0:00 Intro 0:40 Important Points to Consider Before Proceeding 4:26 In This Segment 6:35 4 Keys to Understand the Story of 3īssā 8:43 Reminders From Prior Segments 27:43 Clear QurꜤānic Evidence Regarding 3īssā’s Return 33:38 Has Jesus Returned Already? Evidence 1 41:18 Has Jesus Returned Already? Evidence 2 43:07 Has Jesus Returned Already? Evidence 3 44:18 Has Jesus Returned Already? Evidence 4 49:43 Has Jesus Returned Already? Evidence 5 59:37 Has Jesus Returned Already? Evidence 6 1:09:45 Refuting Some Claims in Advance 1:14:56 What About Aya 43:61? وَإِنَّهُۥ لَعِلْمٌ لِّلسَّاعَةِ 1:24:29 What About the Hadeeths? 1:27:03 A Personal Declaration 1:32:18 What to do With this Information? 1:33:47 Outro
THIS NEEDS TO BE TURNED INTO A GREAT MOVIE!!!!!!! Since I have come across MQ I cannot stop watching. Ya Dr. Hany, tabarak Allah ya Akhi! May Allah swt bless u!
The meticulous methodology in matching two sentences verbatim from different passages of Qur'an to form a sound analysis, is profound! It's no coincidence that it resonates perfectly with the rationale of so many of us. The very reason why it doesn't "shock" me anymore but rather enjoy the many elated moments this podcast offers. Alhamdulillah. Alhamdulillah.
The most detail and precise interpretation carefully choreographed and ever mapped out by our scholars of the yesteryears. The sequence of the interpretation is quite marvelous and so is the forum- the marvelous Quran. Thanks Dr Hani. Your research work is very captivating and believe me unless we are deaf and dumb, nothing is hidden from the public scrutiny. This is undisputed scholarly work and urge those doubting your scholarly authority that theirs nothing academic in this work since the whole concept are self explanatory. Some scholars disputed your educational background on this subject as if those in the immediate interpretation going back three hundred years after our prophet Mohamed ( pbuh) and subsequent translators in the tenth and twelve centuries had a university degrees to authenticate their interpretation academically. May Allah guide Dr Hani in his scholarly work.
overwhelming knowledge, I can’t imagine how would all other big scholars would fight against this, other than “ he is the ultimate deceiver” and “ don’t even watch his videos it’s misleading” etc.
So Isa's first mother was Maryam, and then he came the second time as Muhammad through Amina as a mother... Zakaria as first father and Abdullah as second father. Now this is reincarnation. Now my question is, did Muhammad knew that he was the same as Isa??
You actually show how the Qur'an is a book authored by Allah Himself. Most Muslims say 'the Qur'an is so beautiful', but they don't even know why. This book is as if it's come from another dimension, even beyond the 4D realm of time.
It is a marvelous journey through the Marvelous Quran channel. Due to the misinterpretation in the translations of the Qura'n previously, the stories didn't seem to connect and now everything makes sense and connect very well. May Allah give Dr. Hani good health and complete the mission, and we all support you in this mission, with Allah's support and guidance.
Praise is due to Allahh, the Lord of all the realms. The truth feels so good in the core! I thank Allahh for giving me life to witness and experience this divine ilm! I am more appreciative and grateful for the Quran ever since I joined this channel. Dr. Hany, may Allahh reward you with the best of rewards!
Assalamualaikum Dr Hani. I watched this segment over and over for the past 1 week..emptying my cup as you highly recommended. Being a revert with no arabic background, I just relied on the existing translations. It certainly took me a while to put the pieces together. I must acknowledge you for all your efforts into this superb series. It has really blown my mind. I have since coming to Marvelous Quran stopped sharing trom any other tafsir. May Allah guide us to the Truth.
I have newly started reading the Qur'an, in translation of course, and I had also reached a very similar conclusion, seeing this video is very revealing and relieving 😌 thank you so much for your work
Hello dr Hany I want you to see this message, last week I watch your videos on RUclips about essa bun Mariam , that same night I got a dream I show Issa but he don't speak , he was just looking at me And someone told me in the dream that this is essa, I'm so grateful to find your channel it bring light in to my heart , Allah know I'm not lying It doesn't matter what other people's think about what you doing, Im witness for your good work , may Allah be with you .❤
Alhamdulillah, this is indeed an amazing battle. My honest advice: especially to those who still disagree with us and also those who consider themselves, counter attackers against us. Isn’t it time that who ever genuinely seeks for the truth without necessarily accepting it only if it comes from his/her respective afflicted group, to set back and pounder intensively for once? If we gonna be honest, the moment we accuse Dr Hany of wrong doctrine or misguiding the ummah, then it would definitely mean that, those early scholars are the chief deceivers. But Alhamdulillah, Dr Hany is far from that. Are we not observing how the verses are being interpreted. Did we really not see how previous scholars misinterpreted “3:144” and “5:75” If you haven’t, then go back and watch the video. So upon critical analysis, I conclude that who ever still argues, is doing so because of his/her attachments. And such people are certainly defending the erroneous interpretations of certain scholars that perhaps they dim as holy or so unique. I don’t understand why people cannot differentiate between simple things. The Quran says: (الرسل) one person translates it as “other messengers”, other person says it’s “the messengers” and we know it’s the second one. But because of attachments you fail to see what is right, it means you have a big problem. Put it to thoughts. MAY ALLAH SAFEGUARD US ALL 🙏🙏🙏
Allah works in mysterious ways.. this is one of them. The timing of this reveal is incredible. It appears there was an agenda or strong pre conceived notions before they translated these texts.
Salaamun alaykum, ALHAMDULILAH, took me three days to understand an 1 &1/2 hour session but it was worth it .. Great work sir.. MAY ALLAHH REWARD YOU MULTIPLE MULTIPLES...
Salamun Alaikum to all seekers of the guidance, this series is very difficult and advanced for the majority including me. I recommend with humility to watch this series multiple times.
