Then one need to ask why Wakeone need to put Yujin at the back or at the side most of the time on the dance formation on the original ot9 choreography especially for a b-side upbeat song like this?
this is where i realize the ray of sunshine that yeseo was to the group and the joy she added to performances. gosh that smile, i'll definitely miss her in kep1er
Never understood why Yujin had so little lines this song. Don't understand why she still does in the redistribution! Yeseo's chorus could have been given to her
@@selenophile_- Bro Mashiro and yesseo leaving shouldn't be something exciting so ur favs can get more lines. They redistributed so that it wouldn't affect the choreography as much.
“they can’t give the parts to somebody who’s on the edge” but somehow so many of yujin’s lines in other songs are when she’s on the edge so why is it different now? stop making excuses
Exactly. I keep seeing comments about how they don't want to redo the choreo but it's not necessary. Just have her step forward from the edge position and have the camera focus on her. That is the silliest excuse especially considering how Yujin's voice is similar to Yeseo's
@@Teeeeooo do you understand what you are saying? They are trying to minimize the choreo changes as much as they can they can not change all of it just to give those who have less lines. It is not a ballad song where they can do what ever they want to the lines.
I wish they gave Yujin more lines. It’s great seeing them give Bahiyyih more, but Yujin should get more too. Does anyone know where we can watch the OT7 performance of this song?
It'a veey beautiful to see the girls covering their teammates parts now that they left. But also really sad to see Kep1er perform as 7, i'm so sad to see this side by side, beautiful and sad at the same time T_____T
I hope some of you realize that they don't sing while standing so they can't give yeshiro lines to just the people who have less lines. They will think about the choreo while giving the lines. It is not easy to redistribute the lines because of this.
that would be a good point if the choreography was extremely structured, but it's not: they've literally changed places in choreography for a part on 1:43 so that Hikaru would sing this part and will be in the center, when both Xiaoting and Yujin were already pretty much in the middle in original choreo (Hikaru were only slightly further, just on the left of Yujin though) on 0:53 they could have given Yeseo's part to Yujin and change few steps so she'd had a longer line, same on 2:39 (she's already in the spotlight, and they are just jumping around) my point is, it's really not that hard to change choreography, lots of kpop groups do that when members are absent and lines redistributed (look at EXO for example), many parts won't even be changed at all
@@partiya_vaginodictatury_Aliyi i think you should check a comparison before acting like it is an aesy thing to do. They try to minimize the changes to fit all the parts of the songs they have to think where is the person before and after yeshiro should stand and how if this person took it will effect the rest of song.and dance . Go watch the fancams and compare. There are changes at the end the lost 2 members but they tried to minimize it so the girls won't have to learn a whole new choreo.
@@partiya_vaginodictatury_Aliyi also giving your *examples* go look at the ot9 choreo, for example During chae pre chorus part hikaru was closer to the center ( she even mirrror shiro's position ) so they just give shiro's line to her since she was close to the center. You don't look just for the choreo of this part you look for the choreo before and after.😊
@@baeun142 I'm a bit confused with your answers, I did looked at the original choreography and wrote examples when they changed it are you talking about 1:40, when Mashiro's chorus starts? Yujin and Xiaoting are closer to the center in original, Hikaru steps further but in new version she doesn't I guess you mean that because Yujin already has a part "let's go back into the city" they couldn't give her a chorus before that part? or give Xiaoting both parts in chorus? that's a fair point although they could definitely give Ting both parts, W1 does it sometimes in songs regardless, my point is, they could work around it better, they already changed choreography, and I think it's not about choreography (or original lines) and it is not that hard to change choreography like this one, that's not structured in a complicated way when everyone needs to be in a specific place I see your points better now, I think, still, can't agree
@@partiya_vaginodictatury_Aliyi yes i was talking about shiro chorus and what i meant by my point don't just look at the shiro's part. Go look at chaehyun's before it you will see hikaru's position is mirroring shiro's so it was easier to just give it to her. Do not look just at the part go look at the positions in the parts before and after it to see why they give the part to hikaru. Hikaru was closer and had the same position as shiro in chae part before shiro's
the emotions i got watching this… oh yeshiro how kep1ian will forever love you. i miss my ot9 so so much. it’s been hard, very hard. kep1er you are doing so amazing my loves 💜💜
Just like what i thought.. the next mistreatment member will be Yujin😢 like cmon she should've that Yeseo chorus part, dgmw i love Youngeun being first but Yujin need more ㅠㅠ
Next mistreatment member? Since Kep1er debut, Yujin are mostly given the least impactful part of the song to perform on Kep1er title tracks. She mostly dance on the back or at the side of the dance formation on stage for most of Kep1er title tracks. Yujin almost never dance on the dance break on Kep1er title tracks. Wakeone Entertainment simply do not wish to give the spotlight to Yujin as Kep1er member.
