This reminds me of Nayeon in Ice Cream, I Want You Back, Strawberry adlib "pa pa pa yeah", and first time super high adlib during sana's part and jihyo's last chorus
@@GabrielAlves-ig6wh I think this is too different from Nayeon's lines in ice cream and the bridge of I want you back, probably is closer to her adlib in strawberry but idrk anymore
I think is Nayeon (since she's the one that normally does head voice/falsettos in songs), what is making sound like Jeongyeon is the background vocalist (0:20) that lowkey sounds like her.
Nayeon's falsettos are kinda tense tho, just listen to Ice Cream, and you can still hear the softness in here when she says "know" or "ho ho hooo", especially in 0.5x speed
@@GabrielAlves-ig6wh yeah they can be tense (especially on earlier years). I never really picked a side on that topic. It always felt quite different from Nayeon, but still missing something to be Jeong
comparing with her falsetto in New New, this one not sounds husking at all, at least in her falsetto in New New where she start until the end sounds husky, but here for moments is not husky, same technique Nayeon does in the post chorus of Candyfloss
@@DDP121 But I think it's Jeongyeon cause Nayeon has such a soft voice while doing falsetto It can be that Jeongyeon voice changed as time passes and got more matured That's why she sounds different in New New I think it's definitely Jeongyeon
@@helloitsme535 idk, i’m 70/30, for me is more Nayeon, Nayeon falsetto is versatile in every aspect, the best example is the 2nd falsetto ad-lib in First Time, that falsetto sounds husky and some people still think is Jeongyeon even if Nayeon sing it in live, Candyfloss (Nayeon song) post chorus is a head voice (i’m not sure if is that or falsetto) and sounds husky, btw if someday perform the song again and Jeongyeon sing it i will not surprise, sometimes Nayeon and Jeongyeon sounds similar bc both of them are soprano and honestly, the arguments for the people who think is Nayeon are more convincing than the arguments for the people who think is Jeongyeon imo
This is not deep at all, 0.5x speed you can hear it's actually pretty soft especially when she says "know" and the last "ho ho hoo", jeongyeon never sounded like this, her falsettos sound similar to her normal mix, unlike Nayeon who sound pretty different in this register
thank u!! this is the kind of comment i was looking for! even tho i can see why ppl think its jeongyeon, i think its nayeon bc not only does it sound like her as well but also bc knowing how the producers like to give nayeon a lot of lines, they would most likely DELIBERATELY give her that line so she'd have more lines than most of the members
Also in jeongyeon's vocal range video by proudlymoa, in the upper register area, you can see how her D5s sound different (Ho!'s are D#5 but the video goes from D5 to Eb5 so there's no showcase of a D#5 specifically, but like it's a semitone the difference would be minimal EDIT: THERE'S NO DIFFERENCE IT'S THE SAME NOTE), comparing this to her falsettos in their OST ILYMTA is like night and day
@@GabrielAlves-ig6wh She also has Eb5’s in Wow, fanfare, 132 and four lead clover. I personably don’t know who sings that part in Ho so I’ll wait until they perform it again 🫠
This is not husky at all, 0.5x speed you can hear it's actually pretty soft especially when she says "know" and the last "ho ho hoo", jeongyeon never sounded like this, her falsettos sound similar to her normal mix, unlike Nayeon who sound pretty different in this register
its so confusing but this is why they shouldve just let jeong sing what the background vocalist sings bc they sound so much alike idk why jyp gets background vocalists when they have 9 singers who could do it anyways 😭
Nayeon for me. People only thought it was her because she was seen lip syncing it. nobody ever thought it was her before it, right because it doesn't sound like her that much
this is real, i see some distributions before TWICELIGHTS performance, those distributions counted like Nayeon and nobody argue about that, post-performance some people argue about its Jeongyeon
Honestly this is a matter of perspective. Whatever member between Nayeon and Jeongyeon I imagine in my head I could hear in this audio. If that makes any sense 😭
Para esos que dicen que es Nayeon, se les olvida que jeongyeon tambjen tiene una voz bien versátil fácilmente ella también puede ser y la escucho en el audio
it sounds more like nayeon. and you said in your reply it's yeonseo, so wouldn't that mean she's also singing sana's i gotta let you know part or am i going insane?
