@@althealligator1467For me I think it’s that the original’s verses “lean major” while the chorus “leans minor” so even when that’s flipped, the song still mostly consists of alternating sections of major-ish and minor-ish. This breaks down from the bridge onwards though - the bridge doesn’t resemble anything in the original and there are no more majorish-minorish alternating sections after the last verse
the only reason it sounds normal is bc the melody of this song is just decending notes, so if you have them acending, itll sound pretty much the same just going up the scale
This isn't like other dark songs that get the negative harmony treatment. It didn't turn light like the others; it ended up even more unhinged and sinister than the original already was. If you reverse a black hole, it doesn't become a white hole; it's still a black hole with an opposite charge and spin. Light still can't escape.
This is the first negative harmony cover of yours I've heard that really doesn't feel too different to the original. Kind of like a black hole, and a very dark grey one 😅
@@SB-se7vb Technically speaking, they have precisely the same amount of dissonance. That’s the whole point of negative harmony - because all the intervals are perfectly equivalent, it retains precisely the same ratios of dissonance to consonance, tension to resolution, but in an inverted context
You've managed to preserve the sound of all the tracks without much distortion or artifacts, nice job! The result sounds like a genuine song. So glad the bots aren't tuned to pick these out (yet) so you can upload the whole thing...
There are a lot of these that flip their tone, and a few happy songs that stay happy sounding. This is the only one I've run into that's a sad song that stays sad sounding.
Would be really cool if you could have a collab with youtubers who can imitate Chris' voice. To name a few : Anthony Vincent, Denis Pauna, Steve Welsh. But incredible work nonetheless
Amazing work, but any chance you'll be doing any of these from scratch again? I revisit Here Comes the Sun and Somewhere Over the Rainbow for your beautiful voice and production quite a bit!
This is the version in the universe that exist on the other side of said black hole. I think it's only a planck distance away from our universe, like dimensionally.
I really like your work, and this one is another banger. I’ve been wondering if it would be fine for me to use some of your covers in my RUclips video essays (with proper credit to you of course) because I think their experimental, indie vibe really fits the very specific mood I’m trying to create. Would that be ok?
Could you do The Stranger or Vienna by Billy Joel? They would sound very interesting. Or just any Billy Joel song you find interesting. I’ve been listening to all your negative harmony covers and they are very interesting. It’s like getting a glimpse of a different universe where music is the opposite, yet remains the same. This was one RUclips rabbit hole I gladly went down. Great work! Keep this up!
If you take requests I’d love to hear Say it Ain’t so by weezer in a negative harmony, honestly i think any weezer song would sound really interesting in a negative harmony
came here from a video explaining negative harmony , from what I gather the farther away you go into extended chords like in this song , the less related overall to the original it becomes. in your Beatles covers with mostly simple chords up to 7ths it still relatable to the original . also couldn't you choose arbitrarily a different axis in this case ?
