Cultural Christianity kills. Taking Blake's Christianity seriously. William on Jesus

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 28 сен 2024

Комментарии • 62

  • @jamesmcarthur4720
    @jamesmcarthur4720 2 месяца назад +2

    Breakfast with Mark this morning offered powerful and optimistic insights! Thankyou Mark.

  • @Jimboken1
    @Jimboken1 2 месяца назад +10

    Thanks for this.
    Blake is a mystic and remarkably visual in his thinking and imagination whilst for the vast majority of us, Christianity is just a set of rules that if followed lead to a happier life in this world and comfort in adversity. Additionally Christianity creates a civil society in which the mystic and the leading of a productive rewarding life can flourish. So the Christianity as a religion works for all of us.
    Blake seems full of awe and even excitement as he creates art by drawing or writing what he 'sees'. He sees the outer world as the dance of the Divine rather than 'reality'. The Bible helps him make sense of what he already ‘sees’.
    His naked wonder is itself wondrous as we can have no doubt that he is sincere and thoughtful.
    He'd have a absolutely no need of psychedelics!

    • @PlatosPodcasts
      @PlatosPodcasts  2 месяца назад +1

      Certainly agree with you on your last point. He also felt that vision is for all...

    • @555KL
      @555KL 2 месяца назад

      Blake was not a mystic.

    • @PlatosPodcasts
      @PlatosPodcasts  2 месяца назад +1

      @@555KL You’re right there’s been a big debate about that ever since Northup Frye said he was a visionary rather than a mystic. I think both terms have their uses and limitations…

    • @Jimboken1
      @Jimboken1 2 месяца назад

      @@555KL Only if you insist.

  • @Cat_Woods
    @Cat_Woods 2 месяца назад +10

    Why "Cultural Christianity kills"? There's nothing inconsistent with metaphorical and mythical usages, and there's nothing harmful in that, if so. I never heard of anyone killing someone else over metaphors, only doctrines taken literally.

  • @flow963
    @flow963 2 месяца назад +1

    Excellent vision Mark. It feels so right to me. Delightfully resonating, enchanting, Really, sublime transubstantiated from the all devouring many to the rectified One. Risen.

  • @sashahynds4917
    @sashahynds4917 2 месяца назад +3

    When will your book on William Blake be published? This was enlightening.

  • @richardbuckharris189
    @richardbuckharris189 2 месяца назад +2

    “Prisons are built with stones of Law, Brothels with bricks of Religion”
    ― william blake, The Marriage of Heaven and Hell

    • @randysmith5435
      @randysmith5435 2 месяца назад +1

      That quote freed me from religion many years ago.

  • @davnDaum
    @davnDaum 2 месяца назад +1

    Absolutely fascinating!!! Thank you!

  • @EbbandFlow1234
    @EbbandFlow1234 2 месяца назад +3

    Many faces of the same coin.
    Removing the beam from our own eyes.
    We make mistakes when stumble blindly ( And as wind we wind on down the road.
    Our shadows taller than our soul.. LZ)
    We are all blind, all of us. How do you know Till you know?
    He's asking for us to recoginise our own shadows, cast light on them and take responsibility for the projections we aim at others. Throwing stones. Using our
    tongues and thoughts as swords while standing in the shoes of the hypocrite. No compassion or empathy for eachother can be born from that stance. Towers remove it.
    No trick, just truth.
    Some sort of bridge.
    Animus/ Anima and the great divide. Hes teaching and showing them shes as equally important as they are, a human stumbling blindly.
    You know it coukd be used for the good but all they want to do is weaponise it.
    The imagination, the great eternal sea. The seat of the soul, cos people can fly 🗽
    ruclips.net/video/bUeMvc9LvRA/видео.htmlsi=43HnZR65_AHoDnYr
    " Therefore God becomes as we are"
    The creation of Adam by Micheal Angelo.

  • @birdthompson
    @birdthompson 2 месяца назад

    good to have you back!

  • @stevecallais1713
    @stevecallais1713 2 месяца назад

    wow. thankyou a wonderful video.

  • @BrentDavis75
    @BrentDavis75 2 месяца назад +6

    I'm epistemologically agnostic, but leaning towards metaphysical atheism. I was only ever exposed to evangelical Christianity, which I found off-putting -- the concept of eternal damnation will do that. I wonder what Blake made of the idea of a literal hell?

