If you can follow a person who is pure and sinless; a person who is divine, alive, and next to the Father in heaven; why would you follow a sinful man who is dead? All praise be to God.
1. Linguistically Allah Elahi Eloah Alaha are all linguistic cognates for the one God not "gods" ilah is generic God in Arabic Allah is The One God in Arabic eloh is generic God in Hebrew Elohim is plural so can be used for Gods Eloah or Eloheinu is The One God in Hebrew Hebrew prayers still use Eloheinu e.g. Baruch ata Adonai Eloheinu 2. Aramaic Hebrew Amharic and Arabic are all within the same family Semitic modernly or Afro-Asiatic 3. Factually Prophets such as Joshua Isaiah Elijah all praise YHWH ( btw YaHuWa in Arabic means "Oh He Is" or "Oh He Is the only one who ever was , is , and will ever be." HU and HUWA are referring to the Most High) 4. but what about all the -el prophets names in the Bible? Such as Ezekiel Daniel Ishmael these names praise Eloah or Alaha/Ilahi or Allah s.w.t. 5. Michael Gabriel also the Angels of heaven have -el names only 6. There are at least 72 names of God in Judaism and at least 99 in Islam many are identical Ar Rahman ArRachaman HaShem Hashim El Kodesh Al Quddus Ahad Echad Eloheinu Allah
Also brother rely solely on the Quran. If you rely on the Quran with clean intention you will have no doubt that you’re on the Straight Path if indeed you are. I find it irritating sometimes when they go on with the Arabic. I have credibility in you-no need to regurgitate to sound like a fancy parrot 🦜-now speak in English (or whatever language is yours) for I am keen to listen and learn. Also the Hadiths are BS and written by man 300 years after the death of the Prophet (PBH). Merry Christmas and Peace and Welcome to Islam.
Jesus answered: "My kingdom is not of this world: if my kingdom were of this world, then would my servants fight, that I should not be delivered to the Jews: but now is my kingdom not from hence."
1. Linguistically Allah Elahi Eloah Alaha are all linguistic cognates for the one God not "gods" ilah is generic God in Arabic Allah is The One God in Arabic eloh is generic God in Hebrew Elohim is plural so can be used for Gods Eloah or Eloheinu is The One God in Hebrew Hebrew prayers still use Eloheinu e.g. Baruch ata Adonai Eloheinu 2. Aramaic Hebrew Amharic and Arabic are all within the same family Semitic modernly or Afro-Asiatic 3. Factually Prophets such as Joshua Isaiah Elijah all praise YHWH ( btw YaHuWa in Arabic means "Oh He Is" or "Oh He Is the only one who ever was , is , and will ever be." HU and HUWA are referring to the Most High) 4. but what about all the -el prophets names in the Bible? Such as Ezekiel Daniel Ishmael these names praise Eloah or Alaha/Ilahi or Allah s.w.t. 5. Michael Gabriel also the Angels of heaven have -el names only 6. There are at least 72 names of God in Judaism and at least 99 in Islam many are identical Ar Rahman ArRachaman HaShem Hashim El Kodesh Al Quddus Ahad Echad Eloheinu Allah
I will zelle you $50usd please defeat any of the following numbered facts: 1. Linguistically Allah Elahi Eloah Alaha are all linguistic cognates for the one God not "gods" ilah is generic God in Arabic Allah is The One God in Arabic eloh is generic God in Hebrew Elohim is plural so can be used for Gods Eloah or Eloheinu is The One God in Hebrew Hebrew prayers still use Eloheinu e.g. Baruch ata Adonai Eloheinu 2. Aramaic Hebrew Amharic and Arabic are all within the same family Semitic modernly or Afro-Asiatic 3. Factually Prophets such as Joshua Isaiah Elijah all praise YHWH ( btw YaHuWa in Arabic means "Oh He Is" or "Oh He Is the only one who ever was , is , and will ever be." HU and HUWA are referring to the Most High) 4. but what about all the -el prophets names in the Bible? Such as Ezekiel Daniel Ishmael these names praise Eloah or Alaha/Ilahi or Allah s.w.t. 5. Michael Gabriel also the Angels of heaven have -el names only 6. There are at least 72 names of God in Judaism and at least 99 in Islam many are identical Ar Rahman ArRachaman HaShem Hashim El Kodesh Al Quddus Ahad Echad Eloheinu Allah
By saying, that Jesus has died before completing his message which included violence is a big error on you side. "Jesus died exactly when his mission was complete", his message was calling for " peace and love and forgiveness".. and everything without a doubt went perfectly according to God's plan. Jesus's life is a perfect example of total surrender to God's will.
@@haleemahaleema3236 Why did Allah send Jesus knowing that Christanity would be created? Why did Allah trick people into thinking Jesus was crucified? Why did Allah wait 500+ years to correct the issue he started in the first place?
You are lieying, why follow Mohammed, for more than, other prophet even idolising him, Jesus is not a prophet point of correction, he is God our lord and personal savior, and his kingdom has no end, Amen!!!!
Dr Shabir, what a wise person and what an ambassador for Islam and perhaps all people of the book. I have heard it said many times the Muhammad was a man of violence unlike Jesus. Bear in mind that I'm not actually technically a Muslim I feel many are not comparing apples with apples. Let's look at Jesus, he was a man of peace but he also lived in a very controlled environment, the Roman's ruled with an iron fist otherwise I'm sure the Jews would really have killed him first. Now let's look at Prophet Muhammad, born into the lawless wild west where the only rule was the tribal. He had to marry into tribes to make pacts just like the European royalty did. Often the violence was against people who wanted to stab him inthe back. One man united the Arabs and dormed an Islamic empire that went into North Africa and pushed in Europe through Spain. Remarkable.
@@Steven_Rowe Sorry is that relevant? In your original post you said Jesus is a man of peace. If that were true then why did Jesus shut people like you down and inform them that he did not come to bring peace?
@@br.m Jesus is a man of peace! Did you even understand Jesus’ statement, “I’ve not come to bring peace?” Read it in context and maybe you might understand it.
