In the words of Jane Birkin herself.... “It’s very nice that everyone’s got one or wants one, if people want to go for the real thing, fine. If they go for copies, that’s fine, too. I really don’t think it matters.” She told this to Vogue in 2011 when asked about fake Birkins, and I could not agree with her more.
I love fakes for the price. Designer brands are a rip off. Remember Dior tote cost about sixty dollars to make but retail for two thousand dollars? Hermes bags are the same. Their cost to make is nowhere near their retail price.
I am one of those who have no interest in Hermes bags. I have well over 100 luxury bags and none are from Hermes. I would however not buy the Walmart version either. The reason I don’t want an Hermes «quota» bag is partly due to their games and lack of transparency in how to get one, partly that I don’t particularly like the Birkin or Kelly (although I like the colors and leathers) and partly that I find the B & K cliché. I’d feel awkward running around with one. I don’t mean to offend those who love them and I was very happy for you when you got your mini Kelly because I know how much you wanted it. You have them in special colors that I love as well. But I just don’t feel the pull.
Another unattainable bag😢…no Walmart here in Australia. Absolutely yes I would buy one! I went into Hermes in Melbourne to buy shoes and jewellery and was treated like an unwanted customer they literally hid out the back and keep looking around corner and would not serve me. I was not rude I was dressed well, and I was patient I waited 45 min to get help which did not happen. I was not the only one in the store that this was happening to, a lady who was sitting down said to me she was on day 2 waiting to buy and that if it wasn’t her daughter’s special birthday she would would never have come back with such poor customer service. I left and went and spent my money at LV with amazing lovely customer service.
@@ameliarosescloset I fell in love with everything about Hermes from the history to the craftsmanship, I had saved for a whole year just to go and buy the beautiful pieces and get the experience...I fell out of love with them and in love with LV.
In the past, I bought a dupe for both the Birkin and the Kelly. In buying both bags, I learned that I am not a fan of either the Birkin or the Kelly. The closures are too fussy and I am too OCD to carry my bag partially open. Dupes are a good way to figure out the a bag style and whether or not you want to drop the coin on a high end bag.😊❤
They are a great way of finding out if the bag works, I would have done this with the mini kelly if I was considering buying one resale due to the price
There was a viral dupe for the Row Margaux at TJMaxx/Marshall's not long ago too. Now I see it everywhere on Amazon, Walmart etc. Honestly, I think the veil has been lifted for some people after the Dior scandal and I don't blame them for choosing the budget friendlier version. Honestly, what's the difference between a bag made by Chinese workers with Chinese manufactured materials in China (who get to go home, be with family and sleep in a normal bed) VS. a bag made by Chinese workers trafficked to Italy for low wages, sleeping in the factory without their family, and is made with Chinese manufactured materials shipped to Italy just so they can skirt a few laws to keep the label "Made in Italy" because it's technically *assembled* in Italy... I'm not a huge Walmart person but I do see the appeal. That Teddy Blake bag is so cute. Might have to put that on my 2025 wishlist in a lizard embossed version. ❤
I one thousand percent agree with you, the birkin is not exclusive, the birkin is paywalled and hermes are con artists..... People just fall for their behaviour hook, line and sinker.
I think that I personally feel put off by Hermes because to me the hype feels entirely manufactured. I'm not saying that they're not quality bags but some people act as if they are the only high quality bags on the planet when justifying the price and the hoops to jump through. I'm not a handbag connoisseur but just from an outsiders perspective surely you can buy way better looking bags with the same quality for far less. I watch Jessie Styles here on RUclips and love watching her videos and she has a whole shelf full of Hermes but aside from the bright colors she has I honestly see nothing but a bunch of plain, non descript, and frankly boring bags. I'm not saying that to be mean and clearly she loves them and that's all that matters but in all honesty if it wasn't for the manufactured hype created by the feeling of scarcity I don't think most people would give a hoot about Hermes.
I work for Walmart in the US and we don’t have this bag in the stores it’s basically online only, I’m sure if it was in the stores it wouldn’t last long.
@ Probably not, because bags like that are for the online site, but the stores have their own brand of bags and clothes called Time and True and the bags are not real leather Walmart online also has a leather version of the mini Kelly by Norbrand for $59.05 I’m sure that will sell out also.
I don’t mind seeing “inspired by” bags as most designers seem to be copying each other, as long as they aren’t slapping an Hermes tag on it and trying to pass it off as the real thing.
I would never buy a true fake with a fake label. I own several semi-duplicates. There is zero possibility of anyone on the secondary market mistakenly buying one of my dupes thinking it is an Hermes bag. The shoulder strap makes it even less likely to be mistaken for an original. I would like a WalMart 'Birkin' but we don't have Walmart her in Australia. The luxury houses will take years to recover from the Dior scandal and the shameful greed of the excessive price rises. I don't mind paying extra for a luxury label, but only within proportion. And that does not even apply to Hermes bags because if I had the purchase price, the company would be unlikely to sell it to me. Thank you for the video!
There's (for me) a huge difference between dupes and fakes! A fake is a copy trying to look exactly like the original, a dupe is more "inspired by" and there are obvious points of difference. I have one bag that could be called a dupe, it's the Pourchet Trianon and is similar to the Fendi Peekaboo. It has a turn lock (only on one side, the other is a snap closure), it has a similar shape, top handle and the two compartments. It has the stitching detail that some Peekaboos have. But the turn lock is quite different, and it doesn't have the snap closure at the sides that enable the Peekaboo to smile. For me, the Kelly, Capucines and the Peekaboo all have a similar vibe, but without being identical, and back in the day there would have been hundreds of bags with the same basic shape. My Trianon is a good quality bag, at a reasonable price and I take it everywhere with few worries (it's not the most secure bag with just a turn lock, so that gets taken into account), will I upgrade to a Peekaboo at some point? Possibly, but only after I get my hands on a Fendi Baguette!