A different axis yields the same result but in a different key. And yeah great question, extended chords present a dilemma. In the key of C, Fmaj7 technically inverts to Ebmaj7. But generally in arrangement I find it better, or at least I usually make the choice to invert the simple triad, and then add the extensions, ie. Fmaj7 becomes Gminor(flat6)
The original was already so weird harmonically that this is not so much negative harmony as harmony at right-angles to reality. The end is like a freight train coming at you. I'd love to hear a negative harmony version of Elvis - Love Me Tender, I can imagine it coming across creepy as hell
In my eyes Indisposed In disguises no one knows Hides the face Lies the snake And the sun in my disgrace Boiling heat Summer stench Neath the black, the sky looks dead Call my name Through the cream And I'll hear you scream again Black hole sun Won't you come And wash away the rain? Black hole sun Won't you come Won't you come Won't you come Stuttering Cold and damp Steal the warm wind, tired friend Times are gone For honest men Sometimes, far too long for snakes In my shoes Walking sleep In my youth, I pray to keep Heaven send Hell away No one sings like you anymore Black hole sun Won't you come And wash away the rain? Black hole sun Won't you come Won't you come Black hole sun Won't you come And wash away the rain? Black hole sun Won't you come Won't you come (Black hole sun, black hole sun) Won't you come (Black hole sun, black hole sun) Won't you come (Black hole sun, black hole sun) Won't you come? (Black hole sun, black hole sun) Hang my head Drown my fear Till you all just disappear Black hole sun Won't you come And wash away the rain? Black hole sun Won't you come Won't you come Black hole sun Won't you come And wash away the rain? Black hole sun Won't you come Won't you come (Black hole sun, black hole sun) Won't you come (Black hole sun, black hole sun) Won't you come (Black hole sun, black hole sun) Won't you come (Black hole sun, black hole sun) Won't you come (Black hole sun, black hole sun) Won't you come (Black hole sun, black hole sun) Won't you come Won't you come
omg i actually love this- it’s so unsettling but kinda funny sounding. It really sounds like a cartoon alien invasion, but the cartoon is one of those adult cartoons and before they’re about to hit earth, they’re hit with this thing that makes all their clothes disappear and it’s kinda gross but then again, it’s a cartoon so it’s just funny. The animations are like little coloured in sketches. They’re like graphic-ish but you can tell it’s been done with a black pen and watercolour. As if they were drawn by Trevor Brighton if you know what/who i mean. They’re in their little ships and the humans are scared and we’re trynna find a way to make them disappear as soon as the hit like the atmosphere layer (or whatever. I’m not that smart) but it doesn’t work out. It only makes them lose their clothes, that’s it. Probably bc the inventor was this doctor-nefario-type guy, from despicable me. Smart but misplaces and mishears things. So the naked aliens actually turn out to be good tho. They had come to warn us about something. idk, maybe a…black hole sun? I honestly don’t know, man. I can’t describe what I’m seeing in my brain but this paragraph should be the best i could do. I love these negative harmony songs so much, and i am literally begging to hear the song sonne by rammstein in negative harmony tho
![BLACK BAG - Official Trailer [HD] - Only in Theaters March 14](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Du0Xp8WX_7I/mqdefault.jpg)
Ah yes, "White Filled Moon" by Silencebuilding
More like silencefree
genius
lol
very shoegaze/dreampop song and band name
ayo what?
There’s so much mode mixture in the original that the overall vibe isn’t even that different. Same deal with Blackbird, iirc. So cool.
I totally disagree I think the vibe ends up being completely different
It really depends what you think is different or not about it. Like some aspects of it are very different and some aren't.
And bohemian
@@althealligator1467For me I think it’s that the original’s verses “lean major” while the chorus “leans minor” so even when that’s flipped, the song still mostly consists of alternating sections of major-ish and minor-ish. This breaks down from the bridge onwards though - the bridge doesn’t resemble anything in the original and there are no more majorish-minorish alternating sections after the last verse
This one is way more morbid sounding
It's kinda funny how this would still fit well for a Soundgarden song
the only reason it sounds normal is bc the melody of this song is just decending notes, so if you have them acending, itll sound pretty much the same just going up the scale
Kinda sounds like audioslave rather than sound garden
This isn't like other dark songs that get the negative harmony treatment. It didn't turn light like the others; it ended up even more unhinged and sinister than the original already was.
If you reverse a black hole, it doesn't become a white hole; it's still a black hole with an opposite charge and spin. Light still can't escape.
I just wanna say I love the metaphor/analogy you did, it's great and I keep thinking about it every time I come back to this
I can't wait to listen "comfortably numb" in negative harmony :)
Or Hey You. The dissonance of the vocals and melody would be too muc
i wanna hear Sonne by Rammstein. I feel like the female vocals would sound so off but still so good.