@@edward1412 I can't understand it then. Can you explain it to me? When Jesus said he did not come to bring peace.. Can you explain how by this statement he meant he came to bring peace? Thanks. Plus, Jesus also said nobody can come be his disciple unless they first hate their spouse, family, even their own life.. Have I taken that out of contest too? Thanks
'By praying the way like the Prophet Muhammad prayed, we are automatically praying as other prophets before him prayed.' A definition of the term 'pray' is important. When Jesus fell on his face to pray, he was clearly making a supplication not performing the shalah. Muslims make supplications by raising the palms of their hands facing upwards. And they fall on their faces when they perform the shalah which is made up of a number of postures.
I am Christian don't acknowledge Muhammad as a prophet but this show is top tier in being unbias and speaking his truth regarding his religious beliefs.
Very cool discussion! Personally, I think that when the Quran says to obey God and obey the messenger, it might not actually be saying to follow Muhammad, but rather, to obey the message that he delivered from God. The problem with the Quran just saying to obey God is that it wouldn't be new instructions for a polytheist, a Jewish person, a Christian person, etc. Such a person would already feel that they're following God. Interestingly, in Sura 46 Verse 9, Muhammad says "I am not a novelty among the messengers, nor do I know what will happen to me or to you. I follow nothing other than what is revealed to me. I am no more than a clear warner."
I think that when the Quran says to obey God and obey the messenger, it might not actually be saying to follow Muhammad, but rather, to obey the message that he delivered from God. - Perfectly Said. Well done. This message was deliberately corrupted to justify the man-made Hadiths to corrupt the religion.
@@ML-jw8kf I don't think all of the Hadith are necessarily manmade, but certainly a lot of them are. To me, they're kind like the New Testament of the Bible, which arguably may have some accuracy, but is still largely heresay from multiple anonymous authors
Prophets weren't violent, they were just. It's important words are chosen carefully. A "violent" man is associated with negativity and injustice. David killed goliath, we Muslims call that justice not violence.
Respect to Dr. Shabir from a Christian. I don't agree with some of the religious ideas but I learned a lot about Islam from this channel, I like your nuanced approach to the subject matter and respect to those of different beliefs. May God make us al standfast in always treating eachother in respect!
@@nattycongo7236 Did the Lord only talk with and love the believers and people who were already saved? I think Scripture will tell you the answer. We are called to be holy and one of those things is to have agape, unconditional love
I thought Messiah means an anointed. Why is shabir saying Messiah means a prophet or king. Even in arabi Maseeh means someone who has been touched. In this case touched by the arch angel Gabriel. .
I asked few Imams regarding the Hadith which says that Prophet Muhammad Aleyhiselam will marry the mother of Jesus Christ ,the sister of prophet Moses Aleyhiselam and the wife of the Pharaoh . That Hadith says prophet Muhammad Aleyhiselam will marry them in the Jannah. I asked what is the reason he to marry them ? The Imams were not able to answer this question.
If Dr. Ally knew any of the prophets, he would know that none of them emphasized the physical details of prayer that the Muslims obsess over. The emphasis is always on a heart that seeks God in all aspects of life and the humility to seek God in the manner he has prescribed. In the Old Testament this meant adherence to the Temple worship and Levitical priesthood as laid out by the Old Covenant, and in the New Testament this is superseded by the perfect temple and the perfect priest, Jesus Christ.
The man who married his adopted son's wife Zaynab Justification given by Muslim apologist is unacceptable to most non muslims Can that man be compared to Jesus Please think, brothers
- How do you know that Islam is good and true? - Because the prophet Mohammed said so. - O.K. And how do we know that Mohammed was a prophet? - Because Mohammed said so. - Ha, ha, ha, ha... Really? O.K. A random guy with no credential whatsoever to be a prophet of God comes along with a pile of nonsense, says that he is a prophet of God, and that is that? Come on, man... Come on man and woman. Jesus is Lord. Merry Christmas.
Peace Dr Shabir and to your Daughter, I do wish people would be respectful, for those who do not have a good thing to say, then say nothing, if you must still say something negative or hatred, then it just shows you haven't read the New Testament or Koran, if you think you have, then clearly you didn't understand them. May God grant you the wisdom to understand this one day.
Jesus actually had a lot of negative things to say. I don't know why everyone thinks he was nice and positive. He said to come be his disciple you must hate. He called the Canaanite woman a dog and tried to ignore her. He left Mary standing out in the cold and denied she is his mother. There are many examples of Jesus being negative and rude and disrespectful. This is why I love Jesus so much he is so real.
Because Jesus pbuh himself said so. I am paraphrasing here. " I have yet many things to say unto you. But you cannot bear them now. How be it. When HE, the spirit of truth shall come, HE, shall lead you unto ALL TRUTHS. it is expedient for me that I go away. For if I go not away, HE, the comforter will not come. But if I go I would send him. HE, will not speak of himself. But whatever HE hears, so shall he speak. HE, shall glorify me. And all the prophets of Allah are ordained to follow a similar format for worshiping the one God.
The quality of this show and its content is way above the clouds. More people should start seeing these episodes. Thank you for creating these videos, @LetTheQuranSpeak ❤
What Islam refers as the last prophet after Jesus is not Muhammad, they mistake it with Holy Spirit. My heart breaks when they even say there is Muhammed in the Bible and quote the scriptures where the Bible refers to Holy Spirit, so that tells me that the whole Islamic religion is found on falsehood.
Dr. Shabir, please accept another public discussion with either Dr. Jay Smith ,Dr. David Wood or perhaps even Christian Prince to explain your opinions of Islam and Christianity. Thank you.
He won't accept he now's they will destroy him muslim scholar's only debate the locals who now's nothing about Islam and its false prohet and pagan moon god IL ilah now cal Allah
The only purpose of Islam is to promote Mohammad, they say they love Jesus Christ but they discredit him in every way. At no time the scriptures say that the Lord Jesus Christ came to dethrone Rome. In the Bible the Lord Jesus Christ speaks about his crucifixion, resurrection, ascension and second coming, where he'll judge mankind.
Why do they pretend to like Jesus? What do they hope to gain from it? In this video Dr. Shabir quotes Jesus in Quran 19:33 and Jesus says the day he will die and be raised to life. In a different video Dr. Shabir said that Muslims think Jesus did not die and so was never raised from the dead. It would seem that Islam is nonsensical. Perhaps some grains of truth are there but it is just a jumbled mess?
There were a lot of verses in the Quran where Muhammed claimed that he was sent to the Arabs only and there are verses in the Bible where Jesus was sent to the whole world not only the Jews. John 3:16.
