Everything Wrong With Interstellar, Featuring Dr. Neil deGrasse Tyson
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 28 сен 2015
- Delicious snacks? Come get some: naturebox.com/cinemasins
In order to truly dissect the sins of such a massive science fiction film like Interstellar, we once again turned to the smartest astrophysicist we know, Dr. Neil deGrasse Tyson, for assistance. Please check out Neil's StarTalkRadio channel for more awesomeness: / startalkradio
Next week: Something Pixar.
Remember, no movie is without sin. Which movie's sins do YOU want to see recounted?
Tweet us: / cinemasins
Tumble us: / cinema-sins
Call us: 405-459-7466
Reddit with us: / cinemasins
Jeremy's book now available: theablesbook.com
Suggested by Dreamworks Animation
Kung Fu Panda 3 | Official Trailer #1 Merch: teespring.com/stores/cinemasi... 
Кино
Here's another sin removal: on the water planet, the soundtrack in the background has a prominent ticking noise. These ticks happen every 1.4 seconds. Each tick you hear is a whole day passing on Earth.
I haven't seen the movie yet but I'll remember that when I do. Much obliged.
1.26!! Correction loljk
Instagram
499th like!
Really awesome... thank you for that insight
The only wrong thing with this movie is, it didnt win Oscar
Oscar is meant to be won by disgusting movies only.... Sometimes under super rare cases only good ones win it....
Wasn’t even properly nominated for enough!
Addicted to Air ikr
Sentece from man from land of gods
For me, this is the worst sci-fi movie of all the time.
you can tell cinema sins was really reaching in this one; no one can deny this movie was an absolute masterpiece
Couldn’t agree more 😂
It was hard to watch.. never seen this channel before.. but cant they just review actual bad movies… why go after one of the greats
I'll be honest it was garbage
@@rorymilsom1491 the video or the movie?
@@tanar8668 the movie, im sorry but it was hard to watch.
One thing that strikes me is that he only asks about his daughter when he wakes up. Not about his son. He doesn't even ask Murph about him. Poor kid...
Being that she is very old, maybe he assumed Tom was already dead.
But yeah, he didnt seem to care about Tom overall , like when he leaves, it was rather quick goodbye
Donald is around our age now but murph and Tom are his grandchildren and Cooper is kid
Apple of My Eye vs Couch Potato
But seriously, the scene with him watching his messages from his kids was the closest a movie has ever gotten me to crying.
+Danyal Ahmed Did you forget Schindler's List?
+Danyal Ahmed i cried but i was really drunk lol
+Danyal Ahmed i heard that "hachi - a dog's tale" and "grave of the fireflies" do make you cry, haven't seen them yet though ...
+Danyal Ahmed agreed !!!
+Danyal Ahmed I cry an average of 4 times each time I watch that movie lol.
More appropriate title: CinemaSins rags on Interstellar while Neil deGrasse Tyson defends the movie
I agree
Dr.Tyson was cunt too lmao
Better title : CinemaSins being a dumb whiny baby who doesn't understand shit being educated by Dr.Tyson on elementary school science.
Ayush Thumbarathy Calm your ass down and stop being such a fangirl.
Not fully
A movie over 3 hours long and only had 104 sins. That's how you KNOW it was a masterpiece.
A movie that is over 3 hours long and makes no sense is not a masterpiece.
@@WorldifySanity maybe you're just slow? Ever thought of that
@@WorldifySanity Actually it makes perfect sense, maybe you're just not smart enough to understand it
@@WorldifySanity it's less than 3 hours
@@WorldifySanity A lack of intelligence isn't something you boast
IM SO GLAD THEY REMOVED A SIN FOR THE CRYING SCENE... IT BREAKS MY HEART EVERY TIME AND HE DOES THE SCENE SOOOO WELLL
Have a virtual tissue
@@timb1319 thank you…. Aren’t you kind
I missed watching this in a theatre. My biggest sin.
IFKR
I watched this on my crappy laptop and I feel like I just committed a fucking sin.....watching this in the theaters in 3D or 4D would've been an ethereal experience to say the least
Same like all of us
change your name to adolf hitler to make this funny please
@@saphosapien excusme sir ehmmm, 4D?
@@EdumayYT ye
The reason his voice is scratchy is due to sand in his lungs.
Underrated comment
exactly, that’s why his kids end up with bad coughing (a more severe form)
Ah :(
Problem is not scratchy voice but mumbling. Man learn some diction.
Also btw both only seem to affect him, so not sure it was on purpose unless the movie was just very inconsistent which is not that surprising.
*dirt/dust
At 13:34, it's shown in a prior scene that Mann removes his long-range transmitter from the back of his helmet and throws it. Later when Cooper is struggling to breathe he crawls to it and reattaches it.
yes this is true, but Manns transmitter was still in his helmet
@@f80gibbsyou can turn the long range transmitter off and on so Mann just had his off.
@@f80gibbspretty sure earlier on mann turns his off
There is a scene where Brand can hear Cooper and Mann, but Rommily can't and because of that, dies. That is dumb.
This movie is iconic. It's in the same category with Shutter Island, Inception, Dark Knight, Tenet and Prestige. I can watch them many times.
As much as people rag on Tenet, the replayability value is insane. As is with the movies aforementioned.
I still cANt figure out tenet n given up already
@@AshokKumar-rg4ik Just take everything at face value. There's nothing really TO get. The only thing you have to worry about is properly understanding how the reverse time system works and you're good. These movies are meant to confuse you, so don't think you are in the minority.