Yall need to understand that the distribution is not gonna be like who has the least lines but the dancing too. They can't just give the lines to someone who is in the edge while YeShiro are in the center. Someone near them is gonna sing the line so they can be center
yujin and xiaoting deserved more lines 😿😿😿😿😿 mashiro’s line in the last chorus shoulda been given to xiaoting and yeseo’s to yujin wakeone flop company and this song feels so empty w/o mashiro bcuz she shined in back to the city the most along w/ bahiyyih others shined as well it wouldn’t have felt empty if mashiro’s line in the last chorus was given to xiaoting and yeseo’s to yujin
the “ah come on” is hikaru not dayeon and 3:16 is youngeun not dayeon youngeun and dayeon have a similar voice but it’s youngeun bcuz dayeon lip syncs it lip syncing ≠ it’s your line and it seems more like youngeun so it’s youngeun it’s like in twice where dahyun lip syncs one of chaeyoung and momo’s lines in the live performance but not her actual line
@Kep1er_OT8 having the most lines doesn't determine position... She's given more difficult lines to sing based on her skill, whther she sings the most or not.
@@no4528 we already kinda have an OT8 performance for Galileo so I'm pretty sure she gets yeseo lines but xiaoting is probably 1st since she'll most likely get mashiro's post chorus
@@ifu138 she's not on the same level, she's an E+ vocalist and is the only member other than chaehyun who can support, she was also main vocal in most missions of gp999 and never voice cracked like chaehyun so it would be weird for her not to be
@@ifu138 Youngeun, although with quite shallow support (actually surpassing Bahiyyih, Xiaoting and Dayeon who have both shown support, I'd say they're E-) is a E+ tier vocalist. Plus, her range is large, fitting many high and low notes. She's also quite technically skilled with her runs, switching in and out of head and chest voice, as well as mixing. Thus, she's a main vocalist with Chaehyun.
![[SUB] STAYC's Secret? TWICE JEONGYEON Digs It All (+First Reveal of Their Dorm!!!) EP.14 STAYC](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/uFPx5f0eQOs/mqdefault.jpg)
Im so happy for Youngeun but Yeseo's last chorus should've gone to Yujin, she fits Yeseo's voice so much 😭
for me they're pushing Youngeun sm now, for me her voice dont fit majory lines of yeshiro that gave for her
she was around the corners during that part and thats why she didnt get it ig because they have distribute the parts without the choreo looking messy
Then one need to ask why Wakeone need to put Yujin at the back or at the side most of the time on the dance formation on the original ot9 choreography especially for a b-side upbeat song like this?
There are ways to do it. They could have done it if they wanted to
Youngeun is main vocal, she deserved
this is where i realize the ray of sunshine that yeseo was to the group and the joy she added to performances. gosh that smile, i'll definitely miss her in kep1er
It doesn’t feel the same without mashiro, her parts in the song were my absolute favorites. They still did a good job though
This song feels so empty without Yeseo & Mashiro coz they were the one who shined the most in this song
Never understood why Yujin had so little lines this song. Don't understand why she still does in the redistribution! Yeseo's chorus could have been given to her
Yujin deserves way more
people said when mashiro n yeeseo left, she might cover either one of them part. now here we go again 😕
@@selenophile_- Bro Mashiro and yesseo leaving shouldn't be something exciting so ur favs can get more lines. They redistributed so that it wouldn't affect the choreography as much.