Hello Honorable Dr Shabir, I am Sharoon a Christian from Pakistan and I want to correct you, that JESUS CHRIST was not only sent to the lost sheep of Israel, but he is the saviour of all World because you haven't read the Mathew Chapter 28, from verse 19 to 20, let me read it for you and all audience "پَس تُم جا کر سب قَوموں کو شاگِرد بناؤ اور اُن کو باپ اور بَیٹے اور رُوحُ القُدس کے نام سے بپتِسمہ دو۔ Go ye therefore, and teach all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost: اور اُن کو یہ تعلِیم دو کہ اُن سب باتوں پر عمل کریں جِن کا مَیں نے تُم کو حُکم دِیا اور دیکھو مَیں دُنیا کے آخِر تک ہمیشہ تُمہارے ساتھ ہُوں۔ Teaching them to observe all things whatsoever I have commanded you: and, lo, I am with you alway, even unto the end of the world. Amen."
Thank you very much for collaborating the issue that your fellow ZAKIR NAIK has refuted absolutely... IS IS THIS THAT JESUS WAS CRUCIFIED ON THE CALVARY CROSS AT MOUTT GOLGOTHA. please call ZAKIR NAIK and tell him to correct his statements!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
@@fidelcatsro6948 List the church fathers that agree with you. We have your heresy being refuted by the church fathers. It was a gnostic view that sprung up later and we have writings against it. It was a heretical view that was nonsensical.
@@fidelcatsro6948 listen... i said ADMONISH THIS IMAM named SHABIR here... he has said JESUS WAS CRUCIFIED. May I ask you Fidel, WHAT WAS THE ROMAN CAPITAL PUNISHMENT FOR CRIMES COMMITTED IN THE SAME MANNER AS CHRIST WAS ACCUSED OF? and HOW WAS SUCH A SENTENCE CARRIED OUT?
@@thedemocrat7592 naaaah according to your bible, Jesus was supposedly put on a T bar on Friday afternoon and then taken by Friday evening for Sabbeth, you dont die on a T bar in 5 or 6 hours!! Romans put prisoners on the bar for several days even up to a week before they die...so Jesus never died on the T bar!
Even though there's almost no information about Muhammad in the Quran itself, it's also impossible to base the Islamic practice on Jesus or any other Prophet, because the Quran doesn't have much information about them as well. However, about 85% of the Islamic sources are the Hadith/Sirah, which are focused almost exclusively on Muhammad and his personal companions, that's why the mainstream Islam is almost exclusively about Muhammad.
And this is a big problem. This is why Islam is in a state of corruption today, because Muslims have kept the Quran aside and are obsessed with man-made Hadiths.
@@ML-jw8kf Agree, but keep in mind that the Quran is such a short book, with so little information about its authors, or even the previous Prophets, that the Hadith/Sirah are absolutely necessary for Islam to be functional in practice.
@@ivanos_95 Are you sure? When Allah himself says the Book is COMPLETE and he says the Book is FULLY DETAILED and then he specifically asks the question - In Which other Hadiths other that Quran will you all believe? What justification then do you have to say Hadiths will COMPLETE and provide DETAILS to the Quran?
Simple, a true savior must pay the price for all mankind. So the question is what is the price? The price answers to the debt. Man's debt and problem is sin. So, the true savior must come to pay the price for sin. To pay that price one must be holy and meet the demand of God. So between Jesus Christ and Muhammad, who was holy. Who never sinned, who sinned. Just a clue, Muhammad married. Find out who.
That is true Dr. Shabir ally.why don't people consider that it is really the act of God to send another massager after the one passed away or taken away.so why is it to be surprise of sending the prophet Muhammad after our prophet Jesus.
They’re all equal. It is the disbelievers who say we will take some and leave others. All prophets are the same. One isn’t better than the other. It doesn’t say “we have favored some among others,” it says “we have caused some to exceed others [in tasks], we gave Jesus Son of Mary the gospel, we gave David the book of psalms….” To exceed others means in tasks. In what they do. Not to favor some among others. Also: If you say Muhammad you say them all. Muhammad means from Jesus to Abraham. Also: following doesn’t mean emulating him to a T. I’m 36 now and still single… I have failed to emulate The Prophet (PBH) because I didn’t marry a lady named Khadija (PBH) at 25 when she was 40…. So I might as well kill myself now right?! The Hadiths are BS. Yep. I just said that. I bear witness that there is no god but Allah, and I bear witness that Muhammad is the messenger of Allah.
The text under the video states, "Dr. Shabir points out that in the biblical record, the underlying motif was for Jesus to be son of David, the Messiah, *and his role was to overthrow Roman rule to establish the Kingdom of God on earth* . " "According to the Bible, *he was crucified, so he didn't fulfill this role of violent Messiah* ." Shabir- So this is your conclusion about the Biblical Jesus? I hope not since the New Testament narrative never suggests Jesus came to overthrow the government in any way. And to suggest that the Kingdom of GOD was to be built upon the bloody deaths of humans is a blasphemy against GOD Who needs no one and nothing to build His Kingdom *WHICH IS HEAVEN* . Jesus famously said "he who lives by the sword shall die by the sword". In so many of Muhammad's military battles, this came deadly true for many of his followers. And Muhammad was not merely being defensive as you suggest, but he actively attacked peaceful Jews, pagans and Christians in order to force himself and his religion upon them! The number of swords among the followers of Jesus were 2 (TWO!) swords! Now what conquering could 2 swords do against the entire Roman army? None, except to claim that Jesus was among those who deserved to be crucified along with the thieves on Calvary--- IF you were looking for any kind of thin proof to get rid of him. It's interesting that you, a prominent muslim cleric, define the Messiah of Christianity to be a military leader and conqueror, while as a Muhammadan, you cannot explain how your own Isa fulfills the role of Messiah except to say he was anointed-- while not identifying when and by whom, nor specifying any of the hundreds of Jewish prophecies to be about his coming. Muhammad fits the role of a conquering theocratic military commander; maybe he is the Muhammadan meshiach to the Jews?
