In a proper room with proper setup it is VERY evident that number 1 (b&k omnis) was the most realistic. The cardioid ones were narrower in how I sensed space and it felt weird, can't really put my head around it. It feels as if some frequencies were out of phase. Anyhow, this video is pure gold, we live in amazing times where we can learn so much from RUclips.
Most honest recording test on youtube. B&K is the best, crown's are harsh. Your audience liked them because you have a nice warm sounding piano, wouldn't be the same on a Yamaha. Thanks
The playback for each of the mics was very noticeable through headphones. Just to note, I was using over-ear; not tiny in-ear headphones. I felt that the omni pair created a small pocket of nothingness in the center of the sound field. The Sony mics were personally my favorite. I would love to hear them in XY because I want to reinforce the bass line of the music more to balance it with the melody. The Crowns felt out of place in my opinion. When hearing them, the attack was greatly emphasized for music that was written with romantic period intentions. At some points in the music, the piano sounded "like" a music box. It had a metallic timber to it. I'm curious and want to see the Crowns used in a pop setting. The AKGs were fine. They had a warm sound that could be used to create a live concert hall. Finally, the Gefells were nice. When used in the XY formation, it gave the listener a closed but comfortable space. It made me feel that I was listening to the performer live in my house. With editing, the sound can be placed in a concert hall and do just as fine. (I am still new to the world of recording and these are just my personal observations. I would love to hear more opinions on the mics.)
Checking back here after a year... I agree with all your observations; the Sonys are my favorite too. But I doubt you'd perceive any more bass in XY. The lower strings are (by design) straight in front of the ORTF pair, so their low frequencies should arrive at both mics generally in phase, minimizing any cancellation even if the outputs are summed. And personally I don't care for XY because it gives no arrival time difference cues to the ear/brain to create a sound field with depth or help localize the source. It depends on amplitude differences only, which for me, is kinda "meh" for stereo.
Very helpful and informative video. Thanks. I liked the slight stereo spread of the ORTF pairs. The Sony's sounded crystal clear and very real. The omni's gave a very nice balanced, realistic and slightly ambient sound. I didn't like the XY - a bit too narrow for my taste and an un-appealing frequency response in that particular location.
The Crown PZM 6LP sounded most like a Steinway D, the AKG Tube sounded least like a Steinway D. The B&K 4007, Sony C-500P and Geffel M930 colored the sound differently and it's personal taste as to which sounds "the best." The Steinway D is the most recorded piano and it's obvious microphones alter its sound. This can lead to unrealistic expectations as to what a real piano sounds like. Overall I prefer the B&K 4007 but any of them are fine.
Hi! Perfect video! If you could borrow 4X AKG 414, 2X Neumann TLM 170i, 2X Neumann U 87, 2X Gefell M930 and 2X AEA R44C mics which ones would you use for a yamaha c3 on a livingroom?
Very informative. As a recording buff, I have come across these situations, and these techniques are priceless. I have seen some use a wig fitting foam head, with mics placed at the ears, which gives a natural spacing and timing effect they say of human hearing. Any room for an apprentice ?
Many thanks for posting this. Fascinating and informative. For what it's worth, I favour the B&K omnis. They deliver a sense of realism which the others lack. I'm listening through ADAM-A7s, nearfield placement. One day, I'll be rich enough to afford a decent pair of omnis. :-)
Curious to the mic pre you used. Also what digital reverb do you use on classical? Finally would love to hear a version of this comparison including an Earthworks PM-40 mic setup.
In a proper room with proper setup it is VERY evident that number 1 (b&k omnis) was the most realistic. The cardioid ones were narrower in how I sensed space and it felt weird, can't really put my head around it. It feels as if some frequencies were out of phase. Anyhow, this video is pure gold, we live in amazing times where we can learn so much from RUclips.
