@@wesandsteph6460 something unrelated a spectrogram is a software that turns audio into an image which can hide secrets in audio with out giving a dead giveaway that there is a secret message
wilbur hinted very heavily on stream when he reacted to this that he is doing another ARG around halloween or early November, so Steph's detective hat will return once more
16:24 "...ah, fake ears-" Wes and Steph, simultaneously and immediately: FAKE EARS! FAKIERS! My jaw: *no longer in sight from how I've never caught that* Tbf though, I haven't heard it pronounced that way either, the Red Herring video where it is pronounced like "fake-iers" doesn't bring this clue up. Still, I am in awe.
Note for Steph: You can play a song on two strings if you are playing the notes, not the chords. For example, the Song "Tonight Tonight" can be played solely on the A and E string if you are playing the notes
The og people that tried to figure this out (Jack's fanbase from that time) was primarily teenage guys. Most of that Google doc was stuff discovered by teenagers. We were a pretty intelligent group. I was there when it started. But I didn't help figure stuff out because I was more focused on watching his Minecraft videos lol
wilbur has said that the DID theory is wrong, and even in a stream after the ARG ended someone donated to him talking about their ‘system’ and ‘alters’ (components of DID) and he clearly said that he didn’t know what the words meant. (I don’t think he’s the type to not do a lot of research into something about mental health that he was broadcasting to a wide audience, especially without having it himself)
yeah, i don't think he's the type to do that either. if he ever did represent a disorder he didn't have he'd put in a lot more research, considering basic info like DID forming during childhood wasn't taken into account in these theories.
okay, i'm going to ask here... is having an Alter Ego and DID the same thing? maybe the Fakiers are just an alter ego you know, just playing two different characters like DSMP's Ghostbur and Alivebur?
@@RyanXander06 im not sure what an alter ego actually is, now that i think about it, but i know it isn't related to a medical condition, so they must be different.
Just as a thought experiment, what if the girl was not the one who died. True she is gone from his life, but what if Wilbur was the one who fell into the river, possibly after they broke up. 1) Wilbur is cold. Kai was cold after being in the river for 2 days. 2) Wilbur says at the end that this version of him will be dead and then literally disappears. He emphasizes that this version is dead. Not gone, but dead. Just a thought worth poking at I guess.
It’s amazing how two different people, can come to such a similar conclusion. Getting to that conclusion in different ways, but reaching it nonetheless. I really thought that this video was such a golden egg, in the many of your fun reactions. I enjoyed it.
The prank date thing was huge in my grade from middle school until our junior year. There were a ton of girls that got pranked and were pissed at them. It even got to the point that nobody believes them if they actually want to go on a date with someone. There’s a few people that still do it.
My theory: 1. Wilbur, consumed by his embarrassing secret, became a psychopath of sorts and tried to kill Kai by drowning him, but Kai could swim and he pulled Wilbur in and they had this massive fight which gave him PTSD, hence the 'I'm so cold'. What he doesn't know is that Kai is a psychopath too. And the girl... El? L? She was closely related to Kai in some way, so that's why he's so hell-bent on ruining Wilbur because he did something to her and got 90% caught by Kai, so that kind of explains the Kai situation. The Fakiers? Maybe R. Fakier and I. Fakier are the same person! Maybe by 'son' it's not meant as biological son, it's meant as like a new personality emerging from an old one. So basically, Wilbur accidentally did something to 'L', giving him trauma, Kai is related to L and is now pursuing Wilbur and I. Fakier got a glow-up to become R.Fakier. I'm still deep in thought about the phrase 'Bow on top'. I also have a feeling that water is even more heavily involved than it already is. If you have some clues or ideas, please reply and maybe we can solve this.
btw, I think the fact that the girl didn't love him was true because if you look back to the red herring video, they noticed that a part of spiral galaxy's lyrics was cut down to "my lovers were a lie" or something along those lines.
So I searched and is illegal to swim on the Thames "A new by-law has banned people from swimming in the River Thames without prior permission from the Port of London Authority (PLA)." which could explain why Wilbur is running from the police (if he wasn't the one who killed the girl). My theory is that Wilbur and the Girl had a date, then Wilbur decided (maybe under the influence of Alcohol) to take a swim and invited the girl, after swimming a little and seeing that the water is too cold Wilbur gets out of the water but the girl doesn't, he jumps again trying to find her but she never appear, he panics and doesn't know what to do, he either calls Kai because he saw him recently or because Kai knew the girl, Kai gets mad at Wilbur and calls the police, Wilbur gets scared and runs, the police go after Wilbur to interrogate him but because of him doing something illegal and the girl disappearing he thinks the police wants to send him to jail so he escapes. Days (or weeks) later the girl is found dead and that's the point of breaking and were I. Fakier and R. Fakier are born.
What I haven't seen talked about ANYWHERE is that in the red herring video they talk about voicemails that his "concerned friends" leave him. In the voicemails there is clearly a girl's voice talking about "what happened at the o2 arena". That means there are either 2 girls, or the one he went on a date with did not die at all.
