Billie Eilish - NDA (Official Live)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 14 июл 2021
- Listen to “NDA” from the new album “Happier Than Ever”, out now: BillieEilish.lnk.to/HappierTh...
Follow Billie Eilish:
Facebook: BillieEilish.lnk.to/Facebook
Instagram: BillieEilish.lnk.to/Instagram
Twitter: BillieEilish.lnk.to/Twitter
TikTok: BillieEilish.lnk.to/TikTok
RUclips: / billieeilish
Email: smarturl.it/BillieEilishEmail
Store: smarturl.it/BillieEilishStore
Lyrics:
Did you think I'd show up in a limousine? No
Had to save my money for security
Got a stalker walking up and down the street
Says he's Satan and he'd like to meet
I bought a secret house when I was 17
Haven't had a party since I got the keys
Had a pretty boy over, but he couldn't stay
On his way out, made him sign an NDA
Yeah, I made him sign an NDA
Once was good enough
'Cause I don't want him having shit to say
You couldn't save me, but you can't let me go, oh, no
I can crave you, but you don't need to know
30 Under 30 for another year
I can barely go outside, I think I hate it here
Maybe I should think about a new career
Somewhere in Kauai where I can disappear
I've been having fun, getting older now
Didn't change my number, made him shut his mouth
At least I gave him something he can cry about
I thought about my future, but I want it now
Want it now
You can't give me up
You couldn't save me, but you can't let me go, oh, no
I can crave you, but you don't need to know
Did I take it too far?
Now I know what you are
You hit me so hard
I saw stars
Think I took it too far
When I sold you my heart
How'd it get so dark?
I saw stars
Stars 
Видеоклипы
The auto tune being only during the beat drop is so fucken cool tbh, it gives the song a more dramatic feeling
thats what i thought!!
Ikr
ruclips.net/video/YXGQP4WkeJc/видео.html
I thought the same! It gives me goosebumps everytime
@@giupi4742 same, chillssss
This is gonna be crazy at concerts. I'd kill to witness this live.
IKR
IM GOING TO SEE IT IN MARCH
@@buckbeltzer6137 UR LIVING EVERYONES DREAM OMG
@@gemmanolan3548 RIGHT IM SO EXCITED WTH
I'm going to see her in a few months!!!!
FYI the autotune isn’t used to fix her vocals, we all know damn well Billie can sing. In this case it’s used as an audio effect, it adds to the song. It’s put on the track on purpose.
exactlyyyy
still not working
@@antoniogcj0515 cry
THANK YOU. I couldn’t agree more.
@@Soplap well, the effect _is_ autotune, not just distortion, but it's indeed not made to fix her voice, it's an artistic choice
Am I the only one absolutely obsessed with Billie singing the second voice/harmony in the second chorus? HELLO???????
It's soooo freaking cool
It makes me wish you could hear it better in the recorded version
ruclips.net/video/YXGQP4WkeJc/видео.html
I AM
I’m in love with that part
why do people say she sucks with autotune?? finneas and her are just experimenting with her voice, she has proven she doesn’t need effects on her voice and it shouldn’t always be a voice competition. anyway, stan finneas and billie 🤍
isnt she using vocoder? sorry if i’m wrong but it sounds like she’s using that and not autotune
Yo haciendome la que habla inglés xd te amo aureal y Billie eilish!
If she does use autone, does it matter? She already proof everybody she is one of the best singers in the industry.. what if Ariana wants o use Autotune.she i will be an excellent singer still.
Aureal amo tus traducciones
@@lomejorsoyyo7045 it’s vocoder not even autotune
i actually love the vocal production on this record
ruclips.net/video/7cQNXcJQ0xg/видео.html .
funny seeing you here mario
Yes queen tell em
right??? they hating for no reason..