Dr. Hany! I send my heartful wishes to you. I and I can guess that all the members are eagerly and impatiently waiting for the next lecture. I wish everything is well with you. Best regards
Salaamun Alaikum Thank you Brother Hany for highlighting these verses from the Quran, for many you continue to make us ponder and this is where we start to engage more and toil with the Quranic scripture in search for true guidance. PS beautifully stated that you are merely a wayfarer on the path of self correction. Many do not understand this analogy and becos it's different to what they've been taught they deny the signs of evidence based knowledge primarily extracted, from the Quran. This causes an existential crisis indeed, for some. Your request is only for others to come up with a counter example based on a Quranic methodology. Stunning! Alhamdulilah
Salamun Alaikum, We were thinking about the identity of the Angels, and listening to this segment for the nth time just gave me an answer when (4:173) describes the angels who are the muqarraboon, so there I think is the definition of Angels. Congratulations to everyone who is listening to the channel and the story of 3isa.
This is hard knowledge and I started understanding more about why Quran interpretation was corrupted. I have to go through several times before I can fully comprehend.
Alhamdullilah. Agree. It also makes so much sense too. I’ve read from David Ewing Jr saying Muhammad was Iessa who spread islam around Europe - but he didn’t give detailed explanation like this video. I wish I knew how to dig into the Arabic like this.
Alhamdulillah 💖💯❤💞 sniff i listen vue about 5time to make sure i really understood the segment. May Almighty Allah Taallah keep guide and give you more Nour Dr. Hany! to light ummah of Mohammad S.A.W. the truth tafsir of Quran.
I have the following observations and questions. I’m neither being critical nor trying to rebut, but only trying to understand and make sense out of your very complex lecture. I hope you’ll respond to clarify me confusion. Evidence 1: It could be argued that (مَّا الْمَسِيحُ ابْنُ مَرْيَمَ إِلَّا رَسُولٌ قَدْ خَلَتْ مِن قَبْلِهِ الرُّسُلُ) means (Al Massih son of Maryam is not but a messenger, just like all the messengers that have passed before him). This does not really make Al Massih son of Maryam (AS) the last messenger, as in this ayah the Quran refers to all the messengers that came before him and not the one who will come after him, i.e. Muhammad (ASWS). So it doesn’t seem like a strong evidence that Muhammad is Ԑissa in his second life. Evidence 2: Hasn’t Allah (SWT) endorsed and supported all messengers and prophets with the divine emissary of the holy, even if not mentioned in all cases, except two? Why is it not possible that both 3issa and Muhammad (peace and blessing of Allah be upon them both) were endorsed and supported by Ruh Al Qudus? Evidence 4: This is confusing. On one hand you seem to be saying that ayah 4:172 implies that “as at the time of the revelation of Quran, Al Massih has not yet returned to be a wayfarer and servant to Allah (SWT). It doesn’t mean that it is far in the future…” (time stamp 45:43). On the other hand, you claim that Muhammad (ASWS) is Al Massih in his second life. So, are you saying that Muhammad (ASWS) was not initially Al Massih (at the time of revelation of ayah 4:172) but later became Al Massih? This is mind-boggling and incredible… two in one and one in two - mythological duality, as compared with mythological trinity - three in one and one in three. Evidence 6: You say that ayah 5:110 starts with addressing 3issa son of Maryam and ends with addressing Muhammad (peace and blessing of Allah be upon them both) and placed in a future time of gathering of all the messengers and prophets. How did you deduce from Quran that it is indeed a discussion from future when Allah (SWT) will gather all the messengers and prophets (peace and blessing of Allah be upon all of them)? All the evidence you have provided seem to be circumstantial, based on the so-called markings and similarities between our beloved prophet Muhammad and 3issa son of Maryam (peace and blessing of Allah be upon all of them). You have used the same method to claim that Ism3eel (AS) is none other than our beloved prophet Muhammad (ASWS) and Luqman is Zakariah (AS). Why can’t there be similarities among different messengers and prophets? Why can't Allah (SW) use the same wordings to express similar narratives in His Marvelous Quran? Why similarities between Muhammad, 3issa and Ismeel make them one and the same person? Isn’t it possible that your understanding is erroneous, and you might be getting carried away with your methodology? What about Yahya (AS) who, according to your explanation, is the same person who died and then was revived after 100 years; probably after the Romans destroyed Jerusalem. Is there any account of his second life? It's interesting to see that both the "brothers", Yahya and 3issa (AS), had two lives and lived during two different times. Some may argue that you are trying to turn our beautiful and pragmatic Deen Al-Islam into a mythology with this story of Yahya and 3issah (AS). May Allah guide us all to Sirat Al-Mustaqeem and to the Truth.
@ BenAdam Thank you for taking the time to write... First of all, remember that the Quran told us, in no uncertain terms, THAT ALL THOSE WHO DISAGREED ABOUT HIM (I.E., ANY OPINION IN EXITSENCE BEFORE THE QURAN, OR BASED ON CHRISTIAN SOURCES) ARE WRONG! You whole argument is based on questioning the grammatical indications of Evidence 1 (we have already addressed this in the video in full details, including the dilemma of those who reject our explanation), and on refuting the concept of markings for Evidence 2 (and we have already explained that there are no coincidences in the Quran). Re. Evidence 4, there is no confusion... The expression لن يستنكف is referring to the time of revelation of this specific aya. THIS IS EXACTLY WHAT I SAID, but you have turned it into "at the time of the revelation of the Quran"... Therefore, when you say "you seem to be saying", it is your misunderstanding that is confusing you... Re. Evidence 6: I explained that aya 109 before it clearly states يوم يجمع الله الرسل... What is your explanation for this context, if not at a time in the afterlife? Moreover, requiring historical verification for something mentioned in the Quran (or any text for that matter) is a lame refutation, and you know that! By this same logic, we cannot establish that there was a man named Muhammad, or 3issa, or Mussa, or Ibrahim! You accusation of "turning our beautiful Deen into fables" is indicative that you have not paid attention to all the segments on this channel, where I constantly state that we are referring to the Quran and rejecting unsupported claims, myths, fables, folklores, etc... And therefore, this accusation is bogus and unsubstantiated... My advice: Please reconsider the evidence, without biases, and without taking a predetermined defensive stance about your pre-conceived notions, and you will engage the evidence more objectively. Finally: As I stated in the declaration, I don't claim to understand everything about this issue, just like we (all Muslims) don't understand so many things that the Quran (our beautiful Deen) teaches us of Ghayb (such as angels, nafs, 3arsh, daze, God himself, etc)!. We are required to believe in explicitly specified Ghayb, that's all! Regards
Incredible and so powerful evidences. It is difficult to imagine but such evidences and Quran don't lie. Thank you Dr Hany for sharing with us your knowledge
Thanks very much Dr Very powerful segment indeed _ I'm no longer shocked with this informations bcoz to be honest with you I'm ready to learn directly from the Qur'aan as u always insist Very educative segment
Just finished watching again for the nth time. Just like the series on iblis and shaitan, this series on Isa is liberating. It unshackles us from distractions created by people who are obsessed by the end-times. For example, now we do not have to worry whether the recent build-up of vladimir's troops near another country is related to the army of khurassan who are getting ready to welcome the messiah who will come down from a minaret in syria...etc etc
I am blown away by the revelations in this segment, but I am anxiously awaiting those sections that you mentioned are yet to be disclosed. And once I thought why I was born so many years after the revelation of the text of the Quran, but now I feel so blessed that I was born at the time when the meanings of this great Book are being revealed. Alhamdulillah. I can't be thankful enough.
