Taliban: Religious leaders have issues with girls schools - BBC News
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 26 сен 2024
- It's been one year since the Taliban seized power in Afghanistan. The country is facing a severe economic and humanitarian crisis, and there are growing security concerns.
The US claimed two weeks ago that it killed Al Qaeda’s chief Ayman Al Zawahiri in Kabul.
But one of the most significant issues in an Afghanistan under the Taliban is that girls are barred from secondary schools in most parts of the country.
Our South Asia correspondent Yogita Limaye spoke to Zabihullah Mujahid, spokesman for the Taliban government.
Please subscribe HERE bit.ly/1rbfUog
#BBCNews
"We are working on it," and, "we have formed a committee." The two most placating phrases you can hear in an institution.
Anywhere in the world
@Anonymous World the beat them doesn't mean physical attack
@@cashizcashiz1955 To the point. When western government are asked about housing crisis and income inequality prevailing in their country they behave exactly like that. For example US is still working on Two state solution in middle east. It has been 80 years US and its alliance are working on. Investigation regarding murder of Al jazeera journalist will go on for decades.🤣🤣
@Anonymous World university of copy and paste . You must be a Hindu troll that ate a lot of cow dungs snack 👏
@@muhammadhussain5854 Do not be surprised, because there are many deceivers who are enemies of Islam. They try to read some verses and then use them to realize their hatred by manipulating them and interpreting them to suit the hatred inside them.
Education should not be left in the hands of 'religious scholars' it should be a choice and a right for all who want to pursue it.
Don't like them, but worth noting that your logic does not work here either, especially his explanation is based on 'Safety' and "Locals in regional areas" not wanting them educated.
I am not sure to what extent his statement is true or not, but that is what is said, along with the accurate fact that the Girls do go to school in many regions apparently.
Absolutely nothing should be left to religious scholars.
muslims do not separate religion from state, we dont, with that said, in Isslam there is a commandment from God for all people to seek knowledge and study, so what does that say of scholars that look for excuses to prohibit girls from studying?
says you!
This is not your business this is afghanistan not europe ! You dont have anything to say bud
Proud to this reporter who asked him a Questions very Boldly
let me guess shes indian XD lets praise her everybody we have a supporter here
Proud how straight he answered the Question to which community brutally lost Against them.
@@nrahman3943 what else would you have to say as a Pashtun if not in support of your fellow Pashtun talib ??
@@Ggggggggg631 nothing. And I'm not Pashtun.
@@nrahman3943 Pakistani Pashtun whatever. All the same
The first university was made by a Muslim woman and I have no idea what problems are Taliban facing in Women's education. I still have no idea why women's education feels problematic to them.
As Prophet Muhammad (Peace be upon him) said, "Education is not only the right but the duty of every Muslim, male or female."
Thats true. Its because their culture. Because that culture other religion have wrong opinion about islam.
@@dedyhariansyah7955 Islam and culture are two different things.And most of the people dont understand that
The issue is that the definition behind those words can differ in perspective based on how conservative they are. Education can span from primary to tertiary and some may think tertiary education is unnecessary given their assumption of the conservative roles of women. And their assumption build from their previous experience from a conservative teachings or communities.
Can you think about the implicit assumptions behind the words you have used? What do you mean by education? And what does Taliban think education should be? Maybe the disagreement lies in the ambiguity.
Lets have a look on opinion of prophet about women he is clearly calling them half minded and deficient and also seeing menstruation as some sin commited by women which leads to deficiencies . Hats off to all the muslim ladies are still in this cult after knowing all these things... Sahih al-Bukhari 304
Narrated Abu Sa`id Al-Khudri:
Once Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) went out to the Musalla (to offer the prayer) of `Id-al-Adha or Al-Fitr prayer. Then he passed by the women and said, "O women! Give alms, as I have seen that the majority of the dwellers of Hell-fire were you (women)." They asked, "Why is it so, O Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) ?" He replied, "You curse frequently and are ungrateful to your husbands. I have not seen anyone more deficient in intelligence and religion than you. A cautious sensible man could be led astray by some of you." The women asked, "O Allah's Messenger (ﷺ)! What is deficient in our intelligence and religion?" He said, "Is not the evidence of two women equal to the witness of one man?" They replied in the affirmative. He said, "This is the deficiency in her intelligence. Isn't it true that a woman can neither pray nor fast during her menses?" The women replied in the affirmative. He said, "This is the deficiency in her religion."
that woman asks the Taliban, WHEN the girls will go back to school, but from the Taliban's face expression, it's rather a question IF the girls will ever go back to school ...
since when are you all-knowing?
That's Free-speech and Freedom of Expression expert BBC hwore can't sit in front of him without covering her stupid brain 🤣😂
Because a uneducated society is what a txrror group needs most.
Taliban: does taliban things. Western Media: surprised pikachu face.
How true😂
Literally no different to Saudi or any other Middle Eastern country, don’t see why have such a obsession with the taliban while their allies do the same
Taliban: does taliban things. Western media and politicians: Let's bring them in to our countries and hope for the best!
@@OllieGrigg that’s a lie
@@OllieGrigg no different to any other Middle Eastern country are you ok ????
