BEAST VS SHINee - 비스트 VS 샤이니, KMF 2012
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 фев 2025
- 2012 Korean Music Festival
BEAST : Midnight
BEAST : Beautiful Night
SHINee : Sherlock
공식홈페이지 www.imbc.com/br...
2012 Korean Music Festival(가요대제전), EP02, 2012/12/31, MBC TV, Republic of Korea
![[4K/공간음향] 샤이니 - 셜록, HARD, Lucifer, 링딩동 (현장중계 풀버전) / SHINEE](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/bKn-CVh7D2o/mqdefault.jpg)
내가 기억나는건 이시절 연말무대 발음향 뚫었던게 이 두그룹이었던 것... 새삼 연말무대마다 재조명되는 그들..^-^
하.. 샤이니 미쳤다 종현 미쳤어. 몇년이나 지난 영상이건만 샤이니진짜 입이 안 다물어짐. 저러고 다음해 더 빡센 퍼포 에브리바디 들고 나오심
이때가 너무 그립다.. 진짜 비스트, 샤이니에 시대였는데
두 팀 모두 다시 돌아와줘서 그저 너무 감사함 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 저때부터 벌써 10년이 지났는데 여전히 팀 관계 돈독하고 본업에 진심인 거…진짜 멋짐
딱히 돌아오지 않았음... 항상 그자리를 꾸준히 지키고 있는 흔치않은 그룹🥺
이때 진짜 추억이 많은데 친구랑 전화로 샤이니 나왔다고 소리지르면서 보고 그랬지 진짜 꺅꺅대면서.. 보구싶다 정말 좋아했어
솔직히...이건 누가 이겼냐 졌냐 따지기보간 그냥 저 때로 돌아가고싶어...진ㅈ자....케이팝...전성기...비스트 샤이니 인피니트면 이미 끝났지..ㅠ
인피니트따위를 여기에 들이미네 ㅋㅋㅋ끼워팔기 우윀ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@mtsp-jin 인피니트가 인기가 저 정도로는 없었나요?
@@qwer1641 인기 좋긴했지만 저정도까지는...... 무리가 있죠......
ㅋㅋㅋ샤이니가 제네랑 다른급 아니냐??
@@키보드만집으면강경원 결과론 적으론 그렇죠 그래도 그당시엔 비슷비슷했으니 지금은 샤이니가 비교적 너무 잘나가서ㅋㅋㅋ
우리샤이니ㅠㅜㅠ 대단해진짜ㅠㅠ 저때비스트도대단했는데 진짜 ㅠㅠ추억이야완전
이때가 정말 아이돌들의 전성기가 아니었나싶음.. 음악방송을 하면 하나부터 열까지 모두 팬덤 짱짱하고, 다같이 으쌰으쌰하는 느낌이었는데ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ는 사실 모르겠고 저 시절이 그립다 정말ㄹㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
SHINee was insane in this performance. whenever someone says that idols don't do well in live performances, I show them this.
1
true. All of them did more than great.
미드나잇 방송에서 볼 수 있어서 경쟁이고 뭐고 그냥 행복했던 기억ㅜㅜ 이 좋은 노래 우리만 알고 있었는데 방송으로 해주니ㅜㅜㅜ무대는 내 기준에 난해(?)했지만 애들이 다 너무너무 예뻤다ㅠㅠㅠ 내가 사랑하는 연말비스트ㅜㅜ 연말무대 힘들겠지만 제대 후에 한번만 나와주라ㅠㅠ
*You know they are quality idols when you enjoy their lives more than their mv's.*
This is the quality I'm looking for!! Singing live with strong stage presence and dance!!
*SHINee AND B2ST ARE FOREVER BEST LIVE PERFORMERS.*
PP L 2nd generation idols with great quality of talents. Their fandoms are cool with each other. No fanwars unlike nowadays
Yassss
PP L w
😂 same with me i enjoy live perfomances more than mvs .
That's what I have on my mind since I found out about Shinee. Actually, I watched around 5 MVs and I watch their lives all the time. Truly talented men, gifted I would say. They are the best, absolutely the best.
