Eram ma'am. You have hit the nail on the head. Perfect analysis. We are moving to the 21st century & some people are trying their very best to take us back to the dark ages. Keep up your good work. God bless you & your work.
No need of assumptions lady. He clearly explained, he left because he didn't like this closeness with females. And he was not doing hajj or umrah. He answers ladies. But prophet sallallahu alaihi wasallam never took hand in hand bait from women. Never saw non mehram ladies inspite of being prophet.
First of all after puberty nobody is considered an orphan. Orphans are only those children who have yet not attained puberty. So they were not more orphans.
Islam emphasizes justice, fairness, and the importance of treating all individuals with respect and dignity, regardless of their background. Bias, prejudice, and discrimination are discouraged in Islamic teachings. In the Quran, Allah (SWT) instructs believers to be just and fair: Surah An-Nisa (4:135):
"يَا أَيُّهَا الَّذِينَ آمَنُوا كُونُوا قَوَّامِينَ بِالْقِسْطِ شُهَدَاءَ لِلَّهِ وَلَوْ عَلَى أَنفُسِكُمْ أَوِ الْوَالِدَيْنِ وَالْأَقْرَبِينَ ۚ إِن يَكُن غَنِيًّا أَوْ فَقِيرًا فَاللَّهُ أَوْلَى بِهِمَا ۚ فَلَا تَتَّبِعُوا الْهَوَى أَن تَعْدِلُوا ۚ وَإِن تَلْوُوا أَوْ تُعْرِضُوا فَإِنَّ اللَّهَ كَانَ بِمَا تَعْمَلُونَ خَبِيرًا" "O you who have believed, be persistently standing firm in justice, witnesses in justice, witnesses for Allah, even if it be against yourselves or parents and relatives. Whether one is rich or poor, Allah is more worthy of both. So follow not [personal] inclination, lest you not be just. And if you distort [your testimony] or refuse [to give it], then indeed Allah is Acquainted with what you do." Additionally, the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) emphasized the importance of equality among all people, regardless of their race or status. In his Farewell Sermon, he stated: Hadith (Sahih Muslim, Book 32, Hadith 6348): "All mankind is descended from Adam and Eve. An Arab has no superiority over a non-Arab, nor does a non-Arab have any superiority over an Arab; a white has no superiority over a black, nor does a black have any superiority over a white; none have superiority over another except by piety and good action." These teachings highlight that biases based on race, ethnicity, or social status are contrary to the principles of Islam, which advocates for equality and justice among all individuals.
What is your problem with Dr Naik not wanting to Free Mix with the opposite sex.? What if he does not shake hands with women? That is his belief and he is entitled to it, as long as it is not offensive.
I also respect your perspective and no doubt no one is perfect even if there is an islamic scholar.But the fact is ka jo bhi masla ho if he wasn't comfortable with giving shields to those girls this is totally okay I don't know why people are making it an issue. Secondly, you are totally wrong where you said ka free mixing is allowed.No,free mixing is not allowed In case of hajj, it is already mentioned that hajj was farz on woman when she has mehram with her so that even in free mixing no one can even come closer to her prophet SAW said ka aurat mehram ka baghair safar na kare or na hi mehram ka baghair iska pass koi ghair mard jaye... ,sahih bukhari 1763. And there are many examples. But on the other hand, there is alot of difference in that sahabaa's era and today's era full of temptation. Today there is free mixing everywhere but rather than promoting it we girls especially should maintan some distance jaha tak mumkin ho. Thanks
Iram u have no idea how much u have help me in searching for trúth about our deen I never thought I will actually find the way towards authentic Islam which is understandable with logic and reason and not only by u cannot question any thing about deen !! And Jo Gamdi sb ap na mujha da diya hain na is ka líya to I love uuuuu 🫶🫶🫶💕
What did you gether about Dr Zakir Nyeak behaviour and personality from this incident,is he a misognyst,or a strict believer of segregation of sex or he never wanted these girls to be there in the first place.He should himself explain this to dispel any misconceiving.
Look what he did is none of your business, But if he Preaches Strict teaching and then calls it Farz and too in Pakistan's sponsored events... Then you can disagree otherwise GROW UP
Basically this is what going on in this era, back then only Hazrat Muhammad has a right to interpret words of Allah and now every one is ready to interpretate Holy words as per their own feasibility and understanding and people are believing them with blind eyes and closed minds and thats the very reason Islam has splitted further to many sub sects. What you are explaining making sense to only those people who can read in between the lines of scipture. Keep up the good work
Be wary, this lady is doing self study, which is very very dangerous. If wouldn’t trust her to do a brain surgery on you, why are you taking Islam from her! Best thing is to find genuine scholars.
Well said Erum Saeed ! When I watched the video I immediately got it .. unfortunately it was pure absence of wisdom and courage at Dr.sab's end .. If he was told to behave like that he could've resisted and he could've empathised with the young "Orphan"girls who were looking at him as fatherly figure .... Imagine your Father looking at you with some other emotion ?? It is made complicated by design ... We have been slow poisoned over time about the age of Ayesha r.a ..i don't know how are many of our ulemas going to face RasoolAllah on the day of Qiyamah ... for made up stories On another occasion Dr.sab called a matric student "sister'' when it should've been "daughter" ... We have serious kahturRijaal ... Our men see women in us regardless of age instead of an orphan , or sister or daughters ... Our daughters like Dr.Afia is a proof that we are Fatherless ! Our famous leader is said to be womaniser..... What a nation !! 😢
ارم آپ بہت اچھا کام کر رہی ہیں جو اسلامی جمہوریہ پاکستان میں ممکن نہیں تھا ۔آپکی وڈیو سن کر مجھے دو سال پہلے کا ایک واقع یاد آ گیا ۔ہم میاں بیوی عمرہ کرنے گئے اور مسجد نبوی سے باہر آ رہے تھے تو میری نظر ایک نوجوان جوڑے پر پڑی جو ایک بینچ پر بیٹھے بغلگیر ہو رہے تھے ۔مجھے دیکھ کر بہت خوشی ہوئی اور اپنی بیوی کو کہا کہ نہ جانے بیچارے کس گھٹن کے ماحول سے آئے ہوں گے اور یہاں موقع پا کر پیار محبت کا اظہار کر رہے ہیں ۔زیادہ خوشی اس وجہ سے ہوئی کہ کوئ ان پر احتراز نہیں کر رہا تھا ۔میں ذاکر نائک کو ایک اچھا طوطا سمجھتا ہوں ۔سکالر نہیں
Erum I am so happy that you are challenging so called scholars with full knowledge , research and confidence . I saw your video with Sitara Akram . It was eye opening . Later I watched all her videos on hijab . We need more women scholars . Men scholars only suppress women and talk only on their clothes . Thank God I was brought up in a modest home and have all the facilities to do what ever I wanted to do . Sadly as I grew up I saw the regression in our society . Women are badly affected and impacted by this system . You are now one of few women who are torch bearer to show right path to young women . Instead of following the western agenda listen to these women scholars and follow Islam in a better way.
If you want to watch genuine sincere female scholars, watch Dr. Haifa Younis, Yasmeen Mogahed and the likes who have studied Islam. Beware of choosing “ wannabe scholars” who begin their education by challenging rather than learning.
@@user1-user-0421Eram doesn't say that she is a scholar. Moreover, if someone is not scholar it doesn't mean that they are always wrong, you have to look at their sincerity.