I always could not feel the pain,, pressure of our belovoed SAW until today. Until having come across this video. Now I have learned something, but I cannot share it: First I cannot speak or read Arabic. This does not support my authenticity if I would do so. Secondly, I feel the urge to share with, at least with my family. But I know that they would not understand it. And furthermore, I know this Information would crush their hope that they hold as I did on the subject of fhe returning of Isa! Now I really have a FEELING of how Rasulallah must have been felt...I admit it is a small feeling compared to our beloved, but it's on my mind and keeps me busy...
Masha Allah Dr. Hany, I think anyone with clear understanding and knowledge will know u are not teying to present urself as a messenger or prophet, but clearly as someone who seeks the truth in Al quran alhamdullilah
Thank you Dr Hany for this segment. I accepted this segment more rapidly because whenever I read 3:55, I knew this : وَجَاعِلُ الَّذِينَ اتَّبَعُوكَ فَوْقَ الَّذِينَ كَفَرُواْ إِلَى يَوْمِ الْقِيَامَةِ
Salamun alaikum appreciate your hard work it takes much time to understand the information you present, and i am thinking that how much time you spend for this presentation, may allah reward you in multipules
Salaamun alaykum, How are you Dr. Hany and subscribers of MQ Thanks 🙏 for the lecture I watched The previous one five times as it had a lot of information and it really worked on me.
Alhamdulilah it was not shocking to me especially after knowing zulqarnains lineage, and after the segment of who Issas عيسى pbuh father. But so much emotions and thoughts was rushing through my mind and heart as i watched it. There is a great deal of our youth who are into eschatology and I invested time and energy and money in it before. May forgive my transgressions and between this and the refusing to even listen to us when we show the truth from the quran and the overwhelming feelings and loyalty as a result of being blackmailed by the imams when they ask questions and telling you becoming out of circle of Islam for even thinking, our families and our youth are in reall hot water. This segment was something else for me. So many questions and thoughts and need to do more taqwa and discipline. ربي اني بما أنزلت الي من خير فقير. Alhamdulilah Alhamdulilah Alhamdulilah that I lived to know the truth of the Quran and may Allah return our loved ones and the Muslims to this truth. May Allah bless you Dr Hany tremendously.
I never shocked in any segment, thank you Dr Hany, what have you done in marvelous Quran is confirmation of what I have suspected. What I suspected before is just a hunch, you give me an evidence from Quran. Undeniable of course. Thank you.
حللت اهلا وطئت سهلا مرحبا ب الصراط المستقيم، مرحبا ب القران الكريم. Welcome Welcome to the straight path, welcome to the marvellous quran. Alhamdulilah Alhamdulilah Alhamdulilah for this guidance.
Subhana Allah to the number of His creation. I am utterly flabbergasted. I am not Arab and I don't understand a lot of the grammar of Arabic. But one thing that I was taught when I was studying it was that "Al" mean All or The , meaning all inclusive. So to me it means every last one of them leaving out none of them, have passed away before Prophet Muhammad. Actually you could have came on with this lecture and just literally posted this Ayah 3:144 and no one whether they can read Arabic or not would ever be able to deny it. This is what you called the indisputable truth, Hidden in plain sight. All I have to say now is certainly when Allah wants you to know a thing undoubtedly you will know. ! May Allah reward you, thank you so much. This means a lot to me especially since I am a convert from Christianity to Al Islam. I really feel the love of Allah today. I think Allah for allowing me to be acquainted with you and your work. Thank you for your diligence and uncovering in an earth-shattering revelation, that was hidden in plain sight.
Minute of 40:50 is one of evidences in surah 16 verse 26 : مَكَرَ الَّذِيۡنَ مِنۡ قَبۡلِهِمۡ فَاَتَى اللّٰهُ بُنۡيَانَهُمۡ مِّنَ الۡقَوَاعِدِ فَخَرَّ عَلَيۡهِمُ السَّقۡفُ مِنۡ فَوۡقِهِمۡ وَاَتٰٮهُمُ الۡعَذَابُ مِنۡ حَيۡثُ لَا يَشۡعُرُوۡنَ .. Allah struck at 'very' foundation of their building, and it's collapse completely...from where they did not expect ! Dr Hany, Masha Allah, What a Miracle of Methodology ! Salamu'alaykum !
Masya Allahh. What a disclosure this is. All the messengers had passed away before him.(meaning he is the last one standing ) Lest if one is not careful enough, one would read and mistook it to be ‘all the messengers before him had passed away (meaning there will be messengers coming after his time). Thank you dr hany toiling on these ayat 3:144 & 5:75 . May Allahh bless you always.Alhamdulillah.
Doesn’t this mean that revealing this truth is actually the second return of Issa? I mean he doesn’t have to come back as flesh and blood or only as Al Rasool Mohammad, but he is coming back as an idea or a thought or a re-exposed truth, as you have just did with this segment?
This segment is too heavy for my core to accept it- I3saa and Muhammad is the same. But for now I will just swallow the tons of question I have and reserve it till I watch the next segment. I will patiently wait inshallah.