how much did she pay you to say that
everyone focused on autotune. meanwhile, Finneas looking like a mad genius lol
As always ^^
That's because he IS a mad genius 😁
ruclips.net/video/w0BxmQlWUnk/видео.html
he is, he killed it on this song and the whole album
ruclips.net/video/dUNnQ2kyrQI/видео.html
Masterpiece ⬆️
Billie's sound without autotune:Angelic level
Billie's sound with autotune:God level
Copied comment
@@mrrabia1if u think that I copied the comment from anyone,i didn't see anywhere I just commented for 3 NDA video.People can think same things it's normal,everyone was talking about Billie's angelic sound and i prefer Billie's voice with autotune to voice without autotune so I said "it's better then angelic voice,who is the bigger and better than angels? Of course God" to myself.Yes,I know that I started from Jesus's birth,just never mind
No
Copied comment
this is the best used autotune i ever heard like cmon we all know she doesnt need it and the idea of using it for an artistic effect that turned out like THIS song is just brilliant
👏🏼
periodt
BEST?? you really need to listen to more experimental songs lol
ruclips.net/video/YXGQP4WkeJc/видео.html
@@freshavocado8598 u got some suggestions for me? :)
Ok but Finneas really is out of this world, WHAT A PRODUCTION is unbelievable ✨✨
ruclips.net/video/uYzN7hgxa48/видео.html .....
ruclips.net/video/poJw5I-Xt6E/видео.html
FACTS. AF.
He's really underrated
Bro I just can't and to be honest, don't think I ever will but I can't get over how fucking angelic this woman is and how talented and magical she is. The feeling she gives me when I hear THE SECOND CHORUS LIKE HELLO?!?!?!?!? The whole song overall actually is just amazing. She is just amazing. So unbelievably beautifully made. It's perfect and an absolute masterpiece.
You couldn't have described my feelings better, love that woman
why is nobody talking about her own song references in this??? she’s literally saying the titles of some of the tracks! her mind🤩
I gotta listen again
@diyoni harisinghe starts at 1:42 !
@diyoni harisinghe “my future” “didn’t change my number” “getting older”
thats the whole point of a song title, it gets mentioned in the song
@@denmarrx8355 Billie Bossa Nova: Well, about that-
Finneas vibing in the background is literally me everytime I listen to NDA
Research Donald Marshall on Human Cloning and Vril! Spread this info!
Same here🤚🏻❤
I love the robotic voice effect… Billie is just so aethereal. Love the background jingle too… what a killer song.
++++...
BILLIE is my inspiration!! My mom said that if I got 10k LIKES on my new song!! She definitely buy me a professional mic!! Begging you GUYS!! Please...I LOVE YOU! I'M NOT LYING! PLS!.
BILLIE is my inspiration!! My mom said that if I got 10k LIKES on my new song!! She definitely buy me a professional mic!! Begging you GUYS!! Please...I LOVE YOU! I'M NOT LYING! PLS!.
ruclips.net/video/SgvBAJN6dRY/видео.html
but her brother finneas also works with billie on the songs, together they make it awesome :)
We need more songs like "NDA"
YASSSSSSSS
Real
Just as good live. Wow
2:21 , her holding that note is just so good. The auto tune sounds so cool. Idc what y’all say, she is enjoying herself. She isn’t tryna please anyone but herself
The part "but you don't need to know" right after that is sooooo fucking pretty
@@britt9136 I know I’m obsessed with it it’s so angelic and along with the beat it’s so cool
GIRLLLL her vocals are sponsored by AUTO TUNE.
Like, she already has a beautiful voice without the auto tune so her using it with the knowledge that she doesn't need it puts it to A WHOLE NEW LEVEL. It's a fucking masterpiece just like every other song of hers. It's a nice mix.
m.ruclips.net/video/AG9pgwyVRas/видео.html
there's a difference between needing autotune and using it for an artistic perspective on a song. she uses a lot of effects on different songs, she doesn't use it for every single one. she definitely don't need to use it, she's wanting to use it.
THIS!!! everyone’s hating on the auto tune but it’s clearly for a different type of sound. not to make her voice sound better like it normally is used for.
Say it louder for the people in the back 👏🏼
@@savgianna9219 amen to that. People just want to hate. But they don't hate her Enough not to give her the views so she still winning in my opinion. I loved the way this song sounded. It wasn't autotune tho. It was something ment to make her voice sound like that. I forget what it's called.
@@savgianna9219 I think Maybe it's called a vocodor but I'm not sure. It's sounds very similar to a talkbox (looked up people singing with a talkbox and you'll probably agree with me) It's definitely not meant to fix her pitch at all though. It's meant to make her voice sound a certain way. Like almost alianish or something like that.
@@savgianna9219 Absolutely, this is fire. I think Billie and Finneas may be the best songwriting pair since Lennon and McCartney.
