Technically I think in the Yukon, it might change a bit as DJ wouldn’t cry, and his eyes wouldn’t be glued shut. He might’ve been able to find Bridgette that way?
As DJ's strongest soldier this is now my canon version of World Tour haha. This was excellent and I love all the thought you put into these. Great work as always.
Apparently Noah was originally supposed to be in Heather’s alliance as the ‘Brains’ of the group and he actually would of made it to the merge, so WHAT IF Noah stayed and was apart of Heather’s Alliance?
Really good video as per usual! I look forward to your What If's on the Reboot and I think a good suggestion for the 2nd Reboot Season could be "What if The original Teams were kept?" The thought process behind this was since Reboot S1 and 2 are essentially a full season I thought of how many dynamics would change with the same teams. For example, Caleb wouldn't have his alliance with Priya and potentially join Julia's and MK's counter alliance against Bowie, Emma can have a rekindled friendship with Bowie and whether or not he feels the same or uses her for a vote is up in the air and I actually think the rivalry with Nichelle and Julia could be expounded on now that their still on the same team. There are other ideas but this is more or less a suggestion like my 'What IF: Lindsay won the Paris Tiebreaker' prompt. Regardless, hope this message finds you well and looking forward to the next one!
I’d like to argue that you should’ve started this at episode 4. The only reason why Bridgette was forgotten about by team victory was because DJ was crying about the animal curse to look out for her. I feel like in this reality, team victory potentially could’ve not lost that challenge
DJ's eyes froze from tears because the cold reminded him of his mom's freezer the animal curse being removed would just change the resulting baby seal he kicked, not the eyes being frozen (plus even if he didn't, Team Victory would still lose since they wouldn't be able to quickly get Bridgette off the pole)
what a story, I'm not really a fan of DJ but he really shined in this alternate history I loved his relationships with all the characters, his anger with Duncan and especially the curious relationship with Blainley, I would have liked them to end better, but it was still good to see I imagine you already have many suggestions, but I wanted to suggest What would happen if Drama Island were men vs women?
Really like this one. I was really worried going into this, since I thought DJ was gonna get the CURSE of becoming a support character. Thankfully, that didn’t happen and he actually got to do a lot more than I thought he would, mainly with Alejandro and Blaineley. I don’t have a whole lot to say here, since it did feel a bit similar to the original, but I think that’s fine. Only complaint is Owen has still not made Merge #JusticeForOwen Time to dump ideas: TDI: What If Eva won immunity? TDA: What If Leshawna didn’t trash talk? TDWT: What If Beth won the Aftermath challenge? TDROTI: What If Jo and Scott didn’t swap? TDAS: What If Sam didn’t steal pancakes? TDPI: What If Amy and Sammy didn’t burst the balloon? TDRR: What If Leshawna and Tyler were the Reality TV Pros? TDI Reboot 1: What If MK didn’t slip up? TDI Reboot 2: What If Nichelle didn’t quit? DC 1: What If Gabby and Fiora didn’t swap? DC 2: What If Aiden got poisoned? DCAS (when it finishes): What If Jake and James didn’t have an argument?
A Disventure Camp RUclipsr, _alexa_, has actually done videos on your suggestions for seasons 1 and 2 (though the season 2 one is slightly different, as it’s what if Aiden got poisoned). I recommend checking them out, they’re good vids
@@TheGodIvy I was thinking for it to work is instead of James having to poison Aiden, Yul would do it, and I don’t see how he couldn’t poison Aiden, even without James help, since Aiden is known to be pretty oblivious.
@@LightningvsLightningthen word the title differently, thats part of how these would play out. If it was just "Yul didnt get poisoned" then you can imagine literally anything happening, but if it was something along the lines of "what if Aiden got poisoned" then you could do it
What If: Everyone returned for World Tour (22 OG Cast Members + Alejandro and Sierra) I just edited it to explain how it may work Edit: My YT Notifications go, BOOM BOOM- Edit #2: There would probably be no non-elimination episodes, other than episode 1 because its a 2 parter, Duncan quitting doesn't really matter since he returns in episode 13 anyway, there are 6 Non-elimination episodes, so far we have 21 eliminations with 24 contestents if we count the double elimination in China, after that just add a double elimination somewhere in the first half of the season, or just don't let Duncan rejoin the game O_o, and we can still squeeze in aftermaths here if we exclude Blainely from the season because tbh who would miss her
As always, a very entertaining video. I'm not a big fan of DJ but it was nice to see him be more of a character with a plot and not a character who was only there to make a unnfunny running gag. I have two ideas for more WT What if. What if the teams were formed like in ROTI? What would happen if Geoff didn't make the search team? (Everyone would be in WT and the reward challenges would now be elimination challenges) But I think those would take too much time but hey, they are just suggestions. Another one I have thought about for a while but I wouldn't know how to justify it. What if the Cast of Pahkitew and ROTI were swapped, By this I mean that the Cast of Pahkitew would participate in season 4 and some in season 5 while the Cast of ROTI would compete in season 6. I like this idea since I think it could change a lot of things but I honestly wouldn't know how to justify it other than that in an alternative universe the Cast of Pahkitew and ROTI change ages or something like that. I also wouldn't know whether to leave them with the same teams or not since the team methods are not the same, but whatever, I don't think you're ever going to do that since it's somewhat complicated and kinda weird. See you in the next video.