I am impressed how you addressed this Workin hope! Totally agree, you are down to earth. Love this input on such an unaffordable piece , with so much hipe . Happy New Year’s ❤
Walmart's galore in my home town. Not surprised they are on the gravy train off profit when it comes to mimicking luxury products. The bag will sell and next week will maybe be available in multiple beautiful colours. ❤ your channel
I don’t think I could ever be rich enough to feel comfortable spending the money to buy an actual birkin even if Hermes allowed me to but I do like nice bags so I might buy the Walmart one because I wouldn’t have to stress about it and it does seem like a nice bag
Autumn Beckman made a really good video about this topic too. I'm in the US, but I've never been interested in a Birkin. When a mini kelly dupe comes up, I'll be interested in that!
@ameliarosescloset when I added to my cart this morning it was $188. At lunch I went to buy, they went up $100. Now $288. How? Kinda made me mad. Lol So for now, I'm passing on it.
Yes, these are great - I have a few of them. Size 25 in light pink and gray and size 30 in black. It’s real leather and I paid something like $65 + tax. I can’t afford the actual Hermes one…but these are nice!
I rather buy a bag from a brand that adds their own design elements to the style of bag. It’s totally fine for Coach to make their own quality version of the Margaux or Birkin by integrating their leathers and house codes, but I don’t understand wanting to have something that’s an inferior copy of the real thing. Who are you fooling? There’s so many good mid-range and affordable brands out there with super cute designs!
Awwww…the so called “luxury” ladies are mad because they are crazy enough to spend their hard earned money to a brand (Hermes) who makes them feel like the don’t deserve to buy their purse. But yet smart ladies getting the same look, paying under $100 and keeping money in their wallets. I love it!
Good quality versions of the Birkin have been kicking around for a long time and will continue to. I got one from Teddy Blake back when they used to have them. It was real leather and well made and the beauty of it is I got to test the style out before committing to buying a real Birkin (which I do now have). I was also able to use it without being worried about bumps or scratches. These bags serve a great function in letting us scratch an itch until the hype has worn off or test a bags suitability.
It’s understandable that brands will create a product that is similar to another brand’s product. But to dupe it, not my preference. I don’t believe in giving off false impressions to appear to be something I am not. I believe a fair amount of buyers of dupes are individuals who belittle the brand(s) but then turn around and want to give off the impression that they are carrying the real thing with the dupe. That line of reasoning, I just cannot understand. But again, I don’t believe in giving off false impressions😊. For the Walmart inspired birkin, it’s egregious but at least it’s not a counterfeit. I enjoyed your take on it Amelia. Another great video👏.
Just bought a similar knock off from Amazon this weekend. I’m happy enough and it should arrive this Friday. In a pretty bright tannish orangey color. 😊
Back in October 2024, I purchased 3 one in Kelly Green and when I received i I was impressed with the quality - and the shipping was super fast- so I then purchased a black version for every day use. Mine did not have the cross body strap option, so I then purchased the smallest sz in light pink and the small pink has a cross body option which is nice. I also do have 2 actual Birkins I purchased back in 2003 - I was invited to be on the list and then waited for 2 years to purchase- I do enjoy having the Walmart versions for the very reason that these days I don’t want to run around town sporting a bag that now sells for around $15k to $20k and for everyday use the Workins I have are nice looking-I bought the real leather versions - and functional. I did go on line and ordered real leather straps to convert to a cross body style. And the straps matched the black leather of the Workin one I have beautifully. All in all its is a good option for many of the reasons you state in your video. After all, we should all wear what we love for whatever the reason. Also, let’s not forget that for hundreds of years women of substantial means have had replicas of their fine expensive jewelry made for travel purposes, etc. Having a Workin also serves a similar purpose.
I personally don’t like dupes and I don’t understand why anyone would want to buy a bag that looks like it’s trying to be another bag. I understand there are many bags that look similar style wise but they’re not trying to be another bag-if that makes sense lol I would rather a bag that isn’t trying to look like something else. Is there a shortage of bag designers in the world 😅
half the fun of owning a designer bag is when you know you've saved hard to buy the real deal, and it's your favorite and most cherished bag. buying a dupe comes across as a person who doesn't have a sense of style and buys something just because the internet told them to.
PS: My understanding (I have no training in law, so don't relay on me!) is that there has to be a certain number of differences in fashion items to avoid prosecution for infringement. The inclusion of a shoulder strap and grommets would help Walmart to avoid problems.
I went online and got mine back in November I got a red green and orange one and I love them I put a white one in my cart on the Walmart website all sold out
I just bought one today - 25 green (looks like a teal). Delivery is in about 2 weeks. They had two colors available and both sold out in seconds after my purchase. Paid $90.
Teddy Blake has some nice Hermes looking bags including the Birkin….LOL…😂…Walmart Birkin realized there was demand for those bag and were like “Say less, heres our version. Have at it.”
I love Teddy Blake because the quality and workmanship of the leather is beautiful. I can’t imagine for $80 the quality of this bag would be that great.
There’s alway been Birkin and Kelly dupes for example lily and bean and toteluxe ! I think if you think you’d like it but not 100% sure you can buy a dupe before dropping 20k on the resale market ❤
I think purchasing the Walmart version is a nice way to see if you truly would like to possibly invest in a Birkin. Plus it’s not a fake which makes it even better. Or maybe you can’t afford Hermes but you love the look. I love that there are dupes out there because everyone deserves to carry a nice bag whether real or just a dupe. That’s always been my take ❤❤ I’m on the notify me list because I want to see this viral bag 😂😂. I don’t have a desire for a birkin because they have to many hoops but maybe this bag will change that. ❤❤
While I appreciate the artisan craftsmanship and quality of the genuine Hermes bag, a real leather dupe that look so close to the real deal and cost only $78, it tells you how much markup you are paying for the name. At the end of the day, it’s just a bag.
