I like both. I like this more, because she can actually sing. But there's something about closer, that I enjoy. I'm not sure if it's the beat, or the vibes it gives off, but I definitely wouldn't say it's a bad song
I like closer better because it was the song playing when I realized I was in loved with my best friend. He's my boyfriend now, so that song has a special meaning. (: but this song is amazing
Unknown Unknown yeah she sounds so good here! ashley has such a beautiful voice I'm glad she got her jaw fixed because her vocals are more stable and sound so much better
This was SO good. I wish she'd perform this song more or trouble. And that she said the whole you were red and you liked my cause I was blue but this was beautiful!!
props to the pianist the arrangement isn't simplistic in the least and it's so soaring and beautiful, it complements her voice so perfectly and... omg i love her acoustic/stripped versions of her songs. i will never get over this one.
Crippled_Clay, yes... to say Halsey is way better than other singers, I'm so happy the chainsmokers chose Halsey coz before it was Camilla Cabella and Halsey is the major reason for closer to be a hit !
This cover was already amazing, but if you see her perform "Colors" at the Grammy Museum 2019, you will see how much she has improved since then. Such an amazing artist and person❤all the love
I love Ashley so much! She's so talented, but is it just me or does she seem a lot more nervous and uptight than normal? Either way, great performance!
I wouldn't say uptight because that kind of means something else than what it seems you mean. If she was acting uptight she would be acting really snooty and stuff and she isn't, so uptight isn't really a good word for it.
i've been following ashley since before that little video became viral on her tumblr, and it's so fucking amazing to see how far she's grown as an artist. her vocals have become so smooth when needed and she can still keep that rasp. and she's consistently evolving which is so commendable. i love that only one album in and she's killing the game, i can't wait to see where her music takes her.
She's so beautiful that she makes you not want to take your eyes away off of her to look at the comments till she actually finishes the song! Captivating.
This performance is so perfect 👌. She seems nervous and this is making it even more raw. Hands off As , you are one of the best performers . Sending a virtual hug 🤗 !
this song is way better than closer... even the video...
affan ali Right... 🖒
Never understood why people loved closer so much. This song is amazing.
EMPTY FACE its the chainsmokers tag.. and the sheep people are just hyping it
I like both. I like this more, because she can actually sing. But there's something about closer, that I enjoy. I'm not sure if it's the beat, or the vibes it gives off, but I definitely wouldn't say it's a bad song
affan ali true
I like closer better because it was the song playing when I realized I was in loved with my best friend. He's my boyfriend now, so that song has a special meaning. (: but this song is amazing
shoutout to the piano guy
:(
👍
her voice is omg
the guy on the piano deserves an awared of his own
Tony Symonette fck yes
Hadi Muhammad you and your Arab name HARAM
Kiddo zoello grayyo what???
Ainthisshit ❓❓❓what
Ikr lol
Her voice is sensational.
I have goose bumps!!
Halsey inspires me
OMG I always see you everywhere wth
same wtf
Alain Bruno YOU AGAIN, AGAIN, AND AGAIN T^T
That's the best performance of colors yet!!! Oh my god I'll never get over that
She looks out of breath... 🥺
she's actually better than usual
it's probably because she got her jaw fixed a few days ago
Unknown Unknown yeah she sounds so good here! ashley has such a beautiful voice I'm glad she got her jaw fixed because her vocals are more stable and sound so much better
Hey what was halsey jaw problem?
sorry wrong link
she had Temporomandibular disorder (TMD)
Ahhh QUEEN! But can we take a moment for her highlight!?! It's popping
Yeah im here like "i like her highlighter " 😍
She looks like she could be Eleven in ten years.
LOL
Why not eleven years?
1 2 no, their talking about eleven from stranger things
1 2 it’s a show on Netflix
1 2 😀😀😀
The raspiness is just amazing!😭💙💖overall her voice is phenomenal!💙
Her voice calmes me down ... it gives chills and Best perfoms from that
She's so good... I mean.. just so good...
alison overated and pretenious
no
shut up xoxoxoxoxoxox
Hate Haters aww your feelings hurt?
xoxoxoxoxoxox yes, she's a goddess, sing better than her and then you can open your fat mouth
when she started with the song. omg kill me. she is so good..