It reminded me of her "pa pa pa yeah" in Strawberry, her falsettos in I Want You Back and her higher adlibs in First Time (to which people also claim to be Jeong for some reason), like jeongyeon's vocals doesn't change too much when she goes to her upper register, the sound is like her normal mixed singing imo, whereas Nayeon is very versatile in that register and naturally sounds different than usual when going up to this register
Idk, I wish i could hear Jeong to get an idea of where people are coming from, I simply never could, unlike something like Bring It Back or Hot or these stuff
jeongyeon sang this part in this vid:ruclips.net/video/6jE6KhLL2ck/видео.htmlsi=E9P24sNNnW5E9eI2 but idrk😭 sometimes i hear nayeon and sometimes jeongyeon
@@startsmaran actually nobody sing it, the last audio is the mr removed and theres not live vocals, Nayeon and Jeongyeon lipsync that part, so the live performance not confirms anything
I still hear jeongyeon 😭her and nayeon sometimes sound similar when they are singing in falsetto
It could be Jeongyeon. The tone even reminds me of her final lines ("baby, baby baby") in 1 to 10
This reminds me of Nayeon in Ice Cream, I Want You Back, Strawberry adlib "pa pa pa yeah", and first time super high adlib during sana's part and jihyo's last chorus
@@GabrielAlves-ig6wh I think this is too different from Nayeon's lines in ice cream and the bridge of I want you back, probably is closer to her adlib in strawberry but idrk anymore
I think is Nayeon (since she's the one that normally does head voice/falsettos in songs), what is making sound like Jeongyeon is the background vocalist (0:20) that lowkey sounds like her.
Yes, I agree. It's Nayeon but the BG vocal just sounds like JY
the way she pronounces the “let” is very jeongyeon, it could just be her doing the lower portion and nayeon singing the higher one
@@victjsofjsmdngor But the lower is not Jeongyeon, is the background vocalist.
The vibrato is screaming JEONGYEON, idk what y'all on
I would guess Jeong because of quality, Nayeon falsettos are usually more relaxed and have a more "clean" quality
Nayeon's falsettos are kinda tense tho, just listen to Ice Cream, and you can still hear the softness in here when she says "know" or "ho ho hooo", especially in 0.5x speed
@@GabrielAlves-ig6wh yeah they can be tense (especially on earlier years). I never really picked a side on that topic. It always felt quite different from Nayeon, but still missing something to be Jeong
Clear not clean
0:01 i heard Nayeon
0:14 i heard Jeongyeon
0:27 i heard Chaeyoung or a background singer
0:40 i can't heard a person in particular
based on this it sounds more like nayeon to me, but I'm still not sure at all
its so clearly nayeon 😭
0:05 this part gives me nayeon vibes
Jeongyeon ❌
Nayeon ❌
Sophia Pae ✅
Stop making stupid assumption like that, Sana lines would be background vocalis too
its 1000% jeongyeon. you can hear the huskiness in the voice.