Taliban should understand that by providing education, they don't do anyone favour but for the development of the country
You clown the problem is funding the schools and paying teachers' salaries! The Taliban regime is really poor as they don't have any fundings. If the government is recognised they can easily open schools as they will receive help
@@Exlaty oh please! Many poor countries, including my own in the past, provided as best education as they could to all, irrespective of sex. That is the mist incredulous excuse I have heard in a long time.
@@Exlaty one - the majority of countries rich and poor always maintain schools. Two the Taliban know that development/education undermines their religious stances as it makes people more critical as thinkers who will question the way they do things - particularly women who will be fed up of being treated like second class citizens. The world has said they would be more likely to recognise the Taliban if they didn't reverse the progress of women's rights.
They consider women as mere baby making & food cooking machines, idk if the body parts of women offends them or something that they wana pack them all in body bags like that.. they don’t want them to learn & become critical thinkers, they just want them as a commodity that they can own.
@@zaert21 you idiot! Primary schools and higher education are already open for females! They struggle to resume secondary schools because of the lack of teachers... There was a brain drainage during last year if you know what that means...
All girls/women in all country should be allowed to have the education they deserve and should not be prevented from doing so on religious or any other grounds
Islam doesn't permit women's education or them visiting a mosque.
The males are scared that they will lose control of them. So backward. The country could actually progress and be much better if that damn religion nonsense would die out. Hopefully, the women can form secret groups and beat them at their own game by becoming educated and stronger together.
Man. Shut up we as Muslims are not like you Christians . We have different values and different perspective on our minds
They have weird views and say its from Islam when it's actually not. There is a hadith/saying of the prophet that all Muslims should seek knowledge. Thereby we can conclude all Muslims have the right for education.
Islam bad
Asking the Taliban to ensure women and girls have equal rights is like asking a fox that he will make sure the chickens are OK.
You don't have to worry about the girls of Afghanistan. They have their guardian, and they are human not Alien. Go and read the history and culture of a particular country. Stop judging from western views.
@@IsmailHossain-bq2bo Shut up you troglodyte.
Don't try shit here
Equal rights is not possible in Islam. Women and men have different rights and different duties. Both are advised to learn and apply what is beneficial knowledge throut their life. Besides this it´s a duty for men and women to keep harmony and love in their families alive with all their abilities and the help/blessings of Allah Allmighty. This does not mean that this is more easy for Muslims to accomplish than for other people. Taliban not hurt women by violence. They hurt them through ignoring. And they are ready to work on all peoblems between them to fulfill their deen and for the sake of future of Afghanistan.
I cant imagine the girls in my family not having the option to go to school. I would be ashamed of myself if I stood by and just did nothing.
Homeschooling is the best
@@Harry-bw2xj Maybe accredited formal education is thing the of the past anyway. All you really need is the internet, I learned more in the last 5 years from the internet than I ever did in school
@@Harry-bw2xj Nope. Lack of socialization can be detrimental to a kid.
@ed lubitz that is because you are normal lol. Religion overall has been a major hinderance to human development.
i wouldnt bcs its the choice of the government those who feel ashamed are weak like you you dont deserve that punisher logo on youre pfp
“We have problems and we’re solving them.” These guys (and they’re ALL guys) couldn’t solve their way out of a paper bag.
@@nomad7060 Thats how western people always do,destroy countries then blame them later for being poor, disgusting 👿👿
@@nomad7060 oh look, a Taliban loving TROLL
The guys that beat the Americans?
@reichstag US had already decided to leave Afghanistan since Trump. It was a disastrous war for America and it was seriously hurting the image of Biden. So, these political dynamics facilitated a lot in Taliban's return. If these things didn't happen, what would happen otherwise? Apart from that, you forgot to mention Ashraf Ghani's cowardice. If he was determined and showed leadership enough, Taliban's return would be impractical.
@@infobomb466 the Taliban has enough power in Afghanistan for the US to have been negotiating with them before their withdrawal. It was expected that the Taliban would eventually take over. America left because this was another Vietnam and the Taliban were maintaining a hold despite America’s 20 years there. The Taliban never really left and the fact that they took power so quickly should make that quite obvious.
The journalist is brilliant
If only they could ask questions of our own leaders the way they do from those of a country desperate for humanitarian aid.
Questions directly related to Afghanistan and countries like it:
So the girls not going to school should also starve because you refuse to send humanitarian aid?
The government in Venezuela is corrupt and the people suffer. So you put sanctions on almost every single one of its industries so that the people can suffer some more?
Should teenage-Paralympic athletes from Russia who couldn´t even vote for or against Putin be sanctioned from competing in sports events because of what their government does?
Never heard any questions like this, I wonder why. What you and everyone else should wonder is, is our media truly free anymore or do journalist at least self-censor to the point of absurdity nowdays?
She just asked basic, much-needed questions. I don't see how that pertains to how brilliant she is. I am sure she is smart and capable, but I just don't see the relevance in that she is only doing her job.
@@ActionableFreedom well said
@@FactStorm Because journalists rarely do their jobs I imagine :), so people find this refreshing.
She's indian
Religious fundamentalism is just holding humanity back. You see this in Afghanistan, you see this is in the USA.
religion is accepted insanity, blind belief and gives crazy people a "self importance" delusion.
Well said 🙌🙌🙌 I’m a spiritual person, but humans relying on stories made by earlier humans with nothing better to do ;to run a society
Dumb comparison.
stop it.. we have way more freedom here in America than anywhere else in the world
@@nikeairjordanfly europe is more freedom than us
Imagine thinking that human culture was better in the 7th century. 🙄
Unlike your daughters. Who get fucked by 500 men.. then left mentally, emotionally damaged for life.. then get married?? Right?? Wow.. you guys are on point!! Bravo!!
