So, pag nagkawar who will fight against China? Pinoys or Americans? Care to answer Carpio? Or will your sons or grandchildren fight for the Philippines as well?
@GreenandWhiteArcher Yang ang magandang mangyayari. Mga apo at anak nya ang nasa front line. The Philippine patriotism is now shifting to the military! It's time to be a hero!
@@vondoromal7016 We should also include those chekwas in Binondo and force them to join the military. Di ba they claimed to be Filipinos only with Chinese blood, why not show it?
Dapat talaga tangapin na para matapos na amg paghahariharian ng china at aminin natin na hindi natin kaya ang china kung tayo lang sa lahat ng bagay talo tayo,wag natin ipag sapalaran ang ating kapalaran kung meron namang tamang paraan para isalba ito,america is a good friend,wag natin kalimutan sila ang nagtangol sa atin laban sa hapon at nagbigay sa atin ng kalayaan at mamuhay ng sariling atin
Masyadong mataas ang pride ng pilipinas. Dapat nating pakinggan si justice Carpio alam niya ang sinasabi niya. Kailangan na natin ang tulong ng America period. Mabuhay kayo Justice Carpio sir. I 100% agree with you sir.
@@sasori2037 eh anong gagawin mo gusto mo sa china pumanig bakit di subukan kung anong mangyayari paghinde kumilos ang pinas unti unti lang tayong sasakupin ng mga china mr carpio is right
We salute you Justice Carpio for your advised to accept the offer of US to escort our Coastguard going to Ayungin and scoda shoul. You are truly a Patriot. Mabuhay ka Sir!
Oo naman sir dapat lang magpatulong tayo…WAG TAYONG HIPOKRITO…kaya nga gusto nilang tumulong sa atin kasi nasa TAMA tayo at ATING YANG MGA ISLA AT KARAGATAN..
Tuloy parin ang AFP Modernization kahit tumulong pa ang US. Mas gusto actually ng US na lumakas pa ang military ng bansa, kasama din sa interest nila yan. Syempre mas maganda kapag malakas din ang kakampi nila para hindi nalang lahat asa sa kanila.
I totally agree with justice Carpio, what China is doing to our coast guard vessels in West Philippine Sea is too much already. Why don’t we give it a try accepting the aid that other countries are giving. Enough is enough.
Well according to PCG spokesperson Tariella and USEC lopez, the Philippines maintains "strategic presence" in Escoda even after BRP Magbanua was pulled out. I think these two stooges meant "spiritual presence" of the Phils in Escoda Shoal.
Sabagay may punto din c Justice Carpio na subukan din ng PCG at PN na ikunsidera ang suggestion ng mga expert pra makita kung ano ang magiging reaction ng China ..let's face the reality na wala tau kakayanan pg nag react ang china against armed conflict aggression..
Bakit po hindi natin tinatanggap kung hindi talaga natin kaya? The problem is with us. We need a change of leadership in the AFP. They're thnking for themselves, not for the Philippines. We are already losing a war that's not even started yet.
Tama Po Kasi kung Tayo lang Wala talaga manyayari. Hindi kargado ng tapang ang ating Navy at pcg yong prinsipyo na ok lang na mamatay sa tawag ng trabaho.marami Dyan ang napromote dahil sa pagschooling pero kulang sa tapang at gawa
That’s good idea. Philippines is playing hard to accept U.S. offer. There should be no problem if they did not closed the U.S bases in Clark in 1990. We blamed this to the Senate magic 12 by Erap Estrada
Tama po kayo mr carpio sisirain lng lahat mga barko ng coastguard kapag naunos na anng susunod na gaawin ng coastguar its time na talaga na kumilos magpasama na sa usa
Let us listen to the wisdom of our good supreme court associate justice, Carpio..file the new case, so there would be status quo in the West Phil Sea.Mabuhay po kayo and more power sir. I hope Marcos admin will follow your advice.
Accepting the OFFER WILL BE THE BENEFIT NOT TO ONLY US BUT TO THE WHOLE WORLD we must associate with THE U.S because so far they have been right all along!
Hindi sana ako sasang-ayon Kay Carpio kung may sapat tayong kagamitan , armas at maraming barkong pandigma pero Wala tayong magawa kundi umasa ulit sa US.