Thanks Amelia for doing this video. I have never got on the TT train, I wondered what this was all about. I am definitely one of those people who feel if I have that kind of money for a bag, I should be able to walk in and purchase it. Therefor Hermes will never get any of my money. Even though I like some of their household items, it’s the principal of it. Won’t shop there. I am probably rare in that I am not a fan of that style so I won’t be purchasing the Walmart version. But for anyone who does, I say go for it!
I think everyone in the last 30 years has become ‘collectors’. In the boomer generation, it was pretty much a shoe phenomenon. Since, the year 2000, it seems to be anything and everything.
I love your hair color here. Also I want to style and will be buying a workin. 😂 I was never gonna buy a Berkin because I can’t think of spending that much money on a bag. But hey now I can see what the fuss I all about. Heard they are hard to open. Yes I know it’s not a real Birkin.
I checked it out it looks like a birkin in pictures but it has straps and of course does not say Hermes in the front. However the leather B30 were $268. It sold out like mad!!😂
isnt it still playing the game when you buy things/pre-spend regardless if you wanted to buy the item or if you only did it for pre-spend? i do appreciate the Wirkin being crossbody lol.
If Walmart were to do a dupe of the Kelly, we could call it the Welly. I think the orange Werkin looks great fun and I wouldn’t say no to one. Hermes is way over my budget.
I have a few designer bags but lately I’m having a change of heart. I think I should get back to my old self when I used to save and invest in real estate. All you young people out there, please save your money and invest it in real estate. I spent $200k in real estate on two properties and now they are worth close to two million. This advice is from a lady in her 50s and living in Hawaii.
The birkin not the warkin!!! lol. If it’s not a birkin it is not a birkin. Walmart version is a dupe dupe. Funny people who said it’s an ugly bag are running to buy the dupe!! 😅says a lot about human nature.
My dream bag has always been a Birkin 40… I have to admit that I bought a pretty good replica online and after using for a couple of days I just realized that it’s not for me. It just doesn’t go with my lifestyle nor my everyday clothes, I’m always using gym clothes. I can’t justify wearing a Birkin with gym clothes, it looks ridiculous. I just stopped thinking about it and moved on to other bags that do fit into my lifestyle. Coach and Longchamp are more my style and I can afford buying authentics 😂
Most of us who live in the real world will ever come close to a real Birkin. It is just fun to buy a Wirkin. The colors are fun. It is a functional style that would be really usable.
I LOVE this issue. I can hardly wait to see the Ghetto Boys and Girls proudly swanning along with their Wirkin!!! I can't stand bags being turned into currency. Buy what you want, but bring down the snooty, unattainable $$$ ego bags. Then, we 'will proudly flaunt our dupes (AND OUR GOOD SENSE). Again, if the Lux Brands won't play fair with us, we won't play fair with them
On the Walmart site the pink 25 bag is $188.88. It’s not sold by Walmart, but by some other company, where Walmart is acting as a platform ( like Amazon). The description is full of grammar mistakes. It also uses three different words in different places to describe the leather: genuine, synthetic, vegan. I guess people buy it without reading the full description. 😢if not for the description I might’ve been curious enough to buy it.
Great video. I could never buy an Hermes bag nor would I want to due to the snobbery. My question to Hermes owners is aren’t you concerned about taking one out in public? Not safe!!!
The Walmart version classes as a copy not a fake or counterfeit. A counterfeit is when it’s an exact replica with all logos and hidden features intact and sold as the item it’s pertaining to be. In this context, the ‘Walkin’ is a copy. A copy is a replica without the logos and extras and is not sold as a Birkin. If we had Walmart in the UK, I’d 100% buy one.
Tbh there are well-known designers who are ripping off other brand's designs and take a lot of money for it. See Tory Burch: she has a whole range of bags that are clearly 'inspired' by Chanel and recently released sandals that are obviously meant to be a Hermès Chypre dupe. What I really wonder is how those ripped off brand respond to those designs being 'repurposed'. Clearly they can't be happy? I do wonder what Hermès is making of the Walmart Birkin, too.
People are tired and are waking up and starting to be wise with their money. At the end of the day, it's just a purse. I love my Vera Bradley totes, bought reduced on Amazon. I get lots of compliments ❤.
I REFUSE to pay for any brand Name. I have no problem buying a dupe and saving my money rather than making a board of directors rich. Enjoying unique and original items I stay away from Labels. Ladies don’t feel bad I live in NY and the closest Walmart is 2 hours away.
I'd absolutely buy a Wirkin, except I'm in the UK so not an option. I had a Lily & Bean mini Kelly dupe but it was too small for me so I didn't use it. I'm never going to be able to afford a Birkin so Hermes aren't losing out.
I love designer, however I simply don’t have the self control to save. The best I’m going to do is Coach. Did you see the Coach Maggie tote? It’s very much like the On the Go LV. I think they’ve all just decided to clone the fashion houses.
I wouldn’t buy one because I appreciate quality and have the funds to buy something with better quality at a higher price point. Maybe not Hermes (maybe one day) but there’s a whole spectrum of unique designs and quality leather and craftsmanship in between the Wirkin and the Birkin. I’d rather have an original (preloved or new) in my price bracket rather than a cheap Hermes dupe. But no shade to those that love dupes. It’s personal preference. My favourite workhorse day bag is my Loewe medium puzzle. Easy to get in and out of, secure, IYKYK, cool design, handy back pocket, top handle and a comfy shoulder strap. I think the only way I could see myself buying one is if I had the money for the real thing, but wanted to try out the design first.
I'm okay with a bag that takes some elements of a popular bag and then adds something else creative. But I'm not sure how I feel about dupes, even when, like with the Walmart Birkin, it's very obviously meant to be recognized as a dupe and not meant to fool anyone that it's the original artists design. It feels like you're ripping off the artist (I think fashion is art, call me crazy). But regardless of that-- why would you want a Birkin dupe? The thing that makes Hermes bags special is that they are one of the last designer houses still creating luxury bags-- with handmade details and beautiful leather. I can't afford one, but I can appreciate the quality and I don't see how a Walmart dupe would ever satisfy the desire for a real luxury bag.
