@@TRYBALS i was hoping it was good music, you may have well just sang the wheels on the bus to them. That would have been better, can you do that video?
Great music and singing no matter where its from will always touch somewhere inside and move you,ive listened to Mongolian throat music native American Songscapes and been in tears at how powerful it was...this isn't my favourite version of Hallelujah but its a damn good one
I think the word Hallelujah, or something like, it is fairly universal. It is thought that the word is an onomatopoeic imitation of ululation which is a common expression of joy in various cultures.
@@Evija3000 yeah this song in particular is not actually religious one of the lyrics actually says they are not sure if they is a god but it's irrelevant to what they are feeling.
I am so humbled by the response of these tribal people. they seem so open and appreciative. For years I sang complex harmonies in a band and it is alot of work and truly magical. wonderful to see and hear all of this, brings tears to my eyes. ❤
I agree whole-heartedly. I posted the below on the "Hurt" video on this channel. More people should see the world through other's eyes.. This is my 4th video I've watched, and just subscribed to the channel. Watching these videos has struck me in a profound way. I'm a 60 year old farmer in North Texas, and I tell everyone I know about this channel, even if they won't watch it. Much like the Tribal people here, in rural Texas, you can be isolated from the rest of the world in many ways, but most importantly in a cultural sense. I've that individual humans throughout the world where much like me, our feelings about war, hate, love, joy, are much the same, but we don't get that from news stories, movies, etc. What we get is what our leaders and the media want us to see, to portray other countries people in either a negative light, or a positive one, depending on the political relationships between us. After watching several of the videos, I feel a kinship with these people, because I see them for who they are, what they find confusing, funny or beautiful, and I see in them people around me that would be saying the same things, just in a different language. Years ago, when the Internet first came into being, I had high hopes that it would break down these artificial walls separating us from the rest of humanity, but in the years since, I've grown to think it just made things worse, that we still couldn't communicate with others, we just see what our "leaders" want us to see, and I despaired of it. This is what the internet was meant to be, in its purest form. I thank you for creating this content, keep up the good work, and I hope there is a way that these people can know the affect getting to know them, their true selves, has on others. Again, thank you!
The elder gentleman appeared unmoved during the whole performance, when in reality he was analyzing every minute detail about it and resolved with great appreciation and understanding.
He seems to me to be what they would consider an Elder, very much respected and reserved. He is definitely a man who observes and thinks before he speaks.
@@shannonmcelroy8454 it’s true. I also love Hallelujah. The way they made this indeed captured some emotions. A very intense performance of an equally intense piece of music.
I love that the oldest guy cited their music teachers as being important and he called this a type of education. The arts are SO IMPORTANT to education in general and society as a whole
As a music teacher, this vid is such a powerful tool to show students how music transcends language, culture, grievances and disagreements. Music can connect us all as spiritual humans! 👍
I sing with an acapella choir. It's lead by a natural voice practitioner, one basic principle of the movement is that its a right/need for humans to connect and bond through singing in harmony.
@@elissamarcus think it through. your post. cultural differences separate us. the arts is the driving force that brings us together, an equal appreciation through those barriers. that's how i interpreted her post. unless, of course, we are looking for someone to be offended by today.
If she is giving the opportunity to be in your country with all the developments and technology,just imagine how smart and intelligent she would have comes out
They all were so expressive while watching and listening. The man who was singing along, the man leaning in closer, the ladies tearing up, and the man with the white beard and turban who didn't move a muscle but was transfixed. And they heard their own culture's music in this, and could compare and understand, even without understanding the language. Music is its own language.
Turban guy wasn't transfixed, he was repulsed by these western singers. Especially the "painted lady with her naked face exposed". And then he couldn't help but make it about him "DON'T FORGET ABOUT THEIR TEACHER!" In his world, it's not possible for people to learn skills without giving time and money to an old charlatan.
@@universaldonor3100 Agree! I thought it was because they are afraid of saying the wrong thing too. I doubt that there are any women on the production team, to me, and based on my experience of these situations in this culture, they are probably afraid.
@@beatdizzy True, It's obvious that one girl was clearly romantically infatuated by the first man's singing. She even brings up more than once how she liked seeing him beat his chest, which is a very masculine gesture. No doubt she had to restrain herself do to her upbringings.
It's amazing that, even without the translation, they could feel the emotion behind the song. I love Pentatonix and this is one of my favorite covers. I'm glad you shared the group with everyone.
Correct.. the expression Hallelujah literally means "praise Jah!"..( Jah is the shortened form of God of the bibles name Jehovah/Yehowah = YHWH)..so is its base
Its a universal human nature. A song played in a slow minor cord brings sadness example Chopins Funeral March, a speed up minor cord causes anxiety example the Michael Myers Halloween movie theme song, a song played in a major cord brings joy example The Happy Birthday song, a sped up major can bring laughter goofyness like That Benny Hill tune.
The one lady was even wiping tears away...that's when you know you have something special...they have no idea what the meaning is, but they felt it inside them enough to bring out the emotions in them
can we just take a moment to appreciate how beautiful everyone in this video is? everything from their eloquence to their disposition to their garments. I would love to know more about them!
I could not agree more. This is just a beautiful video altogether. I would love for us all to live in peace and learn from one another. There is so much out there that we don’t even see.
E x a c t l y ..... what a wonderful group of people.... stunning in their reactions, stunning in their clothes, stunning in their beauty. I simply loved this video and the whole concept. Music and sound is universal.
Yes! reaching across cultures and borders like this is the only thing that will save our world. I would so love to spend an evening eating dinner with them and getting to know them.
Yes! It's a beautiful world! There's also a song which lyrics are the same words. If only we all agree to it. Stop the wars, stop the hatred, stop the bigotry, stop evil! ✋love one another, but most of all love and worship the MOST HIGH CREATOR, ETERNAL, FORCE of the universe everyone calls GOD, there's only ONE. No other!!
The man with the white cap truly has a musicians soul. It seems regardless of genre or band he connects with the music on a borderline spiritual level, absolutely facinating to watch
The gentleman who began singing with them made me so happy. Then there were the 2 people who teared up from the song even without having the translation yet. Music is such a powerful thing.
5:09 You know you’re doing it right when someone hears you sing “and love is not a victory march, it’s a cold and it’s a broken hallelujah,” and decides it’s a sad song even though they don’t understand the words.
When the man in the red cap sat up close, his face looked so sweet, it made my heart smile...and the women were brought to tears. They got it... beautiful music always gets through❤️🙏
Amanda Downing. I think that you were really on to something here: if we took the time to really look into most peoples’ faces for more than just a moment, we would see their sweetness and beauty. We would connect with them differently. There are people out there that are doing research on this. Researchers find that if they ask people to sit and face each other in close proximity, and say nothing while they look at each other’s faces for two minutes, that they connect with each other on an emotional level, and some will have tears on their cheeks. Considering the fact that you figured this out without a researcher, you might be interested in looking at their findings. There could even be more to this.
That it does. I sing and play a couple of instruments (but nowhere near professional quality) and it does affect people. I was in a singing group that did a few performances in nursing homes, and even the patients who were not alert and oriented (as we say in nursing) loved the music. 🎵🎶🎼 When I was hospitalized in San Francisco (CPMC), they had a music therapy program. A harper played a lap harp in my room for half an hour. I felt like a Lady being serenaded in her manor. My soul just soared. I didn't notice pain, and that says something.
I’m a classically trained musician. I received my degrees and my formal training and have learned how to express and explain music in educational settings and beyond. It is simply beautiful to watch blind reactions of music they’ve never heard before and explain their understanding of the music’s expressions. It’s universal. Goosebumps the entire time. Makes me absolutely giddy to watch this. Please make more videos like these! They connect us all ❤
There’s something very touching about being able to connect with another culture through a shared love of beauty. It’s like making a connection with our shared humanity. If we did more of this there would be a lot more peace in the world.
Foreign music can (and definitely is) enjoyed by many! But! I loveeee it when the songs lyrics and also the FEELING of the song is translated so perfectly to someone who doesn’t know the language, it breaks such a large barrier and a culture barrier
I had the same reaction when hearing Faouzia sing Arabic runs in her cover of Desert Rose by Sting. I cried immediately. If you haven't heard her then please look her up. She's amazing!
EVERYTIME I listen to this song by Pentatonix the goosebumps and body chills get stronger as the song goes on and by the end I FEEL those words in my soul and just cry. So much more powerful than the original!
