Every reaction video of this song starts the same way. They sing, the mouth drops open on the person watching, then Barry sings and the viewer stops grooving and stares at the screen.
What is it that you do not hear in the music no cursing, degrading of people, nothing about sex, no autotunes back in the late 1970s, the Gibb brothers pure music talent. We will never hear another group even come close to them. If you had a chance to see them in person it magical.
Natural, pure talent! No Auto tune. They wrote their songs. Robin sang with his hands on his hips, Maurice with his hands in his pockets! No effort, just pure talent.
Thiis is not autotune. It was not invented yet. This is how real artists with real talent sang. This is I believe 1978. One of the greatest bands ever.
That's the Munich Philharmonic Orchestra backing them up. Recorded on the International Day of Children in, I think '78. They donated the royalties to the song to the children's charity UNICEF forever...around $15 million so far. They wrote this song, 'Tragedy', and one for little brother Andy, 'Shadow Dancing' in the same day...all three #1 hits! No one except Sir Paul McCartney has written more hit songs than Sir Barry Gibb. Over 1,000 songs written for themselves, and some of the top voices in 3 different decades, and not a bad one in the lot! Enjoy the rabbit hole of ALL rabbit holes! 'Nights On Broadway', 'Alone', 'How Deep Is Your Love', 'Massachusetts', 'Fanny Be Tender With My Love', 'Tragedy', and 'Run To Me' are absolute must-listens! And you've probably heard 'Stayin' Alive'...most of the world has.
This music is from the studio recording from the LP. The video was shot after. You're not hearing what they may or may not be singing in the studio seen on this video.
@@Coowallsky - Although this is a multi-track recording, three tracks were silenced so they could actually sing along. The original recording had the instrument section from the band Chicago playing. That was silenced also so the MCO could play it.
@@tubularguynine we ran this side by side in a control room and it is verbatim from the LP. We had to work to offset the additional compression RUclips adds to most videos but once that was dialed in, spectrum analysis showed identical results. They may have ducked 3 vocals to sing it in the studio and maybe released the results as a different single for the UNICEF benefit but the music in this video is the same from the LP.
NO AUTOTUNE... Just Talent, skill and REAL Musicians! These guys not only wrote their own music, they created Number one hits for Other Artists and Soundtracks for Movies as well! From Kenny Rogers/Dolly Parton's "Islands in the Stream" to the Theme song from Grease and SATURDAY NIGHT FEVER, all the way to Celine Dion's "Immortality" And Barbara Streisand's "Guilty" (and a duet called "What kind of fool"), The Bee Gee's were THE REAL DEAL!
No auto tune all 3 are brothers. The guy on the left is Robin, middle Barry then Maurice nic name Mo. Robin and Mo were twins. Robin and Mo have passed away. They also had a another brother Andy. He also was a talented singer. He has also passed away. I love all 4 guys. Andy was a year older than me. Barry and I share the same birthday September 1st.
Late 70's totally 80's was their biggest popularity but they have had hits in 5 different decades!!! And that doesn't begin to get into ALL OF THE number one hits they wrote for other artists. They are GENIUSES when it comes to song writing. No, there was no auto tune. That was the real voices of the 3 brothers!! They were AMAZING. the Saturday Night Fever soundtrack is off the chain fabulous
That is pure, vocal perfection. These boys grew up just a bit up from me in Scarborough Queensland. Go past their old place on my way to my favourite chippie.
The brothers Gibb were spectacularly talented songwriters and singers. Pure artistry. They loved ad supported each other throughout life and their music always reflected it.
The BeeGees are iconic. One of the great groups in the 1960's onward. Three brothers that harmonize like no others. They had many, many hits over the years and wrote hit songs for themselves and others. Their catalog as singers and songwriters is immense. Staying Alive, How Deep Is Your Love, Night Fever, More Than A Woman, I Started A Joke, I've Got To Get A Message To You, Massachusetts, Nights On Broadway, Alone, Fanny Be Tender With Your Love, Tragedy, You Should Be Dancing, to name a few. A great dive into fantastic music.
These guys have been singing together since they were todlers, and they just got hooked. I cant imagine where you could do something your entire life from cradle to grave!
