A number of comments have asked "What about Car XYZ?" The video says very early on that we tested 14 cars and these are the top five, but if you want to read details on the other nine and why they didn't make it to video stage, you can do so here www.carsales.com.au/editorial/details/best-mid-size-suv-2024-the-other-contenders-145500/
@@BluePandaa284 Personally, for Japanese and Korean car makers, engine noise will always be an issue in comparison to German makers. But this is also due to the fact that German cars generally have bigger engines. It's like asking an athlete to take a jog. Nonetheless, I think the diesel sportage (I have it) doesn't make too much sound. It rides very comfortably and can sit at 100km/hr which still allows me to talk to a passenger without raising my voice (normal voice sound). If you hammer the throttle from a red light, I think all cars will start roaring. The engine is also more responsive if you were to put it in sport mode.
4 weeks ago I’ve got my KIA Sportage PHEV SX (in Europe GT-Line), fully loaded version, just the metallic colour was extra. It’s not really a bargain but the equivalent is a premium like SUV that gives you the premium feeling from A to Z. I think I did the right thing buying this one.
I am so satisfied with my RAV 4 hybrid (2023). It is currently giving me 5.4 L/100 KM, which is just fantastic. Keen to see if Toyota brings in the RAV 4 PHEV with a 200 km range on just electric power. 😀
This was a great video - although would love more explanation on why the Tucson had to “drop out at the last minute”… couldn’t find it in the linked article either.
I really like my Sportage Hybrid SX prestige, and it does have a heated steering wheel. But I guess different markets get different versions. The US doesn't get the diesel.
The mere fact that the RAV4 offers less interior features than the competition and still outsells them all to become the No. 1 best-selling SUV worldwide just goes to show how superior Toyota's reliability is. Their brand value is simply unmatched.
Where Tesla has developed 'The Cult Of Tesla' with their evangelical follower's always reminding everyone "I bought a Tesla", Toyota has their 'sheeple' who blindly follow them due to a carefully crafted reputation for reliability and resale (the best spin Doctors a marketing budget can buy). But what lies behind the cloak of reputation. Design? It's subjective, but what exactly is Toyota's design language? It's amazing how a car can have weird angles and shelf like tail lights but at the same time be as bland as an Aussie families spaghetti bolognaise from the 1970's. It's like the worldwide Taxi Industry drew up blueprints for the ultimate utilitarian passenger delivery apparatus and Toyota stole the plans and built the Camry. Practicality? Have you opened a rear door on a Corolla? It opens about as far as George Costanza's wallet when it's his turn to pay. The highest selling small car in the world for decades is nearly impossible to get in to the back of . . . and yet it's favoured by older people. Why? Because someone said Toyota has a good reputation.
@@planetcountryradio8622well I'm my country they're thousands of 1990s corollas on the road currently about 50 % of the cars are corollas simply because they work and give very few problems and parts are easy to come by
Review incorrectly states that the Honda CR-V VTi L7 has a 360 degree camera though no current Honda CRV models come with a 360 degree camera, it’s not even an option! Reversing camera only. Lack of a 360 degree camera, especially on an all new CR-V model range, could be a deal breaker for some people.
The Mazda brand has shifted its marketing to try and target a more "luxurious" market despite its reputation as a Japanese (reliable) car maker. The CX5 has a lot of tech and the materials are exceptional for a midsize SUV. However, all cars tested in this video are classed as "midsized." Meaning, actually, the CX5 is unfortunately smaller than a lot of its competitors whilst offering quite a high price tag. It's probably closest in dimensions to the Honda ZRV, which also offers more or less the same tech (heating steering wheel, heated back seats). The CX5 however has a HUD and a larger infotainment system. I think it really just what floats your boat. If you want a less family friendly sized car because you prefer the quality of the interior, then the CX5 is definitely the way to go. But the majority of people prefer a car with slightly subpar technology but for bigger size. In this case: Nissan X trail, Kia Sportage, and Toyota Rav 4. Midsize SUVs are generally perfect for newly starting families, and so some of the technology the CX5 offers (such as heated rear seats) are not as relevant compared to the actual dimensions of the car. The CX5 is also comparitvely slow, which means consumers often opt for the turbo line, which also has poor fuel economy. But again, ultimately, everyone is free to have their own personalized score sheet and if you weigh some parts more than others, there's no reason why the CX5 can't be your winner :))
@@TravelFreeBird exactly! very well explained why Mazda is not on that list, I cant find any reason why people buy it except some people like design, how it looks like.
