visual was there but I think they were “to old” for Koreans 🤣😂
To be honest... I am not a big fan of this group but no one deservs to be told that way.... Those girls are young just give them time they will improve..... So if anyone don't like their songs then just ignore them and stop sending hate or negative messages...
If ILLIT would have a concert and they’re charging a huge amount of price per ticket. I wouldn’t go at all if they’re not really singing live. It is just a waste of money for a lip sync group. No doubt that they’re cute girls. But I will not waste my money just for cuteness. I could just watch them on RUclips.
too bad these girls only got the awards because their company is rich... why can't they focus more on the girl's development??? look at UNIS and compare them. Also, they just proved what 2nd gen artists always comment, "5th gen idols are lazy artists"
Because of some similarities they have to newjeans (im not saying copy just similarity) i thought they will be also similar to performance but ig not and im comparing it to 2022 newjeans not to today, newjeans today are even better.
If you want to have an opinion, you should've at least watched RUN. Moka sings very well in there. Almost all of them sings well too. The judgers are people from around the world and selected judges, are you saying that they can't even do their job well? It could be an inside job. You never know. Also...if Moka is encouraged to sing with her voice naturally, it would be better.
This song is too low for them, you can literally hear Yunah singing quietly to reach those low notes. They can sing, Hybe also isn’t in charge of training them, BeLift Lab is
Its is the problem of source music not hybe if that was the case new jeans never could get a stable voice,but they are professional. So source music have to take care of this
Okay, Iroha and Wonhee are still kids, but what about Moka's voice? Minju and Yuna sing average, I think the song itself is not sung according to their voice range. The concept is too childish, it will obviously be difficult for adult members to sing such songs. (p.s: i am not a hater of illit, i love them💗)
Serious question-the first girl who sang in this clip, is her voice naturally sounded cute like chipmunk voice or she is just made to sing like that to go with the cutesy flow of the song. Coz ive noticed that NJ members are all young and cute too but they didnt use "cute" voice when singing, as in they naturally sing using a natural tone of voice. Im not a fan of both (or cutesy genre) but cant help comparing since both groups have a very similar concept
The minju or minji girl was the only one in that group will pass as a singer, she has beautiful and serene tone that fit into their concept, anyway there's always a room for improvement i hope the other girls realize what they're lacking as an so called "idol".
This is not just one bad day because it’s becoming redundant, they can’t sing live. They are studio singers! K-pop as a whole should not debut idols who are not ready to sing live, it’s embarrassing! If this continues they will loose their popularity internationally. It will be sad for the previous idols like BTS who paved the way for them.
Are they in a karaoke bar?! Wtf you call these idols?! Hybe are rushing in mass production of idols just using their fame & money and those fans just blindly worshiping them just because they are from hybe.. annoying af 🙄
I think a good portion of it is that the girls just aren’t in the right range too. HYBE seems to value style and concept over the ability for the girls to naturally sing the range of the notes. It’s a problem I’ve noticed with leseraffim too. They seem to flat/have trouble reaching most of the lower register. They have a lot more trouble singing magnetic than lucky girl syndrome. Of course, they can do with more breathing work (which is a must) and vocal colour training too but if you’re uncomfortable with the notes themselves, it won’t help a lot. You will still be off key or your voice might tremble. If you have a group of sopranos, don’t make them reach lower second soprano notes without adequate training especially if they are moving around a ton and show an inability to get in that range. It must be hard for the girls too. They don’t deserve to get dragged. I just hope their agency puts the work in to have them be extra skilled and confident for their comeback.
Alright, but during the show 'R U Next,' they had to sing different songs with different concepts. And they managed it well. So what happened to them now?
y'all, have you guys seen Tomboy Moka, Feel Special Moka, Attention Moka and R u next Moka?? Their probably not comfortable with the range that they are singing, they sound so much better in Lucky Girl Syndrome than in Magnetic, pls stop throwing hate to the girls.
While I don’t condone hate, you do have to realize RU Next performances aren’t very accurate. They were definitely autotuned and/or gone through post production.