The man with the white beard was like a wise man, carefully studying everything in the minutest of details, he is profound. I love the fact that despite not knowing the language to understand the lyrics, these people could feel the beauty in the song. I love this RUclips Channel❤❤❤
I love that Muharam was so taken / carried by the music that he was singing along with them ❤ Mohammad and Abdul Aziz are so insightful....wise men, ustads themselves
Every song I have ever loved from different genres has that one basic component of being able to stir the soul. If it moves me to tears it's going to be music I love all my life.
Judging by the sophistcated opinions of the listeners, I was impressed by how deeply they analyzed what they had heard. They are some highly intelligent people.
I like that the elder in the white lace cap began to sing along. He didn't even know what the words meant, but the vocals and the tones managed to touch, as I saw someone else say, 'He has music in his soul.' The man with the colorful beard and the smaller beard, I could tell he was starting to choke up. And one of the ladies actually had tears. I find it amazing that all of them seem to catch the feeling of sadness, and they didn't even understand a word.
I realised just how important music is after I had a baby. Little brand new babies who know nothing of the world, they can't even see properly yet, but they respond to music.
The last line in this vid: "Everyone should be like minded to create such kind music" is so beautiful. I think music binds us all. When Pentatonix sings, they sing so beautifully because they're so in unison. Love it ♥️
I would argue that instead, it is diversity of perspective that allows such an incredible variety of music to exist. That said, I agree... to craft music is to create something of beauty, be that the thunder and violence of rock, or the soothing calm of a hymn. The world needs more music.
@Haariet Ward It is all relative to other cultures and religion. I don't judge. People should be free to worship as they choose. You can not look at the mid east or east with western views/culture because it is very different.
@@RachelJane101 The words Hallelu means praise and Jah is God so even though they were talking about Samson & Delilah, they were in fact praising God in the chorus.
@@HighlandBound I know what the word means. My point is, the Hallelujahs in this song are not praising any gods. This song isn’t praising God. This song is about romantic love, lust, sex, disappointment, a breakup, ultimately hope for romantic love, and also questioning the existence of a god. Pentatonix omitted the raciest verse with a Hallelujah that is specifically in regards to experiencing an orgasm.
@@RachelJane101 The song is about the betrayal of Samson by Delilah through the use of her feminine wiles and charms. The words are many times altered somewhat but if you think this is all about an orgasm then I think you might need to expand your reportiore a bit. I might also add that there is to be considered the betrayal of God by Samson, which is ultimately a deeper, more profound sadness than that of a man and a woman. Samson, even after betraying God still prevailed over his enemies after having his hair cut and his eyes put out and so the praise goes only to God for making that happen. Hallelujah.
I'm a grown man and I shed many tears watching this one. Wow. The reactions are just as good as the song itself. You know music is a gift from God to creation when that lady mentioned "they are praising God"
I really like that you included the link to “ Tirri Pawanda” by Allan Fakeer! I hadn’t heard that song before. It made it feel more like a cultural exchange-the Trybals hear popular American music, and we hear their popular music-instead of just handing the Trybals American media and watching them react to it. I feel much more connected, as if we’re hanging out and exchanging our favorite songs together. Please do more exchanges like this if you can!
Yes sure, that's the mission of course. The variation of cultures we all have to share is just beautiful and could be seen like different colors in a rainbow.
I've not seen this channel before. What open intelligent people you've brought together. My respect to them, opening up to experience different and unfamiliar music.
This is the thing I wish people knew on a cellular level. When you travel the World and experience different cultures and beliefs we are much more alike than we are different. And Many other countries have Much better educational systems. This is Humanity.
I couldn't think of the words myself but apon reading yours it is just what I wanted to say. They are are important people to have in our world and it is satisfying to watch and listen to them.
These tribal folks aren't dumb. You don't last long in that world if you're dumb. They're maybe not what we'd call "well-educated," but they are NOT stupid.
That song gives me chills every time. Leonard Cohen was trying to express how many different people have many different ‘hallelujah’ moments in life. I can’t remember how many different verses he wrote for his original song but other people also wrote a church version of hallelujah with his permission.
For some reason I have always felt like it was about unwanted loss....like of a relationship or losing a love one unexpectedly. Always sad though, never in a joyful way.
@@riffhammeron, not to take anything away from the Pentatonix cover, but Cohen was dying from Leukemia in October 2016 when their cover was released, and passed the beginning of November so I'm doubtful Cohen heard the cover. He did state that K.D. Lang's cover was his favorite. She sung it at a Summer Olympics and a tribute to Cohen.
@@Sheepdog1314If you listen to music and know anything about it, like most art, the viewer, or listener takes from it what filters through their own experience. It's never just ONE message or meaning.
@@beastvader I don't know Hebrew but Alhumdulliah is an extremely powerful and spiritual word. You're seem to have matched the meanings well. Always sensed that Hallelujah was an equally spiritually charged and powerful word.
@@user-et2ng1qb2m hallelu means praise, no j in Hebrew it should be yah (יְהֹוָה). Yah is short for YeHoVaH. The God of Israel. A joyous praise in song, to boast in God. 🙏
@itsme Emma Cohen actually was the first to record it in 1984 on his album "Various Positions", but from what I remember it was on an independent label and sold only in Canada. John Cale recorded it in 1991 on his album "I'm Your Fan", so I guess he would be the first after Cohen. The guy who really brought this song into the limelight was Jeff Buckley IMO.
Was so lucky to see Leonard Cohen sing this in Boston in his last tour, on his knees…it was indescribably beautiful….I love hearing this version and these lovely people reacting!
At 8:53 " I mean everyone that was creating different sounds, all different sounds become one eventually " Such simple yet beautiful, powerful words by the lovely woman. It's like her consciousness is on the frequency of love.
I have fallen in love with each one of these people. Watching them experience and learn new things about our world warms my heart. I wish I could return the happiness they have given me. Thanks for the great content, from California.
Hey as you're providing context to the lyrics in the future, here are some notes: Hallelujah is Hebrew in origin. It means Praise Jah. Jah is a short form for Jehovah, the name of the God of the Bible who created of the world. For example, the name Jesus means "Jah is salvation" in Hebrew. The Bible teaches that Jesus was the first creation of Jehovah, to be clear. Many people use Hallelujah as an expression meaning "thanks to God" or "Thank God". But, this song actually uses the term Hallelujah ironically and almost atheistically. I wrote a term paper analysis of the lyrics in college. Part of Cohen's lyrics expose the hypocrisy of religious violence ("Maybe there's a God above, but all I've ever learned from Love was how to shoot somebody who outdrew ya"). The Bible at 1 John 4:8 says "God is Love" and the "Love" in that lyric is referring to God. Many soldiers and armies falsely claim that God is with them. Cohen's lyrics suggest he did not believe that love really exists. His lyrics makes reference to the Bible story of Samson and Delilah, where Delilah betrayed her husband Samson, an Israelite leader divinely empowered with superhuman strength, by shaving his head while he slept and then turning him over to foreign enemies for a bribe of 1000 silver coins. His forever-uncut hair had been the symbol of his dedication to God and conditional to his receiving superhuman strength through angelic assistance. He died as a result of her betrayal. ("She tied you to a kitchen chair, she broke your throne and she cut your hair") The previous lyrics "You saw her bathing on the roof, her beauty and the moonlight overthrew ya" make reference to the adultery of King David of ancient Israel, who saw a beautiful married woman from his palace window bathing at night and he seduced her, conceiving a child with her while she was married to another man. He then had her husband Uriah killed to conceal their adultery. David got nothing but trouble from his actions, including later in life when his son tried to kill him and take his throne. David composed many songs, including songs asking God for forgiveness. That's where the opening lyric "They say there was a secret chord, that David played and it pleased the Lord" is from. The song's lyrics basically bemoan a lack of genuine love and loyalty between people and advances Cohen's cynical view that true, selfless love does not really exist. All of those thoughts are punctuated by the phrase Praise Jah (Hallelujah) as a cynical and sarcastic giving of thanks to God. In Cohen's view, thanks for nothing. Cohen was born Orthodox Jewish but did not hold to his faith. Over the years, he experimented with Buddhism, agnosticism and other philosophies. His lyrics are deep and full of meaning, for sure.
Although he meant it as "thanks for nothing" (as you say), that powerful phrase "thank Jehovah or thank God" overtakes Cohen's meaning and everyone feels the worship that transcends.
