Why Is Jammu Ignored?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 3 окт 2024
- In this podcast, Kushal speaks with Manu Khajuria and Sunanda Vashisht about the current elections in Jammu and Kashmir. This podcast will have a particular focus on the Jammu region that gets ignored in India because of the Kashmir obsession of our media and Intelligentsia.
Follow them:
Twitter: @KhajuriaManu
Twitter: @sunandavashisht
#Jammu #Kashmir #Islamism
------------------------------------------------------------
Listen to the podcasts on:
SoundCloud: / kushal-mehra-99891819
Spotify: open.spotify.c...
Apple Podcasts: podcasts.apple...
Stitcher: www.stitcher.c...
------------------------------------------------------------
Support The Cārvāka Podcast:
Buy Kushal's Book: amzn.in/d/58cY4dU
Become a Member on RUclips: www.youtube.co....
Become a Member on Patreon: / carvaka
UPI: kushalmehra@icici
To buy The Carvaka Podcast Exclusive Merch please visit: kushalmehra.com...
------------------------------------------------------------
Follow Kushal:
Twitter: ku....
Facebook: / kushalmehrao. .
Instagram: / thecarvakap. .
Koo: www.kooapp.com....
Inquiries: kushalmehra.com/
Feedback: kushalmehra81@gmail.com
Want to create live streams like this? Check out StreamYard: streamyard.com...
More power to Dogra beti, Manu. Sunanda deserves Kudos too. The most apt question emerging out of this is 'What is India doing about it?'
Hello col sir! 👋🏻
I watch u on aadi ji channel and JD!!❤❤
Sir please let’s start raising the issue. I know and always follow your discussion on all RUclips channels you are invited.Lets keep that voice raising .More people will know about us and may be one day our Jammu will get what it deserves from generations
Subscribed ! What an amazing discussion first heard for Jammu
Thanks Kushal, Manu and Sunanda for this 🙌🏼
Thank you Kushal. And Manu didi, I am a Dogra from Jammu and I appreciate the voice of my community being heard. If you come here, do visit Jammu. We have better food hahahah. Jai Dev! Jai Hind
Hello Karun. I am in Jammu every few months.
Brilliant debate,educational.If Ladakh was separated from J&K then there must be a valid reason why BJP did not do the same for Jammu .
THE BEST AND THE ONLY PODCAST I’VE EVER SEEN ON JAMMU SPECIFICALLY,KUDOS TO YOU GUYS FOR MAKING THIS HAPPEN.AS A DOGRA I’VE ALWAYS FELT IGNORED AND NEGLECTED, I HOPE THE INDIAN STATE WOULD TAKE A BREAK ON SO CALLED “KASHMIR KA MASLA” AND WILL FOCUS ON JAMMU .JAI DUGGAR JAI DOGRA🙏🏻
Thanks Kushal for providing a platforn to 2 prominent voices fron Jammu...and thanks Manu for making the most of this opportunity and setting the record straight...We need more voices like Manu to make Jammu's case and letting Rest of India know the significance of Jammu and Dogras 👍
Crucial ISSUE discussed. Kudos!! 🎉👏🏻
Very much imp and good discussion. Kudos all three!!👏🏻
Its time to get over Step motherly Treatment or "hangover" as rightly said and Strongly voice for #JammuPradesh.
Huge respect for Manu Khajuria Ji Kushal ji & Sundanda Ji. Excellent discussion on #Jammu!
Did you hear the term Chenab valley ? Does it exist ? 10:02
She used this term twice : 10:02 & 13:50
Though Manu ji corrected it by revealing the hidden agenda behind it : 16:55
@@sumeetkotwal4271 Absolutely!
It's #Chandrabhaga Region of #Jammu
@@sumeetkotwal4271there is nothing like chenab valley..vested interests invented this term
@@ashuexcel exactly !!
Only propaganda and narrative setting tactics!
Well spoken Manu Khajuria ji and Sunsnda ji .Thanks Kushal ji for giving platform to Jammu .