80% of these are made by Christopher Nolan
In my opinion, this movie tops inception,tenet and prestige
The only Chris Nolan movie better than inception is the dark knight
I think this is the most sins they ever removed
+EontheDemon That's just because it had quite a few things they didn't understand. My gut tells me that instead of doing some research, they simply decided to sin it. I'm also guessing that if they were to do research on everything they didn't understand, it would take twice as long to sin any movie.
+Barry McGeorge the truth is the movie isn't quite as interesting if you research a bit about what they're talking about. It's much more fun to ACT like you know what you're watching than actually know so.
no, they removed all of them on the star wars trailer
+Barry McGeorge But that's specifically why they brought Neil DeGrasse Tyson into this, so that they wouldn't wrongfully sin it for its sicence. I think that's a pretty good solution, what's the point of doing so much research? Most of the sins were related to the story or writing. Above all you shouldn't take these videos too seriously though.
+aR0ttenBANANA96 The movie was pretty accurate on a couple of things though. But since nobody wants to watch "interstellar: the documentary" they had to exaggerate/make up quite a few things to keep the fun factor up. Visually it was a stunning movie and I did enjoy watching it.
In a world running short of food, the protagonist drives his truck through a corn field...destroying acres of corn
The corn was drying up a while before that
The corn was already worthless cuz it was drying up and dead
@@AshishJain-yb1ze bullshit, he sold it because he didn’t want to waste it.
@@AshishJain-yb1ze constraints ? You make me laugh
@@mohit_panjwani and cristopher actually made a profit off the corn 😳
12:51 On programming something to recognize danger, there's ways robots can respond but theres also ways they very specifically cannot respond. Let's say "x" is a robot. X can usually regulate temperature unless its fan is blocked, then user must clear blockage to prevent overheating. There's no way for you to program a "clear the blockage" directive because "blockage" is unspecified internally and externally. There's no way to register exactly how it will be blocked or exactly how it should be cleared. Maybe it's iced over, maybe it's gummed up by tar. Each has a unique cause and solution, which the robot would need to identify before fixing. Unless you programmed every eventuality in the world for it to recognize and respond to, a normal robot wouldn't respond to the unregistered/unidentified problem and thus could be destroyed through something super simple it didn't expect. Say it knew about ice but not tar, then something *unknown and tarry* hits the cooling vent 2 seconds into the mission. Now its overheating thousands of miles away with nobody to fix it. If a human is there, it can find a way to clean the tar off and maybe add programming about the new unknown tar after.
So its not necessarily "the fear of death" rather a robots lack of ability to appropriately, and spontaneously, respond to multiple forms of an unknown lethal force.
It’s always entertaining going back to this video during college(specifically for engineering) and finding myself repeating in my head all the things this movie actually got right when Jeremy tries to sin them before Tyson actually can offer the rebuttals to remove said sins, especially when as a young teen watching this I found myself immediately agreeing with Jeremy only to (about a year later) be astonished at watching this video and hearing all the reasons why it’s not fake. That amazement is why I’m working in engineering so that I can work with and help update the advanced technology that always astounded me growing up.
Dude that's so cool, i feel you on that 100%. i studied astronomy & engineering bc i wanted to live up to my great uncle who was a NASA test pilot during the space race & broke a lot of ground for space travel, but my mom said there was no future market for aeronautical engineers(🤔???!).
Someday i'll switch my major and be a damn engineer and i'll have you to thank for inspiration lol
Dr Neil deGrasse Tyson: hi
Cinemasins: *removes sin*
@@tRuStThEsCiEnCeBiGoT you jealous of NDT?
@@tRuStThEsCiEnCeBiGoT at least it was consensual this time
@Al Castill they would be fine in real life too black holes don't just destroy everything
go look it up
@Al Castill yes your right
Cinemasins only took a single sin off for NDT in the grand total
Interstellar is a *SCI-FI* movie that uses physics theories to make the movie seem like it is real.
Sins count reduced to: 0
It's a steaming piece of shit with a sappy magic realism ending and 1/6 of a Rubik's cube for a sassy robot. Get real.
Sins count reduced to: 1. Logos still exist.
Sins count to 2: Minecraft still exist
@@zimzimzalabim Uh, so what lol?
@@JoHn-gi1lb you kids and your idolatry for every turd Nolan shits out. Lol
2001 A Space Odyssey is looked at more as a piece of art. Interstellar is going to be remembered as an experience. Literally every aspect of this movie, whether its the acting, direction, cinematography, the editing, the sound design, THE MUSIC, set design, and writing(debatable)...is firing on all cylinders. It represents the peak of filmmaking.
Seriously, if you sat down and really thought about "what" this movie is about, like really thought about all its themes, all its layers of depth and what its trying to say, your gonna come to only one conclusion. Its about Everything.
I remember seeing this movie in IMAX on the first day of release, planned it perfectly to make sure i got there early to get center seats and not too close to the screen. Right after Cooper pleads to Dr. Mann not to dock and then Mann blew himself up, Cooper accelerates towards the Endurance and Dr. Brandt then asks Cooper what he's doing, and he just says..."docking" (Cue Hanz Zimmer's score). I lost my shit in the theater, I got goosebumps and literally leaned forward and audibly said pretty loudly "what...the...fuck!?!". As the scene went on I remember thinking, Nolan... you crazy bastard , you just cranked the intensity up to a 10. Then the music tipped it over to an 11. That moment, that sequence with that music and the sound just blasting. Sensory Overload...I will never forget the experience
so glad i'm not the only one that capitalizes Everything when referring to... well, _Everything_
I hope I could see it in theaters too, after understanding interstellar ,it became my no1 movie of all time and the music is just Mesmerizing
2001 IS an experience, and as cool as this movie is, there's a good amount of Hollywood cheese to it.
Do you comment this on every video about interstellar?
