Комментарии •

  • @OnceUponAnIsland
    @OnceUponAnIsland 2 года назад +5

    Watch every secrets video I have ever made here! - ruclips.net/p/PL-J4ldj2BdE2McwzPjDDJAuBDHZriyYOG

  • @nataliedepriest9113
    @nataliedepriest9113 3 года назад +118

    I never understood why people bought the FairPlay lie. I remember watching it live when it happened. And he said his visit would either be from his grandma or his friend. The only way his friend shows up is if grandma is dead. But if she was that sick or hurt or whatever to be on death’s door, there’s no way she would be going to the pearl islands for a survivor challenge no matter what. So expecting his grandma made no sense. It was so obviously a lie. But it made for such good tv. I miss the early days of Survivor so much!

    • @AmaraJordanMusic
      @AmaraJordanMusic 2 года назад +4

      Ditto. I was 12 when this aired and even I looked at my parents and said, “Wait, what?) If she was sick, why would she be his other possible helper? It sounded like she was in the hospital or something… she couldn’t help if she was sick.” My parents looked at each other in surprise. 😂

    • @fisher2536
      @fisher2536 Год назад +2

      holy hindsight. stop the cap

    • @XX-vz3fb
      @XX-vz3fb Год назад +3

      To be fair the people that believed him were very VERY naive out there aka Lil Darrah and Tijuana. Plus Burton was his number one so he had a lot of trust in Fairplay. The two players with brains were Sandra and Christa who both saw right through the lie

  • @reginamachamer821
    @reginamachamer821 2 года назад +27

    It irks me how so many people act like Sandra is trash at playing survivor like she may have gotten to the point where she didn't care as much in the late seasons, but her winning seasons (hers wins are usually the subject in question) were definitely well-earned. Especially pearl Islands since the game was still somewhat newish and was evolving so much season to season.

  • @redozmasoma
    @redozmasoma 3 года назад +66

    One of my favorite seasons and marooning in the series... Seeing them trade and buy items from the village was cool and rupert stealing the other tribe's shoes to barter for items 😂

  • @blam9360
    @blam9360 3 года назад +88

    This was my favorite season hands down in the older seasons. Yul's season is a super close second.

    • @oscargonzalez1614
      @oscargonzalez1614 3 года назад +7

      I’m the other way around I love Cook Island, but Pearl island is such a close second

    • @blam9360
      @blam9360 3 года назад +3

      @@oscargonzalez1614 they're both so good it's hard to pick between first and second.

    • @ariellee2329
      @ariellee2329 3 года назад +4

      Cook Islands had a good cast, but the initial race divide was such a weird twist. And they mixed up the teams rather quickly to the point where I wondered what the point even was, yes there was more diversity but why didn’t it last longer then? I still enjoyed it though, I just felt that apart from getting a more diverse cast, that the twist didn’t really go anywhere (apart from the obvious segregation in the early game)

    • @Tvhurdghit4fhi6rr
      @Tvhurdghit4fhi6rr 2 года назад

      It's not hands down then is it

    • @blam9360
      @blam9360 2 года назад

      @@Tvhurdghit4fhi6rr That is a pointless comment. Of all the things you could say, you wanted to say something that would be divisive. STFU with your stupid BS comments. Your only goal is probably to just start drama because it's how you get attention. Grow up.

  • @Admiralkirk95
    @Admiralkirk95 2 года назад +19

    I think if the outcast idea was gonna happen it had to be the season with all the pirate stuff. pearl islands. Just the idea of scorned pirates thrown away to team up together and get revenge just sounds like it works perfectly with the setting they created. So I think that was a great time thematically to do it. And it adds this new idea that threw everyone through a loop so it made for a good idea.

  • @teksnotdead902
    @teksnotdead902 3 года назад +22

    This was probably the 3rd season i had watched ever...after watching the first two i didn't watch another one live until this one and once Rupert stole the shoes it hooked me. Some good characters here for the most part.

  • @bassplayer2011ify
    @bassplayer2011ify Год назад +9

    Jeff: the outcast twist is stupid
    Also probably Jeff: let's have someone come back for the final six and give them the a chance to obtain an idol.
    🤨

    • @alexjames4770
      @alexjames4770 8 месяцев назад +1

      “The outcast twist was stupid”
      Redemption and Extinction: Exist

  • @reginamachamer821
    @reginamachamer821 2 года назад +23

    Wait.. you mean to tell me that a young man *didn't* want to be called "Skinny Ryan"? Shocking.

