Ghost in the Shell Manga Editions Compared - Best Way to Collect?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 27 авг 2024
  • An in-depth look at all of The Ghost in the Shell manga editions released by Kodansha and how they compare!
    Favorite places to buy manga:
    Crunchyroll: geni.us/crunch...
    Amazon: geni.us/amazon...
    The above links are affiliate links, which really help support the channel at no extra cost to you.
    Website:
    animecollectiv...
    Email at:
    inquiries@animecollective.com

Комментарии • 79

  • @jude7286
    @jude7286 Месяц назад +29

    the notifications stay ON for Kristin!!!

  • @videosky_H.264
    @videosky_H.264 Месяц назад +6

    Wow, the timing of this video dropping is kinda crazy. I’d been considering collecting this series, but I had no idea Dark Horse had trade paperbacks. Definitely leaning towards the fully compiled edition after hearing you break down what each edition brings to the table. Thank you!

    • @sengan2475
      @sengan2475 Месяц назад

      Fully compiled has significantly worse paper quality than the individual deluxe editions, there some other videos on RUclips comparing them

  • @playinzegame
    @playinzegame Месяц назад +44

    Average Anime Collective W

  • @donjon8413
    @donjon8413 Месяц назад +10

    Always a joy when you guys post!

  • @atheistsince1210
    @atheistsince1210 Месяц назад +3

    I really appreciate you sticking with making these essential videos thanks to you I'm an addict of the Dark Horse Innocent series it just completely blew my mind the way the artist resurrected French civilization during the time of king Louis XVI. It's right up there as one of my favorites now thanks again !!!

  • @R.Williams
    @R.Williams 29 дней назад +1

    I just looked on Amazon for the compiled edition and its $31.08 right now. I love GITS but have only the DVDs. Thanks for this great review!

  • @koonfasa
    @koonfasa 22 дня назад

    Oh yeah, i need to get this! Thanks for reminding me. Forgot how much i loved this series.

  • @Ace_of_The_Reckoning
    @Ace_of_The_Reckoning Месяц назад +1

    Thank you so so much for this! I own the deluxe already and this was great to see the comparison for the other versions! love the channel!!

  • @user-if5yw3ol7j
    @user-if5yw3ol7j 16 часов назад

    I only started collecting manga because of your series lol love it !!

  • @AdamTheGallant
    @AdamTheGallant Месяц назад +7

    Need that updated collection tour😌

  • @powerrangerrick4675
    @powerrangerrick4675 Месяц назад +1

    I have the Dark Horse issues of Ghost in the Shell (Appleseed too) and was thinking about getting the compiled version. So thanks very much for your review

  • @lizardman6515
    @lizardman6515 Месяц назад +1

    Thank you!! I love your vids because I'm interested in knowing this stuff, but compiling this knowledge takes a lot of work! And most importantly, the vibes are immaculate!

  • @TheClockchan
    @TheClockchan Месяц назад +1

    I think the all in one is the one for me! Thank you for this awesome comparison !

  • @iiizeroiii1636
    @iiizeroiii1636 Месяц назад +1

    I have the fully complied edition and as a bed reader it's not that fun, it gets heavy over time, but yeah otherwise all good! the annotations are quite good as well

  • @andrewreichard6683
    @andrewreichard6683 7 дней назад

    This video was so helpful. Thank you so much!

  • @mvpheat
    @mvpheat Месяц назад +5

    I own the, The Ghost in the Shell Vol. 1 Kodansha Bilingual version.

    • @teevee23
      @teevee23 Месяц назад

      This is the best version

    • @legoguy217
      @legoguy217 Месяц назад +1

      Where Makoto explores her sexuality a bit 👀

  • @HoundNL
    @HoundNL Месяц назад +3

    Honestly, for the first time the "all-in-one" edition seems like the best one, the bleed through doesn't seems like a deal breaker and the overall quality seems on pair with the deluxe edition

  • @piplup12
    @piplup12 Месяц назад

    Thank you so much for this video! I missed the boat on the old dark horse editions and these kodansha versions have had me confused on the details of each.

  • @Kakaragi
    @Kakaragi Месяц назад +1

    There’s one drawback about the Kodansha printing, it’s censored

  • @francolarich
    @francolarich 13 дней назад

    Thank you!! Keep up the great work :)

  • @TheWisestWizards
    @TheWisestWizards Месяц назад

    I went with the Fully Compiled edition and I'm happy with it. I think it was under $30 too, which was a great price.

