15 GENIUS Ancient Siege Weapons

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 17 янв 2025

Комментарии • 454

  • @vincentblair4019
    @vincentblair4019 3 года назад +240

    Archimedes was the greatest mathematician and engineer of the ancient world. It's the combination of the two that truly set him apart. He was SO CLOSE to inventing calculus as well, but he was killed by a Roman foot soldier during the siege of Syracuse even though they had been ordered not to harm him..

    • @midosch7639
      @midosch7639 3 года назад +24

      This soldier surely got crucified for killing ancient Einstein

    • @sameerthakur720
      @sameerthakur720 3 года назад +48

      @@midosch7639 The soldier followed orders.
      They had been instructed to ask, "What is your name?" in Greek (though most common legionaries did not know Greek).
      The soldier asked the question to Archimedes. Archimedes (busy with his work) said, "Don't disturb me." in Greek.
      The soldier thought his name was "Dontdisturbme" and killed him.

    • @midosch7639
      @midosch7639 3 года назад +8

      @@sameerthakur720 oh damn such a bad luck :(

    • @WE-WUZZING-KANGS-N-SHEEOYT
      @WE-WUZZING-KANGS-N-SHEEOYT 3 года назад +4

      Pos we would have better mathematical instruments by now.. Smh😠

    • @sudhamishra6753
      @sudhamishra6753 3 года назад

      False

  • @Aundrich
    @Aundrich 4 года назад +397

    Hey! It's the simple history dude! Lol

    • @sharlondelosreyes2842
      @sharlondelosreyes2842 4 года назад +31

      How many channels do this guy have... Hahahahahaha

    • @louisonggo1147
      @louisonggo1147 3 года назад +17

      Yeah I was wondering why his voice was so farmiliar

    • @louisonggo1147
      @louisonggo1147 3 года назад +9

      How many channels does this guy need

    • @eacio4548
      @eacio4548 3 года назад +6

      Cool i the voice is familiar

    • @minnotmax65
      @minnotmax65 3 года назад +2

      I think so

  • @robhicks2117
    @robhicks2117 3 года назад +29

    Necessity is the mother of invention.

  • @andrew3203
    @andrew3203 3 года назад +68

    Archimedes' death ray wasn't a simple mirror. Even concave mirrors would lack the focus and range to track and lit up ships at a distance. He most likely used focus lenses, much like a telescope, on movable gears. Seeing the Mythbusters attempting to replicate that with a hundreds kids holding mirrors was quite funny though.

    • @Rig0r_M0rtis
      @Rig0r_M0rtis 2 года назад +8

      They did not have technology to create a lens that big - concave metal mirrors are the most likely.

    • @dominiccassidy9708
      @dominiccassidy9708 2 года назад +7

      Archimedes did not invent a death ray. it's a total myth

    • @aaroncapricorn5867
      @aaroncapricorn5867 2 года назад +3

      i wouldnt bother watching mythbusters. those fools won't know anything and neither till we until we go back in time and see every little meticulous detail. these documentaries are good enough

    • @raymondready7496
      @raymondready7496 Год назад +1

      I've read that it was hundreds of mirrors held and aimed at one point. Multiplying the suns reflection.

    • @doowappable
      @doowappable Год назад +1

      Even then theres no way to make a ship burn with that. It needs a still point, not a ship that goes up and down and back and forth. If you ever used a lens to make a fire you would know that it doesnt burn instantly, it needs to be exactly right on focus and then it still takes a bit. Even if that works once like a miracle, it would never work multiple times.
      If they ever had this device as the legend has it, it would probably be more blinding than doing any damage.

  • @giantdad1661
    @giantdad1661 2 года назад +43

    Archimedes was that one guy who invented weird things that were surprisingly effective.

    • @jomangeee
      @jomangeee 2 года назад

      urbam myth! the claw of my azz

    • @jimmyohara2601
      @jimmyohara2601 Год назад +1

      What is weird about anything being effective ?? Maybe your thoughts are 😐🤐.