    • @levig6238
      @levig6238 Год назад +11

      It’s far worse. I went to school with Ryan S. He said Savage literally bullied him before the show even began and persisted even after they were both voted out. Ryan absolutely hated his season on Survivor and wished he didn’t ever go. He was a super fan and Savage and CBS treated him so poorly, he hasnt watched the show again.
      Ryan S is an amazing dude that is self taught artist AND programming. The guy is an amazing athlete despite his physique on the show. He was 6-6’2” and could dunk.
      It was depressing for me to learn he didn’t get voted back in because those others were petty and voted Lill

    • @reginamachamer821
      @reginamachamer821 Год назад

      @@levig6238 that is so sad ☹ he was one of my favorites that season. Savage is such a pos like I cannot stand the mfer. I already highly disliked him but now I dislike him even more.

    • @hithedragon7842
      @hithedragon7842 Месяц назад +1

      I didn't realize there were two Ryans for a while, and I'm pretty sure I said out loud "that is so disrespectful" when the first vote with the nickname was read. Justice for Ryan.

    • @reginamachamer821
      @reginamachamer821 27 дней назад

      @@hithedragon7842 yeah especially when the other ryan already had a nickname lmao "ryno"

  • @cassidy7253
    @cassidy7253 3 года назад +14

    that jonny fairplay ad is so funny, omg this season is so good 😂

    • @roxannemoser
      @roxannemoser 3 года назад +1

      Fairplay was arrested for stealing from Grandma.

  • @Nobody-xe9fc
    @Nobody-xe9fc 3 года назад +30

    17:18 Well this escalated quickly.

  • @kevinlohmann3185
    @kevinlohmann3185 3 года назад +14

    Having all this context for Fairplay’s grandma lie makes it all so much juicier

  • @roxannemoser
    @roxannemoser 3 года назад +12

    Lil drove me nuts wearing that uniform.

  • @stone5048
    @stone5048 3 года назад +22

    The culmination of early survivor.
    All stars is just a poor imposter. Pearl Islands is the pinnacle of the early era and wraps it up in a nice bow.

    • @moviemaniac14
      @moviemaniac14 3 года назад +1

      I much prefer All Stars mostly due to Boston Rob's amazing gameplay as well as the terrible Outcast Twist not being apart of All Stars. That season also changed the way the game was played from that point onward. You can either call it the last old school season or the birth of a new Survivor era.

    • @um773
      @um773 3 года назад +2

      @@moviemaniac14 I disagree. All-Stars was too dark and full of bitterness and ugliness.
      Pearl Islands was truly epic and the storyline was amazing. No one was too bitter either.

    • @moviemaniac14
      @moviemaniac14 3 года назад

      @@um773 nope

    • @ralucaioanagrigoras1489
      @ralucaioanagrigoras1489 2 года назад

      @@um773 yeah, seeing all stars I was shocked to see some players I loved in their original seasons be super dumb and oblivious to what's happening around them, like Colby, Ethan, Tina? They would find out they're targetted and just pray to dear god and not really try to convince anyone to join them.. also the fact that 2 people left without a vote, and just generally the atmosphere, it wasn't too entertaining; I much prefer Pearl Islands

  • @kevinsaavedra0007
    @kevinsaavedra0007 2 года назад +7

    Rupert carried the season along with savage and Fairplay, they were the most interesting characters, rupert getting mad and fairplay baiting him to keep getting mad lol

  • @Admiralkirk95
    @Admiralkirk95 2 года назад +15

    Fairplay is surprisingly evil and chaotic as a player but when he does explain things, like crying each family visit episode it really shows that despite his shameless conniving and cunning, he actually has a heart and he just let himself be totally ruthless in the game.(unless he was also lyingright there) but he did apparently want to be voted out on his second shot because of his pregnant girlfriend. Sadly Jeff disliked him, and used the 'quitter' excuse to not bring him back later in a returnee cast. But I also think Fairplays aggressive lying also made him just a bad pick. he'd be targetted quick unless everyone had the big brain play to make him a goat on day one.