@@mabus7458 Oh yeah, Hey You would be perfect
Uncomfortably sentient
@@inigohernandezherrero2894a mood
Feels like Radiohead did a Soundgarden cover.
or Soundgarden did a Radiohead cover
This is the first negative harmony cover of yours I've heard that really doesn't feel too different to the original. Kind of like a black hole, and a very dark grey one 😅
I have to disagree with many of the comments here. This version is MUCH darker than the original, and it friggin' slaps.
This version might be darker sounding but the original has much more "dissonance", which makes it equally dark and unsettling IMO.
@@SB-se7vb Technically speaking, they have precisely the same amount of dissonance. That’s the whole point of negative harmony - because all the intervals are perfectly equivalent, it retains precisely the same ratios of dissonance to consonance, tension to resolution, but in an inverted context
The dissonance of the harmony make it
3:01 That riff sounded AWESOME
I was gonna say that
rightt so dark
Nice to see that Nine Inch Nails have still got it
not even remotely comparable
@@rainbowrotcod idk i hear it. just barely but its kinda nin
It sounds even darker. :D
I agree but strangely it feels less depressing. Almost like it's more metal and aggressive.
disorder - joy division, as a negative harmony cover would transcend me to another dimension
omg i need him to do joy division/ new order so bad
Cute dog
Negative harmony Deftones would be really interesting. Maybe Change or Digital Bath would be cool. Sick work on this channel
my brain just rewired ..... it is unbelievable how deep in your blood the original song is....
white mountain moon
damn you beat me to it
Is a mountain the opposite of a hole? 🤔
Btw "hill" would have worked better 😎
@@loweffortproductions1985 depends on the size of the hole I guess
You've managed to preserve the sound of all the tracks without much distortion or artifacts, nice job! The result sounds like a genuine song. So glad the bots aren't tuned to pick these out (yet) so you can upload the whole thing...
With the exception of the Britney Spears Toxic and a-Ha Take On Me version (which are both still great, don't get me wrong), I agree with you.
Wow, this is sooo interesting because even the original harmony is very avant-garde, huh
Love opening RUclips to your videos coming out brand new
I would love to see any King Gizzard and the Lizard Wizard song covered. Love all your work
yes
I'd love to see robot stop or something like that
I want to hear gila monster only it's in this kind of hellscape
Beginners Luck would be great, lots of chords in that one
Already massively over hyped
There are a lot of these that flip their tone, and a few happy songs that stay happy sounding. This is the only one I've run into that's a sad song that stays sad sounding.
The negative harmony version of Creep kind of does it, but it also becomes much more sinister like this one does.
What music are you into now? me: you wouldn't get it 🚬
I REALLY WOULD LOVE TO SEE ONE OF THOSE JEFF BUCKLEY’s songs in negative harmony
exactly what I was thinking
that would be so cool !!
I come back to this often. It's just a damn good song. I'm appreciative of your video here.
Would be really cool if you could have a collab with youtubers who can imitate Chris' voice. To name a few : Anthony Vincent, Denis Pauna, Steve Welsh. But incredible work nonetheless
Amazing work, but any chance you'll be doing any of these from scratch again? I revisit Here Comes the Sun and Somewhere Over the Rainbow for your beautiful voice and production quite a bit!
This one would be really hard to cover!
This is the version in the universe that exist on the other side of said black hole. I think it's only a planck distance away from our universe, like dimensionally.
I didn't do drugs in the 1990s, but if I did, this is probably what it would sound like. Lol!
Why does this actually sound good-
i don't even have any words to describe it, it's amazing
the verses sounds like a mix between muse and queens of the stone age while the chorus sounds like failure (the band)
I thought the chorus sounded like Pearl Jam, but you described the verses perfect!
you should try doing negative harmony Tool songs
!! a hundred times yes !! Tool and A Perfect Circle!
YESSSSS
omf i need to hear negative harmony prison sex
You mean Loot.
@@SB-se7vbNo i mean Tool
That "disappear" is where it's at 3:42 🤣🤣
Woah. It turned into a Cave In song.