Definitely a top 5 song she’s EVER released. I’m obsessed with the robotic effect on her voice. THIS SONG IS PURE SEROTONIN.
2:22 Finneas is enjoying it so bad ❤️
Edit: 100 likes!?!!!!?!!! Mommmmmm I'm famouss!!!!
Really ....😂
@@hamzayasan1470 😂😂😂
This song is gonna go hard in concert I just know it
ruclips.net/video/j_jwgObT0tA/видео.html,
ruclips.net/video/7cQNXcJQ0xg/видео.html .
Thanks to drugs
yup. i cannot wait.
@@zachwagner9978 drugs? girl what-
She's an angel. 🖤
yeshhhh
..
And also a racist😍🤞
No 😃 y’all forget the racist and homophobic things she keeps doing?
@@ilovewomenpleasepegmemaam692 fr they switch up so fast😭
this is actually the best song live. obsessed with this version more than the original
this song makes me feel a way i can't describe kinda like nostalgia mixed with confusion but i love it
Me too sis me too
●Hey you, Jesus Loves You! ● God sent His Son Jesus Christ into the world to save mankind, Jesus was born, grew up, healed people, one day they hurt Him and killed Jesus. But on the third day He rose! and He is alive in heaven with God. One day Jesus will return to seek those who have accepted him in their hearts. Now God says: receive, believe in Him, put your trust and faith in Him, I will forgive your sins, and I will guarantee you Eternal Life in Heaven, all this is yours and for free. All you have to do is receive! Jesus wants to save you! ask forgiveness for your sins, for He is Faithful and Just to forgive sins, believe in Him and obey His Word. God bless you!❤🍃
Pls the high note. She really has one of the most prettiest voices. SING ME TO SLEEP BILLIE 🥰
ruclips.net/video/URl9tpOU41U/видео.html 😈
ruclips.net/video/jwr25rL0uY8/видео.html(-:
The high not is just 🤌🏼✨
the second part when she sang “you couldn’t save me but you can’t let me go” IT CHANGED THE WHOLE SONG
ruclips.net/video/aY1zdVIaujU/видео.html🤯🤯🤯
IT WAS SO GOOODDODDDD
Billie never disappoints
exactly
the auto tone is giving me everything I ever wanted
@Billie Eilishmusic are you really pretending to be billie
So obsessed with her voice. Bruh. Her voice is fucking beautiful
The autotube is part of the song, it's an effect to enhance the FEEL of the song, not correct her pitch etc. I think it's symbolic of how she is controlled ("you can't let me go"), since someone else is adding this effect.
ruclips.net/video/l3q1bRlPux4/видео.html
❣
ruclips.net/video/Jwgf3wmiA04/видео.html
People don’t get it, leave them alone…
EXACTLY
It just fits the song its not that deep
Not gonna lie I think this is one of her best ever songs
Me too, what hits me hardest is that this sh!t is going on her life RIGHT NOW. Damn but the girl's gonna kill me.
yes!!!!!! my favorite!!
Honestly not my favorite song but it’s pretty good (edited)
@@sirsytham1588 it’s am opinion calm down damn-
True!!
this song engraves itself little by little into your soul , making u wanting more and more coz the ending leaves u with unsatisfied desire!!! psychologically addictive af....
Yes. This. Exactly.
Holy shit!!!!!!!! Am 42yrs old n av no heard anything as good in yrs mrs u are wise beyond ur years!!!!!! BEAUTIFUL!!!!! 😍😍😍 I HAVE SHIVERS MY BREATH HAS BEEN TOOK AWAY xcxxcccxxx♡♡♡♡♡♡
Stop saying “she doesn’t need auto tune”. We all know she doesn’t need it. The auto tune is for artistic effect and I personally think it suits the vibe of the song quite well.
ruclips.net/video/URl9tpOU41U/видео.html 😈❓
Selling your soul to the devil means you allow those at the cloning center to use/abuse your REM driven clone at the cloning center with your consciousness in your clone every night (or whenever they want to) in exchange for fame and fortune.
RESEARCH DONALD MARSHALL ON HUMAN CLONING!
#GoldenTruth
DON'T BE BLIND, WAKE UP!
this ^^ !!
What's happening is compression. Logic feature....
Right? It's called art!