    • @dennismonk9559
      @dennismonk9559 2 года назад +2

      I think he would have done fine in FvF if he hadn't asked to be voted out. He would have filled the same role Cirie ended up filling

    • @AGJ117
      @AGJ117 Год назад

      I would have loved to see him in HvV, but Jeff hates him, so we'll never see him again.

  • @OnceUponAnIsland
    @OnceUponAnIsland 3 года назад +4

    If you want to pick season we do next for Survivor secrets then head over to Patreon and vote for as many seasons as you want today! - tinyurl.com/4tzbtrnf

  • @emmaussimi2426
    @emmaussimi2426 3 года назад +5

    23:21 Actually, Sandra was roasted when she said "I could do everyone there is doing, plus more" then it shows her sitting out / being bad in challenges.

  • @bigbuffguy9589
    @bigbuffguy9589 3 года назад +51

    I think my favorite was Fairplay being so delighted that he got to vote Rupert out one day before he was going to see his wife.

    • @OnceUponAnIsland
      @OnceUponAnIsland 3 года назад +22

      I like how that personal revenge mattered more than the Grandma lie lol

    • @cannedpineapple2702
      @cannedpineapple2702 3 года назад +9

      dont we all just love to hate fairplay

  • @franniewaffles6093
    @franniewaffles6093 3 года назад +18

    Questions?
    What persons that hasn’t won would you want to win ? And what person that has won you don’t think should not have gotten there win?

    • @OnceUponAnIsland
      @OnceUponAnIsland 3 года назад +13

      As I have said in many videos, everyone who has won the game earned their win.

    • @AmaraJordanMusic
      @AmaraJordanMusic 2 года назад

      Rupert!

  • @cowboy7597
    @cowboy7597 2 года назад +9

    He beats lil for sure. Outcasts don’t beat anyone but themselves (Sandra even despised lil)

  • @chargestone96
    @chargestone96 3 года назад +4

    The unaired mutiny is my favourite trivia from this season

    • @OnceUponAnIsland
      @OnceUponAnIsland 3 года назад +1

      Andrew said that never happened in his interview.

  • @jesses5465
    @jesses5465 2 года назад +5

    Jeff didn't think it was a good idea and then proceeded to do it multiple times lol

  • @joshdepaola4002
    @joshdepaola4002 2 года назад +4

    Rupert is such a unintentional villain lmfao

  • @LB-py8ls
    @LB-py8ls 3 года назад +12

    Here is a suggestion for future vids! Winners are guaranteed to have stories made for them. When we get to seasons with fan favorites, the fan fav should also be guaranteed to have a story of them!

    • @OnceUponAnIsland
      @OnceUponAnIsland 3 года назад +1

      The patrons pick the stories 😊

    • @bigbuffguy9589
      @bigbuffguy9589 3 года назад

      I think that tends to happen anyway, since the patrons pick the stories. Cirie is definitely getting a video in Panama.

    • @OnceUponAnIsland
      @OnceUponAnIsland 3 года назад +1

      I would be surprised if she didn't. Sometimes a fave misses out, like Gary in Guatemala or Ethan in All-Stars.

  • @natesuperfighterdevesiondi4992
    @natesuperfighterdevesiondi4992 3 года назад +3

    13:10 looooool living in Spain without the S while writing that line into the video

  • @reginamachamer821
    @reginamachamer821 2 года назад +9

    I laughed for like 3 whole minutes over the episode promo where they're all pointing the guns and the narrator is talking about how awful Fairplay is 🤣🤣🤣
    Edit: number 25

  • @elchristrejo882
    @elchristrejo882 4 месяца назад

    It was a surprise to hear mention survivor mexico, have you seen something about the show or some episodes?
    The latest season (season 5) finally added the jury instead of the viewers picking the winner
    And the villain that season called john guts was so good

  • @mildtotemperate
    @mildtotemperate Год назад +1

    Good work my man.

  • @l3eastunleashed
    @l3eastunleashed Год назад +1

    Just finished this season today, surprised there’s no secret about Sandra and the fish incident.

  • @JoshNieporte
    @JoshNieporte 3 года назад +5

    Rupert approves.