First chord here is the same one from Blinded by a Blaze lol
Liked this one, do Limo Wreck next
Always stop by Steve's channel when LSD just doesn't cut it anymore.
Real
White full moon, cool 👍🏻
I became a mouth-breather when the chorus hit. Good lord.
I need freak on a leash in negative harmony lol please!!!!!
Superb execution! Tbh I prefer the solo of this to the original
I want to hear hotel California in negative harmony please!!
I need a nutshell version of this now
It sounds so intensely theatrical this way... my skin is crawling. ❤
I need to see some Type O Negative like this.
I hope you see this, can you please do a negative harmony of somebody that i used to know, that would be epic, love your work btw
I really like your work, and this one is another banger. I’ve been wondering if it would be fine for me to use some of your covers in my RUclips video essays (with proper credit to you of course) because I think their experimental, indie vibe really fits the very specific mood I’m trying to create. Would that be ok?
These are really good!
Would absolutely love to see a negative harmony of pumped kick, dark lyrics with dark music
I'm mesmerized by your negative harmony covers, could you do "the wicked rule the night-avantasia"?
Amazing ! Well done
Very nice thanks for the upload!
Fortunate son, creedance Clearwater next???!!!!!!
Could you do The Stranger or Vienna by Billy Joel? They would sound very interesting. Or just any Billy Joel song you find interesting. I’ve been listening to all your negative harmony covers and they are very interesting. It’s like getting a glimpse of a different universe where music is the opposite, yet remains the same. This was one RUclips rabbit hole I gladly went down. Great work! Keep this up!
Nutshell by AIC needs done😊
Imagine for a moment this principle applied as an entire alternate universe...
3:06 THATS SICK
Quasar Moon
Will she go
Or dry on the snowwww...
This is so weird, I love it. Alone I Break by Korn would be weird to hear.
That's how Goundsarden would sound
the perfect girl negative harmony would be so cool
I really love this song of King Crimson
Please can you make Nothing else matters❤️❤️❤️
Supernova moon
Beautiful
Si un bubu passe par ici je l'aime très fort
In true "superuknown" fashion
If you take requests I’d love to hear Say it Ain’t so by weezer in a negative harmony, honestly i think any weezer song would sound really interesting in a negative harmony
Schism by Tool would probably be a pretty wild negative harmony
The riff at 3:00 actually goes hard as fuck, reminds me of Crowbar or something like that
SO FUCKING AWSOMEEEEE Thanx dude!
these are awesome. ender by finch would be cool to hear in negative harmony.
I love this
please do a no surprises version
sounds like Nine Inch Nails or A Perfect Circle in "Emotive" Album
came here from a video explaining negative harmony , from what I gather the farther away you go into extended chords like in this song , the less related overall to the original it becomes.
in your Beatles covers with mostly simple chords up to 7ths it still relatable to the original .
also couldn't you choose arbitrarily a different axis in this case ?
A different axis yields the same result but in a different key.
And yeah great question, extended chords present a dilemma. In the key of C, Fmaj7 technically inverts to Ebmaj7. But generally in arrangement I find it better, or at least I usually make the choice to invert the simple triad, and then add the extensions, ie. Fmaj7 becomes Gminor(flat6)
i would love to see horse with no name negative harmony if possible 😄
would love to hear you do a velvet underground song.
I am begging you for a negative harmony cover of My Hero by the Foo Fighters.
Literally the chorus turns into a Alice in Chains song...like Frogs or another song with dark riff
Alter bridge
@@aoaoa605 Or maybe Killswitch Engage?
you should do paint it black by rolling stones it would sound amazing i think
The original was already so weird harmonically that this is not so much negative harmony as harmony at right-angles to reality. The end is like a freight train coming at you.
