Tap to unmute

WATCH LIVE: Amber Heard Testifies in Defamation Trial - Johnny Depp v Amber Heard Day 16

Share
Embed
  • Published on May 15, 2022
  • LIVE COVERAGE: Johnny Depp v Amber Heard Defamation Trial
    Happening in court:
    Day 16
    Amber Heard Testifies in Defamation Trial - Johnny Depp v Amber Heard
    Actor Johnny Depp is suing ex-wife Amber Heard for $50 million for defamation in connection with Heard’s 2018 Washington Post op-ed, in which she spoke out about being the victim of domestic violence. Heard’s article did not specifically name Depp as her alleged abuser, but according to Depp’s lawsuit, it relied “on the central premise that Ms. Heard was a domestic abuse victim and that Mr. Depp perpetrated domestic violence against her.” Amber Heard is counter-suing Depp for $100 million.
    The defamation trial began Monday in Fairfax County Circuit Court in Virginia, with jury selection completing on the same day. There is a possibility of celebrity witnesses testifying, including James Franco and Elon Musk. Tune in to the Law&Crime Network for daily coverage of this high-profile trial.
    Sign Up For Law&Crime's Daily Newsletter! bit.ly/LawandCrimeNewsletter
    Watch Law&Crime Network NOW on RUclipsTV!
    tv.ruclips.net/user/welcome?...
    OTHER WAYS TO WATCH LAW&CRIME NETWORK IN YOUR AREA:
    lawandcrime.com/where-to-watch/
    READ MORE GREAT ARTICLES FROM LAW&CRIME NETWORK HERE:
    lawandcrime.com
    LAW&CRIME NETWORK SOCIAL MEDIA:
    Instagram: lawandcrime
    Twitter: LawCrimeNetwork
    Facebook: lawandcrime
    Twitch: www.twitch.tv/lawandcrimenetwork
    LAW&CRIME NETWORK PODCASTS:
    Coptales&Cocktails Apple Podcast:
    podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast...
    Law&Crime Sidebar:
    podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast...
    SUBSCRIBE TO ALL OF LAW&CRIME NETWORK RUclips CHANNELS:
    Main Channel: ruclips.net/channel/UCz8K...
    Channel B: ruclips.net/channel/UCVXO...
    Channel C: ruclips.net/channel/UCXCL...
    Channel D ruclips.net/channel/UCMV3...
  • EntertainmentEntertainment

Comments • 2 375

  • kevin ross
    kevin ross 4 months ago +1603

    The trial starts at 17:03
    It takes a break at 1:44:18
    It comes back at 2:07:58
    It takes a break at 3:48:28
    Recap of the trial starts at 3:51:06 until 4:50:22
    The trial comes back at 4:54:02
    It takes a break at 6:17:12
    It comes back at 6:56:48
    You can click on the timestamp in my comment and it takes you to that point of the video. Just in case someone didn't know.

  • Cmjmilo100
    Cmjmilo100 4 months ago +664

    As a DM survivor, after getting hit in the side of the face, the pain and swelling were so severe that I couldn’t talk or eat for a day after. And no amount of makeup was going to hid that. My eyes were so puffy from crying I could barely open them. But sure Amber, he hit you repeatedly and you went on your merry way to events and photo shoots with no swelling, no cuts from the rings, smiling ear to ear. She is a disgrace to all DV victims. She is an Abuser.

    • Nicole Besser
      Nicole Besser 4 hours ago

      @Christie Jensen No it does not.

    • Nic J
      Nic J 2 months ago

      @T Starr so true

    • Moon Orchid
      Moon Orchid 2 months ago +1

      @Madison Clarke and arnica doesn’t reduce swelling. It helps heal bruises but takes a couple days lol

    • Madison Clarke
      Madison Clarke 2 months ago +1

      “But but bruise kit & ice & amica!” 🤣🙄 Ice won’t take down the amount of swelling that comes with a broken nose in 24 hours or less. Her lawyers constantly griping on “natural makeup” too. No matter how good you or the artists that make you up are, no natural looking makeup that fools everyone into thinking you have none on will cover a bruise!

    • Dhillon Webster
      Dhillon Webster 3 months ago

      THIS COMMENT RIGHT HERE NEEDS TO BE MOVED TO THE TOP

  • Naomi Prusakiewicz
    Naomi Prusakiewicz 4 months ago +178

    I can’t believe the Judge even allows AHs female lawyer to continually argue against objections even when she’s already sustained the objection. So irritating to hear

    • stancexpunks
      stancexpunks Day ago

      Judge penny seems like a super nice, fair judge 😊

    • Madison Clarke
      Madison Clarke 2 months ago +2

      That was so unprofessional to me. I get trying to validate yourself when objected to, but arguing with the judge or trying to repeatedly say “I said what if any.” Like Judge Penny finally told Elaine, “what if any is not a fix all.”

    • king of ace
      king of ace 3 months ago

      Which time?

    • Delicia A. Chung
      Delicia A. Chung 4 months ago +5

      Omg she gets me so annoyed w “how is this hearsay?” Like sis….

    • Lie*Lac
      Lie*Lac 4 months ago +9

      i definitely wish the judge would step in more with AH and her lawyer

  • Bully Maguire
    Bully Maguire 4 months ago +505

    The way she kept repeating "yes I pledged it" when asked if she actually donated the 7 mil. Oh lord. Somebody tell her she is in court

    • BreakingPhobia103
      BreakingPhobia103 2 months ago

      Dearest bully maguire, you got to put some dirt in Amber’s eye.

    • Seeking the Truth
      Seeking the Truth 2 months ago

      @Be Real All the money that was donated came from JD or EM. AH donated $0 and recently even said that she didn't have to donate the money even though she was telling everyone that she had donated it all.

    • Be Real
      Be Real 3 months ago

      @Pichii Keen he didn't pay her debts or give her a penthouse. The one was pledged to pay in installments to avoid tax ramifications and she was working with ucla and the children's hospital for whom she has worked for many years. Her legal fees have been 6 million divorcing depp and up to date with him suing HOW could she pay the 7 mill in total! She had paid out of her divorce money over a million before he sued

    • Nicholas Davis
      Nicholas Davis 4 months ago

      Lol

    • #W✿
      #W✿ 4 months ago +5

      ​@The Energy Center® She will win! The title of the worst liar in history. Everyone can see through her lies, by wanting to humilliate Johnny she is humiliating herself.

  • Introvert, Honey
    Introvert, Honey 4 months ago +1051

    “Pledge” and “payment” are synonymous?? I’ve been paying bills all these years when I could have pledged? Thank you, Amber, for revealing your knowledge of English words and their definitions.

    • Nicole Besser
      Nicole Besser 4 hours ago

      Weird. Bills are for services rendered not donations for a cause with nothing in return. I am guessing that you have never donated other than maybe to the bell ringers during the holidays. Usually with large donations, they are pledged to be made over a course of time. Like 7 million over 10 years. What an awful comparison. Thank you for revealing your knowledge of charity, English words, and their definitions.
      Pledge- a solemn promise or undertaking.
      "the conference ended with a joint pledge to limit pollution"
      Similar:
      promise
      undertaking
      vow
      word
      word of honor
      commitment
      assurance
      oath
      covenant
      bond
      agreement
      guarantee
      warrant
      2.
      LAW
      a thing that is given as security for the fulfillment of a contract or the payment of a debt and is liable to forfeiture in the event of failure.
      Donation- Dictionary

      Definitions from Oxford Languages · Learn more
      Search for a word
      do·na·tion
      /dōˈnāSH(ə)n/
      Learn to pronounce
      noun
      something that is given to a charity, especially a sum of money.
      "a tax-deductible donation of $200"
      Similar:
      gift
      contribution
      subscription
      present
      handout
      grant
      offering
      gratuity
      endowment
      bestowal
      giving
      charity
      benefaction
      largesse
      alms
      donative
      Opposite:
      receipt
      the action of donating something.
      "the donation of carpets, chairs, and cutlery"
      Feedback
      Translations and more definitions
      People also ask
      What is the true meaning of donation?
      Definition of donation
      : the act or an instance of donating: such as. a : the making of a gift especially to a charity or public institution. b : a free contribution : gift.
      Both a pledge and a donation result in donors giving money or goods to a nonprofit. But the big difference between a donation and a pledge is the timing. A donation describes the immediate exchange of money or goods from a donor. A pledge is the promised exchange of money or goods from a donor.
      She had a 10 year agreement and had been paying for two years until the lawsuit became a factor. She was honoring her pledge as testified by the organization she had both pledged and donated to.
      Bill-.
      an amount of money owed for goods supplied or services rendered, set out in a printed or written statement of charges.
      It is actually scary that you recieved so many likes for something so utterly ignorant.

    • Sherry Williams
      Sherry Williams Day ago

      Lol right

    • Elisabeth D
      Elisabeth D Month ago

      @Davionious the thing is she already had the whole $7 million dollar divorce settlement she told everyone on national tv that she had "already donated" "that it was gone" for a whole 13 months before Johnny sued her. She didn't know he was going to sue her over the op ed so why did she hold onto and spend some of the money over that year instead of turn it over as she said she was going to? Make it make sense...

  • Karen Garrison
    Karen Garrison 4 months ago +224

    AH came off as manipulative, combative, narcissistic; and absolutely creepy turning to the jury ... the complete opposite of JD's composure on the stand.
    This is the difference between a man being secure in his convictions, and a woman desperate to have anyone believe her sins

    • Be Real
      Be Real 3 months ago

      @Kayden Reece 👍👍👏👏

    • Angela Brink
      Angela Brink 4 months ago +5

      I totally understand looking at the jury, I have had to testify and get that you are supposed to engage with them. That being said I always felt that when someone does it to every question it comes off disingenuous and manipulative.

