... (long post coming through) Water Cave Act 1's soundtrack edit didn't sound bad. Adding the funkiness to the song was pretty good. But Said stage's Act 2 variant was a little off. The funkiness was still good, and I mean, good. Like, they didn't have to do anything else with the music. But, they did. Also, I think it was Water Cave Act 1 when I saw how they edited the level design to two quarter loops heading downward and I awaited an amazing speed design but instead found Sonic hanging on the conveyor. I was disappointed- I waited for a speedy experience but instead got a conveyor belt. That moment felt incomplete. Killer Garden's background palette threw me off a little on a more color direction. The sky's rich red bothered me. If they were going for a dusky look, a softer shade of orange would have sufficed. However, if they were going for a more ominous feel... I don't know what to say about that. For a more ominous feel, I would probably suggest changing the entire palette to give it that feel (and, I don't mean ominously epileptic). Or, a different stage edit in general but that's a lot of work if one is familiar with introducing new shapes and whatnot in a stage (I'm currently learning how to accomplish that). Also, Night of Death stage, like New Island, please fellow hackers, be mindful of underwater palettes. They differ from the "dry" palettes. I don't mess with stages with underwater palettes- too complicated for my beginner mind, for now. And, Mushroom Land's stage palette introduced too many colors. I'm not sure if this is for a joke matter or not but the colors distracted me as I watched this. If this is a joke hack, then I'll let it pass. All of it, really, I'll let it pass. But, I don't think it is. Is it? Sorry if this sounded ultra-critical. I don't to come off as sounding mean or "on-my-high-horse" or anything. I should say kudos to this fellow hacker as they actually uploaded a successful hack. My little behind is still dancing around mine, nowhere NEAR complete and I keep procrastinating on it. Plus, I don't think it'll even be that good which also encourages me to not even uploading it anyway. So if anything, I should be congratulating this hacker instead of criticizing them. xD Also Amy, awesome playthrough! It must have took a lot of practice and time to master this hack and all of the other ones. Keep up the good work!
OW!!!! That God damn music fucks with my ears, and those special stages just want to make your ears bleed, also the new island soundtrack. The only positive thing in this game is most of those changes like the pallette changes but somehow sonic turns black when underwater in the new island zone.
I wish I had Sonic 3 and knuckles project Angel So that I can get to play As Sonic And Tails with all chaos emeralds and knuckles With no emeralds and all extra life’s.
How is that? They'll get feedback and then do better next time. Rom hacking isn't a profession. You can't just expect a certain level of quality out of hobbyists. It could certainly lead to a professional job, but if you don't put your stuff out there and learn how to do it, you probably won't get very far.
TheCongressman1 What I'm saying is, even if it's not their profession, if they take pride in what they do then putting out such shoddy quality work does no good for them as a rom hacker/composer. I understand that feedback is good, but putting time and effort into something before you decide it's ready to be shown to the world is usually the best route to go. This just sounds like they moved the pitches around and basically slaughtered the soundtrack.
The game is bad,but the quality of the vid,why isnt the quality better?360p is the maximum?JESUS CHRIST ABOVE!!With the music,level design and the quality in one vid,im dying.But guys,maybe this was his first try into being a level designer.He made some mistakes,but we all make mistakes,am i right?He'll get better,I'm sure he will.And before u are all,,OH,u just writed hate comments under the vid like all of us",I wrote everything on New Years Eve and my brain doesnt work well in 3 am in the morning.So give time for Apinatyyppi and im sure he'll be a great level designer and make a 8/10 hack for Sonic 3 & Knuckles.
Is this a TAS run? If it is it really should be in the description. If not then sorry, just seems a little over precise for being ordinary human control. Particularly the seventh special stage, I've never seen anyone do anything remotely like that without screwing it up at least once.
Am I the only one that actually liked the music? Thought they were fun remixes for the most part, not to mention any decent hack of S3&K is always a plus in my book.
Possibly a glitch in that particular stage as there seems to be about 123 or so left on the counter. I watched I little more closely in the second Special Stage and there are about 9 left at the end but I'm almost certain that they are all accounted for when the player closes the perimeter of the last box of spheres, turning them into rings. Still watching through the rest of it atm though.