Ironic how people say that Islam disrespects women and encourages slavery when most of the early converts to Islam were women and/or slaves. Subhanallah and alhamdilallah for Islam
And that is the fundamental problem of Islam. That you are required to follow a man who lacks character, courage, conviction, compassion leading to confusion in history thus the Quran is not from the One True God. Calling Jesus anything else is simply muddying the water. You shouldn’t follow a prophet who lack the above mention details. He is not the universal prophet! Just because it is said so I’m the Quran! Jesus does say his message was first to the lost Jews and then to be spread to all humans! Muhammad never left Arabia! The Quran apart from the Hadith is so unclear - so to say the Quran was the final book for mankind is false. The statements making the Quran say things that are not found within the Quran but only later in the Hadith 200 years later only after they came across the greatness of the New Testament! The myth about woman right is so wrong. Read the Hadith and ask where will the majority of women be according to your prophet? Come to the real Jesus not the fable Isa
What's the difference between biblical peace and Quranic peace and us the peace of Jesus a little different from both because biblical peace can have something to do with the old testament scriptures under the law while new testament covenants scriptures peace that Jesus brought or gave was a little something some what different it seems to be more intimate and special heavenly perhaps
If I was a Muslim, I would be anxious about not following the only prophet who was born of a virgin, the greatest woman ever; the only prophet who was pure and sinless; the only prophet who was a giver of life; the only prophet who said "I am the first and the last"; the only prophet who ascended to Heaven and is with the Father in Heaven, and will return and be king. I would be nervous. Very nervous. That "prophet" was clearly a lot more than just a prophet. All praise be to God.
Don't you think Elijah ascended in to Heaven? Scripture seems to indicate that he was taken and ascended in to heaven. Some people argue that he was not taken to heaven, and that he was just spared death like Enoch. However scripture indicates that Enoch did not experience death and was taken from life directly to Sheol without experiencing death. For Elijah it seems clear that he was taken to heaven and ascended in to heaven. What actually sets Jesus apart is that he came down from Heaven. No other prophet came down from Heaven only Jesus. You are right Jesus is more than a prophet. He is the priest king the new Melchizedek. This is why Jesus never cared to preach anything more than the coming Kingdom. He did not need to make a kingdom or order on earth. His kingdom has been established in Heaven.
I think the answer is to follow Jesu s simply because he is Holy, of unique birth, sinless, with power to perform miracles including raising the dead plus he is right now in heaven, while Muhammad demonstrates none of these things. That's why your followers are concerned Dr. Ali
Comments here are now being deleted I like Shabir ally, he is the best apologist I've seen But there are some islamic history that I find disturbing But why delete comments you don't like And keep the ones you like I think this is not correct I put my comments in a respectful way I never use foul language
Im sorry Jesus already told you "in order for the paraclete to come, it is expedient that i go away" Jesus was telling you to prepare for the next parakleytos to come..time to move on and accept the last and final messeger sent to all mankind🐱👍🏿
Mankind will follow the noble prophet for he represent universal values, brotherhood... if there is something that make his followers different then its only in the expression and exclusivity of our worships and rituals.. the christians prays but we prays five time a day, the jews fast but we fast on ramadan... but our universal values are the same... our commonalities the kalimatis sawa shared by all nations.. if killing is wrong in Islam then it wrong in japan in brazil in china etc...
@@fidelcatsro6948 . That is parable.. we’re a Christian. It doesn’t mean we eat the and drink the blood of Jesus.. .. but all Muslims .. everything that Mohammad said is From Allah!!!! Sigh..
@@robust5615 , hahaha! Do you?? Your book exist only 620 years after Jesus died on the cross.. your book only copy paste of Tora , Bible and Hindu.. ..
your common sense should tell you to follow a living Prophet Jesus instead of a dead prophet.. more over Jesus is coming again as a judge and He will also judge mohammed for his sins..
If you can follow a person who is pure and sinless; a person who is divine, alive, and next to the Father in heaven; why would you follow a sinful man who is dead?
All praise be to God.
The thing is muslims believe in the sinlessness of all prophets so for them Mohammed is not sinful nor was David or any of this other proohets
1. Linguistically
Allah Elahi Eloah Alaha are all linguistic cognates for the one God not "gods"
ilah is generic God in Arabic
Allah is The One God in Arabic
eloh is generic God in Hebrew
Elohim is plural so can be used for Gods
Eloah or Eloheinu is The One God in Hebrew
Hebrew prayers still use Eloheinu e.g. Baruch ata Adonai Eloheinu
2. Aramaic Hebrew Amharic and Arabic are all within the same family Semitic modernly or Afro-Asiatic
3. Factually
Prophets such as Joshua Isaiah Elijah all praise YHWH ( btw YaHuWa in Arabic means "Oh He Is" or "Oh He Is the only one who ever was , is , and will ever be." HU and HUWA are referring to the Most High)
4. but what about all the -el prophets names in the Bible? Such as Ezekiel Daniel Ishmael these names praise Eloah or Alaha/Ilahi or Allah s.w.t.
5. Michael Gabriel also the Angels of heaven have -el names only
6. There are at least 72 names of God in Judaism and at least 99 in Islam many are identical Ar Rahman ArRachaman
HaShem Hashim El Kodesh Al Quddus Ahad Echad Eloheinu Allah
As someone who grew up Catholic and am relatively new to Islam, I appreciate these videos.
May the Lord bless you and to your family.. be prepared, you can’t pray to all non Muslims. But we can for you… 🙏🙏🙏🙏
You have to repent and go back, it can be a long journey to realize it's false but you have to.
I also grew up Catholic and now am new Muslim. Alhamdulillah all praise is due to the Lord of the Worlds.
Also brother rely solely on the Quran. If you rely on the Quran with clean intention you will have no doubt that you’re on the Straight Path if indeed you are.
I find it irritating sometimes when they go on with the Arabic. I have credibility in you-no need to regurgitate to sound like a fancy parrot 🦜-now speak in English (or whatever language is yours) for I am keen to listen and learn.
Also the Hadiths are BS and written by man 300 years after the death of the Prophet (PBH).
Merry Christmas and Peace and Welcome to Islam.
Please read the Gospels and then see what it says about Jesus Christ, then see if Islam lines up with the eyewitnesses accounts.
Jesus answered: "My kingdom is not of this world: if my kingdom were of this world, then would my servants fight, that I should not be delivered to the Jews: but now is my kingdom not from hence."