Jack made a video on it, he didnt know wilbur before the initial e-mail, he was also in the dark however he did help but filming random stuff to help give wilbur opertunitys to sync and stuff with jack
I think the reason Matpat thought the girl was pranking Wilbur was from the reoccurring theme that the event was labeled “embarrassing.” But yeah still feels like we are missing something.
You guys should REALLY do a gameplay video on minecraft with you both trying to play minecraft as one player or two players whichever you guys can do, we might even get parts to to gameplay and turn it into a series where you two finally learn to play minecraft lol, it would a be GREAT to watch
Wes and Steph I MISS you guy's run BTS I really wanna see you guys react to any run BTS Maybe episode 122 and 123 part 2 to the cooking one you did So basically the younger member's guiding Jin and suga I don't wanna spoil but run BTS went on break after 155 episodes recently so basically they put a pause on the series that BTS has been doing for 6-7 years now Probably means no run BTS for at least 6 months So while that's it I really wanna see you guys catch up with the episodes
Wes said on stream that they were planning to do a bts reaction soon, I think they've been having a harder time scheduling videos together & so far for bts run they've done together which is prob why it's taken a while (wes reacts alone in a separate channel)
So, i don't think the girl that left him that message is dead because in the last video he did one of the friends that called him(and the only girl who did actually) told him "not to worry about what happened and the o2 arena".
I agree that the voicemail from the girl sounded more like she just wanted to see him. Like how he also received voicemails from friends saying he had been acting weird, she was acting nervous because she can tell there's something going on with him. I think you guys could be right. Maybe the girl didn't reject him and after grabbing a burger they went on a boat and Wilbur caused some kind of embarrassing accident that caused the girl to drown. Wilbur dived into the cold water to save her but he couldn't and she died. Kai must have seen it all or Wilbur told him or something but Wilbur doesn't want people to know that he caused the accident somehow.
Here I feel like I am grading something as a teacher but anyways let's begin. So basically Kai's relation ship with Wilbur would only make sense as to why he wants the editor position over Kai, The girl is a big part but there is one thing I'd like to say the mystery girl said "We haven't been on 'a' date in forever" meaning they probably only went one date which the girl probably classified when they first met as that date and it was most likely a few months before December, if Kai didn't know about what Wilbur did, why would Wilbur go and try to get the editor position unless Kai knew what he did.
Wilbur reacted to the game theory video and in the end where he talks about his thoughts on it he basically 100% confirms that DID was a part of it, I don't know where people have gotten it from that he once said that that part isn't true but yeah, he basically confirmed DID being apart of the mystery
i don’t think he did do that???? he said the part about “that part of you disappearing when you accept something you did” (paraphrased) was pretty right, but he didn’t confirm or deny anything, and i’m pretty sure like a while ago he de-confirmed the DID theory
@@samg5601 Nope listen to it again then, he has not said anything about the DID theory being wrong in any video but in the context of Matt talking about the DID theory he said that Matt was “Pretty damn correct, you could almost say that that’s confirmed” straight from Wilburs own mouth
@@cyberrainofficial no he already said that the DID theory wasnt right. if you actually listened what he confirmed is actually the “this part of wilbur disappearing is signifying he’s moved on” part of the video. wilbur has said he didn’t know what DID was when it was initially brought up to him. and to implement DID in this esp with this theory in particular is toeing very heavily on the ableist stereotype of ppl having multiple personalities means they’re murderers/bad/psychopaths.
I know i’m just really late but: The painting of the wave is just a painting! The painting is called believe it or not: ‘The Wave’ by a japanese artist named Hokusai ( i think that’s how its spelt) and don’t think it has anything to do with the arg.
Wilbur can choose what setting he is in during the ARG, and the environment has been relevant before, so the painting very well could have some meaning/symbolism
Ok my alteration of the theory, get popcorn and a drink this is gonna be a long one. I think Wilbur and this girl were in a past relationship but she cheated on Wilbur with Kai and at some point she broke up with Wilbur to go with Kai because she liked him more, leaving Wilbur heart broken and unable to love again. Years later Kai and this girl decide to pull a prank on Wilbur thinking it would be funny to make him think that this girl still has feelings for her and the worst outcome is that Wilbur gets angry at them. When Wilbur finds out that it’s all a prank he gets angry and pushes her off into the water, gets scared, tries to save her and manages to get her back on land in time for her to say her last words “I’m so cold” and then dies. Wilbur is on the run paranoid of even the smallest things and Kai figures out that something is wrong when the girl seems to be gone and Wilbur is acting weird so he confronts him and gets enough information to know that she died in the water so he goes for a swim trying to find her body, rather he does or not who knows, but doesn’t go to the police because if this gets taken to court then everyone will know about the horrible prank that Kai and the girl tried to pull and no one would be sympathetic for him or believe what he said. Wilbur gets scared and knows that the internet is a place where anyone will believe anything and Kai could easily tell people and get them on his side and that’s how Wilbur decides to make sure that Kai no longer has a editing job. It has most of the components from Mat Pat, and solves the problem of how all three know each other. BOOM I just solved the ARG, thank you for listening to my Ted talk, and you’re welcome, I’ll be here all week.
