Heavy industry was developed in India during 1950s and 1960s with the help of the Soviet Union. That created the foundation. India was developed on that foundation.
Aree bhai kuch na kuch too bolna hii padega naa apni jantaa koo khush karne kee liyee bhale hee jhooth hi kyun naa hoo. Azadi kee baad see apna desh samhaala too jaa nahi raha bas jhooth Bolney mee number 1.
Yeh bhi sahi hai ki manmohan singh ya congress ne khud nhi kiya. Imf bailout package ki conditions thi ki economic open karni hai isliye majboori mein fdi allow kiya , foreign companies ko aane diya.. Agar woh situation na hoti aur congress government continue rehti toh aaj tak bhi wohi hindu rate of growth rehti.. Har jagah licence raaj hota.. Koi bhi factory open karne ki soche toh government permission hi nhi deti thi Har cheez par government ka hold tha.. Aaj bhi socialist idea hi hai congress ki soch. Jis bhi state mein congress ki government aati hai woh debt mein fas jati hai aaj bhi inka yhi haal hai.. Inka freebies ke chakkar mein bjp bhi freebies dena start kar diya Pehle toh congress hi socialist thi ab toh bjp bhi socialist banti ja rhi.. Yeh logo ko ghar baithe khilana chahte hai chahe koi kaam kare ya na kare... Msp dete hai faltu mein kisano ko.. Fully market pe chodna chahiye har koi wheat and rice ugaa deta hai baqi aur faslo ki taraf dhyan hi nhi deta.. Itni badi fouji rakhi hui hai ladai kabhi fouj ki itni badi hogi hi nhi technology ki hogi jab bhi hogi.. Janta bhi government job ke liye hi baithi rehti hai.. Isliye india kabhi china ko compete nhi kar sakta Railway and buses ko bhi 100% privatization hona chahiye. Healthy system bhi fully private ho.. Government ka role kewal defence , administration aur education mein 100% hona chahiye baai sab kuch private hona chahiye
What about ur education ? Sports ? Medicine ? Agriculture? Textile ? IT? Heavy industries?? It’s stupid to say Manmohan singh follow nawab Shariff…😂😂😂😂
@@james432ful Bangladesh's GDP per Capita is only 8% higher than India's. In statistical terms (rolled over average) there is essentially no percentage difference in GDP per capita between the two countries. Compared that with Total GDP, India's total GDP is 700% higher or almost 8 times higher. Let that Sink In. Bangladesh in the coming few years will become a case study as to how a perfectly fast-growing economy ruined it's own future.
Rao was just stamping the papers nothing else. Under pressure of west & IMF india opened the economy to western countries. MMS wanted to do it in 80s but due to political pressure & pro capitalist political party many leaders refused . Indian business houses also pressured congres not to allow foreign investment in many sectors. Indian companies ko daar tha ki wo foreign company se competition nahi kar payege.
@@commonman7730manmohan singh was specially brought by narsimha rao.. rao asked manmohan singh what to do.. manmohan singh told him to devalue currency .. rao called atal ji and seeked coordination with opposition.. atal ji said, do anything for the economy.. Then currency was devalued overnight.. then Manmohan Singh made the revolutionary budget of 1991 as he was himself from RBI.. thats why The whole credit of LPG reforms are rightly given to Manmohan ji.. that was history for the unaware people who still want to be nosy in politics despite their shallow knowledge 👍
Pakistan's forex reserve is $8 billion(contributed by IMF, USA, China and Saudi) India's forex reserve is $670 billion There is no comparison of Pakistan economy with India's economy.
India has done better but not to its full capability. there are lot of reforms still pending. But pakistan has not done any reforms. Two things that really benefitted india was that Indian traders like ambani, adani became industrialist but pakistan traders are still traders. Second thing India did was to capitalize on Indian education system focussed heavily english oriented which saw lot of indians moving to america which brought precious foreign currency. Eventhough India education did not give any practical knowledge nor scientific acumen. Their theoretical knowledge was very good to get employment in top Global MNC and all happened at same time when digital, internet revolution was taking place. So india was at the right place at the right time
Liberalization was brainchild of manmohan singh he was the finance minister of India even many people from his party also opposed it including opposition
Pakistani's decade of development 😂... Comedy at it's best...but this takes the cake... Manmohan Singh ji ne Nawaz Sharif ki privitization policies dekh ke policies change ki 1990 mai... Wah re Sethi uncle wah!! Aur yeh made up aunty messages karne mai busy hain... What a show! 🇮🇳
India will soon be the third largest economy in the world. With a foreign exchange of more than 600 billion dollars, a GDP growth of 7 to 8%, India is today a lender nation. It gave aid to Srilanka that helped SL out of its economic mess. It gives aid to Afghanistan and many other nations. Pakistan OTOH is still with the IMF. It has gone to the IMF for economic bailouts a total of 23 times since gaining independence in 1947, more than any other country. That is a shame! It is fashionable, perhaps compulsory, for Pakistanis to keep comparing their nation with India but that comparison makes no sense today.