1. Linguistically
Allah Elahi Eloah Alaha are all linguistic cognates for the one God not "gods"
ilah is generic God in Arabic
Allah is The One God in Arabic
eloh is generic God in Hebrew
Elohim is plural so can be used for Gods
Eloah or Eloheinu is The One God in Hebrew
Hebrew prayers still use Eloheinu e.g. Baruch ata Adonai Eloheinu
2. Aramaic Hebrew Amharic and Arabic are all within the same family Semitic modernly or Afro-Asiatic
3. Factually
Prophets such as Joshua Isaiah Elijah all praise YHWH ( btw YaHuWa in Arabic means "Oh He Is" or "Oh He Is the only one who ever was , is , and will ever be." HU and HUWA are referring to the Most High)
4. but what about all the -el prophets names in the Bible? Such as Ezekiel Daniel Ishmael these names praise Eloah or Alaha/Ilahi or Allah s.w.t.
5. Michael Gabriel also the Angels of heaven have -el names only
6. There are at least 72 names of God in Judaism and at least 99 in Islam many are identical Ar Rahman ArRachaman
HaShem Hashim El Kodesh Al Quddus Ahad Echad Eloheinu Allah
Allah is Eloah / Eloheinu is Ilahi Alaha
I will zelle you $50usd please defeat any of the following numbered facts:
1. Linguistically
Allah Elahi Eloah Alaha are all linguistic cognates for the one God not "gods"
ilah is generic God in Arabic
Allah is The One God in Arabic
eloh is generic God in Hebrew
Elohim is plural so can be used for Gods
Eloah or Eloheinu is The One God in Hebrew
Hebrew prayers still use Eloheinu e.g. Baruch ata Adonai Eloheinu
2. Aramaic Hebrew Amharic and Arabic are all within the same family Semitic modernly or Afro-Asiatic
3. Factually
Prophets such as Joshua Isaiah Elijah all praise YHWH ( btw YaHuWa in Arabic means "Oh He Is" or "Oh He Is the only one who ever was , is , and will ever be." HU and HUWA are referring to the Most High)
4. but what about all the -el prophets names in the Bible? Such as Ezekiel Daniel Ishmael these names praise Eloah or Alaha/Ilahi or Allah s.w.t.
5. Michael Gabriel also the Angels of heaven have -el names only
6. There are at least 72 names of God in Judaism and at least 99 in Islam many are identical Ar Rahman ArRachaman
HaShem Hashim El Kodesh Al Quddus Ahad Echad Eloheinu Allah
By saying, that Jesus has died before completing his message which included violence is a big error on you side. "Jesus died exactly when his mission was complete", his message was calling for " peace and love and forgiveness".. and everything without a doubt went perfectly according to God's plan. Jesus's life is a perfect example of total surrender to God's will.
Jesus is King !
You are in a big wrong.... don't just say but you have to know from the al-Qur'an... 👌
@@haleemahaleema3236 Why did Allah send Jesus knowing that Christanity would be created? Why did Allah trick people into thinking Jesus was crucified? Why did Allah wait 500+ years to correct the issue he started in the first place?
You are lieying, why follow Mohammed, for more than, other prophet even idolising him, Jesus is not a prophet point of correction, he is God our lord and personal savior, and his kingdom has no end, Amen!!!!
Dr Shabir, what a wise person and what an ambassador for Islam and perhaps all people of the book.
I have heard it said many times the Muhammad was a man of violence unlike Jesus.
Bear in mind that I'm not actually technically a Muslim I feel many are not comparing apples with apples.
Let's look at Jesus, he was a man of peace but he also lived in a very controlled environment, the Roman's ruled with an iron fist otherwise I'm sure the Jews would really have killed him first.
Now let's look at Prophet Muhammad, born into the lawless wild west where the only rule was the tribal.
He had to marry into tribes to make pacts just like the European royalty did.
Often the violence was against people who wanted to stab him inthe back.
One man united the Arabs and dormed an Islamic empire that went into North Africa and pushed in Europe through Spain.
Remarkable.
Please do not think that Jesus came to bring peace.
@Brother.M wow you can quote Jesusso can I.
Matt 5 v9
Blessed are the peacemakers, they shall be called sons of GOD.
@@Steven_Rowe Sorry is that relevant? In your original post you said Jesus is a man of peace. If that were true then why did Jesus shut people like you down and inform them that he did not come to bring peace?
@@br.m
Jesus is a man of peace!
Did you even understand Jesus’ statement, “I’ve not come to bring peace?”
Read it in context and maybe you might understand it.
@@edward1412 I can't understand it then. Can you explain it to me? When Jesus said he did not come to bring peace.. Can you explain how by this statement he meant he came to bring peace? Thanks.
Plus, Jesus also said nobody can come be his disciple unless they first hate their spouse, family, even their own life.. Have I taken that out of contest too? Thanks
'By praying the way like the Prophet Muhammad prayed, we are automatically praying as other prophets before him prayed.'
A definition of the term 'pray' is important. When Jesus fell on his face to pray, he was clearly making a supplication not performing the shalah. Muslims make supplications by raising the palms of their hands facing upwards. And they fall on their faces when they perform the shalah which is made up of a number of
postures.
Jesus is Lord❤️
When you said, he was the Lord... What you mean?
no Lord become human. that is degrade
@@robust5615 , No lord to be a deceiver… that is satan …
@@robust5615 SAHIH MUSLIM 2749, BOOK 50, HADITH 13.. your Allah is a deceiver…
@@olanmanila what deceiver?
I am Christian don't acknowledge Muhammad as a prophet but this show is top tier in being unbias and speaking his truth regarding his religious beliefs.
Thank you. We appreciate your comment ❤️
Good for you then
Very cool discussion! Personally, I think that when the Quran says to obey God and obey the messenger, it might not actually be saying to follow Muhammad, but rather, to obey the message that he delivered from God. The problem with the Quran just saying to obey God is that it wouldn't be new instructions for a polytheist, a Jewish person, a Christian person, etc. Such a person would already feel that they're following God. Interestingly, in Sura 46 Verse 9, Muhammad says "I am not a novelty among the messengers, nor do I know what will happen to me or to you. I follow nothing other than what is revealed to me. I am no more than a clear warner."
There are no problems with the Quran
If anyone don't obey Mohammad is the last messenger of Allah then no one is muslim.
@@anonymous2150 I suggest we do our best to follow Prophet Muhammad. Not following him perfectly is just part of being an imperfect human.