I love how Ashely was nervous at first but when she started singing the chorus she was enjoying and feeling the song. I love her and her vocals
How can anyone dislike this? OMG, every note that she spelled out of her mouth touched me
OMG I love it she killed that performance!!
Francisco Moreno nobel peace prize was amazing aswell
This was SO good. I wish she'd perform this song more or trouble. And that she said the whole you were red and you liked my cause I was blue but this was beautiful!!
can we just admire how nice and pretty piano arrangement was
props to the pianist the arrangement isn't simplistic in the least and it's so soaring and beautiful, it complements her voice so perfectly and... omg i love her acoustic/stripped versions of her songs. i will never get over this one.
how can someone be so adorable and hot at the same time fUcK
@Done no
she is so graceful
ii dedin kral
One of the artists I really admire that sounds exactly the same on live and their recorded version...I love her!
Holy crap when did she get this good!!
This needs to go viral. She CANNOT be associated with that shitty singer from chainsmokers.
Crippled_Clay hes not shitty at all.
xoxoxoxoxoxox hes a good musician, songswriter and producer but hes definetely a shitty singer lol
Crippled_Clay he needs autotune to sing
lmao 😂
Crippled_Clay, yes... to say Halsey is way better than other singers, I'm so happy the chainsmokers chose Halsey coz before it was Camilla Cabella and Halsey is the major reason for closer to be a hit !
CAN WE JUST TAKE A SECOND TO APPRECIATE HOW MUCH HER VOICE HAS IMPROVED OVER THE YEARS DAMN I'M SHOOK
Her and Lauren J. Need to make a song together omggg
Kim Escobedo you don't know how right you are
well i think they will do...
Kim Escobedo I hope they do
they've got a song called strangers coming up, it's on hopeless fountain kingdom
Yes I saw and I got so happy!!
her voice is so different, she have an amazing talent.
This is definitely one of her best performances! I don't understand why people don't like her.
I really love when artists sing a ballad version of a song that's orginally fun and pop...it really changes the feel of it
I love the nodding part at 1:50 of the girl. It just seems like she is getting what Halsey sings about :)
1:58 she looks proud of herself. she's oozing with confidence. she's like "i"m here, listen to my music." I love that.
She feeeels that shit, for sure!!💗💓
I love Halsey!!! her voice is amazing!!
the piano,her song,her voice, her appearance is just...Amazing😍
she has reached so much... i love you halsey 💕
okaayyyy halseyyy SLAY ME WITH THE VOCALSSSSSS
Her lyrics and the stories she tells are choice better than the boring pop shit out there she is above it
so freaking proud of her!! I love you so much Halsey!!
This performance was three years ago and it's still in my top three best Halsey performances !!!! Ashley freaking killed this one!!!
Her voice is so amazing in this like you truly can't tell the difference between this and the real song
Am I the only one who prefers when she sings live while studio ?
Nope, totally not just you!👍🏼
Her voice is so powerful. She deserves more
love it! half wished she included the spoken part but still good
Omg this was beautiful!! Loved how much emotion was put into it, really proud of how far she's come ❤️
This cover was already amazing, but if you see her perform "Colors" at the Grammy Museum 2019, you will see how much she has improved since then. Such an amazing artist and person❤all the love
by far one of her best performance
That emotion when she said tearing through the pages and the ink omg yes
i love her voice
Halsey makes everything sound pretty, nervous or not she is the fucking best and i love her.
her smile at the end! i melted
I love Ashley so much! She's so talented, but is it just me or does she seem a lot more nervous and uptight than normal? Either way, great performance!
Tabitha Marie yes I noticed that too, but I'm glad she did a great performance anyway 😍
I think it's cuz all the attention is on her vocals and now the performing aspect where she can jump around and be in her element entertaining.
I wouldn't say uptight because that kind of means something else than what it seems you mean. If she was acting uptight she would be acting really snooty and stuff and she isn't, so uptight isn't really a good word for it.
Nerves probably because it a such a meaningful song to her
It's Halsey not Ashley 😂
When i miss her i always come back here.
the mF QUALITY OF THE MIC HER VOICE ITS JUST SO CLEAN HOW HAVE I NEVER SEEN THIS.