so, i'm not sure if this is correct however i feel like it would make sense. jack wasnt in on the ARG however kai was. wilbur could have chosen many content creators, however he chose jack. i feel like this is because will knew kai before and told him about the idea (NOT the plot). after kai found out about the idea from wilbur he could have encouraged him to do it through jack. i also think that kai told jack previous to wilbur sending an email, "hey jack, someone i know reached out to me with a great idea, someone named wilbur soot will send you an email, just go along with it." which would then also explain why jack replied to a random email AND why he wasnt too scared or concerned throughout the ARG.
I looked way to much into the meme at the end ngl Also I feel like Wilbur met Kie while on a date with the girl which is why he was awkward Wilbur then tells Kie before he goes on the next date but never sees the girl come back and he suspects Wilbur so Wilbur needs him silenced
You should watch Anthony Padilla's video 'I speak to people with Tourette's. It has a youtuber, called Sweet Anita, who was in one of the sidemens videos.
Please react to Run BTS Episodes 126-127. It’s like a relay race where the members have to complete a bunch of activities or they can’t go home. These episodes are hilarious and I think you guys would really enjoy them. These episodes also show how competitive some of the members are.
Maybe Kai and the girlfriend were having an afair, Wilbur discovers it and in a rage throws the girl, and then all the other things happen.That may also explain why he is like "hating Kai" I actually don't have any idea about this ARG, I have only watch this and Red Hering videos and I'm not even a native english speaker, but I thought that was a cool idea xd
For some reason I get the feeling the e-girl he's obsessing over in his songs has something to do with "Elle's lovely three" but at the same time I doubt it has anything to do with his songs.
@@Velocitist The "I'll Find other people to talk with 'Cause you like me And I think you're a maniac" part is really similar to the theory Wilbur's lover potentially cheated on him, idk I might be wrong but its awfully too connected
I think you should react to more game theory. They have amazing stuff like fnaf, petscop, hiimmarymary and soooooo on. It would be amazing if you checked them out.
Just clicked the notification so haven’t watched anything, just in case this isn’t mentioned, I believe that the multiple personalities has been disproved by Wilbur himself! (I also have no idea if that theory is mentioned)
I HAVE AN IDEA THAT MIGHT FIT UR IDEA BETTER: ok so what if they were going on a date and she told wilbur that she was cheating on him with kai, wilbur in a moment of rage pushes her in, but he thinks he overreacted considering the event he did to be embarrasing. blah blah blah, trauma, DID, etc. Kai knows about this simply by patching it to together that he never talked to the girl again. blah blah blah he tries to kill kai. I think he actually did try to kill Kai because if you remember Kai made a post saying "What a lovely swim that was!", obviously not something you would post after almost getting murdered but Im pretty sure its just supposed to serve as a clue.
wilbur also reacted to it and he didnt give much away and also didnt confirm that is true however said that the part about him dissappearing is about accepting and forgiving himself is correct
The DID has been disproven. Wilbue also confirmed this when he reacted on stream. However the discord have another theory that I'm pretty sure we are correct on. Anyways I'm in the discord and we think we're super close to the truth, we've just got a few more things to figure out.
I think Kai saw this girl with Wilbur, Wilbur saw Kai and when Kai heard she had drowned he puzzled it together. So he tweeted like just had a swim or something to trigger Wilbur, Wilbur get that Kai might know, so Wilbur try to meet Kai and do the same, but Kai was prepared this MIGHT happen. or something that way What do you think Steph:P would love a reply :)
Um Willbur never gave the solution to this ARG, even if he "eliminated" some wrong theory. I don't think the secret will ever really be revealed if Willbur doesn't say it himself, and I think he's having too much fun for now with the theories that still come out about his ARG. The girl theory may be a valid theory ... but it doesn't necessarily have to be a girl he knew in person ... I mean, the girl in the message can be something entirely separate. But a girl may very well have fallen into the river, Will and Kai were there when it happened and tried to save her, failing ...
He did actively discourage Matpat from trying to solve it at all, and he said he messed up when creating this ARG and made it too difficult by accident.