More power to Manu di for representing Jammu. Otherwise our region doesn't exist in the country's sphere at all. I think a godforsaken hamlet in the interiors of the jungles of baster will find mention in the national discourse but never Jammu
We lack development, basic health facilities, employment opportunities etc.
i am from jammu and i must say jammuites are paying for their nationalism. IRONY IS THROUGHOUT HISTORY OF INDIA (even before1947) THE NATIONALIST AND MORAL PEOPLES ARE IGNORED whereas ANTI SOCIAL AND SEPARATIST ARE REWARDED OR PLEASED.
Ignored in what sense? Development?
Every Hindu is paying for being a nationalist. So sad!
Jammuites have been ignored for so long as if it dies not exist.
@@prashanth7097 ignored in sense that we pay taxes and proceeds from that taxes are not spent on jammu, instead those taxes are used to give freebies to kashmir (electricity) and development in kashmir. Also central assistance is also spent mostly on kashmir. ALL WE WANT IS OUR REGION EQUAL SHARE IN DIVISIVE POOL OF FUNDS.
That is the reason NC will win in kashmir because now a days under BJP everyone have to pay electricity bills and kashmiri is unwilling to do that because they have always benefitted from conflicts getting easily and free from all sides (india, pakistan. Jammu). You know what the habit of eating for free (of kashmiri) cant be changed in 5 years into input/tax based economy.
@@manavspolialet's be blunt brother NC will win in Kashmir cause of religion. I feel bad for Jammu people and you guys should stand your ground and demand separation from Kashmir. It can be only done by strong leadership of Jammu, mark my word majority of Hindus support you guys for this demand.
As someone married to a 'Dogra', I feel a strong sense of gratitude after listening to this 'pod-cast'
Both speakers have aptly addressed the longstanding issues faced by the Dogras. It’s encouraging to see Manu Khajuria standing firm and speaking boldly in an international platform about the injustices faced by the Dogra community. It’s time for the world to understand the distinct identity of the Dogras and recognize them as a people separate from Kashmiris. The call for a separate Jammu state is both reasonable and justified.
Very insightful discussion. Thanks.
This is an excellent podcast for anyone who wants to fully understand Jammu. Every word spoken by Manu, along with the insights shared by Sunanda , reflects the sentiments of every Jammu Dogra, who have long awaited their rightful recognition,a wait that unfortunately seems never-ending.
Manu beautifully highlights the contributions of Maharaja Hari Singh ji and sheds light on the legacy of Brigadier Rajinder Singh,the saviour of Kashmir but they too have not got the share of appreciation they truly deserves.
The discussion on Jammu becoming a separate state, with the ability to make its own decisions and take responsibility for its future, is a crucial point that would allow the Dogras to stand out as an independent entity.
Thank you, Manu, our Shakti from Jammu, for being the voice of every Dogra.
Thanks Kushal for covering Jammu in your podcast. 1:16:49
Thanks Kushal, Sunanda and Manuben..Been few times international book fest event and corrected eveytime speaker it is Jammu and Kashmir not only Kashmir.
40:29 I love both of their reactions to what Manu said 🤣
This was so amazing!
Thanks Kushal for showing our Interest....
Boycotted BJP Yesterday
SAVE #OPEN_MERIT
I learnt a lot. I also believed that Jammu, Kashmir and Ladakh should be separate not now but from the beginning. But the reasons Manu & Sunanda gave solid arguments. Kudos to you Kushal. 👍 👍 👍
Sir, Intro music Is just SOOTHING!
PLEASE release full version!
🙏❤️
You made us open our eyes, regarding POK, why it’s really is not being called POJK.
I am from jnk and want to say that BJP removed 370 was a spectacular job but later on, they failed to heal jnk people specially Jammu nationalist people.. People of Jammu are feeling cheated bcoz of LG miss governance and center free hand to him and Beaurocrats..
They lost the public connection and implemented Tughlaq farmans.. We love BJP, Modi but they did wrong with us, I hope they will learn lesson from this debacle of loosing election badly.. Jai hind
Sorry lg mis governance? Is it worse than a nc or pdp govt?
