@@lollycopter Probably wanted owner to become a doctor or lawyer, or doctor of law or maybe medical lawyer but la they have to become a musician. Such disappointment for the whole pack.
Brilliant! For my dog, it's arpeggios. Played or sung, she demonstrates her vocal repertoire at fortissimo as soon as I start. Ignores scales or any other music.
As a trumpet player I can't help but acknowledge the fact that this guy's fundamentals are flawless! Happy to see the dog appreciates that aspect at least😁👍🏽
Yep it’s really cool. My dog comes to my bedroom door whenever I do my warm down routine on the trumpet because he knows I’m almost done. I like to jokingly say it’s his favorite song!
My dog definitely was able to recognize the trombone solo from Bolero. At first he would make this high pitched moan when I got to the highest notes. After a while, just playing the first note would set him off. It got to the point where even if I played it very softly down an octave he would recognize the tune and start to hum along.
Hunting here in Britain uses packs of beagles in which the hounds are controlled using a horn. This command resembles the one known as Doubling the Horn, which is used when the quarry is sighted.
I bet they picked that combination of notes for signaling the chase because that's what got the dogs most worked up. Like how all lullabies sound similar across different cultures.
@@pendlera2959 it's probably also because hunting horns don't have valves which would make them fragile, so as a result usually play the same note repeatedly, like with this opening
@@garry6485 yeah i like it too but i mean every trumpet player has to play and practice it so often (mainly for auditions) that it gets borderline annoying
This is so friggin' funny. I'm sitting here dying laughing showing it to my daughter and explaining the context. But dude . . . you have no idea what you've done. Now my wife is yelling at me because our cats are freaking out hearing your dogs howl !! We have a dog too . . . he could care less.
I took viola lessons for many years from this sweet lady who had a gorgeous black poodle named Winston that always dramatically howled at the top of his lungs when I played a piece in C Major (he was the sweetest and softest dog). My teacher explained to me that many animals (and people) have what is called a “trigger note”, which is a specific tone or noise that sets off many feelings or alarms in someone’s head. Everyone’s perception of sound is different, and some ears can tolerate some noises better than others. For example, some people can handle the THX sound better in D Natural than C# (like me). We associate tones in music to things in real life that correlate with the emotion getting across. The dogs in this video looked just as triggered as Winston would get.
I don't think it has to do with that note (or that specific frequency anyways, when he's playing the scales he lingers on that C# a few times and the dog doesn't react). I'd agree with a different comment which theorizes that the dog anticipates the end of the trumpet solo (which is loud and shrill) and reacts accordingly.
My dog that passed away last year was the same way with Eb regardless of the octave it was played in. He was Border Collie & Husky mix. Summertime starting on G as soon as I hit Eb the singing began. I now have a full blooded Husky and he doesn't seem to be bothered by any note so far. I kind of miss the duets.
😂😂😂 You were not sorry! You did it twice, and from their reaction, one can tell, you were playing even more of it previously. Your dogs are lovely, and they rule you just the way mine rules me. ❤️
When I got my first dog, Bix, as an adult professional trumpet player; I was insistent to train him NOT to howl when he heard the sound of a trumpet. Bix was pretty good about it EXCEPT when I played Schmyl & Goldenberg. That set him off howling in pain!
Don't worry, your dog doesn't hate it. Dogs aren't dumb like we usually think. If dogs don't like something, they'll stay away from it. My dog howls like this when I play the harmonica. His ears even perk up the moment I pick it up.
I had a roommate who had her 8 years old niece at home for a week end. I was listening to Mahler 5 in my room at a point. When I get out, she was there with big eyes saying: you are listening to scary music. Beside that, I had a cat who was very found of Britten's lacrimosa
Our dachshund despised the clarinet which my daughter played in the school band. He would make all sorts of hound howls. The poor kid would go out to the tool shed to practice!
Whenever I would play in a minor key or anything by Grieg on my viola, my Labrador mix would always huff, glare at me, and thump her head down in an obvious show of displeasure. If I continued practicing, she would huff, glare even harder, then leave. She was at least okay with major keys and Mozart, thankfully 😁
When I was a kid, we had a dog that would howl just like this, to certain pieces played at the piano. He'd run up to the piano, get right under it, and howl to his heart's content. He loved Prokofiev sonatas.