Wanted to try suggesting a What If, and the idea I landed on was: "What if Heather swapped places with Sadie in Island?" Maybe she gets sick of dealing with certain teammates (Leshawna) early, or maybe she realizes that if Izzy beats her to switching, that her team will be saddled with the useless besties. Either way, she decides it's better to join the Bass. As the main villain of the season, a major shift like that would be sure to change a whole lot. Who would she make allies with? Would she butt heads with Courtney worse than she did with Gwen? How would her interactions with the Gophers change? Actually, how would the Gophers' team dynamics change in general, now lacking the queen bee who was the source of a good chunk of their drama? And hey, not only do they not get Izzy, but they're the ones saddled with Katie and Sadie now, so how does that affect things?
i thought i'll never see another what if so good as the one of what if there was a tiebreaker but i was wrong this final 3 is literally the best thing i've ever seen
i definitely forgot to think about that while writing lol, but the economy class part of the plane had a door too so i don't see a reason they wouldn't have been able to jump out of the plane still (thanks for the compliment on the thumbnail!)
@@TDWonderer understandable I really do love this what if btw an idea could be What if sierra and Izzy never swapped(world tour ep 2) or Katie and Izzy (island ep2)
This video has kinda shown that honestly if given a whole season, Blaineley would probably do crazy well. I think it would be a pretty interesting What If to do Blaineley on a whole season (Island, Revenge would be interesting, All Stars, etc)
I have a lot of ideas. Here are some them I listed here: Island -What if Izzy didn’t switch places with Katie? -What if Beth didn’t take the totem off of Boney Island? -What if Owen didn’t eat the sticky buns? Action -What if Leshawna didn’t fake cry to get the reward? -What if Chris didn’t bring back Owen? World Tour -What if Izzy never hit her head? ROTI -What if Scott sticks to framing Brick instead of Dawn? -What if Dakota didn’t return to the island? -What if Chef didn’t hijack the Graffiti challenge? All-Stars -What if Courtney didn’t make her list? -What if Sam didn’t blew the eating challenge? Pahkitew -What if Ella never sang throughout the show? -What if Topher didn’t receive the cellphone?
Love this video, but a suggestion right here What if Duncan never came back to the 3rd season. (Yes I am a Noah fan still pissed about his elimination) What if Team Amazon’s plot armour didn’t exist? What if Izzy never left to medical issues? What if Blaineley never joined? What if Harold lost in dodgeball? What if Scarlet wasn’t evil? What if Owen didn’t eat the sausage? What if nobody went to abandon the group and they all joined world tour?
I really liked this what if because it gave DJ and other characters a lot more time to shine and was an interesting finale because it kinda reminds me of the all stars finale(good vs evil) except it’s actually good! *Day* *1* *Of* *Asking* *For* *What* *If* *Gabby* *And* *Fiore* *Didn’t* *Swap* *Teams* (This Isn’t the first time I’ve asked for this what if but now I’m committed till it happens)
If there is going to be continuation to all stars there should be DJ and Blaineley replacing Sierra and Alejandro. DJ's interactions with Ezekiel is something i always needed and wanted, i'm going to headcanon that after this what if version of world tour DJ took Ezekiel back to civilisation and is helping him go back to normal again
@@Simplyywoodland it would work too but honestly... this what if doesn't change TDROTI at all (unless DJ took Ezekiel with him after final) so changing all stars cast wouldn't be the best, i mean last time he did continuation to all stars he let orginal cast of gen that he haven't done what if of stay the same. but both solutions of swapping Alejandro with Blaineley or Sam with Anne Maria (let's say DJ took Ezekiel home after world tour and he never gave gem to Anne Maria so she never quits and she makes all stars) work in my eyes. it all depends on TD wonder if he will do continuation to all stars. we can only be guessing
@@czerwonystudio6301 I’d just like to see Alejandro in Al, stars since it continues DJ and Alejandro’s rivalry and he can have moments with Heather. It’ll be cool seeing Heather and Alejandro work together in All Stars instead of against each other
I have a fun idea for island. I found out that Noah was going to be the brain of Heather's alliance in the original script. In this scenario Heather wanted someone smart to help with her plans & strategies, but not a very threatening contestant. And Noah would of made it to the merge & exposed his alliance with Heather in the episode "No pain no game" I feel like this would make an amazing video idea. Please ☺
The alternatives having aleheather and aleheather with Heather getting money are just so fitting. Although I prefer the og ending, I wish Heather would've been able to similar ending than a bad lord of the rings reference.
Unpopular opinion: DJ's animal curse starts at season one bc Geoff got Bunny lost then at Playa de loser I think bunny got injured twice and one of them was inflicted by dj when he launched him onto the bbq
Amazing video! But question will you make any videos about the reboot like what if mk never said buttknuckle to Julia or What if Julia never yelled at the dinosaur or what if Caleb missed the throw (in episode 9) Or maybe you can make something like what if Duncan and Gwen locked the confessionals or if Beth won the award in the talk show
In the Yukon episode, DJ's curse does effect his team since he cries about hurting a seal so much that his tears freeze his eyes shut so he couldn't see that Bridgette wasn't on the sled. Not sure if that would've changed the outcome, but considering his strength, he could've just taken Bridgette and the pole with them.