@@hakanyazici lower down in the model range the CX-5 competes much more strongly against these other brands, albeit the space is the same obviously. Also, car reviewers never go into much detail on safety and reliability for some reason but Mazda is very strong there too - I would recommend looking up IIHS ratings as well as JD Power rankings for those two factors. Finally, the Mazda handles great and looks great too, as you say, even on the inside I prefer the CX-5 to all of these, it's much simpler and won't age as much.
I really don’t understand why the Honda ZRV was included in this comparison. It is measurably smaller, especially in boot capacity, than the other genuine midsize SUV’s. Surely the only accurate way to categorise SUVs is by size. That definitely disqualifies it.
The ZR-V is categorised as a mid-size SUV so warranted inclusion and we're glad it was. As the video explains, its smaller dimensions don't really penalise it in terms of interior space and while the boot is a little smaller, it's still very practical. Size may discount it for some people, but it'll be more than adequate for most.
While everyone says diesel should be banned, what does it mean that diesel engines are champions in all car comparison videos? I think Australia is quite confused about diesel cars.
@@wosamosman9814 I live in Victoria and often travel to Tassie and Canberra in the dead of Winter. In no case are heated seats needed. I've spent much time in Alaska and far northern Europe and Briton. Only there are heated seats appreciated. Thanks for posting,
How did X-Trail with asthmatic 2.5 NA engine and CVT transmission got 16 out of 20 in performance section of this review on your website, same as CX5 2.5l turbo? 😂
The best SUVs in this class are from Mazda , CX5 and CX50 . By skipping them you are embracing your car knowledge so watching your channel is a waste of time , good bye.
We had every intention of getting a Forester. My friend owns a dealership but I didn't care for the seats. Too narrow and too short in the seat. They could use some power too. The Ascent was super comfortable but my sister's eats gas and the turbo 4 just doesn't cut it.
Let's be honest. Beyond all the gimmicks and fancy stuff thrown in to lure buyers- what matters most in a car is the engine, transmission, ride/handling and reliability- that's where Japanese cars shine compared to Korean Cars and Toyota is the leader followed by Mazda and Honda which are equally good after it. Proud owner of a RAV4 Edge Hybrid here - love it! Only gripe is the CVT being loud when you accelerate uphill.
What do they mean by "the hyundai tucson fell over at the last minute"? Does that mean they couldn't test it? I'm quite curious to hear how the tucson would stack up
Styling is everything for me… And the two Hondas are the winner.. Kia is good too but a little over the top.. I wish with all that winner features, Rav 4 could have used a better exterior styling, the worst is Nissan which doesn’t even try to excel in this category.
Outlander was tested but didn't make the top five, check out the article in the pinned comment for the verdict on that. As for the CX-90, that's far, far too big and expensive to be included here. If you mean CX-60, again that's beyond the price point.
thanks for review.. Why aren't you giving specs for boot space in liters..? not even in a table? saying this boot is slightly larger than the other car ,doesn't mean much.
They are given in their respective reviews, which you can find here: Kia Sportage: www.carsales.com.au/editorial/details/kia-sportage-2022-long-term-review-137914/?__source=editorialArticle&driver_crosssell=editorial.in.article.link Honda ZR-V 2023: www.carsales.com.au/editorial/details/honda-zr-v-2023-review-141650/?__source=editorialArticle&driver_crosssell=editorial.in.article.link Toyota RAV4: www.carsales.com.au/editorial/details/toyota-rav4-xse-2wd-hybrid-2022-review-138672/?__source=editorialArticle&driver_crosssell=editorial.in.article.link Nissan X-TRAIL: www.carsales.com.au/editorial/details/nissan-x-trail-2022-review-138586/?__source=editorialArticle&driver_crosssell=editorial.in.article.link Honda CR-V: www.carsales.com.au/editorial/details/honda-cr-v-2023-review-142962/?__source=editorialArticle&driver_crosssell=editorial.in.article.link
@@carsales I guess the Kia is still there at #1 or #2 but without a diesel variant. It really is a niche engine and when they are just used as family transport in the burbs, the longer term reliability becomes a real money drain. Even though the interior of the RAV4 is looking a little tired these days, hybrid economy and ride comfort are still far too compelling vs a petrol Sportage and it's fuel use.
