Wow, I would say this is, in my opinion, one of the best pieces by Eric Whitacre. So strong! Even if it's only an arrangement, but it's simply congenial!
@@laynewalker8867Do you not understand what "Arrangement Whitacre" allows? You are pretending there are not literally millions of original scores, songs...that have been 'arranged by others' who have taken any and every liberty from the originals. Some are barely recognizable from the original. Why are you playing games here? ANYONE suggesting Whitacre "stay in his lane" or "overstepping"....well...you painted your own character here...I don't need to add a thing.
![Caroline Shaw - Plan & Elevation (2015) [w/ score]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/eIEI80LfaMk/mqdefault.jpg)
Wow, I would say this is, in my opinion, one of the best pieces by Eric Whitacre. So strong! Even if it's only an arrangement, but it's simply congenial!
My god, this is incredible beautiful!!!
Wonderful. No idea seconds on vocals could work so well. So inspiring!
I need to amend my previous comment: this is probably the most beautiful piece I heard this year!
A very, very beautiful interpretation of the song. But I think making it beautiful is a disservice to its meaning.
I disagree, I think that this iteration still conveys the pain of the original but in a different way
Why are there wrong notes written in the solo line? Don't believe me? Go listen to the OG track. Whitacre has overstepped here.
A matter of taste. No overstep
If he can't bother to get the right notes in the melody then he needs to stay in his lane. Do it right or not at all.
@@ryanl4582
@@laynewalker8867Do you not understand what "Arrangement Whitacre" allows?
You are pretending there are not literally millions of original scores, songs...that have been 'arranged by others' who have taken any and every liberty from the originals. Some are barely recognizable from the original.
Why are you playing games here?
ANYONE suggesting Whitacre "stay in his lane" or "overstepping"....well...you painted your own character here...I don't need to add a thing.
@@12B4Christ Need a Snickers? I meant every word I said. You're not gonna change my mind, so you just wanted to bitch. Guess what? I don't care.
@@12B4Christ I'll say what I like. Whitacre. Has. No. Business. Messing. With. Industrial. Music. What's next, KMFDM?