The Five Compound Platonic Solids
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 26 сен 2024
- Do check out my video with Adam Savage over on Tested: • Can Adam Savage and Ma...
Yes, I'm back in NYC for An Evening of Unnecessary Detail on Sunday April 14. www.eventbrite...
Pre-order my new book! mathsgear.co.u...
The excellent graphics of spinning dodecahedrons were made by Ben Sparks. You can see the GeoGebra file here: www.geogebra.o...
Some more details about space diagonals on Math Stack Exchange.
math.stackexch...
Huge thanks to my Patreon supporters. They keep my polyhedra intersecting. / standupmaths
CORRECTIONS
- None yet, let me know if you spot anything!
Filming and editing by Alex Genn-Bash
Written and performed by Matt Parker
Laser cutting by Lisa Mather
Extra graphics by Ben Sparks
Produced by Nicole Jacobus
Music by Howard Carter
Design by Simon Wright and Adam Robinson
Training on using a bandsaw by Adam Savage
MATT PARKER: Stand-up Mathematician
Website: standupmaths.com/
US book: www.penguinran...
UK book: mathsgear.co.u...
4:29 ϕ×ϕ this is my new favourite emoticon!
Fun fact: by definition, φxφ=Φ+1
🤯
фхф
ϕwϕ
classic cat eyes
¯\_(Φ×Φ)_/¯ - PARKER DIAGONAL IN SPACE!
I love dodecahedrons but our relationship will always be platonic
Groan... but also cute.
Perfect pun
nice
What a shame, I thought things were just golden.
That would break plato's heart, he thought the dodecahedron would always be your everything
D I A G O N A L S
I N
S P A C E
sadly youtube bitrate compression messes with my full enjoyment of D I A G O N A L S I N S P A C E
🛸👾
It is just a blatant theft from Science Asylum, but I'm not even mad. Well done by Parker-man.
@@Yezpahr nah, clearly it's blatant theft from The Muppets
I'm sure Adam Savage is a man. I'm tired of the misuse of my language by an elite few, who are trying to spread the misuse.
The quiet echoey "space" at 3:45 killed me 😭😭😭💝💝💝
My condolences to your family.
@@Elesario than you, its so sick how you still have access to RUclips in the afterlife, didn't expect that 💝💝💝
Was about to comment this hahaha great attention to detail
the autotuned "but i couldnt be bothered" cracked me up, this is why matt is the best
The “Diagonals in SPACE” interjection might be the best highlight for this channel in a while. And I’m glad to be a part of it when it becomes a happy meme. :)
Matt still trying to make us forget about the Parker Square.
But we will never forget. :D
I was expecting a more Piiiiigs iiiiiiin Spaaaaaace vibe.
Clearly Science Asylum inspired, if you ask me. Not that I'm complaining.
1:31 Alex, do you want to give me a hand with this?
Alex: Sure
Caption: No
made me think I was insane since I had to scroll so far to find this 😭
Shamelessly stolen from Jean-Luc Godard.
@@2ndfloorsongs who?
@@robinsparrow1618 Jean-Luc Godard was a famous French filmmaker. One of the many things he was noted for was having English subtitles that were frequently different from the spoken French soundtrack of his films. These were not slight differences in the translation, they contained different storylines, conversations, and descriptions of what was happening. They were frequently written by literary authors he'd invited and they were told just to view the movie and write their own script that went along with the visual film and not to worry about what the original French film was about.
He was a legendary innovator and invented the "jump cut" film transition among many other things.
I didn't mean to imply this was actually stolen, this was meant as a humorous joke.
@@2ndfloorsongs oh ok, this is actually really interesting and cool to know about. and it's a good joke with this context, thank you
I see that VFX department got a raise recently
Timing department getting their budgets slashed
Great job on emulating the old educational film aesthetic for those insert animations, really sent me back...
I think a reference to Look Around You
It reminded me of the animated sequences from the classic BBC Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy TV series
4:42: maybe tropic would be a better word than equator, as there are two of them parallel and equidistant from the central plane.
Oh god the SFX budget went sky high for this video!
One might even say it is IN SPACE
Excellent. I especially liked the D I A G O N A L S I N S P A C E.
12:00 a good excuse for drawing 12 pentagrams on a dodecahedron
Matt is summoning something in the exact center of the dodecahedron so that he can trap it
Fun fact: Both the small stellated dodecahedron and the great stellated dodecahedron can be thought of as 3D versions of a pentagram. They are both very cool shapes.