It doesn’t help that they’re compared to Babymonster who is one of the best live vocal groups we’ve seen in a very long time… Bad timing for this to happen to Illit 😢
It’s a Hybe problem. Looking at Aespa, Baemon, and Nmixx, you can see how solid the talent and training has been
nah it’s not a hybe problem it’s a illit (wonhee iroha and moka) and le sserafim (sakura and kazuha) problem. gotta narrow it down. u made it too vague.
It’s neither hybe problem or illit problem. It’s be:lift problem for NOT TRAINING THEM WELL.
Nor*
bro even yujin has been getting shit recently just go watch her performance of im so stupid in love with max. And eunchae is also not controversy free since shes very unstable when singing and performing 😭@snowboardeater
You know they're Kpop BIG 3 company, idk about BIG 4 anymore, no effort
Maybe if Knetz actually voted for groups based off talent instead, this wouldnt be happening. I mean you have groups out there with good music and talent, and yet the Korean public chooses the groups who offer more visuals than talent. People werent lying when they said visuals will get you far in the entertainment industry.
Or maybe they voted for them bc they like the song(I'm not talking about live) but the song and their mini album was different and good.
K netz just care about visuals and song. That’s all. K-pop doesn’t need a good vocalist anymore to be a K-pop idol.
Istg I saw your pfp and thought "Huh when did I write this" 😂😭 also found you
@@Pabolandatiny LOL THIS IS THE 3RD TIME WE SAW EACH OTHER IN YT COMMENTS 😂
@@IcedAssassin atp I'll just give you a sub😂
god save minju she is so talented I feel bad for her
minju and yunah deserve better honestly
Yg
Yg. Baby
please don’t act like just because some of them can’t sing as well as minju that they aren’t talented all of them had to be talented enough to debut.
Idols who can't sing?? What is even the point. Just be models/actresses or whatever other profession where they don't need to sing. How did they even debut like that, that's crazy
Ikr and i hate when people defend them like oh they improved and all... its their job to sing and be at least decent before debut.
It’s because they came from bigger companies. There are much more talented girl groups out there only that they where from the small complanies and we’re barely noticed
just don't listen to them. y'all are complaining over the fact they can't sing, but you are listening to them?
Not a fan of their group, but I do have ears. Their song is viral and it's everywhere. From this video, I can hear that they're not good singing live, which is a fail for an idol. Something I noticed about fans these days is that they don't care about actual skills anymore, a lot of fans care only about visuals. They even defend their beloved idol or idol group even when you can hear them singing/dancing bad or 'decent' (decent as in compared to the average person whose livelihood doesn't depend on singing and dancing. Hello, that's their job, they shouldn't simply be decent!)
The thing is, they should've been better than decent BEFORE debut. Company should also not have debuted them with their skills just at that level, but it's not like they can un-debut. So people SHOULD critique them (without death threats, that's too far) so they know what to work on. If they really cared about their craft, they would work hard to quickly improve to catch up to, and perhaps even surpass, the expectations people have of them. And that's all I have to say about that
@@ojealism thank you for saying this. There's literally people who have never had a day of vocal training and sound better. Like if you can't do your job, just be an actress
The 2nd girl actually wasn’t bad tho like Shes atleast stable
That's becuz she is a former yg trainee
Yg has trained her well
She's a former yg trainee, and she sounds that good because the others sound so bad
Yunah,iroha and minju(the second girl) are the only were stable
@@norrinamohd4906That's more than half of the group and I think Wonhee wasn't too bad as well. Moka just wasn't in her vocal range, so what are y'all hating on?