Thanks for your reply. I just wanted to correct one thing. Absolom (David's son who rebelled against him) was not Bathsheba's son. The son that was conceived in adultery actually took ill and died in infancy. David married Bathsheba and her next son was Solomon who ascended to the throne as the chosen heir of David (but not his oldest son).
@@monicajean37 oh stop it! I was giving a compliment! Besides, "Hot" describes more than just beautiful. Many woman are beautiful. Many are Hot. Not all that are beautiful also have that "hotness" factor. Both these women are a perfect example. Both beautiful, but one has that something extra! Learn to take a compliment.
This very unexpectedly made me cry. I live in Montréal and Leonard Cohen is part of the city's soul. To see how it can touch people who don't even know the language just struck me to the heart, reminding me how blessed I am to be a singer.
To me their reaction is a tribute to Leonard Cohen's talent. Although they don't understand the words they feel the spirit of the music. I have been trying to explain to people that that is what Cohen's music does to me. It touches my spirit.
I am so thrilled to see this and hopefully Pentatonix will see this as well. I love their "Mitch faces". Each one had a very different but strong reaction to his voice. This one of my favorite reactions to this video I have ever seen!! Thank you so much for doing this and the way that you did it not translating the song for them
I must admit seeing these people moved by music they’ve never heard, with words they can’t understand, made me a little emotional myself. It’s quite amazing how powerful music is.
I love the girls reaction. They are so sweet and it was very heart warming to see they were moved by the music even without knowing the full meaning of the words
I just discovered Pentatonix about 4 months ago (I'm American) Blown away by their talents. I think 3 of them have been together since high school! I cry every time I hear this song NO MATTER who covers it
Then you are now a Pentaholic. Enjoy your trip down the rabbit hole. Their standards of bohemian rhapsody Imagine Amazing grace Are Good. My favorite is imagine because of the way they've Updated it with Pentatonix spin on it and how they deliver such a powerful message Themselves to go along with The powerful message in the song. They are known for their Christmas albums. This year's album ever green includes there cover of the Prayer which most people know Prayer which most people know celine Dion and Andrea Bocelli singing it. Since October 29 it has over 3,000,000 views. It is Pentatonix at The pinnacle
I always watch Pentatonix virgins, no matter who they are or what song they choose to listen to. But I love it when they choose this one because there's a good Mitch-slap in it.
Scott, Mitch and Kirsten knew each other before high school. Since they were about 10 years old I believe (though that might have just been Scott and Mitch who were actually friends that young though they definitely knew each other). My memory might be flawed but I believe they met through musical theater classes.
So sweet how you see them moved emotionally even though they don’t understand the language of the lyrics. But they certainly got the essence of its meaning
They are quite astute in their descriptions and their understanding of the emotions being portrayed and the hard work involved. Music truly is universal.💕
I loved watching their faces and posture change as they listened; they weren't just hearing it, they were feeling it! Music is indeed a universal language. Thank you for sharing this!
This is by far one of my favorite youtube channels I have found. As a musician, this makes me happy. As a human being, it makes me proud that at least one thing we do can bring people from across the world together, even if just for the duration of one song. Please keep making these videos. These are amazing people you bring on here, and I love to see their reactions and hear their insightful words.
I love Pentatonix and the first time hearing this I was overcome with emotion. It is so beautiful to me how even without the translation a few of the tribal members were moved to tears by this beautiful song
l listen to this song regularly and cry everytime and seeing these people being moved even without understanding the words shows how powerful this version is.
Now hit them with a vocal rendition of Bohemian Rhapsody, with all it's various beats and rythyms.... I'd love to see their response. They all impressed me with their responses, but something with more variety would surely cause more discussion.
I loved all their reactions, it was so moving. The one that fascinated me the most was the gentleman with the white beard....the intensity at which he was watching facial expressions, body movements along with concentrating on the sensation the music was evoking. He appeared to be the most 'still' yet his eyes were so expressive. A real pleasure to watch these lovely people experiencing this particular music presentation.
I’m always inspired by how kind, thoughtful and insightful this group of people are when viewing new and different things. Thank you for making such uplifting content. Blessings to you all 🙏🏻
This song always gets me. I can barely listen to it without crying. To see how people from all walks of life feel you music, now that’s something beautiful❤️
Yes! Agreed! This song especially sung by them always shakes my soul! And then adding in their genuine reactions to it. Just seriously made my heart burst woth love and joy!
I love how they give their full attention to the music you present. What a lovely song for them to listen to, though if you do show them the original, it might be a tough time translating parts of it, especially for our Hindu ladies who might not understand the Old Testament references.
Im an australian and it was very interesting to hear how you all reacted to this song, It showed me how little we really understand about others ways of life. I loved it! I also loved that you can enjoy such a beautiful song and voice!
I love them all! As an European, we so often forget how important and enlightening is the thought process in other cultures and ways of life. E.g. Mohammad and Abdul both made comments so deep and special, I'm genuinely moved and humbled by their insight. Like the fact that it needs like-minded people, with the same frequency of breathing, to harmonize so well together. Or the thought about their teacher. These may seem rather "simple" thoughts, but they're incredibly deep and multi-faceted, if you think about it. I'm a pentaholic, but today I'm blown away by these Pakistani people. I love them truly.
There really is a universal capacity in music that transcends culture. These people, who didn't grow up with acapella or Hallelujah were able to analyze the performance and connect deeply with the song even without a translation. It's very moving to watch
interpreted i think you meant that took me afew tries to realize what you were trying to say. i'm slow sometimes but interested is not the right word. :) hope you dont mind me saying that. its not meant to be offensive just helpful!
There's a real good reason Hallelujah is the most covered song of all time isn't there? Its just so powerful every time! Might I recommend Bohemian Rhapsody or just Queen in general for a new music genre if you haven't already? Freddies talent has always blown me away
Ummmm they have no teacher. They arrange their own versions of songs and have their own music. They have a producer but they do their own arrangements. THATS how talented they are.
They are a nice group of people! Different but all have their own special ways of looking at things! I am especially fond of Parvati. She is shy, smart and talented!
He felt the pain in Mitch’s verse and that is why we sing. That’s why we make art. I really hope Mitch knows how much he means to all the tenors out there who are afraid to use their voice!
It's a pure pleasure to see how everyone was touched by this song. The lady was brought to tears. Everyone felt that and they enjoyed it. Thank you friends 💓
Amazing video, when the elder started to sing along it hit me hard, I feel humans are here to care an love an to look out for each other but over all the years we were lead in the wrong direction with wrong leaders we all need to come together as one and then and only then will there be peace and happiness. Love and respect all life.
Music is such a universal language. I'm so happy that even without a translation they could feel the mood behind the song and some even caught the reference to God. I'm also impressed by their focus on what they're watching. It's very enjoyable to watch them absorb the different aspects of the performance. Hopefully you'll introduce them to more and let them be impressed by some of the more rhythm heavy songs that Pentatonix has released. Actually, I hope Pentatonix get to see this video. I'm sure they would love it.
I am a Pentaholic (person who can not get enough of Pentatonix) who has loved this group for over 10 years now. I have always thought they do a great job expressing the feelings well by their sound and faces. This shows me how right it is. 3 of these guys have been friends all of their life. Their time together and love of music has produced a group that has done over 200 songs. I hope you get to see some of their happier songs too. 💕🤗😎
Outstanding! I like 'Pentaholic' very much as a descriptor. My taste runs more toward Home Free, and we consider ourselves 'Home Fries' because we can't get enough of their voices.
“ soft yet intense performance“ I loved watching the reactions to this very intense and beautiful version of Leonard Cohen song. Pentatonix is such a fabulous a cappella group.I think the group members would be touched by seeing how well they communicated.
I enjoyed this so much. I salute the participants for their willingness to engage in something unfamiliar and offer their earnest thoughts on it. Their reactions remind us that our humanity binds us, even when religion separates us.
It’s so great to see how in people’s initial reaction to this, they notice and consider the effort, training, and skill that have taken place to make it possible. That seems very pure to me.
My four year old grandson and I listened to this song. I commented that it was so beautiful it gave me goosebumps. A few weeks later we heard it again. My grandson asked if I had chicken pox. I replied, "No sweetie. Why would you think that?" "Grandma, don't you remember? You said this song was so pretty it gave you chicken pox!"
This channel is so moving. The listeners are so open and ready to engage … my eyes are just a little wet watching them talk. What a wonderful thing to see. Thank you.
They’re all so wise. Their culture is very spiritually in-tune with reality. I could sit and listen to them talk about how there are deeper layers to what Pentatonix just did together in that song. Haha.