I think that when the Quran says to obey God and obey the messenger, it might not actually be saying to follow Muhammad, but rather, to obey the message that he delivered from God. - Perfectly Said. Well done. This message was deliberately corrupted to justify the man-made Hadiths to corrupt the religion.
@@ML-jw8kf
I don't think all of the Hadith are necessarily manmade, but certainly a lot of them are. To me, they're kind like the New Testament of the Bible, which arguably may have some accuracy, but is still largely heresay from multiple anonymous authors
Prophets weren't violent, they were just. It's important words are chosen carefully. A "violent" man is associated with negativity and injustice. David killed goliath, we Muslims call that justice not violence.
Respect to Dr. Shabir from a Christian. I don't agree with some of the religious ideas but I learned a lot about Islam from this channel, I like your nuanced approach to the subject matter and respect to those of different beliefs. May God make us al standfast in always treating eachother in respect!
Who do you respect a man that's on his way to hell. The blood of Jesus Christ is the only way for forgiveness of sins, which Muslims deny
@@nattycongo7236 Did the Lord only talk with and love the believers and people who were already saved? I think Scripture will tell you the answer. We are called to be holy and one of those things is to have agape, unconditional love
ask him on my behalf who brought Mohammed..why did Mohamed say he's the last messenger..who prophesied his coming? where is he mentioned?
go read isaiah 42 where is kedar and sela?? which prophet came from there?? Uncle Paul?
do u know where is sela and kedar??
I thought Messiah means an anointed. Why is shabir saying Messiah means a prophet or king. Even in arabi Maseeh means someone who has been touched. In this case touched by the arch angel Gabriel. .
I asked few Imams regarding the Hadith which says that Prophet Muhammad Aleyhiselam will marry the mother of Jesus Christ ,the sister of prophet Moses Aleyhiselam and the wife of the Pharaoh . That Hadith says prophet Muhammad Aleyhiselam will marry them in the Jannah. I asked what is the reason he to marry them ? The Imams were not able to answer this question.
If Dr. Ally knew any of the prophets, he would know that none of them emphasized the physical details of prayer that the Muslims obsess over. The emphasis is always on a heart that seeks God in all aspects of life and the humility to seek God in the manner he has prescribed. In the Old Testament this meant adherence to the Temple worship and Levitical priesthood as laid out by the Old Covenant, and in the New Testament this is superseded by the perfect temple and the perfect priest, Jesus Christ.
The man who married his adopted son's wife Zaynab
Justification given by Muslim apologist is unacceptable to most non muslims
Can that man be compared to Jesus
Please think, brothers
- How do you know that Islam is good and true?
- Because the prophet Mohammed said so.
- O.K. And how do we know that Mohammed was a prophet?
- Because Mohammed said so.
- Ha, ha, ha, ha... Really? O.K.
A random guy with no credential whatsoever to be a prophet of God comes along with a pile of nonsense, says that he is a prophet of God, and that is that?
Come on, man... Come on man and woman.
Jesus is Lord.
Merry Christmas.
That's a nice deceptive answer. Satan would be proud.
Jesus is God quran vers they have taken there rabbits and there monks as God's besides Allah and the messiah the son of Mary
Peace Dr Shabir and to your Daughter, I do wish people would be respectful, for those who do not have a good thing to say, then say nothing, if you must still say something negative or hatred, then it just shows you haven't read the New Testament or Koran, if you think you have, then clearly you didn't understand them. May God grant you the wisdom to understand this one day.
Jesus actually had a lot of negative things to say. I don't know why everyone thinks he was nice and positive. He said to come be his disciple you must hate. He called the Canaanite woman a dog and tried to ignore her. He left Mary standing out in the cold and denied she is his mother. There are many examples of Jesus being negative and rude and disrespectful. This is why I love Jesus so much he is so real.
Thanks Shabir Ally for this concise but yet enlightening answer
Because Jesus pbuh himself said so. I am paraphrasing here. " I have yet many things to say unto you. But you cannot bear them now. How be it. When HE, the spirit of truth shall come, HE, shall lead you unto ALL TRUTHS. it is expedient for me that I go away. For if I go not away, HE, the comforter will not come. But if I go I would send him. HE, will not speak of himself. But whatever HE hears, so shall he speak. HE, shall glorify me. And all the prophets of Allah are ordained to follow a similar format for worshiping the one God.
The quality of this show and its content is way above the clouds. More people should start seeing these episodes. Thank you for creating these videos, @LetTheQuranSpeak ❤
Thank you, Sarmad! Please help us by sharing our videos with your friends and family.
@@QuranSpeaks I already gladly do that 🤗
What Islam refers as the last prophet after Jesus is not Muhammad, they mistake it with Holy Spirit.
My heart breaks when they even say there is Muhammed in the Bible and quote the scriptures where the Bible refers to Holy Spirit, so that tells me that the whole Islamic religion is found on falsehood.
Dr. Shabir, please accept another public discussion with either Dr. Jay Smith ,Dr. David Wood or perhaps even Christian Prince to explain your opinions of Islam and Christianity. Thank you.
He won't accept he now's they will destroy him muslim scholar's only debate the locals who now's nothing about Islam and its false prohet and pagan moon god IL ilah now cal Allah
The only purpose of Islam is to promote Mohammad, they say they love Jesus Christ but they discredit him in every way. At no time the scriptures say that the Lord Jesus Christ came to dethrone Rome. In the Bible the Lord Jesus Christ speaks about his crucifixion, resurrection, ascension and second coming, where he'll judge mankind.
Why do they pretend to like Jesus? What do they hope to gain from it? In this video Dr. Shabir quotes Jesus in Quran 19:33 and Jesus says the day he will die and be raised to life. In a different video Dr. Shabir said that Muslims think Jesus did not die and so was never raised from the dead. It would seem that Islam is nonsensical. Perhaps some grains of truth are there but it is just a jumbled mess?
Thank you Mr shabir
New testament was written by jews that believed Jesus was the messiah. Not by gentiles
Obey the Quran, and follow only the Sunnah of Allah. The Way of God.
Boss, there is sunnah of Allah but Muhammad
There were a lot of verses in the Quran where Muhammed claimed that he was sent to the Arabs only and there are verses in the Bible where Jesus was sent to the whole world not only the Jews.