سیھٹی صاحب انڈیا کی ترقی کے بارے اتنی تفصیل میں جانے کی ضرورت نہیں اِسکی صرف ایک وجہ ہے اور وہ یہ کہ انڈیا میں فوج سیاست نہیں کرتی یہی وجہ ہے اُسکی ترقی کی اور ہمیں بھی شروعات اِسی عمل سے کرنی ہوگی۔. وگرنہ نتیجہ صفر ہی رہیگا۔۔۔۔
انڈیا والے ایک صوبے سے ملک نہیں چلاتے ہیں بلکہ اپنے بڑے سٹی کو بہت اچھے طریقے سے رکھتے ہیں اور عزت دیتے ہیں اور ہمارے پاکستان میں بڑے سٹی کے ساتھ جو سلوک کیا ہوا ہے وہ سب جانتے ہیں تو کہاں سے اپ کا معیشت چلے گی
Bangladesh ka bhi wahi hal hone wala hai jo pakistan ka hai.... shekh hasina balance kar ke chal rhi thi..India china or rashiya ...sab ko sath lekar chalti thi...
اسکی ایک بڑی وجہ یہ ہے کہ ہماری آبادی ۱۹۵۵ کے بعد چھ گنا بڑھی ہے جبکہ انڈیا اور بنگلہ دیش کی آبادی ساڑھے تین گنا بڑھی۔ ہمارے تمام وسائل آبادی میں ہی خدچ ہو گئے۔ ویسے ۱۹۷۲ سے لیکر ۲۰۱۸ تک پاکستان اور انڈیا کی جی ڈی پی ایک ہی رفتار سے بڑھی۔ یعنی ۳۷ گنا۔ مگر ۱۹۷۲ میں انڈیا کی آبادی ہم سے دس گنا زیادہ تھی اور اب چھ گنا زیادہ رہ گئی ہے اسکی وجہ سے انکہ فی کس آمدنی ہم سے بیس فیصد زیادہ گئی۔ مگر ۲۰۱۸ کے بعد جو ہماری اکانومی کے ساتھ ہوا ادکی مثال ہی نہیں ملتی۔ آجکل ہماری اور انڈیا کی جی ڈی پی میں ایک اور گیارہ کا تناسب ہو گیا ہے جو کہ ۲۰۱۸ تک ایک سے ساڑھے سات کا تھا۔ ہمیں اپنی آبادی کے بارے میں کچھ کرنا پڑے گا۔ ہماری آبادی دنیا کی اوسط کے مقابلے میں دگنی رفتار سے بڑھ رہی ہے۔
Read the history this was brainchild of manmohan singh totally risked by himself yes PV narsimha rao was PM but all the credit was attracted towards finance minister manmohan singh
after india and pakistan atomic blasts in 1998, the indian think-tank had a proper plan how to move forward, but pakistan had no such plan. Indian think-tank plan was to adjust its agents in the pakistan establishment's different institutions. they brought pervez musharraf in power expelling nawaz sharif. and their agents acted fully on indian plans till 2013 as pakistan failed to progress in 15 years time from 1998 to 2013. At one stage in 2012 pakistan was at the brink to lose all economic power due to loadshedding. however in 2013 when nawaz sharif again came back in the power he ended the loadshedding of electricity, and of cng and again put pakistan on the road to progress from 2013 to 2017 despite facing many hurdles from imran khan, who was now playing the role in place of pervez musharraf against pakistan. imran khan is still playing that role and trying to bring pakistan down economically. on the other hand a weak pakistan could not stop india to make progress in last 24 years after the atomic blast due to instability. but ironically no pakistani journalists will speak on this fact including najam sethi. Moreover, the anti pakistan forces know well that they could not fight a conventional war against pakistan due to its atomic power so they made a plan against pakistan to weak it politically and economically from inside and that is going on for the last 24 years.
amerika ne takta palt kiya hai or Bangladesh ko lagta hai student ne inklab laya hai...amerika ne aapne katputli ko karshi pr bitha kr Pakistan jesa hal karega 😂😂usne koyi bhi Muslim kantri ko nhi ko nhi baksha to Bangladesh kiya chij hai😂😂
Am sorry, Mr. Sethi, the Indian growth rate for the period you mentioned was 4% to 4.5%, and and not 2% as you refer to, rather maliciously. Actually. an Indian economist found it convenient to term a 4% growth as Hindu rate of growth, although I would think that was blatantly devious him, and has since stuck with that number. Maybe you should correct your mistake.