ikr😿😿😿 wakeone is doing her so dirty
hiyyih❤❤❤
Yujin should have got way more 😭
Idk why they gave her just one extra part she shoulda got one more
kinda unrelated but ot7 version sounds sadder/softer than the ot9 version :(
because Youngeun voice is more mature and dont fit this song, and most of yeshiro lines are given to her
For the first time I think hiyyih got this many lines and ranking
she got many lines in other songs
@@IvyTheAmazingSerene nah back to the city is always the song she got the most lines specially talking about korean songs. OP is saying exactly that
@@isisribeiroaesthetics3667 daisy too
I'm so happy, my bias is Youngeun and my wrecker is Bahiyyih, they are top 1 and 3 of lines in this song
“they can’t give the parts to somebody who’s on the edge” but somehow so many of yujin’s lines in other songs are when she’s on the edge so why is it different now? stop making excuses
Exactly. I keep seeing comments about how they don't want to redo the choreo but it's not necessary. Just have her step forward from the edge position and have the camera focus on her. That is the silliest excuse especially considering how Yujin's voice is similar to Yeseo's
Instead of giving almost everything to Youngeun they could’ve given the lines to Xiaoting and Yujin who barely had any lines in the oficial song 💀
@@АйкоркемКуанышева-п8л u obvi do not know Xiaoting and Yujin
They had to adjust the dance not just the lines. They can't give yeshiro parts to anyone.
@@baeun142 They could've easily gave the lines to those who had less
@@Teeeeooo do you understand what you are saying? They are trying to minimize the choreo changes as much as they can they can not change all of it just to give those who have less lines. It is not a ballad song where they can do what ever they want to the lines.
@@АйкоркемКуанышева-п8л Chaehyun main vocal* +Xiaoting and Yujin can sing👍
Last chorus of Mashiro and Yeseo should be given to Xiaoting and Yujin:(
I wish they gave Yujin more lines. It’s great seeing them give Bahiyyih more, but Yujin should get more too. Does anyone know where we can watch the OT7 performance of this song?
solo busca "kcon LA 2024 kep1er"
It'a veey beautiful to see the girls covering their teammates parts now that they left. But also really sad to see Kep1er perform as 7, i'm so sad to see this side by side, beautiful and sad at the same time T_____T
YOUNGEUN DESERVING ❤❤❤
You'll think they'll make line distribution better if 2 members left but it ended being worst lol
Keplian stop this
When Kep1er lets love and and be happy with our members without fight please 🥺💟
I hope some of you realize that they don't sing while standing so they can't give yeshiro lines to just the people who have less lines. They will think about the choreo while giving the lines. It is not easy to redistribute the lines because of this.
that would be a good point if the choreography was extremely structured, but it's not: they've literally changed places in choreography for a part on 1:43 so that Hikaru would sing this part and will be in the center, when both Xiaoting and Yujin were already pretty much in the middle in original choreo (Hikaru were only slightly further, just on the left of Yujin though)
on 0:53 they could have given Yeseo's part to Yujin and change few steps so she'd had a longer line, same on 2:39 (she's already in the spotlight, and they are just jumping around)
my point is, it's really not that hard to change choreography, lots of kpop groups do that when members are absent and lines redistributed (look at EXO for example), many parts won't even be changed at all
@@partiya_vaginodictatury_Aliyi i think you should check a comparison before acting like it is an aesy thing to do. They try to minimize the changes to fit all the parts of the songs they have to think where is the person before and after yeshiro should stand and how if this person took it will effect the rest of song.and dance . Go watch the fancams and compare. There are changes at the end the lost 2 members but they tried to minimize it so the girls won't have to learn a whole new choreo.
