How To PUNISH A Dog | The Right and The GENTLE Way
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 28 сен 2024
- 🐶 Get Immediate Results with Expert Dog Training Support. Start here: sarodogtrainin...
◉ About Me:
I am a dog trainer, and I coach dog owners. I help you train your dog(s) or puppy without the use of treats, aversive tools like shock collars, prong collars, force, or Dominance. I teach and show you how to use "play and praise" as a reward to train your dog.
❤ FREE DOG TRAINING - DISCOVER THE JOY OF TRAINING YOUR DOG VIDEO MASTERCLASS - sarodogtrainin...
❤ POTTY TRAIN YOUR PUPPY OR DOG IN 48 HOURS OR LESS app.overdogdig...
❤ 2 SIMPLE YET POWERFUL TIPS TO IMPROVE YOUR DOG'S BEHAVIOR pages.sarodogt...
I love this COMPLETELY NEW APPROACH! starting all over with no treats, no negative, no anger, no frustration......all and only positive!
Keep it positive and actually celebrate when your dog makes a mistake because it offers you an opportunity to train your dog. The more your dog makes mistakes the more you train and the the better the dog gets.
It's not a world recognised approach because of what is taught to trainers, they're taught the to follow the four quadrants of dog training, this is the problem basically but there's more to it, traditional methods and protocols are shared from trainer to trainer and these days RUclips videos show them how things can be done, but it's all based on the same principals. I started out helping horses & moved over to dogs around 25 years ago, I didn't take a single course back then, I was naturally talented at reading a dog, I understand facial expressions, body language, different vocalisations, tail movement and environmental context. This helps me to learn about a particular dogs needs & the things he doesn't like too. I worked out for myself how to find what a particular dog loved to do & would encourage it so the dog feels fulfilled. I'm a bit daft, I'm always happy and calm, dogs copy me & become happy and calm too, That's when we can start to play our interactive games, that's when the learning begins. When a dog does what I want, I praise at varying levels, when a dog doesn't do what I want (yet they know), then I take appropriate action, that might be me becoming a physical barrier, I might say 'no', I may place them on a leash to help guide them or just simply end the game and do something different for now. I think that building on trust and relationship is very important, it's my first step toward helping any dog to learn what's wanted from them, yet this step is ignored by most trainers, it confuses me why, because it makes life so much easier when a dog actually wants to work with you. I think Saro dog training & probably only a handful of trainers in the world train this way, so unfortunately it's difficult to spread the word which is a shame because it works so well. This year alone I have helped more than sixty dogs that where about to be put to sleep due to aggression issues, all had worked with other trainers, behaviourists & vets over quite long periods. What they all missed though was relationship, trust, fulfillment of needs & fun. All of those dogs are no longer 'aggressive dogs'. simply because their needs are now met in full. No punshment, no treats. Maybe a bit of flooding to help resolve reactivity.
I would like to see it done on a problematic dog 🧐
It does work, if you have trained the dog the basics and also, if you repeat the procedure few times, the dog learns not to repeat the unwanted behaviour because it has to go through the same routine. It works and I use it whenever I need to, which is hardly.
@@SaroDogTraining Not saying it Dosent work.
Imagine demonstrating a self defense move without somebody attacking or resisting your defensive move.
A demonstration with a complaint dog is completely different to a demonstration with a non-compliant dog.
That is why your dog needs to know basic obedience. So invest in training the basics at least so your dog will become compliant.
@@1Humanoid you gonna still disagree, aren’t you?
@@1Humanoid What I get is that you can't put your dog in an unfair situation and except to perform something they just don't know. Which I actually find reasonable. I've trained dogs and you would fins issues, bad behaviors and so on, but with foundations comes clarity so you can do what he show us in pretty much any situation. But, if you haven't trained them you can't expect to snap them out of a trigger and use obedience as "punishment." And this is why more than 90% of owners fail and have just terrible dogs, because of 0 training or proper training. Is like if you send someone to defend from someone that would attack them but you haven't teach them how to.
Good idea. Thanks Saro. It distracts the dog and takes it away from the negative behaviours.
Absolutely!
@@SaroDogTraining Thank you Saro!!!!
The dog should know the basic commands and also the verbal correction word "No". I would give the verbal correction word first and if the dog does not respond to it, then I would do the mini training session as shown in the video.
Incredibly helpful. I was surprised by how well my dog understood and responded to this method. Thank you!
That is great. Sometimes we just need to get involved and simply be there and interact with our dogs without any attachments.
I'm really happy to see that you are actually train your dog like this and treated him so calm an positivelly. ❤❤
I am glad you like the method and enjoyed the video. I feel this is what dog training should feel and look like.
@@SaroDogTraining yeah it's so true❤️
Fellow dog trainer from Netherlands. Could not agree more! Principles and Methodology are so important. Your dog will remember these cornerstones everytime and without developing unnecessary trauma or irrational fears. It is good training for the dog and the boss! Salut.
Thank you for visiting us from Netherlands. I appreciate your feedback. How long have you been a dog trainer and what is your specialty?
That is very good advice for life. Now I totally understand your point. Buying a leash for my kid today. Wish me luck guys.