I think fakes are great, as long as you’re not “duped” into paying the designer price. Although anyone who pays thousands for a damn purse deserves what they get lol
There are others that will be better quality dupes. Like Tiffany and Fred and others. I’m not a Walmart fan personally. I will never own a Hermes as I just can’t justify that spend. I would prefer to buy real estate. No shame for those that will buy a real Birkin, I just know me and it would sit shelved because I would be terrified to use it.
honestly as a luxury lover. in my opinion. leather is leather. i noe i'm just paying for the brand name. so at the end of the day, it's my money and no one else money. would i buy a dupe? yes if i want to. ❤❤❤
I’m probably the only person who thinks this way but I think the Birkins are unattractive. They look to me like an old lady bag. I’m well on my way to being old myself so I have some perspective. The little yellow one is cute! I’ve always gravitated toward Coach and even Dooney &Burke styles and the prices! 😊
Made in China. You can actually buy the kits with the leather with pre-cut holes for stitching. Not bad looking. I want to emboss my initials in to. Takes about 9 hours to make, so, it will take me 18 hours…!!!😂
What do you think viral Walmart Birkin blowing up tiktok!
Cheap looking I was wondering if Canada has it
China
Update ‼Walmart has removed this listing as the link is no longer working. 😭👜
It’s yet another dupe. It’s just less expensive than most. At this point, TikTok can make almost anything go viral.
I know I dont want one
In the words of Jane Birkin herself.... “It’s very nice that everyone’s got one or wants one, if people want to go for the real thing, fine. If they go for copies, that’s fine, too. I really don’t think it matters.” She told this to Vogue in 2011 when asked about fake Birkins, and I could not agree with her more.
Neither could I!
Mic drop!
I love fakes for the price. Designer brands are a rip off. Remember Dior tote cost about sixty dollars to make but retail for two thousand dollars? Hermes bags are the same. Their cost to make is nowhere near their retail price.
There’s definitely a mark up for the brand name
I am one of those who have no interest in Hermes bags. I have well over 100 luxury bags and none are from Hermes. I would however not buy the Walmart version either.
The reason I don’t want an Hermes «quota» bag is partly due to their games and lack of transparency in how to get one, partly that I don’t particularly like the Birkin or Kelly (although I like the colors and leathers) and partly that I find the B & K cliché. I’d feel awkward running around with one. I don’t mean to offend those who love them and I was very happy for you when you got your mini Kelly because I know how much you wanted it. You have them in special colors that I love as well. But I just don’t feel the pull.
I wish I didn’t feel the pull!
Another unattainable bag😢…no Walmart here in Australia. Absolutely yes I would buy one! I went into Hermes in Melbourne to buy shoes and jewellery and was treated like an unwanted customer they literally hid out the back and keep looking around corner and would not serve me. I was not rude I was dressed well, and I was patient I waited 45 min to get help which did not happen. I was not the only one in the store that this was happening to, a lady who was sitting down said to me she was on day 2 waiting to buy and that if it wasn’t her daughter’s special birthday she would would never have come back with such poor customer service. I left and went and spent my money at LV with amazing lovely customer service.
Same no Walmart here. That’s awful about your experience in Hermes
@@MillBee691 that's so sad, you're such a patient mom to put up with that on behalf of your daughter ☺️
That’s awful so sorry they are jackasses. People still buy. Don’t even get it.
@@ameliarosescloset I fell in love with everything about Hermes from the history to the craftsmanship, I had saved for a whole year just to go and buy the beautiful pieces and get the experience...I fell out of love with them and in love with LV.
Their intention is to treat you like sh-t to create FOMO. It makes you want it more. You should have some dignity and told them to get lost.
In the past, I bought a dupe for both the Birkin and the Kelly. In buying both bags, I learned that I am not a fan of either the Birkin or the Kelly. The closures are too fussy and I am too OCD to carry my bag partially open. Dupes are a good way to figure out the a bag style and whether or not you want to drop the coin on a high end bag.😊❤
They are a great way of finding out if the bag works, I would have done this with the mini kelly if I was considering buying one resale due to the price
Same with dupe perfumes!
There was a viral dupe for the Row Margaux at TJMaxx/Marshall's not long ago too. Now I see it everywhere on Amazon, Walmart etc.
Honestly, I think the veil has been lifted for some people after the Dior scandal and I don't blame them for choosing the budget friendlier version. Honestly, what's the difference between a bag made by Chinese workers with Chinese manufactured materials in China (who get to go home, be with family and sleep in a normal bed) VS. a bag made by Chinese workers trafficked to Italy for low wages, sleeping in the factory without their family, and is made with Chinese manufactured materials shipped to Italy just so they can skirt a few laws to keep the label "Made in Italy" because it's technically *assembled* in Italy... I'm not a huge Walmart person but I do see the appeal.
That Teddy Blake bag is so cute. Might have to put that on my 2025 wishlist in a lizard embossed version. ❤
I used that teddy Blake for quite a while and it stood up well!
I one thousand percent agree with you, the birkin is not exclusive, the birkin is paywalled and hermes are con artists..... People just fall for their behaviour hook, line and sinker.
@@notme1255 can you share the Margaux link?
as much as I like carrying lux bags, a bag is a bag is a bag. They are to put stuff in at the end of the day.
Exactly
Facts 👍🏻
The irony of being unable to get a Birkin dupe is astounding.