Reporter: Why are girls not going to school yet?
Him: Problems problems problems and problems. Did I mention the problems yet?
Stop blaming them after destroying their countries, bombing houses, school killing children and the women you pretend you care about now.shame on you all
The women's ate going in universities and to schools from grade 1 to 6 in all over Afghanistan only secondary schools aren't open for girls in some provinces
@@muhammadhussain5854 BS you are delusional.
@@muhammadhussain5854 I know, I'm just making a joke
@@muhammadhussain5854 Taliban is a terrorist group that was sleeping with Al Quaida. And now he lies and say they know anything about Ayman Zawahiri.
He said " our religious leader has issues with the safety of our girls "
The caption says Religious leader has issues with girls' education.
this is how the western media manipulates its sheep.
TALIBAN HATES WOMEN ..they have sexual relations with young boys
That is a known fact
well the 2nd thing doesn't saprk joy, right? BBC like any other media channel wants trp, what do you expect them to be completely truthful?
It's look women get raped and sexual transmitted diseases in the west and children don't know who is the dady
@@thestargazer6335 wtf are you talking about? The caption is more truthful than what the Taliban has ever said for all time
I like how he is strategically and ambiguously answering questions!
Take notes
"A doctrine insulates the devout not only against the realities around them but also against their own selves. The fanatical believer is not conscious of his envy, malice, pettiness and dishonesty. There is a wall of words between his consciousness and his real self."
~Eric Hoffer
He's a liar. It's not decided by the people. Nothing is decided by the people.
@@mackabeats The people are Muslim not western christians or athiests. They don't think along the lines of godless people. They have different perspectives
@@mackabeats In your opinion, who are the people?
I really love how everyone takes education seriously but not poverty someone ask them what are you going to do for the people who are dying of hunger
Touche
What could possibly solve poverty? Education.
@@krrrrrrrrrrrr3372 no.. education alone can never solve poverty.. end of capitalism might be
@@krrrrrrrrrrrr3372 you can't think properly when your stomach is empty
tell us to remove sanction first
I’m glad they sent a female interviewer to call him out
Edit: I love how she asks him yes/no questions and he ignored answering…
Facts 👩🦰👱♀️
She embarrassed herself by wearing the uniform.
Questioning them isn’t going to change them. Congrats you’re brave for asking such a question, but the Taliban isn’t stupid to execute you for that. They’re wanting to gain their finances back, can’t do that executing random folks,
@CAPTAIN HOOK damn
@Ali Cheema I guess we know what side you're one.
@Ali Cheema I guess we know what side you're on.
Of course it's not going to change them, but the Taliban wants to be accepted as a legitimate government, which means acceptance by the leaders of the world.
If they don't want to change, they will never be seen or treated as legitimate.
@@zepher664 Saudi Arabia are doing just fine though. Idk fam
Religious leaders have issues. Period.
Not really
Nono, not issues
Problems
and they are solving it
XD
And you sir/ma'am are perfect surely
@@usmanmuhammad3743 hahahahaha, you are speaking truths here
@@axeldewater9491 you were made from one drop of detestable fluid, do not act so proudly. You know I was being sarcastic
There is a difference between Trust and Irrational forceful obedience
It is way to unsafe to even question them in the question of 'opening' schools. There have been a 'chain' of 'carbombs' detonated near schoolchildren and it is yet to conclude if this is 'on purpose' or by accidental discharging from screaming young women and or 'making contact' whereas it occurs quite often having a 'discharge' from rubbing a balloon against hair, wool and such.
Also facial recognition software left behind by the Americans and access through relays will solve this problem.
There was a carbomb near the Kabul Airport that detonated in a such way.
Dont question them on this.
Do yourself a favour and keep quiet...your ignorance is showing! FYI Taliban ate Afghans, are own sons of the soil. The war was against the NATO foreign invader terrorists and their puppets not Afghans.
Promises, considerations and delays. Nothing will change that way...
Why do you care it is a Muslim right how he may conduct himself regard education; we invented education
This guy sounds like an American politician….
Taught by the best
Most politicians speak the same way
@@magivkmeister6166 Amen
he sounds more honest to his ideas though
@@wgbhg how did you do it?? Tell me
Definitely... How religious scholars should not have problem with girl's education? If they got educated, they deny the authoritarian power of these leaders, they will not allow any kind of discrimination happening to then, they'll start demanding their social and political rights and many more. How could the religious leaders tolerate this? Because they have considered women as an object which should be kept under control of a men and not as a human being.
Ding ding dong You have figured it out.
If that were true they’d stop men from going to school as well.
@Sylheti go worship your pedo prophet
@@akon360 men won't question religion
They overprotect women , they do not consider a woman to be an object . If you are concerned about women being objects , go to the red light district of Amsterdam .
Bottom line is that many people in Afghanistan support this. The taliban would not be in power if the people didn’t support them. We can’t force western views upon a people that do not want it.
Very astuit.
I agree. Regardless of how competent or incompetent the Taliban is, there's no reason to believe that importing western views and norms in Afghanistan is a guaranteed win.
So true.