This might as well be another song of Billie's stuck in my head for another year or so, her songs make me feel like I'm floating.
BILLIE is my inspiration!! My mom said that if I got 10k LIKES on my new song!! She definitely buy me a professional mic!! Begging you GUYS!! Please...I LOVE YOU! I'M NOT LYING! PLS!.
BILLIE is my inspiration!! My mom said that if I got 10k LIKES on my new song!! She definitely buy me a professional mic!! Begging you GUYS!! Please...I LOVE YOU! I'M NOT LYING! PLS!.
^^
ruclips.net/video/uYzN7hgxa48/видео.html.....
Hello friends 🥰
Because I'm not famous like other singers that's why no one see my music videos. Please see once and then decide.
❤️.... ✨....✨.... ❤️..
THIS AUTOTUNE REMINDS ME OF 100 GECS AND I STAND AND AM HERE FOR IT. I STAN BILLIE AND FINNEAS
Billie is getting better and better in my opinion
She doesn't need the auto- tune, I love how it's used for effect here. This song is so layered and subtle in certain ways then in-your- face at other parts. Had to hear it about 3x before it really sunk in. LOVE seeing and hearing her perform it live.
Right it’s soo good
it's a vocoder
They don't get, the autotune makes it more better on that part lol
Agreed. I love her
It’s not auto tune it’s a vocoder
She is so creative. Her voice is unique and beautiful.
simp
@@gavinboyle xD
Autotune lol
@@gavinboyle she’s just complimenting her lmao
So tell me bout your self 😀
this version made me fall in love w that song, need this on Spotify
This is better than the album version
This is why I love her
i’m obsessed with the autotune ngl. it’s so different and billies voice just sounds amazing
girl are you on drugs
@@cshivvvvy if you don’t agree that’s fine. we all have different opinions
Love it too! Rosalía does it all the times and I found very pleasant to hear Billie’s version.
@@cshivvvvy billie eilish songs are more addictive than drugs
@@cshivvvvy you're embarrassing poppy stans
2:16 "You couldn't save me, but you CAN'T LET ME GOOOOO" AHHHHH! It really hit so hard, I saw 🌟s
hmm right .... even I just tried making my own song inspired by her its called find Someone else
please and tell me if its good /bad..
its in this Channels Playlist.
I would love to hear back from you.❤❤
m.ruclips.net/video/AG9pgwyVRas/видео.html
this is my favorite song on the album, idk what everyone else thinks abt it. i love love love the music video too. billie never flops. ever.
I swear I’m two more plays away from buying my first Billie Eilish album 🔥 #FullyConverted
The visuals
The vocals
Her clothes
Her hair
It's all so perfect ❤
YES
ruclips.net/video/b_y8SJQy73U/видео.html
..... ........
@Mr beast stop
@for you 👇🥰 stop
@@gucciboysrecords stop
'Getting older now'' and stare right into that camera, Yes girl, tell 'm!!!
ruclips.net/video/aY1zdVIaujU/видео.html⭐️
@@LeoraSaharia stfu
2:16 the best part of 2021. The second chorus and bridge has traumatised us all for Life
YOU COULDN'T SAVE ME BUT YOU CAN'T LET ME GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
2:16 was awesome ... she knows what her fans like to listen
This blows the record version out of the water, if that’s possible. Simply stunning. Her live tour of this album is going to be awesome and not to be missed. She keeps getting better and better and better.
ruclips.net/video/URl9tpOU41U/видео.html 😈❓
ruclips.net/video/hXZfj1S4_l8/видео.html
BILLIE is my inspiration!! My mom said that if I got 10k LIKES on my new song!! She definitely buy me a professional mic!! Begging you GUYS!! Please...I LOVE YOU! I'M NOT LYING! PLS!.
Slowed & reverb NDA
ruclips.net/video/2bpMS-N2EdI/видео.html
Selling your soul to the devil means you allow those at the cloning center to use/abuse your REM driven clone at the cloning center with your consciousness in your clone every night (or whenever they want to) in exchange for fame and fortune.
RESEARCH DONALD MARSHALL ON HUMAN CLONING!
#GoldenTruth
DON'T BE BLIND, WAKE UP!