Alright now ima write down my theory So I think the phone call from the girl wasn't for Wilbur I think it's for kai sense from what I've seen it looks like kai knows her and I think Wilbur had a crush on kai's girlfriend so when kai and the girl when on a date to the 02 arena Wilbur must've confronted em and told her he liked her but then I think they must've laughed about Wilbur liking her making it embarrassing so in a fit of rage Wilbur ended up pushing her into the water and I don't think she or kai knew how to swim so Wilbur when to save her but ended up failing and after that I think kai quickly learned how to swim fear that Wilbur might do that same to him which he did but sense kai learned how to swim he survived
honestly if the DID theory is correct after everything... ill be a bit disappointed on wilbur. he's seems way too mental health aware to create yet another murderer character with DID, when systems already suffers so much from these repetitive and harmful depictions. he doesn't seem like the type of person to represent such a stigmatized disorder without making all the research possible to make it accurate, it's wilbur we're talking about here. besides it's just such a boring and cliched explanation. i love game theory's and red herring's videos, seen them so many time, but i simply can't get behind this theory. also some people have been saying wilbur confirmed matpat's theory for some reason. he didn't. even if matpat was 100% right, wilbur wouldn't say anything. all he said was that he liked the idea of moving on and accepting something bad you did. HE DIDN'T EVEN SAY THAT WAS PART OF THE ARG, though we can understand that's probably what he meant. but he made no comment on the rest of the theory, and his face was very blank the entire stream. it's fine if people like the DID theory, but don't go around saying it's anything but a theory, okay? matpat said it himself. in the end of the day, it's just a theory, and always will be, because wilbur will never reveal the story. also matpat's theory about the embarrassing incident is a bit... idk sounds like a stretch to me. like, it could be right, but it has no actual proof so if it's right itd be kinda throwing something on a wall and hoping it sticks
that random girl asking for a date, could have been cold and wilbur gave her his jacket, which she not returned and theres emberassing Notes or USB sticks in there. Maybe even Kai the editor got to greeenwhich? because the girl contacted him, maybe the notes/USBs even were about Kai?... I don't think the emberassing thing ends in murder its more an awkward probably sexual encounter maybe even drunk of either Wilbur and Kai or the girl and wilbur or kai maybe even both! Or some stolen/accidentally taken notes/USB about anything. But i could be totally wrong Also on a sitenote, wilbur was very much only going the same ways at the end of 2018 so meeting w/ someone and meeting a girl and she calling because she did not see him going somewhere again, maybe it even looked like kai and wil were dating. I can see that! Maybe another thing the emberassing thing could be is wil and kai got together and wil realised it was a mistake and he likes girls or not kai atleast??
Steph..... How tf did you get half the game theory synopsis in like 30 secs ? Mad respect for this woman's intellect and instinct
facts
right???
Thank you!! 🥰. I spent way too long thinking about it after the last reaction and reading other people’s comments and the poems!
@@wesandsteph6460 something unrelated a spectrogram is a software that turns audio into an image which can hide secrets in audio with out giving a dead giveaway that there is a secret message
wilbur hinted very heavily on stream when he reacted to this that he is doing another ARG around halloween or early November, so Steph's detective hat will return once more
well, I got some news for you🚶🏻♂️
Hinted? He downright said it!
Well... 😬
16:24 "...ah, fake ears-"
Wes and Steph, simultaneously and immediately: FAKE EARS! FAKIERS!
My jaw: *no longer in sight from how I've never caught that*
Tbf though, I haven't heard it pronounced that way either, the Red Herring video where it is pronounced like "fake-iers" doesn't bring this clue up. Still, I am in awe.
Note for Steph: You can play a song on two strings if you are playing the notes, not the chords. For example, the Song "Tonight Tonight" can be played solely on the A and E string if you are playing the notes
The og people that tried to figure this out (Jack's fanbase from that time) was primarily teenage guys. Most of that Google doc was stuff discovered by teenagers. We were a pretty intelligent group. I was there when it started. But I didn't help figure stuff out because I was more focused on watching his Minecraft videos lol
wilbur has said that the DID theory is wrong, and even in a stream after the ARG ended someone donated to him talking about their ‘system’ and ‘alters’ (components of DID) and he clearly said that he didn’t know what the words meant.
(I don’t think he’s the type to not do a lot of research into something about mental health that he was broadcasting to a wide audience, especially without having it himself)
In the reaction he said that was actually true
@@merelmoukje2229 no he didn't. he said he liked the "moving on" bit.
yeah, i don't think he's the type to do that either. if he ever did represent a disorder he didn't have he'd put in a lot more research, considering basic info like DID forming during childhood wasn't taken into account in these theories.
okay, i'm going to ask here...
is having an Alter Ego and DID the same thing?
maybe the Fakiers are just an alter ego you know, just playing two different characters like DSMP's Ghostbur and Alivebur?
@@RyanXander06 im not sure what an alter ego actually is, now that i think about it, but i know it isn't related to a medical condition, so they must be different.
Just as a thought experiment, what if the girl was not the one who died. True she is gone from his life, but what if Wilbur was the one who fell into the river, possibly after they broke up.
1) Wilbur is cold. Kai was cold after being in the river for 2 days.
2) Wilbur says at the end that this version of him will be dead and then literally disappears. He emphasizes that this version is dead. Not gone, but dead.
Just a thought worth poking at I guess.