You can do it!
@@SaroDogTraining He said he was buying a leash for his *kid* not his dog!
@@Maha_s1999 lol sure it was a joke
It is just dog equivalent of push ups….”Get down a give me twenty “…love it.
I really appreciate these videos! Please keep making them! Do you have any videos for dogs that are already adults but are being naughty?
You can use the same method as long as your dog is trained and knows some basic obedience commands.
This is not at all correct.. think of it, best way to see how to train a dog is to see how mother dogs train their puppies. it's not all lovey, lovey sometimes the mama dog bites and barks harshly
human beings cant know how to train more than the mama dog
when my puppy was small it had a habit of growling every time i gave her a bone.. was so severe that at one point she even bit me just for stroking her while she was eating
i tried this 'calm, non harsh methods in such videos for months.. nothing worked.. " eventually i had had enough, i once took a towel wrapped it around her eyes, she couldn't see me, took the bone from her forcefully and then took her out for a few minutes away from the bone.. closed the door behind her.. she wimped and wimped after about 10 minutes. Then i allowed her back in and gave her the bone
the growling never happened again - like kids sometimes positive reinforcement will not work
I understand that maybe this method is not the right or the ideal method for you. It may be for some others. You can do whatever you like.
What if the dog does not listen and will not do the lesson? They won't respond to treats or redirecting?
If that is the situation, start focusing on developing and working on basic obedience. I explain more in this video. ruclips.net/video/1_Kgr9ajLuQ/видео.html
May I ask. I used to use this practice when my dog would start to whine outside (when she wants smth or is impatient over smth starts whining), and as a result it seems like I ended up the problem even worse.
She whines more thinking that if she does that we will work (high work drive dog).
Would like to hear your opinion on this.
Thank you
Make the training (positive punishment) session short or as long as your dog gives you the signal that it is done. I usually go for 5 to 8 minutes.
@@SaroDogTraining thank you for the insight and your kind support.
I've got an 18 week old puppy and he just bites all the time and never listens. We do training with him but with treats, do we reward with treats at the end or no?
Here are the reasons and solutions for biting: ruclips.net/video/8Ma69mwx2a8/видео.htmlsi=a7xa8vNjVafMUr6g
That's interesting because I did that with my friends dog with out even knowing that I was training her. When I stood up and put her leash on her, what ever she was doing stopped and she would sit and look at me. When I sat down, of course she was back to doing what ever it was. LOL
My one year old loves to chewing plastic pots , new pack of Mulch , digging into garden and chew up roots, if I just repeat the basic trainings you showed, how could he understand he is punished for his wrong doings in the yard and don’t do that again?
Great question. You don't just punish the dog for that reason. This solution in this case would be either confined the dog or do not let it get into the garden first of all. Prevention is the key here. Second, make sure that your dog knows the correction process before you use this method. Third, try providing other forms of stimulation so the dog is not focused on the garden.
Thank you so much for this!!! I'm seeing it working 🥳
You’re welcome 😊. That is great to hear. Keep on working on it and have fun with your dog.
While this may work with most dogs and most breeds, I’d like to see someone try this positive only stuff with a 130 male Rottie or a 150 pond Cane Corso. Good Luck.
Interesting! But you can use this method, if the dog, no matter what the breed, as long as knows the basics (basic obedience). Don't look for excuses. Look for solutions.
@@SaroDogTraining First, You’re making assumptions about my experience because you don’t have a valid response. Second, there is a difference between and excuse and a reason. Do you know what that is? A genuine attempt to resolve the issue. Which, either way, is irrelevant to my comment. I made an objective statement. You’re pushing this positive only stuff and because of it dogs will die. And people, too. When an owner tries the be positive only with certain dogs, and it doesn’t work, what are they going to do? Send them to the pound and they’ll more than likely be killed. Which is far more inhumane than a little buzz when they do something wrong. The tools make them think twice about acts that could be catastrophic. You positive only people demonize e collars and prongs when those tools save dogs and peoples lives. These aren’t your babies. They aren’t helpless little children. They’re animals. And some breeds are more than capable of killing people.
If your positive only stuff worked so well, why are there so many dogs in shelters? Why are so many dogs attacking and killing people? You can’t blame everything on abusive owners. I have two 130 pound male Rotties. And they’re not my first. Balanced training, E collars, prong collars and the like have saved their lives at points. Every day I see dogs without prongs or e collars get out of control when another dog walks by. My dogs don’t do that. I don’t appreciate people making other people feel like they’re bad owners for using these tools.
I understand your position very well and I am sorry if I sounded rude. May I ask then, why is it that you needed to use those tools (E collars, prong collars...) in the first place if you've had experience with dogs before? Is it because they are 130 pounds or you needed additional tools and ideas to train them?
Thank you so much. My puppy was able to follow the punishment. I didn't know how punish them positively. I was adviced to hit or pressure the dog, make a loud noise. I didn't like the idea but I ended up following it. I feel like becoming a monster.
I don't think anybody likes to be mean or angry to their dogs especially when it comes to correcting the dog. I am glad you feel better now and can use a more natural and effective way of correction.