Thank you Dr. Hany. But it's not a surprise to me. It just strengthen my belief. Bocz there is a lot of Quranic and historical evidences that showed that "Mohamed" of the hadiths followers does not exist, as their stories about him do not match the Quran. Now we're learning from you that the true Mohamed was the second coming of Jesus, which makes sens to me. The name Mohamed might be a description but not a proper person name. This is bcoz ALLAH never addressed to the messenger directly by the name Mohamed in the Quran like "Ya Musa! Ya Issa!. All the 4 verses about the name Mohamed descript Mohamed but not talking to him. - What do you think? - How you relate your claim to this verse 7:157 (gentile prophet)? and 93:7 I think that this video disproved those who claimed that the Quran is addressing Jesus but not in the second coming. THANK YOU DR.HANY MAY ALLAH BLESS YOU.
Salamualiku Dr Hay, I am trying to toil by my own for this verse of the Quran and give it meaning 22:79 and I want your verification so that i make sure that for the first time that I am on track; وما جعل عليكم في الدين من حرج ملة أبيكم إبراهيم هو سماكم المسلمين من قبل ٢٢:٧٨ There's no difficulty on you in understanding the Quran (if you follow) the compositional style of Ibrahim's, your spiritual father who named you as Muslim before when you were not called Muslim 22:78. Thank you Dr. Hany.
Salamon alaycom DR.Hanymillions of thanks for this knowledge,,no one reveal it unless guided by Allah U pray that God Allah prolong our life,,i am purely satisfied
Tayab you're suggesting Eesa is one of the many pseudonyms of Muhammad SAW. When you mentioned the verses about how bani Israel accused Eesa about not being able to know about their speech, this could be in reference to the Jews that had settled in Madina for a long time, and they would have all known each other and kept their knowledge between themselves. So when they marvelled at how the Prophet could know about them, its based on the evidence that they had never seen him among them before and so how could he know? This also verifies the whole lineage issue as they thought the final prophet would be from them and not from Quraysh. So do you think Ibn Maryam died and will not be returning, nor will there be a Mehdi or anything like that?
@Marvelous Quran, What you say makes sense a lot... is this the reason why Allahh told Mohammad in several ayats to remember in the story of Maryam or Story of Musa or remember when Musa did so and so? Instead of asking him to learn but to remember!
in part 3, i naively asked the possibility the name to be 'also Muhammad' (which i was mocked by someone for that). now here you are, giving some shocking information that far deeper and heavier than my shallow naivety. this information, that you show us, might cause some accusation of heresy (by some close minded people or fanatics)
I always thought that “your community” in 43:59 and 43:60 are the Qureysh because they said “are our deities better or he?” meaning the speakers were not monotheists. The Jews of Medina were monotheists. Secondly, if "your community" is Jewish, are we confirming that our beloved s.a.w. is of Jewish lineage?
Salamualaikum dear Dr Hany. With fully empty cup, the revelation is indeed its natural sequential course. Alhamdulillah... I thank you again and again for all these substantive works in progress. My continuous prayer for all to be on the righteous path, bi izz nillah. As salam n stay healthy n safe insya Allah
As-salaamu alaykum Janaab, I really wish I could learn Arabic and reading he Qur'an personally from you 😊🤗 I absolutely love your understanding ❤ .. it breaks my heart to think how impossible that is to learn personally from you 💔 .. I will try to follow the videos watching them again and again, hopefully I will understand properly by myself 😊
I want to pray like the Quran says and no one else. How can I do that. Allah speaks about 3 prayers which makes total sense to me because it's very doable and I believe that most Muslims don't pray is because of rhe 5 consecutive players. On the busiest time of the day, Muslims have to do 3 prayers that have more than 2 rakes. Allah said he wants to make our religion easy for us. How's that easy
Even though I know just a little about arabic. But the evidences is real, if you choose to use your mind well. The knowledge presented in this channel is the most make sense and complete (limited to my search) And if Dr Hany said all of us doesn't understand it. (it's limited to the us which Dr Hany know) Make sure you don't fall to errors of your mind. If you truly seeking the truth. Because if you want to stay being connected to Allah you want to make sure you're in the right direction.
Muhammad (ppuh) is the return of Christ (AS). The Qur'an is his return. There is nothing that Christ was promised to fulfill that Muhammad did not fulfill. It is him 100%
0:00 Intro
0:40 Important Points to Consider Before Proceeding
4:26 In This Segment
6:35 4 Keys to Understand the Story of 3īssā
8:43 Reminders From Prior Segments
27:43 Clear QurꜤānic Evidence Regarding 3īssā’s Return
33:38 Has Jesus Returned Already? Evidence 1
41:18 Has Jesus Returned Already? Evidence 2
43:07 Has Jesus Returned Already? Evidence 3
44:18 Has Jesus Returned Already? Evidence 4
49:43 Has Jesus Returned Already? Evidence 5
59:37 Has Jesus Returned Already? Evidence 6
1:09:45 Refuting Some Claims in Advance
1:14:56 What About Aya 43:61? وَإِنَّهُۥ لَعِلْمٌ لِّلسَّاعَةِ
1:24:29 What About the Hadeeths?
1:27:03 A Personal Declaration
1:32:18 What to do With this Information?
1:33:47 Outro
Thank you very much. May Allahh reward you multiple multiples.
Uploaded
This is the only thing in my life that is worth living for! Alhumdulillah that i found this channel!
Alhamdulillah...
THIS NEEDS TO BE TURNED INTO A GREAT MOVIE!!!!!!! Since I have come across MQ I cannot stop watching. Ya Dr. Hany, tabarak Allah ya Akhi! May Allah swt bless u!
The meticulous methodology in matching two sentences verbatim from different passages of Qur'an to form a sound analysis, is profound! It's no coincidence that it resonates perfectly with the rationale of so many of us. The very reason why it doesn't "shock" me anymore but rather enjoy the many elated moments this podcast offers. Alhamdulillah.
Alhamdulillah.
The most detail and precise interpretation carefully choreographed and ever mapped out by our scholars of the yesteryears. The sequence of the interpretation is quite marvelous and so is the forum- the marvelous Quran.