The Forester is not in the top 5? It's one of the best all round medium sized SUV on the market. Sure it's getting a little long in the tooth and a new model is due next year but it could compete against this lot without to much fuss. Go a little off the beaten track and I know what I would want to be driving.
I have looked at and driven all your top 3 my choice would be 1st RAV4 2nd Kia sportage 3rd ZRV. I HAVE ORDERD an XSE RAV4 10 months ago, yes the waiting time would turn a lot of people off.
Does the Rav 4 edge hybrid have heads up display? Im curious about the baby forerunner coming out as well.. Reliability and parts is a go for Toyota for me.. Kia does have the nicer dash however. I wish Toyota made a diesel hybrid mid suv…
You can read about the other contenders in more detail here: www.carsales.com.au/editorial/details/best-mid-size-suv-2024-the-other-contenders-145500/?__source=editorialArticle&driver_crosssell=editorial.in.article.link
You could've made it fair to the rav4, you used the more expensive grades of all the others but the cheapest rav4, there are 2 other grades that are way closer to the others in price
Mitsubishi Outlander is not included? Isn't ZRV is a small SUV? I am sorry to say, review is not good enough to find a perfect mid size SUV car. If I were to review, I would select top 5-7 models excluding those which are not updated (face lift or new models) recently including EU models as well. And my review would be based on following things: 1) Practicality, style and design 2) Cost of ownership and on going maintenance, 3) safety, reliability and long term reliability 4) Fuel efficiency 5) Technology and other extra features. Days are gone where people buy foolishly due to high cost of everything.
The Mitzi failed in terms of comfort and overall engine performance, the Nissan is a better package especially with refinement and comfort however smaller.
According to Carsales other competitors, the ride quality is also poor, the engine is underwhelming in both performance and efficiency and rear seat space is relatively tight. 😢😢😢
Ain't this biased? Where is the MG HS, the Chery Tiggo Pro 7, the Haval H6 or the H6 GT and the Mahindra? Or a few others like the Volkswagen Tiguan, Skoda Kodiak etc? Most unbiased review ever!
Funnily enough, watching the video answers your question. There's no MG HS press car, the Chery Tiggo Pro 7 wasn't made available, the Haval, Tiguan and Karoq were all tested and didn't make the final five. As for the Mahindra, it's in a much different price class.
Maybe in the 2025 if you wait and get the next gen model, and if an only if, it’s an XT 2.4T version. CR-V wins easily for space and arguably style and it is nippy & frugal in E:HEV hybrid form, the ZR-V is better to drive but lacks space and sunroof and is butt ugly, performance from the X-Trail E:Power AWD twin electric motor is mind blowing for a plump mid size SUV and will easily blow away any of these other cars. Kia Sportage with a problematic 1.6T and dual clutch auto manual ….. yeah nah. RAV-4 is obviously great but archaic. If you’re renting one …. go the X-Trail E:Power …. it’s great fun and smashes the Outback XT in a sprint up to at least 80km/h. E:Power X-Trail 0-100, 6.5 sec, 2.5L X-Trail 10 sec.
The Outlander was tested but didn't make the top five, you can read why in the article in the pinned comment, but long story short poor ride quality and packaging.
Unfortunately, it hasn't changed in a long time, but the new gen coming up looks very promising, especially since it will have a toyota hybrid variant, which will make it extra competitive .
Diesel and automatic transmission are so outdated. Direct drive with an electric motor and no gearbox at all is by far the best design. Honda knows how the best hybrid works. I don't know, how could any other design be better? Dual clutch transmission or torque converter, oh no.
Really, no Mazda CX5, Hyundai Tucson, Ford Escape, Subaru Forester, Mitsubishi Outlander and VW Tiguan! Seriously, this isn't the best mid size suv. PS. Having two Hondas just sums it all up - not fair.