So what do you do if you arrive home and the dog has chewed the sofa?
I ask this because the bad behaviour is being done while your not there to redirect the dog while the bad behavior is being done?
That in my opinion is human error and that is the punishment that the human gets. When a dog is in a state of the mind that can destroy the sofa, it means that the dog is being very clear about it's mental and emotional state of the mind. Your dog may have been telling you about how it felt for months or years but you have not listened to it so your dog is being super clear and is showing or communicating it to you physically so you can see it. So, now, you need to ask yourself. What can I do to help my dog? What is causing my dog to have such a negative emotional and mental feelings and how can I help it? It is not a time to punish a dog who is being so clear to communicate to you.
Can u connect the word no to it. And wil it work ?
I don't understand your question. Can you elaborate more?
Wow super helpful thanks so much
Glad it helped. Thank you for watching.
I have a question, how do i train my dog not to bite when i try to approach him with a piece of cloth because he keeps biting it and its so annoying and i don't know how to deal with it
Here are a few tips to help address this behavior: Teach the "Leave It" Command: Start by teaching your dog the "Leave It" command. This command teaches them to let go of or ignore objects on command.
Divert Their Attention: Instead of approaching your dog with the cloth directly, try redirecting their focus onto a different object or activity. For example, use a toy or a treat-dispensing puzzle toy to engage their attention. As they become engrossed in the new object or activity, slowly approach them with the cloth, rewarding them with praise and a treat for staying calm.
Positive Reinforcement: Use positive reinforcement techniques to reward your dog for appropriate behavior. Whenever they remain calm and do not bite at the cloth, offer praise, or playtime to reinforce the desired behavior. Consistency is key, so be patient and reward your dog consistently for their good behavior.
Thank you very much!
How do I keep a male catahoula from running away from home for days .he knows all commands but loves to run free .I live on an unfenced acre lot n rent so can't put fence up..he knows go potty n come home.. usually he goes in woods 15 min or so n returns..but Abt 2xs a month he runs off for a day or 2.. the only things he understands is me with holding food..Last time he did it .I withheld food for 24 hours n he seemed to stay home ..until now..A month later he started running off again..n yes..I've had him neutured
This will explain. ruclips.net/video/Gmj48DW35U4/видео.html
How about putting a leash on him and walking him? Otherwise, you will always have a higher risk of him not returning after his walks.
Hi Saro, thanks for this video, found it interesting! My cocker spaniel has an issue with attacking people, sometimes it can be when he’s touched or it can be quite sudden like when being offered a treat he snaps. His bites are getting worse and I’ve been working with a trainer who has advised that in the event that he snaps to handle him by the collar and say “off” and stay there till he calms down and then repeat the action that triggered him again so that he can learn the correct way. I was wondering what your thoughts were on that and what your advice would be in the event that your dog snaps at someone suddenly, what would be the immediate thing to do in that situation?
Prevention is the key. If you know that your dog will bite at certain occasions, so avoid those situations. Second of all, you need to work on desensitizing your dog when triggered. There are many other things that need to be considered and I explain some of them in this video: ruclips.net/video/RKo_xvR_H98/видео.htmlsi=Ni4iRr1JN-XSMTnV
My dog always chews my garbage can on me and if I forget my food and leave the room for a second he eats it i don’t know how to solve this because the garbage is already chewed and I have heard to show him it and say no sternly but I don’t feel it’s right to yell at him I also have had it suggested to put him in his cage but It seems like he just forgets i tried the other day ago and once I let him out I ran to the bathroom and when I walked out the garbage was laid all out chewed again it’s really frustrating actually because he is the sweetest kindest dog ever so I know he isn’t doing it to act up I have had and seen many dogs before that just outright act up and misbehave also he is fed often and exercised very well multiple times a day he is a Boston terrier pit bull mix anything you could possibly suggest to help would be greatly appreciated
In cases lik ethis, I suggest management which means somehow you need to secure the garbage can somewhere that your dog is not able to get to it but easy for you to access to it. Your dog has learned that are good stuff in the garbage can and likes it. It is also another way of entertainment and interaction with you. Whenever it gets to the can, you interact with it. So, consider focusing on providing your dog's other needs as well and not just exercise. Learn about the needs here: ruclips.net/video/7PLTj5zNSVw/видео.html
Question on this if my dog attacked someone random that wasn't a threat what should I do? Do I do the same thing or do I have to do something different as a result of that?
If your dog attacks another dog, it is a sign that your dog is stressed and you need to address that. Learn more here: ruclips.net/video/2GW2XyjHFEA/видео.html
Ok so now can we have it done with a Doberman pup that won’t stay still, turns into a death rolling alligator while on leash, and can’t stop biting for the life of her. I don’t know what to do at this point, nothings working. Not this method, not the ignoring methods, and 100% not the method my family uses: hitting the dog or biting her ear when she bites us.
I think the biting is the issue, correct? If yes, you need to address the core issues which I explain and share solutions in the following videos:ruclips.net/video/8Ma69mwx2a8/видео.htmlsi=WSI8SMVL6gljdhys and this: ruclips.net/video/EEOqhOrQg5s/видео.htmlsi=Pq9KmcSCpVRfK9f5
@@SaroDogTraining thanks, I’ll check these out! And sorry if this comment did come off slightly rude or harsh.