@@prashanth7097 yes, worst than NC PDP congress, in their govt, common people could reach to them and they listen grievances and on some sort they didn't hurt common masses But this LG regime has done reciprocal,
They implemented Taxes, in the name of development, they destroyed old beautiful structures so that they could put lights on that to shine in night, this is development they claim.. I am critic of congress but they made me speechless.. Zero public connection
2 hours well spent!!
Kushal, I’ve been following this since the last few videos when you took this issue up, I completely agree with your view here, I myself am a part Kashmiri Pandit from my grandmother’s side.
I tried finding a map of Jammu but I couldn’t. All the maps I find are either Jammu and Kashmir or have Laddakh in them.
This is a bigger issue here. If there aren’t any public maps, how do you expect the government to do much about the issue.
On a separate note, could you share a map which shows what part is Jammu in the Jammu and Kashmir region?
Jammu region is ignored since 1947, not only by the central government but also by the national media, the reason why everybody all across India prefers to refer this erstwhile state as Kashmir instead of Jammu & Kashmir, which is absolutely wrong.
One can very well understand the reason behind it, as every one is so fascinated by the word Kashmir in every section of the Indian society all across the country that, it hardly matters whether the Jammu region is mentioned or not, despite the fact that Jammu & Kashmir became one unit as a State only because of the contribution made by the people of Jammu region and specially by the Dogra rulers & not by Kashmir's.
There's a typical mindset which has developed over the years in the Indian administration that nationalist Dogras can be taken for granted, whereas it is more important to keep the Kashmiris in good humour so that they remain in favour of India and literally ignored the Jammu region, by disempowering them politically, administratively, economically, at the cost of separatist's dominated society of Kashmir.
Even in this podcast, Sunanda is referring to the erstwhile Doda region as 'Chinab Valley', a phrase coined only few years back to create an impression as if this area is not a part of Jammu, but a different region with a distinctive identity, dialect & culture, as there is a nefarious design going on for quite some time to further divide Jammu region into three different sub-regions as Chinab Valley region, Pir Panchal region (comprising Rajouri & Poonch Districts) and the remaining part of Jammu province as Jammu region.
Bjp keeps giving importance to Kashmir
They don't really care about jammu
I'm from jammu
People here are not happy with bjp
Every party does the same.
BJP does a little more for Jammu than other parties.
@@ritvikkhajuria5694 tbhi haregi bjp jammu me
Bjp k alava aur koi chara nhi hai vote Dene k liye..pr Aisa bjp kregi to log na chahke b dusri party ko denge
(I voted for bjp btw)
@@ritvikkhajuria5694wrong assumption
Obviously because if we have to keep Kashmir valley withiñ india we have to win over them
❤❤❤
💯
28:30. why we should separate kashmir ? it was bought by our Maharaja from britishers, our raja was our pride our culture. The real Problem is not giving equal power and resources between jammu and kashmir. people of jammu prefer integration over regionalism. we just want equality and our equitable share
Thank You Kushal Bhai but you need to work on the channel it clearly can reach more!
Meethay Dugar tae meethi Dogron de bolee.
Remember these are the people who embraced KPs in 1990. We will remain indebted to them for ever , for taking such a huge responsibility. 🙏🏻🙏🏻
❤
2:30 Madras state before the division into individual states on linguistic lines incorporated a lot of the South under one name. So it may seem more flippant or even insulting now that Indians from the South were called Madrasis but that’s misleading.
This debate about Jammu about is just ridiculous. Yar everybody knows Jammu people are with india and are nationalists, problem is in Kashmir obviously govt will be trying to correct that region. If we again separate Jammu and Kashmir as different entities then kashmiri muslims will have a easy decision to seperate from india. It's so easy to understand
👍🙏🏻
Kumaon & garhwal divisions named himachal pradesh
Time to name jammu & kashmir as Lalit pradesh (lalitaditya of karkota dynasty)?
Madam .. no Chèn@b valley .. it’s Musharraf’s narrative to eat away regions of Jammu using this term. 10:02
As a jammuite, i want a separate state or even UT would be acceptable but we dont want to be with kashmir.
De do hum nationalist ko aazadi
Manu khajuria
30:24 I don’t think it’s a stupid argument, let’s say for any reason Congress comes back in power, in Trying to appease the Islamist left and decide to hold the plebiscite and Jammu is not the part of the equation you can say goodbye to Kashmir.