수록곡 미드나잇갬성 진짜 못잃어ㅎㅎ 중소 첫대상의 기적 구비현하..그 자부심에 학생때 미친듯이 좋아했던 기억이 아른아른 지금까지도 하이라이트, 샤이니가 열심히 활동중인 걸 보면 뿌듯하다 앞으로도 오래가는 그룹이 됐으면!!!!
Onew : Always making fun
Key : Hairstylist attractive boys
Minho : Charm Over girls heart
Jonghyun : Best vocalist
Taemin: Prince of Dancers
Taemin : king of dancers👑
Hun Pagna Onew is beautiful 😍😍
Jonghyun oppa!! ♥️☝️
Taemin my fav since 2012 ❤
LMFAO JONGHYUN AT THE END WITH THE MIC RIPPING AND THE HEAD ROTATION, NO CHILLL. I LOVE YOUUU.
Mady See 💋😊💜💕😂🐰🔪😑💍🍻😍💇👍👌8⃣💔💓🌹💐💖💗💝🚫🇻🇮😅🚸🐁😃🤗🐖💘💛🌸💚💞🐷💩😁😀💟🤐
I MISS YOU JONGHYUN.
Shinee💖 Shinee💖 Shinee💖 Shinee💖 Shinee💖 Shinee💖
l always love SHINEE forever 🔥💖🔥
아 이기광 ㄹㅇ 아이돌같다 잘생겼는데 아이돌같이 잘생긴 그런잘생김임 하.. 반짝반짝 빛나는 잘생김 뭐라고 설명해야되나 암튼 잘생김
이때 진짜 비스트 전성기였다...
승패를 떠나 두 그룹을 보면 행복한 일 밖에 없던 저 시절이 그립다
비스트 음향사고 이후로 아이돌 라이브 실력 쭉쭉 올라가서 ㄹㅇ 진가였지..,, 라이브 장인ㅠㅠ
진짜 추억이다..샤이니 무대보고 소름돋았따..
이기광 차에서 나올 때 존ㄴ 잘생겼냐 사랑해 내 베이비들...
구븉현라 무대장인 구비스트현할랕 보러왔숩니당.. 너무 멋있다ㅜㅜㅜ
Jjong was 110% done with that mic
Lol he just ripped it off and he almost snapped his neck. Thank goodness for those neck muscles. He can't be doing that now tho :-(
me too!!!!!
Shinee💖 Shinee💖 Shinee💖 Shinee💖 Shinee💖 Shinee💖
l always love SHINEE forever 🔥💖🔥
Jasmine Y hahha legit.
i wanna like your comment but it's 669 :(
와 샤이니 갑이다 진짜 특히 김종현 고음 진짜 무대를 뒤집어 놓으셔따 워 진짜 와 보는내내 현실감탄함 진짜 와 성량이며 고음이며 퍼포며 놓치는거 하나 없이... 샤이니 대체... 어쩜 다섯명 다 실력 외모 성격 빠지는거 없이 너무 완벽하단 말....?
둘다 라이브 미친 그룹 .. ㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜ
당시에도 방송으로 봤었지만 지금 보면서 더 느끼는 게, 이런 그룹들의 무대를 함께 보고 즐길 수 있었다는 게 제일 최고였다는 거... ㅠㅠ그때는 쭉 틀어놔도 다 알고 즐기고가 가능했는데 나도 나이가 들고 문화도 바뀌고 그래서인지 암튼 이제는 아니어서 종종 과거여행 하게 된다
샤이니가 괜히 라이브돌이 아니지.
저때 참 어렸구나. 이쁘다.shinee
첨에 기광이형 들어올따 개멋있네 ㅋㅋ 이형은 태생이 멋으로 태어난 아이돌이야 ㅜㅜ
비스트 샤이니래.. 진짜 가슴이 웅장해진다
Shinee was feeling it! They were just hype! Jjong couldn't even contain himself at the end. Taemin was popping when he wasn't suppose to. Man even minho was hype! And Key was rockin his rap at the end! Onew danced out his belt! That's what u call a performance! Shinee ftw!
you are a idiot
pods komutta arivu ketta naaye panni payale eruma ku......
aldous ara ?????
aldous ara?????
ashi taemin hahaha Tamil aa??😂
이때 진짜 비스트 전성기.... 지금 봐도 그럴만했다
What is the best in SHINee performance is..