    • @giantdad1661
      @giantdad1661 Год назад +6

      @@jimmyohara2601 OH I'm sorry I didn't create a hammer that lifted ships out of the fucking ocean and drop them back down.

  • @watchthe1369
    @watchthe1369 3 года назад +25

    Limestone is a popular building material. Vinegar can dissolve limestone, the Beotian Flame thrower opened up cracks to allow it inside the wall.

  • @davidodonovan1699
    @davidodonovan1699 2 года назад +7

    Thank you very much for this information. I had heard of most of these things, but it's very good to have them all together in one quick video like this. Thank you very much. Well done sir. God bless you.

  • @marioacevedo5077
    @marioacevedo5077 3 года назад +29

    The last siege tower used in combat was by the US Army in WW2 to re-capture Fort Drum from the Japanese in Manila Bay.

    • @donHooligan
      @donHooligan 2 года назад

      everything becomes illegal right after the USA gets away with doing it.
      60 million indigenous taught Hitler how to kill 6.

    • @danielciocilteu3545
      @danielciocilteu3545 2 месяца назад

      How do you know? Were you there?

    • @ckl9390
      @ckl9390 Месяц назад

      @@danielciocilteu3545 Such actions would have had records. Not just someone recording "oh we did this" but everything from the cost of materials to the work-hour records for the engineers who did the construction.

  • @josiahscarrmusic6750
    @josiahscarrmusic6750 3 года назад +11

    This video was very interesting there needs to be more of these

  • @kingghidorah102
    @kingghidorah102 4 года назад +72

    Wait a minute, i think i know this voice, IT'S THE SIMPLEHISTORY DUDE..!!! 😲😲

  • @m1herrmann160
    @m1herrmann160 4 года назад +7

    Love the show!!

  • @dariuscommergnat6313
    @dariuscommergnat6313 2 года назад +5

    Wow, that was a really good video,
    I really needed this video because I need to do some essay about these siege artilleries.
    Thank you Top fives!

  • @jamescharlesbutlerjr5519
    @jamescharlesbutlerjr5519 2 года назад +1

    Ancient technology is awesome very amazing ancient tech and weapons.

  • @pranit_33xa91
    @pranit_33xa91 3 года назад +10

    When I was a kid I thought that the battering ram mentioned in the books used to be a live or dead ram - goat thrown at the gates of fortresses.

    • @eziokill9112
      @eziokill9112 3 года назад

      Da mmm

    • @fullarmordiscernment2842
      @fullarmordiscernment2842 3 года назад +2

      Same here, lol. I used to imagine a goat running full speed into a wooden city gate...
      It's all in the name, right?

    • @majorgear1021
      @majorgear1021 3 года назад +2

      then you saw Braveheart and realized the truth.
      Hey, I used to think Molotov cocktails were called Mazeltov cocktails until a Jewish friend corrected me.

  • @caturbayu406
    @caturbayu406 2 года назад +14

    I learned all these technologies from the game AOE II 😅

  • @chrisrnt2548
    @chrisrnt2548 4 года назад +17

    As early as 17th) but as a Greek I m happy hearing almost entirely about Greek warfare😂

  • @edgardolorenzo1797
    @edgardolorenzo1797 4 года назад +3

    Great vid..thanks!

  • @yasiluck5056
    @yasiluck5056 3 года назад +2

    I hope everyone reading this is in good spirits and know that someone loves you .

  • @republicofnoobs7437
    @republicofnoobs7437 2 года назад +1

    at 16:18 this is Atkins hall in Cork Ireland, it used to be a sanaturium, now it is a rather nice appartment complex, I used to live there :)

  • @bigseven8227
    @bigseven8227 Год назад +1

    0:47 The fact that people nowadays still don't know exactly how the Greek Fire was made goes to show how excellent their military was at keeping top secrets.

  • @Ccc.9125
    @Ccc.9125 9 месяцев назад

    Really big fan of simple history and awesome voice 😊😄.

  • @adrianaslund8605
    @adrianaslund8605 2 года назад +3

    Catapults are torsion engines and not counterweight though. So trebuchets aren't really catapults. They use the stored springy energy of coils of hair to launch projectiles.