For ILLIT Hybe can buy awards and achievements but can't buy talent.Their stans can be proud of their fake achievements but can't proud of their talent, because they don't have it 💀. Now ILLIT Stans are gonna eat me for saying some facts😂
i agree with you
Absolute facts, kpop is srsly being ruined. Idols need to be able to sing live, its LITERALLY their job and what they do. I'm so dissapointed by this encore
I can somehow quite understand Min Heejin's complains (although I'm in no one's side)
Newjeans still sing better than Le Sserafim and IILIT combined when Sakura literally debuted for the 3rd time and Yunjin has taken part in a few reality shows and IILIT was formed through a reality show
Spitting facts ✅😂
Yum yum
Minju's vocals are perfectt ❤️🔥love her
illit was from a show to prove that that they have stable vocals. favoritism in runext is kinda crazy gang. i only minju and yunah have hope 🤷🏻♀️
Moka in RUN sings good.
@@ZaNC4847 yeah she can sing so well too but the problem is she’s probably tone deaf. same with sakura. they can’t sing unless they hear themselves. like umm for example when moka covered her ears for one of the encores. she sounded way better when she didn’t. and that is because when you cover one of your ears, it allows you to hear yourself better. ykkk.
Idk how tf they won an award
Payola
Because the song is so good
I don't like the members or their voices but I can't disagree that this song is a bop and the rest is Hybe's 💵💵
because it's hybe.
Magnetic was charting better than any other song
@@fullsunn_kissedIt's not
Just see Class:Y and UNIS, their live is incredible
EXACTLY!!! Unis literally has a member born in 2011 that can sing pretty damn well so these girls have no excuse honestly.
Who voted them in R U next??? U vote them because their visual and now you blame them because they can't sing?? This is why u should wise when you vote them.
Nah I remember r u next the members were not voted for they were picked by the producers I mean jiwoo was the most voted but she didn't make it except for wonhee idk how ppl voted for her?
Minju, Jiwoo, Chanelle, Jeemin, Yunah and Youngseo were the most popular, what u talking about? Wonhee was voted by the korean public and the others were chosen by the producers.
@@OnceUBellieve Those names that you mentioned do not deserve to debut because of their appearance. Although they're talented, what's the point of having talent if you're not attractive?😂😂
@@renejuntababa4706 you're trolling.
@@OnceUBellieve Truth hurts
There is a reason why the Big3 aka Sm, Jyp and Yg have been relevant even after decades and have produced high quality legends after legends.
There is no shortcut to longevity and the big3 have dedicated years and years of time, hardwork, creativity and originality into their artists and still do.
This 2 days old company who lacks any creativity of their own can only go so far before they collapse and their greed will be the biggest reason for their downfall as we can see what's happening with them.
That's why is the Big3 not the Big4 ... I've always said it !
Agreed
Yess
It doesn't change anything if you've always said it. Hybe is still really successful, they literally have Bts
@@K-pop_Sim yeah so ? So what if they have BTS ? What's your point ? Is fame more important than talent and legacy in Kpop !?
Hybe just proved lately that the other 3 companies are still better even if they are the richest in the industry 🤦♀️
@@nouhedg4035 My point is that they're still a big company, no matter how they train their idols
I don't know should I laugh or cry. It's pathetic and tragic at the same time... I thought that they were chosen for the group based on their vocal and dancing skills. But apparently Hybe chose the prettiest faces, thinking that the rest of the work would be done by producers or sound engineers... Who allowed this to happen? Did anyone think that they would later have to face criticism personally? it's cruel that for profit Hybe take advantage of these poor girls who just wanted to come true their dreams, but are not ready for debut at all It's sad to watch
very true and very sad for the girls..
that's why I only stan UNIS and NEWJEANs for this 5th gen idols.
save Minju frm the gp lol
ILLIT simplemente son unas chicas muy talentosas
What's worst is the song is not even hard. No high note..nothing special even a child can sing it properly.
I cant see new jeans in them I see lesserafim.
FR it is not a hard song compared to some other kpop songs
Look like newjeans sound like lesserafim.
Maybe it's not hard for u, but for someone else, it might not be their vocal range. Try to listen to Moka singing high notes
@@ojealismCan y'all stop bringing other groups into everything?
The girl with the bangs is the inly one that can sing
Yunah and minju u mean
Tho iroha also improved kinda
@@dilekminatuysuz4243 Minju
But aren’t Idols supposed to be Singers, therefore, they should at least know how to sing properly. This is bad even whilst standing still.
