John Tory Knew Something
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 фев 2023
- There is an old story about Toronto’s political power that is showing its age. Was the last maneuver of Toronto's mayor carefully calculated? Of course, he's was super strong mayor John Tory!
Extra Content: / paigesaunders
Mastodon: masto.canadiancivil.com/@paige
Peertube: video.canadiancivil.com/a/paige
Get On The Fediverse! fedihost.co/
________________
References & Sources
________________
[1] www.ola.org/en/legislative-bu...
[2] www.ola.org/en/legislative-bu...
[3] www.cp24.com/news/tory-uses-s...
[4] www.toronto.ca/news/bill-3-st... “Choose to appoint the municipality’s chief administrative officer”
[5] toronto.ctvnews.ca/ontario-pa...
[6] www.toronto.ca/city-governmen...
[7] docs.google.com/spreadsheets/...
[8] www.toronto.ca/city-governmen... (Smallest 94.580)
[9] www.toronto.ca/city-governmen... (Largest 129,080)
[10] open.toronto.ca/dataset/ward-...
[11] www.toronto.ca/city-governmen...
[12] toronto.citynews.ca/2022/12/0...
[13] • 2022-12-05 Members’ St...
[14] • Why are cities creatur...
[15] www.ontario.ca/laws/statute/0...
[16] www.thestar.com/news/gta/2017...
[17] docs.google.com/spreadsheets/... Single Detached 32.23% + Semi Detached 9.76 = %41.99
[18] docs.google.com/spreadsheets/... Apartment in a building that has five or more storeys = 12.13%
[19] en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mel_Las...
[20] www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toront...
[21] • Bad Boy NOBODY! (1992)
[22] • Bad Boy Mel Lastman Bi...
[23] • Uncensored video: Tor...
[24] • The Rob Ford Story - t... • The Rob Ford Story - t...
[25] www.theglobeandmail.com/news/... John A Tory
[26] en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_A.....
[27] www.theglobeandmail.com/news/... John S. D. Tory
[28] / johnadtory
[29] • Toronto councillors tu...
[30] docs.google.com/spreadsheets/... (41.99%, 45.54%, 12.13%)
[31] docs.google.com/spreadsheets/... 46.74%
[32] docs.google.com/spreadsheets/... 17,959 vs 16,912. Apartment includes everything over row house.
[33] usa.streetsblog.org/wp-conten...
[34] toronto.citynews.ca/2022/12/0...
[35] • Video & • Video
[36] www.theglobeandmail.com/canad...
[37] www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toront...
[38] storeys.com/john-tory-toronto...
[39] edmontonjournal.com/news/loca...
[40] institute.smartprosperity.ca/... (p19) “When breaking the GTAH data down by census division, we see that only one of the six communities (Toronto) did the 2021 housing stock forecast in 2020 exceed that in 2012, as shown by Figure 6.“
It's crazy how chaotic Toronto is these days, it's nice to see someone do a run down like this and actually look at what's going on.
Totally ominous
I totally agree!
lol mckinsey
HAAIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII
Damn Paige, your journalism is putting the Canadian news networks to shame. Well done sir!!!
Proportional representation... housing policy... esoteric mid-century television... this ticks a lot of boxes on my Paige bingo card.
Great video again; keep up the good work
How do you "only" have 10k subscribers. Your content and its production value puts you in the same league as those with millions of subs. Im just waiting for the moment when the youtube algorithm catches on and you start rocketing. Top stuff
I'm pretty lucky to just enjoy making these, if I took off it would just be a pleasant surprise at this point.
Couldn't agree more
careful what you wish for. Fame comes with a hivemind.
This is part 2 of a 4 part series looking at the legislative changes in Ontario. It starts here: ruclips.net/video/YdXSiScEmNo/видео.html
The next one is here: ruclips.net/video/V-Jr7-C42Fw/видео.html
I became quite fond of Tory while putting this together, I hope that the next mayor picks up the torch and continues.
Did you move to Toronto?
@@PoliticalWeekly no, I like Toronto but I love Montreal
lets go. Excited to see the rest of the series. You should also look into bill 23 i think that MPP Mike Shrier proposed to make 4 story housing as of right province wise and has been ignored by most media sadly.
While I wasn't a fan of Tory he did draft a great housing bill quickly into his new term which makes me sad now as to what the faith of this city is going to become now that he is gone.
Whoops I made a mistake in my comment. Seeings your video on bill 23, My last comment I meant bill 44 and 45 that was proposed by Mike has been under the radar. It's set to end exclusionary zoning province-wide, allow multiplexes of 4 units and 4 stories as of right everywhere and permit 6-11 story buildings on every major road. Obviously I haven't read the bill in detail so I would like to hear your take on it.
@@PoliticalWeekly He only came to Toronto to make his video in front of city hall and the Ontario parliament building.