  • @Dont_cry_my_guy
    @Dont_cry_my_guy 2 года назад +1

    The narrator sounds like Charlie Sheen and I cant unhear it

  • @thisiscrackedbro3567
    @thisiscrackedbro3567 2 года назад +5

    Fun fact here in Serbia we call petarde firecrackers

  • @twilightparanormalresearch186
    @twilightparanormalresearch186 11 месяцев назад +1

    Having studied ancient warfare, I’m never surprised at the weapons men create to kill each othet

  • @wren7195
    @wren7195 Год назад +10

    The hand powered trebuchets most certainly evolved from staff slings. Despite the general depiction, I fully believe that the sling David used against Goliath, and indeed all shepherds used in their vocation, were simple thong slings fitted onto the ends of their shepherd staves as opposed to a hand sling. Indeed, the Greeks consistently used staff slings (or "one man trebuchets" to help you visualize it) as part of their missile barrages during engagements.
    Hand slings, although indeed formidable, are far outpowered by staff slings, and it would take nothing for a shepherd to use that instead. It's incredible how much a simple misunderstanding of what was common for a time can shape a tale thousands of years old into something other than it was.

  • @donovandelaney3171
    @donovandelaney3171 Год назад +2

    All hail Caesar!!

  •  4 года назад +33

    Several of these are not ancient, not siege weapons, or even neither -starting with the first one, greek fire- but the video is interesting nonetheless.

    • @kieranfogarty778
      @kieranfogarty778 4 года назад +1

      Also the Romans managed to take Syracuse

    • @Itsyrm8
      @Itsyrm8 3 года назад +2

      Liquid fire

  • @ederose-no1nz
    @ederose-no1nz 7 дней назад

    Very. Cool😊

  • @OriginalCovfefe
    @OriginalCovfefe Год назад +1

    Simple History man!

  • @misterivandespabiladeras1076
    @misterivandespabiladeras1076 3 года назад +3

    The first one you mentioned was the modern day flamethrower and they love the trebuchet I love

  • @RonaldTrumpOfficial
    @RonaldTrumpOfficial 3 года назад +3

    3:06
    Is about ballista
    *continues to show Scorpio firing*

    • @godisforever7263
      @godisforever7263 3 года назад +3

      I mean they are in the ballista category so that counts I guess
      And crossbows are also mini ballista.

  • @dreamguardian8320
    @dreamguardian8320 3 года назад +54

    I've never even hear of the Claw of Archimedes, the Exploding Mill Wheel, and Archimedes' Death Ray, until now.
    That prehistoric Flame Thrower was cool to discover and learn.
    Scary how they used the Plague as a weapon. I hope people won't find a way to turn Covid-19 into a weapon.
    Greek Fire truly is a mystery, it makes me want to discover if it was truly made in Greece or why they called it Greek Fire. But hearing how dangerous it was, perhaps it's better that it remains undiscovered and a secret, for the safety everyone. The same goes for all the other ancient siege weapons.

    • @sameerthakur720
      @sameerthakur720 3 года назад +3

      Turn Covid into a weapon. Many communist countries have had bio-warfare programs. The Chinese had their premier Virus research facility at Wuhan. They have been researching Coronaviruses at least since 2005.
      Put two and two together.

    • @valkyviktor3228
      @valkyviktor3228 3 года назад +4

      @@sameerthakur720 At least we now trying to fight back and have a staging ground against Covid, imagine Resident Evil game turn true and we have deadly undead instead of this

    • @johnscanlon2598
      @johnscanlon2598 3 года назад +5

      COVID already is a weapon

    • @tweakfreq1982
      @tweakfreq1982 2 года назад +1

      Napalm was the closest modern man has come to equal Greek fire

    • @wesleyhobbs2332
      @wesleyhobbs2332 Год назад +1

      @@tweakfreq1982 And Napalm is far superior to Greek fire.