    • Bob The dope man
      Bob The dope man 4 months ago +7

      @Alicia Jacquelene right? She will look at the jury to just say " yes" or "no" REPEATEDLY back and forth. Its unnatural.

    • Angel
      Angel 4 months ago +1

      Very well said.

    • Alicia Jacquelene
      Alicia Jacquelene 4 months ago +8

      @Kayden Reece you’re supposed to occasionally glance over to them, not stare them down like Amber is doing. The witness box is right next to the jury box - they are very close to each other and so her incessant staring can come off as very aggressive.

  • Antonella
    Antonella 4 months ago +127

    AH disgusts me so much : she's damaging the image of real domestic violence victims. Lately, I have been seeing many comments like "oh, if she was truly scared, she would have changed the locks and leave" but, on the case of a real domestic violence victim, that's almost impossible since they are psychologically and financially dependent of their abuser. I hope people will see this comment so that they will stop developing a lack of empathy for characteristics that are inherent to domestic violence victims, just because, unfortunately, AH tries to imitate them. Its very sad.

    • Madison Clarke
      Madison Clarke 2 months ago +1

      @The Energy Center® I have read some of your past comments in support of AH & I just wanted to comment here & commend you for admitting your realization. As a DV survivor myself, I believed her in 2016, but this trial has definitely opened my eyes. I went into this on no side with an open mind & quickly realized she displays so many characteristics of my abuser. Reactive violence can and does happen, but we definitely don’t taunt our abusers & laugh when they’re raging, or beg, plead, and cry for them to come back when they’re walking away from us. Also, her saying she barely survived or was nearly killed, something along those lines, was very telling to me. Someone who barely survives ends up in the hospital at least once, no ifs ands or buts about it. Trying to protect someone or not, if you’re beaten to the point of bear death you will be in the hospital. You might not tell the MDs what happened, but you’ll be there.

    • eeviegrl
      eeviegrl 3 months ago +3

      Yes, because ah could have gotten away.She definitely had the money to do so. I was afraid of my abuser n wouldn’t have done anything to make him even angrier. Everything made him angrier , I lived on eggshells. This woman had no fear. Her acting skills stunk also. She could atleast pushed out a tear. 😢see I can do it....lol Anyway,,,,I’m happy Johnny won his suit, I hope those that turned their back on him or just believed amber without even listening to the case, hearing the facts...tsk,tsk,tsk. Incredible. I hope he gets the apologies he deserv🎉. Ok I’m done

    • Be Real
      Be Real 3 months ago +1

      I agree with your statement on what d.v. victims look like but we cannot despite the verdict assume that she is lying. There are sides to depp that have come out in this trial that show clearly his jealous controlling raging threatening behaviours. There isn't a perfect 'victim' and im ot saying she was an angel but I don't believe she is lying about all of this.... ppl say she is lying and yeah I think some points she is but he is equally lying about a lot of things as well

    • Be Real
      Be Real 3 months ago +1

      @The Energy Center® did you also listen to the audio of him screaming at her when he is recording her without her permission and the rage in his voice

    • The Energy Center®
      The Energy Center® 4 months ago +8

      ok so I just listened to the audio of AH mocking JD with this maniacal crazy laughter. So I missed that. That now changes how I view AH.

  • Rebecca Walter
    Rebecca Walter 4 months ago +228

    Crazy she remembers everything that benefits her but can’t recall anything is her cross examination.

  • Slivress Sliver
    Slivress Sliver 4 months ago +145

    It is mind blowing how someone can hard core act their way through real LIFE. Out of touch, and really flat out creepy. Such false outrage and real arrogance. 🥴

  • Fabio De Rossi
    Fabio De Rossi 4 months ago +293

    As someone who’s been surrounded by addicts and addiction specialists, and having went to school to become an addiction counselor (not finished though), I’ve never heard of horribly abusive, especially sexually abusive, people just magically become all better when sober. Being abusive is character flaw in and of itself, it’s not a side effect of addiction. Aggressive violent people may become MORE aggressive when in active addiction, but it’s pretty unheard of for someone who’s almost never been physically aggressive to become an abusive monster while in active addiction, and then suddenly change back completely while sober. For most people, the real work begins with sobriety. That’s when the character changes start happening slowly over time. It’s not an immediate process, rather it takes a lot work with a sponsor, a program, and therapy. Not to mention a ton of lifestyle changes. Sometimes even medications to treat the underlying disorders that cause irrational violent behavior. But I’ve never seen all of the changes happen immediately.

    • Elisabeth D
      Elisabeth D Month ago +1

      Amber also said how on Thanksgiving he was drinking and doing coc and he hit her upstairs and broke her wine glass and was beating on her and then they went back to the party with smiles on and continued the fighting after everyone left. So he's able to control himself when he's in a blind rage like that and be nice and happy and act like nothings wrong and not come off high and drunk and then the moster comes back out once everyone leaves? C'mon... her lies and stories are ridiculous

    • Be Real
      Be Real 3 months ago

      @J B I do agree wholeheartedly with your comment. I've also seen this with alcoholics and alcohol excesses 👍

    • J B
      J B 3 months ago +1

      @Be Real for sure, I view alcoholism as a side effect of something underlying. Being dry doesn't mean that they are magically fixed. I see often that alcoholics lack the ability to have healthy communication where they share their difficult, honest emotions in constructive ways and know how to handle them. They often lack proper boundaries. Their self hatred will fuel them to feel as though they are not good enough. I see where they go from almost acting like kind doormats when sober to being raging monsters who are getting all the bad feels out that they don't know how to express in healthy ways when sober.
      I won't say that they can be magically "fixed" but that they are magically a completely different person, like jekyll and hyde... Hyde was a very unhealthy person which is why he created Hyde.

  • Madonna Sackman
    Madonna Sackman 4 months ago +209

    I really have tried to watch this trial objectively, but Amber Heard presents so poorly. Every second I watch her on the stand I dislike her more. I will be shocked if the jury decides in her favor. She comes across so disingenuous. The part she is playing is so overacted. I think they had a horrible marriage and brought the worst out in each other, but I think she was the aggressor and instigator. Just comes across as a horrible human being.

    • Madison Clarke
      Madison Clarke 2 months ago +1

      @Polina Sumina that was too much for me. The wailing but then 5 minutes later with the next question totally fine. If you went through something that truly horrific & had to relive it, you wouldn’t be calm and collected at a mere topic change.

    • Perfectly You Beauty
      Perfectly You Beauty 3 months ago +1

      @The Energy Center® well guess that’s not the case as it has been settled in JDs favor

    • T Starr
      T Starr 4 months ago +4

      I still think there is a good chance Johnny will lose the case, but he has won public opinion for sure. I do think their relationship was abusive but Amber's exaggeration makes her unbelievable to me. I've had coldsores bleed through lipstick and make it hard to smile, but she can laugh with a split lip. A splinter has hurt so much I couldn't put pressure on my foot but she can walk around and not need medical treatment after her feet were completely cut up from broken glass. She had time to think about poor Kate Moss and immediately react to protect her sister. Maybe she's just tougher than me.

    • Joy Walden
      Joy Walden 4 months ago +5

      Agreed! I tried to come into watching this unbiased as well but AH is despicable 🤢

    • Funky B
      Funky B 4 months ago +1

      Well said .

  • Ty
    Ty 4 months ago +228

    She’s so melodramatic. She wanted her name cleared, but she created this Karma because of her abusive nature. She says she was entitled to more than the $7 million, but didn’t ask for it because she didn’t want money. Right. She claims her career was hurt because of divorce but that’s because she created that fiasco. If she didn’t call the police twice, then who did.
    She’s talking about how she didn’t have time to grieve her moms death, because of this. Yet so did Johnny. His mom passed and she created issues for him the same day.

    • Be Real
      Be Real 3 months ago

      If you'd watched it you'd know I. O. Called the cops, btw depp is incredibly melodramatic but you just don't see it

    • cayden crawford
      cayden crawford 4 months ago +2

      @The Energy Center® how you feel now lmao heard is a liar it’s clear bud y’all lost

    • Katherine H
      Katherine H 4 months ago +4

      @The Energy Center® your naive or a troll...

    • The Energy Center®
      The Energy Center® 4 months ago +1

      Wrong. JD became a monster from drugs and alcohol and Amber has proven this. Amber was telling the truth. Amber will win.

  • Samantha M
    Samantha M 4 months ago +54

    I love how Amber says there is a "smear campaign" against her as if it is some sort of conspiracy. This is what happens when you get caught in horrific lies in front of the whole world. You hurt ACTUAL victims when you do this. She should face consequences for her actions and lies.

    • stancexpunks
      stancexpunks Day ago

      If anything, amber was the author behind her smear campaign

    • The Energy Center®
      The Energy Center® 4 months ago

      Amber was telling the truth. Amber will win.. JD had a major drug / alcohol problem which alters personality..............

    • Antonella
      Antonella 4 months ago +3

      That's exactly one of the reasons why she disgusts me so much! She's damaging the image of real domestic violence victims. Lately, I have been seeing many comments like "oh, if she was truly scared, she would have changed the locks and leave" but, on the case of a real domestic violence victim, that's almost impossible since they are psychologically and financially dependent of their abuser. Thanks to AH people have been developing a lack of empathy for characteristics that are inherent to domestic violence victims, but that, unfortunately, AH imitates. Its very sad

    • nieooj gotoy
      nieooj gotoy 4 months ago +1

      so much personal info out there says a lot & hopefully more men will come forward. To be honest I’ve never watched a JD movie or even heard of Amber til this trial.