With due respect miss Erum those were not very young girls. I hope you have seen that video properly and most of them are teenagers. This is quite absurd to make an islamic scholar give awards to girls now be it orphans or whatever. The organisers are to blame too. Islamic scholars are there to give a sermon or lecture not to deliver awards. What he did is 100% according to islamic preachings. It is not recommended for a male to do this. Now you argue that the kids were wearing hijab and scarves. By the way doesn't matter if those teenager kids were wearing hijab or not. Females are females. I wonder how you are comparing equaity with mixing of grnders. Do you mean giving awards to females by a male is a matter of equity and human rights. I would be surprised at your interpretation of things. No matter they were their daughters age. They were not kids. How can you question about hajj. Do you know we don't interact with any females there. Direct interaction is another story. Prophets interacted with females to answer their problems and questions that's what do zakir naik does but those women are not in the same vicinity. If we don't follow any islamic law we should not at least criticize. Wow you saud the rank of orphans what a brilliant way of comparing two different categories. The more the level of faith the more strictly you follow Allah's commandments. A pious man will try to avoid any situation where he could feel the danger of badnazri. Why you are giving examples of other moulvis who gave weird justification. The truth remains the truth no matter if someone tries to prove it in a bad way. I am a big follower of you Erum but today i am disappointed. I am not a blind follwer and i don't follow any sect at all. Period
He even said, “Do not mix the sexes.” Besides, SOS village owner was taxing on ZN’s time. He had allowed 10 min. only. The whole country was waiting. Moreover, the shield had to be presented to ZN. He was not there to distribute anything. The question is why did SOS owner present girls to pass the shield to ZN. Larkay bhi thay udhar…so why not the boys? Eventually, boy cadets presented the shield. That SOS owner was more to be blamed. Wish he had used his wits. He didn’t give the regard that ZN deserved. Why on earth would you put a practicing Muslim into a puzzling situation. Koi lehaz karna chaheay tha. It’s same as asking Farhat Hashmi to give or receive shield from male cadets. If they are not comfortable, they shouldn’t be pushed. Jesay Madam Irum ko azadi hey half sleeves and uncovered head ki , similarly, ZN has the right not to mingle closely with adolescent girls! Also, ZN was trying to evade any controversies. Allah hidayat dey Irum Bibi ko. Pata nahi why she keeps beating round the bush. Just minting views and comments!
@Lehar-e-Behar There is no such thing like being moderate Muslim. A muslim is supposed to follow exact code of conduct which is prescribed by Allah swt. not pick and choose what suits us. May Allah swt guide her to wear hijab. ( It is the command of Allah swt. and not a choice)
Scholars se galti ho sakti h, lekin tum jaiso ne equality morality, ki aad me galat kaam kkisky ishary per shuru Kiya h.. Tum sabki funding kahan se ho rahi h...
Because ur state have given free will these types of people who talk against Islam these liberals must be booked they are enemies of islam 😂😂when ur state will be islamic then they will disappear
Having worked in this organisation, I've witnessed the mistreatment of orphans by the management, especially the Head, who is no less than Burney. All guests are given a tour of the facility and shown how well, how much and since how long they have cared for the orphans but in real the funds are redirected at developing/acquiring multiple properties across Pakistan rather than improving the condition of the little humans. The orphans are exploited to gather funds which are not spent on them at the end. The Head touches the girls inappropriately, off camera. His strong connections to two prominent political parties, government sectors and the establishment have suppressed multiple voices and brushed a lot of dirt under the rug. Calling them daughters but not keeping hands and intentions to yourself - THIS any sensitive person, with an eye to detail can catch.
@@tippi9884 this is totally inappropriate! If you are for real put your real name on this comment. Identify your self fully or I am reporting you. Pakistanis would have a sunk to new low if you turn out to be a fake.
I agree with you, hope that people will think again and again to find the truth, every command in Quran has been given to men first and satr is clearly mentioned for both men and women, face of women isn't mentioned anywhere, instead covering face is strictly and clearly forbidden during Hajj.
Good to hear a woman challenging n questioning the beliefs n behaviour which r not Quran message esp regarding women. Many new modern scholars n resercher r looking into Quran n challenging traditional misconceptions. Recently Dr Alban Hasan did some great work in understanding Koran regarding women.
If the prophet would refrain from being with non-mahram women in such close proximity, these ignorant ‘scholars’ would be offended by him too. I wish she would take a class with Muslim Youth Club scholars.
Looking forward to your conversation in GCIL with Hamza Ali Abbasi❤ It must be on sufism😊 .They are against it and I see that you are very much into sufism.Must be an interesting session.
No but it turned out to be a different story altogether, he was getting late for some other event as this one started late, God knows what the truth is but believing one side is also Incorrect until witnessed yourself
Absolutely agree with you. Dr. Zakir is a respectable person and people appreciate his work for Islam. But he’s a human being and can make mistakes. His behavior was not right. Presenting awards doesn’t involve mixing or touching. When you hand someone something, your hands don’t touch. He could have stood on one side and given them awards. Did he forget how the Prophet pbuh treated the orphans? Prophet pbuh instructed us to be kind to orphans. He could have said a kind word to them as a father figure which the girls would’ve remembered for life. Now what they’ll remember is that one of the biggest Islamic personalities disrespected them. I’m sorry but as Erma said, other than Allah and the prophet pbuh, everyone can be questioned.
As long as we continue to treat our religious scholars as holy cows, we tend to make idols of them unconsciously and tread a path of virtual ignorance. We can't grow as a true believer in Allah alone. Our Muslim society has regressed because of cult following and ceased to ask questions, mental growth suffered ending up in bloated sick egos. People would ask questions to the Prophet PBUH without any fears until sorted out. That's the SOP.
May Allah guide you as being an “influencer”, you will be held accountable not only for yourself but for all the people who you mislead by teaching the misleading version of Islam that you preach. Staying away from interacting with the opposite gender is not denying equality. It’s very easy to feel you are correct when you talk in front of the camera all alone in a room rather than having a discussion with actual scholars. Anyone with half a mind would not follow this sister’s Islamic opinion/advice as she doesn’t understand the basics of what Allah would be displeased by.
Assume all girls were adult and non-mehrams, rather assume they are all 30 years old grown women! right! and if you don't want to give them shield no problem. But why so much out of proportion response. Bhai ap nay shield nahi deni tw koi masla nai, wahan zumurad sahab ko kan mai bta detay kay ap inko shield day dain mujhay munasib nai lagtha .. apna sur neechay rukh kay bagair dekhay bachion ko dua detay aur peechay rukhi seat pay baith jatay .... itna bhag kay stage say utarnay ki kia zarurat thi, jaisay koi bohat gandi cheez dekh li? itni si baat thi!