Its an overrated movie
The truck can still drive because its a dually. You can clearly see at 0:44 that it has 4 wheel on each end of the axle. Meaning that if one of them goes flat, the truck can still drive. Disappointed that Neil missed this. 🤦♂️🤦♂️
I love CinemaSins but I love Interstellar even more.
Bob Longhorn it’s the type of movie to make you stare at a wall for 20 minutes afterwards and question whether someone in the future is controlling you
I have a love/hate relationship with Interstellar. On one hand its amazing. On the other, it made me go into 2021 crying.
Lol Seems like you are pulling a ngeke sizwe ngawe
@@Sakhephi 😂
Yea I’m not of fan of this kind of format, it’s not for everyone.
I could not agree more about the scene where he saw his kids age 23 years in an instant being absolutely heartwrenching. If I had to go thru that, I would cry like I've never cried before. Very powerful scene.
It must've been harder for his kids and every other human on Earth tho. It was like 3 hours for them but 23 years of living for the others. But it must've been the hardest for the other astronauts waiting for 23 years in space.
@@OXIR You mean the one astronaut? There was only one that was waiting for them & yeah I agree, that must have been torturous. I am honestly surprised that he hadn't gone crazy or hadn't killed himself or something. Instead he seemed relatively normal when they got back.
@@skins4thewin yeah I thought they were 2 guys
@@skins4thewin also, that one guy could at least put himself to sleep whenever he liked
Except it didn't take them 3 hours in that planet. Or at least that's not what it seemed. The whole scene lasted less than 20 minutes. Are we supposed to asume they did something else in the planet? Maybe they decided to take surfing lessons! (The scene where he cries is awesome though).
5:04 didnt cooper station end up near saturn when cooper finally arrived? im assuming humanity in the milky way continued evolving at that station and was able to create the wormhole there, which is why it's near saturn. seems odd to consider that a sin, i think its a pretty cool detail
That's what I thought too, they wanted to be as close as possible to the next system without being near the black hole
.
A lot of the science related sins were adressed in the movie, like the one about communicating in the tesseract. The movie explicitly states that the only way coop can communicate with his daughter is through manipulating gravity, and that he cant actually go into the past to “pass a note” or talk to his daughter. Also i feel like any sins relating to the inside of the black hole shouldnt count as its entirely theoretical
Exactly. Also many of the sins about "How did they get that far?" and whatnot can just be explained as cuts to make the movie a bit shorter and aren't actual errors in the movie
How did he encode gravitational information into the watch enough for it to be decoded after the tesseract closed? The physical reality of 3D world is not effected by the manipulation of gravity. This movie had dumb science and.plot holes.
So Matt Damon is stranded on another planet, awaiting rescue. Sounds familiar.
If only it was true
The best potential line in movie history wasted..."Oh no! Not AGAIN!"
The best unsaid line in movie history - "OH NO! NOT AGAIN!"
Are we not going to talk about how murph was an astronaut for a little while? When she accidentally left Matt? And then saved him? Are we not going to talk about THAT?!
ha! lol
How is leaving Earth via worm whole easier than fixing Earth?
Have you ever watched a political debate?
In fact, this explains how you convince 17.4 million Brits to leave the EU...
People like you are the reason our earth is like this
because they need a literally new planet, and the wormhole was put there by "them" to help them find it, which is why they refer to the beings in the movie as "them" only to find out in the end, they were "them" from a different time... or... a different dimension (could be different time), so the people who were helping them.. were actually them.. from the future. only thing i dont get is that this would be a loop in time.. their future selves save their past selves.. who grow older to be those same people who saved them.. so it keeps looping.. thats what i dont get lmao.. its called a causal nexus. but im pretty sure i got some of this wrong lmao
Chase M it’s called the predestination paradox. But you’re right there are many different paradox’s that explain why traveling back in time is impossible.
Seb Beast hmmm well I’m glad you told me that gag at least I know now. I guess the flash taught me wrong hahaha
What’s a sin is that you did not removed any sin for the incredible score Hans Zimmer did for this film
You know a movie is a perfect when the biggest complaint is that the actors are in other movies
You can’t write a note, the film explains he can only affect gravity across the dimensions. Plus HE DOESN’T HAVE A PENCIL AND PAPER
The girl had pen and paper and is seen writing, which he could move using gravity and make it float and write in her notebook. It's not like that because the author didn't want it to be.
@@trinidad17 or because he can only influence gravity the way it naturally flows so he can't work against it but only with it. Also he could barely affect it to settle dust in lines. I think that making a wingardium leviosa and magically writing a note would be nearly impossible given the restraints he had that are very well researched. Imagine trying to piss up the rain the write your name on the raincloud.
He hits the bookshelf, the shelf bends down with the sudden gravity pull and springs up with less force ejecting the books way less than if he hit them directly. If he hit them directly like that and it was translated to gravity they'd fly across the room.