It’s amazing how two different people, can come to such a similar conclusion. Getting to that conclusion in different ways, but reaching it nonetheless.
I really thought that this video was such a golden egg, in the many of your fun reactions. I enjoyed it.
The prank date thing was huge in my grade from middle school until our junior year. There were a ton of girls that got pranked and were pissed at them. It even got to the point that nobody believes them if they actually want to go on a date with someone. There’s a few people that still do it.
I'm so happy that you guys are as excited and interested on this as us, wilbur's community, are.
My theory:
1. Wilbur, consumed by his embarrassing secret, became a psychopath of sorts and tried to kill Kai by drowning him, but Kai could swim and he pulled Wilbur in and they had this massive fight which gave him PTSD, hence the 'I'm so cold'. What he doesn't know is that Kai is a psychopath too. And the girl... El? L? She was closely related to Kai in some way, so that's why he's so hell-bent on ruining Wilbur because he did something to her and got 90% caught by Kai, so that kind of explains the Kai situation. The Fakiers? Maybe R. Fakier and I. Fakier are the same person! Maybe by 'son' it's not meant as biological son, it's meant as like a new personality emerging from an old one. So basically, Wilbur accidentally did something to 'L', giving him trauma, Kai is related to L and is now pursuing Wilbur and I. Fakier got a glow-up to become R.Fakier.
I'm still deep in thought about the phrase 'Bow on top'. I also have a feeling that water is even more heavily involved than it already is. If you have some clues or ideas, please reply and maybe we can solve this.
It's been a year r u still up to solving it?
@@RohanKumar-cp8whtbh i kinda forgot about it but thanks for the reminder
btw, I think the fact that the girl didn't love him was true because if you look back to the red herring video, they noticed that a part of spiral galaxy's lyrics was cut down to "my lovers were a lie" or something along those lines.
Matpat’s theory was not perfect, but it provided a lot more clues so this arg is easier to solve
So I searched and is illegal to swim on the Thames "A new by-law has banned people from swimming in the River Thames without prior permission from the Port of London Authority (PLA)." which could explain why Wilbur is running from the police (if he wasn't the one who killed the girl).
My theory is that Wilbur and the Girl had a date, then Wilbur decided (maybe under the influence of Alcohol) to take a swim and invited the girl, after swimming a little and seeing that the water is too cold Wilbur gets out of the water but the girl doesn't, he jumps again trying to find her but she never appear, he panics and doesn't know what to do, he either calls Kai because he saw him recently or because Kai knew the girl, Kai gets mad at Wilbur and calls the police, Wilbur gets scared and runs, the police go after Wilbur to interrogate him but because of him doing something illegal and the girl disappearing he thinks the police wants to send him to jail so he escapes. Days (or weeks) later the girl is found dead and that's the point of breaking and were I. Fakier and R. Fakier are born.
Good theory
What I haven't seen talked about ANYWHERE is that in the red herring video they talk about voicemails that his "concerned friends" leave him. In the voicemails there is clearly a girl's voice talking about "what happened at the o2 arena". That means there are either 2 girls, or the one he went on a date with did not die at all.
Jack made a video on it, he didnt know wilbur before the initial e-mail, he was also in the dark however he did help but filming random stuff to help give wilbur opertunitys to sync and stuff with jack
Thanks for keeping my request! Love you guys :)
I think the reason Matpat thought the girl was pranking Wilbur was from the reoccurring theme that the event was labeled “embarrassing.” But yeah still feels like we are missing something.
Was just asking for this, just on Wes' channel. Didn't know you both would react to it.
You guys should REALLY do a gameplay video on minecraft with you both trying to play minecraft as one player or two players whichever you guys can do, we might even get parts to to gameplay and turn it into a series where you two finally learn to play minecraft lol, it would a be GREAT to watch
^^^
Vouch
I love you guys this is the second recommendation of mine that you reacted to. You guys make me so happy 😊💓💗
i really want u guys to react to the new run bts episode 154-155 , they’re taking a break from run bts .. i miss ur reaction 😭
18:56 You should check out the Petscop game arg that he mentioned it’s really interesting.
Hey could you please react to Run BTS 126-127, these episodes are so chaotic you’re gonna love them💜
Look I think matpat is the smartest and most persistent youtuber I know I respect him very much
Wes and Steph I MISS you guy's run BTS
I really wanna see you guys react to any run BTS
Maybe episode 122 and 123
part 2 to the cooking one you did
So basically the younger member's guiding Jin and suga
I don't wanna spoil but run BTS went on break after 155 episodes recently so basically they put a pause on the series that BTS has been doing for 6-7 years now
Probably means no run BTS for at least 6 months
So while that's it I really wanna see you guys catch up with the episodes
Wes said on stream that they were planning to do a bts reaction soon, I think they've been having a harder time scheduling videos together & so far for bts run they've done together which is prob why it's taken a while (wes reacts alone in a separate channel)
"Go subscribe to don't subscribe"
Do they know what they did?