Gwen would not get eliminated at picnic at the hanging dork because Chris would save her like Duncan saying like he will eliminate Gwen when the fun just started
Honestly, DJ is such a cool dude. It’s nice to see him have a good plot, rather than one that just puts him in a bad mindset and let’s him show off his talents. Always love seeing your what-ifs. It’s cool seeing how the plot might’ve gone down in a timeline different from the Heather-Alejandro showdown
Have been just randomly thinking of what ifs in my head, going to try and do some just for my own entertainment but figured I may as well comment them. If there's a reddit or discord or something for what ifs I'll post them there but for the moment this cannel is probably the biggest collection of people interesting in doing these that I know. Sorry if this counts as spam or anything. What if the Izzy isn't crazy theory was real? What if Sadie swapped teams instead of Kadie and Izzy? What if Alejandro and Sierra never competed in World Tour? What of Duncan never quit in World Tour? What if Izzy mentioned Chef trying to create an alliance? (So he doesn't make one with DJ or anyone else) What if Izzy was never hit by the plane? What if Izzy was never medically evacuated? (So 'Brainzilla' competed) What if ROTI and/or All-Stars had no idols? What if Mal was the primary personality? (Mal in ROTI) What if Heather never stole Eva's MP3 player? What if Amy never was in Pahitew? What if Justin talked in island? (So action Justin was in island) What if Mal never existed? What if Lindsay was the main villain in island like she was in Camp TV? (Or just what if Camp TV Lindsay was in island) What if Sierra never was into Cody? (Just a superfan) What if Owen quit in World Tour? (Not being able to vote out Noah or Alejandro) What if Scott did frame Brick for stealing everyone's items? What if Scott never broke Fang's tooth and started their feud? What if Zoey stayed Commando going into All-Stars? What if Harold rigged the votes against Duncan? What if Harold never rigged the votes? What if Heather never tried to cut Harold's rope? What if Trent was never derailed in Acton? What if Trent picked Heather in retaliation for Gwen picking Duncan instead of Lindsay? What if ROTI was actually a 13 episode gen 1 season? What if Owen was medically evacuated in 'Master of Disasters'? What if the reboot cast replaced the ROTI or Pahitew cast? What if Pahitew what a second ROTI season? (And/or before All-Stars) What if Pahitew happened before All-Stars? What if Ezekiel returned in 'I See London'? What if Courtney returned at Merge in Island? What if Courtney never returned to Action? What if Owen was medically evacuated over Izzy in World Tour? What if any of Mike's other personalities was the primary personality? That's all the interesting one's I've though of, I guarantee some would be really hard to actually do but I'm going to try to do them for fun anyway :)
Making Noah show signs of being at odds with Alejandro is a smart move cause I think Noah either should have lasted longer or have that storyline start earlier so it doesn’t feel like once Noah had a storyline starting it just stopped. Swapping Tyler’s seeing Gwen and Duncan kiss with Cody is actually meta cause Tyler and Cody share the same VA (and Ezaquel too) though I’m not sure if he would blurt it out cause he said island “so long as Gwen’s happy then I’m happy” showing that it isn’t just a crush but him just wanting things to be ok for her. He may not like Duncan but it seems strange he’d ever blur it out. I think Cody would be able to keep a secret but that’s just my opinion.
This is a crazy idea but: "What if Blainley didn't win the comeback competition?" and there are 5 different paths you follow, similar to the Courtney/Blainley one, in which a different contestant returns. Those being, Leshawna, Beth, Lindsay, Noah and Tyler. It's a lot of work so definitely don't feel like you have to do it, but I think it's a cool concept lol
@MaxSixty-Three true, but no one did this as in depth as he would do it, I'd love to see it here (and Cody is one of my favorites, so if it wasn't for that he'd definitely made it further and everyone would have voted for Heather)
Very glad DJ got to shine in this one. The real World Tour is amazing so I get you when you said that it feels better. But with this What if, we just got to enjoy DJ as a full character. Something we sadly missed out on for many of the seasons he was on. So thankyou for letting DJ shine :D
I'd love to see a part 2 of this for All Stars with DJ on the heroes side. Other than that... What if Ezekiel didn't lose the dowsing rod at the start of World Tour?
Finally my boy DJ cam through and was an alternate winner! Some Total Drama What If suggestions: What if: Gen 1 were in TROTI, What if Scarlett kept her cool in Scarlett Fever. I mean since your already made videos about changing DJ’s storylines in Action and World Tour. I feel like it makes sense to have a DJ Island What if.
You ended up doing this one after all! This was a what if I think about a TON and most tdi content creators don’t talk about it. It’s nice to see this actually being covered.
Alternative idea: what if Harold never sacrificed himself in the Japan episode (DJ would be voted cuz in the episode Chris was about to say Harold’s name and give him the barf bag)
Future Video Idea- What if the team that won that week’s episode loss? Example: The Killer Bass lost in episode 1 of season 1 so what would happen and who would be eliminated if they won and The Screaming Gophers had to vote someone off
Alejandro screwed team Victory and his own team at times so much because if Amazon lost, Heather, his crush, would be immediately voted off. Pre boyfriend kisser Heather was on the chopping block every episode and Al never played with Heather’s heart like the others(at least until she backstabs him). One could argue that Alejandro was a plant from a lawsuit from heather losing her hair AND Chris needed to ensure drama occurs, especially from heather, the total drama Queen. Or Al could feel sympathy for her and caught feelings. remember in Greece when Al threw the challenge to tie it up? Sure he’s trying to hide his skills, but heather would have been GONE before Tyler’s confession
This was awesome! So many great and welcome new directions for the series in this timeline. I like that Team Victory got to shine through for just that little while longer and even play an active role in the finale, and it was great to see a more game-savvy and backbone-oriented version of DJ who didn't let his usual friendship with Duncan get in the way of his own morals, and who learns along the way not to trust the likes of Alejandro or Blaineley, harkening back to in TDI when he had more sass to him, as well as TDA where he learned not to let Chef walk all over him. Alejandro going a bit earlier is...weird, but I can't say it's weird in a bad way because the way he gets played and found out sooner feels earned. Heather also still gets a great ending either way rather than being the fodder she's often bound to prey victim to being in TDWT What Ifs.