All those cars were tested bar the Escape, which is no longer offered in Australia sadly, and the Tucson which is just about to be updated. Check out the article in the pinned comment for how they performed and why they didn't make the top five.
Double check some are not natural leather. For instance the Sportage I bought in the US market has Syntex which is not leather at all. It feels a lot like it but it is not natural.
A number of comments have asked "What about Car XYZ?" The video says very early on that we tested 14 cars and these are the top five, but if you want to read details on the other nine and why they didn't make it to video stage, you can do so here www.carsales.com.au/editorial/details/best-mid-size-suv-2024-the-other-contenders-145500/
I received my sportage in same spec last week and it is so good to drive and packed full of features and tech! The diesel engine is fantastic too!
What abount engine noise ?
@@BluePandaa284 Personally, for Japanese and Korean car makers, engine noise will always be an issue in comparison to German makers. But this is also due to the fact that German cars generally have bigger engines. It's like asking an athlete to take a jog. Nonetheless, I think the diesel sportage (I have it) doesn't make too much sound. It rides very comfortably and can sit at 100km/hr which still allows me to talk to a passenger without raising my voice (normal voice sound). If you hammer the throttle from a red light, I think all cars will start roaring. The engine is also more responsive if you were to put it in sport mode.
@@TravelFreeBird Buy a German car and trade it in before the bumper to bumper warranty expires. This is advice from BMW techs at lunched with.
4 weeks ago I’ve got my KIA Sportage PHEV SX (in Europe GT-Line), fully loaded version, just the metallic colour was extra. It’s not really a bargain but the equivalent is a premium like SUV that gives you the premium feeling from A to Z. I think I did the right thing buying this one.
I’m very happy with our 2024 Kia Sportage SX Prestige Hybrid. Lots of room, great ride and handling, fantastic tech features.
I am so satisfied with my RAV 4 hybrid (2023). It is currently giving me 5.4 L/100 KM, which is just fantastic. Keen to see if Toyota brings in the RAV 4 PHEV with a 200 km range on just electric power. 😀
This was a great video - although would love more explanation on why the Tucson had to “drop out at the last minute”… couldn’t find it in the linked article either.
Without CX-5, this list of carry-overs is just boring. The best of the bunch in handling. Period.
Honda is always the right choice.
Without Mazda this video incomplete 👉💯
I really like my Sportage Hybrid SX prestige, and it does have a heated steering wheel. But I guess different markets get different versions. The US doesn't get the diesel.
The mere fact that the RAV4 offers less interior features than the competition and still outsells them all to become the No. 1 best-selling SUV worldwide just goes to show how superior Toyota's reliability is. Their brand value is simply unmatched.
That Toyota reputation shining through!
What are isavix positions?
Where Tesla has developed 'The Cult Of Tesla' with their evangelical follower's always reminding everyone "I bought a Tesla", Toyota has their 'sheeple' who blindly follow them due to a carefully crafted reputation for reliability and resale (the best spin Doctors a marketing budget can buy). But what lies behind the cloak of reputation. Design? It's subjective, but what exactly is Toyota's design language? It's amazing how a car can have weird angles and shelf like tail lights but at the same time be as bland as an Aussie families spaghetti bolognaise from the 1970's. It's like the worldwide Taxi Industry drew up blueprints for the ultimate utilitarian passenger delivery apparatus and Toyota stole the plans and built the Camry. Practicality? Have you opened a rear door on a Corolla? It opens about as far as George Costanza's wallet when it's his turn to pay. The highest selling small car in the world for decades is nearly impossible to get in to the back of . . . and yet it's favoured by older people. Why? Because someone said Toyota has a good reputation.
@@rickyzoom8059Isofix points are for anchoring car seats or capsules
@@planetcountryradio8622well I'm my country they're thousands of 1990s corollas on the road currently about 50 % of the cars are corollas simply because they work and give very few problems and parts are easy to come by
My mom bought one kislux and she loves it. It had been there for over 10 years when she went out with it.
This is the test I have no interest in but I'm here.
Thanks for dropping by!