Thanks for teaching this US American so much about Canadian politics and housing reform efforts and doing it in a fun and quirky way. You really are good at this.
I remember having CP24 in the background in the morning while staying at a hotel and John Tory literally attended and gave speeches at three different cultural events in three different places in the city all before noon lol While Rob Ford was the customer service mayor (personally returning phone calls to indiviudal constituents) John Tory was the community outreach mayor attending any and all cultural and city events
Yeah, I've probably watched 20 hours of him Torying around town at this point and he fundamentally "did his job" of representing the city very well. If no other scandalous news hits, I get the sense that breaking that fundamental principle and the potential for a rolling cloud of bad representation is what prompted him to quit.
@@PaigeMTL Yeah and he was surprisingly on top of his brief. His politics and personal failings aside he always answered questions (including hosting a call-in show once a month pre-pandemic) and was able to give surprisingly detailed responses. He was like former British PM David Cameron in Prime Minister's Questions that way (again, despite the politics) but I think Toronto is ready to move on from someone (as you rightfully point out) was old Toronto establishment personified (including having a paid position on Rogers Communications). At least that's one nepo-baby down (there's still Ford and Trudeau lol)
@@kiroolioneaver8532 im really afraid that we might get Michael Ford planted as mayor by Doug Ford in order to take control of the city :/
@@Amir-jn5mo I think that may be to naked of a power grab move by Dougie and may feed into the conspiracy that he was behind the leaking of the Ford affair (though if the long-standing rumours are to be believed, dude shouldn't be throwing rocks in a house made of glass lol). I think if Michael Thompson hadn't had his own "improprities" to deal with, he probably would've been the backed candidate. I was surprised they didn't get a Ford to run in Ward 2-Etobicoke North during the last municipal election. You'd have thunk that they wouldn't let Rob's seat fall into non-Ford hands lol
Wow absolutely fantastic, not only the script but also the editing was on point!
How did you get this video released do quickly? The timing is perfect!
Man, it's trippy enough seeing you over here in Toronto at all, and then I watch footage of you flying a drone in the parkette on my street lmao
Thank you. Liked and subscribed
I’m so happy to see where Toronto is headed. It gives me hope that someday, I too can afford an appartment
I'm looking forward to a follow-up to this about Olivia Chow. Chances are she won't be involved with a scandal with a mistress. We never know. But what will get done with her as mayor?
Holy shit man the editing on this video is fantastic
I know next to nothing about Canadian politics or politicians but can't stop laughing at the opening montage ... universally relevant.
That's how I felt too. This is probably my favourite of all his videos to date. Hilariously put together.
well this is timed well
What a cool channel. Great commentaries on the political bs.
Loved the video. I really agree that it's not up to toronto to fix the housing problem. I think the issue is really dependent on the suburbs to accommodate much more density. Which means a stronger (and smarter) premier. The province needs to realize that infrastructure is needed to not just support the growth and the rate of growth, but to create better incentives to housing development, e.g. less parking, better parks, etc. Transit projects need to be based on need, not political maneuvering.
I always imagined Dougie gave Tory strong mayor powers on the hopes that he would basically run densification for him. Meanwhile in places like York Region, Dougie is firing MZOs at developments like RHC that are significantly more ambitious than what Richmond Hill is proposing.
At least they’re doing something. the NDP’s housing plan was good on feels but they weren’t making the actual policy changes we need and that is rapid densification to solve this crisis.
I love your channel especially your content on REM. I’m hyped you did a video on Toronto since I live here hahahah. Would love to see you do a video on crosstown and the many walkable neighbourhoods in the city, that would be so cool! Also looking forward to some more REM videos!
Awesome video, you have a new subscriber. I like to be well informed of all the corruption in Municipal Government. Federal and Provincial. Thank you.
Man yea.. I live in Melbourne (Victoria, Australia) where all the major infrastructure projects and other policies are mostly controlled by the state government. I didn't realise how much a good thing that was since I took it for granted
wow this video came out fast
Great video. Leave it to a Kiwi transplant to explain the intricacies of provincial-municipal relations to Canadians. Thanks for bringing focus to this waiting time bomb should a Rob Ford redux take power.
One of your best videos.... Deserves more antention
Paige "Johhny Harris" Saunders
Great video, excellent breakdown of the history and political dynamics. Why are there so many right wing nuts in the comment section though 😬
Great video, and I agree while Toronto can help in the housing crisis, it probably is still too small to solve it, that can only happen through the province or if the other municipalities in the GTA come to their senses
I knew the nimbys weren't going to give up easily they have holded Toronto hostage for decades and they're not about to give up easily, not a fan of Ford but he maybe next with the proposal he has passed
IMO that's speculation about the nimbys. We don't know for sure at this point what the motives are of the tipster. There is opposition to other aspects of Tory's politics while there seems to be little public opposition on housing.