What does Islam say about the criminal Mulvie and Mulana? In Islam, scholars (Ulama) hold a significant position as they are responsible for interpreting Islamic teachings, guiding the community, and providing knowledge about the religion. However, the integrity and character of scholars are crucial, and any misconduct or criminal behavior by scholars is viewed seriously. Here are some key points regarding the expectations of scholars and the implications of their actions in Islam: ### 1. Responsibility of Scholars - Guardians of Knowledge: - Scholars are seen as guardians of Islamic knowledge and are expected to uphold the principles of justice, honesty, and integrity. They have a duty to convey the teachings of Islam accurately and ethically. ### 2. Accountability for Actions - Moral and Ethical Standards: - Scholars are held to high moral and ethical standards. The Quran emphasizes the importance of integrity: - "O you who have believed, why do you say what you do not do? Great is the hatred in the sight of Allah that you say what you do not do." - (Surah As-Saff, 61:2-3) - Consequences of Misconduct: - If a scholar engages in criminal behavior or misconduct, they are accountable for their actions. Their actions can lead to a loss of credibility and respect within the community. ### 3. Public Trust and Confidence - Impact on the Community: - Scholars are trusted figures in the community, and any criminal behavior can undermine public trust in Islamic teachings. It is essential for scholars to maintain their integrity to effectively guide and educate the community. ### 4. Islamic Teachings on Justice - Justice and Fairness: - Islam emphasizes justice and fairness, regardless of a person's status. If a scholar commits a crime, they should be treated according to Islamic principles of justice: - "Indeed, Allah commands you to render trusts to whom they are due and when you judge between people to judge with justice." - (Surah An-Nisa, 4:58) ### 5. Repentance and Reform - Opportunity for Repentance: - Islam encourages repentance (Tawbah) for those who have committed wrongdoings. Scholars who have erred are encouraged to seek forgiveness from Allah and make amends for their actions. ### Conclusion In Islam, scholars are expected to uphold high moral and ethical standards, as they play a vital role in guiding the community. Any criminal behavior or misconduct by scholars is taken seriously, and they are held accountable for their actions. The principles of justice, integrity, and the opportunity for repentance are central to addressing issues related to scholars who may engage in wrongdoing. Ultimately, the community is encouraged to seek knowledge from trustworthy and righteous scholars who embody the teachings of Islam.
Assalamoalekm ww Irm Allah bless you mai apki videos bht show se dekhti hn please regarding pardah ap aik video bnain please mai succhai ki tamasha mai hn 2 Beto ki mother hn or old home mai as a nurse kaam krti hn or Mujey bht criticism ka samna hai please zarur aik video bnain regarding pardah
ڈیئر اس مشکل موضوع پہ بات کرنا وہ بھی پاکستان میں کس قدر مشکل ہے اس پر خطر راست پہ چلنا اور بات کرنا سیلیوٹ ہے ڈیئر میں نے پہلی مرتبہ آ پ کو سنا میں حیران ہوں کہ ایسی لیڈی کو میں نے پہلے کیوں نہیں سنا سمیعہ گیلانی ایڈووکیٹ ملتان
agar Love of Allah & Muhammad PBUH k Lense say daikhain gay to deen kuch or hai or without love sirf aqal k Lense say daikhain gay to kuch or bas itna sa masla hai.
The dilemma in our society is that we can't even defend the right thing with proper logic and reasoning. What Dr sahab did (regardless of any sect) was 100% according to quran o sunnah. We should have given reasoning but some of our molvis and public are not able to defend it in an appropriate manner which opens up more room for criticism for such people like erum saeed. Bibi i am a big fan of yours but do you think that your analogies and examples are relevant. Who knows dr sahab supports hundreds orphans do you know? But where in islam it says that mingling with women is not allowed unless they are orphans. Who says that don't follow islamic rules when it comes to breaking someone's heart. Your criticism has no logic if anyone can think properly they would understand that you just want to criticise. We don't understand from where women's rights come in this scenario. Using different slogans to justify your criticism in a beautiful way. By the way i am not a blind follower of dr zakir.
Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) exhibited exemplary behavior towards women, emphasizing their dignity, rights, and respect. His teachings and actions serve as a model for how women should be treated in society. Here are some key aspects of his behavior towards women, supported by references from the Quran and Hadith: 1. Respect and Dignity: The Prophet emphasized the importance of treating women with respect. He said: - "The most complete believers are those who have the best manners and character, and the best of you are those who are best to their women." (Sunan Ibn Majah, Book 37, Hadith 2245) 2. Rights of Women: The Quran outlines the rights of women, and the Prophet reinforced these rights in his teachings. Allah (SWT) states: - "And give the women [upon marriage] their due dowries graciously." (Surah An-Nisa, 4:24) 3. Education: The Prophet encouraged the education of women. He said: - "Seeking knowledge is an obligation upon every Muslim." (Sunan Ibn Majah, Book 1, Hadith 224) 4. Consultation and Participation: The Prophet consulted women on various matters and valued their opinions. For example, during the Treaty of Hudaybiyyah, he listened to the advice of Umm Salamah (may Allah be pleased with her). 5. Protection and Care: He taught that men should protect and care for their families. He said: - "Each of you is a shepherd and each of you is responsible for his flock. The man is the shepherd of his family and is responsible for his family." (Sahih Bukhari, Book 62, Hadith 160) 6. Condemnation of Oppression: The Prophet condemned any form of oppression against women. He stated in his farewell sermon: - "O people! It is true that you have certain rights over your women, but they also have rights over you." (Sahih Muslim, Book 32, Hadith 6348) These teachings and actions of the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) highlight his commitment to the fair and respectful treatment of women, promoting their rights and dignity within society. For a deeper understanding, it is encouraged to refer to the Arabic texts and consult with knowledgeable scholars.
Aapko kisi ke dil ke haal nahi pata. So, sabse pehle huzoor (saw) ki hadees ko padhe aur seekhe ki voh kaise aurton se baat krte the. Think before you say anything !
Dr zakir naik n aik patha girl k sath b bohat rudely baat ki Zakir naik n batamizi s girl ko chup kra dia Ye behavior bohat bura lga, zakir naik s ye umeed ni thi Ap plzz bolo
first of all before discussing anything about islam , we have to check are we really that much knowledgeable and following islam that is least ordered by our creator ALLAH to do. what about the man who is not able to lower his gaze and what about the the women who is not able to cover her as per islam ..can such people discuss Islam?.
Muslim sister and brothers please social media platform Hak ke liye istemal karo behayai Rokne ke liye aur Hak baat karne ke liye Quran aur Hadees aur Khatarnak Daur hai please please Quran Hadees padhna aur samajhna bahut jaruri hai
I totally agree with you...I also have huge respect for him but at some point of time,he becomes extremely rude...giving shields to them didn't involve touching at all
main disagree bhi karoon ga yahaan, jo examples ap nay deen hain wo sahaba kiraam or sahabiyat ki hai lakin ajkal ka jo mahool hai or jo dajjali dor chal raha hai us hisab say bhi deen main tajdeed ka amal jaari rahta hai ... ab to itni mixing ho gayi hai k sab kuch hi mix ho gaya hai .. baki zakir naik ko stage per awards denay chaheay thay jab aaye huye thay wo, wo koi aasa masla nahi tha...
Women you are talking rubbish. It's his belief and he has rigid beliefs which one should respect. You really need to evaluate your approach and set your belief to learn respect other people's beliefs and instead criticising and creating a whole podcast against Dr Zakir, you could self study individuality. Here you are wrong. I don't follow you neither I am interested but since your post pops up I sometimes watch. You talk some sense which I appreciate but lady here you need to expand your learning and approach. May Allah gives direction to all.