Thanks Dr Hani. Your research work is very captivating and believe me unless we are deaf and dumb, nothing is hidden from the public scrutiny. This is undisputed scholarly work and urge those doubting your scholarly authority that theirs nothing academic in this work since the whole concept are self explanatory.
Some scholars disputed your educational background on this subject as if those in the immediate interpretation going back three hundred years after our prophet Mohamed ( pbuh) and subsequent translators in the tenth and twelve centuries had a university degrees to authenticate their interpretation academically.
May Allah guide Dr Hani in his scholarly work.
overwhelming knowledge, I can’t imagine how would all other big scholars would fight against this, other than “ he is the ultimate deceiver” and “ don’t even watch his videos it’s misleading” etc.
So Isa's first mother was Maryam, and then he came the second time as Muhammad through Amina as a mother...
Zakaria as first father and Abdullah as second father.
Now this is reincarnation.
Now my question is, did Muhammad knew that he was the same as Isa??
You actually show how the Qur'an is a book authored by Allah Himself. Most Muslims say 'the Qur'an is so beautiful', but they don't even know why. This book is as if it's come from another dimension, even beyond the 4D realm of time.
What a time to be alive, and to hear this kind of truth and infos. Wow, thank you Dr! We needed you!
It is a marvelous journey through the Marvelous Quran channel. Due to the misinterpretation in the translations of the Qura'n previously, the stories didn't seem to connect and now everything makes sense and connect very well. May Allah give Dr. Hani good health and complete the mission, and we all support you in this mission, with Allah's support and guidance.
Praise is due to Allahh, the Lord of all the realms. The truth feels so good in the core! I thank Allahh for giving me life to witness and experience this divine ilm! I am more appreciative and grateful for the Quran ever since I joined this channel. Dr. Hany, may Allahh reward you with the best of rewards!
Clearly explained without doubts and the embellishments of poetic words, using reasoning and logic. No mythology or folklore. Maasha Allah.
Assalamualaikum Dr Hani. I watched this segment over and over for the past 1 week..emptying my cup as you highly recommended. Being a revert with no arabic background, I just relied on the existing translations. It certainly took me a while to put the pieces together. I must acknowledge you for all your efforts into this superb series. It has really blown my mind. I have since coming to Marvelous Quran stopped sharing trom any other tafsir. May Allah guide us to the Truth.
I have newly started reading the Qur'an, in translation of course, and I had also reached a very similar conclusion, seeing this video is very revealing and relieving 😌 thank you so much for your work
Alhamdulillah
@@MarvelousQuran 🤍🤲🏾
Hello dr Hany I want you to see this message, last week I watch your videos on RUclips about essa bun Mariam , that same night I got a dream I show Issa but he don't speak , he was just looking at me
And someone told me in the dream that this is essa, I'm so grateful to find your channel it bring light in to my heart , Allah know I'm not lying
It doesn't matter what other people's think about what you doing, Im witness for your good work , may Allah be with you .❤
Alhamdulillah, this is indeed an amazing battle.
My honest advice: especially to those who still disagree with us and also those who consider themselves, counter attackers against us.
Isn’t it time that who ever genuinely seeks for the truth without necessarily accepting it only if it comes from his/her respective afflicted group, to set back and pounder intensively for once?
If we gonna be honest, the moment we accuse Dr Hany of wrong doctrine or misguiding the ummah, then it would definitely mean that, those early scholars are the chief deceivers. But Alhamdulillah, Dr Hany is far from that.
Are we not observing how the verses are being interpreted. Did we really not see how previous scholars misinterpreted “3:144” and “5:75”
If you haven’t, then go back and watch the video.
So upon critical analysis, I conclude that who ever still argues, is doing so because of his/her attachments. And such people are certainly defending the erroneous interpretations of certain scholars that perhaps they dim as holy or so unique. I don’t understand why people cannot differentiate between simple things.
The Quran says: (الرسل) one person translates it as “other messengers”, other person says it’s “the messengers” and we know it’s the second one. But because of attachments you fail to see what is right, it means you have a big problem.
Put it to thoughts.
MAY ALLAH SAFEGUARD US ALL 🙏🙏🙏
Allah works in mysterious ways.. this is one of them. The timing of this reveal is incredible.
It appears there was an agenda or strong pre conceived notions before they translated these texts.
Salaamun alaykum, ALHAMDULILAH, took me three days to understand an 1 &1/2 hour session but it was worth it ..
Great work sir.. MAY ALLAHH REWARD YOU MULTIPLE MULTIPLES...
Salamun Alaikum to all seekers of the guidance, this series is very difficult and advanced for the majority including me. I recommend with humility to watch this series multiple times.
Dr. Hany! I send my heartful wishes to you. I and I can guess that all the members are eagerly and impatiently waiting for the next lecture. I wish everything is well with you. Best regards
Salaamun Alaikum
Thank you Brother Hany for highlighting these verses from the Quran, for many you continue to make us ponder and this is where we start to engage more and toil with the Quranic scripture in search for true guidance. PS beautifully stated that you are merely a wayfarer on the path of self correction. Many do not understand this analogy and becos it's different to what they've been taught they deny the signs of evidence based knowledge primarily extracted, from the Quran. This causes an existential crisis indeed, for some. Your request is only for others to come up with a counter example based on a Quranic methodology. Stunning!
Alhamdulilah
Salamun Alaikum,
We were thinking about the identity of the Angels, and listening to this segment for the nth time just gave me an answer when (4:173) describes the angels who are the muqarraboon, so there I think is the definition of Angels. Congratulations to everyone who is listening to the channel and the story of 3isa.
I’m relearning this makes sense because the Hadiths states were waiting on so-called Jesus
This is hard knowledge and I started understanding more about why Quran interpretation was corrupted. I have to go through several times before I can fully comprehend.
Subhanallah.. I'm in tears as I've had thoughts long before watching this that Iessa has come back as our beloved I'm in tears subhanallah
Alhamdullilah. Agree. It also makes so much sense too. I’ve read from David Ewing Jr saying Muhammad was Iessa who spread islam around Europe - but he didn’t give detailed explanation like this video. I wish I knew how to dig into the Arabic like this.
