I hate the fact that MBC didn't upload the full performance. Like the beginning was already amazing but the other half was so much more amazing, you can feel Minah's emotion. Soulful voice indeed.
I miss singer Minah so much 😭🤧 Her voice is just too beautiful! It's been years since her solo huhu. For a Main Vocalist like her, it's kinda shame that she rarely release an album.
+Bryan Tuazon yes but they utilize her voice in the wrong way. She only has high parts where she has to put alot of pressure on her voice (female president for example). Listen to the first minute of this ballad, it sounds amazing and suits her voice.
+Bryan Tuazon i have, how would you even know if i have anyway? The commenter was probably referring to their more commercial songs anyway. No need to be all sassy.
it's a good song for her voice - she isn't the best singer - but her voice is pretty and that suits the song - the voice fits that pretty face of hers too - it was easy for me to imagine her while listening to this song Minah - good job of selling the song - the praise over your performance was well deserved
+John Eyon She isn't the best singer?...well she is definitely not THE best singer, but she can bloody sing her arse off 99% than most singers. Name at least 10 better idol vocalists, please lol.
+TheEntelexia SHINee Jonghyun, B2ST Yoseob, SNSD Taeyeon, JYJ Junsu, Big Bang Daesung, EXID Solji, SUJU Yesung, Ailee, SISTAR Hyorin, IU, 2NE1 Park Bom. There you have it, 10+ better idol vocalists. But no, that's not the point. John Eyon wasn't saying Minah isn't a good singer, he's just saying she isn't the best singer, which is true. No need to be so defensive. My ultimate bias is SS501 Young Saeng, he's a good vocalist but isn't the best and i'm okay with people saying that. Let's not argue on this point though, i think it is proof enough through this video that Minah is a good singer. So let's just enjoy her performance (:
To be more specific, could you name 10 idols with better vocal ability. Males clearly do not count. I would also argue that Bom's vocal ability is no where near what it used to be and Minah has equally as much skill as IU.
+TheEntelexia Former Kara Kim Sung Hee, all 4 of Big Mama, all 5 of SPICA, Red Velvet Seul Gi, F(x) Luna, Ailee, SNSD TaeYeon, SHE'Z TaeYeon, APink EunJi, and more. SISTAR HyoRin and LADIES CODE SoJung aren't quite at the level of the previous list in terms of technique, but they are superior to Minah and I enjoy listening to them singing very much. And that doesn't count the ones I've heard but whose name I can't recall. Nor does it count the many males singers who surpass Minah. Male voices do count. You're evidently not a good judge of qualification. Only a fool would think there's some insurmountable a barrier between male & femaile singing abilities that disallows them from being compared. You're weird. It's obvious you don't know how to judge good singers (full tones, technique, etc). Especially if you think IU is a good singer. Geesh! Minah has a pretty voice and fairly good technique, but her voice is thin. IU's voice is far thinner and less pleasing than Minah's. I have no problem listening to Minah - even if she is fully covered up - while I turn away from IU performances.
I love that you've resorted to condescension in your post. When we are talking about a female singer, how is it appropriate to measure her against her male peers? I do not see a correlation between female and male vocal ability when trying to tell how good a female singer, no less an idol singer, on a TV Show. I never said there was any prohibition to females and males being compared, I just think it's irrelevant in the context of finding out Minah's vocal ability when compared to her female idol peers. You then go on to call me weird, cheers for that I guess? Then you criticise my ability to judge what constitutes a good singer, much of which you've clearly pointed out, is a subjective thing with your anti-IU sentiment because you find her voice "less pleasing". So please, if you have an opinion, go for it but don't act like a condescending a-hole trying to prove that you're better at judging singers than anyone else; especially on the internet of all places. Have a great day sir and shall IU's voice never grace your delicate ears ever again :P
+lone ranger yup!! maybe it's what makes her voice distinct from generic kpop vocalists. also Ariana grande's voice is nasal like too but she's goof as hell so why can't Minah 😀
![[King of masked singer] 복면가왕 - Warrior Cat’s girl - Love Over A Thousand Years 20151206](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/u3bYtLLl1QI/mqdefault.jpg)
![[King of masked singer] 복면가왕 - Warrior Cat’s girl - Love Over A Thousand Years 20151206](/img/tr.png)
![[defensive stage] 'Dongmakgol girl' - How do you like, ' 동막골 소녀' - 어떤가요, 복면가왕 20180909](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/3VJFHYiG4sY/mqdefault.jpg)
![[C.C.] Listen to JIHYO's song when she was young #TWICE #JIHYO](/img/1.gif)
I hate the fact that MBC didn't upload the full performance. Like the beginning was already amazing but the other half was so much more amazing, you can feel Minah's emotion. Soulful voice indeed.