How do I convince my dad that a shock collar is no good that my dog is barking no matter what I say he still hits them with a toy hammer and shouts at them and puts a muzzle on them what do I do
Show him this video: ruclips.net/video/sqPZu3hSG1I/видео.htmlsi=XeZvlD6Gisbhihn1
Wonderful approach Sir...
So nice of you. Thank you.
what is the punishment ?
In this case, the consequence involves repeating familiar exercises, making the dog prefer not to repeat the exercise rather than misbehave.
I know a guy who had a little dog and every time it barked and growled loudly at new people he would either smack it (not break its jaw or crack its ribs) but hard eneough to hurt definatly not make it bleed or anything deplorable because then aside from him being a POS the dog would be afraid of him. Or he would more commonly grab its body and face so it couldnt bark and hold it down on its side until it stopped growling. The dog is the chillest small dog ive ever met. It could partially be that it matured but dogs are relativly smart animals and will lern from punishment. I think its dumb to say dogs dont learn from punishment because there intelligent animals capable of doing so and they all have different personalities. Maybe you think that because your dog has the type of personality that makes punishment less effective or your punishment didnt hurt eneough to bother the dog and it just thought you were playing.
Punishment is something that humans do to get results right away. It is something that humans have figured out to use but dogs and animals do not relate to that mindset. They see it as getting physical. Dogs respond to physical activity differently than humans. Dogs have teeth and they can use them to defend themselves. Once they do that, humans feel pain get more aggressive and use more physical punishment. This cycle continues until someone gives up. The better idea would have been not to start it all. If you feel that dogs are intelligent, then why do we have to rely on physical punishment in the first place?
I agree that hitting your dog or yelling at your dog is not the way to go by punishing them but I don't agree with playing with them every time they're bad because what that teaches them eventually is all they have to do is act up and you'll drop everything you're doing and spend time with them, dogs like to be commanded, so I don't agree with this..
I have two dogs and the way I discipline them when they act up is I separate them and I chain them up separately on their leash in two separate rooms and I give them timeouts... At first it was pointless but after a week or two weeks doing it they know by the tone of my voice that they're about to get put in time out...
Now this may not work for every dog but I feel like it's something to try😊
Firstly, you are not playing only with them when using this system. You are retraining them and teaching them that if you misbehave, I am committed to address it. That is what responsible and committed dog owners do. Invest in teaching, training and addressing their dog's wanted or unwanted behaviours.
Secondly, the reason, you are using this system is to emphasis on training and make your dog better so you don't need to correct them in the long term. Once they learn the correction cues plus you invest in providing your dog's daily needs, dogs won't make anymore mistakes. I hardly correct my dogs now because they don't do mistakes.
And finally, chaining and punishing a dog by isolating it, is has a very psychological negative effects on dogs which in long term can cause other unwanted behaviours to develop.
There is a reason why I suggest this system because I have done my research and have studied dog and human psychology for over 20 years. Solutions like yours are very outdated and not scientifically proven, unfortunately.
Shihtzu, my dog, Kanna. Just 4 months old. Is this punishment good enough for the pups or do they have to different technique from adult dogs?
Please write all your suggestions and to the people reading this.
4 months old is too young for you to use this technique because the 4 months old puppy still does not know the basics of the obedience so this won't work. Instead, I would start with this: ruclips.net/video/-O-4jMI5g8Q/видео.html
@@SaroDogTraining thanks soo much!! I know she’s just a baby. Why I asked and thought this may be a little rough. ☺️👌
I'm not sure if this would actually work for a puppy who pees in the house who already knows the schedule we go out to pee for. My 4 month old puppy would get excited if i ask him to sit and stay because he thinks there's a treat coming. And correct me if I'm wrong, I don't really want to give my dog the impression that he's about to get a treat after he just peed inside.
Puppies are a different story when it comes to being corrected when you are trying to potty train them. For potty training use the following info in this video. ruclips.net/video/oFQHPGBMPZc/видео.html
@@SaroDogTraining I use a timeout method as punishment. And my 4 month old knows exactly what's Coming when he gets caught doing something wrong. Typically i make him stay under the bed for a while and to make it feel like a punishment I start giving my bunny treats and not him and he gets it and it's been working really really well for me. You can tell he knows what's right and what's wrong
@@xobano I agree somewhat with the timeout punishment. It does make them feel bad but I am not sure if it teaches them anything. I also believe that positive punishment should be done only few times and not repeated all the time. If you are repeating or the dog is making mistakes, it all means that the punishment was not clear and the dog has not learned it yet.
@@SaroDogTraining funny thing is my dog has this face that he pulls everytime he's done something wrong lol so I know that he knows his mistakes but he's stubborn as a little baby. He's only 6 months old though.
@@xobano my puppy knows that pee inside = me mad. but he doesn't know that me mad = pee outside. so that face your dog makes absolutely does not imply that he knows what's up. there is more than one logical inference and their brains are the size of a nutmeg.