In "Man of Constant Sorrow" one of the members makes the sound of a Harmonica, with out an Harmonica!!! Truly amazing. This is my favorite song from Home Free.
I was taken aback when he said that. Then I realized he was using the word in a different way. It wasn't unnatural in a negative way. It was "not earthly" the music was affecting him (as music affects us all) in an unearthly way. This video shows how music lifts us to higher levels. We function day to day, moving along roads we build to keep us within natural boundaries and normal experiences but Acapella and powerful songs like "Hallelujah", take us to a different highway, without all the natural sounds and instruments that dictate the count, the key, or the style. Sorry if this makes no sense. I'm sure someone else can explain it better.
@@chachyesmeralda18 Yes. I thought he meant unnatural I'm n a negative way, then I realized he meant supernatural as in spiritual. This just proves music is universal.
Well he's not wrong.. It's a very polished and plastic like version of the song. Autotune shines bright here, to put it that way. Not that there's necessarily anything wrong with any of those things. Maybe he's complex enough to like the song as such, and still pick up on the "unnaturalness," of this specific recording of it?
@@HansenFT Autotune?? Do you know anything at all about this group? Their videos/recorded material actually can’t capture what it’s like to hear them live - 100% real. Check out their live performances, including the competition show that launched their careers when they were just babies. I get it, though…upon hearing them, the natural first thought is certainly, “This can’t be real.” But, it is❤️
@@jeanniebuck4193 I heard something like a vocoder. Anyway the audio surely is processed. Probably the man is used to non-amplified, live music and he detects the difference.
That was one of the most amazing things I have ever seen. I am now looking for the video where they learn the meaning of the song. I want to also see Pentatonix reacting this video! Thank you for sharing this.
![Eminem - Fuel (feat. JID) [Official Lyric Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/t5H_CewqpKA/mqdefault.jpg)
Unblocked version: ruclips.net/video/p69c0xBRVhY/видео.html
Have them react to this singer.. 1 man doing a duet..
ruclips.net/video/x462Hia_7hU/видео.html
Why are you showing these people absolute shite musicians?
well, i guess it's better you're doing this than scamming old white people in a call center...
@@alistairmurray626 Why are you watching videos where they show new music to people?
@@TRYBALS i was hoping it was good music, you may have well just sang the wheels on the bus to them. That would have been better, can you do that video?
The man in the white lace cap has music in his soul. He couldn't help wanting to sing with them. That was beautiful.
I kept thinking "that's me!", embarrassingly off-tune but feeling it!
I know...it made me tear up watching him feeling the music and wanting to join along 😊
Yes, I agree. It is vague in my memory. I somehow subconsciously remember the guy with the white hat. (The song is beautiful.)
Love seeing their reaction.Their all feeling it,the power of music
Great music and singing no matter where its from will always touch somewhere inside and move you,ive listened to Mongolian throat music native American Songscapes and been in tears at how powerful it was...this isn't my favourite version of Hallelujah but its a damn good one
When she said "they're praising God" I was so moved. Music is such a beautiful universal language.
I think the word Hallelujah, or something like, it is fairly universal. It is thought that the word is an onomatopoeic imitation of ululation which is a common expression of joy in various cultures.
And she was right on, too, since "hallelujah" means "praise God".
@@thossi09 Well the song is actually about romantic love and uses religion as a metaphor, but you're right about the word itself.
Hallelujah is Hebrew. Hallel = praise. Hallelu = we praise. Hallelujah = we praise God.
@@Evija3000 yeah this song in particular is not actually religious one of the lyrics actually says they are not sure if they is a god but it's irrelevant to what they are feeling.
“We discover new things and make new friends every time here.” That line literally teared me up.
me too ❤
I am so humbled by the response of these tribal people. they seem so open and appreciative. For years I sang complex harmonies in a band and it is alot of work and truly magical. wonderful to see and hear all of this, brings tears to my eyes. ❤
I agree whole-heartedly. I posted the below on the "Hurt" video on this channel. More people should see the world through other's eyes..
This is my 4th video I've watched, and just subscribed to the channel. Watching these videos has struck me in a profound way. I'm a 60 year old farmer in North Texas, and I tell everyone I know about this channel, even if they won't watch it. Much like the Tribal people here, in rural Texas, you can be isolated from the rest of the world in many ways, but most importantly in a cultural sense. I've that individual humans throughout the world where much like me, our feelings about war, hate, love, joy, are much the same, but we don't get that from news stories, movies, etc. What we get is what our leaders and the media want us to see, to portray other countries people in either a negative light, or a positive one, depending on the political relationships between us.
After watching several of the videos, I feel a kinship with these people, because I see them for who they are, what they find confusing, funny or beautiful, and I see in them people around me that would be saying the same things, just in a different language.
Years ago, when the Internet first came into being, I had high hopes that it would break down these artificial walls separating us from the rest of humanity, but in the years since, I've grown to think it just made things worse, that we still couldn't communicate with others, we just see what our "leaders" want us to see, and I despaired of it.
This is what the internet was meant to be, in its purest form. I thank you for creating this content, keep up the good work, and I hope there is a way that these people can know the affect getting to know them, their true selves, has on others. Again, thank you!
He was really feeling it and truly appreciated the singing.
As do we
The elder gentleman appeared unmoved during the whole performance, when in reality he was analyzing every minute detail about it and resolved with great appreciation and understanding.
I found he was totally involved. With his mind. Loved seeing his mind work so intelligent!
He seems to me to be what they would consider an Elder, very much respected and reserved. He is definitely a man who observes and thinks before he speaks.
He's wise enough not to be taken along with the waves but learn to understand what he's seeing
You nailed it!
Intense focus often looks perplexing to onlookers
Proof that music, when done right, can transcend all ages and cultures.
Good music don'e right needs no translation you can feel it in your soul.
Namjoon agrees wholeheartedly. Music definitely transcend all ages and cultures...and borders/boundaries. 💜🎶
IKR! That's why I love Hallelujah so much. Its raw emotion can be felt no matter the language!
@@shannonmcelroy8454 it’s true. I also love Hallelujah. The way they made this indeed captured some emotions. A very intense performance of an equally intense piece of music.
It's not about the words sung, it's about how the music touches the soul
I love that the oldest guy cited their music teachers as being important and he called this a type of education. The arts are SO IMPORTANT to education in general and society as a whole
Yes! Without art, we lose our humanity. We lose our ability to reach out and connect with other humans in ways that transcend time and place.
Absolutely 💯
Never thought I would agree with such a statement, but on reflection so true. One of the sure ways we can advance as a civilization.
The others clearly enjoyed it but you can see the elder is viewing it on a deeper level.
@@bendadestroyer Absolutely! I was awestruck how he processed all this! Awesome channel, BTW
Honestly this was a bit emotional to watch. Seeing everyone just FEEL this song without knowing the story or lyrics.... It's truly something special.
Well done Leonard Cohen
Yes! I cried and cried. Watching them lean in or get curious, or moved to sing themselves. Really great.
Exactly. It got to them. Seeing their emotions without knowing the language and what it was about, that was powerful.
@@chandab5063 🙂
Totally agree
Oh, she FELT it! She teared up! And she didn't even know why....she just felt it. Amazing!
She felt the men, she only smiled when they sang, not so much the women.. read the room dude..
Seek help
@@Cent512
@@Cent51 get over yourself
The man right before her as well, can tell it hit pretty hard. 08:14
As a music teacher, this vid is such a powerful tool to show students how music transcends language, culture, grievances and disagreements. Music can connect us all as spiritual humans! 👍
Such a good video to show
And this is why it's important to keep Music & the Arts in schools!
I sing with an acapella choir. It's lead by a natural voice practitioner, one basic principle of the movement is that its a right/need for humans to connect and bond through singing in harmony.
I totally agree with you!
And indeed it does!
When Mozart was asked, “What is your favorite instrument?” He replied simply, “The Voice”.
The greatest! ❤️
And then he wrote one of the most challenging vocal pieces in the history of opera to showcase that.
It was only when I started listening to music not in my native language that I began to appreciate that
Blake was fantastic on that show!
Word!
love how she wiped a tear away - we are all equally human
Surely there is a better way to put this that doesn't sound like you didn't think she was human before she wiped a tear away 🥴
@@elissamarcus that interpretation is on you honey
@@elissamarcus think it through. your post. cultural differences separate us. the arts is the driving force that brings us together, an equal appreciation through those barriers. that's how i interpreted her post. unless, of course, we are looking for someone to be offended by today.