I think that I personally feel put off by Hermes because to me the hype feels entirely manufactured. I'm not saying that they're not quality bags but some people act as if they are the only high quality bags on the planet when justifying the price and the hoops to jump through. I'm not a handbag connoisseur but just from an outsiders perspective surely you can buy way better looking bags with the same quality for far less. I watch Jessie Styles here on RUclips and love watching her videos and she has a whole shelf full of Hermes but aside from the bright colors she has I honestly see nothing but a bunch of plain, non descript, and frankly boring bags. I'm not saying that to be mean and clearly she loves them and that's all that matters but in all honesty if it wasn't for the manufactured hype created by the feeling of scarcity I don't think most people would give a hoot about Hermes.
Agreed. The quality is immaculate but FOMO is very real in the Hermès world.
For me it’s only the bright colours that make these bags
Wow it’s so worth it because it comes with a strap to wear crossbody👍 I would buy that bag and walk into Hermes to take a piss😂
lol!!! I wonder would they notice the difference!!
I work for Walmart in the US and we don’t have this bag in the stores it’s basically online only, I’m sure if it was in the stores it wouldn’t last long.
I wonder if they will come in store
@ Probably not, because bags like that are for the online site, but the stores have their own brand of bags and clothes called Time and True and the bags are not real leather Walmart online also has a leather version of the mini Kelly by Norbrand for $59.05 I’m sure that will sell out also.
They'd have to store them in a glass case with the deodorant and condoms so they don't get stolen. Fancy!
Do you have the link. I cannot find it. I would like it for a travel bag.
You are so real- I want a Wirkin too 😂, hope your channel grows and grows ❤
Thank you so much!!
I think the whole phenomenon is hilarious! 😆
It’s so intriguing!!
So do I hilarious
I’ve seen plenty of Birkin - ish dupes or inspired bags out there. Made in Italy they look quite nice.
There are a lot about
I don’t mind seeing “inspired by” bags as most designers seem to be copying each other, as long as they aren’t slapping an Hermes tag on it and trying to pass it off as the real thing.
Would have been cool with a Walmart logo
There's a Walmart Picotin for $30 😆
"Premium Genuine Leather Bucket Bag"
Oh really!
I would never buy a true fake with a fake label. I own several semi-duplicates. There is zero possibility of anyone on the secondary market mistakenly buying one of my dupes thinking it is an Hermes bag. The shoulder strap makes it even less likely to be mistaken for an original. I would like a WalMart 'Birkin' but we don't have Walmart her in Australia. The luxury houses will take years to recover from the Dior scandal and the shameful greed of the excessive price rises. I don't mind paying extra for a luxury label, but only within proportion. And that does not even apply to Hermes bags because if I had the purchase price, the company would be unlikely to sell it to me. Thank you for the video!
We don’t have Walmart here either. I think there is a big difference between dupes and fakes
There's (for me) a huge difference between dupes and fakes! A fake is a copy trying to look exactly like the original, a dupe is more "inspired by" and there are obvious points of difference.
I have one bag that could be called a dupe, it's the Pourchet Trianon and is similar to the Fendi Peekaboo. It has a turn lock (only on one side, the other is a snap closure), it has a similar shape, top handle and the two compartments. It has the stitching detail that some Peekaboos have. But the turn lock is quite different, and it doesn't have the snap closure at the sides that enable the Peekaboo to smile.
For me, the Kelly, Capucines and the Peekaboo all have a similar vibe, but without being identical, and back in the day there would have been hundreds of bags with the same basic shape. My Trianon is a good quality bag, at a reasonable price and I take it everywhere with few worries (it's not the most secure bag with just a turn lock, so that gets taken into account), will I upgrade to a Peekaboo at some point? Possibly, but only after I get my hands on a Fendi Baguette!
I am impressed how you addressed this Workin hope! Totally agree, you are down to earth. Love this input on such an unaffordable piece , with so much hipe . Happy New Year’s ❤
Thanks so much!
@@jessier.cardona6062 Amelia is such a sweetie. I love her contact.
Walmart's galore in my home town. Not surprised they are on the gravy train off profit when it comes to mimicking luxury products. The bag will sell and next week will maybe be available in multiple beautiful colours. ❤ your channel
Thank you!
I don’t think I could ever be rich enough to feel comfortable spending the money to buy an actual birkin even if Hermes allowed me to but I do like nice bags so I might buy the Walmart one because I wouldn’t have to stress about it and it does seem like a nice bag
It would be completely cwrefree
@ that would make it enjoyable if I actually bought a real one I’d worry about messing it up or losing it and it would never leave the closet lol
Autumn Beckman made a really good video about this topic too. I'm in the US, but I've never been interested in a Birkin. When a mini kelly dupe comes up, I'll be interested in that!
Autumn’s channel is luxury and life on a budget so I imagine her video on this is superb, she would have a great take on it
There is a Mini Kelly. See Candace Glamluxemama. I haven’t watched the video yet. But I think it was a Kelly that she was holding
The baby Pink in 30 is $200. Here in US. Seriously thinking. Early Valentine's to me.
And you get the use of the bag without worry
@ameliarosescloset when I added to my cart this morning it was $188. At lunch I went to buy, they went up $100. Now $288. How? Kinda made me mad. Lol So for now, I'm passing on it.
Yes, these are great - I have a few of them. Size 25 in light pink and gray and size 30 in black. It’s real leather and I paid something like $65 + tax. I can’t afford the actual Hermes one…but these are nice!
Oh yay!
I have a real B25 and I kinda want one of these 😂
I rather buy a bag from a brand that adds their own design elements to the style of bag. It’s totally fine for Coach to make their own quality version of the Margaux or Birkin by integrating their leathers and house codes, but I don’t understand wanting to have something that’s an inferior copy of the real thing. Who are you fooling? There’s so many good mid-range and affordable brands out there with super cute designs!
Love this
Did I see a strap in that unboxing???
Now that’s actually interesting!!
A Walmart upgrade 😂😂😂😂
You did, but there were no more details to
Show how/ length etc!
@@ameliarosescloset I stalked. There appears to be round metal eyelets in the leather folds at the sides, towards the top binding. Brilliant 😆😆😆😆😆😆
Yes the working has a crossbody strap.