Najam Sethi is wrong abt Manhon Singh. He took the Model of ASEAN countries. Pakistan has hardly any state owned heavy industry ever that could be privatised😂😂😂😂
Dr. Manmohan Singh ki likhi huyi books Economics mein aaj v oxford & Harvard mein padhayi jati hai.... ap besak check kr skte hai.... Economist king kaha jata hai Dr. Manmohan Singh ko
Dr. Man Mohan Singh may not be a strong leader to be a PM. But he's one of the best finance minister we had. Especially during IMF bail out days in 1991 he managed very well. Comparing him with Shariff is a biggest disgrace to Dr. Singh.
Bahria town will never be Empty bcs Pakistan has consistent income of $50 Billion Dollars a yr ($30 + billion are sent via Pak banks) from 10 millions (coror + ) rich Overseas Pakistanis, a Huge amount...so their families in Pakistan can afford a Bahria town Khi Lifestyle. And soon BRICS will replace the US Doller & soft sanctions on Pak will will go away and we will be able to buy half price Petrol & Gas from Iran (energy superpower next door), Russia & petrol prices will come down in Watan, inshallah...Farhan from Chicago.
It appears the hostess already knows what Sethi is likely to say and for how long he will speak. She was busy punching away on the phone confident that her intervention will not be required for quite some time.
Phli baat 1990 m india ki halat bhi kharab ho gyi thi or jo Russia ka model tha wo fail ho ra tha or IMF n propose kiya tha ki relief package tb hi milega jab market open hoga foreign markets k liye .. tab se shi hua h mahool
Mr Sethi, understand your audience are Pakistanis. But your facts on Indian 1991 reforms have got nothing to do with Pak. Am sure it was a slip of the mind n tongue. You are aware of the Indian economy in doldrums and balance of Payments issue. That is the reason that India opened up its economy based on advise from WB and IMF...........and, it was need based and not out of love for populace of india. THE CREDIT SHOULD GO TO PV NARASIMHA RAO the PM. MMS just implemented it and saw it through. Read History.
As Bjp supporter I have many disagreements but how can you compare sucessful 10 years of Pm position and 5 years of Finance position of Manmohan Singh compare to Nawaj Sherif who couldn't even completed his 5 year tenure. And his guy former Pakistan Cricket President comparing, It shows the IQ level of Pakistani intellectual 🤣🤣🤣🤣.
Pak Economy issue is socialist business policies. Nationalization of Industries in 1972 killed Pakistan’s economy forever. Due to socialism USSR got chopped in 16 pieces. Best economy system is capitalism not socialism. Government should not get involve in any business Government job is to make business policies. When government gets involved in businesses corruption is Imminent .USA and most developed countries economy is based on capitalism . Privatization is the key of success.
![Lil Uzi Vert - We Good [Official Audio]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/DrSfBULAsek/mqdefault.jpg)
Pakistan’s International relations
Current lover : China
Ex-lover : USA
Current abusive husband : IMF
Soutan : India
Separated Sister : Bangladesh
Badmash neighbor : Afghanistan
Less Badmash Neighbor : Iran
Rich Phuphi 1 : UAE
Rich Phuphi 2 : Saudi Arabia
Distant Emotional Cousin : Turkey
Distant Practical Cousin : Malaysia
bilkul sahi😃😃😃😄😄😄
Baap: Turkey
Chacha: Saudia
😂😂😂
Pakistan is the current Rakhail, i.e., current Tawaif of China.
😂😂
Manmohan singh ne nawaj Sharif ka model dekha 🤦 itni confidence honi chahiye logon main... Is desh ka haal Aisa kyon hai wo pata chal gaya😂
PCB equates with BCCI,this confidence chahiye
he is doing it for internal politics, he is trying to say Nawaz sharif is visionary leader so people stop supporting Imran khan
@@gatech5190 like all Pakistanis ,he has no stand. It changes with who is in power. They have no opinions. Just propaganda as veiws
😂😂😂😂
Nawaj sharif model could not succeed in Pak but mm copied and succeed. Wah! 😀
Sethi sahib Dr.Manmohan singh is .p.H.D in economics Don't compare Manmohan Singh with Nawaz Sharif
Yunus also has a PhD in economics but Bangladesh went down recently and there is no chance now that it can be revived
Heavy industry was developed in India during 1950s and 1960s with the help of the Soviet Union. That created the foundation. India was developed on that foundation.