I agree to Justice Carpio,you see ,i was heartbroken about the news that our men in uniform eat lugaw while guarding our Escoda Shoal and no drinking water. So sad ,how could they protect us because they were sick due to lack of support especially food. 😢😢😢😢😢
Yes, we get that our government wants to show the world that the Philippines can handle our own issues. But there is strength in numbers kaya our government should consider accepting help from allies. There is no shame in that.
Wala nmang pinakikinggan yung mga opisyal natin sa WPS.puro sablay nman yun mga ginagawa nila,cguro kung ikaw ang tutulong,baka magsawa ka rin pg ganyan,db!
I have the same opinion with former Chief Justice Carpio. Philippine Navy and PCG must accept the offer of the US Navy to escort the next Supply Mission to BRP Sierra Madre. That is in line with Mutual Defense Treaty with America...
I agree we should consider US and other allies deployed along our side millions of Filipinos serve in the US military I my self a retired Filipino in the US military. Freedom of navigation the greedy neighbor must stop. Watching from Florida USA
As an American Tax Payer and someone who grew up in the U.S Military, I think that the Philippines has been bullied long enough. They have been bullied by China 🇨🇳. The Philippines 🇵🇭 should not TOLERATE another country stealing their land. It belongs to the Philippines regardless if China acknowledges it or not. Thats what bullies do. Its like a small teenager in high-school walking to class and then is stopped by some thug being demanded of their Lunch and money. The Philippine govnt only has themselves to blame. Past administrations becoming "too friendly with China." For example, Duterte was pushing an Anti-American culture then turns to China 🇨🇳. It wasnt only Duterte's administration... even the ones prior. Whats the bottom line? MONEY. What was the motive? MONEY. Something or Someone allowed all this to happen. It could have been stopped when it started 5-10 years ago. During ww2, Italy made a bad mistake. That mistake cost them blood shed, thousands of lives, and their own stability in their government. Why? Because they SIDED with HITLER. Hitler invaded Italy 🇮🇹. Hitler lied and tricked Musolini. Philippines, its time that you put your gloves on and work with your allies to put a STOP to China bullying you.
Yes you are right justice. Carpio.Our coast guard vessels are not enough so we need help from the US..Let's repair the BRP Sierra Madre by the aid of the US..And also place another ship to Sabina Shoal..
huwag na po kasi tayong mag mayabang.... di po talaga kaya pag di tayo humingi ng tulong.... 😢😢 di naman siguro mababawasan ego natin kung hingi na tayo tulong sa mga may kaya tumapat sa china.
Ano ? Palakihan ba ng barko ang kumpetisyon...teka nga ? sino ba ang lumalabag sa batas ng karagatan...maski na mayaman o mahirap basta lumalabag sa batas siguradong mapaparusahan !! O anong largest largest kung mali naman ang ginagawa....
Ang Kumunistang China ang lumabag sa kasundoan sa UNCLOS na 200 NM mula sa dalampasigan ng bansa ay Exclusive Economic Zone kun EEZ. Yon ang nilabag sa Kumunistang China... Ang China ay member signaturee ng UNCLOS...
The problem with the tribunal outcome, there’s no actual body that enforces the ruling. The entire world will need to act to enforce the outcome or ruling.
The Philippines should file the second case against Beijing for damaging its vessels. In the meantime, in addition to accepting joint patrols with the US (and possibly other like-minded nations), it should seriously consider the proposed leasing of frigates to immediately bulk up its capabilities in the West Philippine Sea.
There are other analysts that are saying that China wanted to test US capabilities and having small sea encounters with PH and US would give them idea. So PH and US should be cautious as well.
Langis ay liquid gold. Then Jan na Nila Tayo mamanipulahin to control oil market sa east for political agenda in the future. Pero corner Tayo dahil sa bitak na gov't officials na di kayang maikaisa to protect our sovereign rights.