Even kashmiri Hindus never got anything. Everything is for kashmiri speaking mslams
🎉
So information about the Jammu region, its geography, topography and mapping are not available online and should be. Information about languages, leaders, prominent figures, history of it are also sparse online.
This is fact saying by sunanda ji , ek toh geography kisi ko samaj nahi aati.
Jammu ke leaders comedians ha
You give IIT AIIMS and medical colleges to jammu abd still jammu is ignored. Kya hypocrisy hai yr
More power to Mr Laüra Dè Fulà
Sorry for saying this but, the discussion felt like there's one hot girl which is Kashmir and the spot light is on her, in the mean time, there is another girl which is Jammu, who is also a hot girl but has not much attention and she is jealous of Kashmir. I know it's a serious issue but, it just felt like that...😄
I hear ya, this was a catty discussion. I wish it was divided into topics and stayed focused on the problem and their solutions. It would have been great if a reference map was shown of the area. Sunanda could talk about Kashmir and M about Jammu. Far too much ranting and raving, not enough substance. Oh well. Kushalji I wish would learn how to frame a question. Anecdotes, context, caveats, disclaimers - those are separate so say those first then your question. And the guests, if Jammu can’t be separated to be its own entity and you have been told this for time immemorial. By who? Just one example of a subject not clearly defined.
Gurez do not have kashmiri population they are pahadi muslims who are all over hilly areas of jammu and himachal.Their language culture is similar to dogri.It is ST reserved seat.Bjp is doing good in pahadi belt of jk bcoz of ST reservation to pahadis
Viva! Dogras
There was a decriminalization of people of Jammu since 1947.
A gruop of Hindu and Sikh shopkeepers from MirPur went to meet Nehru before the "Qabaili" attack of October 22, 1947.
And requested Nehru to send army for their protection but Nehru said ..go and talk to Sheikh Abdullah.
But both Abdullah and Nehru ignored the request as a result all Hindus and Sikhs of Mir Pur and Muzaffarabad and Kotli ....were killed or migrated after the attack of pak army and Qabaili attack....on October, 22 1947..
Then second time when Indian Army was winning and reached in Jammu region by pushing ..Qabilis back ..
Sheikh Abdullah requested to Nehru to do ceasefire and stop Indian army from further progression.
Abdulah said " these people are not from us they are more aligned with Pehari ..and Punjabi cultures.
Nothing doing with us "
..Now i think .
Hence Abdullahs and Muftis..
enjoyed staying in power for 70 years ..and mostly had CMs from Kashmir..
Now i think
People of Jammu should get up and demand a separate state..
Otherwise it is unlikely that J&K will have CM from Jammu.
...Jay Hind ..
🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Bharat mata ki jay🇮🇳🇮🇳🙏 ...
Love from PoJK..🇮🇳
Topic after 15 minutes starts to become boring. Masala dalo aur discuss hoga
Bro out of topic but abhijit spilled lies lies and lies on dostcast , He's been exposed by peeing human , ye baat zarur karna kal sham podcast me ,
Ye mat bahana banana ki pata nai hai , ye mene bata dia aur comments bhi 1 hi hai to tumne dekha hi hoga. !!
Pichli baar mene superchat se use pucha tha usne ignore kar dia tha
He's known to spread conspiracy theories but he's knowledgeable.
He spreads half truths which can easily be countered but atleast he's not like the hypocritical left who disown their own principles like liberalism,free speech,secularism for the appeasement of one community
Beacuse jammu is Hindu population
Nd modi is another gandhi
In modi gov anti nationals are rewarded nd nationalist are punished
Because he wants to be world leader ,another Mahatma for history books
Very very Self-centred,Selfish nd Hinduo kaa bada wala katnee walaa aadmi hh ye modi
Par hinduo ko nhi samajhh aaega
Jaise ek pahle gandhi ko nhi pakar paee,ye modi bhi apna jindagi aur glory migyaa hh
Hinduo ka nuksann hogya hh bada walaa
Nothing will happen with this podcast kushal.
Modi bkl will still keep on simping for kashmir kashmir kashmir.