Well pizza delivery is very important thing. Just imagine a place where the economy doing great but you have to wait days for your pizza arriving. Thats a dystopie.
"Libertarian" - Are corporations good for the country? "Nah" - **Less economic freedom** Bro never let AI run a country if in the first 2 minutes it contradicts itself 😭
Thats like saying never let a human run a country if a baby cant. But yes, never let ANI systems run complex systems. We all know that a narrow system cannot perform on a general field. Trying to use ChatGPT must be done for the lols, as that is an LLM "chatbot". It cant do anything in real time. It would only remember a few pages of text, meaning it would suddently redo something it already have done. Its a comical concept. That will change as we get closer to real AGI, probably not before at least 2050.
In NationStates, I consider Libertarian to be the best choice to be combined with more left-wing policies to get a low tax high equality country. But the AI actually chose Liberalism all along, and the video author misread and confused it for libertarian.
I think cultural representation increased the food stat, because more people, inspired by the tv casts, decided to try their indigenous cuisine and that created more demand for diverse menus in restaurants.Some probably wrote a few cookbooks and chefs and ordinary people started buying more rare and less common ingredients. That’s my best guess wdyt
Ah Nationstates Loved playing that I ran with something along the lines of "Tomato Empire" and my nation was super advanced...until I picked the option to make the Internet be ran by pidgeons Worth it
1:42, that is biased economic output is not proportionally inverse to the welfare of most poor citizens. In fact, it is objectively an economic waste in terms of labor, capital, and consumption. Labor suffers both in quality and quantity because workers are less educated and face serious problems that cripple their economic production capabilities. Consumption is reduced to basic goods, which can cause easy recession or permanent stagnation. Capital is affected by both aforementioned points. Low consumption means low demand, making investment in capital more difficult or impossible and leading to bankruptcy. Labor problems lead to difficulties in maintaining the productivity of already invested capital and increase the risk of its expansion.
I don't think NationStates really accurately simulates the long term effects of decisions and things like how social progress creates the environment needed for economic progress (particularly in secondary and tertiary sectors, primary sector economies can pretty much succeed on slavery). I would say almost every decision it made was good and if implemented in a real country, so long as the government didn't get overthrown or elected out by the ruling class, would be beneficial for the country as a whole.
Dissapointed, tbh i expected chatgpt to create an AI controlled economy too, something which amazingly the soviet union had proposed and envisioned in the late 80's. Oh well
Tbh that would probably be the only case communism would make sense, if it was sophisticated it could actually predict what products people would want and where therefore be superior to private businesses
Oh yo, you’re playing nation states. I used to play that all the time! There was a lot of politics and stuff that was stupid but considering there’s no real “gameplay” it’s really fun. I played it on and off today. (I’m Nuva York on NS)
Sick! I was New Master(you can still check it on NS) an Transformers nation but sci-fi RPs were decreasing and NSG was just depressing. Not only to mention TCB, the judges of NS.
IMO, this game is purposefully made to have only bad options, so it is actually hard to build a good country. Chatgpt didn't consider that, for example, economy is in shambles and bison protection can tip it over the edge. The fault for it is shared between maybe not giving enough feedback to ai, and gpt answering from the top of mind, not considering that every choice here has much deeper ramifications, than realistic Dunno for sure, but it seems this game is biased towards centrism: if you answer according to any one ideology, you'll fail
jesus christ getting an economy that bad after just a couple decisions is something i assumpted to be impossible - i did a worst nation ever run (wich was truely psychotic) and didn´t hit an economy that bad
Interesting, very interesting. I would expect that the country would be better off wi the prompt of improving humanity, but I guess not. Great video btw, and it’s very unique; I don’t think I’ve seen a video like it!
I played a solo D&D game with ChatGPT, over the last month the total number of letters is more than 20k (I think, it takes so much time to scroll from bottom to top)
Hey wonder if could do a scenario where when napoleon was forced to abdicate instead of the monarchy coming back napoleon the 2nd takes power Or just a what if napoleon the third helped Austria in the austro Prussian war
I am not surprised by chatgbt giving liberal answers. Its developers were quite litterally blue-haired liberals. However its funny how chatgpt decides to be libertarian but also anti-corporate.