in TDI DJ FRICKING THROW OWEN FORM THE CLIFF in this paintball chalenge and I liked this side of him where he is a sweet heart but when pushed enough he can be merciless
Don't worry about thinking this is worse then the original, debate if it was all you like and while as I personally agree that Heather and Alejandro are the best finalist you absolutely made a lot of DJ fans who felt betrayed or robbed by his treatment in World Tour happy. Besides its not like you have to make a perfect replacement for something a whole team of writers and thousands of dollars went into creating by yourself every time you upload.
Ideas: What if the girls agreed to vote out Duncan? (07) What if Owen never returned? (A) What if Blainley didn't blurt out the answer, with a run if Beth won and Lindsay won due to beingbthe last one in? (WT) What if Dakota was never mutated? (ROTI) What if Lindsay didn't want to leave the game? (AS) Wha if Sammy managed to expose Amy for mistreating her? (PI) What if Lauren gave the skull to Chris? (23) What if Millie went down the four pointer herselfunsteadof tricking Damie into doing it? (24)
I don't know if you take requests but I had an idea: What if Ezekiel was let back in the game in episode 13 (because he managed to capture everyone) edit: i realized this might mean duncan wouldn't come back, so it would basically be what if Ezekiel rejoined instead of Duncan
Suggestion: Reboot season 2, what if Priya was eliminated instead of Emma? Since Emma’s elimination seemed a bit weird because Priya technically lost the challenge for the team. I think Emma staying would change some interesting things
Alternate title: what if dj didn't get his character ruined for a joke?
Fr
facts
A joke that wasn’t even funny
Alt title: what if dj got to redeem team victory
Alt alt title: what if the entirety of Team Victory wasnt ruined since World Tour sucks
I adore this idea so much
DJ feels like the kind of person that should have won a season
Blainely mommy arc is not what I was expecting bahaha
AHAHAHHA
HELP ME😭😭
its my job to surprise...
LMAO
I just started watching and I’m so concerned by what this means
Technically I think in the Yukon, it might change a bit as DJ wouldn’t cry, and his eyes wouldn’t be glued shut. He might’ve been able to find Bridgette that way?
But Bridgette still got stuck to that pole. Then again maybe DJ might've found Bridgette before Alejandro could even flirt with her.
DJ cried because the Yukon reminded him of his mama's fridge
@@happypika3oh yeah
😮😮😮 goooood point
and in the japan challenge. obviously he wouldnt kill the panda bear and they couldve got more points.
As DJ's strongest soldier this is now my canon version of World Tour haha.
This was excellent and I love all the thought you put into these. Great work as always.
As DJ’s Second strongest solider I Agree completely
As DJ's third strongest soldier I agree 100%
As DJ's 4th strongest soldier, I can agree too.
46:00 I’m a big fan of how you made Cody have a paranoia arc, it’s actually a good plot point that I would have liked, as much I hate Sierra :)
Apparently Noah was originally supposed to be in Heather’s alliance as the ‘Brains’ of the group and he actually would of made it to the merge, so WHAT IF Noah stayed and was apart of Heather’s Alliance?
What was her alliance
Heather,Lindsay and Beth
Really good video as per usual! I look forward to your What If's on the Reboot and I think a good suggestion for the 2nd Reboot Season could be "What if The original Teams were kept?" The thought process behind this was since Reboot S1 and 2 are essentially a full season I thought of how many dynamics would change with the same teams. For example, Caleb wouldn't have his alliance with Priya and potentially join Julia's and MK's counter alliance against Bowie, Emma can have a rekindled friendship with Bowie and whether or not he feels the same or uses her for a vote is up in the air and I actually think the rivalry with Nichelle and Julia could be expounded on now that their still on the same team. There are other ideas but this is more or less a suggestion like my 'What IF: Lindsay won the Paris Tiebreaker' prompt. Regardless, hope this message finds you well and looking forward to the next one!
❤❤❤
I’d like to argue that you should’ve started this at episode 4. The only reason why Bridgette was forgotten about by team victory was because DJ was crying about the animal curse to look out for her. I feel like in this reality, team victory potentially could’ve not lost that challenge
Even then, they would have to get Bridgette off the pole, since she was stuck, so I don’t think they would win there.
DJ's eyes froze from tears because the cold reminded him of his mom's freezer the animal curse being removed would just change the resulting baby seal he kicked, not the eyes being frozen (plus even if he didn't, Team Victory would still lose since they wouldn't be able to quickly get Bridgette off the pole)
The Noah and Alejandro banter for the 2 ep would’ve been gold
what a story, I'm not really a fan of DJ but he really shined in this alternate history
I loved his relationships with all the characters, his anger with Duncan and especially the curious relationship with Blainley, I would have liked them to end better, but it was still good to see
I imagine you already have many suggestions, but I wanted to suggest
What would happen if Drama Island were men vs women?
As someone who loves listening to long form videos while doing work, I thank you for these!
I love how DJ is in this :D
Caught it early, looking forward to this, cheers for making my day already after just waking up.