I totally stand with Dr Zakir, though I don't follow him neither but I have massive respect. I also agree that one can and one should question any scholar with the pure intent towards learning not to defame the person. I watch Dr Zakir last event he was stiff with the pathan which is completely fine, his beliefs are clear and rigid as its his belief system. And its not wrong btw if he wants to segregate man/woman or teenagers above 12. I totally totally stand by this. You please fix your approach for the sake of having a responsibility towards your audience or else you will loose respect and credibility. You individuality is appropriate to the extent if you are expressing your opinions or views about yourself and not judging other person. You have crossed your bounderies. You are not questioning love you are judging a person who has way bigger in terms of his aamal. Hope you learn as you grow further. People evolve ....only when they want to Learn. Bless you
First of all in Islam u can’t adopt coz they are non mehram. And in Saudi Arabia till today u have Seperate schools for boys and girls. He came to a Muslim country he felt that they follow it. There’s nothing wrong in it . Those girls were 12or 13 most of them reach puberty by that time . He doesn’t add advertisement in his RUclips videos because he doesn’t want non mehram girl adds. Equality doesn’t mean men and women indulging together in acts . He follows certain things it’s his choice he refrains himself from non mehram girls coz in Islam by the age of 12 they reach puberty and it’s the age of marriage he refrains himself from wrong things which is commendable.nothing wrong in that. Plz don’t use him for cheap publicity and fame. Anywaz he doesn’t even care what u think u r minting money on his fame . Go and read Quran before venting stupidity.
Madam wo choti bachiaan nhi baligh larkian thi ar namehram hain is liye islam k nazarye se unko dekhna ya touch krna hug krna ya kiss krna bilkul haram hai even in any way even apka beloved west 18 years k kam larki ko touch krna ya hug krnay ko bilkul prohibit krta hai. Rahi orphan honay ki baat tu islam jitna orphan se acha salook ki baat krta hai uski misal nhi milti
Hug karna, kiss karna ye baate yahan Kahan se aa gyi. Hamein bhi pata hai ki yeh haram hai. Par human dignity bhi kisi chiz ka naam hai aur Islam ke ilawa aur koi religion acchi tarah nahi sikha sakta.
You are illiterate about Islamic framework.Ms. Saeed. Rulings in Islam are not just based on Quran. This shows your lack of knowledge of Islamic jurisprudence. Best if you refrain from making comments in these matters. No hard feelings.
Aap modern kapdo mein arabic duaaon se shuruaat karke yahi message dena chahti hain ki mujhe islam pata hai....aur hum but parasti nahin karte? Really?!! Butt sirf wo nahi hai jo haath se banaaye jaate hain, apni marzi ki zindagi jeene waale khud chalte phirte butt hote hain.....raha sawaal zakir naik ki baaton se agree karne ya na karne ka to aap bikul ye haq rakhti hain jab unki zaati baat ho, deen to bahut clear hai apne dos and donts ko lekar....phir is mein interpretation ka sawaal kahaan se paida ho gaya? What is this bull shit of liberal Islam
First of all, aap hote kon se kisi ko judge krne wale jabki aap unki dill mein jhank kar nahi dekh skte. Yeh sirf Allah janta hai. Moreover, yes I agree ki Islam bilkul clear hai but the problem is that hamein lagta hai ki ham sirf scholars se hi Islam Seekh sakte hain. Deen ko khud samjhe
@@Allahu-akbar-q9t oh really....to phir nahin Anil munkir ka hukum kyu hai? Kyu Allah kehta hai doosro ko burai se roko...haan ye kaha ja sakta hai ki tanqeed akele mein karni chahiye lekin ye koyi mere mama ki beti to nahi ki meri in tak personal pahunch ho...public platform par aa kar apne galat ko Islam ka sahi bataaoge to main to bolungi aur main kya har zarf waali true practicing muslim aurat bolegi...aap kaun hain beech mein bolne waale....ye mohtarma bata rahi hain ki inhone female muslim scholars ko bulakar discussion bhi ki hai to kya unhone inhein inke kapdo aur life style pe Toka nahin? maine scholar se Islam nahin sikha Maine khud sikha hai lekin sikhane ka matlab apni convenience ke hisab se Islam ki gardan modane ka nahin hota genuinely usko follow karna hota hai which means to accept Islam for what it is and mend your lifestyle according to Islam rather than mending Islam to suit you.
@@shazsayyed5269 I agree with the huqm of "nahi Anil munkir" and as Muslims it is our duty forbid evil. But Jo aap kar rahi hain vo is huqm ke matabiq nahi hai. This is what you said about Eram, "Aap modern kapdon mein Arabic duaon se shuruat karke yahi message Dena chahti hai ki mujhe Islam pata hai" Ab ye jo aapne kaha ise wrong judgement na kahein toh kya kahein. Aap ka pura haq hai unse disagree krne ka but aap unko is chiz se judge nhi kr skti ki wo apni dua Allah ke liye padh rahi hain ya phir kisi ko dikhane ke liye. Dilon ke haal sirf Allah janta hai. This is what Allah says, 👇 O you who have believed, let not a people ridicule [another] people; perhaps they may be better than them; nor let women ridicule [other] women; perhaps they may be better than them". (Surah al hujurut ) (49:11) So, you are not one to judge the sincerity of her ibadat, because dua is also an ibadat. This right is only for Allah.
Knowledge??? Do u really have some???... Pleasure to hear that u address those 20% who r below ur knowledge level.... Ahh relaxed me hearing by mistake.. Allah saves true spirits
Aapne Deen ko padke kitna samaj liya hai? aap poori dunya ke samne bina hijab ke baithi deendaaro ko sikha rahi hai, how funny
Eram ma'am. You have hit the nail on the head. Perfect analysis. We are moving to the 21st century & some people are trying their very best to take us back to the dark ages.
Keep up your good work. God bless you & your work.
You are absolutely right dear 💓
No need of assumptions lady. He clearly explained, he left because he didn't like this closeness with females. And he was not doing hajj or umrah. He answers ladies. But prophet sallallahu alaihi wasallam never took hand in hand bait from women. Never saw non mehram ladies inspite of being prophet.
First of all after puberty nobody is considered an orphan. Orphans are only those children who have yet not attained puberty. So they were not more orphans.
Thank you for raising awareness, you’re doing a great job!
Islam emphasizes justice, fairness, and the importance of treating all individuals with respect and dignity, regardless of their background. Bias, prejudice, and discrimination are discouraged in Islamic teachings.
In the Quran, Allah (SWT) instructs believers to be just and fair:
Surah An-Nisa (4:135):
"يَا أَيُّهَا الَّذِينَ آمَنُوا كُونُوا قَوَّامِينَ بِالْقِسْطِ شُهَدَاءَ لِلَّهِ وَلَوْ عَلَى أَنفُسِكُمْ أَوِ الْوَالِدَيْنِ وَالْأَقْرَبِينَ ۚ إِن يَكُن غَنِيًّا أَوْ فَقِيرًا فَاللَّهُ أَوْلَى بِهِمَا ۚ فَلَا تَتَّبِعُوا الْهَوَى أَن تَعْدِلُوا ۚ وَإِن تَلْوُوا أَوْ تُعْرِضُوا فَإِنَّ اللَّهَ كَانَ بِمَا تَعْمَلُونَ خَبِيرًا"
"O you who have believed, be persistently standing firm in justice, witnesses in justice, witnesses for Allah, even if it be against yourselves or parents and relatives. Whether one is rich or poor, Allah is more worthy of both. So follow not [personal] inclination, lest you not be just. And if you distort [your testimony] or refuse [to give it], then indeed Allah is Acquainted with what you do."
Additionally, the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) emphasized the importance of equality among all people, regardless of their race or status. In his Farewell Sermon, he stated:
Hadith (Sahih Muslim, Book 32, Hadith 6348):
"All mankind is descended from Adam and Eve. An Arab has no superiority over a non-Arab, nor does a non-Arab have any superiority over an Arab; a white has no superiority over a black, nor does a black have any superiority over a white; none have superiority over another except by piety and good action."