Singers who can't sing....
What more do i need to say
Yunah and Minju are amazing as they are former yg trainee's but Wonhee and Iroha are okay, they aren't so bad, Moka is the only one who needs improvement
frfr
Shameful idols.. They can still smile while terrorizing our ears.. Hahahaha
The first one, had me like WTF with that face. She's about to cry, and doing her best to look cute but sound hilarious 🤣🤣🤣
Minju and yunah was always SO GOOD!
Iroha really improved need a little more training but nice.
The others.. sad what Hybe does to these girls
Korean people vote for the visual than quality and talent
This doesn't they are more good looking than other groups but there is just nothing on them but the visual
I think its the company
Minju still ate tho 😭.HYBE GIVe THEM TRAINING SHE CARRYING THE WHOLE GROUP LMAO 😭😭
The fact that Minju and Yunah have good stable vocals but they aren’t getting recognised for that instead they are known for bad live vocals, I feel so bad for them
Moka💀😫 I can’t with her weird voice tone
2/5 memebers r obviously good but i think they must be given some songs that matches their voices not baby like song like this ,I've watched the " r u next?" Performances, and hybe made a big mistake by debuting yunnah and minju in this group , they must've been debuted with chanelle and joo and the other girl (forgot her name) in more mature concept,
Moka ,and iroha aren't that bad according to the "r u next?" Performances but they need more practice and another concept as well,
Hybe choose a concept for wonhee and put the other girls in it .
It's als undeniable that it's k fans fault from the beginning cs they vote this lineup instead of some talented onces.
Minju and yunah are so good tho
Thats why i love Unis they have a lot good singer in thier line up. That can sing in Live
Illit cannot sing live.😂😂😂
Edit: did i start a fight?
One of them can
If you see run, all of them can sing well actually. You don't expect the juries to simply pick up bad contestants, do you?
Or you just illit hater because they can sing and you don't like that...
@@moonlightpaw5868yeah no, you’re actually delulu if you think they’re anywhere near other groups that can actually sing. Only 2 members are somewhat stable
Oh don't cry. They can sing
Minju: 💗
Yunah: 💖
Wonhee: 👍
Iroha: 😐👀
Moka: Definitely not her vocal range, but the improvement is kinda nice
And honestly, can y'all give them a break? They've been getting hate since their debut , while some of the members don't deserve criticism at all. And I said criticism, because what are y'all doing is HATING, and do you really have to add another comment that's about the same fuckin thing like every other? Once, Moka said that the comments don't bother her that much, but they do at the stage when she remembers them. Also, Wonhee was literally reading hate comments on their live trying not to cry. THIS AMOUNT OF HATE IS CROSSING THE LINE.
Moka's voice 🥲🥲 make them so bad
Go tell your mom
Bad singers is not a new phenomenon in KPOP. The thing is, even when the members can't really sing they still contribute something to the group. I look at ILLIT and have no idea what's the purpose of this group. They don't stand out in dance, performance, rap, personalities, or even the super shallow visuals. Def. not vocals.
They don't need to be all at Minju(that one strong singer) 's level but Moka is soooo random... like WHY IS SHE EVEN THERE. She is literally like the blonde girl from les sserim. Go be actresses....
MINGU AND YUNAH ARE CARING THE GROUP 🔥🔥🔥🙏🏾
That's why I prefer Babymonster
Thank you to YG who has trained Minju very well❤
But why yg not debut minju
I noticed that Yunnah struggled a bit with her low part, then what’s the problem to give did part to Moka that can really beautifully sing low range songs (u can hear it from Disco with JYP). In addition to that in Magnetic they gave her parts with higher tone and again what’s the problem of giving this part to Yunnah who is better at vocal and can handle higher range? Just swipe their parts
This is why big 3 r yg, sm n jyp and not hybe.. hence proved...