I loved when one of the ladies in the beautiful dresses said they are praising the Lord after the chorus.
If she is giving the opportunity to be in your country with all the developments and technology,just imagine how smart and intelligent she would have comes out
They all were so expressive while watching and listening. The man who was singing along, the man leaning in closer, the ladies tearing up, and the man with the white beard and turban who didn't move a muscle but was transfixed. And they heard their own culture's music in this, and could compare and understand, even without understanding the language. Music is its own language.
⁰
@@stephaniewilliams6289 wrong.
Turban guy wasn't transfixed, he was repulsed by these western singers. Especially the "painted lady with her naked face exposed". And then he couldn't help but make it about him "DON'T FORGET ABOUT THEIR TEACHER!" In his world, it's not possible for people to learn skills without giving time and money to an old charlatan.
@@TigerGreene ...what?
@@gazelle_diamond9768 ... WHAT??
I loved the woman’s reaction. She cried and touched her heart. She truly felt the power of the music to her heart. Beautiful
and yet when they were both asked what they thought....they said 'interesting'....LOL
@@KitchenWitchery I believe they were hedging their response to a male...that was interesting
@@universaldonor3100 Agree! I thought it was because they are afraid of saying the wrong thing too. I doubt that there are any women on the production team, to me, and based on my experience of these situations in this culture, they are probably afraid.
VIP
@@beatdizzy True, It's obvious that one girl was clearly romantically infatuated by the first man's singing. She even brings up more than once how she liked seeing him beat his chest, which is a very masculine gesture. No doubt she had to restrain herself do to her upbringings.
It's amazing that, even without the translation, they could feel the emotion behind the song. I love Pentatonix and this is one of my favorite covers. I'm glad you shared the group with everyone.
Correct.. the expression Hallelujah literally means "praise Jah!"..( Jah is the shortened form of God of the bibles name Jehovah/Yehowah = YHWH)..so is its base
oops wrong thread
Its a universal human nature. A song played in a slow minor cord brings sadness example Chopins Funeral March, a speed up minor cord causes anxiety example the Michael Myers Halloween movie theme song, a song played in a major cord brings joy example The Happy Birthday song, a sped up major can bring laughter goofyness like That Benny Hill tune.
I was thinking that too. It’s a beautiful thing!
The one lady was even wiping tears away...that's when you know you have something special...they have no idea what the meaning is, but they felt it inside them enough to bring out the emotions in them
can we just take a moment to appreciate how beautiful everyone in this video is? everything from their eloquence to their disposition to their garments. I would love to know more about them!
I could not agree more. This is just a beautiful video altogether. I would love for us all to live in peace and learn from one another. There is so much out there that we don’t even see.
E x a c t l y ..... what a wonderful group of people.... stunning in their reactions, stunning in their clothes, stunning in their beauty. I simply loved this video and the whole concept. Music and sound is universal.
Yes wealthiest people.of India here. Just like Kim Kardashian and Brad Pitt.
Yes! reaching across cultures and borders like this is the only thing that will save our world. I would so love to spend an evening eating dinner with them and getting to know them.
Yes! It's a beautiful world! There's also a song which lyrics are the same words. If only we all agree to it. Stop the wars, stop the hatred, stop the bigotry, stop evil! ✋love one another, but most of all love and worship the MOST HIGH CREATOR, ETERNAL, FORCE of the universe everyone calls GOD, there's only ONE. No other!!
The man with the white cap truly has a musicians soul. It seems regardless of genre or band he connects with the music on a borderline spiritual level, absolutely facinating to watch
The gentleman who began singing with them made me so happy. Then there were the 2 people who teared up from the song even without having the translation yet. Music is such a powerful thing.
The exact same reaction about him from me. He really loved it.
5:09 You know you’re doing it right when someone hears you sing “and love is not a victory march, it’s a cold and it’s a broken hallelujah,” and decides it’s a sad song even though they don’t understand the words.
And that's when I started tearing up and nodding. This song always touches me, but hearing it transcend language was so poignant. 🥺❤
This brokenness touched me after the sudden death of my mother and my only son. 💔❤️ Where to find Hallelujah?
@@charanewman1434 God bless you
@@charanewman1434 Oh Chara, so sorry to read your comment.
@@charanewman1434 Music helped me a lot to deal with 3 major loss of my family members. crying and yet still trying to sing through the tears anyway
When the man in the red cap sat up close, his face looked so sweet, it made my heart smile...and the women were brought to tears. They got it... beautiful music always gets through❤️🙏
This song gets everybody. 😆😭
Amanda Downing. I think that you were really on to something here: if we took the time to really look into most peoples’ faces for more than just a moment, we would see their sweetness and beauty. We would connect with them differently. There are people out there that are doing research on this. Researchers find that if they ask people to sit and face each other in close proximity, and say nothing while they look at each other’s faces for two minutes, that they connect with each other on an emotional level, and some will have tears on their cheeks.
Considering the fact that you figured this out without a researcher, you might be interested in looking at their findings. There could even be more to this.
@@daphneraven6745 I may just do that...thank you for your insight☺️
That it does. I sing and play a couple of instruments (but nowhere near professional quality) and it does affect people. I was in a singing group that did a few performances in nursing homes, and even the patients who were not alert and oriented (as we say in nursing) loved the music. 🎵🎶🎼
When I was hospitalized in San Francisco (CPMC), they had a music therapy program. A harper played a lap harp in my room for half an hour. I felt like a Lady being serenaded in her manor. My soul just soared. I didn't notice pain, and that says something.
I noticed his inner peace also
I’m a classically trained musician. I received my degrees and my formal training and have learned how to express and explain music in educational settings and beyond. It is simply beautiful to watch blind reactions of music they’ve never heard before and explain their understanding of the music’s expressions. It’s universal. Goosebumps the entire time. Makes me absolutely giddy to watch this. Please make more videos like these! They connect us all ❤
u sure about that? lol
❤
There’s something very touching about being able to connect with another culture through a shared love of beauty. It’s like making a connection with our shared humanity. If we did more of this there would be a lot more peace in the world.
Amen, sister. We are all of the One. Music is the universal language. A capella is pure. I felt the Oneness with these, my brothers and sisters.
Amen!!!!
Real beauty is in the eyes (ears) of everybody.
Amen
Yes!!
This just proves that Music can break down any borders even without understanding the lyrics it still speaks to the soul
isnt this song about fappin
I would agree. No matter the language we are able to vibe with songs in mostly the correct manner. Energy is infectious
Foreign music can (and definitely is) enjoyed by many! But! I loveeee it when the songs lyrics and also the FEELING of the song is translated so perfectly to someone who doesn’t know the language, it breaks such a large barrier and a culture barrier
music is the sole universal language of the world
I agree..
It's amazing to watch people wipe away tears when hearing the emotion in a song even when not knowing the language! (I have a few on my face also)
I had the same reaction when hearing Faouzia sing Arabic runs in her cover of Desert Rose by Sting. I cried immediately.
If you haven't heard her then please look her up. She's amazing!
Everyone knows what hallaluja means
Me, too, dear one 🥲
@@Jen.V843 that song is awesome
EVERYTIME I listen to this song by Pentatonix the goosebumps and body chills get stronger as the song goes on and by the end I FEEL those words in my soul and just cry. So much more powerful than the original!
The man with the white beard was like a wise man, carefully studying everything in the minutest of details, he is profound. I love the fact that despite not knowing the language to understand the lyrics, these people could feel the beauty in the song. I love this RUclips Channel❤❤❤
I love that Muharam was so taken / carried by the music that he was singing along with them ❤ Mohammad and Abdul Aziz are so insightful....wise men, ustads themselves
I can’t believe how emotional they got without even Knowing the lyrics or the meaning. This song simply speaks to your soul
Amen! the tears run every time i listen to it. This song was meant for the soul.
Yep I cried. Again.
Every song I have ever loved from different genres has that one basic component of being able to stir the soul. If it moves me to tears it's going to be music I love all my life.
@@redbarret123 this song is about mastur bay shon
@@ethelb6237never liked it.
Judging by the sophistcated opinions of the listeners, I was impressed by how deeply they analyzed what they had heard. They are some highly intelligent people.
Its a major part of many pre industrial civilization music is hugely important in maintaining social harmony
The last man's summation was spot on. He really understood the tremendous work involved!
@Rick Boozer, why are you surprised at their intelligence?
@@sandra-jones Not surprised. Admiring.