The rural afghans generally support this, those that live in cities don't.
The women of Afghanistan have suffered because they lost sons, husbands and brothers. Those who invaded are to blame for this. If the west is so worried about girls and their education, they should unfreeze Afghan money.
Terrified of educated women. Tells you everything you need to know about these fools.
There you are again. The modern scientific method was invented by a Muslim named Ibn Al-Haytham, if you didn't know. We certainly don't need a secularists to lecture us about anything, including women. The least thing you can do is say, thank you.
@@Free-Palestine An opinion is not a lecture. Wonder why you feel so defensive. The usual reason?
@@havaguday You ain't Superior to these people in any way shape or form, keep your ignorant opinions to yourself
@@havaguday Well atleast you said it was an opinion, nothing to be taken seriously.🤣
Stop living like you're in the 7th century
Mind your own business!
learn how to wash your ass after you take a shit not just wiping wid tissue
If we did the whole Afghanistan would fall and millions of them would starve ! If we MIND OUR OWN BUSINESS
It is religion bro
@@Ur.MomfAg Playing the moral ground whilst you bombed them and put sanctions on them.
This man talk like a Chinese officer, always avoid the problem and tell us nothing.
How how international diplomates talks folks!
True but have you watched us politicians Q&A?😂😂😂
Logic is not their strongpoint…or telling the truth it seems.
Blind obedience is their thing.
You are the one who lack logic and can't read what they are saying.
@@fromireland8663 Because you don't blindly obey your government? Lol.
Try to go against your government openly and see what happens to you.
@ahmad hanbal Well said, those fools can't identify a woman and they talk about women's rights.
Talk about being illogical, and he dares talk about logic.😂
@@fromireland8663 not just that, watch how they drive their taxis/cars 😂. They don’t have common sense at all 😂
Don't want them to learn at school it's about control keeping them chained to the sink, making their meals and having baby boy's, all about power.
very true
Misogyny as a religious tenet seems pretty dodgy. Then, I noticed it seems to be really popular with guys who like to ride around in the back of pickup trucks waving flags and assault rifles. You know, the scholars.
You came from nowhere, and you're going nowhere. You're a secularists, who believes in human contrived morals, goals, and outlook. We're Muslim, and follow a divine law. We know why we're here, and where we're going. Your definition of "freedom", is also different than ours. You see freedom as drinking, adultery, drugs, vile language, etc. We have a different perspective, including how we view women, and how Muslim women view themselves. In other words, we're not interested in your 'standards', not in the least.
@@Free-Palestine Oh, I'm not a secularist. Just not superstitious.
@@havaguday Well then, you don't know what you are. *And be not like those who forgot God, so He made them forget themselves. Those are the defiantly disobedient.* 59:19 No Godly person would object to anything in Islam, impossible. Not if they had a sound heart, and mind.
The Muslims defeated Britain, Russia, and America, in Afghanistan, because the Afghans weren't willing to compromise.
And no Muslim with a shred of dignity, is willing to compromise with the likes of you. Take that to the bank.
@@Free-Palestine wow it seems great 👍😃 What do you think about women education?
@@Free-Palestine yeah include education in crime category....oh nooo it's a western thing 💀💀💀🤪🤪it will ruin everyoneeee
We should forget about Afghanistan and all muslim countries.
Who is we?
Start with Saudi Arabia. I dare you.
Disgusting comment
America still begs Muslims for oil
One sure way to get bitten in the bum.
the talibans biggest fear, an educated woman,
Not really plenty exist they just don't want women to have positions of power.
It's their biggest fear because they've seen what happens to society when you start going woke. Modern feminism is damages the fabric of society. A society starts from the household. If the household is damaged how can you create a great society with good morals?
The west should stop trying to make everyone in the world follow their culture. Unfreeze their assets and let them figure it out themselves. The west are basically saying "either you become like us or we withhold your assets" and once you give in to the west once it doesn't end there they'll want more.
It's like asking a cancer cell to behave like a normal cell
Afghan religious scholars have no problem with girl schools. Hamid Karzai has said it. From last 20 years experience, we know that Karzai is the only person whose statements about Afghanistan have proved accurate and precise
He said he will never leave, Afghanistan will never fall to Taliban, then left 4 days after saying that and Taliban came to power. Do you have any idea what you're saying?😂
@@bestnocture I am talking about Hamid Karzai, not the stupid Ghani.
@@bestnocture any wise person would leave.
Lies again? True Anal
Islamic extremists being extremists... how shocking🙄
@Peter Andre they didn't say anything said in this interview specifically, but they're blocking women from education. That's an extremist action.
Clearly this man doesn't want girls to go to school, he is looking for excuses for them not to go. It has been Taliban's mission all along, sane people saw it coming.
How 'noble' of the Taliban fighting for the rights and safety of Afghan women and girls then.
This mullah is not your typical mullah
He speaks like a well experienced diplomat
Lol
They are smarter than you think, the problem is your ignorance
Some Mullahs are more educated and well spoken many suite wearing moron. Don't judge a man by his clothes.
@Anonymous World You are misquoting the Quran to serve your agenda. I can also write my own words and white: John 20:5.
Nobody cares if you write fiction and say Quran says so. At the end of the day The Christians and the Jews you are talking about are accepting Islam as ever before, thanks to the lies you write. People research and they find out that all the lies about Islam was to scare them off. Most convert to Islam when they read Quran. Keep writing BS.