Kathy here - 33 brothers, one mic and no auto tune. Music that will never be duplicated. Glad to see the younger generation discovering the music I grew up on. Nothing better than some Bee Gee's, in the arms of your better half and just slowing dancing to their songs. Nothing better in my book, and I am almost 69 years old. Thanks for your review.
OK guys - typo here ! LOL 3 brothers, one mic! Give an old lady a break. I am sure I have seen, heard and danced to more music than you will ever experience! I was in a band for 15 years, lead female singer. I sang Tina Turner, Aretha Franklin, Stevie Nicks, mix in a little country every now and then, and then some of the best soul, R%B music ever made. My band was asked to "open" a new Night Club at the Sheraton Twin Towers at Univeral Studio (Someone recommended us) as they had not yet settled on a house band, said we would probably be there for 2 to 4 weekends. When I "turned in" my microphone after 15 years in the club, it was because I was pregnant at 40! But man, did we have the best music EVER! As some of those meme's say, "We were hippies, smoked, drank, wore bell bottoms, boys grew their hair out and started wearing earrings, but we had the best damn music of any era!"
This is not a live recording. This is the studio recording from the LP. The video was shot after. You're not hearing what they may or may not be singing in the studio seen on this video.
Auto tune didn’t exist but heavy post production did and Barry Gibb was skilled at it. Fanny Be Tender, one of my fave songs of all time, was so heavily produced that they didn’t perform it live because they struggled to make it sound like the recorded track. This song is also very heavily produced and highlights those skills. No need to pretend this is a natural sound.
I'm not sure how was I come across your reaction video but, I did somehow. And I've got to say, wow! You're so amazingly beautiful. I mean really. I mean crazy pretty. Shouldn't you be on television or something or some kind of beauty pageant? Anyways, I like your reaction to this video. Well, to the Bee Gees. They're one of my favorite groups ever.
These Bee Gee songs take me back to when Disco was starting to die out and the 80's were coming in with MTV. I've been a fan of theirs since my High School years in the 1960s. I sure miss those days.
It's always a blast to see a younger person who may have had to endure Beiber and the like get to experience the gems that only happened in the singer-songwriter days. The Bee Gees were one of those gems. I saw UFC on your videos so I know you like the grittier things too, so.... Here's a suggestion that I know you won't regret. Janis Joplin's "Cry Baby". Do the official studio version and not the live version. The official one is her sitting in a chair. I can't wait to see your reaction during the first 5 seconds. After that, you'll be able to breath but your jaw will be dropped fir the entire rest of that song.
No auto-tune till the mid-'90s, however, by the early '80s studio producers could (somewhat) effectively mask bad/subpar vocalists by altering their singing through electronic gadgetry.
Yup, there was no such thing as auto-tune back then. I don't think they had pitch correct or anything like that. They did some overdubbing to fill out the sound, but the pitch was there naturally.
Born in Britain raised in Australia the 3 Gibbs brothers made so many hits , almost entire soundtrack to Saturday Night Fever was there doing, they had a younger brother that also sang, Andy, this is Barry, and twins Morris and Robin
Yes, Maurice and Robin were twins. Became big in the mid to late 1960s with many hits and onwards after that. Please watch "Alone" and the Home videos that accompanies the song. It shows them performing at 10,8 and 8 years of age respectively in Australia.
One of the classics from the 70's (Disco era). Nobody and I mean nobody could harmonize like the Bee Gees. This is a live performance and no auto tune or mixing involved. And check it out.....They are all singing from one microphone instead of individual ones. I love your reaction.....caught you by surprise didn't it. Keep up the good work Maddy. Alway like your reactions.
No computers, no auto-tune, just three amazingly talented Brothers singing their hearts out in front of a gorgeous Orchestra.
THIS is Music ❤
Auto tune did not exist back then. Just genuine talent.
"They can sing" made me laugh.
Understatement of the year.
You know why us Boomers say, we lived through the best generation of music ever!
Indeed
Yep!
yes we did
the 60's was peace and love, the 80's was making money but the 70's was the party, huuuuuuuuuuuuuura
Every reaction video of this song starts the same way. They sing, the mouth drops open on the person watching, then Barry sings and the viewer stops grooving and stares at the screen.
Why would you need Auto tune if you have talent.And there was no Auto tune then people made it on raw talent you either have it or you don't.
