Is Fiction HARAM? (BEST and EASIEST explanation + EXACT rulings!)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 28 сен 2024

Комментарии • 44

  • @SaadtheMuzlim
    @SaadtheMuzlim  9 дней назад +2

    Thank you for Watching!
    GO LIKE AND SUBSCRIBE RIGHT NOW!!!
    What topic would you like to see a video on next?
    I tried to stuff as much as I could into the video, but there’s still a few things that I couldn't discuss for the sake of conciseness:
    Storytelling is powerful. And, its power can be harnessed for the way of Islam.
    Currently, the Muslim world is weak and in its weakness, it has lost its literature. Western literature, containing western values that completely go against Islam, has seeped into the Muslim world, be it through the school system, be it through the internet or through social media. This has weakened the average Muslim and has corrupted the Islamic world. Hence, now, more than ever, there is a need for Muslim writers, who create beautiful pieces of literature by combining modern story writing with Islamic values, fulfilling the need of entertainment for the Muslims while also promoting Islamic morals, to rival the western corruption and create a world for the Muslims.
    So, if you're thinking about becoming a writer, PLEASE DO. WE NEED YOU.
    STORYWRITING IN THE QURAN, For Muslim writers:
    On how to produce prose, Surat Yusuf sets an interesting example of how a writer should describe the events in prose. The story of Yusuf and Zulaykha, in which Zulaykha tries to seduce Yusuf, is a story of human weaknesses and the strength to overcome desires. Nevertheless, the Qur’an portrays these weaknesses but does not play and elaborate on them. Similarly, the Qur’an leaves out the details of Zulaykha’s seduction of Yusuf. Rather, the Qur’an relates the events that befell Yusuf that brought on this seduction. This contrasts with some writings of fiction, which dwell on such events so as to titillate the reader and satisfy the craving of the writer and the curiosity of the reader. Still on the story of Yusuf, the Qur’an avoids describing the beauty of Yusuf at length. Rather his beauty is portrayed indirectly through the incident of the women cutting their fingers out of admiration for his beauty, which they described as angelic and not human. This, too, is not to encourage admiration for another human and also to avoid arousing the sensual instincts of the reader. Similarly when describing how Yusuf’s brothers threw him into the well, the Qur’an avoids giving details of how they carried out this evil deed. Similarly, with the story of Adam’s sons, the Qur’an avoids details of how the brother murdered his brother. This example reminds us that we are not allowed and should avoid relating and elaborating on evil doings so as not to encourage others to behave similarly.
    Jazakallah for reading!

  • @katokarii
    @katokarii 8 дней назад +5

    Would love to watch a video dedicated the topic of anime and if certain media pieces that contain elements of haram, would make the whole medium haram to consume- and the guidelines / proofs for this in sha Allah!

  • @Dorothi1267
    @Dorothi1267 7 дней назад +8

    When i found out that drawing is haram in islam, i started crying because i have a dream for a long time to create a story in the future. I wanted it to be a 2D animated show. Now i think i might right a book.

    • @lailaele.983
      @lailaele.983 6 дней назад +4

      Drawing entirely isn't haram. You can draw nature, surroundings (basically anything that doesn't involve life...because on the day of judgment you will be asked to blow life in the characters you created for surely no one can create life except Allah swt). I even watched some scholars say that it is okay if it's done for educational purpose.(but but but...please do research on this topic on your own account, please.) Sometimes even I had the idea of drawing books in my younger days. I used to negotitate that maybe if my scenes included nothing of the phase...uk like only legs as they show in to, and jerry or hands bu not the entire body?😂 Nvm it all ended as I grew up. Though I haven't left drawing. I sometimes draw like flowers leaves, house, street views without people etc.etc. And make up my journals.