All hail Satan^12.
@@sineray_alwell, duh!
How else would you trap a demon in the centre?
Everyone taking about "diagonals in space" but 11:41 is the best voice sample for an EDM song.
And what about the "but I couldn't be bothered" from 7:47?
@@wyattstevens8574they couldn't be bothered to mention it
Hot take: _Howard Carter's entire soundtrack_ for Matt's entire channel is, like, the only _good_ EDM I've ever heard.
If you want Steve's subscribers, you need to fill that thing with water. You were so close! 😄
I really dig how your personality and style come through even in the bits other people help you with these days. Been a fan of yours for many years, you always bring me smiles, quite a few belly laughs and a ton of inspiration
Ben: Hey Matt! I've made a spinning dodecahedron in Geogebra!
Matt (after this video): I don't need you anymore! I can make my own spinning polyhedra!
The cube dodecahedron relationship is like, my favorite thing about 3d geometry, its so beautiful
Mine is the three orthogonal golden rectangles forming the verticies of the icosahedron.
@@needamuffin oh yes, in fact, that is also a result of same connection between the symmetry groups. (the icosahedron is duel to the dodecahedron, and three orthogonal planes have an associated cube)
Every d12 I own (which is 2, I'm not a weird dice hoarder) has the cube shape drawn on in sharpie, it's so satisfying to look at.
I also like how the pieces you'd have to "cut off" to make the dodecahedron into a cube are shaped like little rooftops.
The smaller solids left behind by the shapes discussed are super satisfying in their proportions too, both the sort of flattened, obliquely truncated triangular prism you get from cutting along the square/cube and the frustrum of a pentagonal pyramid cut off by the near-equatorial pentagon...
I like several of the integrated shapes. Discovering the square within the dodecahedron reminds me of the end of this demonstration of the Cross Sections app: ruclips.net/video/2uHfFp1XCPc/видео.html
I was not prepared for the joke at the end. Well done.
13:34 the convex hull of the 5 octahedron compound is the icosidodecahedron. I know this video is about regular dodecahedrons, but I was a little sad when you brushed it off. It’s my favorite compound, my favorite stellation, and my favorite faceting. It also looks a whole lot like my one of my favorite polyhedra, the disdyakis triacontahedron!
The icosidodecahedron _is_ its convex hull. I don't know what Matt was talking about, maybe he meant that the convex hull is not regular.
@@galoomba5559It really sounds like he accidentally skipped a word.
8:00 the rotation due to parallax and the actual rotation cancel out briefly. very cool to see
"Lots of ridiculous maths things" .... is possibly the best description of this channel I have heard ....
When I started learning 3D modeling and animation on the Amiga circa 1988, one of the bigger challenges I set for myself was modeling and animating regular pentagonal dodecahedron with a raised star on each face (similar to the Chrysler logo) -- thus the dodeca-deathstar was born. A couple years later, working in high end video post production, I used the mathematical precision of the amazing Ampex digital optics device with a precise pentagon matte to layer a spinning dodecahedron with different video on each face -- calculating exact angles and depth offsets with an HP-15c calculator was a wonderful challenge that grew my maths skills considerably. Sorry Matt, but the platonic dodecahedron is, and always will be, the BEST dodecahedron.
Good ol' small stellated dodecahedron and the great stellated dodecahedron
Oh, yeah! I have Steve's last video on the "watch later" list but I always forget that list.
Thanks for reminding me, Matt!
The dodecahedron is slowly de-throning the icosahedron from being my favorite platonic solid, thanks to crazy fun stuff like this.
I love the over-the-top editing style.
Just goes to show how you can't please everyone. I hate it.
8:24 matt's mental maths is on point
8:32 it tickles me no end to learn that Matt is a Look Around You fan
7:40 this is next level editing XD
Matt, you are honestly a master educator. I'm in my thirties and failed nearly every math class I ever took
(and whatever I did manager to learn, I promptly forgot when I graduated high school). Every time I watch one of your videos I learn something and I'm able to truly understand and retain concepts that boggled my mind before.