Number 1 all over the world. All royalties received went to UNICEF.
kings of falsetto , loved Bee Gees when i was a kid in the 70's , this happens to be my favorite
What is it that you do not hear in the music no cursing, degrading of people, nothing about sex, no autotunes back in the late 1970s, the Gibb brothers pure music talent. We will never hear another group even come close to them. If you had a chance to see them in person it magical.
*Autotune? That the 70's...that wasn't event invented. It's called vocal talent*
Natural, pure talent! No Auto tune. They wrote their songs. Robin sang with his hands on his hips, Maurice with his hands in his pockets! No effort, just pure talent.
great era of music the best era in time to grow up in.
It's all there. Their own voices and won't be anymore like them ever!!!
Autotune wasn't invented yet when this came out. This was from a magical time when people had to have real talent to make it.
Thiis is not autotune. It was not invented yet. This is how real artists with real talent sang. This is I believe 1978. One of the greatest bands ever.
The biggest group for several decades
1978 the Brothers Gibb.... the BeeGees❤
No such thing as Auto tune back then...This is pure talent, and hard work!
No autotune back then. Just real, legit, on-point singing.
The Ladies always enjoy it when a man expresses his love and emotions to her. Songs from the '70s & '80s did that best.
Quincy Jones said, " those brothers singing harmonies have an instrument no one else has".
That's the Munich Philharmonic Orchestra backing them up. Recorded on the International Day of Children in, I think '78. They donated the royalties to the song to the children's charity UNICEF forever...around $15 million so far. They wrote this song, 'Tragedy', and one for little brother Andy, 'Shadow Dancing' in the same day...all three #1 hits! No one except Sir Paul McCartney has written more hit songs than Sir Barry Gibb. Over 1,000 songs written for themselves, and some of the top voices in 3 different decades, and not a bad one in the lot! Enjoy the rabbit hole of ALL rabbit holes! 'Nights On Broadway', 'Alone', 'How Deep Is Your Love', 'Massachusetts', 'Fanny Be Tender With My Love', 'Tragedy', and 'Run To Me' are absolute must-listens! And you've probably heard 'Stayin' Alive'...most of the world has.
This music is from the studio recording from the LP.
The video was shot after. You're not hearing what they may or may not be singing in the studio seen on this video.
@@Coowallsky - Although this is a multi-track recording, three tracks were silenced so they could actually sing along. The original recording had the instrument section from the band Chicago playing. That was silenced also so the MCO could play it.
@@tubularguynine we ran this side by side in a control room and it is verbatim from the LP. We had to work to offset the additional compression RUclips adds to most videos but once that was dialed in, spectrum analysis showed identical results. They may have ducked 3 vocals to sing it in the studio and maybe released the results as a different single for the UNICEF benefit but the music in this video is the same from the LP.
@@Coowallsky - So they got the Munich Philharmonic Orchestra to come and pretend to play? Chicago played the original recording.
@@tubularguynine Again, I'm not sure if the Munich Philahrmonic session was ever released as a single. I knew Chicago played on the LP version.
It's like the three of them share one voice.
Right!!!
It's because they're brothers and they share the same DNA. It makes a difference.
Family members who possess singing talent are able to harmonize with near perfection.
Timeless tunes.
no autotune and all singing into 1 mike!!!!
If you want perfection musically, it’s The Bee Gees, a gorgeous R&B Bee Gees song is LOVE SO RIGHT. ❤❤❤
Definitely!!!
That family simply oozed pure talent. Their range, harmony and song writing skills are second to none. The Brothers Brilliant never disappoint!
Those harmonies are on a different level
NO AUTOTUNE... Just Talent, skill and REAL Musicians! These guys not only wrote their own music, they created Number one hits for Other Artists and Soundtracks for Movies as well!
From Kenny Rogers/Dolly Parton's "Islands in the Stream" to the Theme song from Grease and SATURDAY NIGHT FEVER, all the way to Celine Dion's "Immortality" And Barbara Streisand's "Guilty" (and a duet called "What kind of fool"), The Bee Gee's were THE REAL DEAL!
I was a kid and they ruled the airways from 1973-1980 … incredible talent. Check out their younger brother, Andy Gibb, too.
They did have Auto tune in the 70's, but we just called it Talent.