Amazing video, I loved it, and I have a what if idea, what if Chris didn't let Sierra and Izzy switch teams in TDWT.
The king posted again, this day should be remembered forever 🍒🍓💖
Really like this one. I was really worried going into this, since I thought DJ was gonna get the CURSE of becoming a support character. Thankfully, that didn’t happen and he actually got to do a lot more than I thought he would, mainly with Alejandro and Blaineley. I don’t have a whole lot to say here, since it did feel a bit similar to the original, but I think that’s fine. Only complaint is Owen has still not made Merge #JusticeForOwen
Time to dump ideas:
TDI: What If Eva won immunity?
TDA: What If Leshawna didn’t trash talk?
TDWT: What If Beth won the Aftermath challenge?
TDROTI: What If Jo and Scott didn’t swap?
TDAS: What If Sam didn’t steal pancakes?
TDPI: What If Amy and Sammy didn’t burst the balloon?
TDRR: What If Leshawna and Tyler were the Reality TV Pros?
TDI Reboot 1: What If MK didn’t slip up?
TDI Reboot 2: What If Nichelle didn’t quit?
DC 1: What If Gabby and Fiora didn’t swap?
DC 2: What If Aiden got poisoned?
DCAS (when it finishes): What If Jake and James didn’t have an argument?
A Disventure Camp RUclipsr, _alexa_, has actually done videos on your suggestions for seasons 1 and 2 (though the season 2 one is slightly different, as it’s what if Aiden got poisoned). I recommend checking them out, they’re good vids
@@baileylynn5562 I have seen them, but just because one RUclipsr has done them doesn’t mean someone else can’t.
@@LightningvsLightningwhat does the Yul one even change? He had the most votes anyways, what would change?
@@TheGodIvy I was thinking for it to work is instead of James having to poison Aiden, Yul would do it, and I don’t see how he couldn’t poison Aiden, even without James help, since Aiden is known to be pretty oblivious.
@@LightningvsLightningthen word the title differently, thats part of how these would play out. If it was just "Yul didnt get poisoned" then you can imagine literally anything happening, but if it was something along the lines of "what if Aiden got poisoned" then you could do it
I always love your characterisation!
What If: Everyone returned for World Tour (22 OG Cast Members + Alejandro and Sierra) I just edited it to explain how it may work
Edit: My YT Notifications go, BOOM BOOM-
Edit #2: There would probably be no non-elimination episodes, other than episode 1 because its a 2 parter, Duncan quitting doesn't really matter since he returns in episode 13 anyway, there are 6 Non-elimination episodes, so far we have 21 eliminations with 24 contestents if we count the double elimination in China, after that just add a double elimination somewhere in the first half of the season, or just don't let Duncan rejoin the game O_o, and we can still squeeze in aftermaths here if we exclude Blainely from the season because tbh who would miss her
This would be awesome!
Only issue I see is that the fact that there would be more episodes OR some are double eliminations
And some fake eliminations will be regular
Ohhhh!
Freebobox has a point-
Love your content dude! Don’t give up I believe you can make it with this idea for a channel
As always, a very entertaining video. I'm not a big fan of DJ but it was nice to see him be more of a character with a plot and not a character who was only there to make a unnfunny running gag.
I have two ideas for more WT What if.
What if the teams were formed like in ROTI?
What would happen if Geoff didn't make the search team? (Everyone would be in WT and the reward challenges would now be elimination challenges)
But I think those would take too much time but hey, they are just suggestions.
Another one I have thought about for a while but I wouldn't know how to justify it.
What if the Cast of Pahkitew and ROTI were swapped, By this I mean that the Cast of Pahkitew would participate in season 4 and some in season 5 while the Cast of ROTI would compete in season 6.
I like this idea since I think it could change a lot of things but I honestly wouldn't know how to justify it other than that in an alternative universe the Cast of Pahkitew and ROTI change ages or something like that. I also wouldn't know whether to leave them with the same teams or not since the team methods are not the same, but whatever, I don't think you're ever going to do that since it's somewhat complicated and kinda weird.
See you in the next video.
I really like that idea of swap the casts
Wanted to try suggesting a What If, and the idea I landed on was: "What if Heather swapped places with Sadie in Island?" Maybe she gets sick of dealing with certain teammates (Leshawna) early, or maybe she realizes that if Izzy beats her to switching, that her team will be saddled with the useless besties. Either way, she decides it's better to join the Bass.
As the main villain of the season, a major shift like that would be sure to change a whole lot. Who would she make allies with? Would she butt heads with Courtney worse than she did with Gwen? How would her interactions with the Gophers change? Actually, how would the Gophers' team dynamics change in general, now lacking the queen bee who was the source of a good chunk of their drama? And hey, not only do they not get Izzy, but they're the ones saddled with Katie and Sadie now, so how does that affect things?
i thought i'll never see another what if so good as the one of what if there was a tiebreaker but i was wrong this final 3 is literally the best thing i've ever seen
I really love the thumbnail what I would change is if Izzy and Owen jump out as they are both in lower class
i definitely forgot to think about that while writing lol, but the economy class part of the plane had a door too so i don't see a reason they wouldn't have been able to jump out of the plane still (thanks for the compliment on the thumbnail!)
@@TDWonderer understandable I really do love this what if btw an idea could be
What if sierra and Izzy never swapped(world tour ep 2) or Katie and Izzy (island ep2)
Just found this channel and I would love to see more What Ifs from you :D
Yknow it's a good day when TD Wonderer Uploads!!