    • @ALavin-en1kr
      @ALavin-en1kr 2 месяца назад +7

      I agree with you on evangelical Christianity, it has not evolved from dark age concepts yet, when people were scared into behaving. I take Christianity as having to do with consciousness; Christ consciousness. We have human consciousness; awareness of being conscious beings with awareness of our immediate environment. Christ consciousness I take to mean being aware of the whole what is happening within and without in our immediate as well as a a distance. Cosmic Consciousness would mean Cosmic awareness. There is a lot on biological evolution but as consciousness is still ‘the hard problem’ little is known about it, or about mind; is mind elemental emerging with quantum events? We are moving away from a material age into an atomic age when inner forces; electricities; electromagnetism; magnetism, and eventually mind and consciousness will be better, if not fully, understood. Some of that understanding may not come until an age beyond the one on the horizon. That some may be already there is likely, not all evolve at the same time, or at the same pace.

    • @aronmarc5575
      @aronmarc5575 2 месяца назад

      ​@@ALavin-en1kr"Providence has given to the English the empire of the sea, to the French that of the land, to the Germans that of-the air."
      Ezekiel 36:26
      “A new heart also will I give you, and a new spirit will I put within you: and I will take away the stony heart out of your flesh, and I will give you an heart of flesh.”
      1 Corinthians 14:27-28
      King James Version
      27 If any man speak in an unknown tongue, let it be by two, or at the most by three, and that by course; and let one interpret.
      28 But if there be no interpreter, let him keep silence in the church; and let him speak to himself, and to God.
      AdaM👈riB👈Bir=TeSla
      TeSla🪞AlSeX🙃Tails
      3trisex69minD🎀BooTie 4🪱kin🪱 The Tails of Orion'🪱tiP iS NairLaSaiF👈 turn end poinT👉Remember🪞RedMeMer
      OgNam 🥭 iS A BoT orr Tree ♍️ SpiCaaCiqS and picken uP die ✌️ PieCeS☯️SacAid👈
      MariAMS🪞SmairAM waS TriB3SS3DirX tHat MaiD ProMiC3SS3CiMarQ
      🌎VVORD🪞Drov=Tribe
      aGaiN👈 noT from your WORD DiNaS'ehBreWWerdHe'SamiB inner OrrLeeAnnS CounTi Nu🍑Yok
      God iS Lite=NorA 👈Arc, Box
      god🪞baj👈 PolAriS👈 The Little Dipper =The Bager= AJaiN 💎Minner
      🐎👈HerAmeS👈SunArU👈ThE LesSon👈
      HEAVEN=UranuS👉 inn hebrew.
      The Sea of reD🪱=Hart👅👈staG deR VenisoN ❤️‍🔥, MaY German 🪜Art waS weeded for🪞rapH ShAron ImManuel Kant decipher 🌽hEar 🌽booK👈Uroc🌽 MaY 🥖buch🥖HpAol
      The Bread opH Life= LipHe = St.Eve= AronMarC👈 Möse 🐝 We77 Drawn uP🏗 Art 🎨 HE TypeSSeqiT gentileSSelitmap. COMPLETELY UPSIDE-DOWN and BaQword🙃QramDeep En Glish babelledad tunnelS☯️SlawNF

    • @beaanderson6488
      @beaanderson6488 2 месяца назад +4

      So you basically saying you don’t believe a God could exists or if there is a God we could not know it, and that you are leaning toward a belief that there is no supernatural or divine reality of any kind.
      But you are interested in eternal damnation… otherwise you would not ask Blakes view on hell, if he has any.
      Read William Blake, "The Proverbs of Hell"

    • @lazaruscomeforth7646
      @lazaruscomeforth7646 2 месяца назад +7

      Eternal hell has nothing to do with time. It is simply the state of mind of someone who embraces self over others, law over mercy, justice over grace. At death the person is simply what they are essentially in life, darkness and death and misery. Rejecting the eternal embracing light leaves one in the eternal lonely darkness.