  • @SherriRichLifeJohnson
    @SherriRichLifeJohnson 4 года назад +1

    👍😀 great video

  • @bluelionsage99
    @bluelionsage99 2 года назад +4

    The sea claw device seems like it is a myth rather than a reality. It could only reach a little past the walls and there would be little reason for a galley to be cruising just over the submerged rocks right next to the walls. The ship cranes just did not have sufficient range to be an issue. Yeah, supposed those rising boarding ramps were in use but it shouldn't take long to figure out where to avoid the cranes.

  • @eaxamed246
    @eaxamed246 2 года назад +1

    Ancient war is very cool

  • @greenwave819
    @greenwave819 2 года назад +1

    as a city defender, TY for circumvalation!!

  • @mrrice63
    @mrrice63 3 года назад +7

    This is simple history’s voice

  • @leeedsonetwo
    @leeedsonetwo 3 года назад +5

    hoisted by your own Petard refers to sailors being hanged by use of the rope that held up their trousers which was called a petard.

    • @robotniqueee
      @robotniqueee 2 года назад

      This is entirely wrong.

    • @leeedsonetwo
      @leeedsonetwo 2 года назад

      @@robotniqueee It is what I had heard and fits the facts. SO what is your explanation.

  • @11_damaiteguhs.t_ximipa83
    @11_damaiteguhs.t_ximipa83 3 года назад +10

    Archimedes is a real madlad.

  • @TheIceThorn
    @TheIceThorn 3 года назад +11

    Archimedes: because being nerd always had it's advantages. Since ever knowledge has always meant power.

  • @magnussoevgaard8091
    @magnussoevgaard8091 4 года назад +2

    Awesome

  • @sadcharles4845
    @sadcharles4845 3 года назад +2

    I love history

  • @trevorbourke3627
    @trevorbourke3627 5 месяцев назад +1

    the mithbusters made tested them all and they did what they were supposed to do.

  • @donquijote7463
    @donquijote7463 2 года назад +1

    DAVID : HOLD MY BEER.

  • @TenChronicles
    @TenChronicles 3 месяца назад

    18:21 - "The fact that they tested the Archimedes death ray in modern times and it actually worked is mind-blowing

  • @jyzlslazyzyhc3286
    @jyzlslazyzyhc3286 4 года назад +12

    Top Five:15 genius ancient saige weapons

  • @Irishfrasa
    @Irishfrasa 3 года назад +23

    People up until the 20th century: there's just no way we can comprehend the complicated engineering of the ballista. We aren't caught up.
    The ballista: BIG SLINGSHOT

  • @MikeBanks2003
    @MikeBanks2003 4 года назад +7

    The big and small trebuchet were on wheels or on rails--it increased the range by about a third, and stopped the machine wrecking itself.
    ,

    • @renahernandez5120
      @renahernandez5120 4 года назад +1

      War..a guy thing.

    • @MikeBanks2003
      @MikeBanks2003 4 года назад

      @@renahernandez5120 Nope--just applied physics. Action and reaction are equal and opposite--

    • @MikeBanks2003
      @MikeBanks2003 4 года назад

      @@renahernandez5120 Have you not heard of Queen Hatshepsut?

  • @fernandes5986
    @fernandes5986 3 года назад +5

    Very good, concise and informative. Your calm voice also helps delivering the message. I already subscribed. Btw what's the music on background?

  • @alandemir568
    @alandemir568 3 года назад +1

    Anyone know the name of the site around 12:06 , first shot of "circumvallation"?

  • @ozzylepunknown551
    @ozzylepunknown551 2 года назад +3

    KEEP IN MIND: there were no tutorial videos online for these

  • @Itsyrm8
    @Itsyrm8 3 года назад +6

    Caltrops were used by greeks against charging persian elephants

  • @ThunderMeow-r1q
    @ThunderMeow-r1q 4 года назад +4

    Archimedes gotta be time traveler

  • @TheBubblybobby
    @TheBubblybobby 4 года назад +1

    Wow the death Ray !

  • @bigbob1699
    @bigbob1699 4 года назад +6

    So many wars and battles we know so little of .