Most honest recording test on youtube. B&K is the best, crown's are harsh. Your audience liked them because you have a nice warm sounding piano, wouldn't be the same on a Yamaha. Thanks
The playback for each of the mics was very noticeable through headphones. Just to note, I was using over-ear; not tiny in-ear headphones. I felt that the omni pair created a small pocket of nothingness in the center of the sound field. The Sony mics were personally my favorite. I would love to hear them in XY because I want to reinforce the bass line of the music more to balance it with the melody. The Crowns felt out of place in my opinion. When hearing them, the attack was greatly emphasized for music that was written with romantic period intentions. At some points in the music, the piano sounded "like" a music box. It had a metallic timber to it. I'm curious and want to see the Crowns used in a pop setting. The AKGs were fine. They had a warm sound that could be used to create a live concert hall. Finally, the Gefells were nice. When used in the XY formation, it gave the listener a closed but comfortable space. It made me feel that I was listening to the performer live in my house. With editing, the sound can be placed in a concert hall and do just as fine. (I am still new to the world of recording and these are just my personal observations. I would love to hear more opinions on the mics.)
Order a CD of the recordings at djcarlst.provide.net/20160917.htm#CD.
Checking back here after a year... I agree with all your observations; the Sonys are my favorite too. But I doubt you'd perceive any more bass in XY. The lower strings are (by design) straight in front of the ORTF pair, so their low frequencies should arrive at both mics generally in phase, minimizing any cancellation even if the outputs are summed. And personally I don't care for XY because it gives no arrival time difference cues to the ear/brain to create a sound field with depth or help localize the source. It depends on amplitude differences only, which for me, is kinda "meh" for stereo.
Very helpful and informative video. Thanks. I liked the slight stereo spread of the ORTF pairs. The Sony's sounded crystal clear and very real. The omni's gave a very nice balanced, realistic and slightly ambient sound. I didn't like the XY - a bit too narrow for my taste and an un-appealing frequency response in that particular location.
I loveed Gefell M930 and AKG tube sounds!
Omni mics sounded the best to me!!!
B&K 4007 is fantastic!
I usually use Schoeps Mk5 (polar omni), I found that they have a sound similar to these B&K
now this is a real tutorial, unlike those "these 5 plugins changed my life" type of scam tutorials that are allover RUclips
excelent! thanks for share it!
Merci beaucoup, très apprécié, grande valeur technique. J'ai préféré les tube (C12). Merci encore.
The Crown PZM 6LP sounded most like a Steinway D, the AKG Tube sounded least like a Steinway D. The B&K 4007, Sony C-500P and Geffel M930 colored the sound differently and it's personal taste as to which sounds "the best." The Steinway D is the most recorded piano and it's obvious microphones alter its sound. This can lead to unrealistic expectations as to what a real piano sounds like. Overall I prefer the B&K 4007 but any of them are fine.
Awesome video! So well done comparison of mics, lots of info! Please do something similar on cello!
Good informative video.
Thanks for sharing your expertise and the incredibly helpful comparison! So helpful for me!
I loved the B&K 4007 the way they were placed. With the AKG tube in the middle would make my day! Great review! Thanks!
Owww the B&K 4007!
"No one cares about the mono mix anymore".
Amazon: "hold my beer"
Jokes aside, you should absolutely be checking your mono mix.
Hi! Perfect video! If you could borrow 4X AKG 414, 2X Neumann TLM 170i, 2X Neumann U 87, 2X Gefell M930 and 2X AEA R44C mics which ones would you use for a yamaha c3 on a livingroom?
Very informative. As a recording buff, I have come across these situations, and these techniques are priceless. I have seen some use a wig fitting foam head, with mics placed at the ears, which gives a natural spacing and timing effect they say of human hearing. Any room for an apprentice ?
Superbe, merci!. I would love to heat the demo for a solo acoustic finger-style guitar. Would the ORTF pattern work?
Many thanks for posting this. Fascinating and informative. For what it's worth, I favour the B&K omnis. They deliver a sense of realism which the others lack. I'm listening through ADAM-A7s, nearfield placement. One day, I'll be rich enough to afford a decent pair of omnis. :-)
Curious to the mic pre you used. Also what digital reverb do you use on classical? Finally would love to hear a version of this comparison including an Earthworks PM-40 mic setup.
Wow thanks!! Ortf sounded almost if not better than the omnis. Great demos and great commentators!
thank you. very nice video. :)
No. 5