Thank you so much for tips
My pleasure 😊.
I am going to take this to heart and try this now when rooo jumps goes up on my cabinet doors in the kitchen.
Go for it!
@@SaroDogTraining ok since I am a horrible leader / communicator for my dog she peed two times in a row on my bed. had to wash the linens twice. so I used this method to correct her she can sit and when I tell her to stay. stay there for about 15 seconds with me backing up even dropping the leash some times
Thank you when I diseplene my puppy I inmeydalty regret it
It doesn't feel good, right? Also, you don't get good results.
@@SaroDogTraining yeah plus it make you sad thank you🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Hi there do I do same with a rottweiler 4 year old pup mate he's nippy time times when he's on one and don't listen only when he's on one but when he is settled and karm he will listen he can play up on lead to biting on lead but only at times blessings ⚡💥🔥💦💧💯💙🇬🇧👑
Hey! Dealing with a nippy and occasionally disobedient 4-year-old Rottweiler can be challenging, but don't worry, you're not alone. It's important to address these behaviors to ensure a harmonious relationship. Consistency in training and providing positive reinforcement during calm moments can help improve his behavior. This video will help more. ruclips.net/video/0ICPcvpctYA/видео.html
@@SaroDogTraining sorry I didn't mean a 4 year old I shud of read before I sent he's a 4 mouth old rottie so still young to get him right before he gets older sorry bless
But I still watch that link u sent me cool
Chewing on my dads Christmas present that i worked on shoveling sidewalks for days.. (it was $20) (im 12 by the way)
Sorry to hear that. It socks! Learn from this and start providing your dog's daily essential needs so this does not happen again. ruclips.net/video/7PLTj5zNSVw/видео.html
@@SaroDogTraining ill take a look 👍
No treats!??? I don’t even know how that’s possible!! 😮
That is what my channel is all about. When it comes to dog training, dog owners are stuck with the idea that you can not train dogs without treats. It is an impossible task but it is a human concept and challenge and not a dog issue. Once we change the human's perspective about dogs and dog training, everything else lines up for a great successful dog training journey. Watch my video to unlock the secret. Start here: ruclips.net/p/PLtpQk4y0FQeWXZA79y3gWavKcqrkzzHCg
Need to know what to do when dog is constantly following me everywhere.
Thinks he can jump onto furniture.
Your dog is looking for a job and direction from you and you are not directing anything.
What about puppies? When we are outside on the grass he wants to eat the leaves, dirt etc .. how would you handle this? He’s beginning to listen and understand “no” and that I don’t want him to do it but still does it sometimes. Right now when he does it I pick him up, remove it from his mouth, and gently put my hands over his mouth and say “no”. Any ideas?
Puppies are obviously different story. They are not ready yet. I suggest not to place the puppy in situation or places that there are things that the puppy can put dangerous stuff in its mouth. To improve the walk watch this: ruclips.net/video/GZWHF-GPV8Ea/видео.htmlnd to improve this unwanted behaviour watch this: ruclips.net/video/tTq-LsllwsA/видео.html
@@SaroDogTraining thanks Saro 👊🏻
Not good enough for keeping a. Pack under control ... have to use the old voice for that !
Work on each dog individually so everyone is in the same page and then use the method.
@@SaroDogTraining Easier said than done though, if conflict sparks between 2-3 dogs then you practically have a nanosecond to disperse it before things potentially get dangerous? am I expected to step in silent and clip on 2-3 leads and do that which is on the video simultaneously all at the same time for 2-3 dogs? just cant see that happening in a nanosecond... id rather shout to disperse the conflict tbh, tried and true
Maybe you bit more than you can chew?
I don’t agree with using the word punish. We trainers should not even use words that are related to punishment and negativity. Correct, redirect or guide are more accurate words. Dogs do not punish their young to make them learn. They correct and guide. But to explain the difference like so, this will be helpful.
Many of my fans asked me how to punish dogs so I titled it as such. I agree with you that we shouldn't punish dogs as I explained in the video, if you watch it. Watch the video first and then share your thoughts. That will be more constructive.
Hi CECILIA.
Do you have a RUclips channel with dog training on it please send if you do and thank you
Dog listen to you already lol
Yes, because I have trained it also I mention in the beginning of the video( if you had paid attention) that your dog must be trained in order for this method to work.
my yorkie just bit the shi* out of me because I accidentally kicked him. instead of getting mad, I looked up "how to scold dog" on RUclips and found your video. I'm glad I found it. he doesn't know any tricks and he's not particularly motivated (he's a two pound terrorier). but yeah, glad i found you anyway
If I have a tiny older dog that hasn't ever really learned the basics (rescue), what should I do? Should I just make him go through some monotonous song and dance? like, put him off the bed, make him walk up the puppy stairs, put him off the bed, make him walk up the puppy stairs. maybe do it like, 4 times?
Always start training the basics (obedience) and then have some expectations.
I've approached him negatively and he just acts like I'm playing with him.
That is because you have not established a solid training with your dog. Play is fine and it is great to have a playful dog because it will be some much easier to teach and train it but also you need to have some formal training enabled in your dog so it can focus on the task and not the emotions in the moment.