  • @willisskull2676
    @willisskull2676 8 месяцев назад

    Skinny Ryan will always have a place in my favorites because of his "Die Jerks" buff. Why the hell did they call him that if he didn't like the nickname? There's so many nicknames on the show, I figured you'd have to agree to it.

  • @reginamachamer821
    @reginamachamer821 2 года назад +3

    Fairplay vs. Lil.. he *might* just squeak by
    Fairplay vs.Sandra.. clean sweep, or at least close to it. No way he was beating Sandra. Or even coming close.

    • @j_cranberry
      @j_cranberry Год назад

      Yeah Sandra would wipe the floor with Jon. Maybe he would get Burton's vote...maybe. I think Lil against Jon would win 4-2. Lil would get Darrah, Tiauna, Rupert, Krista, Sandra. I think Rhino and Burton would vote for Jon

  • @exiaR2x78
    @exiaR2x78 Год назад +2

    Im convinced Rupert got a favorable edit in Pearl Islands, he was a dick in all stars and H vs V

  • @roycesharp8314
    @roycesharp8314 Месяц назад

    Notice the play on the naked challenge. Morgan Behind lol

  • @graysonthomas1433
    @graysonthomas1433 3 года назад +2

    I think Lil beats Jon because I think Jon would only get Darrah, Burton, Ryan O. and Lil would get Sandra, Rupert, Christa, and Tijuana’s vote.
    I think Sandra definitely beats Jon because she would probably get Christa, Rupert, Darrah, Lil, and Tijuana’s vote. While Jon would get Burton’s and Ryan O.’s vote.

    • @ralucaioanagrigoras1489
      @ralucaioanagrigoras1489 2 года назад

      It really depends on how they make their case. Jon could easily frame his game as a clever, deceptive game where he did whatever it takes for him to win. And if Lil blows the final council as bad as she did in reality with Sandra, then Jon would win over her 100% (probably Lil would get Rupert and Tijuana, and Jon the rest). With Sandra I don't really know. Her great gameplay wasn't that obvious to the jury as it was to us, so Jon maaybe, just maybe, still had a chance against her, but everyone in the world would be so mad if he won over Sandra lol

  • @youruglyleatherpants
    @youruglyleatherpants 2 года назад +8

    The first season I ever watched so it holds a place in my heart, I had to go back and watch every other season before I realized I started off at one of THEE best seasons of survivor. Top 5 for sure. Sandra is the queen❤️

  • @calebgibson55
    @calebgibson55 6 месяцев назад

    This is my favorite season!

  • @survivorfreak78
    @survivorfreak78 3 года назад

    Pearl Islands is one of my favroate seasons

  • @Dej1738
    @Dej1738 8 месяцев назад

    Where can I listen to the Rupert Sandra Christa podcast?

  • @psychluv
    @psychluv 3 года назад +4

    I love Sandra so much.

  • @shellbacksclub
    @shellbacksclub 4 месяца назад

    Don't understand why they don't have live cams ppl can watch like they do on Big Brother? Wth are they doing the rest of the time? I realize they cant have cams all over the island to pick up audio, but they could rig up their shelter space

  • @drunad4170
    @drunad4170 3 года назад +9

    Has anyone here applied to be on Survivor? I kind of just wondering the type of audience these in depth videos get.

    • @OnceUponAnIsland
      @OnceUponAnIsland 3 года назад +9

      I have noticed most of my in-depth videos get people who haven't watched the show or enjoy the intellectual nature of analyzing an entire game. When I do a list video then I seem to reach a broader audience and a more casual fan is likely to watch.

    • @504ever4
      @504ever4 3 года назад +6

      I did once while I was in college (crazy to think that if I had been casted it most likely would have been on Cagayan) but it was a very basic video and I never thought I had a chance of a call back. I'm 30 now and have pretty much decided that I will never apply lol. I like watching but I don't think I could ever do it.

    • @firebymisfire2640
      @firebymisfire2640 3 года назад +3

      You literally got me on to watching this show, I wouldn't have watched it before hand but watching your breakdowns on people's games made me realise how much more this is to this so thankyou from me and my girlfriend who now love to watch haha

  • @youngdidgy8948
    @youngdidgy8948 3 года назад +2

    FairPlay easily beats Lil in a final 2. Lil was seen as a goat by almost everyone in the jury. And Lil only got T’s vote because she answered her question better than Sandra did.