The part that confuses me is how does he move the books and the watch hand because that's not gravitational is it? Someone pls help
@@VanBourner It's Leviosah, not Leviosa
@@dipbeats4782 He affected the local gravity of the book, temporarily making it heavier then releasing it making it normal gravity again which created a very small net force which was enough to move the book. Moving the watch hand is him manipulating gravity's ability to distort spacetime :)
CinemaSins: 104 Sins in Interstellar
Comment section: 16900 Sins in this Video
I'd say that only 2 sins were deserve
"Remove 104 sins for soundtrack!"
13:23 if you watched the movie you would've watched the movie you could've seen that Dr Mann throws cooper's comms piece away
14:16
Cooper: "What happens if he blows the airlock?"
TARS: "Nothing good."
CinemaSins: "Thanks for a helpful and precise answer."
TARS has a discretion setting.
The fact that the movie was able to create a visual representation of the Black Hole before we got our first picture of a black hole just through math
Edit : Looks like we have some astronomers in the comment section
Edit 2: Looks like after 10 months the argument finally ended, 200 replies later
Edit 3: make that 300 additional replies
And they did a pretty good job too
I can't write it coz its too long but the story about creating it is just amazing
They actually passed that to scientist and they’ve got 2 research notes from that...
@@jirivycpalek9285 Actually in 1919indian mathematician Ramanujan briefly explained Black hole even before that term came into exsist
We don't have any pics of black holes. We have a pic of something unscientifically speculated to be a black hole. There is no means of confirming what it is. That's not fact, it's pseudoscience.
All jokes aside, very grateful to be alive during the time this movie was produced. I literally think about some aspect of it everyday
Me too!
Dude! If your grateful to be alive just cause of this movie I hope you get more out of life than just a made up movie. Not sorry😐
@@leep1285 You don't have to be a dick about it to tell him that you idiot.
Lee P okay boomer
Watch 2001 a space odyssey, interstellar is just a stupid copy of it
It was clear you were kinda struggling to find sins in that movie. It is truly a masterpiece.
104?
The movies a joke.
@@oddjob914 I rate this troll a 4/10 simply because it can make people angry.
You have no idea what 'masterpiece' means. You clearly have watched less than 10 movies in your life.
@@oddjob914In every reply to every comment I swear theres just one person that says this movie sucks and then when asked how they never explain. Theres a 90% chance you liked the movie and 10% that you didnt watch it
Sins 57 to 59. EXACTLY. The way the scene played out was NOWHERE near 3 hours. Barely an hour had gone by. They knew time was precious so they are out of the ship as soon as they land. Walk about 200 meters to the crash site before a wave descends upon them. Matthew's character is still wet and they are both breathing hard before the next wave is upon them. I have no problem with them being down there for 3 hours, but at least edit the scene so it feels like 3 hours have passed. If the 45 to an hour is how long before the next wave comes along or how long before they can start the engines, that still would not account for a 3 hour period on the planet. It was either badly written or badly edited. I had the same issue with the playing of time in Dunkirk. The "week" at The Mole did not feel like a week. It felt like it played out over the course of the night.
I'd knock down a sin for this movie muting the explosions in outer space to give us that feeling of space's emptiness and FINALY some realism concerning outer space and sound (or lack of it).
Yeah that moment was incredible in IMax(the real one). It was extremely well done.
+MrKlausbaudelaire 2001: A Space Odyssey did that 47 years ago... and Gravity did it one year before Interstellar... hardly an amazingly intelligent and original decision.
WheresWallace4883 Not really... 2001 had that annoying breathing and Gravity actually did have sounds in the vaccuum of space... so....
Wraith Wrecker
not ot mention the sceens where they cut the sound actualy scared people more than a sudden explosion xD
MrKlausbaudelaire Pretty much though. XD
You gotta admit, even with any plot holes and scientific inaccuracies, it was a fantastic movie.
+Iamthedeception To you maybe. This was just another "OHHHH NOLAAANNN ISSS A GEEENIIIUSSS" hype train of a movie. It was a 6.5/10 to me. Predestination was a lot better.
+RB Gamer Well, I guess it's all a matter of opinions. Really, this was only my second Nolan movie after TDK Rises, but I can see why people don't like Nolan being worshipped as a director.
+Iamthedeception I like Memento, Prestige and inception. TDKR was HORRIBLE! Success got to his head. It all seems like pretentious garbage now.
***** Wow. Well, like I said, opinions. Even though a lot of people disagree with me, I actually find Interstellar to be a damn near perfect film and it sits at the #1 spot of my favorite movies.
Maybe it's just because it feels like a modernized 2001, or maybe I'm just a huge Nolan fanboy.
Iamthedeception Haha I know. Was never knocking you. But I just detest those loud Nolan fanboys. For eg:
Nolanite: WOW! I just saw Interstellar. It was amazing. Nolan is a genius!
Friend: Oh ? What's the story ?
Nolanite: It is an awesome movie. Nolan is a legend. He should direct the next spiderman movie.
When you realize that on millers planet, this movie has barely been out for longer than an hour
The gravitational force needed to slow time to the point where 1 hour equates to 7 years would crush them and the ship to the surface. Not just make walking a little difficult. But who cares, it makes for an amazing scene
One of many plot holes overlooked not mention that said “ Miller planet existing beside that kinda of Blackhole”
It wouldn't, because it's not the gravity of the planet that is slowing them, it's the gravity of the black hole.
They don't feel it in their inertial frame of reference because both they and the planet are being equally pulled by the gravitational force. Relative to an outside observer (like people on Earth, perhaps), there is an extremely large gravitational force which makes the astronauts appear significantly slower to them. In other words, if you could watch them from earth, you'd see them moving in slow-motion.