Yeh he talks BS
That guy is such a slime ball 😅 he knows what he’s doing
@@abumuscaab Bu bu but under invader American, Afghanistan women has more right, can go to school, and allowed to work
@@kalostyr7231 so? Those were "wrongs" not "rights".
@@jubairomar2676 What wrong ? Tell me
Afghanistan when America still there was governed by Afghan ppl themselves, USA was there mainly to fight Taliban. Also like i said when USA is there, Afghan women simply has better life and rights. There are women reporter, women athletes, women doctor all of which because presence and security of USA. Now after US leaves and Taliban rule, women in there live under opression, deprived of education. Is there even women doctor and athletes now in there?They're now simply used as breeding machine and cook in kitchen only.
USA maybe evil when invading Afghanistan but they bring stability esp to women in there, between Taliban and USA, USA simply was lesser of two evils
@@kalostyr7231 what right their country being destroyed? Children being killed and women? Stealing their resources????come on people we know you have no shame but come on 😠😠😠you all suck
@@kalostyr7231 on avg 300 people were killed everyday. US and its allies tortured, maimed and persecuted the people especially Muslims. US backed warlords were running rampants. Imposed western ideologies on people and children (in schools). US was fight Islam in AFG, not necessarily Taliban.
So because of a handful of villages, you are stopping millions in big cities from goin to school.
Does he not realize this?
Do you have any problem? Oil your own machine. Barkhurdar.
What a joke…why even treat these fanatics as a legitimate governing body?
Why bother asking questions when you're clearly being managed... The narrative is being written by their actions
Well spoken
exactly. this interview was pointless.
"We succeed by just being at war."
You can't beat an opponent with that mentality.
No opponent also beat them, with the mentality: "We don't agree with Taliban, so we will destroy them".
That was wrong translation.
yeah u can, just end the war lol now they are losing because they have to govern, this country is over lol
A txrror group has no such thing as "mentality".
@@baharafghanzad_0093A puppet and jahil govt like the previous govt will never succeed in this life or the next life
After deep analysis of this interview and reading between the lines, I have come to the conclusion that there is a problem
looking deep the problem is religion and that religion is islam
👏👏👏
And the problem is the txliban txrrorists and the morrons who think that we want them.
How can a girl child’s education be determined by a group of religious leaders who are men?
Why????!!!!
Women is Islam have a lot of rights and it’s up to men to deprive women of their rights because of their Ego and insecurities.
Safety and danger are things you can’t prevent 100% a lot of girls and women get raped and abused at home too what do they do to prevent that ?? Education is a very important thing as it helps construct society as a whole. Educate men and women on how to live together in a society:
Women in Islam are allowed to:
Work
Own businesses
Education
Consent to marriage
Be apart of society
Divorce
Choose whether to be in polygamous marriage
Keep their names after marriage
Not oblige to stay with the in-laws and the other family
Give women their God given rights
The best solution for them is to take the classes online if its dangerous for them to go school in some rural areas then just do it from the comfort of your own home and the UN could help provide them with all the neccesities such as laptops and Internet.
That's a great idea.
@@vladimirmomperousse4340 dude there is hardly any internet coverage available in poor countries like Afghanistan. even in countries like US not everyone is able to afford internet then how can you expect in Afghanistan?
How can you expect kids to know how to even use it if they’re not even being educated?
An other Taliban mentioned this in another interview, it was the younger one who knows English well .
Opinions aside, from what i got from this interview, the Taliban government is having problems with sending girls to school because of a social and culteral problem that has deep routes in the Afghan society. From this view i can understand why it is going to take time for girls to go back to school as even if the government gives the green light, there is a real possibility that the safety of the girls getting education may be at risk.
BS. They just dont want girls to go to school. In Saudi Arabia which is very religious and conservative, the girls and women go to school.
Especially that several groups among the Taliban might go rouge and break away. Taliban is trying to centralise authority.
Also, ghost schools and ghost teachers are a problem as under the US/NATO watch, activists and govt officials stole the money for education. Most girls and many boys were not going to school under the US/NATO-Ghani/Karzai regime but the NATO govts and ex-Afghan govt and other leaders keep quire about this.
@@fahad_hassan_92 not only Taliban groups. This is deeper and bigger than a few Taliban groups and the IEA governments approach is the best approach to ensure current and future success and getting everyone on board. Majority of Taliban support girls education are not against girls education, 14 out of 15 provinces are ignoring the ban and private girls schools are open. A girls high school was recently conpleted in Kandarhar. Once thos delay is over, it will be the most children going to school in Afghanistan in the past few decades under this new Afghan government.
exactly!
Some countries be dumbing down half their population and then keeps wondering why are they still poor
Very sharp reporter wall done!!
I look forward to see positive changes taking place and equal rights for man and women as this is the only Road to acceptance from other nations**
These men have mothers,wives,sisters and daughters who prefer homeschooling. All thanks to Allah
It will never happen in Islamic states
@@zarajamali2383
It will not happen if Women give up on protesting for equal rights what is veued to be impossible to change has been reformed in other cultures through perpetual protesting media posting and newspaper messages with out question equal rights will become possible in future for if it doesn't other Nations will be put off the acceptance of an Islamic state!