(Jacksucksatlife reference)
that MrBeast channel? lol
So, i don't think the girl that left him that message is dead because in the last video he did one of the friends that called him(and the only girl who did actually) told him "not to worry about what happened and the o2 arena".
React to some tom simon videos with Steph!!!
Kai has been one of my best friends for years and this whole situation is so odd to me. Love this video guys!
I know this isn’t related to this video but could you please react to bts run episodes 154-155 and don’t let bts go on tour by seokjinmyfeels 🥰
Response to your questions: Jack and Wibur never had met before, and didn't plan this out. And Wilbur picked Jack cause he really liked Jacks content.
I agree that the voicemail from the girl sounded more like she just wanted to see him. Like how he also received voicemails from friends saying he had been acting weird, she was acting nervous because she can tell there's something going on with him. I think you guys could be right. Maybe the girl didn't reject him and after grabbing a burger they went on a boat and Wilbur caused some kind of embarrassing accident that caused the girl to drown. Wilbur dived into the cold water to save her but he couldn't and she died. Kai must have seen it all or Wilbur told him or something but Wilbur doesn't want people to know that he caused the accident somehow.
MatPat is a Musical Theater kid, that might explain the fondness of music
Here I feel like I am grading something as a teacher but anyways let's begin. So basically Kai's relation ship with Wilbur would only make sense as to why he wants the editor position over Kai, The girl is a big part but there is one thing I'd like to say the mystery girl said "We haven't been on 'a' date in forever" meaning they probably only went one date which the girl probably classified when they first met as that date and it was most likely a few months before December, if Kai didn't know about what Wilbur did, why would Wilbur go and try to get the editor position unless Kai knew what he did.
Wilbur reacted to the game theory video and in the end where he talks about his thoughts on it he basically 100% confirms that DID was a part of it, I don't know where people have gotten it from that he once said that that part isn't true but yeah, he basically confirmed DID being apart of the mystery
Wut
i don’t think he did do that???? he said the part about “that part of you disappearing when you accept something you did” (paraphrased) was pretty right, but he didn’t confirm or deny anything, and i’m pretty sure like a while ago he de-confirmed the DID theory
@@samg5601 Nope listen to it again then, he has not said anything about the DID theory being wrong in any video but in the context of Matt talking about the DID theory he said that Matt was “Pretty damn correct, you could almost say that that’s confirmed” straight from Wilburs own mouth
i think he did the exact opposite lmao? a while ago someone mentioned having DID and he didnt know what it was
@@cyberrainofficial no he already said that the DID theory wasnt right. if you actually listened what he confirmed is actually the “this part of wilbur disappearing is signifying he’s moved on” part of the video. wilbur has said he didn’t know what DID was when it was initially brought up to him. and to implement DID in this esp with this theory in particular is toeing very heavily on the ableist stereotype of ppl having multiple personalities means they’re murderers/bad/psychopaths.
WOO WILBUR SOOT ARG!
I LOVE YOUR VIDS KEEP IT UP
fun fact: MatPat was a theater kid! Pretty sure you can look it up and it shows a few things he's played in
I know i’m just really late but:
The painting of the wave is just a painting! The painting is called believe it or not: ‘The Wave’ by a japanese artist named Hokusai ( i think that’s how its spelt) and don’t think it has anything to do with the arg.
Wilbur can choose what setting he is in during the ARG, and the environment has been relevant before, so the painting very well could have some meaning/symbolism
@@ayva1106 fair enough
Fun fact: matpat used to do musical theater
you can hear the theatre kid come out sometimes
A spectagram is where you put any audio and shows any image or words thats the best explanation i can do ;-;
Ok my alteration of the theory, get popcorn and a drink this is gonna be a long one.
I think Wilbur and this girl were in a past relationship but she cheated on Wilbur with Kai and at some point she broke up with Wilbur to go with Kai because she liked him more, leaving Wilbur heart broken and unable to love again. Years later Kai and this girl decide to pull a prank on Wilbur thinking it would be funny to make him think that this girl still has feelings for her and the worst outcome is that Wilbur gets angry at them. When Wilbur finds out that it’s all a prank he gets angry and pushes her off into the water, gets scared, tries to save her and manages to get her back on land in time for her to say her last words “I’m so cold” and then dies. Wilbur is on the run paranoid of even the smallest things and Kai figures out that something is wrong when the girl seems to be gone and Wilbur is acting weird so he confronts him and gets enough information to know that she died in the water so he goes for a swim trying to find her body, rather he does or not who knows, but doesn’t go to the police because if this gets taken to court then everyone will know about the horrible prank that Kai and the girl tried to pull and no one would be sympathetic for him or believe what he said. Wilbur gets scared and knows that the internet is a place where anyone will believe anything and Kai could easily tell people and get them on his side and that’s how Wilbur decides to make sure that Kai no longer has a editing job. It has most of the components from Mat Pat, and solves the problem of how all three know each other.