  • @hii7872
    @hii7872 4 года назад +3

    Love it

  • @karumovesV
    @karumovesV 3 года назад +10

    They recreated that Death Ray where hundreds of children carrying a mirror as large as them and then pointing refracted lights from the mirror in the same direction

  • @trustjesusoursavior4179
    @trustjesusoursavior4179 4 года назад +3

    Ballista is a giant slingshot

  • @2ndamendmentsupporter777
    @2ndamendmentsupporter777 3 года назад +2

    So in 420 dudes were blazing in war

  • @erikr968
    @erikr968 2 года назад +15

    Siege towers were not used to put soldiers onto the walls (with some very rare exceptions). Ditches, uneven ground and other defenses would make it impossible to drag such huge structures close enough to the walls. They were simply platforms for archers enabling them to shoot down at the defenders.

    • @davefellhoelter1343
      @davefellhoelter1343 Год назад +1

      Right? a Rope! and Tug? and Down she Goes! Had to stay out of that Range! maybe a ramp if the opertunity was there, but these dudes Lived and Died with their Smarts!

    • @riccardomulazzani7436
      @riccardomulazzani7436 Год назад

      You're wrong man...
      There are several ancient documents and images confirming...
      The siege tower or mobile tower is a war machine used to reach the defensive walls of a city or fortress during a siege.
      The siege towers were made of wood, pulled by oxen and with some walls covered with skins to protect themselves from enemy missiles. Inside there were several floors connected to each other with stairs. At the top there was a "drawbridge" which allowed access to the walls.[1] They had a square base and to ensure they were sufficiently stable, not only did they narrow in height, but the area of ​​the upper platform was equal to 1/5 of the base. They could reach considerable heights, as happened during the campaigns of Alexander the Great where one of these reached the measurement of 120 cubits equal to 53 meters. In Roman times we know that in Masada in 74, one of 60 cubits was built, equal to about 26 meters, also equipped with catapults, ballistae and a large ram.
      Greetings.

  • @1wor1d
    @1wor1d 3 года назад +27

    Archimedes Death Ray has many factors that make it unlikely to be true. Firstly it was never used again, even though many people were needed
    to pull off this strategy so therefore new how to use or make it, also the equipment to do it was not destroyed. Historians, scientists engineers
    have all tried to re-create the Death Ray using technology available at the time, but at best all they can achieve is giving a sailor a nice suntan!!

    • @wankawanka3053
      @wankawanka3053 2 года назад +3

      Nope they actually have recreated it

    • @muhtasimmustafiz7162
      @muhtasimmustafiz7162 Год назад +1

      @@wankawanka3053 Mythbusters proved it was impossible. Can you link where they did prove it?

  • @mikeropaynus410
    @mikeropaynus410 3 года назад +3

    They set water on fire!

  • @alinvornicu7734
    @alinvornicu7734 3 года назад +1

    Archimedes invents death ray.
    Sun: Bye!

  • @ArishVanNikon
    @ArishVanNikon 2 года назад +2

    Correction: The Counterweight Trebuchet was also invented in China in the 4th century BC

  • @reichtangle4146
    @reichtangle4146 2 года назад +1

    Hi Simple History

  • @seanfoltz7645
    @seanfoltz7645 Год назад +2

    You used a screen scrape of Myth Busters proving the death ray didn't work as evidence of it working.

  • @hundun5604
    @hundun5604 2 года назад +14

    Caltrops, the simplest and most dangerous of all of them. That's because of the barbs. Hard to get loose without losing your feet. Especially in those times.
    Patards are still being used in IED's today.
    Btw, for those 'claws' you need huge counterweights to lift a ship out of the water, a very strong grip and beam, and be able to rotate. I've to see it before I believe it. Same goes for the "death ray". Back then, they didn't have mirrors. Anyway, interesting video. Thanks!

    • @DIREWOLFx75
      @DIREWOLFx75 2 года назад +3

      "Back then, they didn't have mirrors."
      Yes they did. First known mirror was from 6k BC or something.
      "Btw, for those 'claws'"
      My guess is that they exploited leverage far more than the vast majority of modern guesswork shows.
      I can come up with several options that should work at the very least. And if they placed them in optimal positions, they wouldn't need that many for them to be as effective as written, especially as they probably also surprised the enemy.