LOL That made my day. That dog doesn't want to hear a death march! Let's hear his reaction to the opening of the 5th. Maybe he'll look out the window??
I would shut myself in an upstairs room so my little dog wouldn’t have to hear me practice the flute, but he would scratch at the door to let him in & sit with me. He loved piano also. Miss him terribly…
@@blackfootindian8258 who spit in your drink dude ? might be yourself considering you're doing the round to be "that guy" on the internet. Why dont you make yourself happy instead of looking to make others miserable huh kid ? might work to fix ya.
This is so funny. I used to look after a Visla that would not care if I whistled. But if I whistled the theme tune for Antiques Roadshow, he would go absolutely beserk. These dogs are too intelligent for their own good!
Perfect. Perfect. Violinist sympathizing with BOTH of you. (The garage can be a very nice place to practice, if you just put in some lights and dress warmly.)
I had a little Jack Russell who would howl like that anytime I played the blues on my sax....I could play anything else an there would be no reaction, but a blues lick would get him going.....
All my dogs decided to howl along from home when I played some trumpet while teaching a band class from home virtually. My students got a kick out of it. I find that they howl less when I play some flugelhorn.
Ps every time you pet him in this situation, you're not consoling him, you're encouraging him. Petting to dogs is different than touch is to humans. He interprets that as a reward and equates that to 'this howling is a good thing.' Cute doggo and nice vid! 👍🏼
Not necessarily...touch is just as much a comforting tool to dogs and cats as it is to humans. Thats like saying talking to them is a reward; it depends on the dog, whatever else you're doing at the time (laughing tells the dog youre happy with them for instance) and the context. Puppies sleep on top of each other, momma dogs will lick their pups to calm them (and herself) down, thunder jackets are fitted to snugly hold your dog and decrease anxiety, etc. In this instance, if the dog felt encouraged, he wouldn't stop howling, he'd continue and get louder. My dog stopped growling at the mailman because I'd comfort him by talking to and petting him. He'll give a little startled woof now but hasnt growled in...years I think. If he felt rewarded, like I said, he wouldn't have stopped the behavior. Now it CAN be a reward, but you have to train them to see it that way and honestly...easier and less confusion to train them to respond to a clicker, if you're going that route.
Dude yes! My dog also does this but I'm on a piano though. My dog somehow loves scales, arpeggios and fast pieces. She kept singing over and over too following the melody, gosh dogs are the best. So cool!
One thing is for sure, if Leonard Bernstein was reincarnated into the body of a dog (at some point of the repeated life cycles), that one definitely isn't carrying Lenny's soul.
The dog has PTSD due to the amount of times this guy has practiced it.
Understandable. He clearly practises 40 hours a day so in dog hours, that would be 280 hours a day.
@@lollycopter Probably wanted owner to become a doctor or lawyer, or doctor of law or maybe medical lawyer but la they have to become a musician. Such disappointment for the whole pack.
Ha ha ha 🤣 you made my day
Lol
My thoughts exactly! 🤣
Brilliant! For my dog, it's arpeggios. Played or sung, she demonstrates her vocal repertoire at fortissimo as soon as I start. Ignores scales or any other music.
Atonal yodelling.
Fortismosso is a volume.
Whats her notes like.
Slurred, staccato, arpeggio,
Major, minor, blues, jazzy?
For mine it's harmonica, anything on harmonica and he'll go wild.
She's a master in her craft I assure you
When dogs howl together, it's a bonding social thing, not an expression of displeasure. Mahler 5 is the call of your pack! 😄
damn what an epic call for the pack
His look at 1:05 was like "dude ! We've talked about this !"
So true!
As a trumpet player I can't help but acknowledge the fact that this guy's fundamentals are flawless! Happy to see the dog appreciates that aspect at least😁👍🏽
@@nycan7725 even without that I don't think any casual would play mahler to play with their dog
except that he has the keys on the second and third pads of his fingers instead of the tips
@@Hello-wo4sx Probably because he's holding it in one hand while he holds his phone in the other.
@@roshanparikh5914 fair point, I didn’t think about that
@@Hello-wo4sx because that is ultimately what makes the difference between a musician and non musician
This goes to show that even animals can learn music with repetition. The dog knows what's coming (the high loud notes).
Yep it’s really cool. My dog comes to my bedroom door whenever I do my warm down routine on the trumpet because he knows I’m almost done. I like to jokingly say it’s his favorite song!
