Parents and teacher discuss critical race theory and beyond in education panel

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 20 окт 2024

Комментарии • 208

  • @justin0ldman233
    @justin0ldman233 2 года назад +8

    Why wouldn't we teach slavery
    Its part of HISTORY

    • @Bigfishfun333
      @Bigfishfun333 Год назад

      CRT opponents are NOT saying don't teach history! Just don't teach that today, today, any black underachievement one might find is the fault of white people.

    • @AndreKing4
      @AndreKing4 Год назад

      Because white people dont like to admit they messed up

    • @scottydu81
      @scottydu81 Год назад +2

      Who is advocating that we not teach slavery?

    • @AdrienLegendre
      @AdrienLegendre Год назад

      Agree, teach history, not political ideology.

  • @Anshulhe
    @Anshulhe Год назад +4

    Simple, abusers don't want abused to speak up regarding abuses

    • @nkeiruka5930
      @nkeiruka5930 Год назад

      @aqrabuamelu5291 abused? Back then black people are torturing even children are you going to say is abuse? Also this slave start in 1619 and 1865. Years when the black people was torture for no reason. This man the founder of crt. He started this crt 1970 and you guys wanted to end it 2021 really. 50 years ago. It not even up to one 100 year. That why white and black aren't equal. It's not fair for the black. I'm just telling the truth.

  • @notofthisworld5267
    @notofthisworld5267 2 года назад +12

    Well, we know Virginia isn’t for it. They voted the democrats out.

    • @justin0ldman233
      @justin0ldman233 2 года назад +2

      CRT is RACISM

    • @bria1660
      @bria1660 2 года назад +1

      @@justin0ldman233 Unless your child is in law school, your child is not learning CRT. You guys think any history that involves Black people is CRT. Also ... CRT is not racism, it is discussing laws and how those laws impact people.

    • @bria1660
      @bria1660 2 года назад

      It is plain they do not want real history taught in Virginia schools.

    • @justin0ldman233
      @justin0ldman233 2 года назад

      @@bria1660 Shouldn't be in Law School
      CRT is RACISM

    • @DoyleHargraves-hr5cl
      @DoyleHargraves-hr5cl 2 года назад

      B b but CRT is only taught in university’s. So colleges need cartoon children’s books to teach college kids? Actually makes sense considering how colleges are ran today.

  • @connorholman2916
    @connorholman2916 2 года назад +6

    I'm in love with the AP History teacher from Texas! I would be honored to have her as a teacher and I'm so glad to see someone as brilliant as her spreading the truth. I was pretty annoyed when the interviewer cut her off to let that smug bigot in the middle speak, but what she said before being shut down was truly wonderful.

    • @Bigfishfun333
      @Bigfishfun333 Год назад +2

      He's NOT a "bigot" - he just doesn't want one race blamed for failures of another race, which is what is happening with CRT being so prevalent in the schools now.

    • @connorholman2916
      @connorholman2916 Год назад

      @@Bigfishfun333 There is no point interacting with people who have their heads so deep up their ass, so find someone else to bother with your ignorance :)

    • @Bigfishfun333
      @Bigfishfun333 Год назад

      @@connorholman2916 I see that you can't counter my argument with truth, logic, and reason.

    • @connorholman2916
      @connorholman2916 Год назад

      @@Bigfishfun333 What argument lol? All you did was state your opinion. Here, I'll "counter your argument": you're wrong, he is a bigot. and so are you :)

    • @Bigfishfun333
      @Bigfishfun333 Год назад

      @@connorholman2916 So my guess is that you feel that any black underachievement that one might find is all the fault of white people, correct?

  • @onceuponacrime9307
    @onceuponacrime9307 2 года назад +9

    Where’s the diversity here why are 3 white people discussing this?

    • @onceuponacrime9307
      @onceuponacrime9307 2 года назад +6

      @Joshua’s HAUS With people like you the whole world can see why your Country is so f**ked up.

