My guess is that the grandparents were actually paying the rent on the place with their Social Security. When her grandmother died they couldn't pay the rent because they weren't getting her social security anymore.
Probably but I think the funeral expenses were likely a factor if MaMaw didn’t have life insurance. . She died in November. They didn’t stop paying until February.
No, it was because it was too traumatic living in a house with someone who was dying, because they eventually died. Ha... she has an excuse for everything.
You could tell that the defendant was dancing around the judge instead of giving her direct answers. Yeah, she owes the rent. Also, if she paid the rent, she should've provided proof. If she can't present her evidence in court, then the action didn't exist.
very surprised JJ didn't ask for the lease agreement and then hold it up and point to it saying "you can't have a verbal agreement. the for corners of this agreement is the entire agreement." she must have had a glass of wine at lunch
Obviously, the Grandparents paid the rent. Making excuses at her age is pathetic. She tried to make it sound as if they were taking care of the Grandparents, when it was likely it was the other way around.
She considered the security deposit February's rent which is why she kept claiming they paid it but had no proof... and why they didn't countersue for the return of the security deposit.
I'm glad I stopped watching when Judge Judy ended and became Judy Justice or whatever. She had gotten so bitter over the years. It's an entertaining program, but she could lighten up some.
It wasn't a hard case. They occupied the property for the three months they didn't pay rent for. I would have preferred he have the bill for the clean-up to settle the matter of the deposit. However, he's willing to let them skate on some of the damages because he made property improvements after they left, and they shouldn't be on the hook for those.
Once he made improvements, he kind of shot himself in the foot for it. You can't claim damages and have the tenant pay for the upgrade. He could only charge for the cleanup of the stuff that is actually theirs.
I hate it when renters assume they own the rental property and make major changes to the house. Turtle boy Defendant is a puppet, he's pussy whipped. His wife does all the talking and all the decision making in that relationship. The Plaintiff is a nice guy and he didn't deserve all this stress from these bums.
I hate people like the defendant that twist things to get away with stuff. Note the text message says "I owe this... but I plan to do this this and this... anything else" and because the LL says "ok thanks" she deliberately manipulates it as INSTEAD OF not IN ADDITION TO. Her entire defense was 'I suggested I do this, and he agreed to it'. I've had family do things like this.
You can rent an older small house in a small town or unincorporated area in the South for like $700 to $900. It was probably $600 when this was filmed. I know you are Canadian so maybe you can’t detect these people are American Southerners.
It’s not that old, maybe the last 2 years or so. Renting in the US is generally cheaper than in Canada. Even in NYC my rent for a 1 bedroom coop apartment is less than 1.5k
something doesn't add up here. They didn't move out in the middle of April, they moved out April 4 and I am pretty sure the landlord and told them that was fine. The landlord didn't show any damages at all, so if anything the deposit should have been applied to the rent that was allegedly owing. The defendants problem was poor record keeping on their part and being too trusting. I've known landlords like this that will give you the "well that's fine, don't worry about it" thing, then turn around and sue you. There is no way the landlord let them stay there for 3 months without paying rent, then had all those huge damages.
@@cb5156 She didn't because she said they owed 3 months rent. She applied the deposit to his alleged damages. I am surprised she never asked if there was a walk through since he is claiming damages. When she asked about that, he quickly starting backtracking and stumbling over his words about "well there was just some trash to remove so its no big deal". There is no way they painted the entire interior of the house, did repair works (none of which he disputed) and then he also had damages. I think the plaintiff is trying to get over. I think the DID pay rent in February (but they have no proof) and that the landlord was going to apply the damage deposit to March's rent (hence the 'just paint everything'). It makes perfectly good sense that they would have such an arrangement. JJ was being snotty for no reason
@@jdsiv3 I agree . Did you notice that he apparently combined his own trash with his tenant's when he did some work on the place after they left? He started to explain to JJ but she didn't want to hear it and never looked at the trash bill. The landlord just said he'd be satisfied with $595 and she gave it to him. That's a lot of money for a trash pickup. Maybe she was adding in their staying 3 days into April, she's a stickler on that (though prorating 3 days rent comes to less than $60.) JJ was really getting extra bitchy around that time and it shows in her rulings. I wonder if this was when she learned the new bosses at CBS were not renewing her golden contract.
My guess is that the grandparents were actually paying the rent on the place with their Social Security. When her grandmother died they couldn't pay the rent because they weren't getting her social security anymore.
So very sad 😢
Aah yes, that would explain it, makes sense, cheers 😊
Probably but I think the funeral expenses were likely a factor if MaMaw didn’t have life insurance. . She died in November. They didn’t stop paying until February.
@@anndeecosita3586 She says they paid in February just didn't have evidence of it (which is very possible given the method of payment).
Probably
Q: "When is rent due?"