@@DipakBose-bq1vv Yunus of Kangladesh is a stooge of US
@@DipakBose-bq1vv what is the connection with Manmohan Singh?
Bhai sethi ko p hd ka matlab bhi nahi pata hoga😅
Manmohan Singh ne Nawaz Sharif ki taraf dekha aur india me economic change aa gaya😂😂😂 joke of the century
😂😂😂😂
Very famous joker name Sethi
Aree bhai kuch na kuch too bolna hii padega naa apni jantaa koo khush karne kee liyee bhale hee jhooth hi kyun naa hoo. Azadi kee baad see apna desh samhaala too jaa nahi raha bas jhooth Bolney mee number 1.
Har cheez to copy india ki maarte hai yeh log..
Yeh bhi sahi hai ki manmohan singh ya congress ne khud nhi kiya. Imf bailout package ki conditions thi ki economic open karni hai isliye majboori mein fdi allow kiya , foreign companies ko aane diya..
Agar woh situation na hoti aur congress government continue rehti toh aaj tak bhi wohi hindu rate of growth rehti..
Har jagah licence raaj hota..
Koi bhi factory open karne ki soche toh government permission hi nhi deti thi
Har cheez par government ka hold tha..
Aaj bhi socialist idea hi hai congress ki soch. Jis bhi state mein congress ki government aati hai woh debt mein fas jati hai aaj bhi inka yhi haal hai..
Inka freebies ke chakkar mein bjp bhi freebies dena start kar diya
Pehle toh congress hi socialist thi ab toh bjp bhi socialist banti ja rhi.. Yeh logo ko ghar baithe khilana chahte hai chahe koi kaam kare ya na kare...
Msp dete hai faltu mein kisano ko.. Fully market pe chodna chahiye har koi wheat and rice ugaa deta hai baqi aur faslo ki taraf dhyan hi nhi deta..
Itni badi fouji rakhi hui hai ladai kabhi fouj ki itni badi hogi hi nhi technology ki hogi jab bhi hogi..
Janta bhi government job ke liye hi baithi rehti hai..
Isliye india kabhi china ko compete nhi kar sakta
Railway and buses ko bhi 100% privatization hona chahiye.
Healthy system bhi fully private ho..
Government ka role kewal defence , administration aur education mein 100% hona chahiye baai sab kuch private hona chahiye
What about ur education ? Sports ? Medicine ? Agriculture? Textile ? IT? Heavy industries?? It’s stupid to say Manmohan singh follow nawab Shariff…😂😂😂😂
He appreciated all these things that India did to form her base to take off.
@@acesam2314those were secondary lines .. primary started with negative
Bhai tu smjha nahi unka kehne ka mtlb h unhone shariff ko dekha or uska ulta kiya🤣🤣🤣
Dont compare India economy with Pakistan.
Compare Pakistan with Afganistan ,Africa and Bangladesh.😢
Bangladesh per capita GDP is higher than India. Even after coup. Sharm kar
@@james432ful Bangladesh's GDP per Capita is only 8% higher than India's. In statistical terms (rolled over average) there is essentially no percentage difference in GDP per capita between the two countries. Compared that with Total GDP, India's total GDP is 700% higher or almost 8 times higher. Let that Sink In. Bangladesh in the coming few years will become a case study as to how a perfectly fast-growing economy ruined it's own future.
@@james432fulgood now they should pay the bills😂 after the imf loan
@@james432ful wrong, aave woh bas COVID ka time hua kyu ki use time india ki GDP giri jada. Aab GDP per capita india ka jada hai, Jake dekh le
Yes.Good one.
Sethi believes Dr. Manmohan copied Mr. Sharif😅😂
He consumes Raiwind churan
Let them live in fools paradise 🎉
Kahin yeh na kehde Dr manmohan singh to Doctor the heart ke patient dekhte the 😂
Height of disillusionment
He is very jealous of India
Tarek Fateh once Said that in Pakistan from Puncture Wala to PhD Scholars every one has the same mindset.
He understood them because he had lived amongst these jaahils
आसमानी किताब पर ज्यादा भरोसा करना और आचरण करना बड़ा कारण है
1990 s economic reforms in India were started by then prime minister pv narasimha rao nd not manmohan singh
Rao was just stamping the papers nothing else. Under pressure of west & IMF india opened the economy to western countries. MMS wanted to do it in 80s but due to political pressure & pro capitalist political party many leaders refused . Indian business houses also pressured congres not to allow foreign investment in many sectors. Indian companies ko daar tha ki wo foreign company se competition nahi kar payege.