The dog didn't do anyrhing at the moment so she can't pretend I have a 3 month old not fully trained now what???
I don't understand. Can you rephrase your question or the comment, please?
This would never work for Doug. Lol. I've tried it before. Never works. He only acts like you're playing with him. Lol.
Once you say, it won't work, you have lost the battle even before it has started. That is a clear sign that you are not in control of your dog and you don't trust your dog which is sad. Your dog does feel the same way as well so focus on improving your basic formal training and also improve the other parts and needs of your dog which I explain here: ruclips.net/video/7PLTj5zNSVw/видео.html
@@SaroDogTraining I tried it with an open mind, thank you. It doesn't work with him.
I understand. Try finding other solutions. Not all methods work for everyone and every dog. Good luck!
@@SaroDogTraining I will. He's definitely worth working with.
This is really unhelpful. The dog is already well trained.
Yes, it is. So, therefore I promote to train your dog. One thing also that you need to understand is that when punishing a dog like I show in the video, gives you an opportunity to train your dog at the same time.
I didn't see any punishment??
That is the idea. You don't need to punish a dog. You just train the dog.
@@SaroDogTraining so if the dog pisses allover your house just calmly put s leash on a do a few laps.... Positive reinforcement of what you don't want him doing
Try potty train it using this information. ruclips.net/video/oFQHPGBMPZc/видео.html
Is there ever a chance where you make a dog sit too much too soon that they stop listening?
Only if you don't have a system to teach and no structure.
that's a trained dog already, show us a random dog. a typical house dog that is a pain in head. how to discipline that kind?
You didn't understand the concept since you didn't pay attention to the video. In order for this method to work, your dog needs to have the basic or the basic obedience commands trained already. If you do, then you can use this method with any dog.
My dad only knows violence and has never trained a dog. His dogs won't even behave on a leash but he does not train him to even walk on a leash. He lets the dog take over everything and if it behaves he kicks the dog in the ribs or slaps it in the face. He trained his children like that too and now we are afraid of him.
Thank you for sharing this with us. It is a lot to unpack here but I hope you are finding ways to deal with your traumas and hopefully can help the dogs and your family. Feel free to share and speak out.
Why I feel like this is a punishment to me not to the dog!!
Don't look at it from negative point of view. Look at it as you are investing time and energy into your dog and spending quality time with your dog which will benefit you and your dog's relationship and life in future.
Youre only punishing yourself
Very funny!
Use a shock collar. God bless. :)
That is for sure a great tool for punishing a dog.
I can’t help myself from getting so angry and frustrated.. the new dog is causing my old dog to act out like never before, barking at strangers while walking.
And treat training is causing my old dog to gain weight, and I feel is the wrong way of rewarding negative behavior
I understand how challenging it can be when introducing a new dog to the family, and I'm here to help. It sounds like you have some concerns about your current training methods. If you'd like, I offer a free video call where we can discuss your situation in more detail and explore alternative training approaches. This way, we can work together to create a more harmonious environment for both your old and new dogs. Just set up a free video call here. link.overdogdigital.com/widget/bookings/dcws
My puppy sits when i say it but wont stay😒
Work on the stay command at home and not outside.
@@SaroDogTraining i am still working on it
Its easy for you cause your dog already trainig try on a dog that doestn know what sit is
If you watch the video, I mention that you need to have the basics trained to your dog. commands such as sit, stay and come.
I would like to disagree with u Sonia, for a simple reason Im lazy as hell with my dog but youtube videos and treats help get your dog to sit so a few minutes a day and treats your dog will listen to u too.
@@veronicaperumal8580 LOL. I agree
Does this apply if my puppy: barks at small children, chews on a book or chewing on my carpet 😂…. I just get so upset 😭
If it trained but if it is not, you need to teach it first. I show it how in this video: ruclips.net/video/-O-4jMI5g8Q/видео.html
All u did was show that your dog is well trained. Has nothing to do with the title.
I am sorry that you feel that way. It sounds like you don't have a well trained dog so your goal should be to start working on training your dog so you can use this method whenever you need to punish your dog.
My method has always been with attention. If the dog is misbehaving or behaving like an animal then it can live outside like an animal. Eventually the dog learns no human praise and no couch or cuddles sucks and you dont need to harm the dog get frustrated or hit or harm it did this with my current dog and now she barks to be let outside and barks to be let in. She also understands If she wants to howl, run, or anything her energetic wants desire she can ask to go outside and behave like an animal an come inside for affection comfort and cuddles
It’s beautiful how you can see that the dog loves him very much 🥰
That is probably applicable to the weakling dog. But to high prey drive, almost want to eat you as a whole protection dog. Punishment with a small physicality is a must. Maybe I am not a trainer. I applied a small amount of physicality with my jack russell. His bad habit of jumping people and biting their clothes. All gone. Never saw her to that again.
Whatever works for you. If you feel good about it and you don't harm your dog, do whatever it takes to solve the issue. I share another option just in case someone needs one.