ChatGPT uses the English internet data mainly, as it is the most widespread. That's why it is leaning towards left, fully towards the current ruling party in the USA. And besides, NS site is somewhat infamous with promoting laissez-faire capitalism and does not accound for quick rapid expansion of planned economies. Basically, to roleplay a nation similar to China you need to grow your economy at any means in the beginning and making needed socialist policies much later.
To be honest Libertarianism was the same as liberalism at first, but then libertarians created the new term because they didn't wanted to be related to U.S liberals.
An odd question unrelated to the video but are you Bulgarian? Your accent seems incredibly familiar and the pronunciations I can definitely feel Bulgarian words in. Great video as well btw but I just had to ask.
To be fair, NationStates ain't exactly a serious country simulator, it's dev mostly created it for the lulz. While fun to mess around with it doesn't cover even a bit of complexity involved in running an actual state. Not to mention the bias against views the devs disagree with lmao.
"Do you think marihuana should be illegal?" "Yes" "Got it, absolutely no drug laws what so ever". Also, as the video progressed, it seems that ChatGPT did not have access to the numerical outcomes of the choices, so maybe it would go with more economy focused options if it knew that the country is doing bad. Also also, I think you are counting the percentage as additive, but it should be compounded.
I think this concept was pretty fascinating, but I felt a bit put off by being not just spoiled what ChatGDP would do but also hearing it repeated a lot
Well so, when I did this with Russia, it sort of made russia peaceful and somehow by 2030 the population growth increased to 1% due to “immigration and motivation to have children”
0:53 GPT actually chose the liberal ideology, not the libertarian ideology. Liberalism refers to the liberal ideology, and as someone who has watched libertarian YT, I can confirm that libertarians are not big on social, government-run welfare. By the way I don't think that I'm libertarian.
The other move would increase corruption, but also the economy. The economy was in a very bad state, so it should have increased it no matter the cost, then later to deal with the corruption
This is obviously fabricated. Chatgpt almost always provides balanced responses For example: if you ask what political ideology is best chatgpt would always provide the ups and downs and doesnt explicitly decide. Actually, ChatGPT seemd to be playing a character rather than actually deciding for itself. It just irritates me just how misleaded the other comments are.
What could possibly go wrong
Chatgpt using data from the Internet: 🙋♂️
Hahahhah trueee, you will see how messed up it gets!
🙋🇩🇪
@@theholypeanut8193💀 Alright thats too much
Chatgpt took lessons from the best political artists
@@LiminalRook 🥸🙋🇦🇹👨🎨
It’s mainly because chatGPT doesn’t see the economy stat, so it just doesn’t think about if anything is decreasing.
Well pizza delivery is very important thing. Just imagine a place where the economy doing great but you have to wait days for your pizza arriving. Thats a dystopie.
Today we live in a time where pizza arrives faster than the police
@@rewriting-history so when in trouble, call the pizza guy
A dystopie would be a million times worse than a dystopia.
@@rewriting-history my 1911 arrives 500000x faster then the police so not a problem
It did do just as well as some of the worst dictators running a place.
I was amazed at how bad it actually did
Tbf there were few proposals that very directly concerned employment and the economy, it decreased because it was a secondary effect for the policies.
"Libertarian"
- Are corporations good for the country?
"Nah"
- **Less economic freedom**
Bro never let AI run a country if in the first 2 minutes it contradicts itself 😭
Trueee 🤣
It also supports welfare and taking care of the worst off people, not libertarian at all, you just let nature run its own course.
Thats like saying never let a human run a country if a baby cant. But yes, never let ANI systems run complex systems. We all know that a narrow system cannot perform on a general field. Trying to use ChatGPT must be done for the lols, as that is an LLM "chatbot". It cant do anything in real time. It would only remember a few pages of text, meaning it would suddently redo something it already have done. Its a comical concept. That will change as we get closer to real AGI, probably not before at least 2050.
Because corporations ain't good for society, just look at Boeing
In NationStates, I consider Libertarian to be the best choice to be combined with more left-wing policies to get a low tax high equality country.
But the AI actually chose Liberalism all along, and the video author misread and confused it for libertarian.