  • @bria1660
    @bria1660 2 года назад +7

    Thanks to the teacher from Texas who tried to explain what CRT is and why it is not taught in K-12 schools. Are the "anti-CRT" folks concerned about the Holocaust being discussed in schools? Are they not concerned that the little white German kid's feelings will be hurt? It is sad that some people have concluded that any history that involves Black people is CRT.

    • @bookgirlny8511
      @bookgirlny8511 2 года назад +2

      I agree. And you KNOW that most critics of CRT never read any. They couldn’t even name ONE founder. Smh

    • @chickenfishhybrid44
      @chickenfishhybrid44 2 года назад +2

      Lmao, as if any school isn't teaching about the holocaust. Its sad that so many people seem to conclude that you need CRT to teach about slavery and racism. Do people seriously believe that everyone who speaks out against CRT and "diversity, equity and inclusion" type rhetoric think that kids shouldn't be taught about slavery or racism at all? Because that's an absolute strawman and seems to be how people present it. Anyone who advocates for somrthing like that is a fool and doesn't represent the majority of people that have concerns about CRT.

    • @bria1660
      @bria1660 2 года назад

      @chickenfishhybrid44 You people are revisionists and do not want real history taught in schools. The anti-CRT folks are calling any history related to black people as CRT and are banning books by minority authors. It is sad that most of your children are smarter than you. While you are banning books and revising history, be sure to take away the computers, cell phones, televisions, and choose your kids' friends. And please stop quoting MLK because the anti-CRT folks are the same kind of people that hated MLK in the 1960's. He was called a socialist, trouble maker, and communist. Do that sound familiar?

    • @bookgirlny8511
      @bookgirlny8511 2 года назад

      @@bria1660 You tell ‘em. And don’t worry. We teachers will not be intimidated. We know how to handle the unruly, immature, and uninformed. It’s what we do every day.

    • @chickenfishhybrid44
      @chickenfishhybrid44 2 года назад

      @@bria1660maybe in your version of reality lmao. I know you want so badly to be able to claim the same victimization and glory that Civil Rights activists went through and received but sorry, it's simply just not the 70s anymore.

  • @karenmiller5160
    @karenmiller5160 Год назад +4

    The person who wants to limit teaching CRT does NOT know what CRT means. He has an objection to teaching the ugly parts of the history of our country. If our students have teacher-led honest and frank discussions on uncomfortable topics, that can only serve to improve their ability to think critically about situations. And that leads to more informed citizens.

    • @johnschuh8616
      @johnschuh8616 Год назад

      You did not listen to him carefully. He is opposed to teaching that our institutions are corrupted by racism. A portrait warts and all is one thing. A portrait that focuses on the warts is not.

    • @AdrienLegendre
      @AdrienLegendre Год назад

      CRT is not history, CRT is a Marxist political ideology.

    • @rorydobbs6700
      @rorydobbs6700 11 месяцев назад

      @@johnschuh8616They are… it’s well documented. Examples being the GI bill benefits being denied to black veterans, housing discrimination against black and brown Americans, Jim Crow laws. This country is racist in nature, ask the Native Americans who were murdered for their land. This country does not at all believe in the fundamental truths of “freedom and equality.”

  • @resonanceliteracy
    @resonanceliteracy Год назад

    No Left Turn guy contributed nothing of value to this discussion. They always talk about Kendi and DiAngelo.

    • @AdrienLegendre
      @AdrienLegendre Год назад

      He told the truth. Those who value truth differ.

  • @ravenillusion2596
    @ravenillusion2596 2 года назад +3

    Its not what you say its how you say it and this is the problem w news reporting as well. History in the United States cannot be forgotten and cannot be taken out of curriculum. Im Mexican and Native Apache mixed. When i was in school US history was taught as is and atrocities included. Didn't make me hate white people. It opens minds and realization to where we gotta go as a society for prosperity for all. But to completely say there is no more race bias now a days is incorrect as well and needs to be addressed accordingly.

  • @kevinldjohnson2950
    @kevinldjohnson2950 2 года назад +2

    Morning It is very wrong to always have people on talking about blacks And never have a black people on what have happen to them Get real

    • @bria1660
      @bria1660 2 года назад

      I have noticed this also. These school board meetings never include CRT experts. Just a bunch of parents screaming and giving their interpretation of what CRT is while the school board members sit like deer in the highlights. Parents are equating anything that is related to black people as CRT since most do not even know what it is.

