I know it's a joke and all, but fully understanding these would at most put you at an undergrad level. Master and Ph. D are about use this knowledge to research and understand more.
urbanturbine I remember in my hydraulics class, we just threw a stick in the water and timed how long it took it to float downstream. Rubber duck is probably better. More visible.
As a Civil Engineer myself, I wish my professors taught me these with these examples. I would have continued as a Civil Engineer instead of moving to Information Technology.
I've always wondered in geo classes that if a simple obstacle really rises the water level that much and effect so far away. This is perhaps the most intuitive resource to understand it. Fantastic video
It is not true, this level rising and slower velocity is from local energy losses. The slope. Of the river is higher in upstream and therefore velocity is higher. Downstream slope is slighter, velocity is reduced. Model is showing constant slope!!
Love how you guys illustrate how the water will actually behave...so clear and easy to understand. I never thought I would ever need to know this but recently I have been making a table top fountain project and the water flow speed was too slow and that's when I thought of this video and came back to look for you guys.
No ducks were harmed during production of this video. :) - It is very instructive and i am glad for two things - its in british language and you are using centimeters :)
This reminds me a lot of my casting classes. We did a lot of fluid flow simulations to design molds for castings. A man named Dr. John Campbell took some xrays of castings while they were being poured, and found that water is actually a pretty good analog for molten iron. So some of the models people use to demonstrate casting techniques look a whole lot like what you're using there :)
Another knowledge explained very briefly.. well done JBA Trust, you showed things that other people might not know that happens in their everyday life.. very good engineering info that would save many people in some developing countries..
so I've always wanted more of the coastal defence videi that I have watched like 10 times everytime It pops up on my youtube now I am saying we need more of these types of water mechanics videos
Jonathan Rabe its the other way around. Mechanical Engineers more likely to have models and prototypes. Civil Engineers only get one chance as every location is unique.
Yep but he always gotta fix what others don’t, so as soon as I saw culvert I was like « yeah send more maintenance for those so that post 10 can focus on unclogging others stuff »
For civil engineers, this is a great way to demonstrate how Water Resources Engineering works! It is hard to believe, otherwise, by just working through formulae.
Why am I here? I'm a trainee accountant in london with huge exams in exactly 3 weeks and way too much work to do. I'll watch it on 1.5x speed so im basically fine.
Can I just add this is a fantastic video, I'm a white water kayaker and loved the explanations of all the different types of weirs etc. Wish they were building them more with recreational use in mind.
These videos show up in my recommended, I never search for them, but I have to say, this is very interesting and I love to learn about this kind of water physics.
I have been looking for information on how to represent these structures in a hydraulic model and this has proved to be very useful in helping me understand what I am doing. Please keep up the good work!
Great! It is in fact the simplest way. The professors did not show me easily when I was in school. It's good that I watched this video. Sorry, my english is so bad
What you call a "stopper" is known as a drowning machine, tom scott has an excellent video about them Also the duck getting stuck in diving is called a delta p event and a grate or screen is far safer then a hole as there is still flow with a hole you're body will block the hole and form a seal making you stuck there and probably die, delta p is horrifying
RUclips Ai, you have to learn to read my comments, understand them and keep suggesting me such great informative content🙏. This was the best video I've seen in months!!
I remembered seeing this video a couple years ago and could not remember to name of it, I searched for about 20 minutes after remembering that I need to know that title and I was not disappointed
How to: Make a practical learning video Demonstrate practical techniques Teach in an entertaining way Teach while also giving real world examples, their consequences, and what to watch out for My man/woman. I'm a CS major, but this has me both learning and entertained. If I ever do animations or scenery for a game/movie, or if I ever write a story, it's details like these that are so important, and if for some odd reason I completely change majors, this is still super helpful. Thanks guys :D
I watched this video a few weeks ago, who knew that I’d need to find it again, along with your other videos to showcase fluid dynamics and Bernoulli’s principle!
I don't know how I got here but this is the most interesting thing I've seen all month.
quarantine reccomendations
Same tho
Same here, I have nothing to do with this subject but I like it
same thing for me, on my side: most interesting thing I've seen all year. Engineers rule
same for me. i live in a country which have the highest number of rivers in the world, more than 2000+ rivers.