  • Nanimo
    Nanimo 4 months ago +1252

    Camille did an EXCELLENT job. She was incredibly efficient and laser-focused. Every thing she presented for Amber to answer, she had proof when Amber (predictably) lied about it. Just really great work!

    • Elisabeth D
      Elisabeth D Month ago

      @Davionious you don't even make sense. You say johnny overlooked the evidence but then in the same sentence say he objected to it being admitted... anyone who defends her seems to have the mentality of a gnat.

    • Seeking the Truth
      Seeking the Truth 2 months ago

      @Nik Hearsay is that you are saying something that you heard from someone else. If that testimony is important then the person that saw it should be testifying not someone else.

    • Seeking the Truth
      Seeking the Truth 2 months ago

      @Davionious The therapist notes are not admissible because they are notes of what Amber said. There is no proof that they are lies or the truth.

    • Seeking the Truth
      Seeking the Truth 2 months ago

      @Beaver4119 Camille proved that Amber lied and lied

    • Seeking the Truth
      Seeking the Truth 2 months ago

      @Vanessa Almanza Just that Amber lied and lied

  • taegi are still savage
    taegi are still savage 4 months ago +103

    She did a good job showing everyone how Amber heard didn't focus on her injuries, went to talk shows the next day not zoning out or looking sad at all... Showed the world how she enjoyed taking pictures of her husband in the pretence of mental health examination, only to not send them to the people who look after johnnys addiction and health problems.. but sent it to her friends to belittle him instead ... Not only that she also proved how Amber set up most of the scenes to take pictures of his cocaine addiction but didn't take a picture of johnny in the act not even once😂 and most importantly if someone believes she didn't need immediate medical assistance after that bottle being shoved in her money maker... I'll loose hope in humanity

    • kris
      kris 4 months ago

      @The Energy Center® k

    • Chandra Jones
      Chandra Jones 4 months ago +5

      Not only that but if her friends really saw all of those injuries they should've taken her to a dr or straight to the police dept. Amber had rn9ugh if her own money to leave. She was not dependent on him for money.

  • Miss Sways
    Miss Sways 4 months ago +78

    Love how JD’s lawyer is annihilating AH with clear, concise, no BS, straight to the point line of questioning. They are exposing AH’s inconsistencies and lies as AH is under oath while revealing AH’s true nature as a manipulative human being out to destroy JD and his reputation. Hope JD gets the justice he deserves and AH gets the karma see sowed for herself.

    • Big D
      Big D 4 months ago +2

      And she’s bringing out the 👿 in AH.

  • Pradeep Mamidi
    Pradeep Mamidi 4 months ago +393

    There is so much satisfaction when you see a liar being exposed.

    • Seeking the Truth
      Seeking the Truth 2 months ago +1

      @elaine brown She used the same picture for different incidents after it was changed to look brighter.

    • Be Real
      Be Real 3 months ago

      @elaine brown 👍✋

    • PM Ready
      PM Ready 4 months ago +6

      @elaine brown You wrote - “You don’t know him don’t be so naive”. Really? Well you don’t know him or her do you? DON’T BE SO NAIVE.

    • Sarah Wynn
      Sarah Wynn 4 months ago +4

      @The Energy Center® and ? That doesn’t make him an abuser !! Also she took drugs and drank heavier than he did !!!!!!

  • Leslie Farris
    Leslie Farris 4 months ago +164

    Good lord she’s so “fragile” with her attorney but when she can answer questions posed by Camille she just asks superior and smug. And she never directly answers any questions, she dances around the facts

    • Ditza Perez
      Ditza Perez 3 months ago +1

      @The Energy Center® this didn’t age well…

    • Ziltch
      Ziltch 4 months ago +6

      @The Energy Center® I would have loved to see your face as you hear the result of this court xD
      I imagine a twist of sadness, shock and anger and then unintelligible shouts

  • Nanimo
    Nanimo 4 months ago +254

    I remember some people being worried about Amber's team having a week, but I was just thinking about how Johnny's team had a week to process all of Amber's lies and prepare to call her on them, and they did exactly that.

    • stancexpunks
      stancexpunks Day ago

      The longer she’s on the stand, the better. She makes herself look worse with each day.

    • Willow Moon Wolf
      Willow Moon Wolf 3 months ago

      💯💯💯💯💯

    • kaimiakid
      kaimiakid 3 months ago

      @The Energy Center® LOL

    • hossein javanmard
      hossein javanmard 4 months ago +5

      @The Energy Center® sure buddy lol

    • Dactrin
      Dactrin 4 months ago +3

      Good point!

  • Mystic J
    Mystic J 4 months ago +146

    48:28 If you listen really carefully to this audio you’ll see she’s the aggressor. She keeps talking over him repeating “please stop” in that awful condescending voice, and in the end he snaps and the conversation escalates. He’s standing up for himself 👏 She knows exactly what she’s doing.

    • Pokyqu
      Pokyqu 4 months ago +1

      Ye Idk how that guy in the break considered this to be convincing evidence of anything. It’s very hard to listen to for Johnny yet loud and clear for Amber (maybe recording without his knowledge). Then she lists the things he supposedly has done and he sarcastically replies lol

    • Kataphora V
      Kataphora V 4 months ago +11

      That's a textbook Narcissist tactic: "Poking the Bear" so to speak. Goading someone until they flip out, only to turn around and call them the "abusive/crazy/immature" one while playing the innocent victim. As if they have no idea where such unprovoked anger came from, but they know very well what they're doing. It's disgusting behavior.

    • Liz Neptune
      Liz Neptune 4 months ago +14

      @Mary D if you watch carefully, she even jumps before he even says anything. horrible actress!!

    • Mary D
      Mary D 4 months ago +17

      And she fake 'jumps' when Johnny is loud - performance for the jury IMHO

    • DonnaMarie Passaro
      DonnaMarie Passaro 4 months ago +13

      She’s talking over the attorney to get her details in, she knows what she has done. The lawyer is revealing who Amber really is!

  • Amy Howard
    Amy Howard 4 months ago +28

    I have never seen a judge allow a lawyer to argue so much against their rulings. Camille is an amazing lawyer and knows what’s she doing and keeps it professional unlike Elaine!

  • Desi Rae
    Desi Rae 4 months ago +161

    I want to see her lawyers faces when she keeps implying they are withholding evidence

    • ljb
      ljb 4 months ago +18

      Or when she said they released the photos, ha ha

  • Karen Zapata
    Karen Zapata 4 months ago +120

    It’s interesting how she talks about the scars in her arms and not being able to cover them completely with makeup but when asked about the pictures when she’s doing press days after being repeatedly beat up she says she covered her bruises and swelling with make up 🤔

    • Seeking the Truth
      Seeking the Truth 2 months ago +1

      @Msthe99percent Do you know that if the scars were from a fight they would not be perfect lines. Those are perfect lines.

    • Be Real
      Be Real 3 months ago

      @Sarah Gianfortune no shewasnt

    • misssimmi2
      misssimmi2 4 months ago +15

      She's repeatedly punched by a man wearing large rings and her face is flawless the next day because she did such an amazing job makeup but she couldn't cover up a few light scratches on her arm with the same makeup?? Really?? 💩

    • Sarah Gianfortune
      Sarah Gianfortune 4 months ago +7

      @Msthe99percent not what her nurses and therapists notes say, but whatevs. Everyone is a liar, except Amber apparently. Lol 😆

    • Msthe99percent
      Msthe99percent 4 months ago +1

      @Sarah Gianfortune no mate, it's from a 'fight' with Johnny. She said she never actually cut herself in court.

  • Ddina
    Ddina 4 months ago +640

    I love Camille. Reduced Elaine to a stuttering, blubbering, argumentative mess and objecting on point. Then calmly reinforcing her questions and catching Amber out on her lies and giving her some gentle persisting pressure. You Go Gurl!

    • Madison Clarke
      Madison Clarke 2 months ago

      @Be Real I did too until she started going on all the talk shows/pulling all the crap after the trial. She was a victim of AH. Sucked in to her lies like so many others (myself included in 2016). She quickly realized that amber isn’t as innocent as she pretends to be & she can’t take responsibility for anything. She is constantly the victim in her own eyes & can do no wrong. If she took an ounce of accountability the verdict might have gone different. It blew my mind when she tried to justify the “I didn’t punch you, I slapped you” recording by saying she was just trying to point out the difference in power between a man and a woman. She had an excuse for everything & her team quickly realized that. Elaine should have gone back to life & dropped the drama like rotten born did. I couldn’t stand him, back have great respect for his sliding slowly back into the shadows.

    • Crys Garcia
      Crys Garcia 3 months ago

      Yes he had an excellent team of lawyers!! Just looking at both sides you can see the energy around them.. the way she speaks is weird like her whole vibe is weird I can’t believe someone would think they are being believed, her voice changes and everything I don’t know how to describe it other then weird AF!!

    • Crys Garcia
      Crys Garcia 3 months ago

      Yes he had an excellent team of lawyers!! Just looking at both sides you can see the energy around them.. the way she speaks is weird like her whole vibe is weird I can’t believe someone would think they are being believed, her voice changes and everything I don’t know how to describe it other then weird AF!!