Alhamdulillah 💖💯❤💞 sniff i listen vue about 5time to make sure i really understood the segment. May Almighty Allah Taallah keep guide and give you more Nour Dr. Hany! to light ummah of Mohammad S.A.W. the truth tafsir of Quran.
The happiness to see the notification that a new video is uploaded ♥️♥️♥️.
I have the following observations and questions. I’m neither being critical nor trying to rebut, but only trying to understand and make sense out of your very complex lecture. I hope you’ll respond to clarify me confusion.
Evidence 1: It could be argued that (مَّا الْمَسِيحُ ابْنُ مَرْيَمَ إِلَّا رَسُولٌ قَدْ خَلَتْ مِن قَبْلِهِ الرُّسُلُ) means (Al Massih son of Maryam is not but a messenger, just like all the messengers that have passed before him). This does not really make Al Massih son of Maryam (AS) the last messenger, as in this ayah the Quran refers to all the messengers that came before him and not the one who will come after him, i.e. Muhammad (ASWS). So it doesn’t seem like a strong evidence that Muhammad is Ԑissa in his second life.
Evidence 2: Hasn’t Allah (SWT) endorsed and supported all messengers and prophets with the divine emissary of the holy, even if not mentioned in all cases, except two? Why is it not possible that both 3issa and Muhammad (peace and blessing of Allah be upon them both) were endorsed and supported by Ruh Al Qudus?
Evidence 4: This is confusing. On one hand you seem to be saying that ayah 4:172 implies that “as at the time of the revelation of Quran, Al Massih has not yet returned to be a wayfarer and servant to Allah (SWT). It doesn’t mean that it is far in the future…” (time stamp 45:43). On the other hand, you claim that Muhammad (ASWS) is Al Massih in his second life. So, are you saying that Muhammad (ASWS) was not initially Al Massih (at the time of revelation of ayah 4:172) but later became Al Massih? This is mind-boggling and incredible… two in one and one in two - mythological duality, as compared with mythological trinity - three in one and one in three.
Evidence 6: You say that ayah 5:110 starts with addressing 3issa son of Maryam and ends with addressing Muhammad (peace and blessing of Allah be upon them both) and placed in a future time of gathering of all the messengers and prophets. How did you deduce from Quran that it is indeed a discussion from future when Allah (SWT) will gather all the messengers and prophets (peace and blessing of Allah be upon all of them)?
All the evidence you have provided seem to be circumstantial, based on the so-called markings and similarities between our beloved prophet Muhammad and 3issa son of Maryam (peace and blessing of Allah be upon all of them). You have used the same method to claim that Ism3eel (AS) is none other than our beloved prophet Muhammad (ASWS) and Luqman is Zakariah (AS). Why can’t there be similarities among different messengers and prophets? Why can't Allah (SW) use the same wordings to express similar narratives in His Marvelous Quran? Why similarities between Muhammad, 3issa and Ismeel make them one and the same person? Isn’t it possible that your understanding is erroneous, and you might be getting carried away with your methodology?
What about Yahya (AS) who, according to your explanation, is the same person who died and then was revived after 100 years; probably after the Romans destroyed Jerusalem. Is there any account of his second life? It's interesting to see that both the "brothers", Yahya and 3issa (AS), had two lives and lived during two different times. Some may argue that you are trying to turn our beautiful and pragmatic Deen Al-Islam into a mythology with this story of Yahya and 3issah (AS). May Allah guide us all to Sirat Al-Mustaqeem and to the Truth.
@ BenAdam
Thank you for taking the time to write...
First of all, remember that the Quran told us, in no uncertain terms, THAT ALL THOSE WHO DISAGREED ABOUT HIM (I.E., ANY OPINION IN EXITSENCE BEFORE THE QURAN, OR BASED ON CHRISTIAN SOURCES) ARE WRONG!
You whole argument is based on questioning the grammatical indications of Evidence 1 (we have already addressed this in the video in full details, including the dilemma of those who reject our explanation), and on refuting the concept of markings for Evidence 2 (and we have already explained that there are no coincidences in the Quran).
Re. Evidence 4, there is no confusion... The expression لن يستنكف is referring to the time of revelation of this specific aya. THIS IS EXACTLY WHAT I SAID, but you have turned it into "at the time of the revelation of the Quran"... Therefore, when you say "you seem to be saying", it is your misunderstanding that is confusing you...
Re. Evidence 6: I explained that aya 109 before it clearly states يوم يجمع الله الرسل... What is your explanation for this context, if not at a time in the afterlife?
Moreover, requiring historical verification for something mentioned in the Quran (or any text for that matter) is a lame refutation, and you know that! By this same logic, we cannot establish that there was a man named Muhammad, or 3issa, or Mussa, or Ibrahim!
You accusation of "turning our beautiful Deen into fables" is indicative that you have not paid attention to all the segments on this channel, where I constantly state that we are referring to the Quran and rejecting unsupported claims, myths, fables, folklores, etc... And therefore, this accusation is bogus and unsubstantiated...
My advice: Please reconsider the evidence, without biases, and without taking a predetermined defensive stance about your pre-conceived notions, and you will engage the evidence more objectively.
Finally: As I stated in the declaration, I don't claim to understand everything about this issue, just like we (all Muslims) don't understand so many things that the Quran (our beautiful Deen) teaches us of Ghayb (such as angels, nafs, 3arsh, daze, God himself, etc)!. We are required to believe in explicitly specified Ghayb, that's all!
Regards
Incredible and so powerful evidences. It is difficult to imagine but such evidences and Quran don't lie. Thank you Dr Hany for sharing with us your knowledge
The first one alhamdulillah, let start watching..
Alhamdulillah.. indeed it is a learning and unlearning journey . Keep it up!