What an amazing voice 😍👏🏼
That last note was So SOFT get it Girl!!!
she is perfect
I love her
i've been following ashley since before that little video became viral on her tumblr, and it's so fucking amazing to see how far she's grown as an artist. her vocals have become so smooth when needed and she can still keep that rasp. and she's consistently evolving which is so commendable. i love that only one album in and she's killing the game, i can't wait to see where her music takes her.
I love her she is AMAZING !!
I really don't know Halsey. I don't know her song and her voice didn't do a thing for me before I watched this. THIS is amazing.
literally perfect
She's so beautiful that she makes you not want to take your eyes away off of her to look at the comments till she actually finishes the song! Captivating.
WHAT HAPPEN WITH YOU WERE RED HALSEY TELL ME
hahahahahaha
yosedime she was going threw a miscarriage at that time
She’s not tryna copy tswift infront of all those ppl
Jk I’m obsessed w this song
@@lyndasa oh, really?
0:42 “You’re ripped at every edge but you’re a masterpiece, and now you’re tearing through the pages and the ink.”🎨
she look like 11 form ST
she's live eleven from stranger things but sorta grown up
shadz's channel hi5 man... i had that going on inside my head.
shadz's channel that moment when you are too lazy to write eleven ... juust kidding I sweaaar lol and yea she looks like her a lot
I literally only came into the comments to check to see if someone was thinking this
the lyrics are so highlighted, i have never loved this song more
I swear to god last week she was opening for the kooks and playing in pubs
Halsey is one of just a few singers that I seek out her live versions of her songs. Such a beautiful silky voice!
AWW SHE DIDN'T INCLUDE "YOU WERE RED YOU LIKED ME CAUSE I WAS BLUE. YOU TOUCHED ME AND I WAS LILAC SKY AND YOU DECIDED PURPLE JUST WASN'T FOR YOU"
I WAS WATING FOR THIS TOO! BUT I FORGIVE.
holy shit everyone was stunned. you can see Nick's face at the end of the show, it seems like he was blown away by her performance
I love her smile...
This performance is so perfect 👌. She seems nervous and this is making it even more raw. Hands off As , you are one of the best performers . Sending a virtual hug 🤗 !
sou apaixonada por essa mulher
No doubt, this is one of her best performances ever. Her voice is so clear and she's just so good and she looks so happy.
Holy fucking queen
Alanis Allie You seem so sweet to say that
I don't understand why this hasn't more views. This is her best performance I listen to it almost everyday since a month
Love her & the way she sings 🌹
the high notes made tears come to my eyes i love her so much
im so proud of eleven yall feel me?
Now we know where she is after she'd taken down the demogorgon 😂
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
Ikrrr it's wrong title who is Halsey anyway ? We (stranger things fans) only know Eleven 😂😂🙌🏻🙌🏻💖💕💙
Got to admit- this is the best of her live performances I've watched.
One of the few singers who sound better WITHOUT auto tune
I can't stop watch watching this. I'd love to hear every single one of her songs in a live version like this one.
She has a nice deep beautiful voice *-*
This is the reason why I like Halsey weather its a MV or she's singing live its stay the same.
Damn she killed it
YOU GUYS THIS IS THE TRUE HALSEY THAT I LOVE NOT FROM THE CHAINSMOKERS AND CLOSER , THIS IS OUR PERFECT QUEEN THAT WE WILL SEE IN THE KINGDOM
😍😍😍😍Awww she looks so nervous
This version is also a masterpiece💕💕😭
Nick Jonas is shown at every performance 😂😂
Oh please. Give her more recognition and publicity. Definitely an underrated singer 😢
omg vocals on point SLAY ME MY QUEEN
I remember listening to this live perfomance on my way to my ex's place in the train two years ago..it makes me so emotional..
eleven is so good i can literally die
I’m so much older than this girl yet I feel a soul sister connection that I don’t yet fully understand. ❤️
1:48 totally me
i just keep on returning to this perfomance, is so beautiful
amazing voice !
2:22 wow she has such an amazing voice
I love her
She gives me life in this day of listening options. Really like her as an artist. Beautiful voice.
SLAY
not only is this song beautiful, she has such a unique voice and style. such a talent