Review incorrectly states that the Honda CR-V VTi L7 has a 360 degree camera though no current Honda CRV models come with a 360 degree camera, it’s not even an option! Reversing camera only. Lack of a 360 degree camera, especially on an all new CR-V model range, could be a deal breaker for some people.
Can’t imagine no Mazda CX 5, probably one of the best!
The Mazda brand has shifted its marketing to try and target a more "luxurious" market despite its reputation as a Japanese (reliable) car maker. The CX5 has a lot of tech and the materials are exceptional for a midsize SUV. However, all cars tested in this video are classed as "midsized." Meaning, actually, the CX5 is unfortunately smaller than a lot of its competitors whilst offering quite a high price tag. It's probably closest in dimensions to the Honda ZRV, which also offers more or less the same tech (heating steering wheel, heated back seats). The CX5 however has a HUD and a larger infotainment system. I think it really just what floats your boat. If you want a less family friendly sized car because you prefer the quality of the interior, then the CX5 is definitely the way to go. But the majority of people prefer a car with slightly subpar technology but for bigger size. In this case: Nissan X trail, Kia Sportage, and Toyota Rav 4. Midsize SUVs are generally perfect for newly starting families, and so some of the technology the CX5 offers (such as heated rear seats) are not as relevant compared to the actual dimensions of the car. The CX5 is also comparitvely slow, which means consumers often opt for the turbo line, which also has poor fuel economy. But again, ultimately, everyone is free to have their own personalized score sheet and if you weigh some parts more than others, there's no reason why the CX5 can't be your winner :))
@@TravelFreeBird exactly! very well explained why Mazda is not on that list, I cant find any reason why people buy it except some people like design, how it looks like.
@@hakanyazici lower down in the model range the CX-5 competes much more strongly against these other brands, albeit the space is the same obviously. Also, car reviewers never go into much detail on safety and reliability for some reason but Mazda is very strong there too - I would recommend looking up IIHS ratings as well as JD Power rankings for those two factors. Finally, the Mazda handles great and looks great too, as you say, even on the inside I prefer the CX-5 to all of these, it's much simpler and won't age as much.
My mrs has just bought a HEV shortage!! It’s seriously good
Highly recommended
I really don’t understand why the Honda ZRV was included in this comparison. It is measurably smaller, especially in boot capacity, than the other genuine midsize SUV’s. Surely the only accurate way to categorise SUVs is by size. That definitely disqualifies it.
The ZR-V is categorised as a mid-size SUV so warranted inclusion and we're glad it was. As the video explains, its smaller dimensions don't really penalise it in terms of interior space and while the boot is a little smaller, it's still very practical. Size may discount it for some people, but it'll be more than adequate for most.
Why no outlander.
Outlander was in the top 14 tested suv.... Didn't make it to the top 5
While everyone says diesel should be banned, what does it mean that diesel engines are champions in all car comparison videos? I think Australia is quite confused about diesel cars.
Diesel is good, only crazy greenies dislike it
Only politicians don't like it
They probably don't have money in diesel vs gasoline and electric. So they have to try to ban it so they make more money lol...
In Australia, cooled seat are more imported than heated seats. And heated steering is stupid.
No need for cooling if they're cloth...
It's needed in Victoria and Tassie 😂
@@wosamosman9814 I live in Victoria and often travel to Tassie and Canberra in the dead of Winter. In no case are heated seats needed. I've spent much time in Alaska and far northern Europe and Briton. Only there are heated seats appreciated. Thanks for posting,
Cooled seat is a must in Qld summers
@letsseeif
No worries and fair point I guess 😅.
Haven't been to real cold places like Alaska so Victoria and Tassie are my reference points
other than RAV4, does any other SUV in the list provide remote climate control via the apps?
How did X-Trail with asthmatic 2.5 NA engine and CVT transmission got 16 out of 20 in performance section of this review on your website, same as CX5 2.5l turbo? 😂
The best SUVs in this class are from Mazda , CX5 and CX50 .
By skipping them you are embracing your car knowledge so watching your channel is a waste of time , good bye.
A very good comparison and review ❤ Helps a lot 👍 Thank you 🎉
Thank you!
@carsales where is subaru forester...I would choose that over these....