Thanks to Dr. Tyson for his knowledge, sense of humor, and his time! (Only a little bit disappointed he couldn't help us understand how the three seashells work.)
you really got tyson to say we never went to the moon ... wtf is wrong with you
+Wesley Tomsky I don't think he was saying we never went to the moon, I think he's saying our science classes in school are shitty and outdated.
+CinemaSins Now I am confused do you think the moon landing is faked or real?
I saw Neil Degrasse Tyson the other day at my school. It totally freaked me out.
+AlexD19931 thank you for clearing that up, I paused it, wtf did NDT just say?! haha my bad.
If the robot states that it is 90% truthful, is that statement only 90% true? Is the robot actually only 81% truthful?
You have to ask it settings 100 times and 10 of those 100 times it will be not true!
But if it's only 81% truthful, then that 90% would become 72,9%, but if it's only 72,9% truthful, then that 90% would become 65,61%, but if it's only...
LOL
No.
The more relevant issue is; what happens if the answer itself is part of the 10% not truthful, which would in turn mean "fuck you human, I says what I wants" because robots can't be trusted EVER!
All jokes aside, I LOVE this film. Despite its flaws I love everything about this movie, mostly the music
There is a gargantuan sin at the heart of this movie.
While in the black hole/tesseract Cooper says “They” (meaning some unknown aliens) didn’t bring them there, but “We brought ourselves.” - implying that humans from the future gave them the wormhole eventually leading to the tesseract. Which of course begs the question, if future humans exist, then why would they need saving in the past at all?
Finally done one says it. Ty
Empathy, I guess. And also closed time loops
I'd day it's most likely the closed timeloops. I feel as if Cooper addresses this as well. When he talks about him being the ghost, shaking brands hand, and the created space. with "we brought us here" feels to me as a double meaning.
No way you are sinning the absolutely jaw dropping foreshadowing of the "I don't think the bookshelf is trying to talk to you"
Yeah they will. It’s not a marvel movie so it’s not good enough (I hate marvel)
@@blitzium709 jaw dropping? You mean hack-y and obvious ?
@@toziassmitt this movie is like a test that exposes weather people actually dissect the plot, writingx and intracacies of a story, vs. people who get amazed by visuals and ignore everything else.
@@xXxXcrosbykidXxXx it’s such a hack film, honestly
@@xXxXcrosbykidXxXx at the end when cooper is in the black hole and it was like like plaid, I instantly realized it was the bookshelf and everything about the bookshelf made sense
13:34 Its because Matt Damons character removed the long range transmitter from Mcconaughey's helmet.
Vouching! The little black plastic thing! Pulled it right off and dropped it on the ground!
Church! Wait, which one? Alpha, the Epsilon, the Director.. I MUST KNOW!
shouldn't you be playing at bloodgulch with Caboose and Sheila?
I thought the same thing, was jsut coming down here to comment it.
So take that sin back
15:54
I'm surprised you didn't mention the fact that an intergalactic spacecraft had an ejection seat to begin with.
You would think the engineers would save the extra space / utility for something else lol
Something else like... a safety system for landing on a foreign planet so the pilot onboard doesnt crash and burn. Remind you of a certain utility called ejector seats?
It's been 8 years already but I still think about this movie to this day. Hell, I'm glad it's still alive and popular especially with tiktok using Hans Zimmer's amazing soundtrack for videos. Shows that if something's a masterpiece, it'll be revered as rightfully so.
“How does a computer so exactly calculate its humor setting?” 75% = a joke in every 3 out of 4 phrases, much like your videos 😉
Ouch lol
Just like 3/4th of the movie is a joke
@@tarunv24 You tried.
@@LuManKrix that's more effort than the storywriters of this film
@@tarunv24 yeah I know, because you are trying too hard
At the docking scene you should have just reset the sin counter.
Nicolas Brandon I thought that the (as far as we know) accurate representation of travelling through a wormhole was already one of the greatest cinematic moments in my memory. Apart from the wave-planet. And the tesseract. And the ice-planet.... Okay, I admit it, this is probably my most favorite movie ever created and I think it's perfect!
Nicolas Brandon I also LOVE that there was no sound in space. Like, it's such a little thing, but so many movies forget that simple rule. This is such a great movie
Neekimu Jardim there is sound in space, just electromagnetic movements that are captured in special instruments. Well, you can say there is no sound in space because there is no air
Basically, this movie is the best thing ever
There are no sound waves in space.
Every single one of those sins was a very emotionnally powerful scene that you dont have the ability to comprehend
There were definitely a few sins that can be attributed to not paying attention. For instance when “space scientist explains wormholes to space scientist” you missed the part where Cooper ISN’T a scientist but a pilot. Or “why don’t they have comms?” When Mann just seconds before rips the comm attachment off Coopers helmet. There’s a few more of these.
Interstellar; the only movie where the revoked sins actually impacted the total.
lol
I love this comment almost as much as the video itself
lol. so true
I actually enjoyed how they removed sins for the ton of things the movie got scientifically right.
Probably one of the reasons why I enjoy this movie so much.
why did i read the og comment in Dr. Tysons voice?
extra sin: Matt's grandchildren and their kids and kids' kids etc. all seem to ignore him for the most part when he's in his daughter's hospital room. this is their ancestor who is a walking breathing miracle and their forefather whom they've never met and they barely acknowledge him.
Yes and it’s for that reason that they don’t acknowledge him.