Mel Lastman was more than a furniture salesman. He was the mayor of North York for many, many years before the burbs got sucked into the "amalgamation" .
Ok wtf, this video needs 1million views.
I didn't know John Tory was going to upzone the Single Family neighborhoods. It's kind of a shame he's stepping down then, right? Unless the next mayor is even better. Yes, the Province needs to remove most zoning ability from local jurisdictions. But just upzoning all of Toronto would go a hell of a long way.
it will happen, even if the next mayor doesnt set it as a priority, they can only slow it down not stop it, the demographics are just heavily against single family zoning in the city of Toronto, since every year the share of people living in single family homes goes down
Will the new mayor be gender and carbon neutral?
Commenting for algo. Great video again, Paige!
This is an amazing video
Good riddance! Toronto's infrastructure and crime has gotten much worse during his time as Mayor.
News from the future: the 66th mayor of the City of Toronto is Olivia Chow. She has named housing, transit, and services as her priority.
Having studied city planning here in Toronto the biggest thing I learned from this video was that not only the "WHO'S BETTER THAN BADBOOY? NOOOOBOOODY" was the owner and that it was a local business. For some reason I always assumed it was American. Living in York region the rate is densification is definitely increasing compared to when I was growing up. 10,000 units to be built across the street from me.
you never nwondered why the mayor of Toronto / North York would show up on so many bad boys commercials
@@TheTroyc1982 grew up out in the burbs so i didnt really care about what actually happens in the city until I had to study it for university.
Your videos are fantastic.
Political ambitions notwithstanding, where I disagree with you is that a single actor with a lot of conviction who “controls” the most important city in the region could very well have set off a chain reaction after some years of tangible results.
To bake a good load of bread, sometimes you have to add something that smells awful before it can rise into something we can all eat.
Overdose awareness day... How do you celebrate that? Overdose on fentanyl? Some people celebrate that everyday, along with defecate-on-the-street day.
And what exactly did John Tory know, it certainly wasn't about how to run a city, or about city planning or about people in general. It was only about how to wield power over people and on how to retain and take advantage of power. Certainly hope that his replacement will be a fiscal conservative.
Rob Ford was good even though he had a drug problem lol.
@@leadnsteel1428: Rob at least was a people's mayor, John Tory was nothing but a political hack, Conservative, Liberal and NDP'er when the opportunity arose. Very weal political ethics. He didn't believe in cyclists having more power than car owner's on streets or roads. He didn't believe in multi-billion dollar glorified streetcars (the LRT)
Does this mean you've moved to Toronto?
I miss David Miller
I'm so glad Tory's gone. I've never seen anyone who loves the sound of his own voice more. During the COVID grift he sanctimoniously virtue signaled at length and delighted in the imposition of illegal and unwarranted restrictions. Hopefully, I'll never hear from him again.
Great video BTW.
Well said !
You're correct on all point you made.
hey, you guys want to do juneteenth too? i mean it's about texas but how trolling would that be?
So what's coming that he wants to get out of the way of?
Well he just resigned the day before this was posted due to an affair scandal so anything he wanted to get in the way of is barrelling forward while he’s out for the count
Great video! Just a side note, I can't access the Google Docs/Sheets in your References and Sources, you haven't made the sharing option open to the public. For example Reference 17 and 18.
Impressive video - I don't know much about Toronto but that is clear concise and well, impressive. 'A city hamstrung by its Premier' seems to be a common pattern in Canada...vive le Montréal libre, I say. Can we get a better candidate to say it than Balarama Dingdong though?
I bet Ford will severely regret his strong mayor bill when it's Olivia Chow, God I can't wait
that actor driving miss daisy said what black month day and he got upset bec that is the thing that divides black and white and there is no discrimination if you do not talk about it
Have you looked into regional government? Something similar to the regional municipalities, but covering the whole region...something similar to Metro Toronto prior to amalgamation.
Personally I don't think Queens Park is equipped to act as regional government for the GTA which is effectively what they are today.
Yes, found that fascinating while I was in Toronto because I actually stay in Hamilton when I go to visit which means you really notice the dynamic. Although Montreal is home, I hope I can get back to Toronto every once and a while to make a video.
@@PaigeMTL
Idk if you have the time to read a book on the topic. But there's a couple good ones "Governing Toronto: Bringing Back the City that Worked" by Alan Redwood, and "The Shape of the Suburbs: Understanding Toronto's Sprawl" by John Sewell.
Toronto's political organizational history is truly fascinating and I think a video dedicated to it would be a boon for urbanist RUclips.
Especially considering the present organization has only existed since basically 2000. And it *just so happens* a lot of the dysfunction of our municipalities has come about after that point.