Manmohan Singh was finance minister then bro
He was made fm
Decision was taken by
Pv narsimha rao
Plz educate u r self
@@_Parmatma_
@@commonman7730manmohan singh was specially brought by narsimha rao.. rao asked manmohan singh what to do.. manmohan singh told him to devalue currency .. rao called atal ji and seeked coordination with opposition.. atal ji said, do anything for the economy..
Then currency was devalued overnight.. then Manmohan Singh made the revolutionary budget of 1991 as he was himself from RBI.. thats why The whole credit of LPG reforms are rightly given to Manmohan ji.. that was history for the unaware people who still want to be nosy in politics despite their shallow knowledge 👍
@@Rocky-pz8px 😅😅😅😅
Bhai u read propaganda
It was dr Swamy blue print
Nothing special done
Economy was opened up
Dr Manmohan just followed
Policy
Ok
In India every state is giving free books, uniform, free food, to every student,
If they have money they give madharasa book
@@moorthit6964😂 abe converted
@@moorthit6964😂 ku Pakistan jaisi haalat karde 😂
we give free madrasa education
@@tarunsaini2848you did not get what he is saying!
Sethi sahib your country have never economic growth it was dollars given by u.s.A
Pakistan's forex reserve is $8 billion(contributed by IMF, USA, China and Saudi)
India's forex reserve is $670 billion
There is no comparison of Pakistan economy with India's economy.
India's now 690 billion dollars
Madam is using Mobile 😅😅😅and making sound- hun hun hunn hun 😅😅😅
comedians h ye🤣🤣
Same service she gives to her husband in home
@@sps6 chhi itni gandi baat par sunke maja aya😂😂
Vibrating Mobile ..
She just doing Google for fact checking maybe. She thinks kahi yah buddhi zaat bakwas to nahi kar rahi.😂
USA doled out billions of dollars to Pakistan. Where did all that money go?
Journale 😂😂😂
Back to US. Generals property
In armys pockets, dubai and other safehaeavens
India has done better but not to its full capability. there are lot of reforms still pending. But pakistan has not done any reforms. Two things that really benefitted india was that Indian traders like ambani, adani became industrialist but pakistan traders are still traders. Second thing India did was to capitalize on Indian education system focussed heavily english oriented which saw lot of indians moving to america which brought precious foreign currency. Eventhough India education did not give any practical knowledge nor scientific acumen. Their theoretical knowledge was very good to get employment in top Global MNC and all happened at same time when digital, internet revolution was taking place. So india was at the right place at the right time
Anchor be like : tu bhauk le, me apne bf ko text karti hu
Development hui? Sab west se mila hua bheek ka paisa tha 🤣🤣
👍
Sir Manmohan Singh not followed nwaz Sharif model but liberalisation process started when soviet union liberalized it's economy
Aisa bol rha ki India ne dal chawal banaya aur kha liya 😅
Inko to yehi lagta hai Hamare baap Dada ne jo mehnat kiya woh inko woh nahi dikhegi 😂😂 inko.lagta hai dua mango sab kuch mil jayega 😂😂
Sethi Saab, Manmohan Singh (a renowned economist) didn't have to learn economic liberalisation & free market economics from Nawaz Sharif 🙏
We have honest politicians in India
LOL good joke
Honest politicians in India 🤣🤣
😂😂🤣
😂😂😂
Only cabinet leaders
Najam sasta nasha fookke aaya hai …..😂😂😂… Manmohan Singh copied Nawaz sharif 😂😂😂😂😂
Karma will hit back anyone everyone
This elder expert will never have the courage to say the truth and will always be beating about the bush !
It's beating around the bush
Emergency was imposed in 1975, liberalism policy was launched by PV Narasimha Rao ji, the then PM , not by Manmohan Singh ji.
Dr Manmohan Singh was Finance Minister back then
Manmohan Singh was finance minister bro 😂, , read the history
Liberalization was brainchild of manmohan singh he was the finance minister of India even many people from his party also opposed it including opposition
Are u mad? Manmohan was never influenced by Nawaz Sharif's economic policy.
After passing 77 years talking about the economy it is too late to discuss the economy
Tarar sethi and many more jokers are there in pakistan to entertain indians us enjoy their jokes
Still best one is qamar cheema
@@KanishQQuotesmulla jatt cheema
Pakistani's decade of development 😂... Comedy at it's best...but this takes the cake... Manmohan Singh ji ne Nawaz Sharif ki privitization policies dekh ke policies change ki 1990 mai... Wah re Sethi uncle wah!! Aur yeh made up aunty messages karne mai busy hain... What a show! 🇮🇳
Whole world copy🤩 Pakistan. 🤩🤩Dr. Manmohan singh top economist of the world copy Nawaz
Why Pakistan is compering with world 5th largest economy country
India will soon be the third largest economy in the world. With a foreign exchange of more than 600 billion dollars, a GDP growth of 7 to 8%, India is today a lender nation. It gave aid to Srilanka that helped SL out of its economic mess. It gives aid to Afghanistan and many other nations.