@@Olamidayo Not to mention he's the one that actually helped his daughter with the right black hole data and saved the whole human race. So at least if the family doesn't remember him the NASA guys would have portrayed him as a hero and he would definitely be shown in media or museum like in Cap America or the daughter would have shown his photos to her children and grand children at least.
I totally back this call, I thought the same thing. I think there was kids there, they would have been asking questions for sure.
i assumed it was because they were giving him and murph the moment they deserved. someones deathbed isn’t really the best time to have a happy family reunion, especially if it’s the first time they’re seeing each other in YEARS
@@abby9448 once you have kids its the kids who take point. his grandchildren diserved to know there grandfather lol
I feel vad for the people who go to watch movies with him
Please more Dr. Tyson his facts make me chuckle like hell
Everything Wrong With interstellar
Answer: Nothing...
it's too long
should be even more longer
It's full of stars!
No, this movie had a lot of faults with it. Yes, it's a beautifully designed with an amazing score reminiscent of 2001: A Space Odyssey. Yes, it has an incredible cast and took the time to put a lot of real scientific explanation to appear more realistic. However, as CinemaSins puts it, no movie is without sin. Although many of the sins listed are jokes, there are some minor plot holes and I'm pretty sure that going into a black hole would just simply kill you, not put you in a tesseract.
Mattaboy correct
Hooooow can you sin the daughter goodbye scene? Cried like a baby
Nahhhhhh. Personally, she annoyed me as a kid.
tejbz she annoyed me thou
tejbz Thumbs up for MW2 nostalgia
***** for real though, dems goooood times
Hi Tejbz!!! I also cried at that scene.
My roommate dragged me to see this film after he had already seen it, saying beforehand, it was already his favorite film of all time. And I'm glad I got to see it in theaters. Seeing the black hole blew me away.
The banter of Jeremy trying to sin this and having sins removed via “science” always gets me.
The saying goodbye to his daughter scene was long, but absolutely necessary imo.
He gave her the watch that helped fix earth in this scene, he gave her a promise that she held all her life in this scene. Think twice
Yeah, that scene and him seeing her older than him were unique concepts I've never seen in a movie before, or anything at all. Those should've had sins taken off.
Honestly I don't know why people cant sit and watch movies that are longer than 2 hours these days.
If anything it definitely makes the money you spent going to the theater more worth it!
Especially if it was in IMAX.
Unless it's transformers
+s Moon Simple solution....dont watch the movies. It always kills me how people can buy something they didnt want and then complain about it. That was the 4th Transformers movie. Are you going to tell me you didn't know what you were getting when you watched the trailers and purchased your ticket anyway? Such stupidity.
+Autry Hicks I never saw it, but I know people who made the mistake of seeing it
+s Moon Commenting on a movie you've never seen is even worse.
+MAXZONE47 IMAX 3D hurts my eyes after a while. It feels a bit like going cross eyed for a long period of time. Especially considering I have to wear the 3D glasses over actual eyeglasses.
Also you could consider that long movies like that may have slow pacing or some other problem and that could be a factor. Its an assumption bias: all 3hr+ movies are slow and boring.
Most of these sins are just "I don't know how that works" that have explanations.
"I couldn't understand the physics behind the movie" *adds 100 sins* 💀
Still love this movie. Now I feel like re-watching it for the 100th time.
Keno Clayton I have seen it many times as well lol
Well they obviousely love movies in general too or they wouldn't have done this channel. additionally, they do this to pretty much every movie, they aren't selective to genre or movies
Keno Clayton.. I watched it 5 times the week I bought the BluRay!! I have seen it a total of 23 times. It never gets old and I love the score!!! I watch the whole credits just for the score!!! It's what a masterpiece should make you feel. The music completely encompasses the way I feel!! I never want it to end.
Star Wookie I know what you mean. Never gets old!
Agreed, fellow fan!
"Thelma and Louise'ing" as a verb. That's a cinema win.
It should be in the Oxford Dictionary.
"Thelma-and-Louising"- vb. Driving your car of a cliff
+ReaderGamerSinger Urban Dictionary maybe?
+ReaderGamerSinger spoilers!!
Christian Pizzasegola Don't worry. The dictionary will come with an spoiler alert.
+ReaderGamerSinger too bad it won't tell you when to use "a" instead of "an"
I’m fairly new to the channel but I’m soooooo glad NGT didn’t pull a Kevin Smith on this one. He stayed in his lane and let the comedians be funny on their own show. Amazing amazing video!
Did y'all notice how as the wave gets closer on millers planet the music gets more intense and as it passes it eases off
I thought Cooper communicated through the tesseract using gravity, that's why he couldn't send a note. Been a while since I've seen the movie, but if iirc that's what was said.
+Lyndon Underwood That's exactly what I think
+Lyndon Underwood Considering that they established that gravity can bend time (which is true, but they stretched the definition a little bit with that scene, I have to say...) that is very probable. Still, you can write a note using gravity, just not..push it through or something.
+Lyndon Underwood That is correct my friend
+Lyndon Underwood How can you program the hands of a watch using gravity, though? It doesn't seem like the most plausible solution.
+TheRobot181 By creating a brief increase in gravity on the watch hand's trailing side, you can delay its forward motion and imprint a pattern. Total scifi bunk but that's how it works in the movie.
The Truck is a "dually" - that is, two tires on each side of the rear axle. If one tire on one side is flat, the other tire will work just fine if there is no heavy load in the back, which there wasn't.
Beat me to it, good call though!