These teachings highlight that biases based on race, ethnicity, or social status are contrary to the principles of Islam, which advocates for equality and justice among all individuals.
Please make a video for Paleatine, Lebanon and Yemen too
What is your problem with Dr Naik not wanting to Free Mix with the opposite sex.? What if he does not shake hands with women? That is his belief and he is entitled to it, as long as it is not offensive.
I also respect your perspective and no doubt no one is perfect even if there is an islamic scholar.But the fact is ka jo bhi masla ho if he wasn't comfortable with giving shields to those girls this is totally okay I don't know why people are making it an issue. Secondly, you are totally wrong where you said ka free mixing is allowed.No,free mixing is not allowed In case of hajj, it is already mentioned that hajj was farz on woman when she has mehram with her so that even in free mixing no one can even come closer to her prophet SAW said ka aurat mehram ka baghair safar na kare or na hi mehram ka baghair iska pass koi ghair mard jaye... ,sahih bukhari 1763. And there are many examples. But on the other hand, there is alot of difference in that sahabaa's era and today's era full of temptation. Today there is free mixing everywhere but rather than promoting it we girls especially should maintan some distance jaha tak mumkin ho. Thanks
Lov u Erum , thank u for introducing us to this wonderful world of Islam .The true essence of Islam ❤
Iram u have no idea how much u have help me in searching for trúth about our deen I never thought I will actually find the way towards authentic Islam which is understandable with logic and reason and not only by u cannot question any thing about deen !!
And Jo Gamdi sb ap na mujha da diya hain na is ka líya to I love uuuuu 🫶🫶🫶💕
you are doing a great job,,,keep it up
Love you Lady!!!!
I love the way you elaborate women’s rights…. In ISLAM
Great points Erum thank u for being our voice! Can't thank u enough!
What did you gether about Dr Zakir Nyeak behaviour and personality from this incident,is he a misognyst,or a strict believer of segregation of sex or he never wanted these girls to be there in the first place.He should himself explain this to dispel any misconceiving.
Look what he did is none of your business, But if he Preaches Strict teaching and then calls it Farz and too in Pakistan's sponsored events... Then you can disagree otherwise GROW UP
Basically this is what going on in this era, back then only Hazrat Muhammad has a right to interpret words of Allah and now every one is ready to interpretate Holy words as per their own feasibility and understanding and people are believing them with blind eyes and closed minds and thats the very reason Islam has splitted further to many sub sects.
What you are explaining making sense to only those people who can read in between the lines of scipture.
Keep up the good work
Be wary, this lady is doing self study, which is very very dangerous.
If wouldn’t trust her to do a brain surgery on you, why are you taking Islam from her!
Best thing is to find genuine scholars.
Well said Erum Saeed !
When I watched the video I immediately got it .. unfortunately it was pure absence of wisdom and courage at Dr.sab's end ..
If he was told to behave like that he could've resisted and he could've empathised with the young "Orphan"girls who were looking at him as fatherly figure .... Imagine your Father looking at you with some other emotion ??
It is made complicated by design ...
We have been slow poisoned over time about the age of Ayesha r.a ..i don't know how are many of our ulemas going to face RasoolAllah on the day of Qiyamah ... for made up stories
On another occasion Dr.sab called a matric student "sister'' when it should've been "daughter" ...
We have serious kahturRijaal ... Our men see women in us regardless of age instead of an orphan , or sister or daughters ...
Our daughters like Dr.Afia is a proof that we are Fatherless !
Our famous leader is said to be womaniser..... What a nation !! 😢
All Muslims are brother and sisters!
ارم آپ بہت اچھا کام کر رہی ہیں جو اسلامی جمہوریہ پاکستان میں ممکن نہیں تھا ۔آپکی وڈیو سن کر مجھے دو سال پہلے کا ایک واقع یاد آ گیا ۔ہم میاں بیوی عمرہ کرنے گئے اور مسجد نبوی سے باہر آ رہے تھے تو میری نظر ایک نوجوان جوڑے پر پڑی جو ایک بینچ پر بیٹھے بغلگیر ہو رہے تھے ۔مجھے دیکھ کر بہت خوشی ہوئی اور اپنی بیوی کو کہا کہ نہ جانے بیچارے کس گھٹن کے ماحول سے آئے ہوں گے اور یہاں موقع پا کر پیار محبت کا اظہار کر رہے ہیں ۔زیادہ خوشی اس وجہ سے ہوئی کہ کوئ ان پر احتراز نہیں کر رہا تھا ۔میں ذاکر نائک کو ایک اچھا طوطا سمجھتا ہوں ۔سکالر نہیں
Erum I am so happy that you are challenging so called scholars with full knowledge , research and confidence . I saw your video with Sitara Akram . It was eye opening . Later I watched all her videos on hijab . We need more women scholars . Men scholars only suppress women and talk only on their clothes . Thank God I was brought up in a modest home and have all the facilities to do what ever I wanted to do . Sadly as I grew up I saw the regression in our society . Women are badly affected and impacted by this system . You are now one of few women who are torch bearer to show right path to young women . Instead of following the western agenda listen to these women scholars and follow Islam in a better way.
If you want to watch genuine sincere female scholars, watch Dr. Haifa Younis, Yasmeen Mogahed and the likes who have studied Islam.
Beware of choosing “ wannabe scholars” who begin their education by challenging rather than learning.
@@user1-user-0421Eram doesn't say that she is a scholar. Moreover, if someone is not scholar it doesn't mean that they are always wrong, you have to look at their sincerity.
Muslim ho sar dhko sister ❤❤
With due respect miss Erum those were not very young girls. I hope you have seen that video properly and most of them are teenagers. This is quite absurd to make an islamic scholar give awards to girls now be it orphans or whatever. The organisers are to blame too. Islamic scholars are there to give a sermon or lecture not to deliver awards. What he did is 100% according to islamic preachings. It is not recommended for a male to do this. Now you argue that the kids were wearing hijab and scarves. By the way doesn't matter if those teenager kids were wearing hijab or not. Females are females. I wonder how you are comparing equaity with mixing of grnders. Do you mean giving awards to females by a male is a matter of equity and human rights. I would be surprised at your interpretation of things. No matter they were their daughters age. They were not kids. How can you question about hajj. Do you know we don't interact with any females there. Direct interaction is another story. Prophets interacted with females to answer their problems and questions that's what do zakir naik does but those women are not in the same vicinity. If we don't follow any islamic law we should not at least criticize. Wow you saud the rank of orphans what a brilliant way of comparing two different categories. The more the level of faith the more strictly you follow Allah's commandments. A pious man will try to avoid any situation where he could feel the danger of badnazri. Why you are giving examples of other moulvis who gave weird justification. The truth remains the truth no matter if someone tries to prove it in a bad way. I am a big follower of you Erum but today i am disappointed. I am not a blind follwer and i don't follow any sect at all. Period
Exactly! 👍
He even said, “Do not mix the sexes.” Besides, SOS village owner was taxing on ZN’s time. He had allowed 10 min. only. The whole country was waiting. Moreover, the shield had to be presented to ZN. He was not there to distribute anything. The question is why did SOS owner present girls to pass the shield to ZN. Larkay bhi thay udhar…so why not the boys? Eventually, boy cadets presented the shield. That SOS owner was more to be blamed. Wish he had used his wits. He didn’t give the regard that ZN deserved. Why on earth would you put a practicing Muslim into a puzzling situation. Koi lehaz karna chaheay tha. It’s same as asking Farhat Hashmi to give or receive shield from male cadets. If they are not comfortable, they shouldn’t be pushed. Jesay Madam Irum ko azadi hey half sleeves and uncovered head ki , similarly, ZN has the right not to mingle closely with adolescent girls! Also, ZN was trying to evade any controversies. Allah hidayat dey Irum Bibi ko. Pata nahi why she keeps beating round the bush. Just minting views and comments!