This was so much fun to watch and in my opinion one of Matt’s best in terms of pure enjoyment and entertainment. Matt’s enthusiasm is totally infectious and a delight to watch. The brilliant choice of music only added a new dimension (!) and I cannot praise this video enough!
agreed
I almost audibly gasped when you taped that square on. This was a really cool way of showing everything, better even than a 3d animation or something I think.
One thing to do would be to also tape the insides, but wait, there's more...
you could have taped each cube with a tape (or drew with a marker) that reacts to a different wavelength of UV. Then by switching different blacklights you could switch between the cubes instead of having them on all at the same time.
Are we sure there is such a product?
The “diagonals is space” visual evokes old school Hitchhikers.
I absolutely adore the visual representation of the see through dodecahedron with the tape to show the square, pentagons etc! it's just such a satisfying visual proof of the lengths of the space diagonals
Once again, you're knocking it out of the Parker with these videos!
I had to make a geometric solid out of paper as a highschool project. I chose a dodecahedron and it was pretty wild finding out that the whole net can be constructed (with straightedge and compass) using just a unit side and like 3 or 4 powers of the golden ratio. Imagine unfolding one half of the dodecahedron into a flower shape. That flower is bounded by a pentagon that's phi^2 larger than the faces.
Matt Parker: "There are 5 regular polyhedra."
Me, a jan Misali enjoyer: "there are 48 regular polyhedra"
the editing on this is impeccable
I've always loved the regular compounds and their beautiful symmetry. When I built my first raytracer and figured out how to raytrace cylinders, the compound of 5 tetrahedra (which is my favorite) was one of the first things I made a render of. The regular compounds were the first things I printed when I first got my hands on a 3D printer. Great video as always!
“Seemed clever at the start, I regretted it immediately”… that can basically be the theme of my life 😂
3:30 I immediately know where this video is going and I love it!
Discovering the square within the dodecahedron reminds me of the end of this demonstration of the Cross Sections app: ruclips.net/video/2uHfFp1XCPc/видео.html
Let me know if a tool like that could aid in visualization.
You could possibly do a follow-up on the hexagon within the hexahedron.
Novice sorcerer: Pentagram on the floor, demon flies away.
Experienced Warlock: PENTAGRAM DODECAHEDRON!
The editing is genius
I love the ones where you can tell how much fun he had with it, and also where the concepts don't fly too far above my head. Also I can see myself making a shitty scaled down version of this in the future.
I aspire to enjoy my work as much as Matt
The subtle joke for diagonals in space about 4 minutes in was really good. I imagine you were thinking, this is a bit silly, no one’s gonna even care. I care. That caught me off guard.
Legend says that he still says "Diagonals in Space"
It hits better when you can visualize it in real life. Thanks Matt
Rollie Williams would be proud of the video's style I reckon
What a lovely coincidence I'm building nested platonic figures in bamboo sticks (up to 3m) with my students at the moment and analyzing this video is their homework. Thanks, Matt.
Loved the book! I love how you were able to invent *time traveling* with trig! Mark my words, This is going to be the best-selling book in history!
i will never look at a megaminx the same way after this
9:20 "The shape we were trying to made was the compound-5-intersecting tetrahedra. Here is a picture [...] and I've actually got a little print out over here" - am I the only one who was a bit sad that it wasn't a 3D print?
your videos are capable of pulling one out of depression and make them fall deeper in love with mathematics. Thanks a lot for your work, sir.
I have to be honest, I really like the stella octangula (the compound of two tetrahedra) just because it has a simplicity that a lot of the other regular compounds don't have. You can take a single glance at it and instantly know how it's constructed.
I love me some DIAGONALS IN SPACE
This is so unhinged, and I mean that as an absolute compliment
Id love the multicoloured luminous compound polyhedron as a pendant
Matt thanks for running the only math channel I've found that will always explain things in a way that makes sense and makes me laugh every time! I've been watching your videos for a long time and you've only gotten better with time!
A masterpiece of maths and editing
Isn't the diagonal shown in 4:28 the longest diagonal, or am I seeing that wrong?
Still enjoying ur vids
Had the same thought!
That's a lovely, easy to visualize, and excellent way to explain these conceps. Absoulytely a great example of how to teach a concept really well. Good job, Matt.
Never would've guessed a pentagonal dodecahedron was actually 6 hip roofed homes trapped orthogonally in the same space.
Love how you cut away from the deeply unsatisfying 'Parker Peel' at the end of the intro.