NDA supremacy ❤🔥
Amo, amo essa música, e no álbum ela veio mais detalhada e com uma batida uooooou...NDA!🤩
The fact that this sounds just like the studio recorded version is so crazy b
❣️ ruclips.net/video/NiRKAgKxxnM/видео.html
better
It’s a bit different I think it’s better
Yea in this live her voice was more clean to hear unlike the studio version that was a little more tuned down, the vocoder in the Chorus part is a little bit higher and it feels like it hits so dope in 2:18
I just love this version 😍
The fact that she whispers most of this song...
I feel like this song has gone back to billies old style of music, like bad guy and everything and I'm living for it
ruclips.net/video/HXHDjoaPp3Q/видео.html
.
.
The plant vs zombie inspired songs are always great
read the "old style" make me feel old, thanks
SAME HERE
Me too, I think so
Using great lyrics, along with a gifted voice and technology to create an incredible hook. This song is addictive.
When she said “no”😍😍😍
love the autotone hands down. she literally can maker her music however she wants. dont like it, dont listen. anyways, this was better than the record. she always surprises us which makes her live performances that much better. billie and finneas you are legends.
hmm right .... even I just tried making my own song inspired by her its called find Someone else
please and tell me if its good /bad..
its in this Channels Playlist.
I would love to hear back from you❤❤..
I agree!
Love
PERIOD.
it's vocoder not autotune :)
are we ignore NDA’s transition to Therefore i am? GOD I’M OBSESSED
I had to play it and it was too smooth!!
I loved it hahaha
Then you would love Pink Floyd
@@LageRUclips The Dark Side of the Moon has the best transitions IMO
@@shawntholo777asmr9 Absolutely. The best album ever made imo
Im in love with billie's hairrr
At first I wasn’t too keen on this song but the live version made me fall in love
End of the day, Billie keeps doing her thing I'm gonna tune in. She hasn't let me down yet. Critics are arguing over semantics, looking for a way to play the hate.
Completely agree!
Periodt
Theres a crazy remix of this and i actually discovered it from the radio. I think its underrated af. Just search "NDA Thnked Remix" i really recommend 🔥
She doesn't deserve all the s**t she receives. She's a whole angel and her music saved me. Literally.
Same girl, she is a litteral godess and shd should be treated like one
Thiss ❤❤
me too
but you, me and every people who loves her will be there to support her💗
@@alwena5190 yess the other people are going to be crawling back when she releases her album and make sad tiktoks to them ❤🙄
@@brisnamendoza1715 so true
I can't express how this song makes me feel! With/without autotune she is so perfect! Always will be my favorite singer! ilysm billie!
i’m in love
I love this song, I can not fathom why people don’t like it 🤷🏼♂️🤷🏼♂️🤷🏼♂️
SAME
Ikr! Everyone is just talking about the bit that sounds like among us 💀
I love billie and her music. She is my favorite artist ever. I just wish there was a version of this song without all of the auto tune. I love her natural voice. It’s so beautiful.
ruclips.net/video/URl9tpOU41U/видео.html 😈
Exactly It would've been much better without the autotune.
obsessed with this song
BILLIEEE HUNNNYYYY AHHHH ABSOLUTELY OBSESSSED WITH THIS BOO
The bridge is so pretty.
@EXPEIRENCE so true
ruclips.net/video/b_y8SJQy73U/видео.html
.....
the chorus definitely got crack in it. so addicting.
yes omg it’s so addicting istg
AAAAAAAAAAAA
ruclips.net/video/aY1zdVIaujU/видео.html⭐️
>
yess
Once she gets more confident people just hating on her? Like come on guys, grow up. We are in the 21st century, like now she is confident and amazing (amazing as usual) and now the hate? Grow up because haters are such ridiculous people. They don’t know what they are saying because they are COO COO!
I agree to NDA, by default, indefinitely, with Billie.
I’m 63 and I enjoy Billie’s singing. Her style is genuine, she has a message in every song and her heart is in everything that she releases. Of course she will outlive me but just to have a small sample of how she will perform in her later productions. Great work Billie and I wish you the very best.
OMG, YOUR WELCOMED IN OUR FANDOM.
I’m 55 and live Billie’s voice and lyrics along with Finneas brilliant production. She’s a ray of hope when so much music is insipid and repetitive.