comparing with her falsetto in New New, this one not sounds husking at all, at least in her falsetto in New New where she start until the end sounds husky, but here for moments is not husky, same technique Nayeon does in the post chorus of Candyfloss
@@DDP121 But I think it's Jeongyeon cause Nayeon has such a soft voice while doing falsetto
It can be that Jeongyeon voice changed as time passes and got more matured
That's why she sounds different in New New
I think it's definitely Jeongyeon
@@helloitsme535 idk, i’m 70/30, for me is more Nayeon, Nayeon falsetto is versatile in every aspect, the best example is the 2nd falsetto ad-lib in First Time, that falsetto sounds husky and some people still think is Jeongyeon even if Nayeon sing it in live, Candyfloss (Nayeon song) post chorus is a head voice (i’m not sure if is that or falsetto) and sounds husky, btw if someday perform the song again and Jeongyeon sing it i will not surprise, sometimes Nayeon and Jeongyeon sounds similar bc both of them are soprano
and honestly, the arguments for the people who think is Nayeon are more convincing than the arguments for the people who think is Jeongyeon imo
@@DDP121 it can be
I thought it sounded really like Jeongyeon
@@DDP121 it doesn’t sound as husky cause Jeongyeons voice has matured a lot. Back in the day her vocals were much lighter 😭
I though it was Nayeon but it actually sounds like jeongyeon in this video
That Sound Like Jeongyeon Lead And Nayeon Adilib Or Harmony
i believe is jeongyeon 🥺
Its nayeon, thats her vibrato
I always had sure it was Nayeon, but in this video it sounds like Jeongyeon to me... It sounds too deep to be Nayeon IMO
This is not deep at all, 0.5x speed you can hear it's actually pretty soft especially when she says "know" and the last "ho ho hoo", jeongyeon never sounded like this, her falsettos sound similar to her normal mix, unlike Nayeon who sound pretty different in this register
it's probably nayeon, it sounds like her and i feel like the producers would choose to give her this line
thank u!! this is the kind of comment i was looking for! even tho i can see why ppl think its jeongyeon, i think its nayeon bc not only does it sound like her as well but also bc knowing how the producers like to give nayeon a lot of lines, they would most likely DELIBERATELY give her that line so she'd have more lines than most of the members
@@J_24 only people I saw sing this live was Jeongyeon and Sana tho?
Por la pronunciacion y como suena para mi es Jeongyeon, pero es bastante posible que sea Nayeon, asi que ni idea😅
Also in jeongyeon's vocal range video by proudlymoa, in the upper register area, you can see how her D5s sound different (Ho!'s are D#5 but the video goes from D5 to Eb5 so there's no showcase of a D#5 specifically, but like it's a semitone the difference would be minimal EDIT: THERE'S NO DIFFERENCE IT'S THE SAME NOTE), comparing this to her falsettos in their OST ILYMTA is like night and day
D#5 and Eb5 are the exact same notes. D#5 is mainly used by musicians especially who play piano
@@s_kpop_pi oh gosh that's true i am stupid af
@@s_kpop_pi either way there's not enough content of an Eb5 only Fake & True 🥲
@@GabrielAlves-ig6wh She also has Eb5’s in Wow, fanfare, 132 and four lead clover. I personably don’t know who sings that part in Ho so I’ll wait until they perform it again 🫠
For me I hear Jeongyeon, the voice more husky than Nayeon.
Edit: But that "know" sound like Nayeon... So IDK 🤷
This is not husky at all, 0.5x speed you can hear it's actually pretty soft especially when she says "know" and the last "ho ho hoo", jeongyeon never sounded like this, her falsettos sound similar to her normal mix, unlike Nayeon who sound pretty different in this register
Probably Nayeon. It sounds like her (I'd say I hear 90%Nayeon and 10%Jeong) and producers would probably give this line to her since Jihyo had more
0:26 I hear Jeong
its so confusing but this is why they shouldve just let jeong sing what the background vocalist sings bc they sound so much alike idk why jyp gets background vocalists when they have 9 singers who could do it anyways 😭
Nayeon for me. People only thought it was her because she was seen lip syncing it. nobody ever thought it was her before it, right because it doesn't sound like her that much
this is real, i see some distributions before TWICELIGHTS performance, those distributions counted like Nayeon and nobody argue about that, post-performance some people argue about its Jeongyeon
It's clearly nayeon
Honestly this is a matter of perspective. Whatever member between Nayeon and Jeongyeon I imagine in my head I could hear in this audio. If that makes any sense 😭
agree
I can heard Nayeon and Jeongyeon 😂❤
Its nayeon 100%
😭😭😭😭😭😭
I can't believe we're at it againnn
Maybe its just both of the girls singing on different layers?
i don’t think so, bc the voice in 0:20 are present (with additional layer) in Sana line
Para esos que dicen que es Nayeon, se les olvida que jeongyeon tambjen tiene una voz bien versátil fácilmente ella también puede ser y la escucho en el audio
@@RandomNachoxd nadie está diciendo que la voz de Jeongyeon no es versátil
What if the possibilities of it being bgv?
it sounds more like nayeon. and you said in your reply it's yeonseo, so wouldn't that mean she's also singing sana's i gotta let you know part or am i going insane?