BOOM I just solved the ARG, thank you for listening to my Ted talk, and you’re welcome, I’ll be here all week.
Oh I love this
And I would like more of Wilbur Soot... So if your interested in his 100players
so, i'm not sure if this is correct however i feel like it would make sense. jack wasnt in on the ARG however kai was. wilbur could have chosen many content creators, however he chose jack. i feel like this is because will knew kai before and told him about the idea (NOT the plot). after kai found out about the idea from wilbur he could have encouraged him to do it through jack. i also think that kai told jack previous to wilbur sending an email, "hey jack, someone i know reached out to me with a great idea, someone named wilbur soot will send you an email, just go along with it." which would then also explain why jack replied to a random email AND why he wasnt too scared or concerned throughout the ARG.
(i also think that this is why the person targeted during the ARG is kai as opposed to jack, as wilbur knew him prior to the ARG)
I looked way to much into the meme at the end ngl
Also I feel like Wilbur met Kie while on a date with the girl which is why he was awkward
Wilbur then tells Kie before he goes on the next date but never sees the girl come back and he suspects Wilbur so Wilbur needs him silenced
I wanted tjis video so much
You should watch Anthony Padilla's video 'I speak to people with Tourette's. It has a youtuber, called Sweet Anita, who was in one of the sidemens videos.
I might be wrong but I think they did, google they're name then that video and see
@@yehwtf3685 nope, they’ve done:
- faceless you tubers
- corpse
- dream
- mine craft youtubers
- DID
@@rosesarerosie4033 oh damn I must've confused the did one
You should react to some of the hermit craft builds, you wouldn’t regret it
36:04 I mean " 3:56 " maybe thats why it was difficult to understand
You guys should listen to revived, it's a DreamSMP song about Wilbur
Please react to Run BTS Episodes 126-127. It’s like a relay race where the members have to complete a bunch of activities or they can’t go home. These episodes are hilarious and I think you guys would really enjoy them. These episodes also show how competitive some of the members are.
OMG YESSSS!!
Maybe Kai and the girlfriend were having an afair, Wilbur discovers it and in a rage throws the girl, and then all the other things happen.That may also explain why he is like "hating Kai"
I actually don't have any idea about this ARG, I have only watch this and Red Hering videos and I'm not even a native english speaker, but I thought that was a cool idea xd
Note for Steph Wilbur dmed Jack saying to just go with it and fun fact tommy was a fan of jack and willne he has a picture with Kai, jack and willne
wilbur disproved the whole DID thing a while ago
Miss your RUN BTS reaction 🥺
For some reason I get the feeling the e-girl he's obsessing over in his songs has something to do with "Elle's lovely three" but at the same time I doubt it has anything to do with his songs.
He’s mentioned somewhere it has nothing to do with his songs, but the coincidence is odd.
@@Velocitist The "I'll
Find other people to talk with
'Cause you like me
And I think you're a maniac" part is really similar to the theory Wilbur's lover potentially cheated on him, idk I might be wrong but its awfully too connected
@@literallyjustali2290 That’s fair…
You should react to Game Theory minecraft darkest timeline
Technoblade Minecraft Monday playlist and Dream 1v1 analysis next
I think you should react to more game theory. They have amazing stuff like fnaf, petscop, hiimmarymary and soooooo on. It would be amazing if you checked them out.
Just clicked the notification so haven’t watched anything, just in case this isn’t mentioned, I believe that the multiple personalities has been disproved by Wilbur himself! (I also have no idea if that theory is mentioned)
They should have contacted L💀
miss your bts reactions!
now you can react to wilburs reaction to this video!
I HAVE AN IDEA THAT MIGHT FIT UR IDEA BETTER:
ok so what if they were going on a date and she told wilbur that she was cheating on him with kai, wilbur in a moment of rage pushes her in, but he thinks he overreacted considering the event he did to be embarrasing. blah blah blah, trauma, DID, etc. Kai knows about this simply by patching it to together that he never talked to the girl again. blah blah blah he tries to kill kai. I think he actually did try to kill Kai because if you remember Kai made a post saying "What a lovely swim that was!", obviously not something you would post after almost getting murdered but Im pretty sure its just supposed to serve as a clue.
On the first skit intro part, did they actually think the random Britain dude voice was wilbur?
also, did you all notice "Poe"? remember... Poe.
Nice video cool
wilbur also reacted to it and he didnt give much away and also didnt confirm that is true however said that the part about him dissappearing is about accepting and forgiving himself is correct
this might be a stretch but when he is doing the cover for crywank he leaves room for another person to sit by him. ???
It's advance techniques 😅 that's what I can say ...
Jack didnt know anything they didnt even ever talk while the arg was going on
Please react to the Cicada 3301 video. It’s so interesting
well the find a friend is very easy to get once u have someones number and the phone is on... not really the most legal thing but u know.
Please react to "Cicada 3301: an internet mystery" by LEMMiNO.