Exactly well explained
Can't agree more. May Allah azza wa j'all guide our Ummah to have better understanding of our deen and be better muslims ameen.
@Lehar-e-Behar There is no such thing like being moderate Muslim. A muslim is supposed to follow exact code of conduct which is prescribed by Allah swt. not pick and choose what suits us. May Allah swt guide her to wear hijab. ( It is the command of Allah swt. and not a choice)
Scholars se galti ho sakti h, lekin tum jaiso ne equality morality, ki aad me galat kaam kkisky ishary per shuru Kiya h.. Tum sabki funding kahan se ho rahi h...
Because ur state have given free will these types of people who talk against Islam these liberals must be booked they are enemies of islam 😂😂when ur state will be islamic then they will disappear
Having worked in this organisation, I've witnessed the mistreatment of orphans by the management, especially the Head, who is no less than Burney. All guests are given a tour of the facility and shown how well, how much and since how long they have cared for the orphans but in real the funds are redirected at developing/acquiring multiple properties across Pakistan rather than improving the condition of the little humans. The orphans are exploited to gather funds which are not spent on them at the end. The Head touches the girls inappropriately, off camera. His strong connections to two prominent political parties, government sectors and the establishment have suppressed multiple voices and brushed a lot of dirt under the rug. Calling them daughters but not keeping hands and intentions to yourself - THIS any sensitive person, with an eye to detail can catch.
@@tippi9884 this is totally inappropriate! If you are for real put your real name on this comment. Identify your self fully or I am reporting you.
Pakistanis would have a sunk to new low if you turn out to be a fake.
Was desperately waiting for your video❤. You are Spot On Eram. Majority do not want to hear the truth.
Islam is a simple religion. but to complicated it without knowing proper knowledge of Quran tarjuma and apply in daily life and improve ourselves
From India
Mam Assalamualaikum, you r quite good, Madam strongly agreed with you,
Allah bless you, thanks a lot, love ur opinion, once again thanks
Well said Eram
I agree with you, hope that people will think again and again to find the truth, every command in Quran has been given to men first and satr is clearly mentioned for both men and women, face of women isn't mentioned anywhere, instead covering face is strictly and clearly forbidden during Hajj.
Apki video kitniiiiiiii hiiiiiii long ho
Dil nhi bharta aur waqt forun guzar jata hy ❤️❤️❤️
100% with u .
Good to hear a woman challenging n questioning the beliefs n behaviour which r not Quran message esp regarding women. Many new modern scholars n resercher r looking into Quran n challenging traditional misconceptions. Recently Dr Alban Hasan did some great work in understanding Koran regarding women.
If the prophet would refrain from being with non-mahram women in such close proximity, these ignorant ‘scholars’ would be offended by him too.
I wish she would take a class with Muslim Youth Club scholars.
What wrong did she say? In my opinion, she is right !
Miss you are misguiding the people May Allah guide you Ameen
I completely agree with u ... Very good
بڑے افسوس کی بات ہے آپ نے قرآن کی آیات بغیر دوپٹہ اسکارف کے تلاوت کی
you are narrow minded muslim
That you for this video❤. Well needed ! ! !
Looking forward to your conversation in GCIL with Hamza Ali Abbasi❤ It must be on sufism😊 .They are against it and I see that you are very much into sufism.Must be an interesting session.
No but it turned out to be a different story altogether, he was getting late for some other event as this one started late, God knows what the truth is but believing one side is also Incorrect until witnessed yourself
@@wellbeingbyafifa956 you commented without watching my video. Pls watch it bfr commenting.
Absolutely agree with you. Dr. Zakir is a respectable person and people appreciate his work for Islam. But he’s a human being and can make mistakes. His behavior was not right. Presenting awards doesn’t involve mixing or touching. When you hand someone something, your hands don’t touch. He could have stood on one side and given them awards. Did he forget how the Prophet pbuh treated the orphans? Prophet pbuh instructed us to be kind to orphans. He could have said a kind word to them as a father figure which the girls would’ve remembered for life. Now what they’ll remember is that one of the biggest Islamic personalities disrespected them. I’m sorry but as Erma said, other than Allah and the prophet pbuh, everyone can be questioned.
You are also right but I think zaker Naik situation or point of view was different at that moment.
As long as we continue to treat our religious scholars as holy cows, we tend to make idols of them unconsciously and tread a path of virtual ignorance. We can't grow as a true believer in Allah alone. Our Muslim society has regressed because of cult following and ceased to ask questions, mental growth suffered ending up in bloated sick egos. People would ask questions to the Prophet PBUH without any fears until sorted out. That's the SOP.
May Allah guide you as being an “influencer”, you will be held accountable not only for yourself but for all the people who you mislead by teaching the misleading version of Islam that you preach.
Staying away from interacting with the opposite gender is not denying equality.
It’s very easy to feel you are correct when you talk in front of the camera all alone in a room rather than having a discussion with actual scholars.
Anyone with half a mind would not follow this sister’s Islamic opinion/advice as she doesn’t understand the basics of what Allah would be displeased by.
Assume all girls were adult and non-mehrams, rather assume they are all 30 years old grown women! right! and if you don't want to give them shield no problem. But why so much out of proportion response. Bhai ap nay shield nahi deni tw koi masla nai, wahan zumurad sahab ko kan mai bta detay kay ap inko shield day dain mujhay munasib nai lagtha .. apna sur neechay rukh kay bagair dekhay bachion ko dua detay aur peechay rukhi seat pay baith jatay .... itna bhag kay stage say utarnay ki kia zarurat thi, jaisay koi bohat gandi cheez dekh li? itni si baat thi!
Yes this is the real point ....
Aap ki batey mujay sahi lagi tanqeed aapki drust hay
Sahi class leti hyn Ap us therki shadi wale aurat dushman mufti tariq masood ki !!!👍🏻👍🏻👏👏👏
May Allah bless us all
Ma sha Allah. Stay blessed.
You have right to your view. Which could be right or wrong
قرانی آیات آپ نے دوپٹہ اسکارف پہننے بغیر تلاوت کی پلیز
Request hy Ap say Without Hijab Quran ki Ayat ki tilawat na krain
I think you misunderstood. What do you think of no hijab ,showing your hands? You ate not saying within Islamic framework.
How were the girls offended? Did they not recieve their awards?
Nailed it
What does Islam say about the criminal Mulvie and Mulana?
In Islam, scholars (Ulama) hold a significant position as they are responsible for interpreting Islamic teachings, guiding the community, and providing knowledge about the religion. However, the integrity and character of scholars are crucial, and any misconduct or criminal behavior by scholars is viewed seriously. Here are some key points regarding the expectations of scholars and the implications of their actions in Islam:
### 1. Responsibility of Scholars
- Guardians of Knowledge:
- Scholars are seen as guardians of Islamic knowledge and are expected to uphold the principles of justice, honesty, and integrity. They have a duty to convey the teachings of Islam accurately and ethically.