+Joe Blow it's a Dodge, and those trucks with a six speed have a manual mode, although it's not with a clutch or anything
+Thomas Maresh That doesn't explain how they could drive fast enough through a cornfield to keep eyes on an aircraft that flies at around 100 knots.
+Alex Mills It's called a sequential gearbox.
Not to mention it makes 850+ lb*ft of torque.. And weighs over 8,000 pounds. But overall it means nothing when talking about relativity and what happens when traveling through the unknowns of space/time.
funny as always lol, lots of good points, but if you watch kip thorne’s talks, some of the science sins won’t be sins. also he knew about edmund’s and brandt’s relationship because brandt did have a tell. edmund’s was the only one she referred to with his first name, for the others she used their last names. also in the scene with the indian drone, he got control over the drone right before the emergency stop and sent it back behind them. that’s why it flies back into view after they stopped and got out.
1 hour has passed on Miller's planet since this video was uploaded.
at 13:34, they can't hear Dr. Mann's comms because he switched his long range off. (it shows him doing this right before they jump down the hill) :P
A Purrson Dass actually cool
I agree like hes not even paying attention to the movie
And then ripped it off
@@adabuyukbay8060 he’s doing it one purpose to be able to give more sins, it’s for entertainment purposes he’s likely we’ll aware that’s it’s explicitly shown about the transmitter.
I did’t mind waiting 45 minutes for them to reach the space, because those were beautiful 45 minutes and I enjoyed it.
LET'S JUST FORGET THT THE MOVIE MAKES NO SENSE AND SEE IT'S SINS
@@sumreensultana1860 symp
Interstellar is one of the most over-hyped bullshit movie. People went to watch the movie, didn't know how to criticise the flaws of the movie. Because they will be labeled as dumb, it'll make them look bad in front of others. Then next batch of people went to watch it, based on first batch's feedback, watched it, came back and didn't accept the fact the movie is shit. The cycle went on and the movie became hit. Classic scam.
@@TheCommonSenseForRegularPeople in your opinion
@@hood6089 of course it is. Everyone has their own opinion, you can like it or dislike it.
Here is one you missed. When they start the trip, one of the astronauts develops motion sickness. Another astronaut goes to get Dramamine (dimenhydrinate) for him. However, Dramamine is more properly used as a preventative measure. A person who is prone to motion sickness would take one or two doses starting at least one hour before travel. The better choice for active motion sickness is Phenergan (promethazine).
You obviously missed a few things. The book case thing where he was able to manipulate the watch and push the books by creating gravity waves which supposedly travel through time. So he wasn't physically passing through the tesseract to push books.
The reason he could reach inside the glass is due to the function of the fourth and fifth dimensions. Just like how in 3d you could reach into the internal organs of a 2d creature, the same logic can be applied to the third dimension. It’s just hard to understand since we don’t see any more dimensions, but a 4d/5d creature would be able to reach inside any 3d object. Since he is in a 5d dimension, he’s able to reach into the glass on the watch.
Interstellar is one of the most over-hyped bullshit movie. People went to watch the movie, didn't know how to criticise the flaws of the movie. Because they will be labeled as dumb, it'll make them look bad in front of others. Then next batch of people went to watch it, based on first batch's feedback, watched it, came back and didn't accept the fact the movie is shit. The cycle went on and the movie became hit. Classic scam.
@@TheCommonSenseForRegularPeople the movie is based on a great theory. no one said it was true but things were explained convincingly and the whole concept is just genius. i don't know why you dislike this movie so bad but i think it's quite enjoyable and definitely not bullshit.
@@TheCommonSenseForRegularPeople My reply had nothing to do with the movie itself/my opinion on it, but rather multiple dimensions.
@@TheCommonSenseForRegularPeople that's amazing bro lemme just go through the wormhole so i can find someone who asked
There is no such thing as any dimension other than the three dimensions. Don't kid yourself
Sins off for the Soundtrack!!!
That’s so awesome to hear my uncle put it together
@@-acpanda-1829 r/thathappened
Then put a sin back for the volume they play it at.
@@maximiliannast5962 r/ihavereddit
good lord no, that sucks.
and after a science degree, 25 years of work experience, and growing up a farmer, with quantum physics books in my library......this movie is both fun and tugged at the heartstrings.......if i had a heart (science majors have to generally shift that work to the liver, it's a long story.....)
Never got to see this in theaters, but you better believe I’m getting the nicest possible projector and screen so I can watch this on my own ‘big screen’!
Cinema sins: everything wrong with interstellar
*THE COUNCIL HAS FOUND YOUR SIN UNFORGIVEABLE*
Did I just get rickrolled?
@@brendorkusaviation8930 yes
People take it too seriously
Thank you, Rick Astley.
Hey Rick
At Sin 82, the reason why the rest couldn't hear the communication between Matt and Matthew was because Matt took off his helmet radio chip. Whatever you call that.
+Ryan B. Yeah I was about to comment this. You see him do it. C'mon Cinemasins, pay attention lol
+Ryan B. gnip!
+Rob Taylor the sin is that they can't hear dr. Mann
+Ryan B. who
+TehMightyWhale he can shut it down, he couldn't force Cooper to do it too, so he ripped it off.
THIS MOVIE IS INCREDIBLE. It crushed my heart. Never cried so hard.
I'm glad I gave this movie a second shot because it really was a pretty good movie!
CinemaSins: *sins movie*
Neil deGrasse Tyson: "I'mma stop ya right there kiddo."