If our Leaders are Wise enough they will choose to Accept the Offer of the Americans to Help and Assist us in the West Philippine Sea. And File another Arbitration Case against China as per Justice Carpio's advise. This is the most practical approach that we can do to Deter China. The People' are convinced that this is the better Option. This is just a humble Advise. But still, it is up to our Honorable President to Decide!😊 Mabuhay ang Pilipinas!😊 Laban Pinas!😊
Your right Sir Carpio , even the international expert asking why the Philippines always rejecting the offer of U.S to Escorting their Ships , it's time for the Philippines to accept it...
Whose idea was it to turn down the offer to begin with? Do Filipinos think they have the military power to control China? Wake up, Philippines 🇵🇭! It would help if you had the U.S. support.
Tama yan justice Carpio. Kung gusto niyo po noong una yung Austria nasukol na ng mga kalaban ngunit yung Flying Hussar ng Poland tumulong at hindi nagi g muslim ang Austria bakit hindi natin gawin ngayon ang flying hussar ngayon ay US pag sila na ang tumulong sigurado kahit yung Poland ngayon at Austria ay tutulong kahit yung Norway, Sweden, Germany ,France kahit yung mga neighbors natin Australia, Japan at Korea maging ang Vietnam, Indonesia at Malaysia ay tutulong o kahit tatlo sa sampo ang tutulong mag agam agam na ang China.
Totally agree with Justice Carpio.
So, pag nagkawar who will fight against China? Pinoys or Americans? Care to answer Carpio? Or will your sons or grandchildren fight for the Philippines as well?
@GreenandWhiteArcher Yang ang magandang mangyayari. Mga apo at anak nya ang nasa front line.
The Philippine patriotism is now shifting to the military! It's time to be a hero!
Nakakalungkot na madami pa din sa ating mga Pinoy na hindi tunay na makabayan. Either that or duwag. 😢😢😢
They only thought about this now?
@@vondoromal7016 We should also include those chekwas in Binondo and force them to join the military. Di ba they claimed to be Filipinos only with Chinese blood, why not show it?
the news anchor has more balls to ask those on point questions than uniform personnel officials 😂 well done anc
Dapat talaga tangapin na para matapos na amg paghahariharian ng china at aminin natin na hindi natin kaya ang china kung tayo lang sa lahat ng bagay talo tayo,wag natin ipag sapalaran ang ating kapalaran kung meron namang tamang paraan para isalba ito,america is a good friend,wag natin kalimutan sila ang nagtangol sa atin laban sa hapon at nagbigay sa atin ng kalayaan at mamuhay ng sariling atin
Tama ka..
Mayabang kc afp
Not friends just have same interest in detering china...americans are not our friends
Masyadong mataas ang pride ng pilipinas. Dapat nating pakinggan si justice Carpio alam niya ang sinasabi niya. Kailangan na natin ang tulong ng America period. Mabuhay kayo Justice Carpio sir. I 100% agree with you sir.
Bangag kasi ang Presidente eh
Hindi yan about sa pride. Kung e accept nang pinas ang offer ng US na mag escort, sa tingin nyo wala yang kapalit?
@@sasori2037 eh anong gagawin mo gusto mo sa china pumanig bakit di subukan kung anong mangyayari paghinde kumilos ang pinas unti unti lang tayong sasakupin ng mga china mr carpio is right
agree
@@sasori2037 I think meron pero di ko alam. Ano kaya ito?
We salute you Justice Carpio for your advised to accept the offer of US to escort our Coastguard going to Ayungin and scoda shoul. You are truly a Patriot. Mabuhay ka Sir!
Oo naman sir dapat lang magpatulong tayo…WAG TAYONG HIPOKRITO…kaya nga gusto nilang tumulong sa atin kasi nasa TAMA tayo at ATING YANG MGA ISLA AT KARAGATAN..
Finally. Someone with common sense. Pero madaming magagalit dyan na gustong kumita sa AFP modernization.
Tuloy parin ang AFP Modernization kahit tumulong pa ang US. Mas gusto actually ng US na lumakas pa ang military ng bansa, kasama din sa interest nila yan. Syempre mas maganda kapag malakas din ang kakampi nila para hindi nalang lahat asa sa kanila.
the problem with common sense is predictable... which we are
Nasa dugo na ng Pinoy ang pagiging kawatan.
I totally agree with justice Carpio, what China is doing to our coast guard vessels in West Philippine Sea is too much already. Why don’t we give it a try accepting the aid that other countries are giving. Enough is enough.