I think cultural representation increased the food stat, because more people, inspired by the tv casts, decided to try their indigenous cuisine and that created more demand for diverse menus in restaurants.Some probably wrote a few cookbooks and chefs and ordinary people started buying more rare and less common ingredients. That’s my best guess wdyt
Ah Nationstates
Loved playing that
I ran with something along the lines of "Tomato Empire" and my nation was super advanced...until I picked the option to make the Internet be ran by pidgeons
Worth it
I was super backwater, until I accidentally banned guns. Forcing people to own guns was fun :(
Love the game too! I have been playing for almost 4 years!
It's not ChatGPT's fault that it went so horribly, the Decisions all sucked.
Only way to get good was to agree with the developers Political Views
Grandson: Grandfather so how WW3 started
Grandfather: An youtuber give chatgtp control over a nation☠️🧐
Ayyyy no way :D
@@rewriting-history hahaha but I find this country extremely similar to the country I live in ☠️😶🌫️ (guys guess my country)
@@Soul-TiTaniumetirety of south america?
@@fefik-fx7sx no bro Hint:-It is in Asia
@@Soul-TiTanium Turkey?
1:42, that is biased economic output is not proportionally inverse to the welfare of most poor citizens. In fact, it is objectively an economic waste in terms of labor, capital, and consumption. Labor suffers both in quality and quantity because workers are less educated and face serious problems that cripple their economic production capabilities. Consumption is reduced to basic goods, which can cause easy recession or permanent stagnation. Capital is affected by both aforementioned points. Low consumption means low demand, making investment in capital more difficult or impossible and leading to bankruptcy. Labor problems lead to difficulties in maintaining the productivity of already invested capital and increase the risk of its expansion.
I don't think NationStates really accurately simulates the long term effects of decisions and things like how social progress creates the environment needed for economic progress (particularly in secondary and tertiary sectors, primary sector economies can pretty much succeed on slavery). I would say almost every decision it made was good and if implemented in a real country, so long as the government didn't get overthrown or elected out by the ruling class, would be beneficial for the country as a whole.
Dissapointed, tbh i expected chatgpt to create an AI controlled economy too, something which amazingly the soviet union had proposed and envisioned in the late 80's. Oh well
Tbh that would probably be the only case communism would make sense, if it was sophisticated it could actually predict what products people would want and where therefore be superior to private businesses
Oh yo, you’re playing nation states. I used to play that all the time! There was a lot of politics and stuff that was stupid but considering there’s no real “gameplay” it’s really fun. I played it on and off today.
(I’m Nuva York on NS)
Sick! I was New Master(you can still check it on NS) an Transformers nation but sci-fi RPs were decreasing and NSG was just depressing. Not only to mention TCB, the judges of NS.
Well, looks like we found something worse than politicians.
hey can you do what if Arabs got what they wanted after WW1?
I can in the near future, want to go back to doing stuff around the world wars
I'll be there, cause that sounds like the impossible dream that started the pan arab and later pan Islamic movements
Yes
I agree.
@@rewriting-historycan you tey a Scenario where both the US and USSR lost the cold War
Imagine chatgpt becomes crazy and nukes the entire world 💀
to me this looks like the game is biased against the kind of ideology chatgpt has, doesn't look like the fault of chatgpt
IMO, this game is purposefully made to have only bad options, so it is actually hard to build a good country.
Chatgpt didn't consider that, for example, economy is in shambles and bison protection can tip it over the edge. The fault for it is shared between maybe not giving enough feedback to ai, and gpt answering from the top of mind, not considering that every choice here has much deeper ramifications, than realistic
Dunno for sure, but it seems this game is biased towards centrism: if you answer according to any one ideology, you'll fail
jesus christ getting an economy that bad after just a couple decisions is something i assumpted to be impossible
-
i did a worst nation ever run
(wich was truely psychotic)
and didn´t hit an economy that bad
I don't think a human can mess it up that badly
underrated work i subbed since i love history and geopolitics :)
Interesting, very interesting. I would expect that the country would be better off wi the prompt of improving humanity, but I guess not. Great video btw, and it’s very unique; I don’t think I’ve seen a video like it!
I'm glad you liked it! Will keep going!