Revisted this segment and Alhamudulillah
His name is MORE PRAISED.....MashAllahh 🌹
💞Alhamdulillah👑Mashaa Allah i needs this kind of explanation 58yrs ago💖Shukran Ya Rabb & Dr💝
Thanks very much Dr
Very powerful segment indeed
_ I'm no longer shocked with this informations bcoz to be honest with you I'm ready to learn directly from the Qur'aan as u always insist
Very educative segment
Just finished watching again for the nth time. Just like the series on iblis and shaitan, this series on Isa is liberating. It unshackles us from distractions created by people who are obsessed by the end-times. For example, now we do not have to worry whether the recent build-up of vladimir's troops near another country is related to the army of khurassan who are getting ready to welcome the messiah who will come down from a minaret in syria...etc etc
I am blown away by the revelations in this segment, but I am anxiously awaiting those sections that you mentioned are yet to be disclosed. And once I thought why I was born so many years after the revelation of the text of the Quran, but now I feel so blessed that I was born at the time when the meanings of this great Book are being revealed. Alhamdulillah. I can't be thankful enough.
Dr Hany you must look into David Ewing Jr.'s studies! You two both confirm eachother without knowing!
Alhamdulillah, amazing segment!
Wow!
Thank you for teaching us about these exciting discoveries in the Quran.
Keep working on the Quran forever
Thank you Dr Hany for this wonderful exposition.
Alhamdulillah
Incredible information, very good work. Some of the best and most important studies being conducted.
Thank You Brother for sharing this information and giving us a better insight on the Holy Quran
Salaamun alaykum,
Alhumdulilah.
May Allah guide us to self-correcting methodology.
Excellent!
Once again, worth the time.... ☝️
Thank you Dr Hany,
Jazaka Allah kheir!
I always could not feel the pain,, pressure of our belovoed SAW until today. Until having come across this video. Now I have learned something, but I cannot share it: First I cannot speak or read Arabic. This does not support my authenticity if I would do so. Secondly, I feel the urge to share with, at least with my family. But I know that they would not understand it. And furthermore, I know this Information would crush their hope that they hold as I did on the subject of fhe returning of Isa!
Now I really have a FEELING of how Rasulallah must have been felt...I admit it is a small feeling compared to our beloved, but it's on my mind and keeps me busy...
Alhamdulillah MaashaAllah thank you Dr Hany
Masha Allah Dr. Hany, I think anyone with clear understanding and knowledge will know u are not teying to present urself as a messenger or prophet, but clearly as someone who seeks the truth in Al quran alhamdullilah
Thank you Dr Hany for this segment. I accepted this segment more rapidly because whenever I read 3:55, I knew this : وَجَاعِلُ الَّذِينَ اتَّبَعُوكَ فَوْقَ الَّذِينَ كَفَرُواْ إِلَى يَوْمِ الْقِيَامَةِ
Salamun alaikum appreciate your hard work it takes much time to understand the information you present, and i am thinking that how much time you spend for this presentation, may allah reward you in multipules
Bismillah, Thank you so much for the information and advices.
Salaamun alaykum,
How are you Dr. Hany and subscribers of MQ
Thanks 🙏 for the lecture
I watched The previous one five times as it had a lot of information and it really worked on me.
الحمدلله رب العالمين والحمد والمنة لله وحده ربنا ثبتنا على الحق واجعلنا من المحسنين. ❤❤❤
Salaamun Alaykum Dr Hany, Thank you v much for your mind opening lectures.
Alhamdulillah. Thank you Dr. Hany.
Alhamdulilah it was not shocking to me especially after knowing zulqarnains lineage, and after the segment of who Issas عيسى pbuh father. But so much emotions and thoughts was rushing through my mind and heart as i watched it. There is a great deal of our youth who are into eschatology and I invested time and energy and money in it before. May forgive my transgressions and between this and the refusing to even listen to us when we show the truth from the quran and the overwhelming feelings and loyalty as a result of being blackmailed by the imams when they ask questions and telling you becoming out of circle of Islam for even thinking, our families and our youth are in reall hot water. This segment was something else for me. So many questions and thoughts and need to do more taqwa and discipline. ربي اني بما أنزلت الي من خير فقير.
Alhamdulilah Alhamdulilah Alhamdulilah that I lived to know the truth of the Quran and may Allah return our loved ones and the Muslims to this truth. May Allah bless you Dr Hany tremendously.
Alhamdulillah,Let's go
SubhanAllah! Thank you!
I never shocked in any segment, thank you Dr Hany, what have you done in marvelous Quran is confirmation of what I have suspected. What I suspected before is just a hunch, you give me an evidence from Quran. Undeniable of course. Thank you.
Amazing observation and discovery
حللت اهلا وطئت سهلا مرحبا ب الصراط المستقيم، مرحبا ب القران الكريم.
Welcome Welcome to the straight path, welcome to the marvellous quran. Alhamdulilah Alhamdulilah Alhamdulilah for this guidance.
Subhana Allah to the number of His creation. I am utterly flabbergasted. I am not Arab and I don't understand a lot of the grammar of Arabic. But one thing that I was taught when I was studying it was that "Al" mean All or The , meaning all inclusive. So to me it means every last one of them leaving out none of them, have passed away before Prophet Muhammad. Actually you could have came on with this lecture and just literally posted this Ayah 3:144 and no one whether they can read Arabic or not would ever be able to deny it. This is what you called the indisputable truth, Hidden in plain sight. All I have to say now is certainly when Allah wants you to know a thing undoubtedly you will know. !
May Allah reward you, thank you so much. This means a lot to me especially since I am a convert from Christianity to Al Islam. I really feel the love of Allah today. I think Allah for allowing me to be acquainted with you and your work. Thank you for your diligence and uncovering in an earth-shattering revelation, that was hidden in plain sight.
Salaamun Alaykum.first.
Minute of 40:50 is one of evidences in surah 16 verse 26 :
مَكَرَ الَّذِيۡنَ مِنۡ قَبۡلِهِمۡ فَاَتَى اللّٰهُ بُنۡيَانَهُمۡ مِّنَ الۡقَوَاعِدِ فَخَرَّ عَلَيۡهِمُ السَّقۡفُ مِنۡ فَوۡقِهِمۡ وَاَتٰٮهُمُ الۡعَذَابُ مِنۡ حَيۡثُ لَا يَشۡعُرُوۡنَ
.. Allah struck at 'very' foundation of their building, and it's collapse completely...from where they did not expect !
Dr Hany, Masha Allah, What a Miracle of Methodology !
Salamu'alaykum !
Alhamdulillah amazing ❤
Masya Allahh. What a disclosure this is.