    • Be Real
      Be Real 3 months ago

      @The Energy Center® really feel for Elaine, she is a good lawyer and doesn't deserve the nasty comments

  • Samantha Hugli
    Samantha Hugli 4 months ago +17

    It's honestly terrifying seeing her lie and try to manipulate every little thing. Her testimony should be studied like they do with serial killers!

  • L L
    L L 4 months ago +211

    Yesterday she said "i have never used the word victim to describe myself"... Yet she literally went to WP and published an article about... being a victim. This is literally the whole reason she, and we, are here is because she claimed she was a victim. Typical gaslighting. Claims to be a victim then says she never said she was when you bring it up. Truly amazing manipulative, dishonest behavior.

    • Be Real
      Be Real 3 months ago

      @Jessica Askin think you will find the op ed states she faced our cultures wrath.... That's true and now moreso than ever as instead of leaving her alone (even Depp when accused of being an abuser by the sun, did not face this) there is a dramatic backlash. She doesn't say she is a victim. She said and doesn't see herself as a victim. That's not gaslighting and it's not changing other people's perceptions or even trying to. What she wrote is her experiences not anyone elses therefore she isn't trying to alter anyone elses and regardless of what happened between them as clearly they were both ridiculous in the relationship it's her feelings not yours. Also my having an opinion is not gaslighting and no I'm not "as bad". What is gaslighting is you stating I should believe your version and that my thoughts and opinions are invalid

    • Jessica Askin
      Jessica Askin 3 months ago +1

      @Be Real "Psychologists use the term “gaslighting” to refer to a specific type of manipulation where the manipulator is trying to get someone else (or a group of people) to question their own reality, memory or perceptions. And it's always a serious problem, according to psychologists."
      Straight from Google the meaning of Gaslighting. She's trying to say she was never the victim when she literally had a whole court case about being a victim in 2016. Shut up and educate yourself. You're gaslighting by just stating that's not gaslighting. You're just as bad.

    • Be Real
      Be Real 3 months ago

      That's not gaslighting

    • Nicole Ryan
      Nicole Ryan 4 months ago +1

      Justifying her behavior or excuses why she did or said what she did and believes that’s a good enough reason for her behavior.

    • The Energy Center®
      The Energy Center® 4 months ago

      Amber was telling the truth. Amber will win.. JD had a major drug / alcohol problem which alters personality..........................

  • Monica Bosquez
    Monica Bosquez 4 months ago +322

    Camille saying “he hasn’t looked at you once, has he?” STRAIGHT FOR THE JUGULAR OMG 😭

    • Markus Gorelli
      Markus Gorelli 4 months ago +2

      @urpieceofheaven 2 No - there was some point in their last meeting where DP promised AH that he would never look at her again. Camille was mocking her that he is holding to his vow.

    • Jess
      Jess 4 months ago +3

      @urpieceofheaven 2 pretty sure victims don't like to look at their abusers. I know that from my own personal experience, and others could be different. But thats just my perspective.

    • urpieceofheaven 2
      urpieceofheaven 2 4 months ago

      @Maisie Durham and yes to this, it could easily be turned around to this.

    • urpieceofheaven 2
      urpieceofheaven 2 4 months ago

      Oh they probably told him not to look at her than

    • Maisie Durham
      Maisie Durham 4 months ago +1

      @Saimagic5K I think she just meant he can't look at her because he allegedly has a guilty conscience not that it is illegal for him to look at her🙂

  • Sal Cosentino
    Sal Cosentino 4 months ago +195

    It's sad how very desperately Amber wants Johnny to look at her. She is dead to him. He will never look at her. It's pathetic, really.

    • Madison Clarke
      Madison Clarke 2 months ago +1

      @Karen Haynes I loved when Camille pulled out the proof of him saying “you will never see my eyes again.” Threw a wrench right in that narrative.

    • bullcrane Kai
      bullcrane Kai 4 months ago +11

      @Grandmaida7 he told her at their second to last meeting she would never see his eyes again, he's keeping that word. Plus as she's a narcissist nothing will annoy her more than having no control over him and him refusing to be her supply

    • Saimagic5K
      Saimagic5K 4 months ago +17

      If Johnny knows she is NPD, ignoring her existence is the absolute worst thing for her and best thing for him.

    • Karen Haynes
      Karen Haynes 4 months ago +14

      She tells jury he doesn’t look at her because he’s guilty. She disgust me! Can you imagine how disgusting she must be to him? He begged her to handle the divorce privately. She wouldn’t have it any other way except to DEFAME him!

    • bullcrane Kai
      bullcrane Kai 4 months ago +17

      Narcissists crave supply and he is not giving her a supply

  • Swetha Ganesh
    Swetha Ganesh 4 months ago +59

    Johnny depp's lawyer nailed it. She asked amber indirectly that she has so many pictures of Johnny sleeping but not a picture of her hurt or medical records of her being hurt. Also she enhanced the fact that johnny wears these rings on his finger and amber claimed to have been repeatedly struck by Johnny on her face but no picture evidence to show the impact of the rings and also next, she showed pictures of amber the very next day after her every accusation of Johnny beating her up and she apparently looks absolute fine .. she also pin pointed the fact that amber didn't pay the charity money and lied several times about it and under oath.

  • 40k challenge with 0 video
    40k challenge with 0 video 4 months ago +163

    Everyone testifies the same: she is aggressive, he is calm. If Johnny doesn't win this case, I will lose faith in people!

    • Brandi Porter
      Brandi Porter Month ago

      @sherry b a bunch more hearsay , not evidence and connections with the sitting judge. Crazy lady how it feel that she lost!

    • larajhilton
      larajhilton 4 months ago

      @BeKsTeR FoReVeR 😆

    • BeKsTeR FoReVeR
      BeKsTeR FoReVeR 4 months ago +5

      Sherry poops 💩 the bed too!!! Lol

    • sherry b
      sherry b 4 months ago +3

      Lost the first one with same evidence so get ready to lose faith 👍🤣

  • Sabrina Torgerson
    Sabrina Torgerson 4 months ago +23

    Hold up a second. She said she needed to know what combination of drugs Johnny was for her safety. And then says she followed him to the main apartment and said something to provoke him. If she was concerned for her safety why would she engage him by saying something to provoke him?

  • Aira Rukawa
    Aira Rukawa 4 months ago +122

    It’s all about her. If she didn’t want to hurt JD, she shouldn’t have written the op-ed. IF she were truly a victim of DA, she has all the support system next door, they have the capacity to remove you or rescue you in that situation. They have access to you 24/7. Taking photo of supposedly minor marks and ignoring major ones is really telling something.

    • Madison Clarke
      Madison Clarke 2 months ago +2

      And what abuser would ever move the victims support system of friends and family into their apartments, directly next door, completely free of charge. Abusers almost always isolate the victims, not make them roommates essentially with everyone close to them.

    • Big D
      Big D 4 months ago +3

      She contradicts herself so much. Her comments about L’Oréal are laughable. Women don’t want to see her advertising anything they might use.

    • Rowland Smith
      Rowland Smith 4 months ago

      Lol

  • Aava Vertu
    Aava Vertu 4 months ago +440

    So Amber makes a clear distinction between "hitting" and "punching", but uses "having pledged" and "having donated synonymously.

    • Madison Clarke
      Madison Clarke 2 months ago

      @PM Ready exactly. I’ve told my kids always tell the truth. If you’re telling someone something that happened to you, don’t lie or elaborate even one part of the story b/c then they will probably believe none of it & will definitely question everything.

    • Marisa White
      Marisa White 4 months ago +2

      English is taught in Texas...wonder where she was.

    • The Energy Center®
      The Energy Center® 4 months ago

      Amber will win. Amber was telling the truth. JD became a monster bc of drugs and alcohol. That is the point.

    • One Of You
      One Of You 4 months ago +3

      Very relevant; hypocrisy, lies, agendas, money grabbing, manipulation, falsehoods, rotten character, proving a long history and past behaviour of orchestrated fabrications.

    • flipchartpad
      flipchartpad 4 months ago +5

      @Grandmaida7 There are multiple reasons why this might be relevant. E.g. consider this: to claim defamation they have to show that her statements in the op-ed are false. Since it's basically impossible to find that out, they have to try other approaches. E.g. they could investigate why she published false statements. If she did so, this can hardly be an accident, both the publishing, but more importantly, the falsity of the statements, as they are implied to be about firsthand experiences. So the question is: "why did she lie?". One possible answer is, to get money out of a divorce settlement. But now she would say, that that can't be the case as she donated the money. And this is where the fact that she didn't donate the money comes in.
      And this is not just connected to the op-ed as described above, but getting money out of a divorce settlement also provides intent to manifacture false evidence to be used for said settlement. Such evidence would also be used in this case to show that she's not lying. So showing the intention to get money out of the divorce settlement also enables them to explain where the false evidence comes from, given that she couldn't have known about being sued for defamation.
      And this is just one reason.

  • EconBlue
    EconBlue 4 months ago +93

    You testified under oath
    “The entirety of my divorce settlement was donated to charity”
    Thats correct,
    I pledged the entirety to charity, I haven’t been able to fulfill those pledges because I’ve been sued.
    You had all of the 7 million dollars for 13 months before Mr Depp sued you & you chose not to pay it to the charities you pledged it to, isn’t that correct?
    I disagree with your characterization of that 😆
    Mmmkay,
    So you disagree with the characterization of the truth?!
    That alone should Be enough to convince any juror of her inability to differentiate between fact and fiction.
    Her “reality” is completely fkn Skewed!