No auto tune all 3 are brothers. The guy on the left is Robin, middle Barry then Maurice nic name Mo. Robin and Mo were twins. Robin and Mo have passed away. They also had a another brother Andy. He also was a talented singer. He has also passed away. I love all 4 guys. Andy was a year older than me. Barry and I share the same birthday September 1st.
Amazing
The Bee Gees were the greatest ever! Their music touches your heart and soul!!
They were masters of the falsetto.
Late 70's totally 80's was their biggest popularity but they have had hits in 5 different decades!!! And that doesn't begin to get into ALL OF THE number one hits they wrote for other artists. They are GENIUSES when it comes to song writing. No, there was no auto tune. That was the real voices of the 3 brothers!! They were AMAZING. the Saturday Night Fever soundtrack is off the chain fabulous
Ah the Brothers Gibb, they started in the 60's and then morphed into the disco of the 70's, back when they really played vinyl on the radio lol
Their 'high" singing is called falsetto. My fav song from them is "Fanny, Be Tender With My Love."
No auto tune just pure talent
That is pure, vocal perfection. These boys grew up just a bit up from me in Scarborough Queensland. Go past their old place on my way to my favourite chippie.
Didn't autotune then. You earned it....
The brothers Gibb were spectacularly talented songwriters and singers. Pure artistry. They loved ad supported each other throughout life and their music always reflected it.
bee gees emotion
💖💖💖💖
No auto tune Maddy just pure voices..
The BeeGees are iconic. One of the great groups in the 1960's onward. Three brothers that harmonize like no others. They had many, many hits over the years and wrote hit songs for themselves and others. Their catalog as singers and songwriters is immense. Staying Alive, How Deep Is Your Love, Night Fever, More Than A Woman, I Started A Joke, I've Got To Get A Message To You, Massachusetts, Nights On Broadway, Alone, Fanny Be Tender With Your Love, Tragedy, You Should Be Dancing, to name a few. A great dive into fantastic music.
Most of their greatest tunes were never played on the radio!
These guys have been singing together since they were todlers, and they just got hooked. I cant imagine where you could do something your entire life from cradle to grave!
This is what a real love song sounds like
There was no auto tune these are talented people who can sing.
Kathy here - 33 brothers, one mic and no auto tune. Music that will never be duplicated. Glad to see the younger generation discovering the music I grew up on. Nothing better than some Bee Gee's, in the arms of your better half and just slowing dancing to their songs. Nothing better in my book, and I am almost 69 years old. Thanks for your review.
33?? There's 30 more of them with this talent...wow....
That's funny!
OK guys - typo here ! LOL 3 brothers, one mic! Give an old lady a break. I am sure I have seen, heard and danced to more music than you will ever experience! I was in a band for 15 years, lead female singer. I sang Tina Turner, Aretha Franklin, Stevie Nicks, mix in a little country every now and then, and then some of the best soul, R%B music ever made. My band was asked to "open" a new Night Club at the Sheraton Twin Towers at Univeral Studio (Someone recommended us) as they had not yet settled on a house band, said we would probably be there for 2 to 4 weekends. When I "turned in" my microphone after 15 years in the club, it was because I was pregnant at 40! But man, did we have the best music EVER! As some of those meme's say, "We were hippies, smoked, drank, wore bell bottoms, boys grew their hair out and started wearing earrings, but we had the best damn music of any era!"
@@Blondemom2855 Thanks, Kathy .
Great reply but lucky I didn't mention the unnecessary apostrophe in " Nothing better than some Bee Gee's,"...😀
@@Isleofskye LOL
Pure talent no AUTO Tune
Talent talent and more talent😊
Beautiful
Barry gibb still can hit the high notes today
This whole song is just too much heaven. Love it. Love the guys
So true!!
This is real. There was no autotube when this was recorded. Singers could sing!!!
This was a live recording before autotune was created
This is not a live recording. This is the studio recording from the LP.
The video was shot after. You're not hearing what they may or may not be singing in the studio seen on this video.
old but gollllddd
100%
Auto tune didn’t exist but heavy post production did and Barry Gibb was skilled at it. Fanny Be Tender, one of my fave songs of all time, was so heavily produced that they didn’t perform it live because they struggled to make it sound like the recorded track. This song is also very heavily produced and highlights those skills. No need to pretend this is a natural sound.
Every singer back then had to have pure talent in order to get near a microphone! No auto tune existed.
Bee Gees-alone
Disco era
Yep, real talent. Welcome to the 70s.