  • @KCKingdomCreateGreatTrekAgain
    @KCKingdomCreateGreatTrekAgain 2 года назад +2

    I remember siege towers from watching the mysterious cities of gold.

  • @thax321
    @thax321 2 года назад +3

    Using an image of a hoplite phalanx from 500 BC when talking about Byzantine, Greek, fire....classic.

  • @MrHide-ty1qk
    @MrHide-ty1qk 4 года назад +7

    Hey this voice is familiar from simple history i subscribe on that channel

  • @sneakyturtle1117
    @sneakyturtle1117 3 года назад +21

    This sounds like simple history's voice....
    WAIT IT IS!

  • @tektoastium7241
    @tektoastium7241 Год назад +2

    The battering ram really wasn't so genius. Testaments to siege warfare suggest that the battering ram was tried oftentimes just in case the enemy had forgotten to get a strong door for their fortress.
    And contrary to popular belief, siege towers were not often used to reach castle walls. They were instead used as an elevated firing platform for archers, and had the stunning speed of 1.25 meters per hour.
    I argue that the most important siege weapon was the shovel. Sieges did not demand the skill of knights, they demanded the skill of engineers. Things like trebuchets and circumvallations could not be made without the skill of siege engineers in one's attacking force, and it could take months to build a single trebuchet.

  • @alphawolffestudios1169
    @alphawolffestudios1169 3 года назад +6

    Myth busters tried recreating number 1 but came to the conclusion it wasn’t possible with modern engineering

    • @PeansINbetweens
      @PeansINbetweens 3 года назад

      finally someone that mentioned it! yeap proved even with modern tech its useless

  • @o.k.productions5202
    @o.k.productions5202 4 года назад +11

    #5, if you can’t beat a wall, build a wall.

  • @LongTail8443
    @LongTail8443 2 года назад +2

    Nah, English longbow is the best old world weapon in my opinion. People still use them for hunting even today, and it's English, it's badass, mate.

    • @TheT3MK4
      @TheT3MK4 2 года назад

      thats not even ancient era weapons longbow is from medieval era.

    • @amkhjogr5062
      @amkhjogr5062 Год назад

      The English longbow was effective only in that it was inexpensive and "easy" to make and when unstrung, doubled as a staff.
      It had less range and power that the recurve bow - and was too large to be used on horseback.
      As a "projectile weapon" is was very much inferior to the recurve bow.
      It is also a lesser weapon to the flatbow (Nth America) which is similar part from the "ends" (which do not taper - therefore adding just that little more tension).
      The main advantage of these masses ranks of longbow archers was not only in the bow - it was essentially in the men themselves - they were also armed with long knives and were more than effective as light infantry - especially effective against heavily armoured "knights" who'd been de-horsed (this was the real decider at Agincourt).

  • @Flankgotnolife
    @Flankgotnolife 4 года назад +1

    Coooool

  • @spectrerevenant7655
    @spectrerevenant7655 3 года назад +2

    I love to play strong hold crusader 😎😍

  • @Bloomio95
    @Bloomio95 2 года назад

    12:09 where is this place?

  • @ericwilliams1659
    @ericwilliams1659 2 года назад

    The thumbnail picture? When in the video was that?

  • @michaelfox2433
    @michaelfox2433 3 года назад +2

    What a cool and interesting video on an interesting topic, thx.

  • @IIIAnchani
    @IIIAnchani 3 года назад +1

    2:25 look closely to the longbowman on the right with the flaming arrow.
    [when you get friendzoned by your crush]

  • @wtfmanicanthaveaname
    @wtfmanicanthaveaname 8 месяцев назад

    Interesting, greek fire was obviously the inspiration for the "Wildfire" in Game of Thrones.

    • @7ThePrimagen
      @7ThePrimagen 8 месяцев назад

      If I remember much like the painting
      There was very lil info
      But I think somebody wanted to make a handheld version of it for normal troops
      The fuckin Greeks were about to set tranches ablaze a couple centuries before the Germans XD

  • @aaronharper1209
    @aaronharper1209 3 года назад +4

    I wonder how strong a spring loaded battering ram would have been.