Two more of those vids and i'm gonne be Ph. D. in waterway engineering.
go to post 10, he got a lot vids with drains, culverts etc
Practical engineering youtube channel
true
I know it's a joke and all, but fully understanding these would at most put you at an undergrad level. Master and Ph. D are about use this knowledge to research and understand more.
That's impossible.
To be a Ph.D. in waterway engineering, you need to watch like 11 videos or something.. at least.
Not gonna lie, this was fascinating and I'd like to watch an entire series.
Mee too, very interesting
RUclips: Here you go
Me: I'm not even interested in waterway engineering
RUclips: Here. You. Go.
Gabe Larsen We’re not really sure why we got here, but now we all know about waterway engineering. RUclips recommendations are great
Pretty much xD
Exactly 😆😆😆
Okey, i will check it.
Uhm, okey..I liked it.
YT recommendation, you did it again.
same but i was excited to watch it
"First, we need to measure velocity"
Tosses a yellow rubber duck into the water
I don't know how you could possibly get more scientific than rubber ducks.
That is really how we measure velocities only difference being in real life the duck actually speaks
Haha that's actually how they measure velocity out there in the field too.... Sometimes simple methods are the most accurate..
urbanturbine I remember in my hydraulics class, we just threw a stick in the water and timed how long it took it to float downstream. Rubber duck is probably better. More visible.
Rubber ducks per second is a total valid velocity unit
The sequel is finally here
Edit: weird to see this at 2.4 million views. I remember it when it had 3 or 4 comments and views in the low thousands
I. Them we’re the days.
The RUclips recommendation algorithm works in mysterious ways. I also got here by chance. Enjoyed myself with the video tho.
The Algorithm works in mysterious ways
I didn't know engineering involves so many rubber ducks 🦆
How do you think they make the ducks?
It’s just the one duck actually
I'm thinking career change...
And in real environment setting do they include clear pvc walls?
In fluid mechanics is practically a measure unit
I have no use for this information, but I find it very interesting.
I’ve honestly never been so happy to learn about something so random as this
As a Civil Engineer myself, I wish my professors taught me these with these examples. I would have continued as a Civil Engineer instead of moving to Information Technology.
as civil engineer my self shall i continue or run ?
@@oussamakada8355 both, i am continuing with backup plans
I've always wondered in geo classes that if a simple obstacle really rises the water level that much and effect so far away. This is perhaps the most intuitive resource to understand it. Fantastic video
NEW WATER VIDEO!!
yay
yay indeed
ok. i'm literally pricing up 2cm acrylic on the internet right now. i must build one of these. so much cooler than a fishtank.
Just put fish in it anyway.
Make sure to install a vortex control device.
Put the fish.. let them have an exercise this quarantine hahahahaha
Don't forget the rubber duck! 👍
What kind of pump there are use?
I'm not an engineer in waterways nor a student in this field, didn't know most of these. Stayed because entertained and earned some knowledge.
Moral of the video:
Upstream always slow
Down stream always fast
It is not true, this level rising and slower velocity is from local energy losses. The slope. Of the river is higher in upstream and therefore velocity is higher. Downstream slope is slighter, velocity is reduced. Model is showing constant slope!!
Love how you guys illustrate how the water will actually behave...so clear and easy to understand. I never thought I would ever need to know this but recently I have been making a table top fountain project and the water flow speed was too slow and that's when I thought of this video and came back to look for you guys.
I don´t have a river, why am I watching this?
You may fall into one
A wise man once said..."you are your own river".
D.M.
@@muhammadzaidhasan1426 I will now be careful around vertical screens
No ducks were harmed during production of this video. :) - It is very instructive and i am glad for two things - its in british language and you are using centimeters :)
This reminds me a lot of my casting classes. We did a lot of fluid flow simulations to design molds for castings. A man named Dr. John Campbell took some xrays of castings while they were being poured, and found that water is actually a pretty good analog for molten iron. So some of the models people use to demonstrate casting techniques look a whole lot like what you're using there :)
Why is this so interesting??? RUclips suggested it and once it started playing I couldn't stop watching it.