1. Onew smirking
2. JongHyun amazing high note + smirking
3. Key being Diva as usual
4. MinHo swaggy dance
5. TaeMin awesome dance
Yey !! Go SHINee !!
you're right!!Jjong owned the stage
and taemin's dance moves :3
You forgot Jjong ended it strong. The boys did a really strong performance.
actually i think he was pissed or something... he keeps on touching the mic alot during the perf... thats why he prolly ripped it out at the end. if you followed them since that period or before, he was quite known to speak out or question when he doesnt like something... ahhh.... such an amazing human...
와...기광이 왤케 이쁘고 잘생긴건데 이 날은 진짜 기광이 날이였던듯 미드나잇도 찰떡이고 아밤도 찰떡이다
김종현 미쳤다.. 보고 싶어 아직도 난 너만큼 라이브 잘하구 잘생기구 음색 미쳤구 다 하는 아이돌을 본 적이 없어
이당시 아이돌이 너무 그립다ㅠㅠ 구비스트 현하이라이트 오래보자💟
어느세 서로 활동하는 것만으로도 위로가 된다는 싸람들 ,,
와 다시봐도 미쳤다 비스트ㅠㅠㅠ💡💡💡💡 저때 아이돌계 짱이었는데..
종현이 라이브 미쳤다...
이때 누가 이겼었음?잼민이라모름
이게 샤이니지 미친 무대와 라이브 실력. 콘서트를 가봐야 이들의 진가를 더 잘 알 수있음. 진짜 케이팝에 보석같은 그룹임
리무진ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 엠비씨 새삼 비스트한테 많은걸 시켰구나.... 사옥투어도 한번 시키더니...
Pre-show pep talks:
Cube to B2st: Alright guys, try to interact with the crowd and have fun with it!
SM to SHINee: You better kill it or....well we've already lost a few artists this year...what's a couple more.
Seriously, I've never seen SHINee so intense. Onew's dancing looked better and Jonghyun's (
You do know that it is from 2012 right..
Saeedat Adesokan: I know it's from 2012 I was talking about how the tvxq lawsuit ended in 2012 not about exo.
Pooh Bear They were dancing like their careers depended on it though.... lol
King of live performance... No one can beat them, they're SHINee~
와아....쫑 진짜 미쳤다 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 마지막에 마이크 벗는 거 멋있따 ㅠㅠㅠ늦덕이라 아직도 볼 영상들이 산더미네🤧
Forever SHINee..the Best Performer was SHINee
구 비스트 중소최초 대상 3개 진짜 까리함..ㅎㅎ 아무리 누구들이 깽판치고 나가고 회사가 이름 뺏어도 자기들끼리 으쌰으쌰해서 회사 차리고 이름 바꾸고..군백기 거치고 1위도 하고 팬들이 어떻게 싫어해..게다가 노래도 감성적인게 딱 내스타일..
SHINee's dance and vocal are beyond perfect^^
That Sherlock performance was.. wow.. SHINee. Beast very great at interacting with the audience. Opened up with fun and engaging atmosphere with Beast then ended with intense performance by SHINee. And best of all, both of them did it live. Amazing.
P.S.:
I'm reluctant to jump into kpop fandom but by God, why is SHInee tempt me like this, stahp.. T_T
Join the dark side.
Choco Wat must.. resist.. nn.. c-can't.. guh.. just.. consider me a shawol now.
Zorya Utrennyaya welcome to the club >:D
I'm a Shawol too! Welcome to the dark side! Have a cookie! =) but Hyunseung is my ultimate bias haha!
shinee just shined all poerformance long. they are amazing
와 진짜 추억이다 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 미드나잇 갑자기 또 좋네 진짜 띵곡 ..
SHINEE......SHINEE
Beast are always entertaining to watch live. I love how Yoseob and Hyunseung always do the harsh thing with their voice when they sing live. Also Hyunseung on stage and Hyunseung off stage are like two completely different people ^^ And Shinee rocks their live performance as always, dose vocals ... Jonghyun
Both B2st and SHINee are awsome
이은진
This was live-live performance, and Sherlock is one of the hardest numbers to do live, kudos to SHINee! They were like from another planet compared to Beast. But here is the thing, today in 2016 SHINee could go against any kpop group in a concert like this and hold their own... Three years after this, SHINee are still strong if not stronger.