Regional government is basically gutted as of Bill 23... no more elected regional chairs and planning is all centralized at Queen's Park...
@@gfox5237 That's Alan Redway, not Redwood.
Cue John Tory being appointed as head of the Greenbelt Council to replace Hazel McCallion (Rest in Sprawl).
Super weird that your conclusion is MORE STRONGMAN PREMIERS & TOP DOWN PLANNING though.
Curieux que vous ayez changé les mots que j'ai utilisés
@@PaigeMTL Sorry if I misunderstood but was the last sentence in your video a joke? "We don't need strong mayors, we need strong premiers." [Because mayors don't have the power to change zoning rules & the province is the level that can change the rules to allow density.]
C'est un jeu de mots
@@PaigeMTL Evidement je ne comprends pas. Merci d’avoir repondu.
Tory has never been more than a VERY fast talking vacuous huckster. He has presided over the DECLINE of Toronto from day one.
Yes , and why did Tory REALLY quit? Surely it wasn't over an affair with a staffer?
Maybe he was being blackmailed over something, and it was over some events from the 70's which have once again, come to light. I saw a great discussion on that just yesterday on Reddit. It had to do with Jack Layton, amongst other things.
Love you Buddy.......it's ok. Work it out.
I will argue that Mayor David Miller who held two terms and desperately begged for Strong Mayoral Powers but kept being shut down by the councillors as a counter example. Furthermore, as much as one may dislike Tory's housing policies, it is essential to recognized there were numerous times he tried to expand housing rights but was shot down by councillors who represent NIMBY voters and suburban areas. It got to the point where Mayor Tory was forced to water down his budgets due to the brutality of the councillors.
I will also argue that mayoral powers are weakened significantly because of the lack of strong powers which forces them to work with everyone and since there are more suburban councillors, it prevents them from taking on more aggressive housing issues. This is especially exemplified by the fact that a lot of suburban councillors receive less votes and to be honest, only get votes from NIMBYs as they are the most vocal and likely to vote in a municipal election.
I am not a Ford fan and do not claim to be, but it is clear to me that we need a mayor to have strong powers to ensure that NIMBY councillors can be steam rolled, especially as by the nature of the job the councillors are more likely to be NIMBYs
If he only had " I banged the secretary day"he'd still have his job.
Wow, you win the Comments section
John Tory was brought down by the Curse of Dundas Street!!! He tried to rename it and it bit back and forced him out. Olivia Chow decided not to rename it for that reason and just rename Dundas Square after some Ghanaian slave-traders (her favorite people) but Dundas Street will get her too!!! Dundas Street is the "Main Street" of my life and the roughest, toughest, meanest critters in Toronto traditionally lived along it and if you mess with it you die!!! Don't mess with Dundas Street!!!
It's so crazy to me that Toronto covers an area about 50% larger than Montreal, with about 60% more people, but they have 25 councillors, and Montreal have 65 plus another 38 boroughs councillors, for a total of 103. I don't know if Toronto has the equivalent of Montreal's boroughs councillors but the difference is pretty staggering.
Doug ford cut Toronto council seats by half
Rob ford was the best mayor the city has ever had. We all know it.
Sex is more important than running Toronto city
Before you proffer 'proportional representation' as a panacea to 'improve' our politics, please take a look at the disfunctional governments in Israel and Germany. That's what you get with proportional representation!
I'm the 14th
It’s just starting Toronto,vote Turdy in again and see what happens,you’re just starting to feel what the rest of Canada has been feeling for the last 7 years.
Blake Acton would be good for Toronto. Hopefully he will get some airtime this time so people know who he is.
Strong Premiers? Sigh. Well, yeah, if the goal is to get movement. What worries me is direction. Do you want strong societies, or strong corporations. Strong corporations only require funding, not strong premiers. But if you want strong societies, you need a strong premier with a vision. Ford only seems like a corporate sellout. He's pretty strong at putting on strong airs of being "for the people." I don't get the impression that's who he is, though. And his statement against "lefty mayors" is kinda telling. Well, that and that he's a conservative. But that anti-lefty rhetoric is reminiscent of the MAGA platform south of the border.
Ford has the principles of a weathervane.
Vote for Gil!
Gil was a shill who was only interested in clawing up interest for his real job. He made up completely ridiculous proposals.
Chloe Brown is who was actually determined to push change
@@ThoughtSpirals well have fun having another mayor you don’t like, cuz he’s gonna win
Gil has good proposals but I seem his bothers record same platform and he has completely delayed subway projects in Bogota. If the Ford bothers teach me something is that that's always some truth in the family
Watch the provincial leader back a centre right mayoral candidate who will tack back to a nimby based agenda. But hopefully he over-tacks and doesn't sheet out so he heels over and capsizes.
Faith Goldy for mayor.