Justice Carpio is RIGHT and PH must FOLLOW this offer. Huwag ng patulog tulog PH NAVY
100% Agree
0秒钟前
as if yoy never beg the help from your master.......hahahahahahaha....funny maids...
@@user-zh5oq3li2e I feel sorry for you. You don't have any Allies or foreign investor left. Your become a stone age like a barbarian
@@user-zh5oq3li2eChinese spotted 💩
Let america & allies escort our ships🇵🇭🇺🇸🇯🇵🇨🇦
Carpio should run for senate
Carpio is best fit to be barangay tanghod !
@@boogieman4170Even in the Philippines private media, I see XiJinpig bot, go eat Winnie the pooh, honey poop.
Tanggapin na kasi alam nman natin na wla tayong magawa sa dami ng chikwa na barko sa WPS
Best decision.
Excellent and thought provoking questions by the interviewer!!!
I hope the Philippine officials are listening
Kaya p raw wala png gyera sumuko na 😂😂😂resign na gen brawner
bakit mo sinama AFP sa kapalpakan ng cost Guard? kaka sh@bu mo yan
It's time. Envoke MDT.
Well according to PCG spokesperson Tariella and USEC lopez, the Philippines maintains "strategic presence" in Escoda even after BRP Magbanua was pulled out. I think these two stooges meant "spiritual presence" of the Phils in Escoda Shoal.
😅😅😅 I love the term - “spiritual presence”
l will make it a little scary by calling it ghost-like presence! matakot sila!!!!
US .JAPAN . AUSTRALIA.GERMANY . AT IBA PANG BANSA TAYO MAGPA ESCORTS
Sabagay may punto din c Justice Carpio na subukan din ng PCG at PN na ikunsidera ang suggestion ng mga expert pra makita kung ano ang magiging reaction ng China ..let's face the reality na wala tau kakayanan pg nag react ang china against armed conflict aggression..
Tama po accept na hindi naman kaya ipagtanggol ang sarili
Carpio should have been a senator.
I like this man talking common sense.
With the kind of voters we have, Carpio will never win the senate. Remember, Robin Padilla #1 last election lol
Accept is very wise decision, to ignore is out of wisdom turns to be fool
Bakit po hindi natin tinatanggap kung hindi talaga natin kaya? The problem is with us. We need a change of leadership in the AFP. They're thnking for themselves, not for the Philippines. We are already losing a war that's not even started yet.
dapat maging NSC si Ex Chief Justice CARPIO dahil alam ang GAGAWIN at MATAPANG SIYA...
Tama Po Kasi kung Tayo lang Wala talaga manyayari. Hindi kargado ng tapang ang ating Navy at pcg yong prinsipyo na ok lang na mamatay sa tawag ng trabaho.marami Dyan ang napromote dahil sa pagschooling pero kulang sa tapang at gawa
That’s good idea. Philippines is playing hard to accept U.S. offer. There should be no problem if they did not closed the U.S bases in Clark in 1990. We blamed this to the Senate magic 12 by Erap Estrada
Medyo may katangahan si Pres. Estrada at that time
Tama po kayo mr carpio sisirain lng lahat mga barko ng coastguard kapag naunos na anng susunod na gaawin ng coastguar its time na talaga na kumilos magpasama na sa usa
Pride of Phil Navy mygosh. 😅
Di na makababalik ang PCS sa Escoda shoal. Nagpull out na si Tere!
Yes, it's time to accept U.S. offer to help resupply mission to west Phil.sea.
I agree with Justice Carpio.
💯 agree!
Let us listen to the wisdom of our good supreme court associate justice, Carpio..file the new case, so there would be status quo in the West Phil Sea.Mabuhay po kayo and more power sir. I hope Marcos admin will follow your advice.
Totally agree.
Ganito dapat ang pang iisip ng Presidente.. Alam naman natin na atin ang West Philippines Sea, at kita na rin natin kung gaano ka hangal ang China..
Bagal talaga Pinas umaksyon pati PCG ma pride nd naman kaya ang obligasyon
Accepting the OFFER WILL BE THE BENEFIT NOT TO ONLY US BUT TO THE WHOLE WORLD we must associate with THE U.S because so far they have been right all along!