    • @aronmarc5575
      @aronmarc5575 2 месяца назад

      @@lazaruscomeforth7646 Ezekiel 36:26
      “A new heart also will I give you, and a new spirit will I put within you: and I will take away the stony heart out of your flesh, and I will give you an heart of flesh.”
      AdaM👈riB👈Bir=TeSla
      TeSla🪞AlSeX🙃Tails
      3trisex69minD🎀BooTie 4🪱kin🪱 The Tails of Orion'🪱tiP iS NairLaSaiF👈 turn end poinT👉Remember🪞RedMeMer
      OgNam 🥭 iS A BoT orr Tree ♍️ SpiCaaCiqS and picken uP die ✌️ PieCeS☯️SacAid👈
      MariAMS🪞SmairAM waS TriB3SS3DirX tHat MaiD ProMiC3SS3CiMarQ
      🌎VVORD🪞Drov=Tribe
      aGaiN👈 noT from your WORD DiNaS'ehBreWWerdHe'SamiB inner OrrLeeAnnS CounTi Nu🍑Yok
      God iS Lite=NorA 👈Arc, Box
      god🪞baj👈 PolAriS👈 The Little Dipper =The Bager= AJaiN 💎Minner
      🐎👈HerAmeS👈 SunArU👈 ThE LesSon👈 iS A Fr33D MaiSon👈
      HEAVEN=UranuS👉 inn hebrew.
      The Sea of reD🪱=Hart👅👈staG deR VenisoN ❤️‍🔥, MaY German 🪜Art waS weeded for🪞rapH ShAron ImManuel Kant decipher 🌽hEar 🌽booK👈Uroc🌽 MaY 🥖buch🥖HpAol
      The Bread opH Life= LipHe = St.Eve= AronMarC👈 Möse 🐝 We77 Drawn uP🏗 Art 🎨 HE TypeSSeqiT gentileSSelitmap. Completely upside-down and HannAh CannA BaQword🙃QramDeep En Glish babelledad tuA tunnelS☯️SlawNF iNward🪞brown👁=Dunn orr Finnish GoSpeL ReWolF 4real📽Son
      🙃Showbiz
      🪜
      💦Siamgiz🪞SipMaiZ and 🐝 cum AsZ humorous as MaY StarSSratS

  • @kerwinbrown4180
    @kerwinbrown4180 2 месяца назад +2

    How do you kill the dead?

  • @ruthlewis673
    @ruthlewis673 2 месяца назад

    And so, I often find these kinds of talks, although interesting, illuminate no path, no direction. All very well, but then what. It may leave us feeling something is stirring within, but what?
    As Jung said, people will do anything other than look within. The inwatd journey takes us down before the assent, a fearful proposition for many.
    It's interesting that the interest in Jung has grown since Covid, where many were forced into self refection. In short listening to elevating discussions wont take you down. And the journey always begins with a fall.❤

    • @entitysix
      @entitysix 2 месяца назад

      How do we get to the place we fall from?

    • @ruthlewis673
      @ruthlewis673 2 месяца назад

      Start where you are.​@@entitysix

  • @theconservativeone2690
    @theconservativeone2690 2 месяца назад

    What do you think of sri aurobindo and mother

  • @Oskar-ey6jb
    @Oskar-ey6jb 2 месяца назад +1

    I wish mystics (Blake included), actually, virtually all thinkers, spoke more sensitively and coherently about the self and "self-annihilation" etc. We really need better language here. Self-expansion is qualitatively different from self-eradication, and any metaphor of death applied to the self should, in my opinion, be heavily heavily qualified or avoided completely. Clearly, a human being without a very robust sense of self is a pathological being, and to say that there is some form of identity between the discrete self and God also needs to be heavily heavily qualified, otherwise it could quickly lead to some schizoid escapism. It puzzles me that usually articulate people become strangely inarticulate and undelicate when it comes to this issue.
    Also, I find a lot of Blakeans completely ignore the primacy of Milton amongst Blake's influences. I'm not sure how Blake can even begin to be grasped without a good grasp of Milton, especially Paradise Lost. Milton's monism is quite unlike your run-of-the-mill mystical non-dualism, and as far as I understand, Blake thought of himself as Milton's successor. In my opinion, Milton actually performed what Romantics like Blake sought to do. For Milton, (His) imagination was indistinguishible from Divine Knowledge. Milton is still the greatest poet, and if we are reviving Blake, we must also revive Milton. Wordsworth called out for Milton, we should do the same.