John 3:16.
Show us Edward
Hello Honorable Dr Shabir, I am Sharoon a Christian from Pakistan and I want to correct you, that JESUS CHRIST was not only sent to the lost sheep of Israel, but he is the saviour of all World because you haven't read the Mathew Chapter 28, from verse 19 to 20, let me read it for you and all audience "پَس تُم جا کر سب قَوموں کو شاگِرد بناؤ اور اُن کو باپ اور بَیٹے اور رُوحُ القُدس کے نام سے بپتِسمہ دو۔
Go ye therefore, and teach all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost:
اور اُن کو یہ تعلِیم دو کہ اُن سب باتوں پر عمل کریں جِن کا مَیں نے تُم کو حُکم دِیا اور دیکھو مَیں دُنیا کے آخِر تک ہمیشہ تُمہارے ساتھ ہُوں۔
Teaching them to observe all things whatsoever I have commanded you: and, lo, I am with you alway, even unto the end of the world. Amen."
The difference is, we dont mere following Jesus, we Worship Him..
Can you worship Muhammad?
Of course not....
Even if you’re not religious, you would definitely follow Jesus Christ if you have to choose.
Thank you very much for collaborating the issue that your fellow ZAKIR NAIK has refuted absolutely... IS IS THIS THAT JESUS WAS CRUCIFIED ON THE CALVARY CROSS AT MOUTT GOLGOTHA. please call ZAKIR NAIK and tell him to correct his statements!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
of cos Jesus wasnt crucifed even many church fathers back then believe Jesus was not crucified..you follow uncle paul not jesus!
@@fidelcatsro6948 List the church fathers that agree with you. We have your heresy being refuted by the church fathers. It was a gnostic view that sprung up later and we have writings against it. It was a heretical view that was nonsensical.
@@fidelcatsro6948 That's where Islaaam takes it from. This gnostic view that sprung up and refuted by the church fathers.
@@fidelcatsro6948 listen... i said ADMONISH THIS IMAM named SHABIR here... he has said JESUS WAS CRUCIFIED. May I ask you Fidel, WHAT WAS THE ROMAN CAPITAL PUNISHMENT FOR CRIMES COMMITTED IN THE SAME MANNER AS CHRIST WAS ACCUSED OF? and HOW WAS SUCH A SENTENCE CARRIED OUT?
@@thedemocrat7592 naaaah according to your bible, Jesus was supposedly put on a T bar on Friday afternoon and then taken by Friday evening for Sabbeth, you dont die on a T bar in 5 or 6 hours!! Romans put prisoners on the bar for several days even up to a week before they die...so Jesus never died on the T bar!
Even though there's almost no information about Muhammad in the Quran itself, it's also impossible to base the Islamic practice on Jesus or any other Prophet, because the Quran doesn't have much information about them as well. However, about 85% of the Islamic sources are the Hadith/Sirah, which are focused almost exclusively on Muhammad and his personal companions, that's why the mainstream Islam is almost exclusively about Muhammad.
Doesnt need info regarding other prophets they would have a similar way of praying
And this is a big problem. This is why Islam is in a state of corruption today, because Muslims have kept the Quran aside and are obsessed with man-made Hadiths.
@@ML-jw8kf Agree, but keep in mind that the Quran is such a short book, with so little information about its authors, or even the previous Prophets, that the Hadith/Sirah are absolutely necessary for Islam to be functional in practice.
@@ivanos_95 Are you sure? When Allah himself says the Book is COMPLETE and he says the Book is FULLY DETAILED and then he specifically asks the question - In Which other Hadiths other that Quran will you all believe? What justification then do you have to say Hadiths will COMPLETE and provide DETAILS to the Quran?
@@ML-jw8kf If that's really what Allah meant, then he was seriously wrong, because Islam as an organized religion doesn't work without the Hadith.
The Messiah is the “Son of David”according to the Old Testament, so how could you say that you believe Jesus is the Messiah, but not the son of David?
It’s easy you want to be violent person follow muhammad , do you want to be a peaceful person who loves people ? Follow Jesus Christ !
If I wanted be a peaceful person that loves people, I would respect other people's faiths.
Simple, a true savior must pay the price for all mankind.
So the question is what is the price? The price answers to the debt. Man's debt and problem is sin.
So, the true savior must come to pay the price for sin. To pay that price one must be holy and meet the demand of God.
So between Jesus Christ and Muhammad, who was holy. Who never sinned, who sinned.
Just a clue, Muhammad married. Find out who.
That is true Dr. Shabir ally.why don't people consider that it is really the act of God to send another massager after the one passed away or taken away.so why is it to be surprise of sending the prophet Muhammad after our prophet Jesus.
They’re all equal. It is the disbelievers who say we will take some and leave others. All prophets are the same. One isn’t better than the other.
It doesn’t say “we have favored some among others,” it says “we have caused some to exceed others [in tasks], we gave Jesus Son of Mary the gospel, we gave David the book of psalms….”
To exceed others means in tasks. In what they do. Not to favor some among others.
Also: If you say Muhammad you say them all. Muhammad means from Jesus to Abraham.
Also: following doesn’t mean emulating him to a T. I’m 36 now and still single… I have failed to emulate The Prophet (PBH) because I didn’t marry a lady named Khadija (PBH) at 25 when she was 40…. So I might as well kill myself now right?!
The Hadiths are BS. Yep. I just said that.
I bear witness that there is no god but Allah, and I bear witness that Muhammad is the messenger of Allah.
The text under the video states, "Dr. Shabir points out that in the biblical record, the underlying motif was for Jesus to be son of David, the Messiah, *and his role was to overthrow Roman rule to establish the Kingdom of God on earth* . "
"According to the Bible, *he was crucified, so he didn't fulfill this role of violent Messiah* ."
Shabir- So this is your conclusion about the Biblical Jesus?
I hope not since the New Testament narrative never suggests Jesus came to overthrow the government in any way. And to suggest that the Kingdom of GOD was to be built upon the bloody deaths of humans is a blasphemy against GOD Who needs no one and nothing to build His Kingdom *WHICH IS HEAVEN* .
Jesus famously said "he who lives by the sword shall die by the sword". In so many of Muhammad's military battles, this came deadly true for many of his followers. And Muhammad was not merely being defensive as you suggest, but he actively attacked peaceful Jews, pagans and Christians in order to force himself and his religion upon them!