Z
Where did u find it
Yes, this ending with the great emotion
Minah's voice would be perfect for OSTs 💕
Agree
Minah, your voice is beyond ethereal, it's the epitome of beautiful 😭
어떤가요 화요비 버전으로 불러줘서 기분 좋음. 애드립이나 박자나 ㅎㅎ
맑음+허스키 적절히 잘 섞인 보컬이라 정말 좋아합니다 ❤
screw anyone who says she cant sing or she isnt a good singer. this was so beautiful :')
Wait, someone tells her that? O.o
@@hawkravenclaw oh yeah! I've heard it many times that she's "lacklustre" or "not a good singer" ect. Its ridiculous
@@kiss2cry that's crazy, I got into Girl's day because of her amazing voice and high notes
Those were haters lols. Minah is definitely and recognized as one of the greatest Female Main Vocalists out there.
aww Minah is a princess not only is she good at singing but she's good at dancing too and she's sooo pretty!
now she's good at acting
And the piano
한 때 나의 최애였던 민아언니♥♥♥
아직도 언니 목소리 들으면
민아언니다!라고 할 정도로
사랑해염!
She may not be the best vocalist but her voice is bloody gorgeous I'm so in love
민아 진짜 잘 부른다,. .ㅠ
Sometimes is not only about the high notes, is about feelings and emotions and Minah makes you feel what she sings. She is amazing!!
She perfect every thing Minah is the best
I miss minah and girl's day :( 2nd generation kpop groups were really big part of my childhood
I'm so inlove with her voice 😍 maaaaan she's good at everything! she's so talented 💗
MINAH is the BEST!!!
such beautiful voice
For me Minah is the best singer on kpop until now.. watchin' this Aug2020.
I miss singer Minah so much 😭🤧 Her voice is just too beautiful! It's been years since her solo huhu. For a Main Vocalist like her, it's kinda shame that she rarely release an album.
Woooow....Minah deserves a solo album... her soothing voice is outstanding...
+horsiwon She's already got one.she released her mini-album for her solo debut ''I Am A Woman Too'' 8 months ago.
Wow! She's really good. I love her voice. The way she sing is very clean. 😊😊😊
자주 나와서 노래 해줬음 좋겠다.
Is it just me that Minah's voice is so ahead of it's time? Like her voice is too modern for Girl's day's era?
민아 노래 너무 잘한다ㅠㅠㅠㅜㅠㅠㅠ
역시 갓 ~ 민아♥♥♥♥♥♥
those husky voice only minah sing like that..
While I love minah and I can't get enough of her vocals eun ji also has that husky sound when she wants as well.
hyolyn too
i love her voice, so cold and beautiful, please Dreamtea promote them and her more please
Minah is my favorite kpop singer of all time. 🥰
Minah's voice it's sooooo obvious lol. I like her voice so much
My goodness. Her company is wasting her talent
uh wtf? She's been singing more than half of every GsD song.
+Bryan Tuazon yes but they utilize her voice in the wrong way. She only has high parts where she has to put alot of pressure on her voice (female president for example). Listen to the first minute of this ballad, it sounds amazing and suits her voice.