  • @nickmoss2046
    @nickmoss2046 Месяц назад

    Fully Compiled goes on sale for roughly $30 very often on Amazon too.

  • @hitachicordoba
    @hitachicordoba Месяц назад

    Cooincidence, I just picked up paperback vol 1 at Book Off in SoCal

  • @InfamyOrDeath-__-
    @InfamyOrDeath-__- Месяц назад +11

    The paperbacks being left to right is a dealbreaker, no way I’m getting those. I always hated that they did that for Blade of the Immortal.

  • @roman2nd
    @roman2nd Месяц назад

    i own the deluxe edition but the fully compiled edition is calling out to me. might have to buy it

  • @theactivewave6689
    @theactivewave6689 Месяц назад

    You should definitely make a video about collection jojos

  • @KillerTacos54
    @KillerTacos54 Месяц назад

    Another spectacular comparison video! Also your cat is so cute!!

  • @mh96s49
    @mh96s49 11 дней назад

    Hey Kristin can you do a video comparing human error processor & man machine interface paperbacks to the deluxe editions/fully compiled?

  • @mh96s49
    @mh96s49 Месяц назад

    Awesome comparisons! You have earned a new subscriber ❤ I have the single deluxe editions from the box set (minus the lithograph and the box) and the fully compiled and I read the fully compiled and it is awesome! I really enjoyed the story! The censorship doesn’t bother me either and I have been critized for saying that.

  • @rosetyler4801
    @rosetyler4801 Месяц назад

    Cool cat! He looks like my cat Mugan. I'm trying to decide between the deluxe editions and the complete all in one version. I hate the censorship because I don't agree with censorship but if it's all the versions I guess that's not a factor between the two. Thanks for the review.

  • @Jakco808
    @Jakco808 Месяц назад +1

    Masamune is a legend

  • @InfamyOrDeath-__-
    @InfamyOrDeath-__- Месяц назад

    Never read this but it’s definitely a series that I’d like, I’ll have to pick it up, probably go for the hardcovers.

  • @AMD-jw6vb
    @AMD-jw6vb Месяц назад +1

    Complete boxset (deluxe ed) is the way to go

    • @AMD-jw6vb
      @AMD-jw6vb 11 дней назад

      I’m so sad that the complete boxset is out of print and I was waiting for it😭

  • @ZKC137
    @ZKC137 Месяц назад

    I have the fully compiled edition and I love it 👌

  • @3IQ_D3MON
    @3IQ_D3MON Месяц назад +1

    Pls do That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Slime

  • @ceberuss_yt8266
    @ceberuss_yt8266 Месяц назад

    On the fence for the deluxe boxset or the fully compiled. For reading I’m thinking the fully compiled isn’t pratical to read unless when it’s resting on a table ?

  • @Xagzan
    @Xagzan Месяц назад

    Unfortunately I must've gotten an older edition of the original manga cause it's a left to right translation. Need to rectify that.

  • @brownmartez
    @brownmartez Месяц назад

    I watched this movie about a year ago and really enjoyed it. I might have to pick this one up

    • @kidrobot.
      @kidrobot. Месяц назад

      i only recommend the 1st one. the last two are not good

  • @jj112499
    @jj112499 Месяц назад

    I managed to find the last copy of volume 1 uncensored in bookoff, I found it hard to find a complete version during my visit to Japan.

  • @AngryStraightWhiteMale
    @AngryStraightWhiteMale Месяц назад

    Fully Compiled it is!!!!

  • @lizardman6515
    @lizardman6515 Месяц назад

    Tell Mikazuki we want more of him!! ❤️🐈

  • @AfroWars
    @AfroWars Месяц назад

    Nice detailed review, thx

  • @oscarcr1142
    @oscarcr1142 Месяц назад

    Honey, hurry, new Anime Collective vid just dropped... yes for real, it's Kristen the goat, and with a goat manga comparison of Ghoat in the Shell ❤

  • @diegoalbertocastillo6320
    @diegoalbertocastillo6320 Месяц назад

    Hi Kristin, I found your channel recently and I wanted to tell you something, especially because you buy manga in French too.
    A new Death Note box has recently been released that includes all the mangas,maybe you might be interested, I know you like to collect all the versions.
    And with respect to the colossal editions of Attack on Titan, the French editions are a little smaller since they only have 3 volumes per book,you might be interested in comparing the quality with respect to the American versions.