Wow illit is so cool. They can sing😍😍😍😘😘😘
Well, you never know what they are going through. Their professional lives are good, they might as well be tired rn. Think b4 you criticize.
Minju is actually good and also wonhee but i feel like wonhee needs bit more training.
Its always netz bc that is what netz do
Minju is just carrying the group 💀
Bro minju carried
Well Knets where the ones voting for them in R u next when perfectly we could have Channel, Jiwooo, Youngseo and Jeemin the talent and visual was there but I think they were “to old” for Koreans 🤣😂
I wish red velvet was popular still.
They have their next comeback soon! Lets give them love and show SM we need talented girls like them still!
WOHOOOOO THEY ARE SO PRETTY WITH NO TALENT WHATSOEVER
Hybe should stick to talent instead of copying ideas from others
Honestly it's just Moka 😭 she really can't sing and they NEED to put her in lessons asap cuz she cannot be an idol with this level of vocals 💀
Is just funny how they sing like that and still getting Awards it just goes to show that everything is Purchased by the companies for this new gen lol
To be honest... I am not a big fan of this group but no one deservs to be told that way.... Those girls are young just give them time they will improve..... So if anyone don't like their songs then just ignore them and stop sending hate or negative messages...
I mean its okay except for mokaaa😅
MINJI be eating all the cd’s in ILLIT
If ILLIT would have a concert and they’re charging a huge amount of price per ticket. I wouldn’t go at all if they’re not really singing live. It is just a waste of money for a lip sync group.
No doubt that they’re cute girls. But I will not waste my money just for cuteness. I could just watch them on RUclips.
nobody ask
yunah and minju carrying as always (iroha had some major improvement tho!!!)
dang! its me singing in smule
too bad these girls only got the awards because their company is rich... why can't they focus more on the girl's development???
look at UNIS and compare them.
Also, they just proved what 2nd gen artists always comment, "5th gen idols are lazy artists"
being an illit defender is so tiring but i will not stop. i promise yall if they didn't make wonhee the entire concept this would've never happened
What happend with hybe😂😂
But then you look at xg. Super solid
Haha some of the girls started dancing while singing so they can hide and have a reason if there voice crack
Iroha and Minju are the only one who can sing. Yunah maybe can be saved too.
Because of some similarities they have to newjeans (im not saying copy just similarity) i thought they will be also similar to performance but ig not and im comparing it to 2022 newjeans not to today, newjeans today are even better.
They do sound better thoo😊
The fact that they are dancing around for an excuse of hiding how untalented they are tho🤣
If you want to have an opinion, you should've at least watched RUN. Moka sings very well in there. Almost all of them sings well too.
The judgers are people from around the world and selected judges, are you saying that they can't even do their job well?
It could be an inside job. You never know. Also...if Moka is encouraged to sing with her voice naturally, it would be better.
This song is too low for them, you can literally hear Yunah singing quietly to reach those low notes. They can sing, Hybe also isn’t in charge of training them, BeLift Lab is
Its is the problem of source music not hybe if that was the case new jeans never could get a stable voice,but they are professional. So source music have to take care of this
Okay, Iroha and Wonhee are still kids, but what about Moka's voice? Minju and Yuna sing average, I think the song itself is not sung according to their voice range. The concept is too childish, it will obviously be difficult for adult members to sing such songs. (p.s: i am not a hater of illit, i love them💗)
Serious question-the first girl who sang in this clip, is her voice naturally sounded cute like chipmunk voice or she is just made to sing like that to go with the cutesy flow of the song.
Coz ive noticed that NJ members are all young and cute too but they didnt use "cute" voice when singing, as in they naturally sing using a natural tone of voice.
Im not a fan of both (or cutesy genre) but cant help comparing since both groups have a very similar concept
This is sad how are they winning smh
The minju or minji girl was the only one in that group will pass as a singer, she has beautiful and serene tone that fit into their concept, anyway there's always a room for improvement i hope the other girls realize what they're lacking as an so called "idol".
Illit can sing, it’s just that the song isn’t suited for them.