My dog definitely was able to recognize the trombone solo from Bolero. At first he would make this high pitched moan when I got to the highest notes. After a while, just playing the first note would set him off. It got to the point where even if I played it very softly down an octave he would recognize the tune and start to hum along.
Humans are animals and they learn music.
@@prs_81 The meaningful distinction here is between men and beasts.
@@seeker.8785 only as much meaning as you and we give it. :p
Hunting here in Britain uses packs of beagles in which the hounds are controlled using a horn. This command resembles the one known as Doubling the Horn, which is used when the quarry is sighted.
Ancestral dog knowledge? Bro
I was thinking along these lines as well
I bet they picked that combination of notes for signaling the chase because that's what got the dogs most worked up. Like how all lullabies sound similar across different cultures.
That's fascinating
@@pendlera2959 it's probably also because hunting horns don't have valves which would make them fragile, so as a result usually play the same note repeatedly, like with this opening
He is a purist, you should only play baroque and classical for him.
I like him!
Either that, or he's a Bruckner fan.
@@henrykwieniawski7233 hi Henryk :D
@@Isa-tn7ex Hey, Frederick!
Nah just classical, baroque is supposed to be the “misshapen” era lol
Nah, he just wants your triplets to be more "fluchtig".
wah. he's very sensitive. I wanna see his reaction to various classical pieces. good idea for a youtube channel
Sure
His reaction will be either nothing or screaming in pain.
@@illustriouschin which is PERFECT.
@@stefaneduard8169 Ayo? Are you one of those dog haters on reddit
Dont tell him what he has to do
Othe pupper came in like “please stop being dramatic”
"For f*** sake dude just play Haydn concerto for a change,"
Has said no trumpet player ever
@@maggoteater2290 it’s actually a pretty good concerto though, even though it’s one of the very few they have
@@maggoteater2290 i meant the dog
@@garry6485 yeah i like it too but i mean every trumpet player has to play and practice it so often (mainly for auditions) that it gets borderline annoying
@@corgansow7176 yes i know and i meant trumpet players
This is so friggin' funny. I'm sitting here dying laughing showing it to my daughter and explaining the context. But dude . . . you have no idea what you've done. Now my wife is yelling at me because our cats are freaking out hearing your dogs howl !! We have a dog too . . . he could care less.
amazing!! ahaha
I took viola lessons for many years from this sweet lady who had a gorgeous black poodle named Winston that always dramatically howled at the top of his lungs when I played a piece in C Major (he was the sweetest and softest dog).
My teacher explained to me that many animals (and people) have what is called a “trigger note”, which is a specific tone or noise that sets off many feelings or alarms in someone’s head. Everyone’s perception of sound is different, and some ears can tolerate some noises better than others. For example, some people can handle the THX sound better in D Natural than C# (like me). We associate tones in music to things in real life that correlate with the emotion getting across. The dogs in this video looked just as triggered as Winston would get.
My trigger is country music, I will immediately turn it off…
I don't think it has to do with that note (or that specific frequency anyways, when he's playing the scales he lingers on that C# a few times and the dog doesn't react). I'd agree with a different comment which theorizes that the dog anticipates the end of the trumpet solo (which is loud and shrill) and reacts accordingly.
Our lab also howls along to Mahler 5 when my husband practices it.
Doggy be like "Dude, why you pettin' me? I was just showing you how it's done!"
My dog that passed away last year was the same way with Eb regardless of the octave it was played in. He was Border Collie & Husky mix. Summertime starting on G as soon as I hit Eb the singing began. I now have a full blooded Husky and he doesn't seem to be bothered by any note so far. I kind of miss the duets.
You cant play mahler 5 with vibrato maybe thats what the dog was trying to tell you
😂😂😂 You were not sorry! You did it twice, and from their reaction, one can tell, you were playing even more of it previously.
Your dogs are lovely, and they rule you just the way mine rules me. ❤️
When I got my first dog, Bix, as an adult professional trumpet player; I was insistent to train him NOT to howl when he heard the sound of a trumpet. Bix was pretty good about it EXCEPT when I played Schmyl & Goldenberg. That set him off howling in pain!
That little snippet is also in Mahler’s 4th Symphony 1st movement if you listen for it.
The first time I heard it I was surprised
!!!!
Don't worry, your dog doesn't hate it. Dogs aren't dumb like we usually think. If dogs don't like something, they'll stay away from it.