We had every intention of getting a Forester. My friend owns a dealership but I didn't care for the seats. Too narrow and too short in the seat. They could use some power too. The Ascent was super comfortable but my sister's eats gas and the turbo 4 just doesn't cut it.
Let's be honest. Beyond all the gimmicks and fancy stuff thrown in to lure buyers- what matters most in a car is the engine, transmission, ride/handling and reliability- that's where Japanese cars shine compared to Korean Cars and Toyota is the leader followed by Mazda and Honda which are equally good after it. Proud owner of a RAV4 Edge Hybrid here - love it! Only gripe is the CVT being loud when you accelerate uphill.
Dont forget Subarus😊
Too narrow seats and cramped inside compared to the CRV.
“E” cvt
What do they mean by "the hyundai tucson fell over at the last minute"? Does that mean they couldn't test it? I'm quite curious to hear how the tucson would stack up
Styling is everything for me… And the two Hondas are the winner.. Kia is good too but a little over the top.. I wish with all that winner features, Rav 4 could have used a better exterior styling, the worst is Nissan which doesn’t even try to excel in this category.
Where are the beasts Outlander and Mazda cx 90?
Outlander was tested but didn't make the top five, check out the article in the pinned comment for the verdict on that. As for the CX-90, that's far, far too big and expensive to be included here. If you mean CX-60, again that's beyond the price point.
thanks for review..
Why aren't you giving specs for boot space in liters..? not even in a table? saying this boot is slightly larger than the other car ,doesn't mean much.
They are given in their respective reviews, which you can find here:
Kia Sportage: www.carsales.com.au/editorial/details/kia-sportage-2022-long-term-review-137914/?__source=editorialArticle&driver_crosssell=editorial.in.article.link
Honda ZR-V 2023: www.carsales.com.au/editorial/details/honda-zr-v-2023-review-141650/?__source=editorialArticle&driver_crosssell=editorial.in.article.link
Toyota RAV4: www.carsales.com.au/editorial/details/toyota-rav4-xse-2wd-hybrid-2022-review-138672/?__source=editorialArticle&driver_crosssell=editorial.in.article.link
Nissan X-TRAIL: www.carsales.com.au/editorial/details/nissan-x-trail-2022-review-138586/?__source=editorialArticle&driver_crosssell=editorial.in.article.link
Honda CR-V: www.carsales.com.au/editorial/details/honda-cr-v-2023-review-142962/?__source=editorialArticle&driver_crosssell=editorial.in.article.link
I love kisluxs that on the butterfly bag it says auguri / tanti auguri which means happy birthday
The Best is the X Trail e Power. I own one since 2 Month. It’s a phantastic Car.
Good summary. I think you have picked well for the most part, although I would not buy a diesel
Would you have a different top five and guessing a different winner? We'd love to hear your thoughts :)
@@carsales I guess the Kia is still there at #1 or #2 but without a diesel variant. It really is a niche engine and when they are just used as family transport in the burbs, the longer term reliability becomes a real money drain. Even though the interior of the RAV4 is looking a little tired these days, hybrid economy and ride comfort are still far too compelling vs a petrol Sportage and it's fuel use.
@@bazinga615 Without the 10/100K mile powertrain warranty Kia and Hyundai wouldn't sell any ICE vehicles.
nadine looks tiny in the x-trail compared to the others lol great video!!
All new RAV4 redesign will be mind blowing.
The price will be too😂
With interior size of the CRV. Research the cost of a simple oil change on a Toyota Hybrid. It's outrageous with 0-8 oil.
The Forester is not in the top 5? It's one of the best all round medium sized SUV on the market. Sure it's getting a little long in the tooth and a new model is due next year but it could compete against this lot without to much fuss. Go a little off the beaten track and I know what I would want to be driving.
I have looked at and driven all your top 3 my choice would be 1st RAV4 2nd Kia sportage 3rd ZRV. I HAVE ORDERD an XSE RAV4 10 months ago, yes the waiting time would turn a lot of people off.
We walked into a Toyota dealer on a Sunday and drove away with a new RAV4 hybrid cruiser the next Saturday last month.