@Tesla Maven thank you for your response; however, the question was directed towards @Rick Boozer.
I like that the elder in the white lace cap began to sing along. He didn't even know what the words meant, but the vocals and the tones managed to touch, as I saw someone else say, 'He has music in his soul.' The man with the colorful beard and the smaller beard, I could tell he was starting to choke up. And one of the ladies actually had tears. I find it amazing that all of them seem to catch the feeling of sadness, and they didn't even understand a word.
This reaction brought tears to my eyes. I love how music does not know borders, language, cultures, it just touches your soul. What else is needed?
This
I wish I could hit the like button more than once. Absolutely this! ❤
Nothing else is needed, my friend.
I realised just how important music is after I had a baby. Little brand new babies who know nothing of the world, they can't even see properly yet, but they respond to music.
Yes!!!
The last line in this vid: "Everyone should be like minded to create such kind music" is so beautiful. I think music binds us all. When Pentatonix sings, they sing so beautifully because they're so in unison. Love it ♥️
I would argue that instead, it is diversity of perspective that allows such an incredible variety of music to exist. That said, I agree... to craft music is to create something of beauty, be that the thunder and violence of rock, or the soothing calm of a hymn. The world needs more music.
Ķ
@Haariet Ward, it is? 🤔 I don't believe it. How dare they ban music anyway? 😤😤😤
@Haariet Ward It is all relative to other cultures and religion. I don't judge. People should be free to worship as they choose. You can not look at the mid east or east with western views/culture because it is very different.
@Haariet Ward I find it's Occident that bans art more often than not. Occident religions, particularly
@ the 4:45 mark when she said “they’re praising the Lord” that stirred my soul and made me happy inside! I love it! Hallelujah! 😊
Well she’s wrong, because this song isn’t about praising the lord.
@@RachelJane101 The words Hallelu means praise and Jah is God so even though they were talking about Samson & Delilah, they were in fact praising God in the chorus.
@Eugene Bell, yes, the women understood.
@@HighlandBound I know what the word means. My point is, the Hallelujahs in this song are not praising any gods. This song isn’t praising God. This song is about romantic love, lust, sex, disappointment, a breakup, ultimately hope for romantic love, and also questioning the existence of a god. Pentatonix omitted the raciest verse with a Hallelujah that is specifically in regards to experiencing an orgasm.
@@RachelJane101 The song is about the betrayal of Samson by Delilah through the use of her feminine wiles and charms. The words are many times altered somewhat but if you think this is all about an orgasm then I think you might need to expand your reportiore a bit. I might also add that there is to be considered the betrayal of God by Samson, which is ultimately a deeper, more profound sadness than that of a man and a woman. Samson, even after betraying God still prevailed over his enemies after having his hair cut and his eyes put out and so the praise goes only to God for making that happen. Hallelujah.
I'm a grown man and I shed many tears watching this one. Wow. The reactions are just as good as the song itself. You know music is a gift from God to creation when that lady mentioned "they are praising God"
I really like that you included the link to “ Tirri Pawanda” by Allan Fakeer! I hadn’t heard that song before. It made it feel more like a cultural exchange-the Trybals hear popular American music, and we hear their popular music-instead of just handing the Trybals American media and watching them react to it. I feel much more connected, as if we’re hanging out and exchanging our favorite songs together. Please do more exchanges like this if you can!
Yes sure, that's the mission of course. The variation of cultures we all have to share is just beautiful and could be seen like different colors in a rainbow.
I've not seen this channel before. What open intelligent people you've brought together. My respect to them, opening up to experience different and unfamiliar music.
This is the thing I wish people knew on a cellular level.
When you travel the World and experience different cultures and beliefs we are much more alike than we are different.
And Many other countries have Much better educational systems.
This is Humanity.
My thoughts as well. Love seeing them
I couldn't think of the words myself but apon reading yours it is just what I wanted to say. They are are important people to have in our world and it is satisfying to watch and listen to them.
These tribal folks aren't dumb. You don't last long in that world if you're dumb. They're maybe not what we'd call "well-educated," but they are
NOT
stupid.
That song gives me chills every time. Leonard Cohen was trying to express how many different people have many different ‘hallelujah’ moments in life. I can’t remember how many different verses he wrote for his original song but other people also wrote a church version of hallelujah with his permission.
81 verses that we know of.
It’s a breakup song. Every verse is a different aspect of the end of a relationship.
For some reason I have always felt like it was about unwanted loss....like of a relationship or losing a love one unexpectedly. Always sad though, never in a joyful way.
I believe Cohen said this was his favorite cover of this song
Agreed. Goosebumps...every. single. time.
@@riffhammeron, not to take anything away from the Pentatonix cover, but Cohen was dying from Leukemia in October 2016 when their cover was released, and passed the beginning of November so I'm doubtful Cohen heard the cover. He did state that K.D. Lang's cover was his favorite. She sung it at a Summer Olympics and a tribute to Cohen.
This was a special one. Folks who don't even speak the language felt it. They're all super special souls. I wish them smiles and good tears.
It’s a song about a sexual relationship gone wrong. Seriously?
@@Sheepdog1314If you listen to music and know anything about it, like most art, the viewer, or listener takes from it what filters through their own experience. It's never just ONE message or meaning.
"Hallelujah" in any language is a VERY powerful and deeply significant word.
Amen.
The Muslim or Arabic version is 'alhamdulillah' and like you said it's indeed powerful!
@@beastvader I don't know Hebrew but Alhumdulliah is an extremely powerful and spiritual word. You're seem to have matched the meanings well. Always sensed that Hallelujah was an equally spiritually charged and powerful word.
@@user-et2ng1qb2m hallelu means praise, no j in Hebrew it should be yah (יְהֹוָה). Yah is short for YeHoVaH. The God of Israel.
A joyous praise in song, to boast in God. 🙏
Leonard Cohen was such a class act... RIP, such a legend... Pentatonix did him proud with this version
Great reaction guys!!
@itsme Emma who was the first?
@itsme Emma he wrote it!
@itsme Emma Cohen actually was the first to record it in 1984 on his album "Various Positions", but from what I remember it was on an independent label and sold only in Canada. John Cale recorded it in 1991 on his album "I'm Your Fan", so I guess he would be the first after Cohen. The guy who really brought this song into the limelight was Jeff Buckley IMO.
I shed a tear every time I hear Cohen version and they definitely have made him proud
Was so lucky to see Leonard Cohen sing this in Boston in his last tour, on his knees…it was indescribably beautiful….I love hearing this version and these lovely people reacting!
I love Mr. Muharam singing along with them. The joy on his face every time he listens to music is just so great. 💛
At 8:53 " I mean everyone that was creating different sounds, all different sounds become one eventually "
Such simple yet beautiful, powerful words by the lovely woman. It's like her consciousness is on the frequency of love.
I have fallen in love with each one of these people. Watching them experience and learn new things about our world warms my heart. I wish I could return the happiness they have given me. Thanks for the great content, from California.
Me too.
But you can. We all can. We can all be kinder to the strangers among us, every day.
Less kindness is almost never the right answer.
SAME! Lol, Reading the subtitles makes it REALLY hard to multi-task.
I feel the same way.
Hey as you're providing context to the lyrics in the future, here are some notes:
Hallelujah is Hebrew in origin. It means Praise Jah. Jah is a short form for Jehovah, the name of the God of the Bible who created of the world. For example, the name Jesus means "Jah is salvation" in Hebrew. The Bible teaches that Jesus was the first creation of Jehovah, to be clear. Many people use Hallelujah as an expression meaning "thanks to God" or "Thank God".
But, this song actually uses the term Hallelujah ironically and almost atheistically. I wrote a term paper analysis of the lyrics in college.
Part of Cohen's lyrics expose the hypocrisy of religious violence ("Maybe there's a God above, but all I've ever learned from Love was how to shoot somebody who outdrew ya"). The Bible at 1 John 4:8 says "God is Love" and the "Love" in that lyric is referring to God. Many soldiers and armies falsely claim that God is with them.