    • rbrthnan
      rbrthnan 4 months ago +1

      she has different world (her own world), (in her world) some word has her own definition
      i wont go inside to that world

    • hildaamethyst
      hildaamethyst 4 months ago +3

      Exactly. That’s really scary actually that she can twist the truth to make herself look better because that might be what she’s trying to do with Johnny. She might actually believe herself 🙁

    • Liam 6549
      Liam 6549 4 months ago

      Time stamp please?

    • laswan s.
      laswan s. 4 months ago +3

      RIGHT?!!

  • AW_Tig Tiggerific
    AW_Tig Tiggerific 4 months ago +376

    There is no way that she would just be able to ice her face, cover it with makeup and look pristine if he punched her many times in the face with rings on. Swelling and marks would still be visible, also her face would have a lot of pain making it very hard and uncomfortable to smile and talk.

    • Madison Clarke
      Madison Clarke 2 months ago

      @Aþort Mən that was in the early 70’s. Not even compatible to the quality of photos now and the plethora of devices everywhere to take said photos. There are also photos of her with obvious bruising on parts of her body, but they’re more difficult to see with the poor quality photos in the 70’s had. Even my cheap Polaroid takes 100 times better photos than the best camera in 1975.

    • Xenon
      Xenon 3 months ago +2

      @The Energy Center® Well she didn’t win.

    • Lymmitless
      Lymmitless 4 months ago +4

      Coming from someone with recreational fight sports experience, if he hit her repeatedly with a bunch of rings on she’d look like she went 10 rounds with a blender. Look at what just bare knuckles can do (via bare knuckle boxing).

    • Nikki Kyriacou
      Nikki Kyriacou 4 months ago +4

      Some one else done that to her face..she just said the where expecting the police and someone else done that to show them she was hit by JD because she was scared...i dont believe a word she says

  • MinionGuy
    MinionGuy 4 months ago +37

    Without picking a side and just looking at the objective evidence JD wins this hands down easily. AH has said to much of absolutely nothing and by her own words has destroyed any credibility she had.

    • nieooj gotoy
      nieooj gotoy 4 months ago +3

      If The sunlight shining on Camille like an Angel isn’t symbolism of Johnny’s innocence, I don’t know what is

  • smariner1
    smariner1 4 months ago +114

    Question ? If Johnny used drugs, why in the heck would she tell him to bring weed and alcohol to her birthday party. She used too. She testified that the reason she text him so much was she was trying to divert him from using when he tried to get away from her. If your spouse is a user would you not quit using yourself to try and stop the cycle, and both of you get therapy to help get clean?

    • Aja Hanna
      Aja Hanna 4 months ago +1

      Exactly

    • Amber Slocum
      Amber Slocum 4 months ago +1

      @T J That's wildly inaccurate and assumptive.

    • Pichii Keen
      Pichii Keen 4 months ago +7

      That is exactly what I said!!! When your spouse, whom is the love of your life, is fighting to overcome an addiction, you support him/her by stopping the use of the substance yourself!!! She wanted her cake and to be able to eat it too, so to speak.

    • T J
      T J 4 months ago +1

      All STARS uses drugs

    • Elon Clarke
      Elon Clarke 4 months ago +7

      Seems a little fishy to me.
      In world do you ask an alcoholic to buy the alcohol or anything. Sounds like entrapment to me. Or a straight up lie

  • Diane Al
    Diane Al 4 months ago +173

    She can't call herself a victim because she will lose a sense of control by doing so because she is the abuser.

    • Pichii Keen
      Pichii Keen 4 months ago +2

      Yet she went straight to a court to get a TRO against Johnny? And she 'never' called herself a victim??? She is sitting up there this day stating he hit her repeatedly, she got a TRO, she wrote an op-ed stating she was a victim of DV, but she never said she was a 'victim!' So which is it then, you are a victim of DV or you are 'NOT' and just lying about it all???

    • Diane Al
      Diane Al 4 months ago +2

      @Reveka T someone had to take the first punch, or as Amber says Hit

    • Aleaha A
      Aleaha A 4 months ago +6

      @Reveka T But she has no evidence for any of the injuries she claimed he inflicted upon her.

    • R R
      R R 4 months ago +6

      @Reveka T lol no.

    • Reveka T
      Reveka T 4 months ago +1

      Maybe they’re both abusers?

  • Elon Clarke
    Elon Clarke 4 months ago +41

    It’s wild that her lawyers are just like “Hey. Is this thing you’re being accused of true?”
    “No, I’m a good girl.”
    Witnesses 1-99 “Yeah. She’s sheisty.”
    “I rest my case., not guilty.”
    Meanwhile Johnny’s lawyers are like “Did you do this?”
    Johnny: No.
    Witnesses 1-99: No.

  • Jess Jayne
    Jess Jayne 4 months ago +277

    The little side smirk sad face thing she does is exactly what my narcissistic ex did when I saw her after I left her. It used to make me feel so bad and guilty like I affected her. It’s clear amber is doing this to try and get sympathy and make the jury feel bad for her.

    • Katherine H
      Katherine H 4 months ago +2

      @The Energy Center® are you amber herself....wow imagine..

    • Mary Lynd
      Mary Lynd 4 months ago

      @Fire lord lol umm

    • Lalala
      Lalala 4 months ago

      And JD wanted the jury to hate him, right? Pull your pants up, your bias is showing. They both want to win. They both were awful to each other. They are both guilty of DV. The jury only has to decide whether she defamed him by lying and did so with malice.
      EDIT: and when I say “pull your pants up…” I’m referring to your big boy/big girl pants. And if that doesn’t clear it up, I’m saying to be mature and be objective.

    • Steve.
      Steve. 4 months ago +11

      The Queen of gaslighting.

  • K
    K 4 months ago +48

    It disgusts me how the justice system of ours,, has no catch all as to when a witness is under oath,,,and lies and keeps on lying,, on the stand under oath. There is no justice,,,it's sickening.

    • i took a chonce
      i took a chonce 4 months ago

      @Pokyqu 💀💀

    • Pokyqu
      Pokyqu 4 months ago +2

      Ah the times when people had religion and feared God

    • laswan s.
      laswan s. 4 months ago +3

      @EllieDaSpatula
      That's true. So unfair. Can you imagine what it must be like for JD to sit there and listen to all of her lies??!!

    • EllieDaSpatula
      EllieDaSpatula 4 months ago

      well, what would you suggest you do? You can't really stop someone from lying. Even though- yes it sucks, there's really no other solution other than an oath under law.

  • Daan
    Daan 4 months ago +35

    When you tell him you want to protect him, because you love him, because you don't want to hurt him, because you don't want him arrested, etc.. it's strange that you all take pictures and see everything in advance as something that could harm him.

  • melanie webster
    melanie webster 4 months ago +9

    So I'm going back and watching this after the verdict. Elaine had the nerve to go on so many talk shows and claim that the jurors COULDN'T have stayed off social media during the trial and the 10 day break but it's so clearly obvious that Amber and Elaine did, in the middle of her testimony, when she's not supposed to be talking to her attorney about her testimony. They went online and saw all the questions people had about her testimony and then came back to the trial & pretty much answered them all. I don't think you want to be disparaging the judge & jury when you clearly did what you say they did.

    • Markus Gorelli
      Markus Gorelli 4 months ago +3

      3:45:29 "This is obviously not the exact one I used"
      Except to someone on the jury, it would not in fact be obvious. Or even at minimum, I would have thought that while it was not the exact one - being unused, I would have taken it to mean that this was the correct model and brand that she always used.
      It would have been a surprise to find out that she did not in fact use this brand at all, and I would have wondered why the heck did AH's lawyer make such a big fuss over a kit that played no actual part in the case when it would have been easier to bring in the actual kit that she did in fact use. As I commented elsewhere, it would be like holding up a Glock and saying this is the exact weapon used, and then later saying, "Well it was not exactly a Glock, it was a Smith and Wesson." Except that even here, we still do not know what brand she actually used other than it was "Glockish" 🙄
      4:54:14 Wait. They tendered the Milani makeup kit that did not exist at the time into evidence?

  • AudryfromN64
    AudryfromN64 4 months ago +41

    Way to go Camille. 👏👏👏 I was so excited for her cross examination and can’t wait for tmrw!!! Justice needs to be served. The world is watching. One punch would spilt her face open. I literally have the same skin and body/facial structure. I would know. The judge knows. The jury knows. I’m so glad she’s exposed. I’m sure the relationship was toxic. She takes no responsibility and never answers the question head on. Johnny was very forth coming and honest. I’m so so so satisfied with the cross examination today. I pray that true justice is served because this is a huge huge huge part of law history. Showing the world that you can’t get away with this BS!!!

    • EYOK
      EYOK 4 months ago

      @Doctor Dank she's a lawyer doing her job, I'm goig to call her properly. If you meet her while walking the dog of course she's Camile, but not in court

    • Doctor Dank
      Doctor Dank 4 months ago +2

      @EYOK lmao bro chill, relax a minute. We're not at the unit alright? You don't have to call everyone by their last name. People have first names for a reason and as a civilian that's what you use, unless you're gonna add a Mr. or Mrs. But you didn't so your opinion is moot.

    • EYOK
      EYOK 4 months ago

      yeah she was amazing but her name is Vasquez, she's not your sister

  • Candace Rain
    Candace Rain 4 months ago +94

    It's so amazing how she has conversations with her husband recorded. Why did she record private conversations? What was the purpose behind it except to try to have something/anything on him, no matter how insignificant? I mean I don't record my and my husbands conversations.