+mewantspocky have you ever listen to their non-title songs or her collab song(skyfall)? or even her SOLO DEBUT? I don't think so.
+Bryan Tuazon i have, how would you even know if i have anyway? The commenter was probably referring to their more commercial songs anyway. No need to be all sassy.
+Bryan Tuazon you need to settle down.
Her diction, her dynamics and her emotions is awesome! 👌
Mbc님 복면가왕 초반 무대들 풀로 올려주기면 안될까요? ㅜㅜ
I love her voice.. especially when she's crying,. it has impact to me:(
I cried watching this... my baby bang!! ❤
minah saranghe yo
Minah its a good singer. Minah voice so beautiful:)
한때 정말 많이 돌려들었었는데… 오랜만에 다시 들으니 역시 너무 좋네요 요즘은 배우로 활동하지만 가수도 꾸준히 해줬으면 좋겠어요 ㅎㅎ
it's a good song for her voice - she isn't the best singer - but her voice is pretty and that suits the song - the voice fits that pretty face of hers too - it was easy for me to imagine her while listening to this song
Minah - good job of selling the song - the praise over your performance was well deserved
+John Eyon She isn't the best singer?...well she is definitely not THE best singer, but she can bloody sing her arse off 99% than most singers. Name at least 10 better idol vocalists, please lol.
+TheEntelexia SHINee Jonghyun, B2ST Yoseob, SNSD Taeyeon, JYJ Junsu, Big Bang Daesung, EXID Solji, SUJU Yesung, Ailee, SISTAR Hyorin, IU, 2NE1 Park Bom. There you have it, 10+ better idol vocalists.
But no, that's not the point. John Eyon wasn't saying Minah isn't a good singer, he's just saying she isn't the best singer, which is true. No need to be so defensive. My ultimate bias is SS501 Young Saeng, he's a good vocalist but isn't the best and i'm okay with people saying that. Let's not argue on this point though, i think it is proof enough through this video that Minah is a good singer. So let's just enjoy her performance (:
To be more specific, could you name 10 idols with better vocal ability. Males clearly do not count. I would also argue that Bom's vocal ability is no where near what it used to be and Minah has equally as much skill as IU.
+TheEntelexia Former Kara Kim Sung Hee, all 4 of Big Mama, all 5 of SPICA, Red Velvet Seul Gi, F(x) Luna, Ailee, SNSD TaeYeon, SHE'Z TaeYeon, APink EunJi, and more. SISTAR HyoRin and LADIES CODE SoJung aren't quite at the level of the previous list in terms of technique, but they are superior to Minah and I enjoy listening to them singing very much. And that doesn't count the ones I've heard but whose name I can't recall.
Nor does it count the many males singers who surpass Minah. Male voices do count. You're evidently not a good judge of qualification. Only a fool would think there's some insurmountable a barrier between male & femaile singing abilities that disallows them from being compared. You're weird.
It's obvious you don't know how to judge good singers (full tones, technique, etc). Especially if you think IU is a good singer. Geesh! Minah has a pretty voice and fairly good technique, but her voice is thin. IU's voice is far thinner and less pleasing than Minah's. I have no problem listening to Minah - even if she is fully covered up - while I turn away from IU performances.
I love that you've resorted to condescension in your post. When we are talking about a female singer, how is it appropriate to measure her against her male peers? I do not see a correlation between female and male vocal ability when trying to tell how good a female singer, no less an idol singer, on a TV Show. I never said there was any prohibition to females and males being compared, I just think it's irrelevant in the context of finding out Minah's vocal ability when compared to her female idol peers.