My dog howls like this when I play the harmonica. His ears even perk up the moment I pick it up.
Remember that the movement this trumpet solo is from is a funeral march, and that explains the dog's reaction!
I had a roommate who had her 8 years old niece at home for a week end. I was listening to Mahler 5 in my room at a point. When I get out, she was there with big eyes saying: you are listening to scary music.
Beside that, I had a cat who was very found of Britten's lacrimosa
That's exactly the reaction Mahler wanted
This is the most hilarious thing I've seen for ages! The pah-pah-pah-paaaah was the first Mahler I ever heard, so I get how impressive it is :-)
If you hit the frequency of their howl, they'll howl.
Nice trumpet-playing! You've got skills! So does the pooch!
As a trumpet player and dog lover, this pleases me more than you can know.
So weird! My Newfoundland dog also has a really strong reaction to Mahler’s 5th, he doesn’t seem spooked, but his head starts tilting.
mahler 5 gets me all emotional every time too..
“cmon man just play something different and original, like the Petrushka solo or the Neapolitan Dance”
You must have played it very loud in the past and now he is afraid that you're going to blow out his ears again.
His sorrys doesn't even feel legit
@@snotsnarler1174 cry more.
I think in this piece, shortly after what he played here, there come very high notes, and the dog doesn't like those.
It made him want to howl but he knows he isn't supposed to be loud
My word, what are they like with Mahler’s 9th 4th movement?
I have to say, I laughed long and loud at this. 😂😂😂😂😂
Our dachshund despised the clarinet which my daughter played in the school band. He would make all sorts of hound howls. The poor kid would go out to the tool shed to practice!
He's a Bruckner fan
It kind of sounds like a hunting bugle call. Maybe those were developed to connect with something in the dogs
Even though these are the first notes of a funeral march I have not laughed so much in many days!
Whenever I would play in a minor key or anything by Grieg on my viola, my Labrador mix would always huff, glare at me, and thump her head down in an obvious show of displeasure. If I continued practicing, she would huff, glare even harder, then leave. She was at least okay with major keys and Mozart, thankfully 😁
When I was a kid, we had a dog that would howl just like this, to certain pieces played at the piano. He'd run up to the piano, get right under it, and howl to his heart's content. He loved Prokofiev sonatas.
The amount of fed up in that bark was crazy
that look at the end said it all. not to mention the other dog coming around to bitch him out. priceless!
Best video I had ever seen this year so far
I'm glad to see someone else knows what I'm talking about. F# on the soprano sax sets my dog off into a howling match with me for some reason.
That is hysterical! I don't understand, none of my dogs have ever expressed a dislike for Mahler.
LOL That made my day. That dog doesn't want to hear a death march! Let's hear his reaction to the opening of the 5th. Maybe he'll look out the window??
I would shut myself in an upstairs room so my little dog wouldn’t have to hear me practice the flute, but he would scratch at the door to let him in & sit with me. He loved piano also. Miss him terribly…
Who asked?
@@blackfootindian8258 Using dapz’s proof, we can deduce that I asked.
@@blackfootindian8258 who spit in your drink dude ? might be yourself considering you're doing the round to be "that guy" on the internet.
Why dont you make yourself happy instead of looking to make others miserable huh kid ? might work to fix ya.
@@blackfootindian8258 Your comment has far less valid solicitation in context than hers, sit down and learn some basic respect.
@@DonCYHauteNice oppinion. One small issue. I am inside your home.
That is so funny. Never seen anyone who dislikes Mahler that much before. (^:
I have. My voice teacher. I sent her this cuz her husband loves Mahler and they ‘fight’ about it
Vizslas recall that sound for hunting! Their soul remember the ancient times with Kaiser Franz Josef in Hungary!!! 😄
Introduction to Mahler's 5th accompanied by dog howls. Brilliant.
That's some nice trumpet playing right there.
Yo that’s wild that’s not even the first dog I’ve seen react this way to Mahler five
This is so funny. I used to look after a Visla that would not care if I whistled. But if I whistled the theme tune for Antiques Roadshow, he would go absolutely beserk. These dogs are too intelligent for their own good!
Perfect. Perfect. Violinist sympathizing with BOTH of you. (The garage can be a very nice place to practice, if you just put in some lights and dress warmly.)