Awwww…the so called “luxury” ladies are mad because they are crazy enough to spend their hard earned money to a brand (Hermes) who makes them feel like the don’t deserve to buy their purse.
But yet smart ladies getting the same look, paying under $100 and keeping money in their wallets.
I love it!
I’m still crazy enough to spend my money at Hermes!
@ 😅🤣
Good quality versions of the Birkin have been kicking around for a long time and will continue to. I got one from Teddy Blake back when they used to have them. It was real leather and well made and the beauty of it is I got to test the style out before committing to buying a real Birkin (which I do now have). I was also able to use it without being worried about bumps or scratches. These bags serve a great function in letting us scratch an itch until the hype has worn off or test a bags suitability.
I have the kelly style from teddy Blake, used it the same way as you
It’s understandable that brands will create a product that is similar to another brand’s product. But to dupe it, not my preference. I don’t believe in giving off false impressions to appear to be something I am not. I believe a fair amount of buyers of dupes are individuals who belittle the brand(s) but then turn around and want to give off the impression that they are carrying the real thing with the dupe. That line of reasoning, I just cannot understand. But again, I don’t believe in giving off false impressions😊.
For the Walmart inspired birkin, it’s egregious but at least it’s not a counterfeit. I enjoyed your take on it Amelia. Another great video👏.
That is the bit i don’t get either, if the hate the bag!
Just bought a similar knock off from Amazon this weekend. I’m happy enough and it should arrive this Friday. In a pretty bright tannish orangey color. 😊
I have a tan and beautiful green that I also purchased from Amazon and I LOVE them. I would never spend that much just for a label.
Hope you enjoy it!
Back in October 2024, I purchased 3 one in Kelly Green and when I received i I was impressed with the quality - and the shipping was super fast- so I then purchased a black version for every day use. Mine did not have the cross body strap option, so I then purchased the smallest sz in light pink and the small pink has a cross body option which is nice. I also do have 2 actual Birkins I purchased back in 2003 - I was invited to be on the list and then waited for 2 years to purchase- I do enjoy having the Walmart versions for the very reason that these days I don’t want to run around town sporting a bag that now sells for around $15k to $20k and for everyday use the Workins I have are nice looking-I bought the real leather versions - and functional. I did go on line and ordered real leather straps to convert to a cross body style. And the straps matched the black leather of the Workin one I have beautifully. All in all its is a good option for many of the reasons you state in your video. After all, we should all wear what we love for whatever the reason. Also, let’s not forget that for hundreds of years women of substantial means have had replicas of their fine expensive jewelry made for travel purposes, etc. Having a Workin also serves a similar purpose.
Oh fab, congratulations!!
I personally don’t like dupes and I don’t understand why anyone would want to buy a bag that looks like it’s trying to be another bag. I understand there are many bags that look similar style wise but they’re not trying to be another bag-if that makes sense lol
I would rather a bag that isn’t trying to look like something else. Is there a shortage of bag designers in the world 😅
I know what you mean
Agreed!
half the fun of owning a designer bag is when you know you've saved hard to buy the real deal, and it's your favorite and most cherished bag. buying a dupe comes across as a person who doesn't have a sense of style and buys something just because the internet told them to.
@@SofiaSeesBeauty 🩷🤝
@@TeenDream888 agree, and there are so many nice, all leather handbags that can be bought which are nice in their own right 🩷
Omg your accent when you say Walmart Wirkin is fantastic, I want one !!
lol thank you!
PS: My understanding (I have no training in law, so don't relay on me!) is that there has to be a certain number of differences in fashion items to avoid prosecution for infringement. The inclusion of a shoulder strap and grommets would help Walmart to avoid problems.
Ah enough to differentiate the bag from the original
I would totally have one of it had Walmart stamped on the front. Anything to give the middle finger to Heremes 😂
Now that would be a vibe!
Search for the Kamugo brand, it's the one that sells genuine leather. I'm not from the US either, but I found a local seller in my country.
Oh thank you!
I went online and got mine back in November I got a red green and orange one and I love them I put a white one in my cart on the Walmart website all sold out
Congratulations!
It's SYNTHETIC LEATHER.
Oh thank you!
Another reason I prefer lowkey designer bags. The most popular styles get obliterated by dupes and fakes.
Yes they do, like LV monogram
@ the real ones are still super worth it but ya. Makes you look at less popular things in a different light.
I just bought one today - 25 green (looks like a teal). Delivery is in about 2 weeks. They had two colors available and both sold out in seconds after my purchase. Paid $90.
Tell us what it’s like when it comes!
ALL sold out already
Teddy Blake has some nice Hermes looking bags including the Birkin….LOL…😂…Walmart Birkin realized there was demand for those bag and were like “Say less, heres our version. Have at it.”
I used my teddy blake kelly for quite a while!
I love Teddy Blake because the quality and workmanship of the leather is beautiful. I can’t imagine for $80 the quality of this bag would be that great.
There’s alway been Birkin and Kelly dupes for example lily and bean and toteluxe ! I think if you think you’d like it but not 100% sure you can buy a dupe before dropping 20k on the resale market ❤
I was tempted to get the lily and bean if I was going to consider the mini kelly resale price
I think purchasing the Walmart version is a nice way to see if you truly would like to possibly invest in a Birkin. Plus it’s not a fake which makes it even better. Or maybe you can’t afford Hermes but you love the look. I love that there are dupes out there because everyone deserves to carry a nice bag whether real or just a dupe. That’s always been my take ❤❤ I’m on the notify me list because I want to see this viral bag 😂😂. I don’t have a desire for a birkin because they have to many hoops but maybe this bag will change that. ❤❤
Yes it lets you try out the style
I heard about it and laughed so hard!! I ordered one! I don’t even like Hermes!
I can see why you did!
Wondering are the stores themselves selling it or the website?
Apparently it’s the website
Already there is nothing to be found on Walmarts website. The link brings you to a lost page... What was the actual brand to the Wlamart Berkin?