Pakistan OTOH is still with the IMF. It has gone to the IMF for economic bailouts a total of 23 times since gaining independence in 1947, more than any other country. That is a shame!
It is fashionable, perhaps compulsory, for Pakistanis to keep comparing their nation with India but that comparison makes no sense today.
Tv. Anchor Debate me involve k badle mobile chat me busy rahti hai, ye only ye karti hai humm, hummm
Shayad uska chakkar chal raha ho.😊
Excellent analysis of both economies! Thank you!
Because there is no " CHERRIA " over there 😢
Cherria means what ?
@@njscan007Islam
سیھٹی صاحب انڈیا کی ترقی کے بارے اتنی تفصیل میں جانے کی ضرورت نہیں اِسکی صرف ایک وجہ ہے اور وہ یہ کہ انڈیا میں فوج سیاست نہیں کرتی یہی وجہ ہے اُسکی ترقی کی اور ہمیں بھی شروعات اِسی عمل سے کرنی ہوگی۔.
وگرنہ نتیجہ صفر ہی رہیگا۔۔۔۔
Deislamization the only way...
Najam sahib, vision, will, aur skill, bhi to zaroori hota hay
انڈیا والے ایک صوبے سے ملک نہیں چلاتے ہیں بلکہ اپنے بڑے سٹی کو بہت اچھے طریقے سے رکھتے ہیں اور عزت دیتے ہیں اور ہمارے پاکستان میں بڑے سٹی کے ساتھ جو سلوک کیا ہوا ہے وہ سب جانتے ہیں تو کہاں سے اپ کا معیشت چلے گی
Bangladesh ka bhi wahi hal hone wala hai jo pakistan ka hai....
shekh hasina
balance kar ke chal rhi thi..India china or rashiya ...sab ko sath lekar chalti thi...
This happens when you learn from madarsa & get your economics degree.
Stop sending msgs on WhatsApp 😂😂
اسکی ایک بڑی وجہ یہ ہے کہ ہماری آبادی ۱۹۵۵ کے بعد چھ گنا بڑھی ہے جبکہ انڈیا اور بنگلہ دیش کی آبادی ساڑھے تین گنا بڑھی۔
ہمارے تمام وسائل آبادی میں ہی خدچ ہو گئے۔
ویسے ۱۹۷۲ سے لیکر ۲۰۱۸ تک پاکستان اور انڈیا کی جی ڈی پی ایک ہی رفتار سے بڑھی۔ یعنی ۳۷ گنا۔ مگر ۱۹۷۲ میں انڈیا کی آبادی ہم سے دس گنا زیادہ تھی اور اب چھ گنا زیادہ رہ گئی ہے اسکی وجہ سے انکہ فی کس آمدنی ہم سے بیس فیصد زیادہ گئی۔
مگر ۲۰۱۸ کے بعد جو ہماری اکانومی کے ساتھ ہوا ادکی مثال ہی نہیں ملتی۔ آجکل ہماری اور انڈیا کی جی ڈی پی میں ایک اور گیارہ کا تناسب ہو گیا ہے جو کہ ۲۰۱۸ تک ایک سے ساڑھے سات کا تھا۔
ہمیں اپنی آبادی کے بارے میں کچھ کرنا پڑے گا۔
ہماری آبادی دنیا کی اوسط کے مقابلے میں دگنی رفتار سے بڑھ رہی ہے۔
قرآن پڑھا کر آبادی کو انسانی وسائل میں تبدیل کیا جا سکتا ہے تو اللہ کی رحمت برسے گی اور پاکستان میں صرف ترقی نظر آئے گی۔ 😅
Kiyon Keh Wahan Khabees Siyasi Jernail Nahi Paaey Jaatey !!!
Science aur education ko important Deni chahiye tabhi koi desh aage jayega 😊
Agreed
A sound and comprehensive analysis by Sethi sahib
Aise economist wahi rakhna Pakistan me.... Don't export such economists like Sethi to India. 😅😂🙏🏻🇮🇳
What's difference in between of Market & markit.
It was not remittance, it was aid given by USA for using paj soil. Now aid stopped, pak economy in doldrums.
India is India❤🇮🇳
Congress ne bahut heart kiya h india ko ..
Oh accha bihari ?