    • Tara L
      Tara L 4 months ago +13

      And her being the only person who knows they are being recorded means she can manipulate what she says to make her sound like the victim

    • Jenn McIntyre
      Jenn McIntyre 4 months ago +14

      Recording their conversations was suggested to them by a therapist. They would claim one of them said something, and the other would deny it. In California, both parties have to know there are recordings though. Johnny always told Amber, but after a while, she stopped telling him.

  • Christina Aguirre
    Christina Aguirre 4 months ago +9

    I have never in my life seen someone "cry" so much with absolutely NO tears. Ever. All I have to do is think about my dead dog or the geese that came to work for years and got hit by a car and I'm crying like a baby. Tears, snot and all. Probably because I have empathy and am not a liar 🤷‍♀️.

    • Mikka Hibbs
      Mikka Hibbs 3 months ago +1

      Seriously though!! Such fake crying... I was in an abusive relationship before and if I'm talking with anyone about things I went through tears start flowing like crazy no matter how hard I try to hold it in... She's full of crap!!!

  • SleepySatellite
    SleepySatellite 4 months ago +14

    Thanks to Camille and JD’s lawyers team, the truth is starting to come out, and crystal clear 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

  • Shawnesse Marie
    Shawnesse Marie 4 months ago +34

    When Camille says you’ve been looking at Johnny multiple times and he hasn’t looked at you once I was like yesssssss I’ve been saying this I’m so glad she called her out on that 👏👏👏👏

    • Tarkus
      Tarkus 4 months ago

      @The Energy Center® indeed, and Lionel Messi plays in my backyard everyday

    • The Energy Center®
      The Energy Center® 4 months ago

      Amber will win and was telling the truth. JD was a monster bc of drugs and alcohol.

  • MinionGuy
    MinionGuy 4 months ago +15

    I wish they would let us see the jury so we can see their reactions to each time AH looks at them.

  • The Geek Within
    The Geek Within 4 months ago +132

    All I heard during Amber's testimony was objection, objection, objection 😂 Mega Pint for Camille!

  • Amrutha
    Amrutha 4 months ago +44

    Vasquez did a stellar job. This entire cross examination was so masterfully done, carefully exposing each and every single one of Amber’s lies. Huge respect to Camille

  • Sad America
    Sad America 4 months ago +22

    Unfortunately we’re not the jury… Hopefully the jury sees what we all do and that she is a liar.

  • Мистер Огонёчек

    Every time I see her start crying I question every director and other staff who ever casted her for a movie

    • Madison Clarke
      Madison Clarke 2 months ago +2

      @PM Ready I agree. I even love Zombieland, Pineapple Express, & The Stand series & never realized any of those were her 🤣

    • Madison Clarke
      Madison Clarke 2 months ago +1

      It’s the exact same crying she did in Zombieland & some other movie I can’t remember. Same faces/expressions & same lack of tears.

    • Marisa White
      Marisa White 4 months ago +3

      Can you call it crying if there are no tears?

    • sopan shirdhonkar
      sopan shirdhonkar 4 months ago +1

      @Jess Dee to be honest after the trial I realized that the red haired girl i aquaman was actual amber heard, I just knew her like ok there is one actresses with that name who looks good.

  • freespirit
    freespirit 4 months ago +77

    She forgot about her child when talking about the good things going on in her life. Ridiculous!

    • SusanScrapPassion
      SusanScrapPassion 4 months ago +11

      Imagine having her for a mother.

    • AWEtistic
      AWEtistic 4 months ago +14

      I didn't know she had a child... that's honestly terrifying.

  • Tammie Roth
    Tammie Roth 4 months ago +13

    Playing the victim and all the crocodile tears. Incredible to witness how twisted she is. She's a bad act. PERIOD!

  • 42 Roads for Man
    42 Roads for Man 4 months ago +24

    I've never met anyone who has sustained such horrific physical violence but whose body is so impervious to swelling or bruises as Amber heard. She must be a superhero in real life. Nothing apparently hurts her physically. The rest of us little people bump into a chair and we get a bruise. Heard can get beat up by a man with chunky rings and show nothing.

    • Madison Clarke
      Madison Clarke 2 months ago +1

      @GloryReclaimed oh & “amica” 🤣🤣 sorry forgot that one!

    • Madison Clarke
      Madison Clarke 2 months ago +1

      @GloryReclaimed and ICE! 🤣😜

    • GloryReclaimed
      GloryReclaimed 3 months ago +3

      But...........MAKEUP!!!!! Lol

  • Sophia Soto
    Sophia Soto 4 months ago +28

    The pledge and not donating money just showed the lies.
    Her cheek bone implants are driving me crazy.

    • The Energy Center®
      The Energy Center® 4 months ago

      Sophia, Maybe you are just crazy...

    • Daan
      Daan 4 months ago +7

      The cheekbones are looking like bruises

  • Lymmitless
    Lymmitless 4 months ago +13

    The fact that AH and her friend thought to take photos in different types lighting to show the police who were about to arrive is just weird. She could have just moved to good lighting for them. That’s just the most sus/guilty vibe I’ve ever heard.

    • The Energy Center®
      The Energy Center® 4 months ago

      Or maybe you are weird for defending a monster that JD became from drugs and alcohol. Amber was telling the truth. Amber will win.

  • PeppermintGekko
    PeppermintGekko 4 months ago +22

    I know it’s been said a thousand times, but Amber documented everything but after being punched OVER & OVER & OVER in the head & face by a man that wears a handful of heavy metal rings on every finger, she could only document a few questionable pictures that are easily passed off as recovery from Botox, fillers, & dark circles from a hangover or bender? It just doesn’t pass muster. I hope hope hope the jury recognizes this.

  • Taylor Voisin
    Taylor Voisin 4 months ago +96

    Amber saying "obviously not the exact one I used to carry" in regards to the color-correcting kit..... her and her team are DEFINITELY viewing others' reactions about this case. They know Milani called them out.

    • Dina Issa
      Dina Issa 4 months ago +1

      I’m so glad they are viewing people’s reactions hahaha! They know she’s hated.

    • PrincessFidelma
      PrincessFidelma 4 months ago +3

      It's a shame the jury can't be told she's either a time traveller or a liar.

    • MarianneF
      MarianneF 4 months ago +5

      damage control, damage control, damage control lol

    • MrsCopperlady
      MrsCopperlady 4 months ago +13

      They aren't but obviously are doing. You can tell as soon as they brought up her "never" playing the guitar again after there was footage of her doing so and she so carefully stated well she posed with one. Why bring that up at all again and switch to another subject so quickly as a checklist to go through to try and redefend all her lies.

    • Taylor Voisin
      Taylor Voisin 4 months ago +10

      @Oliver Lang in the middle of her testimony she is not allowed to. The judge reminds her before every break that she is not even allowed to discuss the case with her lawyers.

  • vhnf1
    vhnf1 Month ago +2

    I’ll never understand why they never played the second 911 call in this trial. It was clearly Rocky’s voice on it and it could’ve been used to impeach Amber when she said she had no idea a second set of officers were going to come.

  • Adesuwa Gold
    Adesuwa Gold 4 months ago +24

    Standing ovation for lady Camilla. What an amazing and smart woman

  • Christina Aguirre
    Christina Aguirre 4 months ago +8

    She'd been to the Met Gala, numerous movie premieres and never saw as many photographers in one place as she did the day she left the courthouse after filing the restraining order 🤦‍♀️

  • Mark Antrobus
    Mark Antrobus 4 months ago +208

    If he was a secret wife abuser why wpuld he move in his wife's friends and even sister in next door?

    • MDBRF
      MDBRF 4 months ago

      @Doctor Dank I don’t talk in emoji lol

    • Doctor Dank
      Doctor Dank 4 months ago

      @MDBRF👀🧠

    • MDBRF
      MDBRF 4 months ago +7

      @Evelyn Exactly. It’s been mentioned during these proceedings that her mom had said to Johnny, after Amber’s allegations and their divorce, that she still loved him. What mom would say that to a man who she believed beat her little girl?

    • Oliver Lang
      Oliver Lang 4 months ago +2

      And I also believe Rocky and her ex fiancé hate Amber so much they aren’t testifying.

    • Evelyn
      Evelyn 4 months ago +7

      I keep thinking about the same, he even took her friends and family with them on trips. Based on massages shown it looks like he had a pretty good relationship with her parents instead of trying to remove them from her life. Also Amber repeated many times that spending time with her friends was her coping mechanism, so clearly she wasn't being prevented from seeing them.

  • Gulzhan Khusnetdinova
    Gulzhan Khusnetdinova 4 months ago +271

    Liar. She was taking multiple pictures of Johnny sleeping, and did not took a picture of bleeding nose or anything else.

    • FunWithLavey
      FunWithLavey 4 months ago +3

      You can actually change the dates and times for photos on iPhone to make it look like they were taken on different dates

    • rom s
      rom s 4 months ago +1

      Because there none

    • Justin H.
      Justin H. 4 months ago +1

      @Yukon West exactly, when they're in a blackout they won't remember hitting you. and when they're passed out they are not as dangerous, so go can look at them a quietly release their power over you.

    • Amanda Bonilla
      Amanda Bonilla 4 months ago +5

      ​@Karen Haynes I don't remember if they ever stated that the ID on the table was his or not. If not, I feel like they can work some magic and scan the ID to get the info on who's ID it is.