@@partiya_vaginodictatury_Aliyi also giving your *examples* go look at the ot9 choreo, for example During chae pre chorus part hikaru was closer to the center ( she even mirrror shiro's position ) so they just give shiro's line to her since she was close to the center. You don't look just for the choreo of this part you look for the choreo before and after.😊
@@baeun142 I'm a bit confused with your answers, I did looked at the original choreography and wrote examples when they changed it
are you talking about 1:40, when Mashiro's chorus starts? Yujin and Xiaoting are closer to the center in original, Hikaru steps further but in new version she doesn't
I guess you mean that because Yujin already has a part "let's go back into the city" they couldn't give her a chorus before that part? or give Xiaoting both parts in chorus? that's a fair point although they could definitely give Ting both parts, W1 does it sometimes in songs
regardless, my point is, they could work around it better, they already changed choreography, and I think it's not about choreography (or original lines)
and it is not that hard to change choreography like this one, that's not structured in a complicated way when everyone needs to be in a specific place
I see your points better now, I think, still, can't agree
@@partiya_vaginodictatury_Aliyi yes i was talking about shiro chorus and what i meant by my point don't just look at the shiro's part. Go look at chaehyun's before it you will see hikaru's position is mirroring shiro's so it was easier to just give it to her. Do not look just at the part go look at the positions in the parts before and after it to see why they give the part to hikaru. Hikaru was closer and had the same position as shiro in chae part before shiro's
the emotions i got watching this… oh yeshiro how kep1ian will forever love you. i miss my ot9 so so much. it’s been hard, very hard. kep1er you are doing so amazing my loves 💜💜
I love how they gave hiyyih and youngeun majority of yeseo and mashiro parts
mashiro and yeseo is so thankful to youngeun doing their part ❤
ugh they couldn’t give yujin one chorus line
It's practically a sin not to give Yujin even a chorus
Some parts can give to yujin
Just like what i thought.. the next mistreatment member will be Yujin😢 like cmon she should've that Yeseo chorus part, dgmw i love Youngeun being first but Yujin need more ㅠㅠ
Next mistreatment member? Since Kep1er debut, Yujin are mostly given the least impactful part of the song to perform on Kep1er title tracks. She mostly dance on the back or at the side of the dance formation on stage for most of Kep1er title tracks. Yujin almost never dance on the dance break on Kep1er title tracks. Wakeone Entertainment simply do not wish to give the spotlight to Yujin as Kep1er member.
she's been treated unfairly since his debut
@@ringgamlndrinot since debut but since UP
Yall need to understand that the distribution is not gonna be like who has the least lines but the dancing too. They can't just give the lines to someone who is in the edge while YeShiro are in the center. Someone near them is gonna sing the line so they can be center
If we exclude ad-libs part, Bahiyyih actually have the most lines by word.
ヨンウンのセリフの多さに
他のを含めて😢
動線の問題もあるんだけど。
yujin and xiaoting deserved more lines 😿😿😿😿😿 mashiro’s line in the last chorus shoulda been given to xiaoting and yeseo’s to yujin wakeone flop company and this song feels so empty w/o mashiro bcuz she shined in back to the city the most along w/ bahiyyih others shined as well it wouldn’t have felt empty if mashiro’s line in the last chorus was given to xiaoting and yeseo’s to yujin
first non swear comment
the “ah come on” is hikaru not dayeon and 3:16 is youngeun not dayeon youngeun and dayeon have a similar voice but it’s youngeun bcuz dayeon lip syncs it lip syncing ≠ it’s your line and it seems more like youngeun so it’s youngeun it’s like in twice where dahyun lip syncs one of chaeyoung and momo’s lines in the live performance but not her actual line
Now why would you do that 😢
F**k w1
yeshiro...
They’re finally treating Youngeun as main vocal/lead vocal
She is always treated like that lmao
@@Lucas-jw4fyno she wasn't before their latest album
@@Kep1er_OT8nop, she is was treated like that in every album lmao
@@Lucas-jw4fy not in Galileo album though, the only redeeming part of the album for her was the love on lock highnote
@Kep1er_OT8 having the most lines doesn't determine position... She's given more difficult lines to sing based on her skill, whther she sings the most or not.
They couldve given xiaoting a part..
In LVLY and WADADA they give yeshiro parts to Xiaoting
Youngeun deserves, she's a main vocalist yet has never been treated like one until the latest album
I hope she gets more line in Galileo when she had barely any lines 💀
@@no4528 we already kinda have an OT8 performance for Galileo so I'm pretty sure she gets yeseo lines but xiaoting is probably 1st since she'll most likely get mashiro's post chorus
I don't get why Youngeun is supposed to be a main vocal when she's on the same level as all the non-Chaehyun members
@@ifu138 she's not on the same level, she's an E+ vocalist and is the only member other than chaehyun who can support, she was also main vocal in most missions of gp999 and never voice cracked like chaehyun so it would be weird for her not to be
@@ifu138 Youngeun, although with quite shallow support (actually surpassing Bahiyyih, Xiaoting and Dayeon who have both shown support, I'd say they're E-) is a E+ tier vocalist. Plus, her range is large, fitting many high and low notes. She's also quite technically skilled with her runs, switching in and out of head and chest voice, as well as mixing. Thus, she's a main vocalist with Chaehyun.
So sad :(( It was Mashiro's song
That was Shiro song ☹️
ikr😢😢😢 it was her’s and bahiyyih’s song imo
Youngeun has too much lines
Why is there no dayeon?