It's always better to be the optimist when all seems down and out**🍀🕊☯️
@@Harry-bw2xj homeschooling would on average be preferable to most though those educated through homeschooling would not be brought up with a shared cultural education background if not participating in cultural school education*
Haven't noticed any kind of sharpness there. Just spiting the same repetitive, pre-formulated western talk and usual responses. 🤦♂🤦♂
What a sausagefest of a regime.
“Consensus of men” is what he is referring to every time he says “consensus of people”. Sigh!
"Consensus of ultra-conservative, traditionalist, religious, old men" is what he really is referring to.
Consensus of the scholars, you ignorant, which not everyone can reach that level.
The modern way to save our civilisation,women being mothers and wives.
@@Harry-bw2xj I thought having them still in school into their late 20's earning a phd would work 😂
@@keyboardmouse7699 it will help to achieve society capital and raise funds, while regimes like Taliban will make population growth. And eventually someday your daughter meet Abdullah and accept Islam
Knowledge and education is the no. 1 weapon against an enemy!
Actually the Quran says that both men and women should be educated. There is nothing Islamic about depriving women of an education
Countries which killed millions in Afghanistan, suddenly they are so cautious about Afghanistan's human rights.
Excellent responses by the spokesperson.
Such a Original profile name. 🙄
That's Free-speech and Freedom of Expression expert BBC hwore can't sit in front of him without covering her stupid brain 🤣😂
I would be curious what percentage of rural tribal leaders agree with the Taliban's restrictions. It's not just the Taliban - it's partly Afghan culture as well (specifically rural Pashtun culture)
In the midst of famine, he looks well fed…hurmmm🤔
Famine in Afghanistan?? You must be living in a cave my friend
@@afghanistan9196 are you afghan?
This is future of secular countries including 🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧UK...
Muslims always support radical islaam... No matter country...
Good
Nothing changes if nothing changes.
I love how the reporters go to Afghanistan and try to grill them,
They aren’t listening to the west and don’t give a damn about their opinions. 😂
And yet they beg for financial and humanitarian support.
@@juanzulu1318 true 😂
@@juanzulu1318 They are not begging. They are asking their own assets to be unfrozen.
@@juanzulu1318 they should stop working with the west, we just going to stop them for progressing.
They should work with Russia and Iran nk, China etc.
@@dave84111 « you’re aren’t following us so we’re going to freeze your banks and stop your country »
~ the west
School is not the only requirement for a fulfilled life. Modern lifestyle have abundant schools. Despite of that, most people are suffering from anxieties, depression , mental health issues etc. Stop giving undue importance to western education system. 90 % of the things which we learn in our basic school system, are not even used all our life. Let people of the country decide their rules . Stop enforcing your mentality on them.
You are right these british american people created this new slavery system when they dont even care about us.
Hello, In Islam, education is very important. Men and women both are required to learn about Islam. Other than that, boys and girls need other types of education as well. If a man gets sick he needs to go to the doctors. If there are no doctors because noone had education, what will happen to the man? If a women is sick and has to go to the doctors what will happen to her. When people get extremely sick they stay in hospitals and it would be better if a male has a male nurse to bath or check him and it would be better for female nurse to bath and check a female patient. Engineers are important to make homes, roads, bridges, medical supply, etc. So these are just few examples, on why both girls and boys need education.
@@merida4321 No you are wrong stop worshipping this british made up education.
I do agree
I agree with karam minhas
The absolute prerequisite for any positive development is FREEDOM + PEACE + SECURITY.
None of it exists in this country. ( SECURITY does not apply to many who work for a better Afghanistan, particularly women ).
Islam destroys everything it touches.
What makes it funny is that what they are doing is actually against the teachings of Islam. Also who are those "scholars" that he mentioned because as a Muslim myself I don't think that he should believe those scholars over the literal teachings of prophet Muhammad (pbuh) because many of them interpret the qur'an and hadith as they like to support their political views and their kings which happened many times in history of Islam and other religions and that's probably what the Taliban is doing so they can rule over people with power and use religion as an excuse.
And the same goes for ISIS and alqaeda.
Haha and you are a cleric! Aren't you? Know the basics of Islam before claiming to be a muslim. Either you are a moderate muslim or an ignorant muslim who doesn't know that how to judge others.
Long story short: Men want power, not peace.
They are and hopefully they will do something about it soon.
Questioning them isn’t going to do jack 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Shooting them is better.
OK albert🤡🔫🔫
Neither did the war. The west has their behinds kicked
only one year in government, he is already good at dodging the questions. lol
Taking notes from White House press secretary
Let those people do what they want. We tried for 20 years. Is that not enough? Do you not see that this is who they are and what they want.
It's ironic situation for me
When some people died because of starvation in Afghanistan because of the frozen money some people fight for the women rights of education.
I mean the west are making people starving and you just want the girl to study as if they study the people of Afghanistan will solve all their problems in a blank of eye.
It's not the West responsibility.
The West use to spend billions of dollars because they wanted a non terrorist Afghanistan. They didn't want another 9/11.
It was a free money but the West doesn't want to pay anymore
@@abrammasa9132 your money is what in your pocket what's in other pockets is theirs not yours but maybe you couldn't understand that because you have the same mentality as your ancestors who stole the resources and lifes of other nations to make their prosperous west.
you know why, they went women for only one purpose.
that's what always says in the Quran that they are hypocrites
It's time to respect human rights, respect other religious beliefs, build an inclusive society that includes all minorities in government and to peacefully coexist in the region.