    • Lily
      Lily 4 months ago +1

      @Yukon West I was in a similar situation, now I’m not in her custody

  • Leon
    Leon 4 months ago +172

    Amber got absolutely pieced up by Camille and made 100 points in under like 60 minutes!! Loved how Amber was getting angry and when she non stop tried to sneak away from the donation questions.

    • Loading
      Loading 4 months ago +7

      @The Energy Center® bro Amber was the one spending thousand's on Wine, using mushrooms and allowing her sister to do cocaine with Johnny 😂

    • Elvira Feher
      Elvira Feher 4 months ago

      @MinionGuy I think it's could be gin

    • Arezo Pourdavani
      Arezo Pourdavani 4 months ago +6

      We got to see AH 2016 depo 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 the real amber

    • Loading
      Loading 4 months ago +2

      yeah that was nasty to watch

  • Btissam Kassimi
    Btissam Kassimi 4 months ago +78

    you know what would be interesting, asking her about the time she backed away from Johnny in court (where she is safer) .... and yet she went to see him alone after their divorce when there was no protection; that is contradiction in its finest forms.

    • nemesisX rox
      nemesisX rox 4 months ago

      ... howz bout the day she was leaving the court room n nearly hopped right into his waiting suv n' just grinned n' dismissed it

    • Btissam Kassimi
      Btissam Kassimi 4 months ago

      @Katherine Damaris and she really went to say goodbye to him and give him a hug, this is where my mind stopped ...... A HUG TO HER ''ABUSER''.

    • Katherine Damaris
      Katherine Damaris 4 months ago +4

      i was wondering this exact thing too. makes no sense

  • Mihaela Todoca
    Mihaela Todoca 4 months ago +8

    She's obviously telling us what she did to him and saying it was done to her, such a sick twisted person!

  • eioshen boboi
    eioshen boboi 4 months ago +17

    ALONG THE LINES OF “I didn’t want to label myself a victim” yet in the op-ed she called herself a victim??

  • MinionGuy
    MinionGuy 4 months ago +46

    I loved it when Elaine objected to her own clients statement. Priceless!!

    • Targard .QuantumFrack
      Targard .QuantumFrack 4 months ago

      This whole trial is priceless. I hope Manson's one will be broadcasted.

    • A S
      A S 4 months ago

      Do you have a timestamp?

  • Ananda Balasana
    Ananda Balasana 4 months ago +153

    The way she wanted to make sure she does not want to be called a victim and never said this about herself yet JD was able to say „yes I am“ says it all….

    • Diane Al
      Diane Al 4 months ago +2

      Because if she claims she is a victim then she loses that sense of control which the abuser uses to control their victims.

    • Carmen🌻
      Carmen🌻 4 months ago +3

      @Nanimo Exactly what I was thinking!!

    • Nanimo
      Nanimo 4 months ago +30

      She literally put her name on an Op-Ed claiming victimhood. 🥴

  • hildaamethyst
    hildaamethyst 4 months ago +36

    This whole trial is very interesting but as I sit here watching it I start seeing Johnny and Amber as children and can’t help but feel sad. Two hurt and damaged children got into a toxic relationship that blew up and hurt each other 😞 they both need to separate and heal like that one witness said

  • Ana Fleming
    Ana Fleming 4 months ago +47

    God I love this judge.
    Also Johnny's face when she's talking about him "hallucinating" makes me giggle. I love watching his reactions when she speaks BS.

    • Madison Clarke
      Madison Clarke 2 months ago +1

      @KAM Hyde I’m still laughing at “I took a bunch of sleeping pills..well Um not a bunch, 2, which is A LOT for me.” 🤣

    • Ana Fleming
      Ana Fleming 4 months ago +2

      @KAM Hyde Oh never. But every audio sounds like she's high or drunk AF. If she does admit to drug use, she makes it sound like a one time thing because it was a "horrible idea" 🙄

    • Ana Fleming
      Ana Fleming 4 months ago +1

      @Johanna Jonasson 1:17:42 is when the judge starts jumping in with "sustained" and she's talking about his mental health.

    • Johanna Jonasson
      Johanna Jonasson 4 months ago +2

      Ohh at what time was this?

    • KAM Hyde
      KAM Hyde 4 months ago +4

      Yet AH rarely, if ever , mentions her own substance use.

  • margaritablue
    margaritablue 4 months ago +49

    If she was so scared living in his penthouse and wanted to change the locks why didn’t she just move and pay for her own place? Instead of living off of him for free? 🤷🏻‍♀️

    • Spirit Seeker Squad
      Spirit Seeker Squad 4 months ago +4

      I'm assuming this is a rhetorical question... 🤣
      I believe she was only with him for money and fame and drugs and whatever else she could get from him. 💯
      Shes really bad at acting! I see why I had never heard of her before this trial. 🤷🏽‍♀️

    • Devonna Semple
      Devonna Semple 4 months ago

      😂😂

  • Home Home
    Home Home 4 months ago +24

    Finally some actual court display. Boy amber got nailed and proven to be a liar. This is so good. Makes you wish she would get thrown in jail.

  • James Martin-Davies
    James Martin-Davies 4 months ago +197

    Love how Amber tried to gaslight Camille Vasquez and she constantly put Amber back in her place. Amber's attempt at dominance isn't going so well for her now, is it?

  • Emilie Wood
    Emilie Wood 4 months ago +28

    I’m just waiting for the day either Ambers lawyer, or Amber herself has a complete meltdown from sheer frustration that JD’s team & lawyers are absolutely bloody brilliant..

  • Denise Lopez
    Denise Lopez 4 months ago +24

    1. He tries to remove himself from the situation( never heard of an abuser doing that)
    2. The hair "pulled" from her scalp is bright blonde, her roots were darker than that.
    3. He is on audio multiple times talking about her hitting him, and she agrees. She never is heard putting it out there on tape that he did any of these things.
    4. The fact that she is not triggered by going back into that house, where the sa supposedly took place, is unbelievable. Flashbacks commonly happen, and she makes indication of any.
    5. EVERYBODY ELSE is lying if they don't corroborate her story. She is the ONLY one telling the truth.....and her lawyer is pathetically inept....jeez

  • Kladje GaoNie
    Kladje GaoNie 4 months ago +11

    a mother she didnt care for, and when Johnny was truly grieving his mother, she made all in her power to make him miserable... omg..

  • Stella Blue
    Stella Blue 4 months ago +39

    I’m sorry, but if you’re not allowed to talk about your testimony to your attorneys - HOW DID THEY KNOW to circle back to these new “revelations” regarding timelines??

  • Bekki McGrath
    Bekki McGrath 4 months ago +22

    OMG I can't even with this woman...
    "I just forgot about this time"
    2 seconds later: "you never forget the first time someone hits you"
    SMH she's such a hack

  • Brittany White
    Brittany White 4 months ago +21

    I’m a survivor of DM and she’s such a liar! My ex head butted me once from about 2 feet away and knocked me completely out and I had a huge knot in the middle of my forehead it was so bad I lost a job bc they recommended me leave and go to a DM shelter (I didn’t of course) I was choked multiple multiple times to the point of blacking out and had not just marks but dark BRUISING on my neck for days after. She’s full of herself and she’s a horrible actress! She better find another career after this trials over that’s for sure!!

  • Jana RN
    Jana RN 4 months ago +3

    As I continue watching this, the ENT testimony blows my mind… during discussion of medical records from the ENT and those records being “produced” when her atty stood up and said she did have the records (which obviously they hadn’t provided for some odd reason) I bought fell out of my chair … this woman, as an atty, to continually stand and speak as she does which basically is like testimony in my opinion blows my mind that she’s not admonished to the point she’d stop doing it by the judge …. I’ve never seen such an unprofessional atty in my life !! It’s like she’s not ever been in a court room … then to have to be reminded to turn on her microphone yada yada … wow !! This cross is tearing AH apart not only in facts being misrepresented by her but common sense stuff like why a pic of a bruise on a arm but zero, absolutely zero, of serious injury she claims to have received by JD !! Anyone with a brain cell can see It’s blatantly obvious some serious false allegations and flat out lies have been told by her !!! It’s truly criminal!!!!

  • January Melody
    January Melody 4 months ago +8

    Why is ambers lawyer allowed to interrupt the flow of questioning so often. It allows Amber lots of time to concoct a lie to tell.
    Amber says testimony given under oath by others is a lie whenever it goes against her. Everyone cannot be lying!

  • Taylor Reid
    Taylor Reid 4 months ago +15

    1:01:00 - 1:06:10 this is completely different to what she said about this door and toe incident in her 2016 deposition. back then she was talking about it as all one incident, where she claimed she was trying to escape Johnny, and he was trying to get into the room she fled to and then the toe thing happened. even back then she messed up a couple times about who was trying to get into where since she was lying, and it was actually Johnny trying to get away from her when all that happened. but now she's saying it was two separate incidences? and now she's saying that when her toes got hit with the door it was when he was in the bathroom to get away from her (but she claims she thought he was passing out?) and she was trying to open the door, and the time where she was trying to get away from him was a different thing all together. yet again, in the 2016 deposition she's trying to say Johnny hit her toes with the door trying to get into the room at her to continue hitting her. even in that recording back then when she was saying that, you can hear Johnny saying that she was trying to get in and he was sorry he accidentally hit her toes trying to keep her out. but she was trying to say it was the other way around. and now she has switched the story back around again. I hope they bring up that 2016 deposition and compare because it's wild how different her stories are, and how Johnny's have stayed consistent since the beginning. I also love how she constantly has tried to mention that Johnny is twice her size, yet they're literally the same height lol. on red carpets she's even taller than him with heals on. it's obvious that these are all such blatant lies.