    • @SaadtheMuzlim
      @SaadtheMuzlim  6 дней назад

      Imma need that book Dorothy

    • @TheLordMeniquiin
      @TheLordMeniquiin 4 дня назад

      bruv you haven't seen those arab animes? what a shame

    • @lailaele.983
      @lailaele.983 4 дня назад

      @@TheLordMeniquiin The Arabs aren't whom we look upto for Islam. Islam is to be understood through Quran and teachings of Prophet, not from a muslim.

    • @TheLordMeniquiin
      @TheLordMeniquiin 3 дня назад

      @@lailaele.983 yep, and that is why musical instruments isn't entirely haram

  • @maesizmayonnaise2745
    @maesizmayonnaise2745 9 дней назад +2

    Did you just reupload? For A second I thought this is was a new video, Was hella confused

    • @SaadtheMuzlim
      @SaadtheMuzlim  9 дней назад +1

      Aoa! Yeah, i made a mistake in the last video that I couldn't live with, a new video will come out in a week inshallah.

    • @maesizmayonnaise2745
      @maesizmayonnaise2745 9 дней назад +2

      ​@@SaadtheMuzlim Ameen! Ya raba al alamin! Some ideas sfor your videos(take your time):
      -Video Games
      -Friends(ones for are dirty minded and one who are good and what to do with them)
      --repentance

  • @mdakibraja8731
    @mdakibraja8731 5 дней назад

    Plzz make a video on keeping the beard and if can't then....

  • @neohybridkai
    @neohybridkai 7 дней назад

    Very good channel for the new generation of muslim, you did a good job watching all those video and summarizing them
    Let me share my opinion from the perspective of millennial. Regarding fiction, drawing and music, if you are still young and likes those as hobby, rest assured because when you are adult and have jobs and other priorities, your time for hobby will be diminished significantly. The problem is when you aim for those to be your job, so my advice is if you still have time to change course please consider to switch to any other field of expertise. I was an avid anime, manga, game fan back in my youth but nowadays I only have 1 or 2 hour for my hobby, the rest are for works and family. My interest also no longer as high as used to be, most fiction are starting to feel repetitive and no longer relatable. And depend on your circumstance you might no longer have interest on entertainment industry, especially when your life start to get more and more difficult. Of course we pray to Allah not to have difficult life but when you're adult many things can happen beyond your control. You know the ayyah about the world is just a play and amusement? During my teens I just think that as Quran wisdom to remind us to pray and ibadah more but its when I experienced a really tough time and injustice beyond my control and capability I could feel how powerful the ayyah means and now I realize that nothing give you the same reassurance and comfort than getting closer to Allah.
    As for my interest in fiction, I realize that what I love is the story and character behind it and then I came to realization what's more beneficial than the story of our prophet Rasulullah SAW? and this is why I'm now learning about sirah nabawiyah rather than watching anime or read manga. I also gain new interest on ancient civilizations and islamic histories in various regions. I thank Allah for this shifting of interest.

    • @SaadtheMuzlim
      @SaadtheMuzlim  6 дней назад

      That was really beautiful! Jazakallah for sharing

  • @zackzoom8779
    @zackzoom8779 6 дней назад +4

    All of these hardships will end when we are in jannah, we don't have to worry about not being able to share the feeling of discussing stories because we'll have like... forever😤

  • @shihanafridhi9517
    @shihanafridhi9517 23 часа назад +1

    Would love to make a video on if cartoons like Tiny Toons, Animaniacs, Tom and Jerry, Looney Tunes, Woody Woodpecker and Ren and Stimpy are haram?

  • @Vanyl_de_Cecilia
    @Vanyl_de_Cecilia 9 часов назад +1

    Then what about writing it?

  • @Bumblebee77
    @Bumblebee77 6 дней назад +2

    Amazing video, Akhi! May Allah reward you, This was an interesting topic.

  • @sadiyamohammed8484
    @sadiyamohammed8484 5 дней назад +1

    This help me so much. Definitely a thumbs up for me!