All the messengers had passed away before him.(meaning he is the last one standing )
Lest if one is not careful enough, one would read and mistook it to be ‘all the messengers before him had passed away (meaning there will be messengers coming after his time).
Thank you dr hany toiling on these ayat 3:144 & 5:75 .
May Allahh bless you always.Alhamdulillah.
Doesn’t this mean that revealing this truth is actually the second return of Issa?
I mean he doesn’t have to come back as flesh and blood or only as Al Rasool Mohammad, but he is coming back as an idea or a thought or a re-exposed truth, as you have just did with this segment?
ALHAMDULILLAHI RABBIL ALAMIN.❤
Incredible
Yes, indeed...and I'm revisiting this segment yet again, and again
This segment is too heavy for my core to accept it- I3saa and Muhammad is the same. But for now I will just swallow the tons of question I have and reserve it till I watch the next segment. I will patiently wait inshallah.
Very interesting Dr Hany
Thank you Dr. Hany. But it's not a surprise to me. It just strengthen my belief. Bocz there is a lot of Quranic and historical evidences that showed that "Mohamed" of the hadiths followers does not exist, as their stories about him do not match the Quran. Now we're learning from you that the true Mohamed was the second coming of Jesus, which makes sens to me. The name Mohamed might be a description but not a proper person name. This is bcoz ALLAH never addressed to the messenger directly by the name Mohamed in the Quran like "Ya Musa! Ya Issa!. All the 4 verses about the name Mohamed descript Mohamed but not talking to him.
- What do you think?
- How you relate your claim to this verse 7:157 (gentile prophet)? and 93:7
I think that this video disproved those who claimed that the Quran is addressing Jesus but not in the second coming.
THANK YOU DR.HANY MAY ALLAH BLESS YOU.
Alhamdulillah
Salamualiku Dr Hay,
I am trying to toil by my own for this verse of the Quran and give it meaning 22:79 and I want your verification so that i make sure that for the first time that I am on track;
وما جعل عليكم في الدين من حرج ملة أبيكم إبراهيم هو سماكم المسلمين من قبل ٢٢:٧٨
There's no difficulty on you in understanding the Quran (if you follow) the compositional style of Ibrahim's, your spiritual father who named you as Muslim before when you were not called Muslim 22:78.
Thank you Dr. Hany.
Salamon alaycom DR.Hanymillions of thanks for this knowledge,,no one reveal it unless guided by Allah U pray that God Allah prolong our life,,i am purely satisfied
First. Shocking. Profound methodology. Truth. May we be part of the branches.
Tayab you're suggesting Eesa is one of the many pseudonyms of Muhammad SAW. When you mentioned the verses about how bani Israel accused Eesa about not being able to know about their speech, this could be in reference to the Jews that had settled in Madina for a long time, and they would have all known each other and kept their knowledge between themselves. So when they marvelled at how the Prophet could know about them, its based on the evidence that they had never seen him among them before and so how could he know? This also verifies the whole lineage issue as they thought the final prophet would be from them and not from Quraysh.
So do you think Ibn Maryam died and will not be returning, nor will there be a Mehdi or anything like that?
@Marvelous Quran, What you say makes sense a lot... is this the reason why Allahh told Mohammad in several ayats to remember in the story of Maryam or Story of Musa or remember when Musa did so and so? Instead of asking him to learn but to remember!
Thank you and may Allah Bless you Dr Hany and give you health and courage to continue your valuable work
in part 3, i naively asked the possibility the name to be 'also Muhammad' (which i was mocked by someone for that).
now here you are, giving some shocking information that far deeper and heavier than my shallow naivety.
this information, that you show us, might cause some accusation of heresy (by some close minded people or fanatics)
I always thought that “your community” in 43:59 and 43:60 are the Qureysh because they said “are our deities better or he?” meaning the speakers were not monotheists. The Jews of Medina were monotheists. Secondly, if "your community" is Jewish, are we confirming that our beloved s.a.w. is of Jewish lineage?
Alhamdulillah. All praises be to Allah, the Lord of all realms. I am at peace. Salamun Alaikum.
Salamualaikum dear Dr Hany. With fully empty cup, the revelation is indeed its natural sequential course. Alhamdulillah... I thank you again and again for all these substantive works in progress. My continuous prayer for all to be on the righteous path, bi izz nillah. As salam n stay healthy n safe insya Allah
Shukran
Alhamdulillah ❤❤❤
Another good lecture. Will have to watch it again to pick up all the information in this lecture.
Why you don’t call Isaa son of Zacharia??????
Alhamdulillah - Salamun Alaikum Dear Dr Hany -
As-salaamu alaykum Janaab, I really wish I could learn Arabic and reading he Qur'an personally from you 😊🤗 I absolutely love your understanding ❤ .. it breaks my heart to think how impossible that is to learn personally from you 💔 .. I will try to follow the videos watching them again and again, hopefully I will understand properly by myself 😊
@@MarvelousQuran 🤍❤
Maa Shaa Allah. Dr Hany May Allah Protect you , you and your Family…Amin
I want to pray like the Quran says and no one else. How can I do that. Allah speaks about 3 prayers which makes total sense to me because it's very doable and I believe that most Muslims don't pray is because of rhe 5 consecutive players. On the busiest time of the day, Muslims have to do 3 prayers that have more than 2 rakes. Allah said he wants to make our religion easy for us. How's that easy
Every action is a prayer.
Synchronizing mindfulness of Allah with your action.
It is so powerful, that is why it’s been hidden.
Great
Yep, explains so much.
ALHAMDULILLAH...
Amin
Even though I know just a little about arabic.
But the evidences is real, if you choose to use your mind well.
The knowledge presented in this channel is the most make sense and complete (limited to my search)
And if Dr Hany said all of us doesn't understand it. (it's limited to the us which Dr Hany know)
Make sure you don't fall to errors of your mind.
If you truly seeking the truth.
Because if you want to stay being connected to Allah you want to make sure you're in the right direction.
Muhammad (ppuh) is the return of Christ (AS). The Qur'an is his return. There is nothing that Christ was promised to fulfill that Muhammad did not fulfill. It is him 100%
Allah(swt) kept secret and he dont want to reveal!!! whata statement