The vintage eductational video aesthetic is giving strong "look around you" vibes...
....I N S P A C E
8:34 "Write that down in your workbooks" 🤣
6:45 the coolest part of this was that this was wholely unsurprising thanks to your previous videos on the rhombic dodecahedron
It's lovely when one maths investigation is helpful in understanding a completely unrelated one
The compound polyhedron made of a pair of intersecting regular tetrahedra, is aka the "stella octangula."
It was a favorite of Johannes Kepler, the guy who fiddled around with the 5 Platonic solids to try to explain the relative sizes of the planetary orbits, and the guy who formulated the famous "3 Laws of Planetary Motion" that bear his name.
Anyway, the 8 vertices of the stella octangula are the vertices of a cube.
Which also explains the 10 regular tetrahedra in the regular dodecahedron, once you've highlighted the 5 cubes in it.
Fred
PS. Also interesting to note, is that the main (longest) diagonal of an n-dimensional hypercube of unit edge, is √n.
Once the pink tape came out, it started clicking in my brain. This is clever.
This is why the dodecahedron has magical powers.
Matt just dropped the hardest cube-in-a-dodecahedron edit and thought we wouldn't notice!
Video idea: One hour of Matt Parker reading digits of Pi randomly interrupted by “DIAGONALS IN SPACE”
There are, in fact, more than 5 regular polyhedra! jan Misali has a great video on this, titled "There are 48 regular polyhedra" if I recall correctly
Thanks, Matt. Thatt.
I love your visualization, it makes the whole thing insanely well understandable for me
We want a t shirt of this with text "Diagonals IN SPACE"
The title of the book is perfect.
Consider:
"2 Intersecting Tetrahedrons" (also known as a "Stella Octangula") are enclosed by a cube, & since "5 Intersecting Cubes" are enclosed by a Dodecahedron, it means that "10 Intersecting Tetrahedrons" can also be called "5 Intersecting Stella Octangula".
Imma need that track. 🎶"I couldnt be bothered."🎶
Matt: I'm a maths educator who invented the Parker Square.
Also Matt: 5x12 = 12x5
One good way of investigating the relationships among the vertices, edges and faces of polyhedra is to use your favorite 3D graphics program to create a model of one, rotate it into various positions, and project the points and lines onto a plane using a parallel projection. It's easy to find perpendiculars to the faces by using the cross-product (a vector operation) of points on the edges (e.g., the vertices). The perpendiculars can then be used to orient the polyhedron appropriately.
I've done some work involving polyhedra, including plans for cardboard models, which are available for free, if anyone's interested. One of my main sources of information has been the book "Mathematical Models" by A.P. Rollett and H. Martyn Cundy, which is one of my favorite books.
@12:53 seven swans a-swimming,
six geese a-laying,
FIIIIIVE INTERSECTING CUUUUBES
I like how the editing of this video makes every joke feel like it glitched out and entered Matt's subconscious where he comes up with these gags.
I like how the cable ties make dotted lines under the black light.
*Diagonals in Spa-*
This is one of my favorite Stand-Up-Maths video!!!!!
Are you THE Matt Parker from the Parker Square? What an honor!
Matt, that Dodecahedron in the title card isn't even physically possible unless you start warping the faces. At best, it's some kind of Pentagonal prism that bulges to look like a Dodecahedron, but really isn't. The face directly opposite of another on a Dodecaherdon is rotated 180°. The dotted lines are emerging from the wrong vertices on the contour edge of the image.
I had to scroll way more than I thought to find this comment.
@@bogdanieczezbyszka6538 Well it's nice to know someone else noticed.
This is like a super fun kindergarten arts class for adults.
I thought Matt made a clear dodecahedron to be quirky, but then he started explaining... there's method to his madness!!
your editor deserves a raise.
"You're a geometer? What does that mean?"
"I study shapes in space."
"How did they get up there?"
man my workbook is getting full thank you for that note
The cube inside the dodecahedron is actually how Euclid himself constructed the dodecahedron! Check out Book 13 of his Elements, it’s proposition 17!
Come for the maths. Stay for the awesome things maths can do.
Steve Mould's tip from the cable with a door handle to use PHYSICAL props is paying off really nicely!
Yes but Matt should really be filling his polyhedra with water to get people interested!
That video where he talks about spreadsheets is worth the view.
Adding new shapes to the friends list!