  • Larissa
    Larissa 4 months ago +26

    Every time I see her start crying I question every director and other staff who ever casted her for a movie

  • SL Turner
    SL Turner 4 months ago +16

    Her crying always comes with a lot of sniffing and no actual tears. I really hope the jury can discern the truth

  • Vapor Skies
    Vapor Skies 4 months ago +168

    I WAS LOSING IT THE ENTIRE CROSS EXAM, CAMILLE CAME IN HOT AND STAYED THAT WAY OOOF I WAS NOT READY FOR THAT
    Edit: ALSO, AMBER SAID SOMETHING ALONG THE LINES OF “I didn’t want to label myself a victim” yet in the op-ed she called herself a victim??

    • Perfectly You Beauty
      Perfectly You Beauty 3 months ago +3

      She called herself a victim on the dateline special she just can’t keep her narrative straight 🙄

    • Sarastro
      Sarastro 4 months ago +7

      "tell the world johnny I too am a victim of domestic violence"
      If he is a victim TOO, she thinks of herself as a victim in the first place

    • S L
      S L 4 months ago +4

      Yup, she's incongruent.

    • G ME Haywood
      G ME Haywood 4 months ago +6

      I was so giddy with elation and satisfaction haha!

  • Lisa Jefferies-Wilkin
    Lisa Jefferies-Wilkin 3 months ago +3

    People generally assume that others will live by their standards of behaviour. Therefore AH openly essentially accusing pretty much everyone, right down to the jury, of lying in some capacity, shows me that she absolutely is a liar. She assumes that because she can lie so freely and compulsively, that everyone else must be a compulsive liar too. She makes me sick. It’s her kid I feel sorry for - having to live with someone like that. When you can’t even trust your own mother that shi hurts.

  • Blank Space Provided
    Blank Space Provided 4 months ago +60

    We saw a strong, smart, and empowered woman speak in court today, and her name is Camille Vasquez.

  • Aisha
    Aisha 3 months ago +3

    2:44:00 face photos
    2:47:30 lighting photos
    2:50 Picture taken at exact same time with different lighting
    2:52:30 police card
    2:58:30 jewelry stand
    3:00:00 let someone else tell
    3:19:30 magnum bottle wine
    3:23:30 dog poo
    3:30:00 objection x2 in texts
    3:42:30 never seen so many cams, screamed at me
    3:45:24 bruise kit
    3:35:00 I wouldn’t survive so scared
    3:37:00. Change locks
    3:39:00 no one found out I filed - paparazzi outlets..
    3:40:00 courthouse photo of face bruise
    3:41:33 walk-in to courthouse
    3:42:00 they screamed at me
    3:43:20 skin condition !
    3:47:30 several people testify no makeup 💄
    4:55:00 audio tmz
    5:05:00 I was begging him to not to prove it
    5:11:00 nose wipe
    5:12:00 audio - do you really think I’m an abuser amber
    5:13:30 mediation
    5:14:30 meeting after tRO
    5:15:00 press machine
    5:15:30 dropped from campaign, inundated with press
    5:16:00 carino
    5:17:00 mutual statement to clear my name
    5:18:00 Idc about $$$ - if didn't agree to number, overturned never settle
    took far less than what I was entitled to
    5:19:00 why did you donate 3.5/3.5?
    5:19:50 she wanted tax benefit
    5:25:15 intend to fulfill pledge? deadline?
    5:26:00 separation agreement - he acknowledge I didnt make false claims important to me
    5:38:00 I tweeted it but didn’t have control over the title 🤣🤦🏻‍♀
    5:52:00 sophists yes pr machine
    5:49:20
    I lived through this
    5:55:20 move to strike
    6:05:00 box office bonus Justice league
    6:00:00 L’Oréal contract acts as if she doesn’t know lol
    6:25:00
    6:48:35 cross exam

  • Fake Account
    Fake Account Month ago +1

    As some who has never been the victim of DV, I find Amber Heard quite frightening.

  • Darien Hemmerlein
    Darien Hemmerlein 4 months ago +57

    Amber: he didn't even feel the cigarette burning his leg
    Me: ... So you took a picture because you were concerned for his safety rather than grabbing the cigarette...? O.o

  • Lilo Jade
    Lilo Jade 4 months ago +15

    Amber’s lawyer can NOT lay a foundation to save her own life!! 🙄 it’s painful to watch 😳

    • Katherine H
      Katherine H 4 months ago

      @The Aztec Engine clients grave...oh my head...

    • The Aztec Engine
      The Aztec Engine 4 months ago +2

      I disagree. She seems to be extremely adept at laying the foundation to her client's grave.

  • Facts Don't have Feelings! Be AWAKE!

    Amber states "I have to relive this. I don't want to relive this. I don't want to have to talk about it. But I can't. I'm here. I want to move on. I just want Johnny to move on"
    Yet... she went out of her way to get TMZ outside the courts for the TRO... She went out of her way to become an Ambassador for a charity that handles DV Survivors. She wrote an Op-Ed in a Well known Media Document that she knew would go internationally.
    She had stated even "I was told by a lawyer* or someone*... that she has the most evidence she's ever seen for a DV case"
    Amber's wanted this in the public eye for so long. Because she was hoping this would rocket her into a higher career by being well known from this all. Well she's well known alright... Just that no one believes her anymore & people will boycott whatever project she's involved in... whatever Movies/Shows/Books her name is associated with. This all backfired on her... And it's all because she just can't tell the truth... She's made a mockery of actual victims of DV... And most of all she's made a show & public mockery of herself...
    She's what a byproduct of... If "The Boy Who Cried Wolf" 🐺& "Pinocchio🤥" had a child👶 together.🐺+🤥=👶💩
    This woman just can't tell the truth if her life depended on it.
    I would love to see her do this all over again but while attached to a lie detector Test. I don't know if the charts read that high though. She might actually break the machine & program.
    This woman is a quack. 🦆
    Good thing Elon was smart enough to get away when he did.
    And jeepers... she says "I never wanted fame" but then goes on about "the red carpet" many times... The movies & roles she's gotten... The Met Gala... Private Jets... Security... Being on Private Islands... And even mentions at 1 point "I don't know if you could relate to being on the red carpet or Met Gala"...
    She tasted Fame. She tasted the spotlight. She tasted the money surrounding it. She got used to the Private Jets. She got used to the many houses... Penthouses... Bubble away from the 'rest of society'... She attended all the red carpet, Met Gala, and other high profile events where there were lots of others in the industry, the cameras & media, etc... so she could get noticed & recognized... But with Johnny it wasn't enough. She was using him as a stepping stone & using him & all his contacts cause she ultimately wanted to leave him & have a huge famous career on her own without him... Where she alone was in the public spotlight.
    Ugggh I can't stand this woman... this hoax... this fraud... this user & abuser.

  • Ibrahim
    Ibrahim 4 months ago +35

    Camille Vasquez single handedly destroyed and embarrassed Amber Heard, moved to strike answers beyond the scope of the questions, but notably completed day 1 of cross examination without a single successful objection from the defendant!

    • Jean Singer
      Jean Singer 4 months ago

      Trauma is CANCER

    • Jean Singer
      Jean Singer 4 months ago

      5 years try 30 everybody fights

    • Je
      Je 4 months ago

      Less than half a day to be fair.

    • Loading
      Loading 4 months ago +1

      Camille looked like prime Lebron on that court 🦾

  • MegHen
    MegHen 4 months ago +58

    She basically just told everyone how she applies bruises with her "bruise kit" because you don't apply color correction on top of foundation & concealer 🤨 busted

  • Faith Melton
    Faith Melton 3 months ago +5

    “My hair was falling out, I was scared, I had shingles, I was falling apart…” I know she didn’t just insinuate that Johnny Depp gave her chickenpox that caused her shingles lmaoooo

  • mybonnieandclyde
    mybonnieandclyde 4 months ago +14

    SO, if the op-ed wasn't about Johnny, why have we all sat through weeks of testimony claiming his abusiveness? You don't get to have 2 opposing defenses.

    • JenicaT
      JenicaT 4 months ago +6

      I think Johnny's side is trying to prove that her writing the op-ed was malicious and intended to mess with his career especially since it's not true while she's trying to prove that the op-ed wasn't supposed to refer to Johnny but at the same time, saying he WAS abusive so even if people assume it's Johnny, it's fine cause it's true anyway. Honestly, her opening statement was all over the place but that's what I understood 🤷🏻‍♀️

  • Evelyn
    Evelyn 4 months ago +37

    AH lawyer just keeps showing zero respect for the judge in my opinion. Like when there's an objection at one point she just says "oh no thats ok" and keeps moving on without waiting for the judge to rule on the objection or when there is a sustained objection she keeps asking the same question over and over leading to a row of objections. She also keeps arguing after the judge ruled something and there are instances where it seems the judge decides something on the bench and she immediately goes against that. Then theres the moving away from the mic while talking and her inability to keep track of the evidence. But the worst to me is all that huffing and puffing when there's an objection, it all seems so unprofessional and disrespectful of a courtroom. At least that's my impression off it when compared to how JD's team is acting.

    • nemesisX rox
      nemesisX rox 4 months ago +3

      ... she's just portrayin herself as 'judge-jury-executioner'

    • Alicia Jacquelene
      Alicia Jacquelene 4 months ago +3

      Yeah I don’t think the judge likes that lawyer much either lol