I have several questions bout the level design.Why in 3:56 the forest is black when its burning,why in the Sky Sanctuary remake zone the sky is black,then turns into a mix of day and night,then back to black,why in New Island zone Sonic is black underwater,why is the Death Egg Robot purple,and why,just WHYYYYYY,is the second part of The doomsday zone is all glitched out,like wtf?
guys! dot get angry at the music composer, it's not his fault he was born deaf! at least show him some love and direct him to a hobby that he actually has some knowledge of.
Wow! The instrument change in Act 1 of Icecap Zone/ Ice Cave Zone makes the Icecap Zone theme sound rather full! That's good!
Nah it sounds worse
YA
The Mushroom Land Act 1 theme is the E-Rank version of Mushroom Hill Act 1.
I appreciate the attempt this person made to try this hack but... UGH! The music is just godawful!
Wat is the music,BEAUTIFUL or GODFULL or AWFUL?Just tell us,man
Can’t believe it’s been 10 years since I watched this video, which is how I also found this channel and you’re still active in 2024? That’s some work
Maybe I'm just a crappy S3&K player, but, wow, this guy is a frickin daredevil when it comes to the 3D special stages, especially that last one.
Hydro City Zone Carnival Night Zone remix!
Am I the only one repulsed by the music here?
Nope, it's awful.
All of it is complete poo
I like only a select few (Hydrocity Zone being my favorite) but the rest sounds like it got broken when it was released.
***** you can definately say that!
***** yeah wish it wasnt
why the hell does this hack look and sound like a fever dream. my ears and eyes are offended
This isn't a fever dream... it's a fever nightmare
@@marcysoucy9522 NO THIS IS SPARTA HAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
Why does the music sound like farts? Why is it even "remixed"?
It's not fart!! Those musics are so good!!
***** Dude, you have serious problems if you think so...
Shiny Pikachu™ don't call me dude!
Me too I can relate
***** I don't have your number I can't call you :/
AIZ act 2 music goes hard
That theme music reminds of sonic 3 and knuckles master edition 1 and 2
That Mago Emperor battle music's hurting my ears!
I just realized that Mushroom Kingdom Zone act 1 Project Angel music farts.
Project ANGEL?! Yeah, okay, maybe if the "angel" is named Harpy.
Three cheers for Amy Rose Longplay and Sonic 3 & Knuckles: Project Angel Longplay as "Sonic & Tails"
Hydrocity Zone soundtrack is epic!!!!
Its sounds little bit like carnival night zone theme in the background
What's up with half of the S3K hacks having music ranging from meh to awful?
I love how 99% of Sonic 3 Hack video comments are about the music 😂😂😂
GREAT SONIC III & KNUCKLES: PROJECT ANGEL (GENESIS ) - LONGPLAY AS SONIC & TAILS !!!!
... (long post coming through)
Water Cave Act 1's soundtrack edit didn't sound bad. Adding the funkiness to the song was pretty good. But Said stage's Act 2 variant was a little off. The funkiness was still good, and I mean, good. Like, they didn't have to do anything else with the music. But, they did. Also, I think it was Water Cave Act 1 when I saw how they edited the level design to two quarter loops heading downward and I awaited an amazing speed design but instead found Sonic hanging on the conveyor. I was disappointed- I waited for a speedy experience but instead got a conveyor belt. That moment felt incomplete.
Killer Garden's background palette threw me off a little on a more color direction. The sky's rich red bothered me. If they were going for a dusky look, a softer shade of orange would have sufficed. However, if they were going for a more ominous feel... I don't know what to say about that. For a more ominous feel, I would probably suggest changing the entire palette to give it that feel (and, I don't mean ominously epileptic). Or, a different stage edit in general but that's a lot of work if one is familiar with introducing new shapes and whatnot in a stage (I'm currently learning how to accomplish that).
Also, Night of Death stage, like New Island, please fellow hackers, be mindful of underwater palettes. They differ from the "dry" palettes. I don't mess with stages with underwater palettes- too complicated for my beginner mind, for now.