Agreed. As I watch my mommas deal with puppy misbehavior, I see lots of physical correction. She isn't trying to cause pain, but is giving them feedback. And the behavior extinguishes because of that feedback. To omit correction is to fail to speak the "language" the dog understands to learn what is inappropriate.
This is a really great explanation with no fluff and opened my eyes as a dog owner. Question for you, what to do if during the punishment/mandatory training session, dog doesn’t feel like listening after a few commands? Thanks again for posting this
Good question! Train more until your dog learns.
I’d like to see this work on an energetic rebellious large Pit bull
The idea here is that if you have an energetic, rebellious, large Pitbull dog, you need to be more preventative and not allow a strong breed of dog to get to that level that you don't have control over. Most dog owners wait to deal with dog-related issues when the situation is out of control and is too late. Then they start looking for quick solutions to fix a problem that they have created and blame it on the dog's size or energy. In any case, I suggest you go back to the basics if you need help and start pretending that your big dog is an 8-month-old puppy and start building the basics. As mentioned in the video, this is ideal for dogs who have some basic training and are familiar with the basic obedience commands. Don't feel bad going back to basics. It is not a matter of pride. It is a matter of making the wrongs right as no one will know this other than you.
I do with my dog what I did with my son, put him to bed. This evening, I put my ten month old puppy into the kitchen and shut the door. He's knows he's been a naughty boy because he is silent and gone asleep. When he wakes up he will be better behaved like my son was when he was a child.
This worked well with me since first day . His behavior changed and listen to me . Also having a stiff leash changed the communication with him to 180* better . Thank u . I watched this video after first time hit my dog for not listening to me .
I am glad you don't need to use physical correction anymore. Thank you for watching and learning.
Spare the rod spoil the child. Humans and dogs are completely different. Not to mention my dogs wont listen to you if your soft spoken. They hear that and think playtime. My jack russell will literally look at you sneeze and continue on doing whatever unless you slightly raise your voice like your scolding a child.
It appears that you haven't established clear word associations with specific actions for your dog. With the right approach and a clear understanding of dog behavior, your dog can respond better to commands. By taking precise and consistent steps in training, you'll avoid common mistakes and achieve desired results. While dogs and humans are distinct, they share emotional commonalities, and it's essential to recognize that dogs have been selectively bred by humans for human companionship and cooperation.
Like the video, but the word Punish should be removed. Correction is a more acceptable term.
I agree but most dog owners use and are more familiar with punishment.
This is EXCELLENT method of “punishing” your dog. Very, very good. Thank you!!!
Thanks for watching! Please feel free to ask any question that you may have.
I used to be really calm and took the time to see things from my dog's perspective. But lately, I'm so stressed and I got a new puppy last august. He is sweet, crazy, and also has awful behavior. He pulls trash out all the time. As soon as the trashcan starts to fill up, he tips it over and pulls every single piece of trash out and strings it across the house, including his old poop. (He also is just absolutely not picking up potty training, no matter how patient I am. I've tried Kennel training, Treat training, potty pads, letting him out on a frequent schedule.. it just will not click for him). He also has successfully managed to remove the couch covers, pull out every one of the cushions and had the entire living room covered in cotton and foam. Sometimes I just lose it and start screaming at him. I feel so bad after I calm down and take a step back. I just wish I could see things through his eyes. And when I say he is sweet, he really is. He loves giving kisses, playing, and will even fight to crawl under the blanket with you when you're going to bed. My other dog is the complete opposite and I've never had to deal with this before. My other dog is 3 yrs old, is so calm and angelic even. He always lets me know when he needs to go potty, follows his commands, never tears anything up, waits for your permission to eat, etc. I don't know what to do, I still love him at the end of the day, I just don't know how to get him to understand.
I feel you and I'd love to help you out. Let's set up a free video call to see if I can help you and if you can benefit from me. I have the solutions and I am willing to offer you my services, if you like to be helped and coached. Simply set up a day and time that works for you and let's get started. sarodogtraining.com/perfect-dog/
I've got a dachshund puppy. He's already stubborn on the leash. He won't budge, but i don't wanna force him. He doesn't respond to treats as a motivativator
My dog punished me for leaving him with my mom for a week of travel.
Thank you for reaching out and sharing your experience. It's not uncommon for dogs to exhibit certain behaviors when their routines are disrupted or when they experience a change in their environment, such as being left with someone else for a period of time.
It's important to remember that dogs live in the present moment and may not fully understand the concept of time or the reasons behind our absences. Their reactions can be influenced by a range of factors, including their attachment to their owners, their individual personalities, and their overall comfort levels in different situations.
To help your dog adjust and minimize any negative reactions, it's essential to gradually introduce them to new experiences, such as being left with someone else, and provide them with plenty of positive reinforcement and reassurance. This can be done through gradual separations, leaving them with familiar and comforting items, and maintaining a consistent routine.
Additionally, when you return from your travels, it's important to provide your dog with extra love, attention, and reassurance to reinforce the bond between you. Engaging in activities that your dog enjoys, such as playtime or walks, can help rebuild trust and create positive associations.
I mean that would work if you don't have a brain dead dog
Great videos as always.