    • @Xeper616
      @Xeper616 2 месяца назад +1

      I'm not sure why there needs to be sensitivity with the language used for the mystical experience. The metaphor of death is often used because the mundane identity is something which is utterly transcended in these moments of ecstasy, it is a powerful and apt way to get that point across.

    • @MegaPsychoticPanda
      @MegaPsychoticPanda 2 месяца назад

      The medical equivalent of self annihilation is Ego Death - identified as the demon Choronzon by Aleister Crowley.

    • @Xeper616
      @Xeper616 2 месяца назад +1

      @@MegaPsychoticPanda Choronzon is not ego-death, the demon of dispersion shouts "I am I", desperately clinging. The overcoming of Choronzon and giving one's self up to Babalon is what causes ego-death or to become a Babe of the Abyss.

  • @pencilpauli9442
    @pencilpauli9442 2 месяца назад +3

    Icons as windows of eternity.
    IMHO regarding a painting as a window is a western concept of a painting developed since the Renaissance with the reintroduction of perspective.
    Icons use a "reverse perspective" and give the impression of the painting projecting into our space, and as such the eternal is projected into the world.

  • @pocketfullofshellz
    @pocketfullofshellz 2 месяца назад +5

    These videos are extremely needed to all that listen

  • @AdmiringGardeningTools-dy2rz
    @AdmiringGardeningTools-dy2rz 2 месяца назад +2

    The 20th century Neville Goddard, " mystic" quotes Blake alot

  • @theomnisthour6400
    @theomnisthour6400 2 месяца назад +2

    It's an eternal refinement of all entities in the simulation multiverse, a self-sustaining family of virtual realities that accommodates all manner of Christs and Antichrists, and isolates them from those who would be perpetual Hobbits of a particular well-defined community.

  • @medicalmisinformation
    @medicalmisinformation 2 месяца назад +2

    More than anyone else you mentioned, St. Irenaeus emphasized this theosis by virtue of the Incarnation.

  • @soundscholar5408
    @soundscholar5408 2 месяца назад +4

    Love this, ive slightly been able to understand our imagination, it really seems divine, blake was probably spot on...

    • @mralexander99
      @mralexander99 2 месяца назад +1

      I think you are on to something and it is immersed with the Mystery Of Being
      🦅🌹🦅

    • @soundscholar5408
      @soundscholar5408 2 месяца назад +1

      @@mralexander99 ❤ it really does seem to be that way, the little bit i can gleam is enough to last me many lifetimes in exploration

  • @gphilipvirgil355
    @gphilipvirgil355 2 месяца назад +3

    Just Wow…. I’m slayed…thank you for this

  • @EbbandFlow1234
    @EbbandFlow1234 2 месяца назад +3

    Sorry, I called you Vernon yesterday. I recently listened to Vernon Neppe, and you remind me of him.

  • @MortenBendiksen
    @MortenBendiksen 2 месяца назад +1

    The reformers were the ones who brought back to peoples conciousness the centrality of the mystical union with God. It was very prevalent in their theology, and protestant mystical writings inspired an interest among the Orthodox at the time, and were widely circulated in Russia, and had a lot to do with why this is so central in Orthodoxy today.

  • @Footnotes2Plato
    @Footnotes2Plato 2 месяца назад +1

    This is just fantastic, Mark. Thank you.

  • @loriscunado3607
    @loriscunado3607 10 дней назад

    Thank you for a wonderful inspiring talk. I will listen again as there are such riches here.

  • @NTNG13
    @NTNG13 2 месяца назад

    It doesn't matter if he had the most beautiful poetry, he wasn't a divinely inspired writer. His stuff can't take the place of "cultural christianity" which only means Real Lived Christianity.

    • @toybokz
      @toybokz 2 месяца назад +3

      He was.

  • @Zxuma
    @Zxuma 2 месяца назад

    Blahity

  • @MarcusBarnabassisSystersSonne
    @MarcusBarnabassisSystersSonne 2 месяца назад +3

    Great talk, so thankful the Lord brought me to your channel ☦️

  • @margueritespringer3687
    @margueritespringer3687 2 месяца назад

    Thank you Thank you