    • @OnceUponAnIsland
      @OnceUponAnIsland 3 года назад

      We will never know for sure.

    • @youngdidgy8948
      @youngdidgy8948 3 года назад +1

      @@OnceUponAnIsland Fr though, always had felt that he's at least self-aware enough that he wouldn't pull a Russell Hantz if he had made FTC, which imo gives him the W over Lil and at least a bit of a chance against Sandra. However, Fairplay's downfall is essential to the story of Pearl Islands. If he had somehow won, I don't think we get to see the villainous edit we saw.

    • @whatkindoftrainisthis4981
      @whatkindoftrainisthis4981 3 года назад +4

      it just bothers me because sandra was 1 vote away from having a perfect game

    • @dennismonk9559
      @dennismonk9559 2 года назад +1

      agreed. Fairplay v Sandra would have been really fun though, thats harder to predict who wins

  • @dennismonk9559
    @dennismonk9559 2 года назад +1

    Fairplay would absolutely beat Lil in a final two, she was a big goat. not sure about Sandra though. But I'm not sure there is any scenario they would play each other, I think Fairplay would have taken Lil if he won and Sandra for sure would have taken her.

  • @DublinSeafoodInc
    @DublinSeafoodInc 8 месяцев назад

    Please make a video on Lil in the Pearl Islands!

  • @reginamachamer821
    @reginamachamer821 2 года назад

    10:30 number 14- OMG it's just like the one Halloween episode of The Office.. they all voted Lil bc they thought she would get the least amount of votes, which would help their own chances lol I somehow didn't even consider this before
    Edit: 15- ew well that's disappointing..

  • @itsBooweee
    @itsBooweee 2 года назад

    26:01 I think this was asked during the reunion.

    • @OnceUponAnIsland
      @OnceUponAnIsland 2 года назад +1

      But we can never really know. At the reunion everyone has had the time to cool off and watch the show.

    • @itsBooweee
      @itsBooweee 2 года назад

      @@OnceUponAnIsland Yep. We will never know.

  • @smileygirl622
    @smileygirl622 4 месяца назад

    The "I would never quit" mentality is so weird to me when its pushed on the medical emergencies and people like jenna who did lose her mom 8 days after she got home, she absolutely would have missed that. Why would you not quit for those things? It makes no sense.

  • @amiyousoff6560
    @amiyousoff6560 2 года назад

    20:21 troyzan is shook

  • @Whatupitskevin
    @Whatupitskevin 2 года назад +1

    Don't forget that Fairplay quit on his second season. Wasted a spot just because "Me, Me, Me" yet tries to say that about Rubert lol I don't buy it still hypes himself up to this day about that he played on survivor almost 20 years ago

    • @jacobwilliams1223
      @jacobwilliams1223 2 года назад +5

      Actually he quit because prior to the season he got punched in the face by Danny Bonaduce (Seriously) and broke his jaw. He was denied being able to have his painkillers and when Yau Man slammed his face into the boat well he couldn't endure it.

  • @declanhurley8030
    @declanhurley8030 3 года назад +1

    I wanna see a Thailand 45 secrets

  • @ptpilario
    @ptpilario 3 года назад

    7:35 Wow Lil LOL

  • @ivolcanic4401
    @ivolcanic4401 11 месяцев назад

    I have been watching every season in order and was cheering for them to bring back voted out players as a twist, but I am upset that otherwise Rupert would’ve won.

  • @shellbacksclub
    @shellbacksclub 4 месяца назад

    I personally can't stand the loved ones challenge. They're literally at a tropical Fat Camp & have 1 in whatever (at the time) chance of winning a $million! Ppl go to literal war for months & aren't afforded that luxury, what is there to cry about!?