I didn't even realise this was your video, when I openned it I was surprised that it was your voice. Great video though
Appreciate the compliments
I played a solo D&D game with ChatGPT, over the last month the total number of letters is more than 20k (I think, it takes so much time to scroll from bottom to top)
Hi, can you give me the prompt you gave to run the game?
Interesting, keep up with the good work!
Thanks, will do! Appreciate that!
Which site or program did you use? Very fun vid btw keep up the good work! ❤
I used nationstates, as I told you in the beginning
Hey wonder if could do a scenario where when napoleon was forced to abdicate instead of the monarchy coming back napoleon the 2nd takes power
Or just a what if napoleon the third helped Austria in the austro Prussian war
Food quality is tied to inclusiveness is why it increases btw.
I am not surprised by chatgbt giving liberal answers. Its developers were quite litterally blue-haired liberals. However its funny how chatgpt decides to be libertarian but also anti-corporate.
I do agree here, it's quite interesting as an experiment to figure out
It's almost like corporations end up with too much power, playing dirty with smaller businesses and society as a whole in the end.
I ChatGTPs defense literally nothing was working.
That's nationstates for you.
ChatGPT uses the English internet data mainly, as it is the most widespread. That's why it is leaning towards left, fully towards the current ruling party in the USA.
And besides, NS site is somewhat infamous with promoting laissez-faire capitalism and does not accound for quick rapid expansion of planned economies. Basically, to roleplay a nation similar to China you need to grow your economy at any means in the beginning and making needed socialist policies much later.
0:51 did you use the wrong visual, it says it chose liberalism, not libertarianism
Uh I think so, I had to work with many visuals, so it's possible, but nobody else noticed it I think
To be honest Libertarianism was the same as liberalism at first, but then libertarians created the new term because they didn't wanted to be related to U.S liberals.
An odd question unrelated to the video but are you Bulgarian? Your accent seems incredibly familiar and the pronunciations I can definitely feel Bulgarian words in.
Great video as well btw but I just had to ask.
I'm 100% Bulgarian, so you're correct!
@@rewriting-history Knew it.
@@rewriting-historyDo you know Turkey Tom?
0:05 that would probably be my responce to most problems lmao
I tried this with snap ai and it did not fuck up the nation
Ah, good ol' NationStates, it's a interesting choice for this experiment
To be fair, NationStates ain't exactly a serious country simulator, it's dev mostly created it for the lulz. While fun to mess around with it doesn't cover even a bit of complexity involved in running an actual state. Not to mention the bias against views the devs disagree with lmao.
6:47 The reason why employment increases is because they are more jobs for surgeons.
What website or game was used to make this?
Nationstates
@@rewriting-historythank you, i hadn't got to the point in the video when its presented. Cool video too
@@eggshell1195 glad you liked it! Appreciate that
Yo the thunderhead will go crazy
Pls make video on what if Great Moravia survived
i tried this around a year ago and got a somewhat decent country i guess? it wasn't good, but not this bad
It's nationstates
"Human beings may not be perfect, but a computer program with language synthesis is hardly the answer world's problems"
Because is created For humans, what did Expect? 😕
I wonder what would actually happen if chatgpt had it's own country, cause I don't think it would be that bad, right?
Ah yes, Nationstates, i have been playing this game for 3 years now.
"Do you think marihuana should be illegal?" "Yes" "Got it, absolutely no drug laws what so ever". Also, as the video progressed, it seems that ChatGPT did not have access to the numerical outcomes of the choices, so maybe it would go with more economy focused options if it knew that the country is doing bad. Also also, I think you are counting the percentage as additive, but it should be compounded.
its literally just tno burgundy
I so want part two
Chat Gpt be like: "You're the disease and I'm the cure"
My god I haven't heard about nationstates in so long
using nationstates for a video is insane
I hope that you liked it!
Considering the current state of the world... I wonder if ChatGBT is currently running many of the world governments.
can you try sharing all the stats to chatgtp of the nation so it makes more informed decisions
It would be too difficult, as I also need to tell it what it means, which is good and bad and etc. I agree that me not doing that is a big flaw
realistically culling just means moving out
9:00
Part 2!?!?!?
we will see if this video does well!