My 14month old border will run away when I try to put leash in her. She is afraid to go out on sidewalk to park. Fine at park but walking around neighbourhood her tail is always tucked in. And once off leash does not come! Its very trying
You need to work on building the foundation and that only happens by starting or improving the basic obedience commands at home so it can bring his confidence level up. Once you get 100% results, than you need to practice them at back yard, front yard and such before getting to the dog park. I will explain a bit more in my upcoming video.
Was the clip at 1:40 really necessary???
Yes, to make a point.
@@SaroDogTraining pretty extreme way to make a point don’t ya think?
You are welcome to think so. Is it triggering?
I have 4 dogs 2 is a cry baby 1 is the noisy and the annoying one 1 is the mature and the kind one but when the mature one saw a stranger or a cat he bark and my dogs always fight like they bite each other but not really cuz hey are siblings since they are 1 minute old they're names are Aki, Axie, Cassie And Axie Axie is the mature one and the only boy and yeah bye
i don’t understand, what was the punishment? all i saw was sit, stay, and then walking again. but my dog doesn’t know commands
As mentioned in the beginning of the video, your dog needs to know the basic commands of sit, stay and come. The punishment is that you use the info that your dog knows and reiterate it to make them to become better and learn that if they make a mistake, they need to rework the lessons.
I need something that actually works
Good luck finding something that works. Wish you all the best and success.
What if yr in the car or in bed innthe middle of night
I would train my dog in other situations that I am able to correct so that when I can't physically correct my dog, I would rely on my verbal corrections.
What about if they ae chewing on your shoes or just ate chocolate?
Those situations we call them "human error" and the human needs to be punished for making such mistakes.
Sometimes with big dogs u have to tell them stronger and bigger
Maybe! But it is not a fact and size does not matter in dogs. Attitude and confidence is what matters.
I really don’t get this approach with no negative feedback, how is the dog to know especially when it’s intentionally disobey. I hate all these videos that say make sure your dog knows the commands already. They do.!! and that dog’s tail is obviously wagging the entire time so it’s enjoying the training that it would seem it would be positive reinforcement. I think there’s some details missing here. Further, I can’t stand, watching another video about training out barking by rewarding non-barking. If that was the case, I’d be constantly feeding my dog treats for non-barking as most of the time they don’t bark.
Thank you for your feedback. Your feedback has given me an idea that I need to explain your question and the confusion which is a common one among dog owners with a video. Please stay tuned and i will respond to your question with a video. Coming soon!
Here is my video reply to your original question: ruclips.net/video/xbBJRKZHBIM/видео.htmlsi=7NtO0WhnuaB_nxUS
It won’t work
Why is that? what is the issue that you are having?
What about a dog peeing on the bed
This video will provide you the answer: ruclips.net/video/EwtzDH6VTTw/видео.html
This is fine in some circumstances, not all.
Thanks for sharing. My husband wants me to hit my dog with newspaper if she does something wrong. I don't want to do that. That will just make her worse. I don't agree with it. She barks constantly and chews the couch and pillows when she hears people outside and sometimes she bites me. She goes to the window and starts going crazy. Yesterday she was so good. We played for awhile throughout the day and after she just laid down and slept. She is 7 years old.
Thank you I have a problematic dog and a bad behave dog I will use this on her thank you❤
Thank you, it works!
You're welcome! I am so glad you think so.
Distracted Ruby away from chewing the carpet!
What does this have to do with unruly dog?
What was the reason you watched this video?
Thanks for the video. You got wisdom with your age. I'll try this too.
My dog is so love motivated that a stern voice is all she needs to stop doing what she is doing. Definetly lucked out with my evee
Use that and make her better.
I liked you before but I love you now!
I would say basically you're putting the dog on the leash and putting them to work doing basic commands and getting them to pay attention to you and respect you and respect your commands in a working format. It's kind of like what trainers would do with their Arabian horses if they do it if they train the horses correctly. They're very sensitive and intelligent so getting angry and hitting them is not the way to go about it. So I think there is a similar parallel between the Arabian horse and the Beagle.
I agree, there are similarities between dogs and horses.
I will admit I use to pop my puppy it started only when he would bite my face I only did it a couple of times and he learned it was a no no but idk why I guess I assumed it worked good with that so I tried it with biting in general and it does not work if anything it causes them to do it more because they’re being rough and so are you but this actually works for him it’s cute him like sighing because he knows I’m punishing him with tricks
Any video suggestions for a dog which is too friendly with strangers?
That has not been a major issue to make a video about it but in anyways, try providing some rules and boundaries for your dog so it learns to follow your cues and commands when needed.
My dog pulls the leash so hard and it’s so painful on my back and neck I have a spine injury and my hands sometimes lose the strength he just pulls so hard and I have to yank it back and I hate doing that
I feel you and I am sure this video will help you. ruclips.net/video/fScTjLykn-I/видео.html
I'd love to try this but when my dog is biting hard I can't get his lead on
Based on the clues that you have offered, the reason your dog bites and you can't put the lead on your dog is because you are not providing enough or ideal amount of exercise and mental stimulation. Watch this video to learn more. ruclips.net/video/7PLTj5zNSVw/видео.html