    • @kennethwoods2071
      @kennethwoods2071 2 года назад +1

      Bria.i was seeing and noticed this too.thry don't even have a clue to what they are talking about.its just like history there are so many lies in what they are saying..

  • @ravenillusion2596
    @ravenillusion2596 2 года назад +2

    In Germany students must learn about WWII (world war 2) cant just hide history. Just teach it as what has happened not teach to hate but teach the wrong and reality that happens and the truth.

  • @WildwoodClaire1
    @WildwoodClaire1 2 года назад +4

    Stephen Colbert accurately described conservative/Republican/reactionary opposition to "Critical Race Theory" as opposition to any history education critical of American racism.

    • @bookgirlny8511
      @bookgirlny8511 2 года назад

      👍

    • @pookiethepringlelord8304
      @pookiethepringlelord8304 2 года назад

      That's not what it is. And schools don't teach history. I learned about slavery in America, not about barbary slave trade. Or that race has been a dividing issue everywhere with everyone. There is no oppressor race. All can be oppressed all can be oppressive.

    • @bookgirlny8511
      @bookgirlny8511 2 года назад

      @@pookiethepringlelord8304 True, in very general terms. But here in the USA, White people have occupied the dominant position for hundreds of years. There’s no two ways about it.
      And schools can only teach so much. We good citizens should model ourselves by emulating the founders: read widely and often. Our education does not end when we’re handed our diploma.

    • @scottydu81
      @scottydu81 Год назад

      @@bookgirlny8511 Are you suggesting that white people be replaced?

    • @bookgirlny8511
      @bookgirlny8511 Год назад

      @@scottydu81 What?! What a silly comment. Seriously… do some reading.

  • @resonanceliteracy
    @resonanceliteracy Год назад +2

    The No Left Turn guy memorized his lines. This is verbatim what we hear across the country by "parent" advocate groups. Not worth the airtime. But if this parent is honest, he will admit that he has never read the Frankfurt school authors. Just bumpersticker talking points.

    • @josephwheeler8753
      @josephwheeler8753 Год назад

      Exactly! Talking points are all the MAGA tribe has to offer. Research may kill them. Their heads may explode.

    • @AdrienLegendre
      @AdrienLegendre Год назад

      The guy memorized his lines because he was intelligent, prepared and reviewed the subject, unlike the 2 other persons.

  • @chickenfishhybrid44
    @chickenfishhybrid44 2 года назад

    So you as a Texas teacher, who clearly points out how much each state and local school board has influence over the curriculum feel strongly enough to say what is and isn't being taught in all schools?

    • @bookgirlny8511
      @bookgirlny8511 2 года назад +1

      The board should, not the Governor. Youngkin, DeSantis and Abbott should NOT be issuing mandates and then claim to be small government conservatives.

    • @AdrienLegendre
      @AdrienLegendre Год назад

      @@bookgirlny8511 Best approach provide the curriculum and reasons for the curriculum to the community and develop a community consensus.

  • @jeffgo5742
    @jeffgo5742 2 года назад +10

    Teaching about the history of racism. Isn’t the same as teaching kids one race is better then the other. Theories is not facts. Teach the facts about history, not certain people’s theories.

    • @dude999642
      @dude999642 2 года назад +1

      Bingo!

    • @gtgargon
      @gtgargon 2 года назад

      idiots usually believe they're smart.

    • @Bigfishfun333
      @Bigfishfun333 Год назад

      CORRECT! CRT is a theory, not fact. It blames while people for all black underachievement one might find, which is a wrong way to do it.

    • @AdrienLegendre
      @AdrienLegendre Год назад +1

      Theories based on science are good. Theories based on an ideology like CRT are bad.

  • @poormannews3381
    @poormannews3381 2 года назад

    Then why did so many books get canceled Dr Seuss blah blah blah

  • @Bildgesmythe
    @Bildgesmythe 2 года назад +6

    History needs to be taught. History is never comfortable.