Good luck with that under an extremist Taliban regime
That's Free-speech and Freedom of Expression expert BBC hwore can't sit in front of him without covering her stupid brain 🤣😂
Respecting religious beliefs and respecting human rights don’t go hand in hand.
This would be hilarious if it wasn’t so tragic.
"When we came to power, there were a lot of problems". The problem was that you came to power.
The bigger problem would've been the corrupt Afghan government lmao.
Taliban are still better,whether you like it or not.
@@Tabish_Nooristani Better how? It seems that what he is blaming, and what's the real reason that they came to power so easily, is a deeply ingrained strict fundamentalist Islamic culture, especially among men. I wish all Afghan women could simply leave the country and let that culture die out.
@@Tabish_Nooristani I'm inclined to believe that the Taliban leaders are smart enough to realise that letting women go to school and work is critical to their country's economy, and perhaps even that they actually want to keep the promises they made, but they can't deliver if they can't get the masses on board. I wonder how hard they've tried, though.
Let them live and lead their country as they want,and focus on yours.
U can feel the pain in her voice...!!
This is messed up
Actually its in Pashtoons tribe culture that girls shouldn't go to school and educate, the questions is that why you relate this to some nonsense things like safety or religion, you have to consider and respect other tribes desires as well.
So much care for the girls. I like it. But we know that action speaks louder than word....
ya one can see the level of nudity, pornography, sexual objectification of women in the west
There’s no care they don’t want to give them freedom
Why is everyone acting surprised? Islam has never let women to get empowered!
Imagine living in a society where comedians are "cancelled" for making jokes in bad taste but terrorists are given platforms? You don't have too.... You're already there.
In what universe is this being given a platform to? This is not but a mere criticism, specially considering the negative atmosphere around Afghanistan in the west.
We're letting terrorists like Taliban members speak on our media and giving legitimacy to them. How is my criticism "mere"?
@@internationalaudio9702 the western media has been referencing the Taliban and the very governmental system of Afghanistan many times over. If they were simply not interested in this matter then, why all the commotion? Since they're so outspoken about it, an interview is far more civil than a biased monolog, isn't it?
Education come from experience in life not what people think is education for you. As everyone says we’re all different.
When you can’t read or write you miss out on a lot of life experiences.
A religeous education is worse than being uneducated
Who really cares🤷♂️ I don’t rather be more worried about are own people in the uk
Yep... that's how you spell all of this.
Is English your first language or is it the case that you don't care about grammar either?
@@fromireland8663 What's wrong with it?
@@WeasyMac "I don't rather be more worried..." ???? Does that look like correct grammar to you?
@@fromireland8663 Dude my first comment was sarcastic. Of course it is completely botched grammar...
Priorities people. Afghanistan needs:
- To formalise its power structure with military voting and a council. It should change its name to the Mujahideen Collective of Afghanistan, as it accurately reflects what it is and is much better for international press.
- It needs a constitution to bring back the rule of law.
- It needs some way or another to allow voices for reform while minimising the risk of revolt.
Once the nation is functional and united, we can move down our priority list (make one) to social change.
Bruh It is Islamic doctrines to change social fabrics would be to against Islamic fundamentalism and we all know Taliban and their guns won't allow such deviations from Islamic principles.
@@laknidubandara Islamic doctrines have no preferred government type with any caliphs available.
No Islamic principles need to be changed to do the important thing and make the government functional and the nation united.
@@UniDocs_Mahapushpa_Cyavana I am not Muslim but I am pretty sure you are misconstrued They absolutely do, to change the social climate to say it is fine for girls to attend schools presumably does go against Islamic fundamentalism.
@@UniDocs_Mahapushpa_Cyavana you do realize how this particular government came to power don't you? They ousted the previous government these are hardline Muslim you have been fighting for 20 years so they can impose strict sharia law in Afghanistan, you think they won't impose strict sharia law after they have come to power.
@@laknidubandara How are they going to stop private education anyway? That is so impractical to enforce, it cannot last long.
State schools going away is fine eventually as private (and religious) institutions can easily take their place.
Think in the real world.
💚❤ why BBC not focusing on what's happening to Muslims in India and China
The French, India have human right issues too. Not allowing women to wear what they want.
I just dnt get the madness of these people killings and stopping women from going to sch.
It's not your fault. you're brainwashed by the Western media.
Islam
What’s the point of questioning when they have totally different values to the west
What are the values of the West?? Plz share lol
@@Zam786 dress however you want gain capital at the expense of others the list goes on
@@Zam786 surely you cannot see how the west is totally different to the Middle Eastern culture the war of Afghanistan is proof western culture will never fit into middle eastern culture and to me that’s what makes us different and we should leave it as that
@@samsloan2526 Some things are objectively wrong, doesn't matter if it's from east culture or west culture.
e.g. refraining from education.
@@drprtk2904 no it’s just what we think is wrong and want them to live the way we live
Lesson from Afghanistan:
You can have good intentions, but when u interfere unnecessarily in others' affairs, you will mess it up.
Same can be said about the Taliban "inferring" in other rights like women, gays and minorities?
And the US didn't intfere "unnecessarily " in Afghanistan, it was because the Taliban harbored AL-Queda which lead to 9/11.
@@pythondre and the alqaeda got a safe place in afghanistan because US funded the mujahideens.