2017... even after so many years and so many had happened...shinee got stronger....beast was great tho but cheers to shinee...!
SHINee has a strong performance but most of all, they all have strong charisma that they can still attract me in June 2017.
SHINee tho they killed it man, that's why I love them so much they never fail to give an amazing performance
........ thats why "SHINee is always SHINNIng" without doubt.....
SHINEE
being a B2TY and a SHAWOL I Loved watching this.. BEAST you for a great job But It's obvious who wins because you are against the World King of Live Performances..SHINee 😍😍
샤이니 라이브 오진다 진짜.. 지금 현역 중에 젤 연차 많은데도 인기 많은거 대단
Watching this in 2015... and I just noticed... THIS IS WHERE SHINee based their INTRO FOR LOVE LIKE OXYGEN LIVE 2015 Version.. Watch that MCount Special and ull see..
+MyCode yesss! I was just about to comment this lol
Seriously though SM, what did you say to SHINee to get them so worked up? -.-
비스트(할랕) 예전에도진짜잘했다 대단하다
ㅇㅈ~
Both of them are great singers.They have their own uniqueness and style. But I must say SHINee was the best. Their great vocal plus their powerful live stage performance was full of energy and charisma. I was fascinated with Taemin intro until the end of SHINee performance all of them are great dancers. But i like Beast too, their song was really fun,enjoyable with their great live vocal and the intro was creative. Both of them are on the level of professional artist in Kpop. Congratulations to SHINee for winning it and SHINee had just won the Best Male Dance Performance for MAMA 2013 just now. Congratulations to SHINee and Shawols.
OMG SHINee that perfomance was PERFECT ♥
이때로 돌아갈 수 있다면 얼마나 좋을까
SHINee REALLY DID THAT!! LIVE VOCALS WERE AMAZIGN, JONGHYUN IS AMAZING AND SO WAS EVERYONE
2020에도 보는 사람 있으려나... 있다면 할랕 보러 오셨나요 샤이니 보러 오셨나요...?ㅎㅎ...
아 설마 분쟁 조장이라 오해하실깝ㅘ... 전 둘다 보러왔습니다>
전 샤월인디 둘 다 보러 왔어요
구븉현랕 둘다 보러왔습니다... 그립네여 저시절...
저도 둘 다 보라왔습니다 ㅎㅎㅎㅎㅎ 너무 멋진 그룹이죠 둘다
둘다요오오ㅗㅇ ㅠㅠ흑
Beast selected Midnight as the opening song. Walking and moving to the hall entrance with Midnight song was great selection. Beast songs and his live performance always connecting to the audiences.
Yeah! I love that they start from the red carpet with Midnight. Swag, u got it Beast.
Yeah but they performed both songs as if it was just a little performance of no importance and i did not liked that in this case cause it was a battle, i was expecting so much more. Well and shinee....even though i love beast more they dominated so hard hands down
shinee the kpop Michael Jackson? I swear every dance move just screamed MJ and I loved every minute of it
진짜 두그룹 다 레전드 청백으로 나뉜거 겁나 오랜만에 본닼ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ ㄹㅇ이때 연말무대 재밌어서 무조건 챙겨봤었는데
연말만 되면 라이브 찢던 하이라이트가 너무 보고시품..ㅠ
Omgggg im blown awayyy. SHINee's performance was soooo goood!! Everyone gave their 110% I love thissss
투피엠샤이니비스트 진짜 찬란햇다 2세대전성기아이돌...
SHINee & BEAST are two of the most talented groups of Kpop, seriously!!! They also have so scandals.
I love both of the groups but seriously, "Sherlock" is amazing. It was such a shame that SHINee didn't win any Daesang with this song & the album.
THATS WHAT I'M TALKING ABOUT. GIVE IT UP FOR SHINEE'S Perfect performance.
Sorry. I ment SHINee. Its the correction thing.