    • @justin0ldman233
      @justin0ldman233 2 года назад +2

      CRT is Racism

    • @DarkPassenger
      @DarkPassenger 2 года назад +3

      Well good thing CRT isn't history.

    • @justin0ldman233
      @justin0ldman233 2 года назад +3

      @@DarkPassenger History is History
      We teach the Good, Bad & Ugly
      CRT is RACISM

    • @jeffgo5742
      @jeffgo5742 2 года назад

      @@DarkPassenger right that’s why it shouldn’t be taught to little kids

    • @chickenfishhybrid44
      @chickenfishhybrid44 2 года назад

      You don't need CRT or frameworks like it to teach history.

  • @iowastate358
    @iowastate358 2 года назад +1

    One sided propaganda

    • @huslr6266
      @huslr6266 2 года назад

      slavery was also one-sided.

  • @RougeLino
    @RougeLino Год назад

    that dude is a bad politician lol. continusly admitting that the 2 others are right

    • @AdrienLegendre
      @AdrienLegendre Год назад

      He described how the other were wrong.

    • @RougeLino
      @RougeLino Год назад

      @@AdrienLegendre about what?

  • @tomare6479
    @tomare6479 2 года назад +3

    punish these people trying to ban books

    • @silverpairaducks
      @silverpairaducks 2 года назад +3

      You do not want your children reading some of these. Taking it off the curriculum isn't banning.

  • @billpool1217
    @billpool1217 2 года назад +6

    If you don't want children to learn CRT, DON'T SEND THEM TO LAW SCHOOL.

    • @justin0ldman233
      @justin0ldman233 2 года назад +1

      I studied CRT & ITS RACIST

    • @billpool1217
      @billpool1217 2 года назад

      @@justin0ldman233
      What law school did you go to?

    • @scottydu81
      @scottydu81 Год назад

      CRT isn’t being taught to students, it’s being implemented in their systems. You people are so sneaky with your black nationalist hate movement

    • @AdrienLegendre
      @AdrienLegendre Год назад

      Better option, do not teach CRT in law school.

  • @RougeLino
    @RougeLino Год назад

    is it me or the 2 sides literally want the same thing lol ? more accurate and explanatory truth about american history.
    see, that's the problem when the media 2 these little debats... WE ACTUALLY FIND SOLUTIONS

  • @gemthetics8084
    @gemthetics8084 2 года назад +8

    "Call on the Lord in the day of trouble,
    and he will deliver you"
    - Psalm 50 :15

  • @Notwithstanding0
    @Notwithstanding0 2 года назад +8

    CRT needs to be in every school curriculum.

    • @romancewiththepast7979
      @romancewiththepast7979 2 года назад +2

      Segregationist.

    • @papawheelie5576
      @papawheelie5576 2 года назад +3

      LOL! Keep your Marxist garbage out of our schools. 👍

    • @bookgirlny8511
      @bookgirlny8511 2 года назад

      @@romancewiththepast7979 Can you even name ONE CRT founder?

    • @bookgirlny8511
      @bookgirlny8511 2 года назад

      @@papawheelie5576 Can you even name ONE CRT founder? Doubt it…

    • @papawheelie5576
      @papawheelie5576 2 года назад +2

      @@bookgirlny8511 I can't name a BLM founder either, but I know Marxist trash when I see it. 👍

  • @dynisemc9749
    @dynisemc9749 2 года назад +3

    Good debate. I agree with the male teacher. We are going backward as Americans.....back to segregation. Not what Dr. King's dream is all about. My privileged black kid told me she was really upset because she went to an ivy-league "white" Catholic University. Why are you all trying to destroy our kids? We are four generations of Catholics and well educated - but the liberals told my child something different. She's married and didn't baptized the child and doesn't go to Mass. This is sad!

    • @Nexter1
      @Nexter1 2 года назад

      Your bot process got screwed up.