@@TheGreatVivek7oh acha gobar Lindu ?
Najam Sethi (A Khatri-Arora Hindu) 😊
Sethi saab ap 1947 mein convert hue the 😢
No Sethi sahab,it was not ManMohanSingh,it was NarsimhaRao whose liberalisation policies because of which India has progressed.
Read the history this was brainchild of manmohan singh totally risked by himself yes PV narsimha rao was PM but all the credit was attracted towards finance minister manmohan singh
*🕉️ 🚩 🇮🇳 INDIA 🇮🇳 🚩 🕉️*
after india and pakistan atomic blasts in 1998, the indian think-tank had a proper plan how to move forward, but pakistan had no such plan. Indian think-tank plan was to adjust its agents in the pakistan establishment's different institutions. they brought pervez musharraf in power expelling nawaz sharif. and their agents acted fully on indian plans till 2013 as pakistan failed to progress in 15 years time from 1998 to 2013. At one stage in 2012 pakistan was at the brink to lose all economic power due to loadshedding. however in 2013 when nawaz sharif again came back in the power he ended the loadshedding of electricity, and of cng and again put pakistan on the road to progress from 2013 to 2017 despite facing many hurdles from imran khan, who was now playing the role in place of pervez musharraf against pakistan. imran khan is still playing that role and trying to bring pakistan down economically. on the other hand a weak pakistan could not stop india to make progress in last 24 years after the atomic blast due to instability. but ironically no pakistani journalists will speak on this fact including najam sethi. Moreover, the anti pakistan forces know well that they could not fight a conventional war against pakistan due to its atomic power so they made a plan against pakistan to weak it politically and economically from inside and that is going on for the last 24 years.
It's not the Hindu rate of growth it is congress rate of growth especially Nata ji
Correct explanation
Setting Sahib Ji
Mera khass friend v Sethi...per India ch😂😂 Dear I listen 2 u..Good Man🎉🎉🎉
amerika ne takta palt kiya hai or Bangladesh ko lagta hai student ne inklab laya hai...amerika ne aapne katputli ko karshi pr bitha kr Pakistan jesa hal karega 😂😂usne koyi bhi Muslim kantri ko nhi ko nhi baksha to Bangladesh kiya chij hai😂😂
1 doller -300pk rupees and 1doller - 80INR , Indian rupees. It shows the economic disparities
In 19s Pakistani growth was based on US dollars 😂
Yes with us money paid to them
Am sorry, Mr. Sethi, the Indian growth rate for the period you mentioned was 4% to 4.5%, and and not 2% as you refer to, rather maliciously. Actually. an Indian economist found it convenient to term a 4% growth as Hindu rate of growth, although I would think that was blatantly devious him, and has since stuck with that number. Maybe you should correct your mistake.
Pakistan and democracy with secularism, difficult to dream😂😂😂
Why Political Stability is not found in 55 muslim countries? Except few Gulf countries all muslim state are not capable of it?
Najam Sethi is wrong abt Manhon Singh. He took the Model of ASEAN countries. Pakistan has hardly any state owned heavy industry ever that could be privatised😂😂😂😂
Because majority population is Hindu here
ایوب دور میں تو اصلی ترقی اور گروتھ ہوئی لیکن ضیا اور مشرف دور میں صرف امپورٹ کر کے ہم گروتھ ریٹ شو کرتے رہیے۔اور ڈالر امریکہ سے ا رہیے تھے
jab America se funding hoti Afghanistan me Americans apna control karte rahe please correct your knowledge
@@hariomsen2655 of course there is no free lunch.
پاکستان اپنی خدمات امریکہ کو ہمیشہ دیتا رہا ہیے بس ڈالر انے چاہئیں۔
Dr. Manmohan Singh ki likhi huyi books Economics mein aaj v oxford & Harvard mein padhayi jati hai.... ap besak check kr skte hai.... Economist king kaha jata hai Dr. Manmohan Singh ko
Sir you forgot nationalization, huge corruption and IPP families.
Dr. Man Mohan Singh may not be a strong leader to be a PM. But he's one of the best finance minister we had. Especially during IMF bail out days in 1991 he managed very well. Comparing him with Shariff is a biggest disgrace to Dr. Singh.
MASHALLAH
fantastic expert analysis by Najam sethi good job keep it up
Bro You Are Commenting Sarcastically... Ain't It...?
Bahria town will never be Empty bcs Pakistan has consistent income of $50 Billion Dollars a yr ($30 + billion are sent via Pak banks) from 10 millions (coror + ) rich Overseas Pakistanis, a Huge amount...so their families in Pakistan can afford a Bahria town Khi Lifestyle. And soon BRICS will replace the US Doller & soft sanctions on Pak will will go away and we will be able to buy half price Petrol & Gas from Iran (energy superpower next door), Russia & petrol prices will come down in Watan, inshallah...Farhan from Chicago.