I didn’t screen shot it unfortunately, I think they have removed it all together
I bought a special order fake hand made Birkin from China. Black Birkin retourne size 40cwith gold hardware. And it is exactly the same. £350.
I did not know you could do that
While I appreciate the artisan craftsmanship and quality of the genuine Hermes bag, a real leather dupe that look so close to the real deal and cost only $78, it tells you how much markup you are paying for the name. At the end of the day, it’s just a bag.
It’s now apparently confirmed it’s not real leather
Thanks Amelia for doing this video. I have never got on the TT train, I wondered what this was all about. I am definitely one of those people who feel if I have that kind of money for a bag, I should be able to walk in and purchase it. Therefor Hermes will never get any of my money. Even though I like some of their household items, it’s the principal of it. Won’t shop there. I am probably rare in that I am not a fan of that style so I won’t be purchasing the Walmart version. But for anyone who does, I say go for it!
I totally understand this
I think everyone in the last 30 years has become ‘collectors’. In the boomer generation, it was pretty much a shoe phenomenon. Since, the year 2000, it seems to be anything and everything.
I love the Fendi Peekaboo colors ❤
Hey are gorge
I was just on the Walmart website they have preowned birkins for 15-40,000. All colors. Never did see the fake one
I had no idea they had those!
Yes apparently they are from Tokyo and the reviews were not nice saying they were fake
Great video! I agree with you! I would love that look in fun colors and Im ready to go buy some fun ones!
You should!
I love your hair color here. Also I want to style and will be buying a workin. 😂 I was never gonna buy a Berkin because I can’t think of spending that much money on a bag. But hey now I can see what the fuss I all about. Heard they are hard to open. Yes I know it’s not a real Birkin.
It gives you the idea of how the bag would work for you
walmart link does not function for the bag….😢
I think they have removed it!
I checked it out it looks like a birkin in pictures but it has straps and of course does not say Hermes in the front. However the leather B30 were $268. It sold out like mad!!😂
I can see why it’s flying off the shelves!
Did you also see all the pre-loved Birkins listed for sale on Walmart? Who knew?
I did and I had no idea!!
isnt it still playing the game when you buy things/pre-spend regardless if you wanted to buy the item or if you only did it for pre-spend?
i do appreciate the Wirkin being crossbody lol.
Maybe it is, Hermes is a bit of a mystery!
If Walmart were to do a dupe of the Kelly, we could call it the Welly. I think the orange Werkin looks great fun and I wouldn’t say no to one. Hermes is way over my budget.
Ah the welly!
What is the name of the bag
Apparently it had been removed from the site
And the Kellys looked very good too😂
I have a few designer bags but lately I’m having a change of heart. I think I should get back to my old self when I used to save and invest in real estate. All you young people out there, please save your money and invest it in real estate. I spent $200k in real estate on two properties and now they are worth close to two million. This advice is from a lady in her 50s and living in Hawaii.
This is fabulous, congratulations!!
The birkin not the warkin!!! lol. If it’s not a birkin it is not a birkin. Walmart version is a dupe dupe. Funny people who said it’s an ugly bag are running to buy the dupe!! 😅says a lot about human nature.
It really does!
Not all of us. Still an ugly bag.
What’s the link to the Walmart bag or how is it listed?
It was linked in the description
@@ameliarosescloset ok, they all seem to be sold out
Funny I really thought your Pink bag was one of the Walmart bags 😂
Would’ve saved me a fortune!!
I'm confused because I saw a tiktok with a yellow version but no sign of that color online?
I also saw a purple
My dream bag has always been a Birkin 40… I have to admit that I bought a pretty good replica online and after using for a couple of days I just realized that it’s not for me. It just doesn’t go with my lifestyle nor my everyday clothes, I’m always using gym clothes. I can’t justify wearing a Birkin with gym clothes, it looks ridiculous.
I just stopped thinking about it and moved on to other bags that do fit into my lifestyle.
Coach and Longchamp are more my style and I can afford buying authentics 😂
It does give the opportunity to try out the style
What a fortunate discovery!
This was an interesting video. I agree with your take on this. I think you are brave to speak your mind.
I appreciate that, I will always say what I truly think
Most of us who live in the real world will ever come close to a real Birkin. It is just fun to buy a Wirkin. The colors are fun. It is a functional style that would be really usable.
I agree!
They actually have the Kelly 25 version on Walmart’s website . I saw it yesterday.
Oh do they!
I LOVE this issue. I can hardly wait to see the Ghetto Boys and Girls proudly swanning along with their Wirkin!!! I can't stand bags being turned into currency. Buy what you want, but bring down the snooty, unattainable $$$ ego bags. Then, we 'will proudly flaunt our dupes (AND OUR GOOD SENSE). Again, if the Lux Brands won't play fair with us, we won't play fair with them
@marchgregoroff4605 What does ghetto boys & girls mean?
I think a lot of people will feel like this
On the Walmart site the pink 25 bag is $188.88. It’s not sold by Walmart, but by some other company, where Walmart is acting as a platform ( like Amazon). The description is full of grammar mistakes. It also uses three different words in different places to describe the leather: genuine, synthetic, vegan. I guess people buy it without reading the full description. 😢if not for the description I might’ve been curious enough to buy it.
Oh I didn’t know Walmart did that
Not sure I need this from Walmart, but would love an hour or 5 to shop in Walmart…..and American Target!
I don’t think I’ve ever been in one!
Great video. I could never buy an Hermes bag nor would I want to due to the snobbery. My question to Hermes owners is aren’t you concerned about taking one out in public? Not safe!!!
I take mine out regularly, I’ve never felt uncomfortable
The Walmart version classes as a copy not a fake or counterfeit. A counterfeit is when it’s an exact replica with all logos and hidden features intact and sold as the item it’s pertaining to be. In this context, the ‘Walkin’ is a copy. A copy is a replica without the logos and extras and is not sold as a Birkin. If we had Walmart in the UK, I’d 100% buy one.