Lol
2011,2012년은 비스트의 해였지ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 저때로 돌아가고싶다 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
Why am I just finding this!!! Beast was great but SHINee was daebak!!! My feels were all over the place especially the last bit of choreo after the 3,2,1... I must have watched it AT LEAST 10 times
2018 and yet SHINee still rocking the world with great music...true legend indeed...great to reminisce our Jjong powerful voice...SHINee such great performer and artist...most of all they are great person also...pure hearted...so proud to know them... =)
I am neither a fan of Beast nor Shinee - it seems to me that Beast has very strong vocals because they in fact do not need much background voices, but sadly they did not draw my full attention simply because of the stage arrangements (e.g. I don't understand the theme of their dance?) Shinee, on the other hand, has stable vocals and also very strong image and charisma! Let me vote for Shinee this time~
Huhu .. for the beautiful night .. it more like freestyle .. haha .. maybe.. hehe
That's because instead of doing their choreography for Beautiful Night, they decided to do it freestyle. More on interaction with fans and using all of the stages. I'm a B2TY but I also like Shinee because these boys are also talented. And fun too! Both groups can be dorky and adorable. :)
That's because Beautiful Night is just supposed to be a fun song. It's more freestyle (if you try to watch the MV and the choreo video). If you want to see them with better choreography, I recommend you watch their 12:30 video or Shock. But you're right, we cannot remove the fact that Shinee is excellent. I'm a loyal B2TY but I also like Shinee. Both groups are great and work hard. Let's love both groups. :)
종현 성량봐....
비스트ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 이때로 돌아가고싶다
Both are great! But I personally prefer SHINee
Amazing performance from both groups! Truly the Kings of Live singing and performance! BEAST and SHINee rule!!! 🥰❤️😍
DAYUUUM, SHINee!!! MY BOYS, YOU WON THIS HANDS DOWN!
SHINee is still shining ❤️
근데 둘이 ㄹㅇ 결이 달라서 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 샤인비 너무 좋다 그 때 그시절… 근데 피치 하나 안떨어지고 저 안무에 라이브 하는 샤이니 도랐나.. ㅈㄴ 잘해
진짜 두그룹 다 너무 좋아ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
I prefer SHINee ♥ but BEAST also did a great job :) Haha but I can't deny that I'll always prefer SHINee ~ >w
Shinee daebak 😊🤗🤗🤗🤗
I think both of them are great but I prefer SHINee (just my opinion)
비스트.. 이때 정말,, 쩔었지
So many beautiful shots of Minho....thank you cameraman.
SHINEE's fan chant are really amazing!
SHINee!! SHINee!! That performance was beautiful! I love my oppas!
와 샤이니 에너지 봐 ㄷㄷㄷ 샤방한 미소년5명이 무대할땐 에너지가 화면을 뚫고 나와버리네.
비스트랑 흥얼거리며 놀다가 샤이니때 몰입감 쩌는 영화한편 본 기분
미드나잇 너무 좋다ㅠㅠ이 날 기광이가 진짜 예뻤네 이때 이겨야 된다고 가족들 폰 다 동원해서 투표했었는데ㅋㅋㅋ
im not a shinee fan but they killed it in this performance. they really impressed me.
나 이때 11살 ㅋㅋㅋ이어서ㅠㅠㅠ 아이돌에 관심 1도 없었는데 이때나 좀 많이 좋아할걸 이때가 진짜 케이돌들 최전성기인듯 샤월이지만 비스트 샤이니 둘다 실력 대박 얼굴 대박ㅠㅠ
저도 샤월이에용ㅎㅎㅎ 마찬가지로 이때 11살이어서 아이돌 아예 모르던 시절😶😶
많은 샤이니 영상에 오이니님 있어서 혼자만 내적 친밀감 드네요ㅎㅎㅎㅎ 항상 응원합니당
종현아 정말 널 잊지 못할거야.. 너무 사랑해..
Sorry but Shinee OWNED that!! When you are breathing that hard and your mic is falling off, that means you were doing some work! :)
I love that each fandom is complimenting everybody and not bashing the other groups
Wow I wish some other fandoms could b as nice as these two
P.s. Both groups did amazing and I love both b2st and SHINee
리무진에서 내리는 기광이 까리한거봐~저때 시상식마다 특이 컨셉 많이 했었는데~구비현하 하이라이트 치열하게 살았구나ㅋㅋㅋ
At first i like shinee just because of my ultimate bias minho but swear shinee is the best. Onew and jonghyun's voice, taemin's dance moves, key's dorkiness and minho's perfection. Hwaiting shinee! 😘😍