And, Mushroom Land's stage palette introduced too many colors. I'm not sure if this is for a joke matter or not but the colors distracted me as I watched this. If this is a joke hack, then I'll let it pass. All of it, really, I'll let it pass. But, I don't think it is. Is it?
Sorry if this sounded ultra-critical. I don't to come off as sounding mean or "on-my-high-horse" or anything. I should say kudos to this fellow hacker as they actually uploaded a successful hack. My little behind is still dancing around mine, nowhere NEAR complete and I keep procrastinating on it. Plus, I don't think it'll even be that good which also encourages me to not even uploading it anyway. So if anything, I should be congratulating this hacker instead of criticizing them. xD
Also Amy, awesome playthrough! It must have took a lot of practice and time to master this hack and all of the other ones. Keep up the good work!
No, you’re not being high and mighty. I agree with you. Hope you’ve gotten to be an expert.
22:14 Super Sonic!
Good job on completing this!
errrgh! that special stage music
morsoe1 uu
OW!!!! That God damn music fucks with my ears, and those special stages just want to make your ears bleed, also the new island soundtrack. The only positive thing in this game is most of those changes like the pallette changes but somehow sonic turns black when underwater in the new island zone.
Good lord! :o Sonic 3 and Knuckles on LSDs! :p
OMG AWFUL MUSIC!!!!
It's Nice! Thank's For Sharing & More Power Too!
Not forget to play all sonic hacks in 2013 year
13:43 Listen to the sound of the stage 😂😂😂
1:06:39 What was that noise?
Water cave looks like ketchup underwater
THE DEVIL IS IN SONIC 3!!! 0:58
The only decent one is the final boss theme
Amy he looks like dark sonic
What happend at the Boss of Launch Base Zone Act 1?
I like Flying Fortress Zone act 1 mid boss remix though.
FBZ1 didn't sound too bad, but the rest was pretty rough
I start the game and it immediately crashes.
The music sounds really strange!
You not
better luck in next time
VegaLTE did not created this hack especially that he does much better at level designing hacks.
MY GOD THIS SOUNDTRACK IS EAR RAPE
Why the hell is Water Cave's theme sped up?!It sounds like Sonic using the power sneakers!
Damn 28:19 is on the rhythm
Competition music used in Volcano Palace Zone?!
Y’all crack me up about the music lol
0:16 What ?!
I wish I had Sonic 3 and knuckles project Angel So that I can get to play As Sonic And Tails with all chaos emeralds and knuckles With no emeralds and all extra life’s.
Sonic 3 And Knuckles Project Devil
or Sonic 3 And Knuckles Project Demon
Avant Sonic 3 and Knuckles Project 10th annivesary.
or may be Sonic 3 and Knuckles Project Hyperdrive
Not forget to complete all chaos emeralds
this is either a hack-of-hack (Sonic 3 & knuckles master edition) or a prototype of the mentioned
Holy **** this music sounds terrible. probably the worst megadrive music i have heard. D:
It's Z80 sound driver music.
SunkythePootis shut up. I have no choice but to disable all of your comments.
how about you disable your life support
BlueyAnimations Wow, how rude of you!
@@AeizzatToha 😂
from now we call hydrocity water cave
Jesus christ! This hack should have been renamed Sonic 3 & Knuckles: Project Dumb Angel because this music sounds about as creepy as Happy Appy!
2017 Edit: I managed to beat this game. Somehow. If you listen closely, you can hear my soul vomiting everywhere.
The Salkkupolis music doesn't sound as bad as a lot of it...
This music is ear rape.
when you touch an orb you hear father
How did you transform a second time into Hyper Sonic?
***** Except he didn't do that yet in Marble Zone. He was super, hit a box and then BAM, Hyper Sonic.
***** Cool
What did they do to the soundtrack? I have the feeling they don't have much experience in this.
Gotta learn somehow.
TheCongressman1 That's true. But they released this to the public. That's just bad practice for anyone making Rom hacks.
How is that? They'll get feedback and then do better next time.
Rom hacking isn't a profession. You can't just expect a certain level of quality out of hobbyists. It could certainly lead to a professional job, but if you don't put your stuff out there and learn how to do it, you probably won't get very far.