Because Pakistan is like Bihar
Ab बिहार को क्यों ghasit रहे हो bihari kafi mehnati or एजुकेशन pe kafi focus karte hain
Zero ka invention Bihar me Hua tha Aaryabhatt Bihar kerehe h Nalanda university Bihar me thi
@@mukeshsinha848 you are ✅. Bihari’s are smart & hardworking but it is destroyed by corrupt politicians
@@sameerranjan446bihar, UP and Jharkhand are a curse for India
Don't insult Bihar by comparing it with failed and bankrupt state Paxtan.
Exam Hall:
Manmohan Singh: Nawaz Bhai, paper me zara apna model dikhana
Nawaz Sharif: Yahan dekhle
Manmohan Singh: Ok bhai.. Privatisation likhna h
U r saying we follow your economic model, then how u become beggar no. 1 and we are aiming for 3 largest economy
Ayesha i luv u ❤️🇮🇳
It appears the hostess already knows what Sethi is likely to say and for how long he will speak. She was busy punching away on the phone confident that her intervention will not be required for quite some time.
He didn't answer the question. He just said things he wanted say even when most of them to orthogonal to the original intent of question.
آپ لوگوں کو کتنی ذِلت اور گالیں کی اور ضرورت ہے ؟
Plz let us know. We will try to fulfill if your requirements are not too much.
We Indians (including me) are obsessed with Pakistan!! We should be competing against Vietnam instead of a failed state!!
Pakistani ko Adam seeker, Christian prince ye ex muslim sameer ka RUclips channel dekhna chaiye, ek saal me rich desh banega.
Phli baat 1990 m india ki halat bhi kharab ho gyi thi or jo Russia ka model tha wo fail ho ra tha or IMF n propose kiya tha ki relief package tb hi milega jab market open hoga foreign markets k liye .. tab se shi hua h mahool
Anchor is using Mobile
Seriously on such a serious Topic
🎉🎉
Najam Sethi (A Khatri-Arora Hindu) 😊
Proud to be a Punjabi Hindu Arora's
Yes no state is neighbor of Pakitan 😂 and south has all Indians
@@80sidd ???
भारत मे growth का मुख्य कारण है लोकशाही.
हमने आतांकि प्रोमोट नही करते थे।
Najam Sethi (A Khatri-Arora Hindu) 😊
Sir aj bhi raj humara hi chalta hai Lahore mein par convert hona pada hinduo ko sethi saab
Mr Sethi,
understand your audience are Pakistanis. But your facts on Indian 1991 reforms have got nothing to do with Pak. Am sure it was a slip of the mind n tongue. You are aware of the Indian economy in doldrums and balance of Payments issue. That is the reason that India opened up its economy based on advise from WB and IMF...........and, it was need based and not out of love for populace of india.
THE CREDIT SHOULD GO TO PV NARASIMHA RAO the PM. MMS just implemented it and saw it through. Read History.
As Bjp supporter I have many disagreements but how can you compare sucessful 10 years of Pm position and 5 years of Finance position of Manmohan Singh compare to Nawaj Sherif who couldn't even completed his 5 year tenure. And his guy former Pakistan Cricket President comparing, It shows the IQ level of Pakistani intellectual
🤣🤣🤣🤣.
sunni deobandi punjabistan Ek Jazbay Wali Qaum 🎉🎉
Because south indian ❤ carry full india economy
Khan Sahab Badshah to nahi ban saktey, magar Khan Sahab to Khan Sahab hein !
Ex BF USA
Currently CHINA
🎉🎉
Best of luck for your Future
Not just better than beggar Pakistan but better than the whole world.
😊
Mirzai qadiani Balmike Lalbaig not Pakistani 😮
Lady is playing with her mobile 😂
Pak Economy issue is socialist business policies. Nationalization of Industries in 1972 killed Pakistan’s economy forever. Due to socialism USSR got chopped in 16 pieces. Best economy system is capitalism not socialism. Government should not get involve in any business Government job is to make business policies. When government gets involved in businesses corruption is Imminent .USA and most developed countries economy is based on capitalism . Privatization is the key of success.
Najam Sethi (A Khatri-Arora Hindu) 😊
KHAN SAHEB KO SAHI SAMJAYA GAHERAIYA BATO ME AAP KI 🎉
Manmohan singh ne Nawas Sharif ka model dekha......Waaah re sethi sahab.. 😂😂🤣🤣