    • @rhuonaChanel
      @rhuonaChanel 2 года назад +1

      Would have needed a really large spring and maybe some gears. Maybe a leaf spring design might be simpler. This is definitely an interesting idea

  • @doobie9550
    @doobie9550 3 года назад

    This is the 2nd video I've seen from this channel and both are top 15 videos on a channel called top fives. What am I missing here?

  • @robloxandgachalifemobileta9976
    @robloxandgachalifemobileta9976 3 года назад +3

    The greek fire was the first flamethrower cuz it shoots fire like a flamethrower

  • @amadomarceseo3022
    @amadomarceseo3022 4 года назад +6

    Heeeeeeey simple history what's up man

  • @محمد-س1ل2ص
    @محمد-س1ل2ص 4 года назад +6

    Damn🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

    • @-buser
      @-buser 4 года назад

      420bc blaze it

  • @AKSnowbat907
    @AKSnowbat907 9 месяцев назад

    How was that ancient sailing ship in the beginning moving with its sails closed?

    • @zachmoyer1849
      @zachmoyer1849 8 месяцев назад

      probably has an engine now or is being moved by a tug which could be that dingy you see

  • @forzafiori9363
    @forzafiori9363 Год назад +1

    So many issues with this post. The timeframe described is far from "Ancient" (which is a specific historical term used to refer to a time period which, at least in western history, took place prior to the Classical era, or at most, includes the Classical era and ends with the start of the middle ages) - Explosives and Trebuchets are from the Renaissance and later. Circumvallation is not a "weapon", but a strategy of conducting a seige. Claiming it is a "weapon" would be like claiming encirclement or a feint is a "weapon". Finally, both Aristotle's Claw and Archimede's Mirror are almost certainly fake. They have been investigated multiple times, and never shown to have worked. Of the 15 "ancient seige weapons", over 1/3 don't actually fit the category, and they couldn't even bother to make all 15 at least be weapons.

  • @mariaslamat4999
    @mariaslamat4999 2 года назад

    Can someone tell me what was the siege weapon in the thumbnail was?

  • @peterhoulis1184
    @peterhoulis1184 3 года назад

    Interesting

  • @_MaxHeadroom_
    @_MaxHeadroom_ 6 месяцев назад

    The name of the chapter for "The Claw of Archemedes" has a typo it says The Claw of Aristotle

  • @connerfondo2020
    @connerfondo2020 3 года назад +1

    The thumbnail is false cuz I can see signs and a street light

  • @ferencszathmary9689
    @ferencszathmary9689 Год назад

    Nice video. However, don't forget to double your English system with Metric equivalent. Thanks.

  • @mordechaimandel8118
    @mordechaimandel8118 3 года назад +2

    Rome, Rome, Rome. It's all fucking Rome!

    • @TheBlackjack54
      @TheBlackjack54 2 года назад

      Most of these are Greek? Some Syracuse too

  • @gs7256
    @gs7256 3 года назад +9

    In other words:!!!
    Greeks invented first the majority of these things…
    I wonder really..
    If these people were United and not fighting each other, what would have been…
    I believe that by far Greeks are the most smart, and they offered the biggest in human history in every aspect if life..Not only in war, but in piece, in mind, in sciences, in everything..everything we value today comes from them..
    Huge respect..
    We owe them everything…

    • @papasfritasduras
      @papasfritasduras 3 года назад +1

      Read "The Red Queen's Race" a Sicence Fiction short story from Isaac Asimov.

    • @tweakfreq1982
      @tweakfreq1982 2 года назад

      And as all things end, we can thank the romans

  • @anyoneanywhere8212
    @anyoneanywhere8212 4 года назад +3

    Onager spam ALWAYS wins. No exceptions.

  • @paulozaurusrex2719
    @paulozaurusrex2719 2 года назад +1

    Please research more🙏

  • @jayav1738
    @jayav1738 3 года назад +1

    There are many techniques used in Indian sub continent not mentioned here

    • @mrvn000
      @mrvn000 3 года назад

      Make your own channel and coment it.