### 2. Accountability for Actions
- Moral and Ethical Standards:
- Scholars are held to high moral and ethical standards. The Quran emphasizes the importance of integrity:
- "O you who have believed, why do you say what you do not do? Great is the hatred in the sight of Allah that you say what you do not do."
- (Surah As-Saff, 61:2-3)
- Consequences of Misconduct:
- If a scholar engages in criminal behavior or misconduct, they are accountable for their actions. Their actions can lead to a loss of credibility and respect within the community.
### 3. Public Trust and Confidence
- Impact on the Community:
- Scholars are trusted figures in the community, and any criminal behavior can undermine public trust in Islamic teachings. It is essential for scholars to maintain their integrity to effectively guide and educate the community.
### 4. Islamic Teachings on Justice
- Justice and Fairness:
- Islam emphasizes justice and fairness, regardless of a person's status. If a scholar commits a crime, they should be treated according to Islamic principles of justice:
- "Indeed, Allah commands you to render trusts to whom they are due and when you judge between people to judge with justice."
- (Surah An-Nisa, 4:58)
### 5. Repentance and Reform
- Opportunity for Repentance:
- Islam encourages repentance (Tawbah) for those who have committed wrongdoings. Scholars who have erred are encouraged to seek forgiveness from Allah and make amends for their actions.
### Conclusion
In Islam, scholars are expected to uphold high moral and ethical standards, as they play a vital role in guiding the community. Any criminal behavior or misconduct by scholars is taken seriously, and they are held accountable for their actions. The principles of justice, integrity, and the opportunity for repentance are central to addressing issues related to scholars who may engage in wrongdoing. Ultimately, the community is encouraged to seek knowledge from trustworthy and righteous scholars who embody the teachings of Islam.
Why criticism? Afsoos
Thank you erum❤
Unki khidmaat ko salaam
Assalamoalekm ww Irm Allah bless you mai apki videos bht show se dekhti hn please regarding pardah ap aik video bnain please mai succhai ki tamasha mai hn 2 Beto ki mother hn or old home mai as a nurse kaam krti hn or Mujey bht criticism ka samna hai please zarur aik video bnain regarding pardah
Thank You ❤
I agree with you erum bless you
Well said!!
Very nicely said ❤
Very intelligent
To call Jahil Naik a scholar is like calling a crocodile begetter 😂
✌️
Allah unsay razi hojaye
Sort of religious discussions, arguments in 21st century 😂😂😂😂😂
What's wrong with that?
ڈیئر اس مشکل موضوع پہ بات کرنا وہ بھی پاکستان میں کس قدر مشکل ہے اس پر خطر راست پہ چلنا اور بات کرنا سیلیوٹ ہے ڈیئر میں نے پہلی مرتبہ آ پ کو سنا میں حیران ہوں کہ ایسی لیڈی کو میں نے پہلے کیوں نہیں سنا سمیعہ گیلانی ایڈووکیٹ ملتان
agar Love of Allah & Muhammad PBUH k Lense say daikhain gay to deen kuch or hai or without love sirf aqal k Lense say daikhain gay to kuch or bas itna sa masla hai.
❤❤❤❤❤❤
The dilemma in our society is that we can't even defend the right thing with proper logic and reasoning. What Dr sahab did (regardless of any sect) was 100% according to quran o sunnah. We should have given reasoning but some of our molvis and public are not able to defend it in an appropriate manner which opens up more room for criticism for such people like erum saeed. Bibi i am a big fan of yours but do you think that your analogies and examples are relevant. Who knows dr sahab supports hundreds orphans do you know? But where in islam it says that mingling with women is not allowed unless they are orphans. Who says that don't follow islamic rules when it comes to breaking someone's heart. Your criticism has no logic if anyone can think properly they would understand that you just want to criticise. We don't understand from where women's rights come in this scenario. Using different slogans to justify your criticism in a beautiful way. By the way i am not a blind follower of dr zakir.
Agree...we respect them but agar wo gussa kare ghay toh ego hua muje b Aisa feel hua
Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) exhibited exemplary behavior towards women, emphasizing their dignity, rights, and respect. His teachings and actions serve as a model for how women should be treated in society. Here are some key aspects of his behavior towards women, supported by references from the Quran and Hadith:
1. Respect and Dignity: The Prophet emphasized the importance of treating women with respect. He said:
- "The most complete believers are those who have the best manners and character, and the best of you are those who are best to their women." (Sunan Ibn Majah, Book 37, Hadith 2245)
2. Rights of Women: The Quran outlines the rights of women, and the Prophet reinforced these rights in his teachings. Allah (SWT) states:
- "And give the women [upon marriage] their due dowries graciously." (Surah An-Nisa, 4:24)
3. Education: The Prophet encouraged the education of women. He said:
- "Seeking knowledge is an obligation upon every Muslim." (Sunan Ibn Majah, Book 1, Hadith 224)
4. Consultation and Participation: The Prophet consulted women on various matters and valued their opinions. For example, during the Treaty of Hudaybiyyah, he listened to the advice of Umm Salamah (may Allah be pleased with her).
5. Protection and Care: He taught that men should protect and care for their families. He said:
- "Each of you is a shepherd and each of you is responsible for his flock. The man is the shepherd of his family and is responsible for his family." (Sahih Bukhari, Book 62, Hadith 160)
6. Condemnation of Oppression: The Prophet condemned any form of oppression against women. He stated in his farewell sermon:
- "O people! It is true that you have certain rights over your women, but they also have rights over you." (Sahih Muslim, Book 32, Hadith 6348)
These teachings and actions of the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) highlight his commitment to the fair and respectful treatment of women, promoting their rights and dignity within society. For a deeper understanding, it is encouraged to refer to the Arabic texts and consult with knowledgeable scholars.
Theres no explanation from his end so we cant assume why he didnt distribute the prises . . So dont jusge yo the conclusion
❤ superb
Aoa .how r u
Dua partay waqt sar per duppata tou lay lo
Dr Zakir Naik sahab ka aap Naam lekar popularity hasil karna chahti hai aur kuchh nahin ki aapki ghatiya soch hai
Aapko kisi ke dil ke haal nahi pata. So, sabse pehle huzoor (saw) ki hadees ko padhe aur seekhe ki voh kaise aurton se baat krte the.
Think before you say anything !
Very widely said
Kayi bar ham ney utube pe dekha islami scholers bilkul close discussion ya q n answer kar rhi hoti hay khwateen k saath.
Dr zakir naik n aik patha girl k sath b bohat rudely baat ki
Zakir naik n batamizi s girl ko chup kra dia
Ye behavior bohat bura lga, zakir naik s ye umeed ni thi
Ap plzz bolo
first of all before discussing anything about islam , we have to check are we really that much knowledgeable and following islam that is least ordered by our creator ALLAH to do.
what about the man who is not able to lower his gaze and what about the the women who is not able to cover her as per islam ..can such people discuss Islam?.
Muslim sister and brothers please social media platform Hak ke liye istemal karo
behayai Rokne ke liye aur Hak baat karne ke liye
Quran aur Hadees aur Khatarnak Daur hai please please Quran Hadees padhna aur samajhna bahut jaruri hai
I totally agree with you...I also have huge respect for him but at some point of time,he becomes extremely rude...giving shields to them didn't involve touching at all
main disagree bhi karoon ga yahaan, jo examples ap nay deen hain wo sahaba kiraam or sahabiyat ki hai lakin ajkal ka jo mahool hai or jo dajjali dor chal raha hai us hisab say bhi deen main tajdeed ka amal jaari rahta hai ... ab to itni mixing ho gayi hai k sab kuch hi mix ho gaya hai .. baki zakir naik ko stage per awards denay chaheay thay jab aaye huye thay wo, wo koi aasa masla nahi tha...