@@kdegraa your so lucky we are still waiting. It’s been 12 months now, maybe it’s location eg: I live in Adelaide Australia 🇦🇺
Can't wait for my Toyota rav 4 xse awd hybrid in a few weeks
Does the Rav 4 edge hybrid have heads up display? Im curious about the baby forerunner coming out as well..
Reliability and parts is a go for Toyota for me.. Kia does have the nicer dash however. I wish Toyota made a diesel hybrid mid suv…
You are claiming to be able to get a RAV 4 for 48,000 Australian how? They are 78,000 australian here in the UK
Ouch 😅
The cost is before taxes and stuff. This RAV4 costs around $53k on the road.
Can I please know, what suburb u been driving around. It looks so stunning 😊
This was filmed near Ascot Vale in Victoria.
Nth suburbs of Melbourne 🤮🤮🤮
Cx5 or CX 50?
not putting the QX60 into this arguement should be a crime.
Suprisingly, no mention about reliability...don't want to get 'stuck' somewhere with kids in the car, do we...
Im interested in the claim quote of each car upon 100000 km. 😅
Why no outlander instead of small Zrv?
Should be most expensive mid size SUV. Not really a comparison when you only have half of them.
You can read about the other contenders in more detail here: www.carsales.com.au/editorial/details/best-mid-size-suv-2024-the-other-contenders-145500/?__source=editorialArticle&driver_crosssell=editorial.in.article.link
Wait where is Haval h6?
Why byd atto 3 is included, it supposed to compare with smaller suv like hrv and corolla cross?
Byd is a cheaply build suv. You can’t compare it with the good SUV’s. If you really look it up and ask a good mechanic he will tell you so as well.
What about 2024 Mitsubishi Outlander?
Didn’t make the top 5
You could've made it fair to the rav4, you used the more expensive grades of all the others but the cheapest rav4, there are 2 other grades that are way closer to the others in price
Mitsubishi Outlander is not included? Isn't ZRV is a small SUV?
I am sorry to say, review is not good enough to find a perfect mid size SUV car.
If I were to review, I would select top 5-7 models excluding those which are not updated (face lift or new models) recently including EU models as well.
And my review would be based on following things: 1) Practicality, style and design 2) Cost of ownership and on going maintenance, 3) safety, reliability and long term reliability 4) Fuel efficiency 5) Technology and other extra features.
Days are gone where people buy foolishly due to high cost of everything.
The Mitzi failed in terms of comfort and overall engine performance, the Nissan is a better package especially with refinement and comfort however smaller.
ZRV is mid size. Dimension is equivalent to CX-5 with bigger leg room but less boot.
kislux I love you so much and watching your videos makes my day brighter
Those are compact suv, not mid-size suv. Australians call mid-size suv, large suv.
So what do you call the category smaller than compact then? Teeny? I think you're mistaken
Where's Australia's 3rd best selling mid size suv? Mitsubishi Outlander?
According to Carsales other competitors, the ride quality is also poor, the engine is underwhelming in both performance and efficiency and rear seat space is relatively tight. 😢😢😢
Rav 4
A real car lover needs to know most reliable car
Vincenza Trail
Ain't this biased? Where is the MG HS, the Chery Tiggo Pro 7, the Haval H6 or the H6 GT and the Mahindra? Or a few others like the Volkswagen Tiguan, Skoda Kodiak etc? Most unbiased review ever!
Funnily enough, watching the video answers your question. There's no MG HS press car, the Chery Tiggo Pro 7 wasn't made available, the Haval, Tiguan and Karoq were all tested and didn't make the final five. As for the Mahindra, it's in a much different price class.
You missed the King...Subaru Forester hands down!
Maybe in the 2025 if you wait and get the next gen model, and if an only if, it’s an XT 2.4T version.
CR-V wins easily for space and arguably style and it is nippy & frugal in E:HEV hybrid form, the ZR-V is better to drive but lacks space and sunroof and is butt ugly, performance from the X-Trail E:Power AWD twin electric motor is mind blowing for a plump mid size SUV and will easily blow away any of these other cars. Kia Sportage with a problematic 1.6T and dual clutch auto manual ….. yeah nah. RAV-4 is obviously great but archaic.