A 10 minute video has taught me more than all my teachers have!
This entire channel is a hidden gold mine
Another knowledge explained very briefly.. well done JBA Trust, you showed things that other people might not know that happens in their everyday life.. very good engineering info that would save many people in some developing countries..
They didn't teach this in our Water Resource Engineering classes... Now I understand the concepts properly..
so I've always wanted more of the coastal defence videi that I have watched like 10 times everytime It pops up on my youtube now I am saying we need more of these types of water mechanics videos
This is a summary of my 4 years of structural engineering. Good job
Mechanical Engineers: "We will use first principles and solve any scenario"
Civil Engineers: "Let us just test each possible one"
Jonathan Rabe its the other way around. Mechanical Engineers more likely to have models and prototypes.
Civil Engineers only get one chance as every location is unique.
Don't know how i got here but this is the best thing i have seen this week
This is going to have a million views in a couple of weeks. I'm telling ya.
EDIT: Ha! Called it!
Yeah
No it wont have a million views ^^
@@nalyddoow9295 im leaving a reply here so I'll get notified
almost there
@@mathiasrasmussen7455 oops
Loved "Open Channel Hydraulics" in college but that was almost 40 years ago. Nice work on the video. Thanks
Finally, I have answers to the questions I never asked.
This video is very important for kayakers, I think all kayakers should watch these videos before entering a river.
post10 would never let that culvert getting clogged
Steffen Vetrhus post10gang
hahaha exactly!
Yep but he always gotta fix what others don’t, so as soon as I saw culvert I was like « yeah send more maintenance for those so that post 10 can focus on unclogging others stuff »
Post 10! ❤️
For civil engineers, this is a great way to demonstrate how Water Resources Engineering works! It is hard to believe, otherwise, by just working through formulae.
This is one of the best videos I have seen in my life.
My bother is an architecture student. 10/10 would recommend this to him.
You guys have put SO much effort into this and it looks great and is very interesting. Thank you 😁
A comment from me that has already been said.. unsure of how on earth I landed in this RUclips wormhole, however, fascinating! 👏👏
RUclips recomendations usually nail some of my science curiosity
Normally i generally wouldn't care about anything of this sort since you get the basics in college but this is actually interesting to watch. Thanks.
Teached me more than everything I ever learnt in school
Obviously it didn’t teach you grammar.
I, for some reason, was recommended this. I'm not dissapointed, you guys seem proffesional
Why am I here? I'm a trainee accountant in london with huge exams in exactly 3 weeks and way too much work to do. I'll watch it on 1.5x speed so im basically fine.
The whole video is 100% worth watching ESPECIALLY for the end, I had no idea water could be control in such way! Loved it, thanks for sharing!
6:20 They even know how to freeze water for half a second! (Watch water closely)
What does this mean
It's a glitch
This is the kind of vid that i want my son to watch rather than watching youtube content of other youtube vloggers out there.
"the kayak will not have a good time" and that is called a perfect drowning machine
Can I just add this is a fantastic video, I'm a white water kayaker and loved the explanations of all the different types of weirs etc. Wish they were building them more with recreational use in mind.
Finally I can brag my water management knowledge infront of friends.
These videos show up in my recommended, I never search for them, but I have to say, this is very interesting and I love to learn about this kind of water physics.
Мало что понял, но было интересно.
И как это видео выскочило у меня в рекомендациях?
I have been looking for information on how to represent these structures in a hydraulic model and this has proved to be very useful in helping me understand what I am doing. Please keep up the good work!
2:23 I remember this! Officially warning signs call it a drowning machine iirc
Don't know how I got here but I watched the whole video and enjoyed every second of it.
humans: the earth raised all the water levels !!
earth: you did most of that yourself first...
I thought this would be a boring video but turns out it's so interesting to me nd I didn't skip the video! I watched the entire video
"what are you doing step-screen?"