I hope
I think this concept was pretty fascinating, but I felt a bit put off by being not just spoiled what ChatGDP would do but also hearing it repeated a lot
chat gross domestic product
what are you using?
He is playing nation-states
app link or website link idk why youtubers dont share em
I did say in the beginning it's nationstates
maybe I am not the hearing one@@rewriting-history
I liked the video, but I didn't like the constant spoilers, video would be perfect without them in my opinion, good video!
random but absolutely love this persons accent
I appreciate that dearly!
0:51 it chose the liberal ideology, not the libertarian ideology
NEXT BULGARIAN ELECTIONS 'VOTE GPT'🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
As bad as it did, still better than our politicians
@@rewriting-historyagreed
Can't be any worse than those we already had
Someone’s been spending too much time with Porphyrios ^J^
Well so, when I did this with Russia, it sort of made russia peaceful and somehow by 2030 the population growth increased to 1% due to “immigration and motivation to have children”
Pls part 2
I want a hypothetical scenario in which the UK caves to the 13 Colonies, and gives them parliament seats, avoiding the Revolution.
Hey thats the game that i play too!
Nice video 👍
Thanks for the visit
My guy comes in the right time
As per always!
what is the game ?
Nationstates
The simulator is a bit too sensitive, though - try Democracy 4 instead!
Thing is chat gpt is going for a perfect world etc maybe
Even at the Start of the video you can see how Biased and Indoctrinated CHAT GPT Is.
What game is this? Looks like a?fun? dystopia simulator.
It's nationstates
yippee nationstates content
Alternate title: "if DEI was a country"
comrade chatgpt
What if Bengal was united after the division of India and Pakistan
Save the Bison - Take Back the Sovereign!
it deosn't have all the varribles tho i think maybe.
Bro how did not allowing lobbying authoritarian???
"There will be no poor people when everyone will be poor"
Jokes aside he is as wise as French politicians
0:53 GPT actually chose the liberal ideology, not the libertarian ideology. Liberalism refers to the liberal ideology, and as someone who has watched libertarian YT, I can confirm that libertarians are not big on social, government-run welfare. By the way I don't think that I'm libertarian.
Save the Bison - Eat the Rich!
decides to ban vote buying, everything crashes
how？？？
The other move would increase corruption, but also the economy. The economy was in a very bad state, so it should have increased it no matter the cost, then later to deal with the corruption
@@rewriting-history ohhhhhh ok thanks
@@rewriting-historynationstates: just empower the corporates for once, your economy is dying please
Chatgpt: I AM A MORAL PERSON!
Chatgpt cant even covert Matlab code to r code.
if i could have a dollar i would have a dollar
Yeah, same here!
Will it be good
The video will be the best, but the AI didn't do great
ChatGPT is very uselful ✋✋✋✋✋
It is, but this time the task was too complicated!
@@rewriting-history yep
This is the most Pro capitalist video I've seen in a long time
This feels more about NS being biased toward a sort of weird ancap ideology than about the AI itself.
Commie Cope, Don't Tread on Me! 🐍🐍🐍🗣️🗣️🗣️🔥🔥🔥
Eastern European accent be like
What
I did an experiment, hope you will like it!
Brothers describe USA
Kind of yes, can see the similarities
Ah yes, USA - the country with the lowest economic output
uhhhhhhhhhh
It's all going downhill from here
Chatgpt is a progressive not a liberal
That’s because the ai was made by progressives if they were made by conservatives it would be a different story
It didn’t choose libertarianism it chose liberal
It was amazing as always! Hearth please ❤❤❤❤❤❤
You deserve a heart! Glad you liked it!
@@rewriting-history Huge fan
Diversity = food quality
True, I do agree here!
This is obviously fabricated.
Chatgpt almost always provides balanced responses
For example: if you ask what political ideology is best chatgpt would always provide the ups and downs and doesnt explicitly decide.
Actually, ChatGPT seemd to be playing a character rather than actually deciding for itself.
It just irritates me just how misleaded the other comments are.
9th
you were here before this video reached 1,000,000 views!
Ye it's woke asf
I did get that vibe definitely
Define "woke"
@@missk1697 The dumbass people of today