If you’re renting one …. go the X-Trail E:Power …. it’s great fun and smashes the Outback XT in a sprint up to at least 80km/h. E:Power X-Trail 0-100, 6.5 sec, 2.5L X-Trail 10 sec.
The seats suck for a wide shouldered man like me.
Surprised that the CX5 hasn't made the list. It's so much better than the nissan
No outlander?
The Outlander was tested but didn't make the top five, you can read why in the article in the pinned comment, but long story short poor ride quality and packaging.
If u consider these cars as mid size suvs than in India we get mid size suvs even smaller than these cars.
Outlander?
Hyundai Tucson
Where is the Subaru Forester?
Why are they all so over priced??? No way would I spend $48K on a RAV4 and $50k on a Kia Sportage!
Because people buy them.
No forester? 😢
Unfortunately, it hasn't changed in a long time, but the new gen coming up looks very promising, especially since it will have a toyota hybrid variant, which will make it extra competitive .
The Subaru Outback Touring XT with turbo beats any of these cars and no mention???
I don’t think Rock climbing is less sporty than F1, jeesh
Despite the presenter looking abit like king Charles ; she is kinda cute.
However, these vehicles are not mid size SUVs , they are compact SUVs
Did not like the list of cars here. Missing best sellers like CX5, Outlander, etc. 2 Honda, where one them is smaller.
All those cars were tested but did not make the top five. You can find out how they performed in the article in the pinned comment.
Haha she thinks the ZRV is jittery, wow is she wrong. Don't think she drove it hard through the country roads. Handles like a sports car.
Definitely agree with you on this one. I own one and its also very comfortable and quiet cabin noise.
Kia telluride ??
midsize suv. read and listen 😂
Fell over..without Tucson you don’t have a top 5
these reviews drive me nuts as they don't revriew all brands of cars!
Diesel and automatic transmission are so outdated. Direct drive with an electric motor and no gearbox at all is by far the best design. Honda knows how the best hybrid works. I don't know, how could any other design be better? Dual clutch transmission or torque converter, oh no.
50,000+?!?!? In American currency?!?
This is AUD prices
Hey all these SUVs you review are uproarious please can you put Toyota Fortuner sigma 4 in your SUV line
Who buys a Honda these days? Must be paid promo
Judged on our assessment, people who like good cars.
in America we call them the Honda Bumps
Well biased video from Carsales as usual.
Really, no Mazda CX5, Hyundai Tucson, Ford Escape, Subaru Forester, Mitsubishi Outlander and VW Tiguan!
Seriously, this isn't the best mid size suv.
PS. Having two Hondas just sums it all up - not fair.
All those cars were tested bar the Escape, which is no longer offered in Australia sadly, and the Tucson which is just about to be updated. Check out the article in the pinned comment for how they performed and why they didn't make the top five.
Not even close to valid results.
I don't like Kia Sportage. Kia's Aggressive design will not help. Kia Sportage technology is not superior.
Chivi Travers??!!!
The honda zrv does not belong in this class, there is no outlander , no subaru forester , no mazda cx50
This is a very bad comparison
where's hyundqi tucson 2024 it's
the best
KIA is the winner in my book.
wheres Mazda...?
The CX-5 was tested and performed very well, but the cramped interior and thirsty (albeit powerful) engine meant it just missed the top five.
This review is biased, period
The comments on this Zizek interview were all about cars. ruclips.net/video/IVgAc_oJ6DY/видео.html
Great... they all have leather. Pass on all of them
Double check some are not natural leather. For instance the Sportage I bought in the US market has Syntex which is not leather at all. It feels a lot like it but it is not natural.
RAV4 is is small not midsize
where os cx5😅😅😅
Walsh Unions
Where's Lexus?
A mid-size Lexus SUV for ~$50,000?
@hazemsalem Japan. 😉
Clark Brian Moore Angela Hall William
RAV 4 ITS CAR FOR OLD MENS....
ONLY HONDA CRV !
Williams Margaret Young Melissa Thomas Thomas
Harris Joseph Taylor Jennifer Clark James
Only drive diesels not microwaves
Who can afford cars with those idiotic high prizes nowadays????