    • @deyhatejujo
      @deyhatejujo 2 года назад +1

      Your response sounds bizarre…

  • @mwildthing5525
    @mwildthing5525 2 года назад +4

    End crt

  • @Gisaeng
    @Gisaeng 2 года назад +2

    "Those who do not remember history are blind to its effects."This has been taught and read in many class rooms across america. So why should it not continue? In school they teach and expect the person to remember and give the lesson back in test form and now you are saying that said fact should be excluded from the teaching? I ask when is the truth not relevant or is it that only those truths to be controlled?

  • @alntr2872
    @alntr2872 2 года назад +2

    Well done, give one of the truth tellers the last word. WELL DONE!

  • @AdrienLegendre
    @AdrienLegendre Год назад

    CRT is taught in some California school districts, a curriculum promoted by the Liberated Ethnic Studies Model Consortium. History teacher is wrong; need to have better prepared and less deeply biased people.

  • @olmcmonnie7445
    @olmcmonnie7445 2 года назад +1

    Does this Dad not know that CRT is only taught in undergraduate and graduate schools?

    • @justin0ldman233
      @justin0ldman233 2 года назад

      The Teach CRT in my 9 year olds Classroom
      I have read all of Kimberly Crenshaw's Works
      CRT IS RACISM

    • @jeffgo5742
      @jeffgo5742 2 года назад

      Not true and because you change the name of it, it’s stil CRT

    • @AdrienLegendre
      @AdrienLegendre Год назад

      The Virginia teacher directly saw CRT teaching material so he is correct. CRT is taught in some California school districts, a curriculum promoted by the Liberated Ethnic Studies Model Consortium.

  • @NYmomAdrienne3915
    @NYmomAdrienne3915 2 года назад +4

    Learn history, 💯. Some CRT curriculums factually and historically incorrect. I saw things stating Christianity creates privilege. That is far from truth in our Armenian family. We were killed partly for it in Armenian Genocide. It would make my daughter believe the rhetoric of Erdogan. They should teach history, blaming current people, no. We all come from different countries, I actually don’t even know anyone whose family was here before the Civil War. Due to that, privilege walks and such, no; history absolutely yes as I understand the hurt/anger of denial as Turkey denies to this day. We also lost people slaughtered by IS in recent times

    • @TruthOverFear21
      @TruthOverFear21 2 года назад +1

      So you will be ok with the fact that White supremacy started back during the Crusades with the Catholic Church putting out messages and the ideal of anyone that was born with European Blood then they are less than human and have no souls?

    • @NYmomAdrienne3915
      @NYmomAdrienne3915 2 года назад

      @@TruthOverFear21 no, that blames people today. History yes, blame people today, no. The inquisition and crusades and the history of what they did, yes

    • @silverpairaducks
      @silverpairaducks 2 года назад

      @@TruthOverFear21 bullshit

    • @NYmomAdrienne3915
      @NYmomAdrienne3915 2 года назад

      @@TruthOverFear21 you realize what history you sound like..”Ottoman empire is falling, the Armenians historically have rebelled, so while them out with crucifixions and burning, shooting, and death marches”. How do you think these things occurred in history? It’s blaming an entire race of people. I don’t hold Turks alive today accountable, and they don’t even acknowledge the Armenian Genocide. It was a “crime against Turkishness” to discuss when my family left. Yet I don’t blame anyone personally, government yes

    • @NYmomAdrienne3915
      @NYmomAdrienne3915 2 года назад

      @@TruthOverFear21 you should also realize we are separate. Armenia became the 1st Christian state in 300 CE approximately. Islam started in 610 CE approximately. Not Roman Catholic, however, Christians are not always the aggressor. In our case, no. That is why you can’t broadly paint people with the same brush, always exceptions. To blame an entire race for ills today is what The Young Turks and Nazis did..it doesn’t end well. I agree we should learn and fulfill a modern equivalent of the Freed Man’s Act (I realize 40 acres and a mule is not a profitable farm as it may have been then, adjust for modern equivalent value). Black, Jewish, Armenian, Indigenous all have had horror happen to us, recognize, learn, but not repeat on another

  • @justin0ldman233
    @justin0ldman233 2 года назад

    This is so funny 🤣

  • @SilverXT
    @SilverXT 2 года назад

    "It's becoming McCarthyism"
    I love that. She's totally right.