I'd love to hear a negative harmony version of Elvis - Love Me Tender, I can imagine it coming across creepy as hell
For real. If anything it sounds more experimental, maybe more 70s, almost picking up Black Sabbath vibes
Sound like a bit “bones of birds” in their king animal album.
lovely
Ngl i really wanna hear The Adults are Talking by the strokes
Negative harmony for Don’t You Forget About Me, by Complex Bodies. 😛
where is negative harmony cover of bohemian rhapsody? :( I love it
Can you do change by deftones
Could you do Playground Love by Air?
Can you do Hey Jude by the Beatles. Also I feel a heavy song would sound cool, maybe a seasons in the abyss by slayer, or some other heavy metal bands
How do you create the covers? What tool do you use?
In my eyes
Indisposed
In disguises no one knows
Hides the face
Lies the snake
And the sun in my disgrace
Boiling heat
Summer stench
Neath the black, the sky looks dead
Call my name
Through the cream
And I'll hear you scream again
Black hole sun
Won't you come
And wash away the rain?
Black hole sun
Won't you come
Won't you come
Won't you come
Stuttering
Cold and damp
Steal the warm wind, tired friend
Times are gone
For honest men
Sometimes, far too long for snakes
In my shoes
Walking sleep
In my youth, I pray to keep
Heaven send
Hell away
No one sings like you anymore
Black hole sun
Won't you come
And wash away the rain?
Black hole sun
Won't you come
Won't you come
Black hole sun
Won't you come
And wash away the rain?
Black hole sun
Won't you come
Won't you come (Black hole sun, black hole sun)
Won't you come (Black hole sun, black hole sun)
Won't you come (Black hole sun, black hole sun)
Won't you come? (Black hole sun, black hole sun)
Hang my head
Drown my fear
Till you all just disappear
Black hole sun
Won't you come
And wash away the rain?
Black hole sun
Won't you come
Won't you come
Black hole sun
Won't you come
And wash away the rain?
Black hole sun
Won't you come
Won't you come (Black hole sun, black hole sun)
Won't you come (Black hole sun, black hole sun)
Won't you come (Black hole sun, black hole sun)
Won't you come (Black hole sun, black hole sun)
Won't you come (Black hole sun, black hole sun)
Won't you come (Black hole sun, black hole sun)
Won't you come
Won't you come
plz do undone negative harmony cover
Next Number Of The Beast-Iron Maiden!
Acabo de descubrir tu canal y me encanta todo lo que haces✨
Chorus feels like an early 2000s King's X song.
I have a couple! Snowbird (Anne Murray) and Runaway (Del Shannon)
Dude pls do still loving you by the scorpions. I'd love to hear that song in negative harmony pls
The chorus is even doomier than the original
How about something from A Love Supreme? That might be a challenge.
omg i actually love this-
it’s so unsettling but kinda funny sounding. It really sounds like a cartoon alien invasion, but the cartoon is one of those adult cartoons and before they’re about to hit earth, they’re hit with this thing that makes all their clothes disappear and it’s kinda gross but then again, it’s a cartoon so it’s just funny. The animations are like little coloured in sketches. They’re like graphic-ish but you can tell it’s been done with a black pen and watercolour. As if they were drawn by Trevor Brighton if you know what/who i mean. They’re in their little ships and the humans are scared and we’re trynna find a way to make them disappear as soon as the hit like the atmosphere layer (or whatever. I’m not that smart) but it doesn’t work out. It only makes them lose their clothes, that’s it. Probably bc the inventor was this doctor-nefario-type guy, from despicable me. Smart but misplaces and mishears things.
So the naked aliens actually turn out to be good tho. They had come to warn us about something.
idk, maybe a…black hole sun?
I honestly don’t know, man. I can’t describe what I’m seeing in my brain but this paragraph should be the best i could do.
I love these negative harmony songs so much, and i am literally begging to hear the song sonne by rammstein in negative harmony tho
I want to hear big girls dont cry by fergie in negative harmony. i wish that more than just one guy did this
Can you do Feel Good by the Gorillaz? I've been binge listening to a bunch of these. Worth a like and sub!