Holy shit they can sing!
Love your reaction when you realise these boys can sing, lol
Loved your reaction. No such thing as auto-tune back then.
I'm not sure how was I come across your reaction video but, I did somehow.
And I've got to say, wow! You're so amazingly beautiful. I mean really. I mean crazy pretty. Shouldn't you be on television or something or some kind of beauty pageant?
Anyways, I like your reaction to this video. Well, to the Bee Gees. They're one of my favorite groups ever.
100% pure natural music,. One take. Live,. Nothing artificial..
I listened to this back in high school 80's on cassettes and Walkman 😮
Barry was told to sing high, there is a documentary out. Really good
Glad to see you are into The Bee Gees Ms. Maddy.❤
Nothing like family harmony
Exactly Maddy ❤ Bee Gees are in a different league all together ❤
These Bee Gee songs take me back to when Disco was starting to die out and the 80's were coming in with MTV. I've been a fan of theirs since my High School years in the 1960s.
I sure miss those days.
It's always a blast to see a younger person who may have had to endure Beiber and the like get to experience the gems that only happened in the singer-songwriter days. The Bee Gees were one of those gems. I saw UFC on your videos so I know you like the grittier things too, so.... Here's a suggestion that I know you won't regret. Janis Joplin's "Cry Baby". Do the official studio version and not the live version. The official one is her sitting in a chair. I can't wait to see your reaction during the first 5 seconds. After that, you'll be able to breath but your jaw will be dropped fir the entire rest of that song.
Bee Gees - Falsetto is the voice style they are using
Ya there voices are called talent
They are brothers. They also have another brother named Andy Gibb. He's a singer worth listening to also
Of course you do 💯1️⃣🎵🎶🦘🌅🇦🇺💯🇦🇺
Incredible moment, incredible voices...magical moments...thanks Maddy!!
Great Band! Great Track! Great Reaction!!!! Thank You so Much ✌ Subbed and Thumbed ✌✌✌ 🇦🇺
No auto-tune till the mid-'90s, however, by the early '80s studio producers could (somewhat) effectively mask bad/subpar vocalists by altering their singing through electronic gadgetry.
Autotune didn't come out until the late 90's. This was when singers knew how to sing.
I LIKE YOU and Your so PRETTY Maddy!❤🥰
Yep. Released 1978.
Watch how dreamy Barry’s eyes get. Thinking of Linda. Married over 50 years. ❤
Yup, there was no such thing as auto-tune back then. I don't think they had pitch correct or anything like that. They did some overdubbing to fill out the sound, but the pitch was there naturally.
When a song sounds like it is just for that one special person in their life, it hits the heart and stays there !@
Born in Britain raised in Australia the 3 Gibbs brothers made so many hits , almost entire soundtrack to Saturday Night Fever was there doing, they had a younger brother that also sang, Andy, this is Barry, and twins Morris and Robin
Yes, Maurice and Robin were twins. Became big in the mid to late 1960s with many hits and onwards after that.
Please watch "Alone" and the Home videos that accompanies the song. It shows them performing at 10,8 and 8 years of age respectively in Australia.
Back when actual talent was the thing that made you successful. 99.9% of todays music pales in comparison.
I'm so happy to see young people discover and enjoy such great music from the past
They were this good. And they passed too early
They was at a Benefit for UNICEF BeeGees donated all their proceeds to the cause.
Autotune wasn’t even Invented yet. All Natural.
All the royalties from this song go to UNICEF... I THINK it's $10 million to date....
Yes, you're correct. That needs to be emphasized more often. 👍
ozzie osborne crazy train is good one
There is no autotune because they have been singing since the 60s
One of the classics from the 70's (Disco era). Nobody and I mean nobody could harmonize like the Bee Gees. This is a live performance and no auto tune or mixing involved. And check it out.....They are all singing from one microphone instead of individual ones. I love your reaction.....caught you by surprise didn't it. Keep up the good work Maddy. Alway like your reactions.
Yes they can sing. Read up on their history and please play more. Barry in the middle has been married to same woman for over 50 years.
I grew up in the 70s so I experienced them as their songs were released. Now we only have Barry left of the 4 brothers Gibb, (Andy performed solo).
….. This Trio of the 70’s took all of the Grammys 🏆.
They can sing!😂