Btw: New TD What If Idea: What if Blainely never debuted in World Tour?
So she’d be replaced by Beth (since Beth was about to win the aftermayham)
Intersting
@@milanbeerepoot4260 It could be her, or Noah since wasted potential. Yeah.
Amazing video as always
This video has kinda shown that honestly if given a whole season, Blaineley would probably do crazy well. I think it would be a pretty interesting What If to do Blaineley on a whole season (Island, Revenge would be interesting, All Stars, etc)
Thank you for the videos as always ❤
Ah yes finally DJ doesn't get an auto elimination this time
You should make: What if bridgette never cheated on geoff. i hated how they just snapped her character in half
He should do What If Ezekiel wasn't sexist continuation into Action
Another reason Harold wouldn't root for DJ during the final 3 is that DJ WAS a part of the guys alliance that made fun of Harold in TDI
I have a lot of ideas. Here are some them I listed here:
Island
-What if Izzy didn’t switch places with Katie?
-What if Beth didn’t take the totem off of Boney Island?
-What if Owen didn’t eat the sticky buns?
Action
-What if Leshawna didn’t fake cry to get the reward?
-What if Chris didn’t bring back Owen?
World Tour
-What if Izzy never hit her head?
ROTI
-What if Scott sticks to framing Brick instead of Dawn?
-What if Dakota didn’t return to the island?
-What if Chef didn’t hijack the Graffiti challenge?
All-Stars
-What if Courtney didn’t make her list?
-What if Sam didn’t blew the eating challenge?
Pahkitew
-What if Ella never sang throughout the show?
-What if Topher didn’t receive the cellphone?
Love this video, but a suggestion right here
What if Duncan never came back to the 3rd season. (Yes I am a Noah fan still pissed about his elimination)
What if Team Amazon’s plot armour didn’t exist?
What if Izzy never left to medical issues?
What if Blaineley never joined?
What if Harold lost in dodgeball?
What if Scarlet wasn’t evil?
What if Owen didn’t eat the sausage?
What if nobody went to abandon the group and they all joined world tour?
Can you do a What If? for the Ridonculous Race? One that I was thinking of is What if Josee didn't pick up the lava rock?
Early on he said that he would eventually, but its much more challenging to write for that season.
Also hello RT pfp
Chinese fake out has double elimination even though it wasn't a tie Chris planned on eliminating two people there
I really liked this what if because it gave DJ and other characters a lot more time to shine and was an interesting finale because it kinda reminds me of the all stars finale(good vs evil) except it’s actually good!
*Day* *1* *Of* *Asking* *For* *What* *If* *Gabby* *And* *Fiore* *Didn’t* *Swap* *Teams*
(This Isn’t the first time I’ve asked for this what if but now I’m committed till it happens)
I'M SO HAPPY I SAW THIS I'M SHITTING MY PANTS
I feel like no matter what TDWT what if, Heather will always make final 2 every time.
If there is going to be continuation to all stars there should be DJ and Blaineley replacing Sierra and Alejandro.
DJ's interactions with Ezekiel is something i always needed and wanted, i'm going to headcanon that after this what if version of world tour DJ took Ezekiel back to civilisation and is helping him go back to normal again
Maybe just swap Sierra with DJ and if the gender numbers need to be even just swap Sam with Anne Maria or Dawn
@@Simplyywoodland it would work too but honestly... this what if doesn't change TDROTI at all (unless DJ took Ezekiel with him after final) so changing all stars cast wouldn't be the best, i mean last time he did continuation to all stars he let orginal cast of gen that he haven't done what if of stay the same. but both solutions of swapping Alejandro with Blaineley or Sam with Anne Maria (let's say DJ took Ezekiel home after world tour and he never gave gem to Anne Maria so she never quits and she makes all stars) work in my eyes. it all depends on TD wonder if he will do continuation to all stars. we can only be guessing
@@czerwonystudio6301 I’d just like to see Alejandro in Al, stars since it continues DJ and Alejandro’s rivalry and he can have moments with Heather. It’ll be cool seeing Heather and Alejandro work together in All Stars instead of against each other
New TDwonderer video just dropped
I have a fun idea for island.
I found out that Noah was going to be the brain of Heather's alliance in the original script. In this scenario Heather wanted someone smart to help with her plans & strategies, but not a very threatening contestant. And Noah would of made it to the merge & exposed his alliance with Heather in the episode "No pain no game"
I feel like this would make an amazing video idea. Please ☺
If you haven’t done this I’m gonna suggest making a what if Harold rigged the votes for Courtney?
Not my fave what if but good as always !!! Love the blainley momma arc ! Keep the good work up
The alternatives having aleheather and aleheather with Heather getting money are just so fitting. Although I prefer the og ending, I wish Heather would've been able to similar ending than a bad lord of the rings reference.
TDAS/TDPI: What if All-Stars happened after Pahkitew Island
Makes TDWT better
Unpopular opinion: DJ's animal curse starts at season one bc Geoff got Bunny lost then at Playa de loser I think bunny got injured twice and one of them was inflicted by dj when he launched him onto the bbq
@akieboygamingI Miss Matpat.
What if Cody’s character actually grew from his development in season 1
Amazing video! But question will you make any videos about the reboot like what if mk never said buttknuckle to Julia or What if Julia never yelled at the dinosaur or what if Caleb missed the throw (in episode 9)
Or maybe you can make something like what if Duncan and Gwen locked the confessionals or if Beth won the award in the talk show
Suggestion, what if Alejandro was a hero and Sierra was the villian?