But Yeh baat bhi samjhiye ki Islam human dignity ko bahut importance deta hai, aur Fir to vah bacchiyan yateem bhi thi.
Women you are talking rubbish. It's his belief and he has rigid beliefs which one should respect. You really need to evaluate your approach and set your belief to learn respect other people's beliefs and instead criticising and creating a whole podcast against Dr Zakir, you could self study individuality. Here you are wrong. I don't follow you neither I am interested but since your post pops up I sometimes watch. You talk some sense which I appreciate but lady here you need to expand your learning and approach. May Allah gives direction to all.
I totally stand with Dr Zakir, though I don't follow him neither but I have massive respect. I also agree that one can and one should question any scholar with the pure intent towards learning not to defame the person. I watch Dr Zakir last event he was stiff with the pathan which is completely fine, his beliefs are clear and rigid as its his belief system. And its not wrong btw if he wants to segregate man/woman or teenagers above 12. I totally totally stand by this. You please fix your approach for the sake of having a responsibility towards your audience or else you will loose respect and credibility. You individuality is appropriate to the extent if you are expressing your opinions or views about yourself and not judging other person. You have crossed your bounderies. You are not questioning love you are judging a person who has way bigger in terms of his aamal. Hope you learn as you grow further. People evolve ....only when they want to Learn. Bless you
Agar ap hijab,nhi,laga rahe hai wo,marzi wo,unki,marzi ap,bhi,to,wahi,kar rahe ho
First of all in Islam u can’t adopt coz they are non mehram. And in Saudi Arabia till today u have Seperate schools for boys and girls. He came to a Muslim country he felt that they follow it. There’s nothing wrong in it . Those girls were 12or 13 most of them reach puberty by that time . He doesn’t add advertisement in his RUclips videos because he doesn’t want non mehram girl adds. Equality doesn’t mean men and women indulging together in acts . He follows certain things it’s his choice he refrains himself from non mehram girls coz in Islam by the age of 12 they reach puberty and it’s the age of marriage he refrains himself from wrong things which is commendable.nothing wrong in that. Plz don’t use him for cheap publicity and fame. Anywaz he doesn’t even care what u think u r minting money on his fame . Go and read Quran before venting stupidity.
Get yourself treated in a good mental health facility!
Pahly khud deen ko samj lo phir aa kr logo k samny bethi or deen ki bat karo, aurat k liye parday ka hikam pahly aya hy libral aurton
Ap,ne jankari nikali kiyun aisa kiya ap ne ek,video dekha matlab,ap,confirm nhi,ho kiyun aisa kiyun?????
thank you for raising your voice on it
Madam wo choti bachiaan nhi baligh larkian thi ar namehram hain is liye islam k nazarye se unko dekhna ya touch krna hug krna ya kiss krna bilkul haram hai even in any way even apka beloved west 18 years k kam larki ko touch krna ya hug krnay ko bilkul prohibit krta hai.
Rahi orphan honay ki baat tu islam jitna orphan se acha salook ki baat krta hai uski misal nhi milti
Hug karna, kiss karna ye baate yahan Kahan se aa gyi. Hamein bhi pata hai ki yeh haram hai. Par human dignity bhi kisi chiz ka naam hai aur Islam ke ilawa aur koi religion acchi tarah nahi sikha sakta.
You are illiterate about Islamic framework.Ms. Saeed. Rulings in Islam are not just based on Quran. This shows your lack of knowledge of Islamic jurisprudence. Best if you refrain from making comments in these matters. No hard feelings.
First cover your self then give advice..
First mend your mindset and read the Seerah of the Prophet (saw) then say anything !
@@Allahu-akbar-q9t no pick & choose
Pahle aap puri bat urdru me kare.plz.
Zakir Naik ka behaviour Pakistanis k sath Acha nai lag rha mujhe
Dr. Sab nay sahi nhi kiya
Aap modern kapdo mein arabic duaaon se shuruaat karke yahi message dena chahti hain ki mujhe islam pata hai....aur hum but parasti nahin karte? Really?!! Butt sirf wo nahi hai jo haath se banaaye jaate hain, apni marzi ki zindagi jeene waale khud chalte phirte butt hote hain.....raha sawaal zakir naik ki baaton se agree karne ya na karne ka to aap bikul ye haq rakhti hain jab unki zaati baat ho, deen to bahut clear hai apne dos and donts ko lekar....phir is mein interpretation ka sawaal kahaan se paida ho gaya? What is this bull shit of liberal Islam
First of all, aap hote kon se kisi ko judge krne wale jabki aap unki dill mein jhank kar nahi dekh skte. Yeh sirf Allah janta hai. Moreover, yes I agree ki Islam bilkul clear hai but the problem is that hamein lagta hai ki ham sirf scholars se hi Islam Seekh sakte hain. Deen ko khud samjhe
@@Allahu-akbar-q9t oh really....to phir nahin Anil munkir ka hukum kyu hai? Kyu Allah kehta hai doosro ko burai se roko...haan ye kaha ja sakta hai ki tanqeed akele mein karni chahiye lekin ye koyi mere mama ki beti to nahi ki meri in tak personal pahunch ho...public platform par aa kar apne galat ko Islam ka sahi bataaoge to main to bolungi aur main kya har zarf waali true practicing muslim aurat bolegi...aap kaun hain beech mein bolne waale....ye mohtarma bata rahi hain ki inhone female muslim scholars ko bulakar discussion bhi ki hai to kya unhone inhein inke kapdo aur life style pe Toka nahin? maine scholar se Islam nahin sikha Maine khud sikha hai lekin sikhane ka matlab apni convenience ke hisab se Islam ki gardan modane ka nahin hota genuinely usko follow karna hota hai which means to accept Islam for what it is and mend your lifestyle according to Islam rather than mending Islam to suit you.
@@shazsayyed5269 I agree with the huqm of "nahi Anil munkir" and as Muslims it is our duty forbid evil.
But Jo aap kar rahi hain vo is huqm ke matabiq nahi hai. This is what you said about Eram, "Aap modern kapdon mein Arabic duaon se shuruat karke yahi message Dena chahti hai ki mujhe Islam pata hai"
Ab ye jo aapne kaha ise wrong judgement na kahein toh kya kahein. Aap ka pura haq hai unse disagree krne ka but aap unko is chiz se judge nhi kr skti ki wo apni dua Allah ke liye padh rahi hain ya phir kisi ko dikhane ke liye. Dilon ke haal sirf Allah janta hai. This is what Allah says, 👇
O you who have believed, let not a people ridicule [another] people; perhaps they may be better than them; nor let women ridicule [other] women; perhaps they may be better than them". (Surah al hujurut ) (49:11)
So, you are not one to judge the sincerity of her ibadat, because dua is also an ibadat. This right is only for Allah.
👽👽👽👽💩👽👽👽👽
Fazool ki criticism
Knowledge??? Do u really have some???...
Pleasure to hear that u address those 20% who r below ur knowledge level.... Ahh relaxed me hearing by mistake.. Allah saves true spirits