Love your reactions :)
Now that one was masterful.
The DID has been disproven. Wilbue also confirmed this when he reacted on stream. However the discord have another theory that I'm pretty sure we are correct on. Anyways I'm in the discord and we think we're super close to the truth, we've just got a few more things to figure out.
I'm so cold
Wilbur actually reacted to this on stream.
Can you react to Molly Burke plz!!!
Seeing this Game Theory video is kinda sad now seeing as Wilbur basically said it wasn't true lmao
I think Kai saw this girl with Wilbur, Wilbur saw Kai and when Kai heard she had drowned he puzzled it together. So he tweeted like just had a swim or something to trigger Wilbur, Wilbur get that Kai might know, so Wilbur try to meet Kai and do the same, but Kai was prepared this MIGHT happen. or something that way What do you think Steph:P would love a reply :)
How do you know when you solved an arg?
Um Willbur never gave the solution to this ARG, even if he "eliminated" some wrong theory. I don't think the secret will ever really be revealed if Willbur doesn't say it himself, and I think he's having too much fun for now with the theories that still come out about his ARG. The girl theory may be a valid theory ... but it doesn't necessarily have to be a girl he knew in person ... I mean, the girl in the message can be something entirely separate. But a girl may very well have fallen into the river, Will and Kai were there when it happened and tried to save her, failing ...
He did actively discourage Matpat from trying to solve it at all, and he said he messed up when creating this ARG and made it too difficult by accident.
Well seeing this video pop up is awkward. I can’t really see him the same way anymore
Wilbur reacted to the video also they hired an English voice actor
Hey can you guys please react to Technoblade: The victim of heroes by westy live
react to jacks videos they are sooooo cool
Alright now ima write down my theory
So I think the phone call from the girl wasn't for Wilbur I think it's for kai sense from what I've seen it looks like kai knows her and I think Wilbur had a crush on kai's girlfriend so when kai and the girl when on a date to the 02 arena Wilbur must've confronted em and told her he liked her but then I think they must've laughed about Wilbur liking her making it embarrassing so in a fit of rage Wilbur ended up pushing her into the water and I don't think she or kai knew how to swim so Wilbur when to save her but ended up failing and after that I think kai quickly learned how to swim fear that Wilbur might do that same to him which he did but sense kai learned how to swim he survived
Wilbur follows Obama on Twitter, just thought I'd let you know....
you guys should deffs react to some jacksucksatlife videos hes amazing
❤️❤️❤️❤️
Mat
Did people just gave up solving it? Or its just fucking unsolvable?
It’s not solved yet
pls react to smallishbeans empires episodes
Hello
Wait so Wilbur actually killed a girl ?
Oh no I'm late
honestly if the DID theory is correct after everything... ill be a bit disappointed on wilbur. he's seems way too mental health aware to create yet another murderer character with DID, when systems already suffers so much from these repetitive and harmful depictions. he doesn't seem like the type of person to represent such a stigmatized disorder without making all the research possible to make it accurate, it's wilbur we're talking about here. besides it's just such a boring and cliched explanation. i love game theory's and red herring's videos, seen them so many time, but i simply can't get behind this theory.
also some people have been saying wilbur confirmed matpat's theory for some reason. he didn't. even if matpat was 100% right, wilbur wouldn't say anything. all he said was that he liked the idea of moving on and accepting something bad you did. HE DIDN'T EVEN SAY THAT WAS PART OF THE ARG, though we can understand that's probably what he meant. but he made no comment on the rest of the theory, and his face was very blank the entire stream. it's fine if people like the DID theory, but don't go around saying it's anything but a theory, okay? matpat said it himself. in the end of the day, it's just a theory, and always will be, because wilbur will never reveal the story.
also matpat's theory about the embarrassing incident is a bit... idk sounds like a stretch to me. like, it could be right, but it has no actual proof so if it's right itd be kinda throwing something on a wall and hoping it sticks
The first and hello who are reading this i wanna say that be safe,be careful,and be grateful thank you for reading this comment😊
Hey react to sidemenreacts to animals save people
that random girl asking for a date, could have been cold and wilbur gave her his jacket, which she not returned and theres emberassing Notes or USB sticks in there. Maybe even Kai the editor got to greeenwhich? because the girl contacted him, maybe the notes/USBs even were about Kai?...
I don't think the emberassing thing ends in murder its more an awkward probably sexual encounter maybe even drunk of either Wilbur and Kai or the girl and wilbur or kai maybe even both!
Or some stolen/accidentally taken notes/USB about anything. But i could be totally wrong
Also on a sitenote, wilbur was very much only going the same ways at the end of 2018 so meeting w/ someone and meeting a girl and she calling because she did not see him going somewhere again, maybe it even looked like kai and wil were dating. I can see that! Maybe another thing the emberassing thing could be is wil and kai got together and wil realised it was a mistake and he likes girls or not kai atleast??
3