@@dearmoonlyrics it’s sarcasms haha
@@DDP121 makes sense that had me confused 💀
Always Was Nayeon When The Song Release, IDK Since When People Hear Jeongyeon In My Opinion 🤷🏻♀️🤷🏻♀️🤷🏻♀️
Cause she’s the only one who sang it live 😂
@@whatsopanime Nayeon Sing It Too, Why The Delusional Jeongyeon Stans Can’t Understand That? 🤷🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️
I listen nothing lmao, I can't identify a member
Me tooooo lmaooooo 😭😭😭😭
It's Sophia Pae 💀
@@GabrielAlves-ig6whno, is Yeonseo 💀
@@DDP121 nah you have to be kidding me, for real?
@@Oliver-uz1fsnah ofc it’s a joke.
just do jeongyeon and nayeon for this one
What wrong? I thought it was officially declared it was jeong literally sounds so much more like her from the beginning and makes more sense
It’s always a debate anytime it remotely sounds like Jeongyeon. I don’t see anyone talking about Sana singing the same exact line 😂
@@whatsopanime because sanas voice is very distinct here
I hear Jeongyeon, her voice is so versatile
my voice? i’m not a singer xddd
@@DDP121 LOL xD
Her voice not versatile, Nayeon is so versatile and can be immitate for every member
@@snsdgivemetwice i know Nayeon voice is versatile, but i think Jeongyeon voice too.
0:17 is absolutely Jeongyeon.
it sounds really different from Jeongyeon tho. the 2nd "let you know" is nothing like her
@@CalifornianDreamin-e4l those are the background vocals done by Kim Yeonseo
@@murilo6233 Those are the ones that sounds the most to Jeongyeon, in fact if one part can be Jeongyeon here, its definitely these.
Isn’t the falsetto Nayeon?
What song is this?
Ho!
@@elizabethlung3095 Ho!
For me it's clearly Nayeon 🤷🏻 I can't hear Jeongyeon, it's too light
It reminded me of her "pa pa pa yeah" in Strawberry, her falsettos in I Want You Back and her higher adlibs in First Time (to which people also claim to be Jeong for some reason), like jeongyeon's vocals doesn't change too much when she goes to her upper register, the sound is like her normal mixed singing imo, whereas Nayeon is very versatile in that register and naturally sounds different than usual when going up to this register
i think the same, plus this voice is so similar with her voices in post-choruses in Candyfloss
@@GabrielAlves-ig6wh Completely agree
Idk, I wish i could hear Jeong to get an idea of where people are coming from, I simply never could, unlike something like Bring It Back or Hot or these stuff
It's too deep to be Nayeon IMO. But at the same time i don't think they would give this type of line to Jeongyeon so idk
It’s so clearly Nayeon to me, I don’t understand where people hear Jeongyeon.
I can’t hear nayeon anyway, It’s clearly jeongyeon for me 😭
jeongyeon sang this part in this vid:ruclips.net/video/6jE6KhLL2ck/видео.htmlsi=E9P24sNNnW5E9eI2 but idrk😭 sometimes i hear nayeon and sometimes jeongyeon
@@geinyourmind the last audio is the MR Removed from that performance, nobody sing it in live and Nayeon lipsync too
its jeongyeon... the live version shes singing
@@startsmaran actually nobody sing it, the last audio is the mr removed and theres not live vocals, Nayeon and Jeongyeon lipsync that part, so the live performance not confirms anything
@@DDP121 Oh
sorry but it's jeong voice imo
@@somberasmrfrozenfood7171 WHY BIASED LMAO LIKE YEAH JEONG IS MY BIAS bUTT
for example I always thought that the "I~" in Rush wasn't her
@@liar9950 idk honestly I take that back, I worded that really weirdly but it does 100% sound like jeong coming from a Mina Nayeon biased
I want it to be Nayeon so bad, but I only hear Jeongyeon...
why do u want it to be Nayeon so bad?? she already has spotlight in many other songs...let jeongyeon have this...
@@samurai_ionian a battle between Nayeon and Jeongyeon bias lol
What song is this?
Ho! from What is Love album