    • @nubiagaviria5774
      @nubiagaviria5774 Месяц назад

      En España está la versión integral, se podría decir que es 4 en 1 y la versión en Catalán es color verde, en lo personal me parece más bonito ese color

  • @Launchpad05
    @Launchpad05 Месяц назад

    That's A cute cat you have there.

  • @nursingguide3500
    @nursingguide3500 Месяц назад +1

    Do collection video

  • @stevetrevor2633
    @stevetrevor2633 Месяц назад

    A Off topic question.. how come all your manga on your shelf never looks aged at all ?🤔?...
    your
    Secret is ???

  • @josechavez1473
    @josechavez1473 Месяц назад

    Where did you buys your bookshelves from?!?!

  • @Chinmaynalawade3774
    @Chinmaynalawade3774 Месяц назад

    Hi,
    Anime collective
    Pl tell me whether mangas printed in italy,canada are considered to be original manga???
    Because I had bought volume 1 of Naruto printed in Canada.
    Pl reply me if possible

  • @ircey
    @ircey 17 дней назад

    you getting Vagabond Deluxe?

  • @janicemank9199
    @janicemank9199 Месяц назад

    Try to do ruroni Kenshin after this

  • @bottlesthemole9455
    @bottlesthemole9455 Месяц назад

    You should do Fairy Tail next

  • @akagi9475
    @akagi9475 Месяц назад

    I Love this channel 💙

  • @zdamha6890
    @zdamha6890 Месяц назад

    thats crazy just watched it last night lol.

  • @namanex8206
    @namanex8206 19 дней назад

    Can you pleases check out the alice in borderland manga

  • @caiohnr9694
    @caiohnr9694 Месяц назад

    thats manga is awesome, i love the story

  • @fakhrulislam6033
    @fakhrulislam6033 Месяц назад

    Me and the homies waiting for anime collective

  • @lil----lil
    @lil----lil Месяц назад

    I need a "real" colored E-ink reader! Maybe in FIVE years?

  • @makavelimusolini1036
    @makavelimusolini1036 Месяц назад

    At least tell us what it was that got censored or cut. Like, wtf happened?

    • @faynarawn4164
      @faynarawn4164 Месяц назад

      It's been a while but what I remember is: Motoko and her female friends get together, use mind-altering substances, and have a graphic intimate encounter in virtual reality, until they're interrupted by an urgent call from Batou. While some may find the scene gratuitous and unnecessary, it had some storytelling merit. Because Motoko has a top-of-the-line cyborg body (paid for by the government), she able to feel physical sensations that other cyborgs (with less expensive bodies) are unable to feel, so she records her physical sensations during these trysts and sells the recordings for those cyborgs to experience. So from the scene we learn that Motoko is open to same-sex encounters, has an entrepreneurial side-hustle, and about the challenges (and workarounds) of having a low-end cyborg body.

    • @makavelimusolini1036
      @makavelimusolini1036 Месяц назад

      @@faynarawn4164 Honestly, it's bs to cut something like that out. This isn't a kids comic ffs.
      Especially concerning all the dicks and gay shit shown in series like got and the boys, we cut something tame like this?

  • @simonb.8868
    @simonb.8868 Месяц назад

    The text of the first edition is too big for the size of the balloons

  • @ttalah2964
    @ttalah2964 Месяц назад

    Best manga channel 😊❤❤❤❤❤

  • @YoQ
    @YoQ Месяц назад

    i prefer my comics and manga to be compact and in all-in-one format, so i don't regret my trading of the box set for the compiled version.

  • @colby_oshawott
    @colby_oshawott Месяц назад

    Cute kitty!

  • @calidude4211
    @calidude4211 Месяц назад

    Nice. 👍

  • @arfanik9827
    @arfanik9827 Месяц назад

    Your little one is cute as hell!

  • @hanauzaki6264
    @hanauzaki6264 Месяц назад

    Finally

  • @joshfilips6102
    @joshfilips6102 Месяц назад

    w

  • @Alfonso-nx2yx
    @Alfonso-nx2yx Месяц назад

    Peak

  • @XocdanDMonke
    @XocdanDMonke Месяц назад

    First

  • @weabooavatar399
    @weabooavatar399 Месяц назад

    Didn't know it was a manga, what.