In the Yukon episode, DJ's curse does effect his team since he cries about hurting a seal so much that his tears freeze his eyes shut so he couldn't see that Bridgette wasn't on the sled. Not sure if that would've changed the outcome, but considering his strength, he could've just taken Bridgette and the pole with them.
I’m pretty sure he was crying about him missing his momma, then he kicked the seal because his eyes were frozen shut
@@Rias-sl6fqyea
Here is a fun what if: what if Sierra was obsessed with another contestant or Noah didn’t actually tell Owen his suspicions? :)
now im thinking how would DJ sing all the songs
FINALLY U POSTED
Just got to Blaineley and its...interesting, wondering where it goes.
Gwen would not get eliminated at picnic at the hanging dork because Chris would save her like Duncan saying like he will eliminate Gwen when the fun just started
Well done!
53:14 I was so scared Alejandro will go home right now 😭
Honestly, DJ is such a cool dude. It’s nice to see him have a good plot, rather than one that just puts him in a bad mindset and let’s him show off his talents. Always love seeing your what-ifs. It’s cool seeing how the plot might’ve gone down in a timeline different from the Heather-Alejandro showdown
Have been just randomly thinking of what ifs in my head, going to try and do some just for my own entertainment but figured I may as well comment them. If there's a reddit or discord or something for what ifs I'll post them there but for the moment this cannel is probably the biggest collection of people interesting in doing these that I know. Sorry if this counts as spam or anything.
What if the Izzy isn't crazy theory was real?
What if Sadie swapped teams instead of Kadie and Izzy?
What if Alejandro and Sierra never competed in World Tour?
What of Duncan never quit in World Tour?
What if Izzy mentioned Chef trying to create an alliance? (So he doesn't make one with DJ or anyone else)
What if Izzy was never hit by the plane?
What if Izzy was never medically evacuated? (So 'Brainzilla' competed)
What if ROTI and/or All-Stars had no idols?
What if Mal was the primary personality? (Mal in ROTI)
What if Heather never stole Eva's MP3 player?
What if Amy never was in Pahitew?
What if Justin talked in island? (So action Justin was in island)
What if Mal never existed?
What if Lindsay was the main villain in island like she was in Camp TV? (Or just what if Camp TV Lindsay was in island)
What if Sierra never was into Cody? (Just a superfan)
What if Owen quit in World Tour? (Not being able to vote out Noah or Alejandro)
What if Scott did frame Brick for stealing everyone's items?
What if Scott never broke Fang's tooth and started their feud?
What if Zoey stayed Commando going into All-Stars?
What if Harold rigged the votes against Duncan?
What if Harold never rigged the votes?
What if Heather never tried to cut Harold's rope?
What if Trent was never derailed in Acton?
What if Trent picked Heather in retaliation for Gwen picking Duncan instead of Lindsay?
What if ROTI was actually a 13 episode gen 1 season?
What if Owen was medically evacuated in 'Master of Disasters'?
What if the reboot cast replaced the ROTI or Pahitew cast?
What if Pahitew what a second ROTI season? (And/or before All-Stars)
What if Pahitew happened before All-Stars?
What if Ezekiel returned in 'I See London'?
What if Courtney returned at Merge in Island?
What if Courtney never returned to Action?
What if Owen was medically evacuated over Izzy in World Tour?
What if any of Mike's other personalities was the primary personality?
That's all the interesting one's I've though of, I guarantee some would be really hard to actually do but I'm going to try to do them for fun anyway :)
I’m not even joking, I was watching World Tour earlier today, and thought about this happening.
Idea: Sierra being the villain for total drama world tour
Making Noah show signs of being at odds with Alejandro is a smart move cause I think Noah either should have lasted longer or have that storyline start earlier so it doesn’t feel like once Noah had a storyline starting it just stopped. Swapping Tyler’s seeing Gwen and Duncan kiss with Cody is actually meta cause Tyler and Cody share the same VA (and Ezaquel too) though I’m not sure if he would blurt it out cause he said island “so long as Gwen’s happy then I’m happy” showing that it isn’t just a crush but him just wanting things to be ok for her. He may not like Duncan but it seems strange he’d ever blur it out. I think Cody would be able to keep a secret but that’s just my opinion.
Cody Fr Broke DJ’s trust
This is a crazy idea but: "What if Blainley didn't win the comeback competition?" and there are 5 different paths you follow, similar to the Courtney/Blainley one, in which a different contestant returns. Those being, Leshawna, Beth, Lindsay, Noah and Tyler. It's a lot of work so definitely don't feel like you have to do it, but I think it's a cool concept lol
Nice, can you please do a what if Cody never got mauled please
Unfortunately someone already did that, but it would be interesting to see other people's takes on it.
@@MaxSixty-Three exactly.
@MaxSixty-Three true, but no one did this as in depth as he would do it, I'd love to see it here (and Cody is one of my favorites, so if it wasn't for that he'd definitely made it further and everyone would have voted for Heather)
@BrumBrum89 true.
Very glad DJ got to shine in this one. The real World Tour is amazing so I get you when you said that it feels better. But with this What if, we just got to enjoy DJ as a full character. Something we sadly missed out on for many of the seasons he was on. So thankyou for letting DJ shine :D
I'd love to see a part 2 of this for All Stars with DJ on the heroes side. Other than that...