Yes it is a dupe
I wonder if they will do a restock
I think they will
Tbh there are well-known designers who are ripping off other brand's designs and take a lot of money for it. See Tory Burch: she has a whole range of bags that are clearly 'inspired' by Chanel and recently released sandals that are obviously meant to be a Hermès Chypre dupe. What I really wonder is how those ripped off brand respond to those designs being 'repurposed'. Clearly they can't be happy? I do wonder what Hermès is making of the Walmart Birkin, too.
Very true, Steve Madden also
It looks like the bag was taken down from Walmarts site. Still trying to find it.
Someone also told me their order was cancelled
I love the teddy bag. The orange is so pretty.
It’s a fab colour!
People are tired and are waking up and starting to be wise with their money. At the end of the day, it's just a purse. I love my Vera Bradley totes, bought reduced on Amazon. I get lots of compliments ❤.
I think a lot are fed up with the price increases also
I REFUSE to pay for any brand Name. I have no problem buying a dupe and saving my money rather than making a board of directors rich. Enjoying unique and original items I stay away from Labels. Ladies don’t feel bad I live in NY and the closest Walmart is 2 hours away.
Brands aren’t for everyone
I'd absolutely buy a Wirkin, except I'm in the UK so not an option. I had a Lily & Bean mini Kelly dupe but it was too small for me so I didn't use it. I'm never going to be able to afford a Birkin so Hermes aren't losing out.
I was going to buy a lily and bean if I was considering the mini kelly on the resale market
I love designer, however I simply don’t have the self control to save. The best I’m going to do is Coach. Did you see the Coach Maggie tote? It’s very much like the On the Go LV. I think they’ve all just decided to clone the fashion houses.
There are a lot of designs that are truly
Inspired by other houses
I have one of their scarves and two belts and love them 😍. That said, I am unlikely to ever get an Hermes bag. Who knows though 😂.
I though I would never get a mini kelly
But you also have pre-used original Birkins on Wallmart
I didn’t know this!
@@ameliarosescloset now I read the comments that it's all fake
I wouldn’t buy one because I appreciate quality and have the funds to buy something with better quality at a higher price point. Maybe not Hermes (maybe one day) but there’s a whole spectrum of unique designs and quality leather and craftsmanship in between the Wirkin and the Birkin. I’d rather have an original (preloved or new) in my price bracket rather than a cheap Hermes dupe. But no shade to those that love dupes. It’s personal preference.
My favourite workhorse day bag is my Loewe medium puzzle. Easy to get in and out of, secure, IYKYK, cool design, handy back pocket, top handle and a comfy shoulder strap.
I think the only way I could see myself buying one is if I had the money for the real thing, but wanted to try out the design first.
I love the puzzle, I just need a fun version
I'm okay with a bag that takes some elements of a popular bag and then adds something else creative. But I'm not sure how I feel about dupes, even when, like with the Walmart Birkin, it's very obviously meant to be recognized as a dupe and not meant to fool anyone that it's the original artists design. It feels like you're ripping off the artist (I think fashion is art, call me crazy). But regardless of that-- why would you want a Birkin dupe? The thing that makes Hermes bags special is that they are one of the last designer houses still creating luxury bags-- with handmade details and beautiful leather. I can't afford one, but I can appreciate the quality and I don't see how a Walmart dupe would ever satisfy the desire for a real luxury bag.
For me I would still want the real thing
I don't mind people wearing fake stuffs as long as don't pretend as if they are original 😅
it looks stunnning. and wal mart will be sued in no time over it
Apparently has been removed from the site…
@@ameliarosescloset the bags are not available anymore?
Funny 😂 I guess it’s not a counterfeit because they don’t call it Birkin 🤔
It’s a Wirkin!!
as long as its not stamped Hermes in any way, its not counterfeit. It also obviously looks different especially around the lock area.
@@ameliarosescloset😂
I totally agree with you about the bright colors. My dream Birkin is a 40 sellier in epsom or Togo in anemone. I’m a sucker for that gorgeous purple.
That purple is on my dream wish list! I have a screen shot of a mini kelly in anemone on my phone!
Just buy that orange dupe and enjoy it for much less money! Maybe you will make some new discoveres about yourself
I would only we Don’t have Walmart and it’s sold out!!
@ Walmart will definitely restock them, because demand is huge.
I don't think there is much Hermes can do as long as they arent stamping it with Hermes.
It has been removed now
I think fakes are great, as long as you’re not “duped” into paying the designer price. Although anyone who pays thousands for a damn purse deserves what they get lol
Absolutely it is different if sold as authentic
There are others that will be better quality dupes. Like Tiffany and Fred and others. I’m not a Walmart fan personally. I will never own a Hermes as I just can’t justify that spend. I would prefer to buy real estate. No shame for those that will buy a real Birkin, I just know me and it would sit shelved because I would be terrified to use it.
Real estate makes more sense!
honestly as a luxury lover. in my opinion. leather is leather. i noe i'm just paying for the brand name. so at the end of the day, it's my money and no one else money. would i buy a dupe? yes if i want to. ❤❤❤
I will also still buy the brand
I got two and I love them.
Congratulations!
I’m probably the only person who thinks this way but I think the Birkins are unattractive. They look to me like an old lady bag. I’m well on my way to being old myself so I have some perspective. The little yellow one is cute! I’ve always gravitated toward Coach and even Dooney &Burke styles and the prices! 😊
For me they need to be bright colours to make them
Fun!
Hi! Is the Wirkin leather? I thought it was vegan leather? Either way very interesting! Tfs
Apparently they have brought out a leather version at around $280
Made in China. You can actually buy the kits with the leather with pre-cut holes for stitching. Not bad looking. I want to emboss my initials in to. Takes about 9 hours to make, so, it will take me 18 hours…!!!😂