@@paulsmith9666 wooooooah, thx for understanding us young guys👍😋
ruclips.net/video/SgvBAJN6dRY/видео.html
True💥
The moment Billie started to get more confident people start to cancel her, you guys are sick
ikr? jealousy jealousy
Its so sad. She’s only 19
Tbh people were just holding her accountable
No real fans cancelled her. The rest won't be missed. :)
@@sidney.8803 No hun they were going w the trend and tearing her apart
¿Por qué hace canciones tan pegadizas?, DIOS es la pura perfección
💪💪
Came to watch the LIVE version x
Everyone hate the autotune part. That’s my favorite part tho😩😩
@Billie Eilishmusic you are not Billie?
Same
Sameee
sameee
Samee
Old billie: depression: people love her.
Billie now: happier then ever: people are trying to ruin her career and being mean to her
@@sarahsmusicalselections9845 people just wanna clout hop
@@sarahsmusicalselections9845 lets not try to ignore the fact that billie has been acting shitty lately. people arent calling her out for nothing
@@theon3pieceisreal nope she has not she has had a lot to deal with
You can make sad songs being happy tho?
ruclips.net/video/YXGQP4WkeJc/видео.html
2:15 no puedo creer lo buena que es esta parte dios mio es perfectaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
YES
concuerdo al 1000%
Me encanta amo mucho esta parte😊
OMMMG LO MISMO OPINOOOO.😻
Fact: Billie Eilish is making everyone's life better with her Music
Wasn’t she canceled like 2 weeks ago?
@@implyivy She was but people switched up lmao
@@implyivy your still here so ig not
YEP
@@implyivy most people held her accountable you could say but yea some people tried to cancel her lmaooo
Honestly, this song would be amazing in euphoria
Yes!!!!!! This!!!!!
Or in among us
@@jessicapartida6239 I don't understand at all what the fuck y'all hear by saying this song should be in Among Us. Are you okay?
@Antariksa in a scene when she’s doing molly or smt😭😭😭😭
Yep 💅
Guys try headphones while listening 🤤🤤
THIS IS BILLIES BEST SONG
okay but billie literally has the best voice ever-
ruclips.net/video/URl9tpOU41U/видео.html 😈
this performance brought tears to my eyes. its so fucking good billie GAWD
ruclips.net/video/aY1zdVIaujU/видео.html🤯🤯🤯
Among us?
Best song on the album
0:57 That second Billie's voice sounds so good, it’s amazing.
I love that ❤
we will always support you Billie
No.
Who’s we herhhe
YESSS
Yes forever
Periodt
I so wish people let artists experiment with with different sound and continuously try to create good ass music. Just because ur hearing something diff. for the first time don't mean it's not GOOD AF
ruclips.net/video/HXHDjoaPp3Q/видео.html
..
U WORDED IT PERFECTLY
How can somthing be this perfect
Billie you saved my life❤
Time: 4:34 AM.
Was thinking i wasted whole night staying up.
Billie:Hold my beer
Love how she always makes us want to hear more and more of her voice
hmm right .... even I just tried making my own song inspired by her its called find Someone else
please and tell me if its good /bad..
its in this Channels Playlist.
I would love to hear back from you❤❤.
🎶
ruclips.net/video/aY1zdVIaujU/видео.html⭐️
this is going to be amazing to hear live in a concerttttt
If only we were all nice to each other.
Uh yeah the world will be so much better
Am I the only who loves when she sings "Did I take it too far?"?
Like, this part is the best part and I always listen the entire song bc of this specific part. It sounds really nice..
THATS MY FAVORITE PARTTTT 😩😭
@@cxutiegamer3676 Yeah, me too!
The whole ending sequence is the backbone of why this song is so awesome
Exactly.
Don't get me wrong. I love Billie's albums but I'd REALLY love to buy an live CD. I could watch her live videos all day and not get tired of hearing her voice.
ruclips.net/video/poJw5I-Xt6E/видео.html
Paramore did this with their the final riot CD/DVD and I loved it so much growing up
2:17 JESUS CHRIST idk how someone can be so talented
This needs to be released as a streamable / downloadable track. Live is better. Legit.
Billie hasn’t changed.. she’s better than ever! Respect happier than ever
ruclips.net/video/aY1zdVIaujU/видео.html⭐️
Actually. I hope she did change. People who don't change when they grow up are stagnant and boring. I absolutely adore Billie and how she's grown (changed) and change makes her better. :) :)