Hindi sana ako sasang-ayon Kay Carpio kung may sapat tayong kagamitan , armas at maraming barkong pandigma pero Wala tayong magawa kundi umasa ulit sa US.
I agree to Justice Carpio,you see ,i was heartbroken about the news that our men in uniform eat lugaw while guarding our Escoda Shoal and no drinking water. So sad ,how could they protect us because they were sick due to lack of support especially food. 😢😢😢😢😢
Real talk. I admire and believe all the advice of the justice carpio
Yes, we get that our government wants to show the world that the Philippines can handle our own issues. But there is strength in numbers kaya our government should consider accepting help from allies. There is no shame in that.
Pls po, gobyerno makinig kayo ki Justice Carpio. Magkaso na.
Hinde jan sasaangayon si brawner at tarilla kasi mataas pride nila at kaya daw nila ng walang tulong sa ibang bansa.
Hindi yan pride, bayad nayan sila kaya wala kwenta PCG at AFP pagdating sa WPS.
Tama po
go go go! Justice Carpio to become our commanding officer if war breaks out!
Kung pwede sana si justice carpio ang maging pinuno sa AFP
Totally agree
Matagal na dapat nagpatulong etong mga taga AFP nagmamagaling di nman kaya.
Tama si CJ Carpio
yes, iboboto ko yan sa Senator
Good j0b sir carpio.
dito nag aapply ang katagang: "Panu ka tutulungan kung ayaw mo tulungan ang sarili mo"
Correct Justice Carpio..Sana makinig siyo ang PH Government.
Wala nmang pinakikinggan yung mga opisyal natin sa WPS.puro sablay nman yun mga ginagawa nila,cguro kung ikaw ang tutulong,baka magsawa ka rin pg ganyan,db!
I agree to Mr. Justice Carpio
I have the same opinion with former Chief Justice Carpio. Philippine Navy and PCG must accept the offer of the US Navy to escort the next Supply Mission to BRP Sierra Madre. That is in line with Mutual Defense Treaty with America...
Yeah Justice Carpio is right. Even the whole world thinks that we need help and we should seek one not only from US but from all of our allies.
Absolutely correct.
I agree we should consider US and other allies deployed along our side millions of Filipinos serve in the US military I my self a retired Filipino in the US military. Freedom of navigation the greedy neighbor must stop. Watching from Florida USA
PBBM should make justice Carpio as a member of the maritime council
As an American Tax Payer and someone who grew up in the U.S Military, I think that the Philippines has been bullied long enough. They have been bullied by China 🇨🇳. The Philippines 🇵🇭 should not TOLERATE another country stealing their land. It belongs to the Philippines regardless if China acknowledges it or not. Thats what bullies do. Its like a small teenager in high-school walking to class and then is stopped by some thug being demanded of their Lunch and money.
The Philippine govnt only has themselves to blame. Past administrations becoming "too friendly with China." For example, Duterte was pushing an Anti-American culture then turns to China 🇨🇳. It wasnt only Duterte's administration... even the ones prior.
Whats the bottom line? MONEY. What was the motive? MONEY.
Something or Someone allowed all this to happen. It could have been stopped when it started 5-10 years ago.
During ww2, Italy made a bad mistake. That mistake cost them blood shed, thousands of lives, and their own stability in their government. Why? Because they SIDED with HITLER. Hitler invaded Italy 🇮🇹. Hitler lied and tricked Musolini.
Philippines, its time that you put your gloves on and work with your allies to put a STOP to China bullying you.
I AGREE 100%
Agree 100percent
Pride of an officer who wont accept help even though he already knows he is incapable. Nagmamagaling!
Best advise of Carpio to accept US offer of escorting Ph vessels !
Let's move now, Philippines!
Yes I agree..Now it's the time we need help from our friend U.S and our allies..
Yes you are right justice. Carpio.Our coast guard vessels are not enough so we need help from the US..Let's repair the BRP Sierra Madre by the aid of the US..And also place another ship to Sabina Shoal..
huwag na po kasi tayong mag mayabang.... di po talaga kaya pag di tayo humingi ng tulong.... 😢😢 di naman siguro mababawasan ego natin kung hingi na tayo tulong sa mga may kaya tumapat sa china.