A: "Well, it's not _past due_ until the 8th"
I can't stand people like that.
Totally could never give a straight answer. Arrrgh!
She thinks she’s being sneaky
Me neither! People who take grace periods literally are wild. Pay it NOW or BEFORE.
Duhh😮
i dont even understand what that even means? Can you explain it like how a 5 year old would understand?
After granny passed, they had to move. Wonder if they depended on her income for rent. Anyway, that smiling hubby was a big help.
LOL!
No, it was because it was too traumatic living in a house with someone who was dying, because they eventually died. Ha... she has an excuse for everything.
Agreed. He is a creepy looking dude.
You could tell that the defendant was dancing around the judge instead of giving her direct answers. Yeah, she owes the rent. Also, if she paid the rent, she should've provided proof. If she can't present her evidence in court, then the action didn't exist.
She really thought she was going to win. 😂😂😂😂😂
kk ...
I got the impression that hubby knew his wife was lying and trying to pull a scam.
At least the defendant’s husband is wise. He kept his mouth shut.
JJ should've asked the husband to sit down.
That stupid smirking and head shaking 🫨 was annoying.
I kept waiting for JJ to say, "look at me, don't look over there!"
Squatters and Their Sob Stories for a thousand please, Alex.
$500, $400 rent⁉️😳 Where⁉️
😂😂😂ok
IKR 😮
When I saw that judge judy ponytail, I was like wow!
In my state it’s $1600 and up . That’s 4times the amount . Which state is this
Exactly!!!!
What a big help her husband was😂😂😂😂😂😂
Her mouth is big enough for the both of them.
He knew she was wrong.
@@Spankmepink no, he doesn’t even know what day it is let alone know she was wrong.
@@nancybemak6646right! This is a man who obviously lets his wife handle all their affairs because "she's better at it than me" 🙄
@@nancybemak6646 And how did you come to that conclusion? You're an example of sexism at its peak.
Maybe in her fantasy head she believes what she is saying 🤣
Q: When is your rent due?
A; Well, Jesus of Nazareth was 33 when he died, so 9 years from now we'll have to paint.
😅😅😅😅😅
Judge Judy rules!!!
very surprised JJ didn't ask for the lease agreement and then hold it up and point to it saying "you can't have a verbal agreement. the for corners of this agreement is the entire agreement." she must have had a glass of wine at lunch
Past due on the 8th is GENEROUS!
Where the hell they live that rent is so cheap
Sounds like Kentucky.
It's North Carolina as was clearly depicted in the video clip...
@electricboogaloo347 calm down. North Carolina an entire state. Smdh
Mobile home?
@@21johnja I'm quite calm. It's Kenly, NC, as clearly depicted in the video. Some people...smdh.
400 and 500 dollars for rent, where do they live????
They're probably renting a room in someone's home now that granny passed away and isn't paying the rent anymore.
100% they were depending on the grandma's social security income.
Obviously, the Grandparents paid the rent. Making excuses at her age is pathetic. She tried to make it sound as if they were taking care of the Grandparents, when it was likely it was the other way around.
She considered the security deposit February's rent which is why she kept claiming they paid it but had no proof... and why they didn't countersue for the return of the security deposit.
I can’t stand ungrateful people. I can’t stand liars specially liars in court. You’re an old ass, adult act like one
society would change overnight if more people read the book Magnetic Aura by Takeshi Mizuki
That couple are a pain, she's evasive
Ugh I hate when litigants just can't answer the question.
Did they literally just come on TV to have Judge Judy pay their rent??
How hard is it to answer a question??
Well that was fair. All sorted out now. I am glad he won.
Defendant appears so confident, wonder how she would behave if she weren’t lying. JJ was too soft on her
His faces...😂
Will we know wears the pants in the defendants family 😂
Defendant is kinda person who lies in order not to tell the truth 😅
Yes, and she doesn't tell the truth so she can lie instead.
That husband is high as a kite.
That woman was insufferable and the man said nothing??? 😅😅😅😅 He might have been afraid of JJ 😂😂😂
I’m waiting to hear the husband speak…if she lets him speak.
Maybe he squeak instead of speak. 😊
I'm glad I stopped watching when Judge Judy ended and became Judy Justice or whatever. She had gotten so bitter over the years. It's an entertaining program, but she could lighten up some.
I love my JJ lunch fix
where can i pay $400 for rent ?!?!
It wasn't a hard case. They occupied the property for the three months they didn't pay rent for. I would have preferred he have the bill for the clean-up to settle the matter of the deposit. However, he's willing to let them skate on some of the damages because he made property improvements after they left, and they shouldn't be on the hook for those.
Once he made improvements, he kind of shot himself in the foot for it. You can't claim damages and have the tenant pay for the upgrade. He could only charge for the cleanup of the stuff that is actually theirs.