Dude! I was thinking the same thing! 😂
Great! It is in fact the simplest way. The professors did not show me easily when I was in school. It's good that I watched this video. Sorry, my english is so bad
my favorite part was when they Introduced The Duck
I don't know why this video have been recomended to me, but was amazing.
Hugs from Brazil
What you call a "stopper" is known as a drowning machine, tom scott has an excellent video about them
Also the duck getting stuck in diving is called a delta p event and a grate or screen is far safer then a hole as there is still flow with a hole you're body will block the hole and form a seal making you stuck there and probably die, delta p is horrifying
I don't know how this was suggested to me but it was really well made and explained. To top it off it was interesting to watch.
Me who don't even know how I came here and why I'm watching.
My Mind: Watch it...
I learned more in this video than I learn in a Engineering class.... great presentation...
This is literally just Bernoulli's principle put into action
Venturi effect
RUclips Ai, you have to learn to read my comments, understand them and keep suggesting me such great informative content🙏. This was the best video I've seen in months!!
Me : wow this stuff looks so fun!
Also me : get "D" on fluid lesson
These suggested videos are big brain energy.
No hablo inglés, pero le entendí muy bien al vídeo uwu
i don't speak ur language but i can understand it uwu
This video had my mouth hanging open since they put in the first object. This was very interesting and easily explained
Video: water go splish splash
214,000 people: interesting
I dont know why this was in my recommended but ngl I really enjoyed it.
This came up in my recommendations.
Right up my street. Most informative video I’ve watched for a long time.
RUclips must be reccomending these types of niche engineering videos to get us ready for something...
The first picture (the bridge) is in Oporto (Portugal)
I remembered seeing this video a couple years ago and could not remember to name of it, I searched for about 20 minutes after remembering that I need to know that title and I was not disappointed
How to:
Make a practical learning video
Demonstrate practical techniques
Teach in an entertaining way
Teach while also giving real world examples, their consequences, and what to watch out for
My man/woman. I'm a CS major, but this has me both learning and entertained. If I ever do animations or scenery for a game/movie, or if I ever write a story, it's details like these that are so important, and if for some odd reason I completely change majors, this is still super helpful. Thanks guys :D
That’s got to be one of the best videos I’ve ever watched on here. Very interesting stuff.
I did not search for this but this was completely entertaining.
I'm so glad he explained what a bridge is, I was lost for a second there
they are like better version of teachers, now i know how things work like that, so THANKS school.
MIght be the 2nd time youtube recommendation actually recommended something i watched through and enjoyed.
Amazing video!
I stumbled upon this randomly and I enjoyed it way too much, informative, simple, interesting, just great!
i never searched for this,
i guess i liked it once or twice
but every odd year
i get a video on waterway engineering
Nice.
THIS IS THE MOST INTERESTING THING I'VE EVER SEEN I NEED MORE WATER VIDEOS
RUclips recommendation episode 45: It is always so far from what i'm used to watch and at the same time very interresting. Good video guys
RUclips knows you better than yourself
Amazing and clear presention that i have ever seen on how structures effect the river flow.
Not sure how or why this was recommended to me, but I’m really glad it was. Very interesting video.
JBA Trust, for everything related to water, I trust you.
Water works in very different and mysterious than what I thought.
Very interesting.
THIS IS FREAKING INTERESTING , WATCHING IT WITHOUT EVEN SKIPPING 5 SECONDS AHEAD
I didn't search for it after watching i don't regret
Great demonstration 🔥
I watched this video a few weeks ago, who knew that I’d need to find it again, along with your other videos to showcase fluid dynamics and Bernoulli’s principle!
Did not ask for this but did I watch every second of it with wonders in my eyes. WELL YES :)
Really a very good video to get educate ourselves and by showing this prototype model how water can be easily diverted really wonderful.
The Vortex control device blows my mind. So cool!
I'm not even study engineering but this is really fascinating to watch.
Perfect representation of the physics and underlying hydraulics in these structures. Thanks.
Thank you youtube for the recommendation. learnt something new today. More respect for civil engineers.
Good to know and to understand nature of the water to resolve the city flooding. Thank you.