  • @pinkxxmango
    @pinkxxmango 3 года назад +2

    why was mark upset with the nudity? lol

    • @OnceUponAnIsland
      @OnceUponAnIsland 3 года назад +2

      I think because it happened during a challenge so the editors had no way to cut it out of the episode if they wanted? All I know is what you hear in this video lol

    • @YellowTwerker
      @YellowTwerker 3 года назад +2

      That’s extra work for the editors to censor it and extra work convincing CBS to air it since nudity on prime time tv is still a no no

  • @GreggAdventure
    @GreggAdventure 3 года назад +3

    Darn it, Blue Dress Girl, went out way to soon.

  • @isabellaearnhardt6380
    @isabellaearnhardt6380 3 года назад +3

    💙

  • @shellbacksclub
    @shellbacksclub 4 месяца назад

    They had lighters back then!? What kind of Survival is that?

  • @markjackson6431
    @markjackson6431 3 года назад +4

    Outcast twist sucks...literally they got a shower and a meal

    • @OnceUponAnIsland
      @OnceUponAnIsland 3 года назад +2

      When Jeff said they got to stay in a hotel, I then realized the luxuries they had.

    • @bigbuffguy9589
      @bigbuffguy9589 3 года назад +3

      It wasn't perfect, but the Outcast twist was amazing television and part of the reason Pearl Islands is so beloved.

  • @santinoaugustosesmilo5268
    @santinoaugustosesmilo5268 3 года назад +1

    Do Next all star

    • @OnceUponAnIsland
      @OnceUponAnIsland 3 года назад

      Become a patron and vote for any season you want :)

    • @johnhancock6769
      @johnhancock6769 3 года назад

      Once Upon An Island pay me and I’ll do whatever your heart desires

    • @OnceUponAnIsland
      @OnceUponAnIsland 3 года назад

      @@johnhancock6769 Haha 😄

  • @j_cranberry
    @j_cranberry Год назад

    Sandra would 100% win against Jon. I think she'd get all the votes except Burton's and maybe Tijuana's. I think Lil would win against Jon, but it would be closer. I reckon Lil would get Krista, Sandra, Rupert and Tijuana. Burton would vote for Jon. Rhino and Darrah might have voted for Jon because they didn't respect Lil returning after being voted out. So Lil would win no matter what, either 6-1, 5-2, or 4-3. Thankfully, she was a dumbass as usual and picked Sandra instead of Jon. Queen Sandra forever. Love her and Parvati, amazing female role models for me growing up.

  • @bassethoundblooze8778
    @bassethoundblooze8778 3 года назад +6

    Not my fave season. Now don’t make fun of me, but Thailand is my favorite

    • @OnceUponAnIsland
      @OnceUponAnIsland 3 года назад +1

      Why is that?

    • @bassethoundblooze8778
      @bassethoundblooze8778 3 года назад

      I don’t know. I just didn’t like the setting or the people. Don’t get me wrong, I like Rupert and Sandra and christa, but other than that no.

  • @TyroneMcDonalds
    @TyroneMcDonalds 2 года назад +3

    this whole video just makes andrew savage look like a clown lmao

    • @levig6238
      @levig6238 Год назад

      He was a complete dick. Always the worst, was a caricature of what people thinks lawyers are like in real life.

  • @shellbacksclub
    @shellbacksclub 4 месяца назад

    Johnny Fairplay is too weak minded to be an effective villain

  • @danielhoward8354
    @danielhoward8354 8 месяцев назад

    Note to self: If ever on survivor wear 10 pair of underwear day one.

    • @thetaekwondoe3887
      @thetaekwondoe3887 2 месяца назад

      There was a season after this one, I think, where one older guy was the only one to have his bathing suit with him because his wife told him to make sure he wore it wherever they took them. Pretty sure for that season they did something similar to this one where the cast didn't have access to most of their personal items.

  • @backstreetsbackalright4363
    @backstreetsbackalright4363 2 года назад

    I've seen Survivor Hungary. They just sit around and bicker like high school girls. They air an episode every night so they don't even have enough filler, just mundane nonsense.

  • @shellbacksclub
    @shellbacksclub 4 месяца назад

    Ppl die from a single staph infection like every day. Is ur life really worth $1 million... Before taxes?

  • @shellbacksclub
    @shellbacksclub 4 месяца назад

    Why are contestants still in underwear today? Why wouldn't they wear swimshorts with underwear lining under their pants?

  • @GreggAdventure
    @GreggAdventure 3 года назад

    Christa is Haaaaaawt