Tbh its minju yunah and wonhee who can actually sing
Be thankful they are singing live like most idols lipsync nowadays
This is not just one bad day because it’s becoming redundant, they can’t sing live. They are studio singers! K-pop as a whole should not debut idols who are not ready to sing live, it’s embarrassing! If this continues they will loose their popularity internationally. It will be sad for the previous idols like BTS who paved the way for them.
Are they in a karaoke bar?! Wtf you call these idols?! Hybe are rushing in mass production of idols just using their fame & money and those fans just blindly worshiping them just because they are from hybe.. annoying af 🙄
I think a good portion of it is that the girls just aren’t in the right range too. HYBE seems to value style and concept over the ability for the girls to naturally sing the range of the notes. It’s a problem I’ve noticed with leseraffim too. They seem to flat/have trouble reaching most of the lower register. They have a lot more trouble singing magnetic than lucky girl syndrome. Of course, they can do with more breathing work (which is a must) and vocal colour training too but if you’re uncomfortable with the notes themselves, it won’t help a lot. You will still be off key or your voice might tremble. If you have a group of sopranos, don’t make them reach lower second soprano notes without adequate training especially if they are moving around a ton and show an inability to get in that range. It must be hard for the girls too. They don’t deserve to get dragged. I just hope their agency puts the work in to have them be extra skilled and confident for their comeback.
It's the companies fault, their concept was supposed to be girl crush but they changed it to cute because they wanted Wonhee to stand out the most.
the fact that the only girl in illit with stable vocals is an ex-trainee of YG (im talking abt minju)
Guys can we stop hating on iilit and hate on hybe number 1 they don't even fit cute concept they fit in like girl crush concept
Alright, but during the show 'R U Next,' they had to sing different songs with different concepts. And they managed it well. So what happened to them now?
I mean, Yuna and Minju, who suit the girl crush concept too, can sing songs with a cute concept. So why can't the others?
@@user-ip2rl8gf6k no u don't get it girl like u seen the vocals when they sing like more girl crush concept there voice like doesn't Crack
@@user-ip2rl8gf6k they actually have good vocals that's why minju used to be a ex yg trainer and yunah she already had good vocals
It good but wohnne need to stop jumping a litte and dont be scared
I was wondering why their technique is like that. Their tone is good, but their technique in singing doesnt bring out the best in them.
It’s not that bad honestly ofc not good but they don’t deserve this much of hate
But at least you can tell their trying their best
It is the mistake of hybe they can't handle them and that's why they don't help them ❤
Minju did well, thats about it
y'all, have you guys seen Tomboy Moka, Feel Special Moka, Attention Moka and R u next Moka?? Their probably not comfortable with the range that they are singing, they sound so much better in Lucky Girl Syndrome than in Magnetic, pls stop throwing hate to the girls.
While I don’t condone hate, you do have to realize RU Next performances aren’t very accurate. They were definitely autotuned and/or gone through post production.
It doesn’t help that they’re compared to Babymonster who is one of the best live vocal groups we’ve seen in a very long time… Bad timing for this to happen to Illit 😢
I dont see any wins from babymonster lol
@@lucasdomingues849 I never said Illit weren’t popular. I love Magnetic! Was just commenting on their live vocals in that encore. Hope this helps :)
@@lucasdomingues849 wins dont equate to being talented though, for sure u know that
Youngseo is lucky that she didnt debut becuz if she did she would get hate train.
Would she? Minju is part of the group but she’s avoiding most of the hate because she can actually sing decently.
@@kpopnimation Mhm
I mean, moka has an Amazing stage presence and good dance but honestly She can't sing
Nro i think they improve alot 😅
Hybe song is good but the girl group vocal are literally 😂
Hybe more produce underage yet untalented idols..shame
Moka is the only one that sings teeeerrible
i think minju and iroha sing properly
WHY DID THEY EVEN DEBUT. 🤡🤡🤡
Wonhee just wanted to be cute and not to sing and dance
it sounds pretty bad, I feel sorry for them