Looks exactly like my first dog! Beautiful breed
My dogs literally freak out like this when I play too, I feel so guilty
That's so cute 😭 the way you kept saying sorry too 😂
Watching this... feels so good.
Great tone
I've never been so happy to be a band nerd 😅
Da da da da is a traditional hunting call. Your dog is ancestrally responding to it.
Classic, mine does the same when my kids play piano.
Omg, my dog is the exact same. Mahler 5 opening is her trigger that sets her off the same way.
I had a little Jack Russell who would howl like that anytime I played the blues on my sax....I could play anything else an there would be no reaction, but a blues lick would get him going.....
All my dogs decided to howl along from home when I played some trumpet while teaching a band class from home virtually. My students got a kick out of it. I find that they howl less when I play some flugelhorn.
This is the trumpet equivalent of 'cellist Beatrice Harrison and that bird
😂😂😂💖💖💖 in loop today!
Poor pupper is having flashbacks of "The Hunt"
Ps every time you pet him in this situation, you're not consoling him, you're encouraging him. Petting to dogs is different than touch is to humans. He interprets that as a reward and equates that to 'this howling is a good thing.' Cute doggo and nice vid! 👍🏼
@Dog Woof based
Howling isn’t a bad reaction though ❤️
@@stormcloudsabound haha no sir or mam
Not necessarily...touch is just as much a comforting tool to dogs and cats as it is to humans. Thats like saying talking to them is a reward; it depends on the dog, whatever else you're doing at the time (laughing tells the dog youre happy with them for instance) and the context. Puppies sleep on top of each other, momma dogs will lick their pups to calm them (and herself) down, thunder jackets are fitted to snugly hold your dog and decrease anxiety, etc. In this instance, if the dog felt encouraged, he wouldn't stop howling, he'd continue and get louder. My dog stopped growling at the mailman because I'd comfort him by talking to and petting him. He'll give a little startled woof now but hasnt growled in...years I think. If he felt rewarded, like I said, he wouldn't have stopped the behavior.
Now it CAN be a reward, but you have to train them to see it that way and honestly...easier and less confusion to train them to respond to a clicker, if you're going that route.
@Dog Woof it's not for you. Do you also say boring while you scroll past channels on tv? Am I scolding a child rn?
His DNA from his great great great great... grandpa during Roman wars triggered a serious PTSD moment.
Hilarious!! I fricking loved it!
Dude yes! My dog also does this but I'm on a piano though. My dog somehow loves scales, arpeggios and fast pieces. She kept singing over and over too following the melody, gosh dogs are the best. So cool!
The dramatic escalation at 00:40 😂😂😂😂
“Our pack leader is calling his pack. We must join in to say “we are here””.
My dog would always come sit next to me when I played my acoustic guitar. He loved it
So, now we know who the music critic of the Guardian really is!
My dogs do the same when I play ANYTHING on my bagpipes!
Damn, so dramatic🤣 I love it
makes him remember when he was wild, good times buddy
Haydn's Military, too, I suspect!
Growing up, my friends' sheepdog would howl like this to all kinds of different songs, but the most predictable one was from Shostakovich Polka.
I like the sound of your dogs very much, you play them very well!
People are saying to me, sir, this is the top RUclips video, the best. And I have to agree, tremendous video. One of the great video
They might prefer Mahler 10, the A-flat minor section at the 1st movement climax, with the chord from hell.
Cue Mr. White from Quantum of Solace... "I guess Mahler isn't for everyone."
That pup definitely looks the Dvorak type.
This is so fascinating, has he always responded this way?
You‘ve struck a chord with him!
Outstanding defence mechanisms
One thing is for sure, if Leonard Bernstein was reincarnated into the body of a dog (at some point of the repeated life cycles), that one definitely isn't carrying Lenny's soul.
Lenny's voice tho maybe? ;)
You are probably the most liked neighbor in your street
Everyone is a critic, including the dogs.
my same reaction to his 6th symphony (almost)!
That’s hilarious! My dogs only do that to sheep sounds.
Mine does this whenever I even open the case.
My Dads dog loves to howl when I play harmonica lol
The look that the doggo gave him at the end, like “why do you torture me, human?”
Love the collective bat shit insane response from every dog in four miles
That is funny as shit... I'm not a "cute dog video" guy. Made me crack up.
you should try w mahler 7 (opening of last mvt) on a c instrument