Whats the use of the balikatan treaty if ur turning down the help!
Agree 100
Hindi boodle fight ang sagot. Fight for freedom and democracy yun ang gagawin.
Hinihintay pa nila na may masawing pilipino saka pa aaksyon
Ano ? Palakihan ba ng barko ang kumpetisyon...teka nga ? sino ba ang lumalabag sa batas ng karagatan...maski na mayaman o mahirap basta lumalabag sa batas siguradong mapaparusahan !! O anong largest largest kung mali naman ang ginagawa....
To enforce the law we need resources which we don't have.
Ang Kumunistang China ang lumabag sa kasundoan sa UNCLOS na 200 NM mula sa dalampasigan ng bansa ay Exclusive Economic Zone kun EEZ. Yon ang nilabag sa Kumunistang China... Ang China ay member signaturee ng UNCLOS...
Ipatangal mo sir si brawny baka umayos ang WPS at coast guard.
AGREE Swallow your pride, and actually defend out territories
Ngayon na. Kailan pa tayo gagalaw do we wait till they occupied our islands?.
Yes the Philippines should allow the escort of US vessels
The problem with the tribunal outcome, there’s no actual body that enforces the ruling. The entire world will need to act to enforce the outcome or ruling.
When did the US 'offer'?...the theater commander didn't make any formal offer and neither is he authorized to.
Dapat humingi na tayo ng tulong sa mga kaalyado nating bansa para di na madagdagan pa mga artificial island ng china sa WPS
totally agree with fcj carpio.
Agree, the PH should proceed to ask the US to send warships to fight China for the PH, its valuable alliance in Asia.
Justice Carpio was right
Agree mbuhay po kyo justice carpio
Tama!! Palitan yan si Brawner mukhang walang yagbols
sa susunod na election justice antonio carpio pwede sa senado pwede rin maging presidente
pinatagal pa ,, dun din nmn pupunta. pinahirapan pa ung crew ng teresa
I think PBBM admin have to listen to the wisdom of retired CJ Carpio,though he is not sitting in any gov.body.
The Philippines should file the second case against Beijing for damaging its vessels. In the meantime, in addition to accepting joint patrols with the US (and possibly other like-minded nations), it should seriously consider the proposed leasing of frigates to immediately bulk up its capabilities in the West Philippine Sea.
There are other analysts that are saying that China wanted to test US capabilities and having small sea encounters with PH and US would give them idea.
So PH and US should be cautious as well.
Langis ay liquid gold. Then Jan na Nila Tayo mamanipulahin to control oil market sa east for political agenda in the future. Pero corner Tayo dahil sa bitak na gov't officials na di kayang maikaisa to protect our sovereign rights.
Right mr, carpio
If our Leaders are Wise enough they will choose to Accept the Offer of the Americans to Help and Assist us in the West Philippine Sea.
And File another Arbitration Case against China as per Justice Carpio's advise.
This is the most practical approach that we can do to Deter China.
The People' are convinced that this is the better Option.
This is just a humble Advise.
But still, it is up to our Honorable President to Decide!😊
Mabuhay ang Pilipinas!😊
Laban Pinas!😊
We are not capable now.. so we need to ask US.
Your right Sir Carpio , even the international expert asking why the Philippines always rejecting the offer of U.S to Escorting their Ships , it's time for the Philippines to accept it...
Whose idea was it to turn down the offer to begin with? Do Filipinos think they have the military power to control China? Wake up, Philippines 🇵🇭! It would help if you had the U.S. support.
Agree
Tama yan justice Carpio. Kung gusto niyo po noong una yung Austria nasukol na ng mga kalaban ngunit yung Flying Hussar ng Poland tumulong at hindi nagi g muslim ang Austria bakit hindi natin gawin ngayon ang flying hussar ngayon ay US pag sila na ang tumulong sigurado kahit yung Poland ngayon at Austria ay tutulong kahit yung Norway, Sweden, Germany ,France kahit yung mga neighbors natin Australia, Japan at Korea maging ang Vietnam, Indonesia at Malaysia ay tutulong o kahit tatlo sa sampo ang tutulong mag agam agam na ang China.