The number of swords among the followers of Jesus were 2 (TWO!) swords! Now what conquering could 2 swords do against the entire Roman army? None, except to claim that Jesus was among those who deserved to be crucified along with the thieves on Calvary--- IF you were looking for any kind of thin proof to get rid of him.
It's interesting that you, a prominent muslim cleric, define the Messiah of Christianity to be a military leader and conqueror, while as a Muhammadan, you cannot explain how your own Isa fulfills the role of Messiah except to say he was anointed-- while not identifying when and by whom, nor specifying any of the hundreds of Jewish prophecies to be about his coming.
Muhammad fits the role of a conquering theocratic military commander; maybe he is the Muhammadan meshiach to the Jews?
Well said: Sheikh...!!!
Follow Gods Words ! YOU follow The Message The Messengers Bought ! MAY allah Guide Us All !
Ironic how people say that Islam disrespects women and encourages slavery when most of the early converts to Islam were women and/or slaves. Subhanallah and alhamdilallah for Islam
A war load can never be compared to Jesus please
Why should I believe there is ANY GOD AT ALL? Could you disprove atheism? Thanks.
And that is the fundamental problem of Islam. That you are required to follow a man who lacks character, courage, conviction, compassion leading to confusion in history thus the Quran is not from the One True God. Calling Jesus anything else is simply muddying the water. You shouldn’t follow a prophet who lack the above mention details. He is not the universal prophet! Just because it is said so I’m the Quran! Jesus does say his message was first to the lost Jews and then to be spread to all humans! Muhammad never left Arabia! The Quran apart from the Hadith is so unclear - so to say the Quran was the final book for mankind is false. The statements making the Quran say things that are not found within the Quran but only later in the Hadith 200 years later only after they came across the greatness of the New Testament! The myth about woman right is so wrong. Read the Hadith and ask where will the majority of women be according to your prophet?
Come to the real Jesus not the fable Isa
It is very simple. One is alive and one is dead. Make your choice!
Innadina Indalahil Islam!
Takbeer!
What's the difference between biblical peace and Quranic peace and us the peace of Jesus a little different from both because biblical peace can have something to do with the old testament scriptures under the law while new testament covenants scriptures peace that Jesus brought or gave was a little something some what different it seems to be more intimate and special heavenly perhaps
If I was a Muslim, I would be anxious about not following the only prophet who was born of a virgin, the greatest woman ever;
the only prophet who was pure and sinless;
the only prophet who was a giver of life;
the only prophet who said "I am the first and the last";
the only prophet who ascended to Heaven and is with the Father in Heaven, and will return and be king.
I would be nervous. Very nervous.
That "prophet" was clearly a lot more than just a prophet.
All praise be to God.
Don't you think Elijah ascended in to Heaven? Scripture seems to indicate that he was taken and ascended in to heaven. Some people argue that he was not taken to heaven, and that he was just spared death like Enoch. However scripture indicates that Enoch did not experience death and was taken from life directly to Sheol without experiencing death. For Elijah it seems clear that he was taken to heaven and ascended in to heaven.
What actually sets Jesus apart is that he came down from Heaven. No other prophet came down from Heaven only Jesus. You are right Jesus is more than a prophet. He is the priest king the new Melchizedek. This is why Jesus never cared to preach anything more than the coming Kingdom. He did not need to make a kingdom or order on earth. His kingdom has been established in Heaven.
I think the answer is to follow Jesu
s simply because he is Holy, of unique birth, sinless, with power to perform miracles including raising the dead plus he is right now in heaven, while Muhammad demonstrates none of these things. That's why your followers are concerned Dr. Ali
Comments here are now being deleted
I like Shabir ally, he is the best apologist I've seen
But there are some islamic history that I find disturbing
But why delete comments you don't like
And keep the ones you like
I think this is not correct
I put my comments in a respectful way
I never use foul language
Who will forgive the sins?? Only God can.. Jesus Christ forgive many people sinners infront of many people's.
Jesus is the Way, the Truth and the Life
Which Jesus are talking about ? The Jesus of Islam who was a human or the Jesus of Christian, who is also the god of OT .
The new testiment the good seed that the farmers planted an enemy came and sowed bad wicked seed weeds among the wheat
Jesus was also a universal prophet according to Ibn Abass Tafsir of surah Yasin 13
Im sorry Jesus already told you "in order for the paraclete to come, it is expedient that i go away"
Jesus was telling you to prepare for the next parakleytos to come..time to move on and accept the last and final messeger sent to all mankind🐱👍🏿
@@RamoLasiaf God is not a man! its in your book too
Thank you🙏
Jesus kingdom is not of this world
Simple answer Jesus is King> Muhammad did NO MIRACLES
Follow neither one, they are both false religions.
very nice
Interesting
You're qualified to be either or both Shabir Ally. I've watched and listened to you for years.
perfect
Hell's warming its fires for this one.
❤️
Host, are we allowed to see you when makeup is applied?
Close your eyes
The beard man looks scary. For me he is not trustworthy.
Bro how old are you
Very deceptive
Follow Jesus
Mankind will follow the noble prophet for he represent universal values, brotherhood... if there is something that make his followers different then its only in the expression and exclusivity of our worships and rituals.. the christians prays but we prays five time a day, the jews fast but we fast on ramadan... but our universal values are the same... our commonalities the kalimatis sawa shared by all nations.. if killing is wrong in Islam then it wrong in japan in brazil in china etc...
😭
Really misinformed is Shabir
Are you practicing your Taquiya now??? 😅😂🤣
no we reminding you not to eat and drink blood and meat of messiah
@@fidelcatsro6948 . That is parable.. we’re a Christian. It doesn’t mean we eat the and drink the blood of Jesus.. .. but all Muslims .. everything that Mohammad said is From Allah!!!! Sigh..
@@olanmanila Christian got original manuscript?
@@robust5615 , hahaha! Do you?? Your book exist only 620 years after Jesus died on the cross.. your book only copy paste of Tora , Bible and Hindu.. ..
@@olanmanila you are misguided
What shabir says is laughable at best.
Shabir is misinformed
your common sense should tell you to follow a living Prophet Jesus instead of a dead prophet.. more over Jesus is coming again as a judge and He will also judge mohammed for his sins..
Very deceptive