TheCongressman1 What I'm saying is, even if it's not their profession, if they take pride in what they do then putting out such shoddy quality work does no good for them as a rom hacker/composer. I understand that feedback is good, but putting time and effort into something before you decide it's ready to be shown to the world is usually the best route to go. This just sounds like they moved the pitches around and basically slaughtered the soundtrack.
I find some of it acceptable, I'm diggin water cave act 1 and the special stage
Some Music Like The New Island Theme Isn't Too Bad, But The Special Stages... ARGH!
The game is bad,but the quality of the vid,why isnt the quality better?360p is the maximum?JESUS CHRIST ABOVE!!With the music,level design and the quality in one vid,im dying.But guys,maybe this was his first try into being a level designer.He made some mistakes,but we all make mistakes,am i right?He'll get better,I'm sure he will.And before u are all,,OH,u just writed hate comments under the vid like all of us",I wrote everything on New Years Eve and my brain doesnt work well in 3 am in the morning.So give time for Apinatyyppi and im sure he'll be a great level designer and make a 8/10 hack for Sonic 3 & Knuckles.
I wish I had that game
Is this a TAS run? If it is it really should be in the description. If not then sorry, just seems a little over precise for being ordinary human control. Particularly the seventh special stage, I've never seen anyone do anything remotely like that without screwing it up at least once.
Its always possible that he or she has played blue sphere very extensively.
8 years late, but yes, it is!
The music is so bad that it's good.
Am I the only one that actually liked the music? Thought they were fun remixes for the most part, not to mention any decent hack of S3&K is always a plus in my book.
I do too, just gotta get used to it
heavy game play heavy game
It's like ACRES of water on almost every level. 😐
Cool I TASed this hacks :D
cool vid amy
Donde puedo descargar esta versión del juego?
That Doomsday battle music sounds really bad.
А как это Соник по красным шарикам прыгает на 19-й минуте?
1:29:53 😊
Oh dear. Death Star Zone act 2 Launch Base Zone remix. That's bad.
cool , amy rose
Soundtrack... God...
360p and low bit rate in 2014.....really?
No offense but I don’t like the music that much I still think it’s a great concept and the hack seems intresting and wacky but maybe fix the music
Wow this music is so depressing
1:18 Weren't there blue spheres left on the stage?
Possibly a glitch in that particular stage as there seems to be about 123 or so left on the counter. I watched I little more closely in the second Special Stage and there are about 9 left at the end but I'm almost certain that they are all accounted for when the player closes the perimeter of the last box of spheres, turning them into rings. Still watching through the rest of it atm though.
Ugh, some of the palettes really need work.
I have several questions bout the level design.Why in 3:56 the forest is black when its burning,why in the Sky Sanctuary remake zone the sky is black,then turns into a mix of day and night,then back to black,why in New Island zone Sonic is black underwater,why is the Death Egg Robot purple,and why,just WHYYYYYY,is the second part of The doomsday zone is all glitched out,like wtf?
come on how did u even get sonic 3 and knuckles project Angel ? this is impossible
@Snow344 Starting a level crashes the game.
why did i hear the mini boss theme in knuckles' song?
Soda laugh, >>
dat music do
I love the music plus every one stop being rude
1:15:46-1:15:49 😅
the rom doesn't even work
You must be a speed runner
The music sounds terrible!
this is ok... but the music it's so bad and the speial stages look weird
how did someone remade this game ? like the music in new land act 2 at 5:28
The only thing I have to complain about the hack is the way the special stages are designed, when making a hack don't do that shit.
what's with the complaints?! it's an ***** upload. everyone should bow down
where did you get this
Tightwing look at the description for download link
I dont get the zone after flying fortress
how can you make tails fly you in the air?😮😮😮
just so much water
what in the everloving FUCK did they do to mushroom hill
my kega fusion cannot play it can somebody help me? Sonic keeps dying and the game restarts
guys! dot get angry at the music composer, it's not his fault he was born deaf! at least show him some love and direct him to a hobby that he actually has some knowledge of.
But it gave me a headache...
i think that was because the joke went over your head.
What did you use to hack?
Why does it sound so different it has too much squeak