@@pythondre the US are the ones that were giving them weapons and supplies for decades so can you tell me why that was necessary? the US is the biggest arms dealer in all of Saudi Arabia, been that way since the 1980s lol
@@env0x We never gave Al-Queda any supplies. The Taliban didn't exist till after the Russian invasion... Another problem Russia caused.
Except that those good intentions are in reality bad 😈 intensions, just an excuse for crime.
Imagine being so insecure that you don't want women to be smarter than you 🤣
I'll stand by our mujahideen brothers until the end.
Truly it is the Taliban military who keep girls from school. "Religious" leaders don't have power to do that without the military. Martial law exists in AFG. The Taliban military does not hide the fact it has taken ownership of AFG women and has the power to restrict and eliminate women.
Islam is pro-pedophile and anti-science. Of course they don't want girls to be educated.
World's most peaceful religion, indeed!
They are twisting the words of their book. They are followers pf wahabbism. It is the root cause of all this taliban control over basic rights and common sense.
In ISLAM Education is Mandatory for all Men and Women
At least they are working towards it
Thank goodness for Britain. As an American, I want to know more about the rest of the world but our relationship with other countries is so bipolar. Some countries love us, and some hate us. You're u likely to get this kind of interview if it was an American reporter.
Is the reporter British?
We could say the same for USA, we love some countries ,and others, we don't 😁
That applies for every country.
That's Free-speech and Freedom of Expression expert BBC hwore can't sit in front of him without covering her stupid brain 🤣😂
No country loves America. We love the music and movies though
@@danielavalcheva7611 Not every country is a racist greedy war machine
(1:05) Education in our country is [democratic?] decided by the people and the body of religious scholars.
(2:35) I don't think this will affect our relationship with the world an the US.
(3:38) ...how are you going to prevent any attacks on America or its allies [performed by drone strikes] ?!?
These questions that were asked by the correspondent are the same questions that were asked in other media, without change! These questions come from the media agenda and correspondence is only a tool used to utter these questions.
@@o.cchannel6299 Even though these questions were only asked for propaganda purposes, the answers nicely showed that the Afghans seem to have a democratic system, but with a very different constitution than some people are used to.
🎀She asked some really brillant questions. 🎀
🎀I’ve never understood the need for such excessive control, over people. Especially when it comes to the education of women and girls. Educating everyone improves the whole of society. 🎀
These questions that were asked by the correspondent are the same questions that were asked in other media, without change! These questions come from the media agenda and correspondence is only a tool used to utter these questions.
each socity has laws ..
like in Afghanistan women arent allowed to were mini dresses .. while in Europe women are allowed to expose their body parts .
ur law is based on " What people wants " , Afghanistan law is based on " God"s law" .
its very simple if u just think out of the box that there are many cultures other than western cultures ... i find western culture and society morals so backward .. compared to our Islamic Morality foundations .
That's Free-speech and Freedom of Expression expert BBC hwore can't sit in front of him without covering her stupid brain 🤣😂
By the time they're done with their ideologies, the country would be back to stone age
So called religious scholars. It is necessary for every man and woman to get education in Islam
They need George Bush and Obama to fund the girl school. Send the Taliban to Guyana. Guyana has about 50% of Taliban families.
There is a huge difference between culture and religion they are just following their culture not Islam ,Islam is a really bold ,civilized and modern religion and the right way of living is Islam. but the culture that are human made are not correct in Pakistan,India ,and Afghanistan these people are stuck with Thier cultures .
Same things are happening in the Middle East too all that honor killings and stuff these things existed before Islam too and people are still practicing it even after Islam
read the nisa verses and you''ll understand how ''modern'' is islam lol
Nisa, Ayat 34-35) in KURAN === Men are the protec-tors and maintainers of women because Allah has made one of them excel over the other, and because they spend out of their possessions (to support them). Thus righteous women are obedient and guard the rights of men in their absence under Allah's protection.58 As for women of whom you fear rebellion, admonish them, and remain apart from them in beds, and BEAT them.Then if they obey you, do not seek ways to harm them
@@21erkhan21 sahih bukhari's tafsir :
Men are in charge of women by [right of] what Allah has given one over the other and what they spend [for maintenance] from their wealth. So righteous women are devoutly obedient, guarding in [the husband’s] absence what Allah would have them guard. But those [wives] from whom you fear arrogance - [first] advise them; [then if they persist], forsake them in bed; and [finally], strike them. But if they obey you [once more], seek no means against them. Indeed, Allah is ever Exalted and Grand.
Yusuf ali:
Men are the protectors and maintainers of women, because Allah has given the one more (strength) than the other, and because they support them from their means. Therefore the righteous women are devoutly obedient, and guard in (the husband’s) absence what Allah would have them guard. As to those women on whose part ye fear disloyalty and ill-conduct, admonish them (first), (Next), refuse to share their beds, (And last) beat them (lightly); but if they return to obedience, seek not against them Means (of annoyance): For Allah is Most High, great (above you all).
Of course you have to use the tafsir that has words such as: BEAT,ADMONISH etc. To support your view. And yet you prove nothing.
@@21erkhan21 you're actually right this is how modern Muslims practice Islam they follow the Quran literally
You can't just read the Quran and follow what it says literally, this is why "Tafsirs" exist because the Quran can easily be misunderstood
RIP young lady