You then go on to call me weird, cheers for that I guess? Then you criticise my ability to judge what constitutes a good singer, much of which you've clearly pointed out, is a subjective thing with your anti-IU sentiment because you find her voice "less pleasing". So please, if you have an opinion, go for it but don't act like a condescending a-hole trying to prove that you're better at judging singers than anyone else; especially on the internet of all places. Have a great day sir and shall IU's voice never grace your delicate ears ever again :P
wooooah im listening her voice and crying kkkk~
Minah 😍 everydays girldays
Minah.. Pretty, cutie, sexy body, great at acting and great voice too.. :)) i love her
민아 잘부른다ㅎㅎㅎ 챌린져 티어급이군
This was so soothing and beautiful I actually ended up dozing off to it.
캬~~ 좋다. :)
진짜 대박이야~! 민아 사랑해요
민아 노래 더 듣고 싶다
1:16 me anytime I listen to Minah sing
敏雅唱的超好聽的!!!!!!!!>
Even on the first second, I already know if it's you, Ms. Angelic Smile--Minah.
wow queen 👑😍❤
she should have gone further
she did a beautiful job in 2nd round
My forever favorite Minah. 😍😙💖
OMG! Minah my heart was fluttered💓
Minah.... 💙💙💙💙💯👌 Perfecto...., love of drama "am robots
If im JYP im gonna get Minah. The whole world needs to hear her lovely voice.
my queen 😍
으.... 저 감성과 몰입력!!!
play the duru duru duu part at my funeral
goosebumps
omg her voice like kill u 😻🔪 she is my second best singer ❤ my first ofc with out thinking iu 👑
Minah i love your voice so much😍😍😍
A little nasally in the beginning, but overall a wonderful performance. Bang Minah fighting!
I love girls day..minah
너무 좋다..민아
The original singer was a boy but when i heard it sung by girlsday bang minah ... I love the song......
So sweet ❤️
bangminah good singer.. fighting minah
Bang Minah jjang!!
MINAH YOU ROCK GURL
Süper... 💖💖💖 Minah... 💖💖💖
Is there studio version for this yet? I really love Minah's cover!!
minah 💖
she doesn't sound like Bomi at all
who sayed it's like bomi ?
+Bushra Hassan you can see comments from bomi's video king of masked
+Arafad Muhd fikri okey.
she's a lot better than Bomi...
that's a FACT!!!
Wonderful voice minah
What the title of song and who is singer that song
+Jocelyn Nala its "어떤가요 how are you" from park hwayobi, released in 2002.
+Cody Ref thank you 😊😊
+Cody Ref thank you
But i search the title how are you wrong title
The original title is BECAUSE I LOVE YOU by park hwayobi
wow queen 👑👑👑👑👑👑👑👑👑👑👑😍❤
Minah queen
she is better than the original singer😮😍😭😍
i love this song
Where's the great ending ?? Why they cut ??? It's very great
Eom Da Da😉
Who is the original singer of this song..?
💕💕💕
Whoa
what song,, pls tell me who sang
❤
아 뒤에 왜 자르냐고 ㅡㅜ
the name of the song ?
+Lourdes Santos how are you" from park hwayobi, released in 2002
어떤가요
what song is this??
+Eileen H how are you" from park hwayobi, released in 2002
thaanks
+Eileen H lee jeong bong 1996
+A Cloud (Bi Rain Fan) original lee jeong bong 1996
She’s so good she could have been really big. What happened?
what is the title of the song? can someone tell me?😍😍😍
How are you by Lee Jeongbong
Ethereal.
At first I thought it was the song from Architecture 101 😂😂
Ep??????
이게 풀렸노 ㄹㄱㄴ
She really needs to work on her voice being nasal-like but overall I like the perf! btw I'm a Dai5y ;)
hahaha... i understand the nasal-like voice you said. hmm yeah but i think i things it is her style of singing
+lone ranger ...i think it is....*
+lone ranger yup!! maybe it's what makes her voice distinct from generic kpop vocalists. also Ariana grande's voice is nasal like too but she's goof as hell so why can't Minah 😀
@@cerulean1602 agree .. it's her talent maybe she want minah to sing like sojin
wow is amazing.... the song is????
어떤가요
To much echo
my queen 😍