Cohen's lyrics suggest he did not believe that love really exists. His lyrics makes reference to the Bible story of Samson and Delilah, where Delilah betrayed her husband Samson, an Israelite leader divinely empowered with superhuman strength, by shaving his head while he slept and then turning him over to foreign enemies for a bribe of 1000 silver coins. His forever-uncut hair had been the symbol of his dedication to God and conditional to his receiving superhuman strength through angelic assistance. He died as a result of her betrayal. ("She tied you to a kitchen chair, she broke your throne and she cut your hair")
The previous lyrics "You saw her bathing on the roof, her beauty and the moonlight overthrew ya" make reference to the adultery of King David of ancient Israel, who saw a beautiful married woman from his palace window bathing at night and he seduced her, conceiving a child with her while she was married to another man. He then had her husband Uriah killed to conceal their adultery. David got nothing but trouble from his actions, including later in life when his son tried to kill him and take his throne. David composed many songs, including songs asking God for forgiveness. That's where the opening lyric "They say there was a secret chord, that David played and it pleased the Lord" is from.
The song's lyrics basically bemoan a lack of genuine love and loyalty between people and advances Cohen's cynical view that true, selfless love does not really exist. All of those thoughts are punctuated by the phrase Praise Jah (Hallelujah) as a cynical and sarcastic giving of thanks to God. In Cohen's view, thanks for nothing. Cohen was born Orthodox Jewish but did not hold to his faith. Over the years, he experimented with Buddhism, agnosticism and other philosophies. His lyrics are deep and full of meaning, for sure.
Thanks for sharing your insights, very interesting! :)
Although he meant it as "thanks for nothing" (as you say), that powerful phrase "thank Jehovah or thank God" overtakes Cohen's meaning and everyone feels the worship that transcends.
Thank you for sharing, your analysis was a treat to read.
Thanks for your reply. I just wanted to correct one thing. Absolom (David's son who rebelled against him) was not Bathsheba's son. The son that was conceived in adultery actually took ill and died in infancy. David married Bathsheba and her next son was Solomon who ascended to the throne as the chosen heir of David (but not his oldest son).
So basically a bitter song from someone who hasn't figured out love.
Lakshmi is lovely to watch! She's so expressive, I can see she really connected with the music
Speaking of Lakshmi, I couldn't help noticing that she and Pavarti have the same last name
Are they sisters??
@@karlsmith2570 , I think it was said that Lakshmi is Pavartis sister in law when they reacted to Heilung - Krigsgaldr.
Pavarti is pretty in her own right, but Lakshmi was straight up HOT!
@@jrdjr212 that's disrespectful! Don't talk about her or her sister like that! Saying Beautiful is more appropriate.
@@monicajean37 oh stop it! I was giving a compliment! Besides, "Hot" describes more than just beautiful. Many woman are beautiful. Many are Hot. Not all that are beautiful also have that "hotness" factor. Both these women are a perfect example. Both beautiful, but one has that something extra! Learn to take a compliment.
Heard this song so many times in many versions. I think it's arguably the most beautiful song ever composed.
No, not even close.
There is almost no version of this song that I’ve ever heard that didn’t make me cry.
Bouncing off clouds, fast car, Sia's anthems. This song is good but those are up there as well.
This very unexpectedly made me cry. I live in Montréal and Leonard Cohen is part of the city's soul. To see how it can touch people who don't even know the language just struck me to the heart, reminding me how blessed I am to be a singer.
To me their reaction is a tribute to Leonard Cohen's talent. Although they don't understand the words they feel the spirit of the music. I have been trying to explain to people that that is what Cohen's music does to me. It touches my spirit.
I’m sure he would have been so touched by their reaction.
I often get emotional with music as well. The first time I heard Pentatonix sing this song, I cried because it was so beautiful
the version shown in the video is horrible though. Cohens version is unbeatable
@Pryor Crossley r
I am so thrilled to see this and hopefully Pentatonix will see this as well. I love their "Mitch faces". Each one had a very different but strong reaction to his voice. This one of my favorite reactions to this video I have ever seen!! Thank you so much for doing this and the way that you did it not translating the song for them
I must admit seeing these people moved by music they’ve never heard, with words they can’t understand, made me a little emotional myself. It’s quite amazing how powerful music is.
I love the girls reaction. They are so sweet and it was very heart warming to see they were moved by the music even without knowing the full meaning of the words
I just discovered Pentatonix about 4 months ago (I'm American) Blown away by their talents. I think 3 of them have been together since high school! I cry every time I hear this song NO MATTER who covers it
I think the comment about the teacher would make them happy.
Then you are now a Pentaholic. Enjoy your trip down the rabbit hole. Their standards of bohemian rhapsody Imagine Amazing grace Are Good. My favorite is imagine because of the way they've Updated it with Pentatonix spin on it and how they deliver such a powerful message Themselves to go along with The powerful message in the song. They are known for their Christmas albums. This year's album ever green includes there cover of the Prayer which most people know Prayer which most people know celine Dion and Andrea Bocelli singing it. Since October 29 it has over 3,000,000 views. It is Pentatonix at The pinnacle
I always watch Pentatonix virgins, no matter who they are or what song they choose to listen to. But I love it when they choose this one because there's a good Mitch-slap in it.
@@lesaahrenstein6360 oh wow Thank You I'm gonna check it out they just make the soul feel good 👍
Scott, Mitch and Kirsten knew each other before high school. Since they were about 10 years old I believe (though that might have just been Scott and Mitch who were actually friends that young though they definitely knew each other). My memory might be flawed but I believe they met through musical theater classes.
I love the intensity of their concentration. Even without translation, they "got" the sense of the message.
I really loved hearing them recognize their own cultural music styles in this :) truly, there is nothing new under the sun
Leonard Cohen's musical heritage is fairly close to this lot
I love your Ecc reference.
So sweet how you see them moved emotionally even though they don’t understand the language of the lyrics. But they certainly got the essence of its meaning
Music: The language that needs no translation. Beautiful reaction to a beautiful song! ❤
4:13 the lady on the right side just looked down, bit her lips and smiled while Avi played his part. Such a sweet reaction :)
I saw that!!! I was like same girl. Haha
I saw that too! So cute
I noticed that too! So cute 🥰
Yea,. Cute. Lol. She wants that deep voiced man
I always have the same reaction 🥺🥺
They are quite astute in their descriptions and their understanding of the emotions being portrayed and the hard work involved. Music truly is universal.💕
I loved watching their faces and posture change as they listened; they weren't just hearing it, they were feeling it! Music is indeed a universal language. Thank you for sharing this!
It's interesting to see that the "Mitch slap" transcends culture and language...judging by their expressions :)
The man in the blue shirt is awesome and absolutely felt that in his soul! He was singing and grooving along.
Loved watching all of their reactions!
This is by far one of my favorite youtube channels I have found. As a musician, this makes me happy. As a human being, it makes me proud that at least one thing we do can bring people from across the world together, even if just for the duration of one song.
Please keep making these videos. These are amazing people you bring on here, and I love to see their reactions and hear their insightful words.
I love watching their faces as the music affects their emotions. They are such peaceful, happy people. We should learn from them. So beautiful.
I love Pentatonix and the first time hearing this I was overcome with emotion. It is so beautiful to me how even without the translation a few of the tribal members were moved to tears by this beautiful song
I cry every time I hear it. And yet I will listen to it over and over again and my husband will being me a box of puffs.
Idc if you're male or female, if this song doesn't touch your heart and make you emotional, then God hasn't found you
Seeing their reactions to the song how their expressions change. It's as if their souls understood the language that is music. Yes im crying
l listen to this song regularly and cry everytime and seeing these people being moved even without understanding the words shows how powerful this version is.
Now hit them with a vocal rendition of Bohemian Rhapsody, with all it's various beats and rythyms.... I'd love to see their response. They all impressed me with their responses, but something with more variety would surely cause more discussion.
Especially the part where they sing "Bismillah"... my Iranian husband is still trying to convince me of other things they are "probably" saying.
and Michael Jackson
Or Pentatonix's Daft Punk. It would blow their mind. 😄
This song always brings a tear to my eyes seeing the lady who didn't understand the lyrics but still cried proves how powerful the song is 😢😅
I loved all their reactions, it was so moving. The one that fascinated me the most was the gentleman with the white beard....the intensity at which he was watching facial expressions, body movements along with concentrating on the sensation the music was evoking. He appeared to be the most 'still' yet his eyes were so expressive. A real pleasure to watch these lovely people experiencing this particular music presentation.
100% agree with you ...
He truly gave the impression of being a scholar and a student :)
Yes,the man with the white beard and turban seemed to be a very wise man and the two women also seemed very nice Ladies.
I’m always inspired by how kind, thoughtful and insightful this group of people are when viewing new and different things. Thank you for making such uplifting content. Blessings to you all 🙏🏻
My goodness.the young woman was moved to tears by the beauty of the sound.this video is amazing I loved it
Tears here in Australia too my Lovely Ones - Every knee shall Bow and every tongue confess that JESUS Christ is LORD - All Praise Almighty GOD.