  • @sammoh6746
    @sammoh6746 7 дней назад +2

    Brother ❤, i love your content I'm the writer as i had commented before. I have a suggestion for a video, seeing upon which topics you discuss about i believe it'll be a really good topic if you mske a video talking about the idea of simulation, and ai. It wasn't art directly that prophet Muhammad didn't liked, it was in the sense that the common people were imitating God, and since ever art couldn't be more that just 2D lifeless paintings. but with technology, and ai we have reached a time were this debate gets more heated. Like the idea of Games, and npcs, Ai being able to think and respond. It's a very crucial age. I'd love to see you making a video about it ✨

    • @SaadtheMuzlim
      @SaadtheMuzlim  6 дней назад +1

      Aoa! I'm working on a video on games rn, Ai is a really good suggestion although I think that topic is yet to become super prevalent in society.
      I really appreciate the suggestions!

  • @sync8780
    @sync8780 18 часов назад

    would like to see a video similar to this regarding fiction in games with magic,mythology,etc.

  • @TheLordMeniquiin
    @TheLordMeniquiin 4 дня назад

    i've questioned this before and realized this was one of the dumbest question i've ever asked about islam. This is literally a 5th grader's question. It is CALLED FICTION

  • @TheNeorch
    @TheNeorch 7 дней назад +1

    Assalamualaikum Saad,i'm just asking about how do you solve the debate of Muhammad pbuh marrying Ayesha at 9 y/o.

    • @SaadtheMuzlim
      @SaadtheMuzlim  6 дней назад +1

      Aoa! It stopped bothering me when I understood that my morality is heavily influenced by the west, and that the marriage only seems weird to us because we were born in the 21st century.

    • @TheNeorch
      @TheNeorch 6 дней назад +1

      @@SaadtheMuzlim you shall probably make a good video on that Saad,it would be good.

  • @vanadiumzed4627
    @vanadiumzed4627 9 часов назад

    Is spy x family haram?

  • @sikandargill-qz3vt
    @sikandargill-qz3vt 9 дней назад +1

    Assalamualaikuj

  • @Hyusa22
    @Hyusa22 6 дней назад

    What if a game called Genshin Impact there's have archons which is called 'Gods' and I played that game. Is it Haram for me to play? And is it shrik?

    • @Bumblebee77
      @Bumblebee77 6 дней назад +1

      That really depends, If you're wise enough to realize that those characters in the game are just fictional, Then probably no. However, Doesn't Genshin Impact have female characters with too revealing clothes? Moreover, In order to unlock a character (Or, At least I think that's how you get one) You have to open some stuff (Wish system or whatever it's called), And if you're lucky enough, You might just get one. However, They're merely randomized. It's somewhat similar to gambling, But not exactly the same. So, I'm not sure about that part.
      I'd say that the game is most likely haram.

    • @hirzihilman6928
      @hirzihilman6928 6 дней назад +1

      ​@@Bumblebee77I not a smart people but I think not using any real money is ok? Or maybe using the in game money that you get for free but requiring spend some time to get it so using real time and real energy to get free in game money just to use for the gacha is not ok? Idk, so what is your opinion?

    • @Bumblebee77
      @Bumblebee77 5 дней назад

      @hirzihilman6928 Perhaps yeah, I suppose that makes enough sense. It depends whether you use real money or not. I'm not completely sure, But things that are based off luck are haram. I do remember a hadith talking about a man who told someone else to choose one out of three arrows that were sticked into the ground, Each of them would give him a different reward. But, I couldn't find it. So, I won't confirm it is haram until I do.

  • @sikandargill-qz3vt
    @sikandargill-qz3vt 9 дней назад +2

    Can you include a classical tafseer rather tan maariful quran

    • @SaadtheMuzlim
      @SaadtheMuzlim  9 дней назад +1

      Aoa! Isn't maariful Quran pretty reliable?

  • @maesizmayonnaise2745
    @maesizmayonnaise2745 6 дней назад +1

    Keep clicking 1:07 😂😂😂😂