What if Ezekiel didn't lose the dowsing rod at the start of World Tour?
Finally my boy DJ cam through and was an alternate winner! Some Total Drama What If suggestions: What if: Gen 1 were in TROTI, What if Scarlett kept her cool in Scarlett Fever. I mean since your already made videos about changing DJ’s storylines in Action and World Tour. I feel like it makes sense to have a DJ Island What if.
You ended up doing this one after all! This was a what if I think about a TON and most tdi content creators don’t talk about it. It’s nice to see this actually being covered.
I think Chris would have made it a non elimination round because all the drama Duncan and Gwen caused
Alternative idea: what if Harold never sacrificed himself in the Japan episode (DJ would be voted cuz in the episode Chris was about to say Harold’s name and give him the barf bag)
DJ is ❤ love the gentle giant
I think it would be great if you would make what if everybody was in action and then continuation of it if everyone was in world tour
What’s If I could think of: What if Duncan and Gwen didn’t break up in AS, What if Courtney and Duncan didn’t swap teams
Can you PLEASE either do what Izzy and Katie never swapped teams or Sadie got eliminated instead of Katie in episode 6
Suggestion For The Next Video: What If Harold Didn't Rig The Votes Against Courtney In TDI (Episode 12)
he wouldn't have been a running gag and would make it far
and blainley actually survives more than 2 episodes
Future Video Idea- What if the team that won that week’s episode loss? Example: The Killer Bass lost in episode 1 of season 1 so what would happen and who would be eliminated if they won and The Screaming Gophers had to vote someone off
Alejandro screwed team Victory and his own team at times so much because if Amazon lost, Heather, his crush, would be immediately voted off.
Pre boyfriend kisser Heather was on the chopping block every episode and Al never played with Heather’s heart like the others(at least until she backstabs him).
One could argue that Alejandro was a plant from a lawsuit from heather losing her hair AND Chris needed to ensure drama occurs, especially from heather, the total drama Queen. Or Al could feel sympathy for her and caught feelings.
remember in Greece when Al threw the challenge to tie it up? Sure he’s trying to hide his skills, but heather would have been GONE before Tyler’s confession
What if Izzy and Katie never swapped teams or what if Izzy and Sierra never swapped teams could both be fun. Loved the vid as usual
This was awesome! So many great and welcome new directions for the series in this timeline. I like that Team Victory got to shine through for just that little while longer and even play an active role in the finale, and it was great to see a more game-savvy and backbone-oriented version of DJ who didn't let his usual friendship with Duncan get in the way of his own morals, and who learns along the way not to trust the likes of Alejandro or Blaineley, harkening back to in TDI when he had more sass to him, as well as TDA where he learned not to let Chef walk all over him. Alejandro going a bit earlier is...weird, but I can't say it's weird in a bad way because the way he gets played and found out sooner feels earned. Heather also still gets a great ending either way rather than being the fodder she's often bound to prey victim to being in TDWT What Ifs.
in TDI DJ FRICKING THROW OWEN FORM THE CLIFF in this paintball chalenge and I liked this side of him where he is a sweet heart but when pushed enough he can be merciless
Weird question, wasn't Rapa Phooey a non elimination episode ?
Yes but, when he has an extra person he elims someone there he did it in the tie breaker what if as well
What font do you use for thumbnails
antreas
Don't worry about thinking this is worse then the original, debate if it was all you like and while as I personally agree that Heather and Alejandro are the best finalist you absolutely made a lot of DJ fans who felt betrayed or robbed by his treatment in World Tour happy. Besides its not like you have to make a perfect replacement for something a whole team of writers and thousands of dollars went into creating by yourself every time you upload.
Ideas:
What if the girls agreed to vote out Duncan? (07)
What if Owen never returned? (A)
What if Blainley didn't blurt out the answer, with a run if Beth won and Lindsay won due to beingbthe last one in? (WT)
What if Dakota was never mutated? (ROTI)
What if Lindsay didn't want to leave the game? (AS)
Wha if Sammy managed to expose Amy for mistreating her? (PI)
What if Lauren gave the skull to Chris? (23)
What if Millie went down the four pointer herselfunsteadof tricking Damie into doing it? (24)
Those are awesome ideas, I think Bridgette should have stayed longer
wut if zeeke wasn't sexsist island special continuation??????
If I can suggest one:
What if Owen got eliminated instead of Beth in "If You Can't Take The Heat..." from TDI Season 1.
Then the season would be extra good
Idea:
What if MK wasn’t exposed by Julia in the catapult episode of season 1?
😮 what if in revenge of the Island the teams will never switch I want to see what happens if Scott were a sabotage the whole team
27:47 which makes WHO happy??
I don't know if you take requests but I had an idea:
What if Ezekiel was let back in the game in episode 13 (because he managed to capture everyone)
edit: i realized this might mean duncan wouldn't come back, so it would basically be what if Ezekiel rejoined instead of Duncan
Now, to do a version where Lindsey won the tie against DJ (somehow, someway)
1:09:16 thats such a realistic thing to happen
Maybe you can do what if duncan never came back in world tour
Nice video, are you gonna continue the Alejandro and Sierra being in Island storyline with World Tour?
Suggestion:
Reboot season 2, what if Priya was eliminated instead of Emma?
Since Emma’s elimination seemed a bit weird because Priya technically lost the challenge for the team. I think Emma staying would change some interesting things
What if All Stars was split into Gen 1 vs Gen 2 instead of Heros vs Villains?