Not more than a prophet 🤏
This song always gets me. I can barely listen to it without crying. To see how people from all walks of life feel you music, now that’s something beautiful❤️
❤❤❤
Yes! Agreed! This song especially sung by them always shakes my soul! And then adding in their genuine reactions to it. Just seriously made my heart burst woth love and joy!
I love how they give their full attention to the music you present. What a lovely song for them to listen to, though if you do show them the original, it might be a tough time translating parts of it, especially for our Hindu ladies who might not understand the Old Testament references.
They might understand the Torah........the 1st 5 books in our bible are straight from the Torah.
They even sat forward more after the start... very lovely reaction to a very lovely song.
because they are lovely
It's a beautiful song and they correctly identify it as sad. The "Hallelujah" is ironic. It's a story of an old, broken man remembering failed love.
Im an australian and it was very interesting to hear how you all reacted to this song, It showed me how little we really understand about others ways of life. I loved it! I also loved that you can enjoy such a beautiful song and voice!
These folks are wonderful to watch. Purity in the way they listen.
I love them all! As an European, we so often forget how important and enlightening is the thought process in other cultures and ways of life. E.g. Mohammad and Abdul both made comments so deep and special, I'm genuinely moved and humbled by their insight. Like the fact that it needs like-minded people, with the same frequency of breathing, to harmonize so well together. Or the thought about their teacher. These may seem rather "simple" thoughts, but they're incredibly deep and multi-faceted, if you think about it. I'm a pentaholic, but today I'm blown away by these Pakistani people. I love them truly.
We love you too Alessandra 🤗
😭💚😁🇵🇰💯
There really is a universal capacity in music that transcends culture. These people, who didn't grow up with acapella or Hallelujah were able to analyze the performance and connect deeply with the song even without a translation. It's very moving to watch
I love how even without understanding the language they can feel they are praising the Lord❤
This song does not praise God. Look at the lyrics
I love how in tune they are with how they interested the song as opposed to how it really is... They were able to discern it's meaning quite well!!!
interpreted i think you meant that took me afew tries to realize what you were trying to say. i'm slow sometimes but interested is not the right word. :) hope you dont mind me saying that. its not meant to be offensive just helpful!
@@supposedly1-2 yes you're correct.. Silly autocorrect..
There's a real good reason Hallelujah is the most covered song of all time isn't there? Its just so powerful every time!
Might I recommend Bohemian Rhapsody or just Queen in general for a new music genre if you haven't already? Freddies talent has always blown me away
I love how they acknowledged the teacher of PTX. Music should be prescribed as medicine, no matter what part of the world you are from.
Ummmm they have no teacher. They arrange their own versions of songs and have their own music. They have a producer but they do their own arrangements. THATS how talented they are.
Agree! Singing it and feeling it.
@@prettygirlrene Certainly they’ve had teachers along the way, even if they do all their own arranging now.
@@prettygirlrene They still had to learn how to do all that.
They convey joy, and pain....without words. The best music expresses feeling without needing the words.
They are a nice group of people! Different but all have their own special ways of looking at things! I am especially fond of Parvati. She is shy, smart and talented!
He felt the pain in Mitch’s verse and that is why we sing. That’s why we make art. I really hope Mitch knows how much he means to all the tenors out there who are afraid to use their voice!
It's a pure pleasure to see how everyone was touched by this song. The lady was brought to tears. Everyone felt that and they enjoyed it. Thank you friends 💓
All of the participants' had such incredible insights. Their responses made me think more about the music. This was wonderful!❤❤❤
It's amazing how music can transcend language. Also, I love the older gentleman with the glasses. He always tries to sing along. He makes me happy.
Amazing video, when the elder started to sing along it hit me hard, I feel humans are here to care an love an to look out for each other but over all the years we were lead in the wrong direction with wrong leaders we all need to come together as one and then and only then will there be peace and happiness. Love and respect all life.
Stephen you are so right. More now than ever.
Music is such a universal language. I'm so happy that even without a translation they could feel the mood behind the song and some even caught the reference to God. I'm also impressed by their focus on what they're watching. It's very enjoyable to watch them absorb the different aspects of the performance. Hopefully you'll introduce them to more and let them be impressed by some of the more rhythm heavy songs that Pentatonix has released. Actually, I hope Pentatonix get to see this video. I'm sure they would love it.
the guy in the white lace hat is ADORABLE and I wish I could adopt him as my dad!
I adore seeing all the cast with traditional dress on! So lovely to see. 🥰
I am a Pentaholic (person who can not get enough of Pentatonix) who has loved this group for over 10 years now. I have always thought they do a great job expressing the feelings well by their sound and faces. This shows me how right it is. 3 of these guys have been friends all of their life. Their time together and love of music has produced a group that has done over 200 songs. I hope you get to see some of their happier songs too. 💕🤗😎
Outstanding! I like 'Pentaholic' very much as a descriptor. My taste runs more toward Home Free, and we consider ourselves 'Home Fries' because we can't get enough of their voices.
“ soft yet intense performance“ I loved watching the reactions to this very intense and beautiful version of Leonard Cohen song. Pentatonix is such a fabulous a cappella group.I think the group members would be touched by seeing how well they communicated.
I enjoyed this so much. I salute the participants for their willingness to engage in something unfamiliar and offer their earnest thoughts on it. Their reactions remind us that our humanity binds us, even when religion separates us.
It’s so great to see how in people’s initial reaction to this, they notice and consider the effort, training, and skill that have taken place to make it possible. That seems very pure to me.
This song gives me chills EVERY TIME.
My four year old grandson and I listened to this song. I commented that it was so beautiful it gave me goosebumps. A few weeks later we heard it again. My grandson asked if I had chicken pox. I replied, "No sweetie. Why would you think that?" "Grandma, don't you remember? You said this song was so pretty it gave you chicken pox!"
This channel is so moving. The listeners are so open and ready to engage … my eyes are just a little wet watching them talk. What a wonderful thing to see. Thank you.
I've cried ...happy tears ...with every one of them .... gives me hope the world isnt as broken as they make us think it is♡
They’re all so wise. Their culture is very spiritually in-tune with reality. I could sit and listen to them talk about how there are deeper layers to what Pentatonix just did together in that song. Haha.
Home Free “Man of Constant Sorrows “ depicts a wide range of their voices. Anything of theirs is amazing also.
In "Man of Constant Sorrow" one of the members makes the sound of a Harmonica, with out an Harmonica!!! Truly amazing. This is my favorite song from Home Free.
@@detrix42 Mine too.
@@detrix42 and don’t forget the jaw harp! Also very impressive, done by another member of the group.
@JRummy Or Oh Holy Night. But I think Do You Hear What I Hear would also be a great choice.
This was beautiful to watch. Even the guy that said “sounds unnatural” started leaning in.
I was taken aback when he said that. Then I realized he was using the word in a different way. It wasn't unnatural in a negative way. It was "not earthly" the music was affecting him (as music affects us all) in an unearthly way.
This video shows how music lifts us to higher levels. We function day to day, moving along roads we build to keep us within natural boundaries and normal experiences but Acapella and powerful songs like "Hallelujah", take us to a different highway, without all the natural sounds and instruments that dictate the count, the key, or the style.
Sorry if this makes no sense. I'm sure someone else can explain it better.
@@chachyesmeralda18 Yes. I thought he meant unnatural I'm n a negative way, then I realized he meant supernatural as in spiritual. This just proves music is universal.
Well he's not wrong.. It's a very polished and plastic like version of the song. Autotune shines bright here, to put it that way. Not that there's necessarily anything wrong with any of those things. Maybe he's complex enough to like the song as such, and still pick up on the "unnaturalness," of this specific recording of it?
@@HansenFT Autotune?? Do you know anything at all about this group? Their videos/recorded material actually can’t capture what it’s like to hear them live - 100% real. Check out their live performances, including the competition show that launched their careers when they were just babies. I get it, though…upon hearing them, the natural first thought is certainly, “This can’t be real.” But, it is❤️
@@jeanniebuck4193 I heard something like a vocoder. Anyway the audio surely is processed.
Probably the man is used to non-amplified, live music and he detects the difference.
That was one of the most amazing things I have ever seen. I am now looking for the video where they learn the meaning of the song. I want to also see Pentatonix reacting this video! Thank you for sharing this.