"Can we just all agree that they're good astronauts who will do all the technical things that astronauts do and get moving already?"
No, no we can't. Because in any other video you would have sinned them for NOT showing you these types of things.
Someone's a interstellar annoying fanboy
@@delta-bird-thing-donkeysir506 ummmmm
he is right tho
@@delta-bird-thing-donkeysir506 ironic
@@delta-bird-thing-donkeysir506 to be fair jeremy does that and he also manipulates scenes he show for extra sins, sins characters for things the movie also say are wrong because its supposed to be character buildings, sins things he likes, makes Pop culture references he makes into sins of the movie and much more
@@Bruh-hq1hx so? Jeremy literally admits to things like that and he says that people shouldn't take his sins seriously but people still do for some reason
THANK you... I recently watched this movie and can't unsee it now
Kip is actually a name given to a character in one of Robert a heilene's books have suit will travel
Fun fact, during the time they were in Miller's planet (water planet), every 1.25 seconds, you can hear a tick. Every one of those ticks is a day passing on Earth compared to the time flow they experience there. I did the math and one hour of those ticks is around seven years. Love the attention to detail!
It says one hour is seven years IN the movie
@@thatoneguy9666 What the fuck are you talking about? That's what he's saying, one hour of the ticks equals seven years. That fact doesn't change between the movie and reality.
@@psychoticAjAX yea, he said “I did the math and one hour of those ticks is around seven years”. My point was hes either lying about doing the math or he wasted a bunch of time considering they say it in the movie
@@psychoticAjAX also, calm down bro
@@thatoneguy9666 he isn't lying about the math. He's proving that the movie is accurately depicting something. A lot of movies gloss over that shit, and it's often not right. This movie got it right
-Asks why the Aliens put the wormhole so inconveniently far away from earth.
-Proceeds to answer his own question by contemplating: "doesn't a wormhole possibly affect the gravity of the region?"
-Still gives the movie 2 sins for his own ignorance
For being decently well spoken this guy isn't too bright.
>people who take cinemasins seriously and think the sins they give have any real meaning or value
+S E L A W Z
>people who give other people excuses for their hypocritical tendencies.
and that is why they say that it's paradoxical, and cinemasins is just for fun.
I mean they say it themselves, the sins mean nothing. They're comedians, not scientists or movie reviewers.
Agreed +The9theMan99. There are many cliches that deserve sins, but there were more than a few times coincidences are later explained... The physics is fairly accurate in the movie from what I'm aware, even though the writers used it creatively and added a bit of plot magic
Fun fact, they grew that corn, then sold it for a profit after filming the movie
Damn right you take a sin off for the crying scene. He didn't even play it and just the two seconds it was on the screen made me instantly remember it and my eyes were welling up again. That's how impactful it was. 💥
Am I the only one who thinks that a fear of death would probably be easier to program into a robot than a versatile sense of humor?
+Jason Brown nop
No
+Jason Brown Given how the fear of death is just adding an emotional component to self preservation, something there are already computer programs out there which have in their code, we could theoretically make a machine afraid of death right now if we put a bit of money into it.
Humour, on the other hand, not so much.
+Jason Brown "Chances are 42% percent I'll suffer fatal damage"
+Mychael Howard Siri's sense of humor is scripted though. I'm sure people are asking for 'intrinsic' (for lack of term) humor. In otherwords, Siri 'naturally' understanding why something is funny, instead of just going by input.
The moment Siri says something hilarious without being poked and prodded to do so, is the moment I'll bow down to our new robot overlords, though.
Ok so, he pretty much tried to sacrifice himself by jumping into a black hole. I'm not %100 sure, but I don't think that you'll have a handy dandy pencil and paper to make a note
That is the the most irritating plot hole of all time other than the entirety of the star wars prequels
He could rip pages out of the 100s of books and make some sort of note. I'm sure he could find, "It's Dad" or something like that or "I'm here"
So you would be calm and composed in that situation? Wow man they should've had you write the script, wouldve been much better if he just told her so they didn't have to shoot any of the movie
But there wasnt a pencil and paper inside the room that he could indirectly affect, like the watch hand or the books?
Thats not how it works.
What we saw in the movie was a 3d image of different times happeneing at different points.
Interacting with the tessaract isnt phyically interacting with the objects, it is just creating gravitational anomalies at the point in time you create them.
It dosent process physical objects, so you couldnt grab a book and pull it through, or write a note and pass it through to the other side.
*Solution for SIN NUMBER 94:*
Cooper can only affect gravity,
therefore Cooper cannot transfer things between the parties, neither a page nor a sound.
Thus, it can be said that pushing the books is only a *symbolic act that causes gravitation, over which he has control.*
The only sin in the movie was the Love Transcending space and time thing.
13:36 Dr. Mann disabled Coopers long range radio. It was a small device attached to his helmet.
Mann disconnected it and threw it before pushing Cooper down the slope.
He switched his own off.
Its like he didn’t watch the movie properly... ig that explains why he’s criticising it
I'm surprised they missed that, they clearly show it in the movie.
For real man, at least be fair on your strikes smh
Your right but to be fair Dr. Mann still had his
Neil deGrasse Tyson has a voice like butter.
There you are again!!!
This video made my legs feel weak
I loved that Gravity Falls episode where he played Waddles after he become super smart.
+The swifter Arms spaghetti
I'd like to sleep on a bed made out of morgan freemans voice
There's no way you could communicate via radio in such a strong gravitational field.
I always love the sudden Wes Bentley in every movie his in.