I wish my rent was $595.
since when, as a renter, is one allowed to paint the walls of the residence you're renting? I never knew that was an option.
Why they had to pay April's rent if they moved out on the 3rd ? A pro-rated amount for 3 days would have been fair
Two grown people who cannot come up with $595 rent. Sad.
Very.
😅😅😅😅😅😅😅 what a joke there actually the husband never opened his mouth we know who the boss is
defendant not likeable
afternoon lunch crew!
Her man didn't say a single word lmao
Might not have anything toothful to say.
He didn't need to say anything..... she lost the case easily on her own.
Prob saw JJ before and new better.
😂😂 Guess who's silent at home?
He would not be able to keep up with her lies...or understood them.
JJ didn't ask what they do for a living. I would like to know.
Scam artists
I hate it when renters assume they own the rental property and make major changes to the house. Turtle boy Defendant is a puppet, he's pussy whipped. His wife does all the talking and all the decision making in that relationship. The Plaintiff is a nice guy and he didn't deserve all this stress from these bums.
the truth feels dangerous, and that’s why the book Magnetic Aura by Takeshi Mizuki is ignored
They moved because granny died and they didn't have granny's check anymore
lan sau toi se khong oai si nua dau ma. Nhu the khien toi khong thay vui va thay dang ghe khi nhin nhung thu nhu the nay
the book Magnetic Aura by Takeshi Mizuki is what everyone avoids because it’s too real
She was very pretty .
What deadbeats 😅
they don’t want you to read the book Magnetic Aura by Takeshi Mizuki because it sets you free
I hate people like the defendant that twist things to get away with stuff.
Note the text message says "I owe this... but I plan to do this this and this... anything else" and because the LL says "ok thanks" she deliberately manipulates it as INSTEAD OF not IN ADDITION TO.
Her entire defense was 'I suggested I do this, and he agreed to it'.
I've had family do things like this.
In what fantasy world can your rent a house for $500? In Canada renting a whole house would be like 3-4k
These are older episodes.
You can rent an older small house in a small town or unincorporated area in the South for like $700 to $900. It was probably $600 when this was filmed. I know you are Canadian so maybe you can’t detect these people are American Southerners.
It’s not that old, maybe the last 2 years or so. Renting in the US is generally cheaper than in Canada. Even in NYC my rent for a 1 bedroom coop apartment is less than 1.5k
@@severenkoski856It’s not that old, check out JJ’s hairstyle 😮
@EliF-ge5bu This is from the late 2010s so last 5 years at least
chan that the la tet nam nay khong dam lam gi nua roi. Ke ca tien mua tu toi cung phai xem lai roi. Nhu the nay that qua dang qua di ma
everything you believe might crumble if you read the book Magnetic Aura by Takeshi Mizuki
She looks like Susan Smith.
something doesn't add up here. They didn't move out in the middle of April, they moved out April 4 and I am pretty sure the landlord and told them that was fine. The landlord didn't show any damages at all, so if anything the deposit should have been applied to the rent that was allegedly owing.
The defendants problem was poor record keeping on their part and being too trusting. I've known landlords like this that will give you the "well that's fine, don't worry about it" thing, then turn around and sue you. There is no way the landlord let them stay there for 3 months without paying rent, then had all those huge damages.
I wonder if JJ didn't consider it as she stated there was no counterclaim from the defendants for the deposit.
Several States have laws prohibiting deposit monies from being applied to rent owing.
@@cb5156 She didn't because she said they owed 3 months rent. She applied the deposit to his alleged damages. I am surprised she never asked if there was a walk through since he is claiming damages. When she asked about that, he quickly starting backtracking and stumbling over his words about "well there was just some trash to remove so its no big deal". There is no way they painted the entire interior of the house, did repair works (none of which he disputed) and then he also had damages. I think the plaintiff is trying to get over. I think the DID pay rent in February (but they have no proof) and that the landlord was going to apply the damage deposit to March's rent (hence the 'just paint everything'). It makes perfectly good sense that they would have such an arrangement. JJ was being snotty for no reason
@@jdsiv3 I agree . Did you notice that he apparently combined his own trash with his tenant's when he did some work on the place after they left? He started to explain to JJ but she didn't want to hear it and never looked at the trash bill. The landlord just said he'd be satisfied with $595 and she gave it to him. That's a lot of money for a trash pickup. Maybe she was adding in their staying 3 days into April, she's a stickler on that (though prorating 3 days rent comes to less than $60.) JJ was really getting extra bitchy around that time and it shows in her rulings. I wonder if this was when she learned the new bosses at CBS were not renewing her golden contract.
Where do these people stay ? My tenant pay 1500 for a small studio
First comment!! ✌🏽
🍪
You are indeed second.
I doubt it.
Defendants are idiots, she is a lair , brings no proof that they have paid rent.
This woman is useless